Top 10 Supernatural Plot Holes You Never Noticed 

"Why are the angels still in their vessels in heaven?" Answer : Budget

"Supernatural Plot Holes You Never Noticed"...ummm, no. Especially Adam. We all noticed Adam's plot hole, considering the show itself poked fun at the plot hole during the 200th episode "Fan Fiction".

“Dean surviving in purgatory without food or water.” He was in purgatory. Nothing in purgatory needs to eat. That’s why Benny didn’t have the hunger from being a vampire because he was dead. And technically so was Dean.

Jimmy Novak is actually Cas himself, Jimmy is long dead and Cas merged with the vessel completely

"Never noticed"? I think you're underestimating the SPN family...

The Angels being in their vessels in heaven was referenced by Zachariah in the episode "Dark Side of the Moon". We see the vessels because we're limited. Not a plot hole.

Top 10 things that MsMojo didn't understand about Supernatural's plot.

"Why are angels in their vessels in Heaven?" Well does it look like you can fit a Chrysler Building in that hall?

“God Not Realizing Gabriel Was Still Alive” Answer: God knew the whole time. He always had everything under control even with Amara. He lied numerous times on the show and he was probably lying about that just to make a better “story”.

jimmy died so lucifer only needed castiel`s "Yes" to get inside his body!!! crowley is a demon; he doesn´t need consent!!

Ms. Mojo: “how the boys get their income” Also Ms. Mojo: *plays clip showing how they get it*

Most of these “plotholes” have been explained or recognized already.

Imagine you're brother dying so much people expect you not to be upset by it.

The Lucifer, cas, and Jimmy vessel issue isn't ssn issue. Your forgetting that God rebuilt cas multiple times, and Jimmy was no longer alive.

I’m guessing that the reason jimmy is so strong as a vessel is because 1: Jimmy is dead after exploding and god recreated just the vessel for Castiel. 2: God might have recreated the vessel stronger.

When amara says "first" shes probably talking in order of importance to god, she did NOT say first BORN or first CREATED.

Somebody’s gotta explain to MsMojo what a plot hole is, because most on this list isn’t, something that you find odd, or don’t understand doesn’t automatically make something a plot hole.

Number 3 shouldn’t be on here because Sam and Dean don’t know if the other is gonna come back that time so they mourn their death like it’s the permanent one

I'm confused. most of these "plot holes" are clearly explained in the show.

There’s also the whole “Angels are stronger than demons” inconsistencies. In season 4 when they were first learning that it was an angel who freed Dean from hell, even Ruby was acting incredibly scared and nervous. Saying that Angels are far more powerful than demons, which does make perfect sense. Yet over the years, we saw demons beat the crap out of angels numerous times! Cas was even captured by some one time because he apparently unknowingly walked into a bar that was filled with them.... uuhhh... what?? How did he not see even one when angels can apparently see the true faces of demons! Then to be over powered by them when he’s an angel? Even if he was at half strength he still should have been able to defeat them. And don’t get me started on how Gabriel was captured by Asmodaeus!! I don’t care that he was a prince of hell, Gabriel was an ARCH ANGEL!!!!! He should have seen him coming from a mile away and Asmodaeus shouldn’t have been able to lay even one finger on Gabriel let alone capture and in-prison him for years!

"I don't have the power to bring Gabriel back." Chuck knew Gabriel was alive, but he knew there was no way Gabe would abandon his pornstars

of course they’re gonna be sad when they watch their sibling die, are you kidding?

Jimmy was literally brought back by god himself. It’s an extremely powerful vessel.

Chuck knew gabriel was still alive, he only continued to say that Gabriel was dead was because it was part of the "story" and the plot that he wanted

Jimmy died and his soul is in heaven. Castiel's vessel has been destroyed and brought back numerous times over the years so the fact that Lucifer can inhabit it makes sense. As for Crowley being in it, demons don't ask for permission. They take position of a body

Most of these things are literally explained in the show.

10: so we can tell the angels apart from one another and also budget 9: they faked their death to get the police off their back and they´ve pretty much forgotten about Sam and Dean because everyone thinks the case is closed 8: after God resurrected Cas, Jimmy died and Cas became bound to the vessel. It´s basically Cas, that´s why it´s so strong 7: Gabrie tried to make sure not even God could find him. If God had made an effort he could have found Gabriel for sure, but God doesn´t actually care, as mentioned several times in the show 6: the archangels were all created at the same time, but Michael kind of took on the role of the eldest brother. I think it´s still fair for Amara to call Lucifer "first", as the archangels were the first things to be created by God 5:The Empty has never proven itself to be more powerfull than God, it only said that. The empty has lied before, so it could have just told Cas no one could help him to take away his hope and send him back to sleep. 4: actually a valid point 3: idk i´d still be fucking sad if my sibling died, even for the 5th time, they can´t know for sure if the other will ever come back. We as the viewers do, but the characters don´t, especially because they are generally pessimistic and depressed. 2: Ruby was working with Lilith all along, so of course it was a scam to make Ruby seem more trustworthy. The demon knife is the same for demons as a normal knife is for Humans, it´s that simple. 1: Sam doesn´t care about Adam and Dean even dislikes him. They don´t consider Adam a part of their Family. And also it´s a meme Congratulations, you found one plot hole. Just watch the fucking show instead of just googling supernatural plotholes and reading them out. I´m not even like a huge fangirl, I watched the show once (now starting to watch it again with my best friend tho). I gathered all this knowledge by litterally watching it once and from a basic understanding of christian mythology (point 6). Can yt just please stop being stupid

man there are so many mistakes on that lists... like if you wanna an “answer list” for this video

Didn’t Sam and dean fake their death to get the police of their chest after the whole president thing

"those inconsistencies you missed on your first watch..." Here's the thing - we all have watched it many more times than just that!

In Season 4 ep 3, Dean goes back in time and when he meets his dad in the diner a man walks in and has a short convo with John. He ends the conversation by saying, “Say hi to your old man for me!” But later on we find out Henry Winchester went into the future to protect the Men of Letters key from Abbadon. John thought Henry abandoned him. Small detail I noticed ig.

It's like you've never watched the show before.

Mmmmm no Lilith was never scared of the knife. She was scared of Sam. There is a difference.

As im watching this, i can literally explain almost all of them.. Because ive actually watched the show

I had a whole thing typed out before I realized my answer to each plot hole was the same. If you know the show... CHUCK DOESN'T CARE ABOUT ANYONE OR ANYTHING OTHER THAN THE WINCHESTERS STORYLINE also, about Sam and Dean dying so much and they still grieve the other, that's bc there have been multiple times that they have thought the death was permanent and also they love each other their income: they run credit card scams... this was legit covered in the very first episode Adam: at first it was just an accident and then let's be honest, the writers saw how much of a joke it had become with the fans and they rolled with it.

#5 when Gadreel healed Cas, Cas was human so it was just an angel resurrecting a dead human. Also later on in season 15 (after this video was posted) it’s confirmed that Chuck definitely has power to bring angels and demons back from the Empty.. for example Lucifer and Lilith.

#3 kind of doesn’t make sense....what are they supposed to do? Watch their brother die and be like “eh, I’ll figure out a way...they’ll be back tomorrow”. Like wtf, of course they’ll be sad and devastated...their brother just DIED. And they know there’s that slight possibility that they won’t be able to bring them back.

7 is not a plot hole. Chuck could have just been prolonging the plot for his entertainment

The souls in purgatory don't go anywhere. They resurrected in purgatory to fight and die again and again, like humans in hell

Yeah I was always pissed that they left Adam in hell however he's out now and he's essentially told them they can sod off.

Ok, everyone knows that they forgot Adam. It was a MEME in the fandom for years

10 - humans/human souls can't see angels in their true forms. Zacharia explains why he looks human in heaven. Demons need a vessel in hell to be able to talk and do spells, smoke is pretty useless. 9 - when the leviathan pretended to be Sam and Dean, the police used THOSE bodies to air in the news that Sam and Dean were dead. 8 - castiels body (not jimmies anymore) is strong because God made it that way. God references "I've rebuilt castile more times than I can count" 7 - he didn't say Gabriel was dead, he said he didn't have the power, at the time, to bring him back. Which is true: they would have had to fight osmodeis and his demons ontop of trying to stop amara. 6 - not a plot hole, just a bad character. She gets plenty of things wrong. 5 - castile woke up in the empty because of JACK. his power was strong enough to stretch to the empty. 4 - monster souls aren't like human one's, they are tainted by "eve" and probably respawn for all eternity. If they could die in their god would have killed the liviathin in there. 3 - because they know to many people WANT them to stay dead. And heaven isn't an enviting option because angels don't like them. It's not always 100% certain they can come back, they usually have to make deals. 2 - lilith was ACTING scared of Sam. She needed to be killed at the right place, at the right time. She wasn't actually scared of the knife, she needed to drag out them chasing her to let lucifer out of the cage.. 1 - Sam's soul was bad after being in the cage. In the end he went mental and castile had to take it from him, and suffer with it himself. Adams soul would now be soup. There is no point in saving him.

As for Adam I don't think they ever really considered him a true brother. Especially after he agreed to host Michael for such a selfish reason which was what they were trying to avoid.

Number 7: "He's a Writer.Writers lie"

the angels are not in their vessels when they are in heaven!!! we see them that way because we are limited!!!

Dean didn't show hair growth in purgatory because he used his knives to at least shave, jensen asked the producers about it

More like “Plot holes that everyone else noticed and has explanations for except for Ms Mojo”

"the antichrist boy" was interesting i always wanted him to return

“Never Noticed” *Sees Adam* Oh trust me...we notice lol

The angels keep their vessels because could you imagine having to re-inhabit your vessel after just going to Heaven to ask a question? "Hey, Jimmy, its Cas, can I come back now?" "Well...."

The income one confused me at first too but then I remembered that a) they do credit card fraud and b) Charlie made cards with endless amounts of money on them or something along the lines of that

How about this: How did Crowley get Sam's body out of the cage, when in later seasons even just getting access to the cage was this whole huge ordeal requiring that special powerful witch book that Rowena had?

Me watching the video: What? Oh, I can't wait to read all the comments and see the SPNFamily explain the show to you. Me reading the comment: Yep, not disappointed.

Castiel was brought back by Chuck several times, at the and of season 5, Cas even said he's new and improved. Maybe that's why his vessel is so strong...

Defeated monsters in purgatory just re-spawn somewhere else in the realm.

Couldn't help but chuckle as I listened because as a hobby I dabbled in short story writing a serial. I ran out of ideas at story 51. I had to keep track of who was who, who was related to who, who had a conflict and why with who, evolution of the characters in later stories and keeping continuity. So many things to remember to do. This just reminded me how difficult it can be to tie up loose ends and remember the complex relationships with past and present and new characters and keeping everything straight. Not easy.

For number 9, that was tired up when their deaths were faked by a police officer

"Forgetting" Adam isn't a plot hole. They also haven't tried to bring Bobby, or John, or Charlie, or really anyone else besides each other back.

I was eye rolling throughout this video.

There is a major plot hole in the episode where dean pulls a back to the future meeting his dad a lot younger. When the waiter asks john how his dad was doing he said hes fine but when dean and sam meet their grandpa it turned out that john last saw his dad when he was 5 I think..

Adam will be back in season 15. I'm so curious to see how that plays out.

Seen supernatural loads of times, pretty sure any big fans of the programme will have already noticed these plot holes

Number 8: Jimmy aient in the vessel no more, hes dead, Number 7: god has been lying

So sad to see this show go! Feels like part of my childhood and adulthood is being taken away! Im so glad you cam watch these episodes a milliom times and they never get old!

*Number 1:* Supernatural x Scooby Doo crossover _There's one plot hole: Shaggy uses 0.0001% of his powers to create the best crossover that everyone has to offer._

"Castiel has died several times" ... No he hasn't ... The vessel has been destroyed, that's it. Did MsMojo do any of her homework for this one?

The income was explained (or atleast fixed) through Charlie making them a "super credit card"

Try the fact that Lucifer should have known that a normal angel blade wouldn't kill an archangel, only an archangel blad could, so he would have known that Gabe wasn't dead.

Angels are still in their vessels so we know who they are, lmao.

God just said that he isn't able to bring gabriel back. He never said back from the dead

When dean goes back in time when he is sent by cas someone says "say hello to your old man" to john. Henry was stuck in the future and died seasons later and dean thought he was a dead beat. That plot hole always stuck out to me.

Only thing I'm griping about is that somehow *Bobby* of all people got possessed by a demon back in season 5. He should've had a charm too on him since he knows that he can get posessed but idk just suddenly became careless or plot hole?

God rebuilt “Jimmy” and even gave Cas an upgrade to Seraph.

Practically all of these plot holes happen after season 5.

Cas not having his wings, even though he had his grace stolen and was teleported to earth instead of being cast out like all the other angels. Also. If heaven is powered by the angels, why didn't it implode after Metatron cast out all of the angels?

All of these inconsistencies came when they decided to continue the show instead of having the intended ending with season 5

These are all very small common retcons that would happen to any show over the course of 15 years and multiple showrunners, had Kripke ended it after S5 like he originally intended the story would have been flawless

I'm so glad they mentioned the Anti Christ. Hope he comes back

okay so one question I’m wondering (I could have maybe just missed something) but when dean went back in time and saw John and Mary when they where younger and his grandpa/ Mary’s dad met dean, deans grandpa was not alive when Michael erased John and Mary’s memory of them, so when deans grandpa comes back alive, how did he not recognize dean, or did he just never mentioned it or did Michael just erased his memories while he was in hell or something

10: probably if they ever need to go back to Earth, dont need the hassle to get a new one, maybe something to do after the fall? 9. Unsure, maybe just faded with time, or God intervention as he 'wanted to keep watching his show' 8. Once resurrected, Jimmy was gone so Cas being alone likely fortified the strength of the vessel. 7. Either Asmodeus was that good, or God was saving face, knowing that Gabe wouldnt help, even if he freed him. 6. Lucifer is first, but God still couldve made him young while the other brothers were created more mature, thus seemingly older. 5. Likely both fast enough resurrected before ending up in the empty, or the Shadow bluffs his power. 4. Souls can reside in Purgatory, so once the monster dies, it just becomes essence. 3. Sure, there are many loopholes, but they never expect the resurrection so emotions are natural. 2. Lilith may just be scared of the unknown of the pain, maybe if used in some particular way that only she knows can kill a white eyed demon. HM Credit card scams | they mightve only figured out it was a rugaru back then because of experience/the journal | Dean seems to forget that trip happened | Purgatory could perhaps affect you differently based on your emotions/attitude. 1. They never forgot, there just never seems to be another good way to ever get him back.

A show running so long is definitely gonna have continuity errors

What about the fact that when they went down to the cage, adam wasn't in there?

My personal theory on the whole Police/FBI/Secret Service “Plot hole” has always been that I think they stopped searching for them because the higher ranks in those agencies know about the work the brothers do and know of their importance. I mean look at how MANY people work for said groups some of them HAVE to know what’s really out there 🤷🏼‍♀️

and you didn't even mention the fact that squirrel had the amulet on him when they first met chuck but it didn't glow

Oh we know about these plot holes... We just ignore it

#3 just cause you've come back before doesn't mean you come back again.

Let’s see, Cass is an angel possessing Jimmy’s body, and just his body as Jimmy is dead. So Cass basically is Jimmy at this point. So when Lucifer possesses Cass, rules can be bent as they are both angels. Crowley is a demon and doesn’t need permission, and a true vessel. So, Cass, Luci and Crowley could technically all fit inside Jimmy Novak. Thanks for coming to my ted talk.

The archangel Mike from the other universe said that dean was his true vessel, but during the season where another universe was showed to us we could hear that sam and dean were never born there....So, is this a hole too?

Reacting to a loved ones death is a natural human reaction, I wouldn't really call that a plot hole? lmao

SPN established that we all have own heavens and that we see what we want to see. I never assumed the angels were actually in their vessels in heaven. I thought it was just supposed to be from the audience's POV. You know because humans can't really handle seeing their true form? Zachariah confirmed this in season 5

Bold to make a video like this about a show with such a strong fandom

Dean survived purgatory without food because it wasn't him as a human it was just his soul and souls in such a place as a purgatory don't need to eat or drink or sleep or whatever because they are soules!

1:14 Misha Collins is a marvelous being of creation

I wanna believe the theory that chuck is actually a third sibling of god and amara acting as god and trapped the real god in the empty

it’s been said JohnvWinchester “always grew up believing “ his father walked out on him&his mom at an early age, ( really he died while becoming a man of letters) however, 1st X Dean was sent back in time, while in the diner, he hears a man ask newly back home Marine John “tell your dad hello” how’d they forget that? always wondered if anyone else caught that

Jimmy died when lucifer killed cass the first time back in season 5

I have been noticing a lot of plot holes in the show and the one's you chose aren't exactly plot holes.

ALMOST ALL OF THESE HAVE ANSWERS. im just saying...

One of the biggest plot hole I think is the story of the Alternate Kaia. She just vanished after giving Dean the spear and didn't even bother looking for it again or even knows its already destroyed. Season 15 is still long and they would probably end her arc before the series ends but it would be a shame if they just forget her storyline.

a lot of these aren't even plot holes... eg not knowing rugaru their dad had a hunting journal and they dealt with a rugaru they obviously now know what is it.