Trans activists have no right to pervert the English language

Подписаться 33 тыс.

Просмотров 5 тыс.

50% 1

"“Woman. Noun. Adult human female,” read the sticker applied to Queensland MP Shannon Fentiman’s office window. Walking past the window at the Waterford Shopping Centre in Logan, one might have assumed the sticker belonged to Fentiman. She was, until Thursday, Queensland’s Minister for Women.
But one would’ve been mistaken. “I know the sticker doesn’t look like it says much, and most people will be lucky enough to be unaffected by what it says,” Fentiman wrote on her Instagram page. “But for some people in our community, these stickers represent much more - they represent a movement which discriminates against them and denies their existence.”
--------
Welcome to Episode 2! Today with better placement of our microphones and less mmms. Today we discuss Claire's latest column in The Australian- Trans activists have no right to pervert the English language, by Claire Lehmann: www.theaustralian.com.au/comm...
------
Quillette is an Australian-based online magazine that focuses on long-form analysis and cultural commentary. It is politically non-partisan, but relies on reason, science, and humanism as its guiding values.
Quillette was founded in 2015 by Australian writer Claire Lehmann. It is a platform for free thought and a space for open discussion and debate on a wide range of topics, including politics, culture, science, and technology.
Quillette has gained attention for publishing articles and essays that challenge modern heterodoxy on a variety of topics, including gender and sexuality, race and identity politics, and free speech and censorship.
---
Quillette's revenue comes from our readers. We are a grassroots organisation that relies on voluntary subscriptions and community membership as our primary revenue stream.
Support Quillette by becoming a subscriber: quillette.com/#/portal/signup
Or donate via PayPal: paypal.me/QUILLETTEPTYLTD?cou...
We made our website using Ghost, a powerful app for new-media creators to publish, share, and grow a business around their content. It comes with modern tools to build a website, publish content, send newsletters & offer paid subscriptions to members. Try it here: ghost.org/?via=claire91

Опубликовано:

23 май 2023

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 60

@benp4877 Год назад

Great job from America, ladies. Quillette is one of a handful of outlets that has been such a breath of fresh air among the madness.

@dimitrikorsakov2570 Год назад

I'm glad you guys are doing more RU-vid content. It's a way to massively increase your discoverability.

@Quillette Год назад

Thanks!! That’s the plan. We are glad you see it 😎

@cut_thru Год назад

Finally a balanced, educated, informed discussion. As much as I used enjoy Joe Rogan and Jordan Peterson, these two are far more educated, balanced, informed and it's actually nice to hear this from two young women in a space where these discussions are usually held by men 50+ .

@Quillette Год назад

Thanks for your kind words :)

@banistersmind Год назад

This is a great addition to the Quillette stable! Fantastic conversation 🍋!!

@Quillette Год назад

Thanks for your support :)

@sueclarke6298 Год назад

Shannon Fentiman still is the Minister for Women, she didn't lose that portfolio. She lost the Attorny-General portfolio and rightly as you said picked up the Health portfolio.

@Quillette Год назад

You’re correct 😊 this column was written last Wednesday/Thursday and published last Friday, so details about her portfolio may have changed.

@sueclarke6298 Год назад

@@Quillette Shannon Fentiman is my MP and I have met with her over this issue. She is steadfast in her commitment to men. We have started up a campaign in Logan, where the electorate of Waterford is in Queensland and we did an action on May 16, roadside action outside of her electoral office, 4 of us and she called the police on us. We are going to have a concentrated campaign in an attempt to lose her her seat in October 2024. The police confirmed that we were not acting illegally but took our names. This was an attempt to intimidate us but we knew the action we were taking was no unlawful. That sticker that was left on her office the previous week has been her downfall.

@MettleHurlant Год назад

We need to be precise with our language. Trans woman or trans man is not precise. Trans identifying males or female is a more precise term. You can’t change your sex and gender is not the same as sex. When referring to female anatomy or health care we need precise terminology which they are trying to conflate. “Persons” don’t give birth, women do. “Persons” don’t get prostate cancer, men do. Reject this trans ideology because it makes no sense logically or scientifically.

@Mouse01011 7 месяцев назад

But how about biological women who can't give birth? Or what about Intersex people who have ambiguous genitalia (for some reason, no one on the Right or in the Center ever talks about their existence except when their genitals MUST be corrected to stick to one gender; as in "pick a side"). We must also recognize that the trans-movement as a whole does NOT SPEAK for most trans individuals. I've heard and read many an opinion from Trans folk who say that they are NOT women (or men); that they are trans-women/men.

@melodyrachel Год назад

Great episode! I like the conversational style and the interviewers questions ✴

@Quillette Год назад

Thanks Melody!

@annarboriter Год назад

yes, so Platonic

@melodyrachel Год назад

@@annarboriter yes very!!

@kevinyang6254 Год назад

Probably one of the most balanced conversations I've heard regarding the problem with modern feminism. Appreciate the convo.

@Quillette Год назад

Thanks! We are glad to hear it

@semperfidelis6943 Год назад

Great conversation … measured and interesting.

@Quillette Год назад

thanks!

@fordjack Год назад

You're really getting into some interesting topics, and bravely so. Thank you, and keep up the good work!

@Quillette Год назад

Thanks so much for your support- we are excited to do more!

@miroirs-jumeaux Год назад

Ooh, super-southern domestic politics! Cool.

@Quillette Год назад

Thanks for watching ☺️

@annarboriter Год назад

The problem isn't that words are getting redefined. This is a natural, ongoing process and essential to philosophical discourse. The problem is that feminists insist that only their new definitions are valid and not abiding by their moral imperative to regulate speech is misogynist or whatever the latest insult might be

@unnamed3932 Год назад

Feminism is not a monolith. You are talking about the VIchy feminists, the academic or 'third wave' feminists who have lost the plot. Lesbian feminists esp. have been warning about the male, heterosexual cross-dresser sexual fetishists w/ their paraphilias for decades and their danger to women. Janice Raymond, a lesbian feminist U of Mass professor, wrote her book, The Transsexual Empire, in 1979, calling out the dangers of 'trans' for women. Lesbians have known for some time who these sex pests are b/c of those who make the absurd claim that they are lesbian--they are dangerously deluded.

@roseh1132 Год назад

Claire, I absolutely agree that we should be focusing on the politics of difference between the sexes.

@Cotictimmy 11 месяцев назад

On the abortion question and majority opinion. I think the U.S. Supreme Court pronouncement last year as a MASSIVE own goal for The Republicans. It instantly torpedoed the favorable mid-term results had been expecting prior to The Court's move. It was NOT rocket science: it was obvious what would happen when the news broke that the Court was going to make a major decision on the abortion question. My reaction was: "You Morons! - you had a chance to build a coalition of reasonable people (opposed to extrme Identity Politics) - but you've just pushed the self-destruct button."

@MonkeyBuRps 2 месяца назад

I like it when they orient the camera a little further back, so we can see Zoe's pumpkin patch. 😏 Claire bear's lips look amazing, particularly for someone in her late 30's. 😚

@hooligan9794 7 месяцев назад

I cant agree more with her comment about statistics and the desperate need for people to have at least a basic understanding of it.

@fraserct533 21 день назад

23:40 if stats is not taught in these 'Xxx Studies' disciplines - that points to their being based on ideology (where you aren't constrained by reality) rather than science (where you have to be) - who could bear to be constrained by pesky measurement ⁉️

@bwake 11 месяцев назад

The apparent biological clock for men may be a function of heritable factors such as personality, which also contribute to our late marriages.

@irenalovesart4064 Год назад

And are men's language being erased? Likely not

@cut_thru Год назад

Go on....

@hooligan9794 7 месяцев назад

Are you claiming here that trans activits are just so respectful of men that they aren't going to interfere with language around men? 😂😂 Or course they happily change language for men, of course they demand that transmen can use men's bathrooms etc. The difference is that men don't care so there is no big deal about it. It should be obvious why this is not a concern for men but is for women, and this is why it is women's spaces, and women generally are the battleground. Please don't try to turn it in to some kind of dopey patriarchy claim, if that is where you were going with that...

@irenalovesart4064 7 месяцев назад

@@hooligan9794I'm not dopey I'm sneezy

@jonahtwhale1779 10 месяцев назад

Lea Thomas is participating in female sports at the University of Pennsylvania ( I think). Title IX forbids sex discrimination against individuals in education. The law reads "No person in the US shall, on the basis of sex, be denied participation in .... any educational program or activity ...". In light of this human rights law - on what basis is it legal to exclude men from female sports?

@hooligan9794 7 месяцев назад

Because, even if you have the right to participate in sports, that does not give you the right to participate in any category you want or flout conditions for entry. If I were to wake up tomorrow and decide I want to join a league intended for children, are you under the impression that citing title ix will quash any objection? If I decide that I want to swim in the championship finals despite never having participated in any swimming before, do you think citing title ix will gain me entry, or should? If you get why the above scenarios are absurd, you should have no problem understanding why men can't just rock up and demand entry into a competition for women.

@johnstewart7025 Год назад

The meaning of words are constantly changing; I agree we should not have laws telling us what words mean in our common usage. Legal definitions are necessary, of course, and some women object to males in female spaces.

@quentinnewark2745 3 месяца назад

Arguably feminists have a hand in this (which Claire does not mention at all, I spotted no irony when she said the meaning of words had to be communally agreed), some years ago they minted entirely new words that had never existed: Ms and Womyn. This kind of political neologism, one could see this as the beginning of where we are now.

@davewinterton4 11 месяцев назад

Great discussion 👏

@galaxytrio 10 месяцев назад

Have you considered having a discussion about whether there should be any limits on abortion?

@blugreen99 10 месяцев назад

Do animals have gender and is it performnative and what about the gender pay gap?

@ConanDuke 10 месяцев назад

Wittgenstein FTW! ✊

@BlackThyme Год назад

we can test theory that is not empirically testable, it's called deductive reasoning aka logic: philosophy, unlike science which is just inductive, anecdote: you can never get to truth (if there is such a thing that humans can attain) via inductive reason, you only get a probability

@birsay123 Месяц назад

Woman = Zoe Booth ❤

@BlackThyme Год назад

gender study is more of a philosophical course, well mine was, so not a science in terms of quantitative statistical analysis, it's more argument, reason. some science but not a lot

@ConanDuke 10 месяцев назад

0:53 XX