Tone Deaf Whispers 

Yeah, but they could get it from the beats

Tone deaf but not that beat deaf

He's actually gotten a lot better since the last video I watched of him.

He’s definitely not tone deaf tbh, he just can’t sing lol. When they sing the melody back to him he immediately knew if it was right or not.

He wasn’t that bad. And why laugh at him? If Eddie went on a weight lifter’s channel, it wouldn’t be cool for the host to laugh at him.

@UCksMAtMP3NKN-NxRb92Dm8A goddamn the bots got twoset too

how? i can hear it after hearing it once, you just already repeat it in your head while he is still playing, but do it fast so you could hear how the song continues

Yes I can't, maybe I need to hear it while try to sing it, otherwise I am gonna butcher the thing.

@@irissupercoolsy lol that's only true if you listen to music actively already. Most people listen to music by beats and not pitch. Not only that but he's obviously not used to classical music. It's harder to remember things that are far from what music you relate too. All you described is what classical musicians would do (not the point of this comment) And also, for the last pieces i'm pretty sure a lot of people (especially male tenor voices) would fucking shred them because of the lows and highs

Not to mention, the way he discusses it is really interesting and thoughtful. Like when he was asking about what kind of difference the downbow makes. As a non-violinist, I learned something from that even though I do know my way around a melody.

Yea he's awesome

Such a wholesome fun person!

He's really cute

fr

Yes please. More Ibo.

We are laughing with Ibo

I'd say I'm laughing more at their reactions to his singing :) And also, these pieces were harder to sing than the last time, but he managed to grasp it maybe even a little better.

When Rey gets on here Brett and Eddy troll him so hard but then when Ibo gets here he turns the tables and starts to troll them

We're laughing WITH Ibo AT Eddy and Brett's struggling

Why should we be supposed to be laughing at Ibo???

I really agree, especially if the person does not listen to Classical music a lot, it's quite difficult to remember the melody!

True, especially if you don't know the piece. I know most of them. The ones I know would've been easy to sing, but I would've struggled with the ones I don't 🙃

same

Right? He actually did an amazing job, better than I would have done anyway.

150th like

I sang in choirs and took lessons for years and I would’ve found some of these pieces very challenging to reproduce a cappella after hearing them only twice. Not to mention the range needed to sing some of them. The guy’s saving grace is that he had pretty good repetition of the rhythms

Not exactly, tone deaf is about the tone or the notes, Rhythm doesn’t could because anyone can repeat a rhythm but it’s when the notes aren’t close to what the actual notes were, if you understand what I mean.

@@pjschmid2251 I totally agree!

That's what I wrote under the first video. He just can't sing. I'm the same, I hear music in my head but can't make my voice sing it correctly.

Ibo even said "I can already hear how bad it is". I don't think he's tone deaf.

Also, as someone who's not trained in music and doesn't have that natural feeling for it, it can be really hard to remember melodies. I'm pretty sure I wouldn't be able to do this either, unless I already know the pieces.

@@Roozyj of course. Honestly - I was struggling, couldn't remember all those higher lvl pieces. Ibo did a great job. He also can recognize different rhythms. BTW, 9:33 explains everything. Not everybody has a good control of the voice. I could sing as a kid but in my teen years I stopped singing even in my house. At the moment I'd give my singing 3/10, booo.

@@dominikaksiazek7177 Same, I can hear pitch but I remember when I took singing lessons for fun I couldn't sing a damn pitch correctly. Props to singers.

Yeah, im not tone deaf and i struggle a little to remember aswell

Same here, I tried to play along and my memory just sucks 🤣

There were a lot of notes to remember beyond even level 1. They probably would have had more success if they played less, honestly.

@@CopShowGuy agreed. This would be hard for many. I have a good recall for a phrase or two ....but not for as long as the passages in this game.

Agree, I could hardly remember the melodies...

The way RU-vid works. expect him to end up a publishing artist.

ibo has actually appeared in several of their old vlog type video, like when they went to taiwan and stuff.. one of the titles is 'teaching him mandarin' or smth similar

yes, indeed!

Yes! They should definitely bring Shaun back! We need more cursed musical genius videos. 😂

Yes! I miss Shaun! We need more of Brett’s evil genius.😆

he never claimed to be tone deaf, eddie and brett "diagnosed" him on their own.

Theres levels of tone deafness. Like my mom cant sing a major scale. She cant even tell its off when she hears a recording of herself. At all. But obviously she can still tell that two sounds far apart are different.

+1 - Very frustrated that Brett and Eddy yet again demonstrated an almost complete lack of understanding about the reality of music skills. They rush to the defense of the Youth Symphony, but fall flat on their faces again with this one.

YEA!! I was searching for this comment! (I found that part really interesting!!)

Yep definitely not tone deaf. Undeveloped tone recognition perhaps but he's moving octaves to represent the melodies in his vocal range

he's most definitely just untrained and not actually tone deaf-

@@whatcommsmusic its not serious…….obviously

no he doesn't.....

Everyone has good rhythm, in this perspective. Another reason the video is frustrating from a music education perspective. This has nothing to do with tone deafness. In fact, that term is used completely inaccurately in almost all contexts and should be avoided at all costs.

Justice for Ibo😂 I think soprano voices can interpret violin sounds quite well. Fir us, mortal humans is mission impossible 🤣

Haha, same

I agree the last one one is probably my favourite 2set video as well

SAME

It's not my favourite but I love it a lot! It's probably the TwoSet video that made me laugh most.

Probably because you're tone deaf?

5:14 was particularly precious lol

I love this Pokemon evolving analogy! Hahaha

He's not tone deaf at all

@@SarahYasmineXO right. 9:33 is a proof.

@@dominikaksiazek7177 Word. Tone Deaf is a terrible term, not useful at all. Should never be used, IMO.

@@whatcommsmusic I don't like it either.

@@dominikaksiazek7177 Thank you. It's in really poor taste and shows a real lack of understanding and contrary to their usual positive and accurate attitudes towards music learning. The newest video with Ibo demonstrates their lack of understanding very clearly. They really don't know what the average person understands musically. Just because they can't sing a melody, identify a melody, or have a high accuracy of pitch identification or memory, or can apply music theory knowledge doesn't mean they hear music or understand music at some "Tone Deaf" level. In fact, very, very, very few people actually have the condition called Amusia. Most "Tone Deaf" people are just not very well trained, acculturated, or given the right environment and time to demonstrate their musical understanding. It's a universal human experience and Brett and Eddy are gate-keeping here, that's why I'm so frustrated and disappointed.

i think you will be right

Yeeeess

@Don't Read My Profile Photo Ok I wont 😐

you were right

@Don't Read My Profile Photo I won’t thx

No way. Is that the Ibo with no comments???

If you study violin using suzuki then you prob know most of these so its easy

Because Eddy is more of an introvert probably, whereas Brett is more of an extrovert

I think Ibo was Brett’s friend before he (Ibo) was Eddys friend, just from those old travel vlogs, way back.

Found u and I love the videos with him too

And you're right. 9:33

Would be able do a couple of phrases singing back but these passages would be too long for me to sing back. Ibo's rhythm is much better than mine.

Me neither! I'd forget it the instant they finish if it's a piece i don't know.

thanks a lot!

Loved it😂😂

I would like to dare this. Giving him lessons in somisation. Is he interested? We could do it on Skype.

@@dirkbrodling4230 Great idea!

Love how he mentioned pitchy :) made me think back to that one month I binged roomie 😅

Interestring

Interesting

@@gabrieller4474 ahh the singer with spotify name "Lil Pitchy". love that guy as well

This was filmed before Editor-san got sick.

@@xandraxandra1437 i didn't know that. Thanks for letting me know. I hope they get better soon!

yeah, i noticed that too maybe having it in front of him helped. lol

I know! Twoset is better than medication (unfortunately they don't release a new video every day as the drugs do) Hope you get better soon, you know you are worth it ❤

@@xandraxandra1437 thanks for the support💗

I'm sorry you're going through tough times, it's great that TwoSet's videos help you. (They help me too with my mental health issues.) Hugs from France! 😚💕💞💕

It's probably a little bit late, but welcome to the channel ! 😊

@@MissTwoSetEncyclopedia such a lovely community 🥰🙏 glad to be here!

@@sola6437 😘

Exactly. Even for someone "with perfect pitch". Music skill is a spectrum. Absolute Pitch is a threshold above which a person can name pitches under certain conditions. Tone Deaf, likewise is an equally difficult term, but much more inaccurately applied. Almost no one on earth is truly tone deaf. There are lots of people whose aural and singing skills are very, very, very low. Ibo himself actually appears to be right in the lower middle of the bell curve, from my understanding as an educator, definitely not tone deaf. 9:33 is a good example.

Aww. He heard it twice it was just shown only once.

@@emilwandel Not sure what your point is? My problem is not with Ibo's performance, skill, or the conditions of the test necessarily. Rather, the music education advocates and music professionals who are somewhat unknowingly perpetuating harmful music education falsehoods.

Brett can actually sing okay if he puts his mind to it as long as the range works to his advantage. And some of these are pretty hard to sing. I hope I am a pretty good singer (otherwise my last two decades of singing in choir would have been a bit of a waste) and I just tried to sing the Wienawski and it's actually pretty tricky to sing.

tho i wouldn't mind seeing the 1 hour long (or however long it took) raw footage of this game either