To Tell the Truth - Lion tamer; Butler to the stars (Mar 19, 1957) 

5:16 Hy Gardner to the Lion Tamer: Were you ever on 'What's My Lion"?

First contestants - Kitty says she is a feminist and that's why she votes for #1. That was an interesting statement for 1957.

The format of Bud not collecting the ballots saves time and the panel can speak for themselves. Now the panel has to get used to giving their reason for their vote without Bud asking why all the time. I am noticing that Kitty Carlisle enjoys herself on the show. Thanks for the video.

It’s interesting to see people laughing uproariously at such innocent, folksy fun. This wouldn’t be remotely funny today. Pity.

The Butler Host at the Jai Lai ( sp) palace in Dania, Fla!! My father took me there on my 21st birthday!!! Didn"t bet but just watched...(1966) after we went to Jaxon's Ice Cream Parlor...big yum...both are still there ☺️☺️☺️☺️☺️

Even in 1957, Kitty Carlisle wrote the #1 as a roman numeral!

doesn't Kitty look & sound like Arlene Francis?? I sure think so ha ha

With the one with the Butler, WOW did he ever have a serious look on his face lol (not even HALF of a smile lol)

#2 Lion Tamer was stupid on purpose "I IMAGINE they use real lions" "I was a double at several studios" it already revealed that was only once. very sneaky

Does #2 lion tamer look like Peter Falk to anyone else beside me??

Celebrity Guests: 1. Polly Bergen 2. Ralph Bellamy 3. Kitty Carlisle 4. Hy Gardner Host: Bud Collyer

Someone must have told Hy Gardner he is witty. He ain't!

John J. Anthony also appeared on Groucho Marx's "You Bet Your Life!" at about the same time, so i knew from the git-go which one it was.

Man #2 in Game #1 Man #3 in Game #2 Man #2 in Game #3

Was the March 12, 1957 show cigarette-sponsored?

Good for you, Ms Carlisle!! 🥰

The woman Instrument Flight Instructor said she worked out of Teterboro, "NY". She knows very well that Teterboro Airport is in New Jersey. I'll bet the producers told her to say "NY". :-/

Ralph growls: "It says here in the affidavit..." Zzzzzzzz