Тёмный

Tucker vs. Bill Nye the Science Guy 

Fox News
Подписаться 11 млн
Просмотров 5 млн
50% 1

Bill Nye has argued that climate change deniers suffer psychological delusions. Tucker takes him on in an unforgettable debate #Tucker

Опубликовано:

 

26 фев 2017

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 57 тыс.   
@BlackkAreolaa
@BlackkAreolaa 7 лет назад
Tucker was that one annoying white kid in the back who wouldn't shut up thinking he was funny..
@ILoveTVShowsAndStuff
@ILoveTVShowsAndStuff 7 лет назад
Cheeto O and you're that one guy who brings race into the RU-vid comment section. lul
@ImEin
@ImEin 7 лет назад
Iron Man Kungfu ...... why does that matter?
@TylerDavis.420
@TylerDavis.420 День назад
​@@ILoveTVShowsAndStuffbecause he's racist. That's the only people who care what people look like
@RunnyBabbits
@RunnyBabbits 3 года назад
Not sure why Fox would post this. This is embarrassing.
@randomBBL
@randomBBL 3 года назад
Exactly, Science is a good thing and putting on an actor who goes on TV and pretends to be a scientist is embarassing.
@swaezi6515
@swaezi6515 3 года назад
@@randomBBL also putting an idiot who cant seem to understand anything a "fake" scientist is saying is even more embarrassing
@McAmberlee
@McAmberlee 3 года назад
@@randomBBL I honest to god thought you meant Tucker Carlson for a minute... Or are you pointing out that even an "actor," as you say, knows more about simple science than ya boi Tuck?
@theuglykid5388
@theuglykid5388 3 года назад
Embarrassing in a good way.
@bigtobaccolobbyist7093
@bigtobaccolobbyist7093 3 года назад
They are more transparent and honest than cnn
@andrewdebner7057
@andrewdebner7057 9 месяцев назад
It's really hard to argue with someone who's smart, it's impossible to argue with someone who's stupid.
@andrewabele9750
@andrewabele9750 7 месяцев назад
What is your point humans contribute to like 0000.6% of o2 in the atmosphere witch causes climate change the planet releases tons of its own green gasses on its own causes its own climate change, climate change has never been predictable the planet does it itself
@normodb
@normodb 5 месяцев назад
I agree, bill nye is a moron
@archerandthemouse
@archerandthemouse 5 месяцев назад
This!!!
@daquanbenson549
@daquanbenson549 3 месяца назад
Smh😂😂😂
@thebigbarbosa1
@thebigbarbosa1 10 месяцев назад
Whenever I'm feeling a little down, I rewatch this as it never fails to make me laugh.
@zombieghostguy3434
@zombieghostguy3434 9 месяцев назад
Yeah, is more entertaining.
@manifestman132
@manifestman132 7 месяцев назад
The crossfire episode withe Jon Stewart is funny too.
@lamaripiazza5226
@lamaripiazza5226 6 месяцев назад
*rewatch
@thebigbarbosa1
@thebigbarbosa1 6 месяцев назад
@@lamaripiazza5226 fixed.
@henryharris3431
@henryharris3431 6 месяцев назад
It makes me feel worse
@ursa8772
@ursa8772 3 года назад
Tucker is that one kid who thought he was smarter than the science teacher. Edit for all the Tucker defenders: Fox News once won a court case by arguing that no reasonable person would take Tucker Carlson seriously.
@epickiller30
@epickiller30 3 года назад
Of course cause the science teacher is always right and the student is always wrong
@thomasmacisaac1503
@thomasmacisaac1503 3 года назад
It's more like Tucker has an honest question that the "teacher" won't answer.
@Danymok
@Danymok 3 года назад
@@thomasmacisaac1503 Bill Nye did answer the question very well.
@Danymok
@Danymok 3 года назад
It's more like Tucker is the one kid who thought he was smarter than the science teacher, but he didn't do any of the homework and he failed every test, but still thinks he's smart.
@ScorpionXII
@ScorpionXII 3 года назад
@@thomasmacisaac1503 ...because the question is malformed and idiotic. I mean... "when would the next ice age have happened" was the dumbest thing I've ever heard, the look on Bill's face was priceless. It's like handing somebody a cake and then saying... "I'm skeptical that this is a cake, just a question... when would the eggs used in this cake mix have hatched?".
@ReaIHuman
@ReaIHuman 3 года назад
Fox: why is the climate is changing Bill: "answers the question" Fox: I guess we'll never know.
@TheOkieLife
@TheOkieLife 3 года назад
This is the CC for the whole thing. Thank you for taking the time to caption the entire show for us. You brave soul. (Sarcasm is present, but not aimed at you @Lucifer)
@mr_gamer2267
@mr_gamer2267 3 года назад
@quagmirefeels he did lol
@Day100
@Day100 3 года назад
Bill is a sellout and looking for TV attention. Tucker is supposed to fight with Bill for drama. They're both just trying to generate attention. Bill's right, that saying climate prediction is super volatile. We can barely predict the current daily weather, but we can see the skews. Determining our direct correlation to specifics in climate is actually kinda tough given so many outside factors. Even looking at historical data as well as political games show all sorts of funk that could alter our current perceived impact. TLDR; the only thing interesting going on here is that it's news drama for the sake of click baits.
@vanessawilliams4018
@vanessawilliams4018 3 года назад
@quagmirefeels yes he did lol, if humans weren’t here the climate would be changing about a 1000xs slower.
@threebasketeers336
@threebasketeers336 3 года назад
@@mr_gamer2267 no he didnt
@delectablemimi
@delectablemimi Год назад
People who are losing a debate almost always raise their voice to compensate.
@michaelkilgoresr.8361
@michaelkilgoresr.8361 12 дней назад
He must be a Trump supporter 😂😂😂
@AtomicAtom87
@AtomicAtom87 Год назад
Tucker: “so how much is our impact?” Bill: “200%” Tucker: “but you’re not answering my question”
@bennieknape4857
@bennieknape4857 Год назад
Really stunning to watch?what is stunning is your lack of a sence of reality about climate and its change
@larncieldarknciel440
@larncieldarknciel440 Год назад
He is not answering the question. You don't say 100%. you id1ot. you provide a reference from a per review document. you provide the name of the author and provide the real numbers not 100%. As he said already climate always changes. Our part in climate change can not be 100% or 200% stup1d asshol3 because the climate always changes 100 or 200 % would mean that we are literally responsible for climate Change in general, and without us the climate will always be the same. he is talking out of his azs. Tucker is calling him out and you are so clueless you don't even get it.
@bigverybadtom
@bigverybadtom Год назад
This is not a valid answer. It cannot be more than 100% in this instance.
@AtomicAtom87
@AtomicAtom87 Год назад
@@bigverybadtom we’re not dealing with absolutes because we are converting math into human ecological impact, so it can very well be an unquantifiable 200%
@bigverybadtom
@bigverybadtom Год назад
@@AtomicAtom87 But we are. You cannot fill a glass 200%. Use your common sense.
@chetmcgovern9985
@chetmcgovern9985 3 года назад
Poor Bill. He's having a battle of brains with an unarmed man.
@Tyronius_Maximus
@Tyronius_Maximus 3 года назад
Lmao
@cryptic_rain8951
@cryptic_rain8951 3 года назад
It’s logic vs theory.
@menamesskit3336
@menamesskit3336 3 года назад
@@cryptic_rain8951 The theory is that there's a definitive way to know what the climate would be today if there was no carbon footprint. The logic is that humans have pushed carbon dioxide into the air and carbon dioxide warms things up a lot. You can do an experiment. Take a plastic bag and wrap it around your head. Leaving no air holes. See if you can survive for long.
@xixie5854
@xixie5854 3 года назад
Tristan Vassar how are climate scientists making up eildly dofferent statements each year?
@UNcommonSenseAUS
@UNcommonSenseAUS 3 года назад
You realise that bill nye is an *ACTOR*
@shane9245
@shane9245 3 года назад
Tucker “👁 👁” Carlson 🕳
@sarconi11
@sarconi11 3 года назад
Lol why does he always make that face?
@shane9245
@shane9245 3 года назад
sarconi11 I would guess it’s because he is trying to understand what they are saying, but that’s just my guess.
@sweakerthan
@sweakerthan 3 года назад
laughed out loud. thanks for this
@elijahlahde906
@elijahlahde906 3 года назад
Tucker=🤡
@TheA10Phonex
@TheA10Phonex 3 года назад
I wish they had a butthole emoji.
@colevilleproductions
@colevilleproductions 7 месяцев назад
I can feel the cognitive dissonance coming inside me 😩
@flamingpaxtsc
@flamingpaxtsc 14 дней назад
Lol
@patrickstar3293
@patrickstar3293 9 месяцев назад
"Im open minded you are not" LMFAOOOO
@chaseelzinga4640
@chaseelzinga4640 4 года назад
Who wants to see Bill Nye and Ben Shapiro debate.
@shockwavesyndrome6433
@shockwavesyndrome6433 4 года назад
Eminem Awol27 why so Ben Shapiro can talk about the science of selling houses that are under water
@EdgieAlias
@EdgieAlias 4 года назад
@@shockwavesyndrome6433 Or so he can make arguments that don't really matter. Or are just wrong.
@567BubbaGump
@567BubbaGump 4 года назад
Ben would completely embarrass him
@EdgieAlias
@EdgieAlias 4 года назад
@@HuyVu-lx1mf Can I get a link?
@EdgieAlias
@EdgieAlias 4 года назад
@@HuyVu-lx1mf Sorry, what's the excuse?
@brendanhorrocks4109
@brendanhorrocks4109 4 года назад
the camera man won this debate when he zoomed in on bill nyes lips
@christophervanzetta
@christophervanzetta 4 года назад
HAHAHAHAHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAa
@andreaflores2189
@andreaflores2189 4 года назад
😂😂😂😂
@Demon_Lord_Coom
@Demon_Lord_Coom 4 года назад
I hate politics, one side is a bunch of pussys and the other side doesnt believe in science. Also the pussys don't believe in biology and are disgusting.
@itsmepreston89
@itsmepreston89 4 года назад
4:32
@michaelwall4022
@michaelwall4022 4 года назад
@@Demon_Lord_Coom you need to change your nick to "I am stupid" Because I don't buy your specific theory does not mean I don't believe in science. It means I think you have a BS theory. When one side keeps claiming the science is settled and we know their numbers are bogus and somebody stands to make a great deal of money and have an unprecedented amount of power if we believe them. There is not only cause but a responsibility for skepticism.
@andtou1342
@andtou1342 Год назад
Why does Tucker Carlson always have a confused look on his face when he interviews people?
@monotech20.14
@monotech20.14 Год назад
Thats the I'm really paying attention , thinking hard and interested look. So Tucker can act like he's fair. Which we know isn't true.
@phatrickmoore
@phatrickmoore Год назад
Seems like it might not be a look 🤣
@thegreatWIIMO
@thegreatWIIMO Год назад
It would help if the reporter shut his mouth and let bill talk
@aspiringbeamoflight7047
@aspiringbeamoflight7047 3 года назад
Tucker and Bill are the two spectrum of American intelligence
@arlaghdoth4434
@arlaghdoth4434 3 года назад
Stupid vs Can't Admit that They're stupid
@user-cf6dn5tg4f
@user-cf6dn5tg4f 3 года назад
@@arlaghdoth4434 logical vs they think they are logical*
@stevensanchez1192
@stevensanchez1192 3 года назад
@@arlaghdoth4434 Littearlly a scientist vs a biased person
@blamecyrbx4942
@blamecyrbx4942 3 года назад
You are wrong Bill is the only intelligence
@aspiringbeamoflight7047
@aspiringbeamoflight7047 3 года назад
@@blamecyrbx4942 FACTS! 🙌
@nasaman5440
@nasaman5440 3 года назад
the conversation that broke bill nye’s hope in humanity
@Yupper277
@Yupper277 3 года назад
This conversation broke my hope in humanity
@Sarah53123
@Sarah53123 3 года назад
@@Yupper277 you had hope before 👁👄👁
@l.c3994
@l.c3994 3 года назад
Love how he timed how long it took for the Media guy to interrupt him
@wicked1-666
@wicked1-666 3 года назад
This made me lose hope I didn't know I had.
@jonathanbridger5847
@jonathanbridger5847 3 года назад
Facts
@bowler7922
@bowler7922 6 месяцев назад
Man Bill Nye is absolutely amazing.
@flamingpaxtsc
@flamingpaxtsc 14 дней назад
You should change your pfp, Trump mugshot commenters have a terrible reputation.
@bowler7922
@bowler7922 13 дней назад
@@flamingpaxtsc lol nah, its funny to me
@LlamaSticks
@LlamaSticks 4 месяца назад
pulling out the stopwatch was crazy LMAO
@davidfirth
@davidfirth 6 лет назад
This is what it looks like to see a man so desperately out of his depth, and aware of it, trying his damned hardest not to look like an idiot whilst maintaining a solid position on something he knows absolutely zero about. This is really embarrassing to watch.
@UbuhEats
@UbuhEats 6 лет назад
I want you to know that your salad fingers series scarred me. Love ya work.
@emanthemyth
@emanthemyth 6 лет назад
You're referring to the host right?
@benjiii3407
@benjiii3407 6 лет назад
Holy crap we have a god among us and n one realizes it.
@marcusanderson7198
@marcusanderson7198 6 лет назад
David Firth I was thinking the same thing. This idiot needs to shit the hell up.
@GlaciusTS
@GlaciusTS 6 лет назад
I do hope you are talking about Tucker. Big fan, by the way. What is most absurd is the lengths Tucker will go to in order to make sure Nye doesn’t get to finish making a point.
@xeric1
@xeric1 7 лет назад
I wonder if Fox News thinks this makes them look good.
@penmae5397
@penmae5397 7 лет назад
to the public that matters, which is any rational person it does. You climate cultists can group down vote and block comment this all you want. Science, time & nature are not on your side. You're over.
@XEZ616
@XEZ616 7 лет назад
Climate cultists lol
@ameerkhattab
@ameerkhattab 7 лет назад
8bingbang H
@Killerjosh89
@Killerjosh89 7 лет назад
+bigstrudel >says they're number 1 >bitches about mainstream media in other vids
@Jeustful
@Jeustful 7 лет назад
Ignorance can be bliss, but just while it lasts. When truth finally settles in, the realization becomes a heavy burden.
@ermertieplug
@ermertieplug Год назад
It's good to have conversations but not when one person is just trying to make the other one look bad. It distracts from the issue and from the truth.
@Darling137
@Darling137 10 месяцев назад
I know, right? Nye exhibited no good faith and didn't even make an attempt to answer any questions. He undermined his own case.
@bobbygetsbanned6049
@bobbygetsbanned6049 10 месяцев назад
Nye embarrassing himself, doesn't have a single data point. The climate would be like 1750, when humans had been impacting the environment for thousands of years with millions of people burning wood for heat?? Interesting.
@IGotGills
@IGotGills 9 месяцев назад
@@Darling137Carlson was trying to get ån Irrelevant answer he says “what is the rate and percentage of the change” where that isn’t Documented he wanted Nye to concede the point. The point Nye was preaching was that warming is accelerating. Carlson was clearly presenting a Strawman and not even trying to Listen.
@Darling137
@Darling137 9 месяцев назад
@@IGotGills It's not a straw man and it's entirely relevant when proponents of a cause make very specific claims that X is happening because of Y. Tucker asks valid questions about metrics. If X is true, then tell us the details of the cost of ignoring our fighting it
@brothaMan84
@brothaMan84 Год назад
Quick summery, Tucker thinks 2+2=3. He gets cranky and throws a fit. It’s explained to him that it’s 4, but he can’t comprehend it. He has a huge tantrum and goes to bed 👍🏽
@ItsDangerousGoAlone
@ItsDangerousGoAlone Год назад
But it is an open question for debate. To what degree does 2+2=3? Answer the question, to what degree? You are closed minded and we are out of time
@conemsrs444
@conemsrs444 7 лет назад
Talking over someone doesn't make you more right or your point more valid. Bill Nye wins
@mathewjones4681
@mathewjones4681 7 лет назад
Connor CWC k. Which is why bill couldn't answer a simple question. I don't blame him for interrupting
@assemblyrequired7342
@assemblyrequired7342 7 лет назад
He kept trying! But he kept on getting cut off!
@the7thage576
@the7thage576 7 лет назад
Connor CWC bill could not provide...wait for it...EVIDENCE
@assemblyrequired7342
@assemblyrequired7342 7 лет назад
Furher Coleman Then you were clearly not paying attention. He said 100% percent at 3:34.
@ANDIRAMA999
@ANDIRAMA999 7 лет назад
There is nothing to be gained from looking at percentages as your metric. Like, there is not a percentage of the changed climate that was caused by humans, it's not how it works. The more useful way of looking at it is to look at the change in rate of climate change
@potatotomato6094
@potatotomato6094 3 года назад
Tucker: says something Bill Nye: smiles painfully
@potatotomato6094
@potatotomato6094 3 года назад
@Jim Harol imagine being dumb
@DemMyHouser
@DemMyHouser 3 года назад
@@potatotomato6094 lmao true, that’s pretty much sums up the average conservative.
@potatotomato6094
@potatotomato6094 3 года назад
@@DemMyHouser didnt have to make it political but ok
@DemMyHouser
@DemMyHouser 3 года назад
@@potatotomato6094 I mean all of those characterizations you just gave is the average conservative who thinks that all media is fake unless the president approves of it, coronavirus is a hoax because the president said so, the government is corrupt “unless it’s my political party”, a whole bunch of conspiracy theories and even conspiracy groups such as QAnon and so forth. Just because you didn’t want to attach the appropriate label to the characterizations you gave in order to seem unbiased doesn’t mean that I wouldn’t lol.
@irchristo
@irchristo 3 года назад
I know, right? His mouth doesn't make that shape.
@kadeskeen5133
@kadeskeen5133 9 месяцев назад
Why is a mechanical engineering talking to us on climate change??
@justinsanchez1305
@justinsanchez1305 Год назад
Huge mistake for Tucker to try and take on Nye. Made himself look dumb.
@jonathancampbell7798
@jonathancampbell7798 Год назад
He doesn't need Bill to make him look dumb. He does a great job on his own
@s1t2e3i4n5
@s1t2e3i4n5 8 месяцев назад
It's quite interesting how people can watch the same video and yet appear to have watched 2 completely different videos.
@judithwake2757
@judithwake2757 6 месяцев назад
Mr Turkey doesnt just look dumb he is dumb.
@judithwake2757
@judithwake2757 6 месяцев назад
​@@s1t2e3i4n5 It happens because some people are completely ignorant of healthy,😊 constructive communication techniques. So they misinterpret what is said by both participants. Oops! Sorry I used a 12 letter word.😊
@thedankatheist3466
@thedankatheist3466 3 года назад
If Tucker had a stroke live on air I don’t think anyone would notice.
@exile9237
@exile9237 3 года назад
Lol
@makdaddy7226
@makdaddy7226 3 года назад
I applaud this comment
@ohmiohwa4199
@ohmiohwa4199 3 года назад
Or care.
@Jacob-zk1jy
@Jacob-zk1jy 3 года назад
He’s not having a stroke?
@cryptic_rain8951
@cryptic_rain8951 3 года назад
Ok buddy
@atms04
@atms04 3 года назад
Tucker: how much are humans responsible for the increasing rate? Bill: 100% Tucker: okay so how much?
@explosivemallard8038
@explosivemallard8038 3 года назад
Lmao well said.
@explosivemallard8038
@explosivemallard8038 3 года назад
@Mary Charge It’s the rate.
@explosivemallard8038
@explosivemallard8038 3 года назад
@Mary Charge 100% isn’t a rate of change.
@explosivemallard8038
@explosivemallard8038 3 года назад
@Mary Charge To be fair, you sound as sure as a 5 year old identifying Luxembourg in geography class. And with comparable math skills, too. Anyone who knows how to solve 1/1 wouldn’t be asking if it’s a rate or not. Edit: maybe you’ll be better at tee ball after school. At least then your random swinging might land a hit.
@explosivemallard8038
@explosivemallard8038 3 года назад
@Mary Charge I didn’t think you were smart enough to see your own stupidity in stating his claim, then stating he has no claim. Edit: I still don’t think your smart enough to see your flawed argument and thought process.
@Zentao420
@Zentao420 7 месяцев назад
" that's a very ominous thing to say. I don't know what it means..." WOW! You know what it means now!😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@BirdGang6
@BirdGang6 Год назад
I remember when this video came out and the Republicans tried to spin it as Tucker “Owning” Bill. That couldn’t be further from the truth. It’s like watching a toddler try and argue with their pre school teacher.
@mauriannarichardson1874
@mauriannarichardson1874 3 года назад
Tucker literally talked over Nye the entire time and all of a sudden the time is up... why are they like this.
@magiccoleman6764
@magiccoleman6764 3 года назад
Tucker keeps asking "basic questions", but doesn't even understand the basics of climate change itself. Tucker wanted to try and make Bill Nye look dumb, but he made himself look like an idiot. Nye: answers questions Tucker: I'm open-minded, you are not. Nye: 🤨 (must be that cognitive dissonance i was talking about 😏)
@LGCYBeats
@LGCYBeats 3 года назад
@@magiccoleman6764 It makes me sad that people like tucker have such a wide platform. Imagine even thinking that you could get a simple answer to a topic as complex as climate change (even though Bill did what he could to make it bite sized). Tuckers metal capacity is so small, trying to explain that would be like ramming a tree into a pencil sharpener.
@adamoshea2793
@adamoshea2793 3 года назад
Because they know they have no answers so they just shout .
@gondor532
@gondor532 3 года назад
Well if Nye tried to give concrete answer maybe he wouldnt get talked over
@bigyoshi7134
@bigyoshi7134 3 года назад
@@gondor532 he did give answers. The main point is that humans have speed up the time in which it takes for climate around the world to change. We would be in the position we are currently in in maybe another thousand years or so. But because of all the technology and fossil fuels we use, that change has come around in less than 100 years
@novo995
@novo995 3 года назад
I feel like fox is just a very elaborate Onion News joke
@shawnv123
@shawnv123 3 года назад
it’s not
@Fitchman55th
@Fitchman55th 3 года назад
best comment +1
@janeismyname588
@janeismyname588 3 года назад
If Only!
@kemidoesgaming5106
@kemidoesgaming5106 3 года назад
I am the 100th like :)
@kemidoesgaming5106
@kemidoesgaming5106 3 года назад
Also eat your cereal
@cb-9938
@cb-9938 Год назад
Bill Nye looks like Clint Eastwoods nerdy younger brother
@followthesun2115
@followthesun2115 10 месяцев назад
Whenever someone tries to end debate by claiming the science is "settled," it's proof that their ideas cannot withstand scrutiny.
@JR-yd5pf
@JR-yd5pf 10 месяцев назад
Such a stupid comment. I say it's settled us humans need water to live. It IS setteled, in the sense that it is a sound conclusion.
@Megke17
@Megke17 10 месяцев назад
If it's settled...why wouldn't he answer his question on "to what degree the climate would change if humans weren't a factor?" We need to know this if we have any way of preventing a future ice age or massive pole shifts. If it's settled, wouldn't the data show that? Settled, is to reach a conclusion with all the data...but where is the data? It's like a parent saying I'm right to their child so don't you dare question my authority. If climate change science is rooted in data and research... why not share the data? Yes, the earth is warming, but how can we prove that this isn't just apart of mother natures or gods design? We shouldn't be dismissive of others, it is divisive and not helpful in unifying people to come together and make positive changes.
@followthesun2115
@followthesun2115 10 месяцев назад
@@JR-yd5pf The difference, of course, is that there is consensus in the scientific community that humans need water to live. There is no consensus on climate science, the impact of human activity and how to mitigate any impact. But maybe you're too stupid to understand that.
@JackJohnson-wg1ye
@JackJohnson-wg1ye 9 месяцев назад
@@JR-yd5pfWater? We’re talking about the climate you twat and the rate humans are contributing to it. I bet you still wear a mask in public.
@connorblanton275
@connorblanton275 9 месяцев назад
​@Megke17 Bro, he couldn't exactly pull out his phone to find the stat, do you know how long it takes for a apple tree to grow a perfectly ripe apple. No, cuz that's an obscure question that would be hard to memorize unless that was your whole career. Bill doesn't study only climate change, so he's probably not gonna know the stat of the top of his head seeing as he's done and is doing a lot of other stuff in his life
@DulceneiaMinaj
@DulceneiaMinaj 3 года назад
Bill: **explaining science** Tucker: "SLOW DOWN, BEFORE WE START NAME CALLING..."
@Sham_Knubs
@Sham_Knubs 3 года назад
Facts
@chasepotter2376
@chasepotter2376 3 года назад
Nye literally didn’t answer Tuckers actual question and the things he did say weren’t even scientifically accurate.
@DulceneiaMinaj
@DulceneiaMinaj 3 года назад
@@chasepotter2376 did we watch the same video?
@GM-dp8nz
@GM-dp8nz 3 года назад
@@chasepotter2376 yea he did
@troppur7355
@troppur7355 3 года назад
Chase Potter Reeee
@colinpost1066
@colinpost1066 3 года назад
"I'm open minded and you are not... and we are out of time" -Tucker Carlson
@gabriel_sm
@gabriel_sm 3 года назад
"If You Open Your Mind Too Much Your Brain Will Fall Off" ~Tim Minchin
@Obi-Wan_Kenobi
@Obi-Wan_Kenobi 3 года назад
The epitome of open-mindedness is telling other people they are not open-minded.
@aidannolanlogansawyer9777
@aidannolanlogansawyer9777 3 года назад
Really it's the other way around
@castle9165
@castle9165 3 года назад
@@aidannolanlogansawyer9777 that's the irony of *ucker Carlson saying that he's bragging about having an open mind after refusing evidence and cutting the guy off so he can't refute the statement on open mindedness
@codyrebelcb
@codyrebelcb 3 года назад
"Is it 74.3% human activity that causes climate change?" -Tucker Carlson That right there, shows he doesn't even know what answer he wants. That itself, doesn't even make sense.
@janet30ish
@janet30ish Год назад
Tucker is the only one shouting
@wobotnik
@wobotnik 8 месяцев назад
Tucker just demonstrated his total unfitness to be a journalist of any sort.
@Cptn.JackWandil
@Cptn.JackWandil 3 года назад
Bills answers get more and more basic as he realizes the intelligence of tucker
@ajgillies
@ajgillies 3 года назад
That was my take as well. He had to dumb it down to a lower and lower school age grade level for the ranting host who can’t be patient enough to hear an entire response
@edwarddongres7866
@edwarddongres7866 3 года назад
Opinions. Mechanical engineer is NOT science teacher, he's TV entertainer.
@wangstar
@wangstar 3 года назад
@@edwarddongres7866 Mechanical engineers have to take science classes, so they would understand the basics of science. The actual engineering classes then apply the sciences they learn to build things. So I think he's fairly qualified to talk about science.
@edwarddongres7866
@edwarddongres7866 3 года назад
Any SPECIFICS?
@edwarddongres7866
@edwarddongres7866 3 года назад
@@wangstar No science class will show you the ice in the north till you actually fly over. I do often every time I fly to Thailand. Now where is the warm up again?
@TheCrunchyGum
@TheCrunchyGum 7 лет назад
Tucker: *Asks a question* Bill Nye: *Answers Question* Tucker: "YOU'RE NOT ANSWERING THE SIMPLE QUESTION"
@TheAmericansinger
@TheAmericansinger 7 лет назад
Crunchy Gum It's funny, cause this is the reverse of Kellyanne Conway. Where she's asked a question and dodges around it.
@o-t-m5195
@o-t-m5195 7 лет назад
Maybe thats becase he was not answering the fucking question
@TheAmericansinger
@TheAmericansinger 7 лет назад
O-T -M He was very much answering the question.
@sypoth
@sypoth 7 лет назад
Crunchy Gum more like Tucker: asks simple question. Bill Nye the engineer Guy: avoids and deflects. Tucker: pushes for answer Bill Nye the has no background and fails at basic science Guy: How dare you make me answer a question any grade schooler knows but I don't! Your anti science *thumps religious text that's been scientifically disproven by real scientists.*
@sypoth
@sypoth 7 лет назад
ArgusOfNight if you call an obvious deflection and red herring response an answer.
@LetsPlayArcanium
@LetsPlayArcanium Год назад
“ im asking you a simple question” continues to answer it in a way he doesn’t want to hear it.
@ereman6
@ereman6 10 месяцев назад
So you were able to gather the degree which humans have caused the climate to change? I didn't hear the answer please enlighten me. 100%? we know that's just not true, so what's the real number. When I hear "humans cause climate change". My first two questions are - 1.what exactly are we doing? 2.what degree of change is that (what we are doing) having on the planet? You really can't calculate one without the other. Bill didn't come close to answering those questions. Mostly he rattled off the effect of the climate changing - everyone concedes the climate is changing. Which brings us back to the two questions. They are having a circular argument because Bill refuses to answer the question.
@bigverybadtom
@bigverybadtom 9 месяцев назад
Fails to answer it you mean.
@ereman6
@ereman6 9 месяцев назад
Obfuscation is not answering
@canadiankewldude
@canadiankewldude Год назад
This was a complete and unnecessary interview. Science has the answer, people just need to read more. The proof is in the data, Tucker.
@andyzhang7890
@andyzhang7890 3 года назад
Tucker "waitwaitwAitslowdownholdOnHOLDONSTOP" Carlson
@SlimbyTheSillyGoose
@SlimbyTheSillyGoose 3 года назад
Well, bill never answered Carlsons question, Bill was starting to talk about a different topic. Carlson was trying to stop him before so,
@ansley3674
@ansley3674 3 года назад
@@SlimbyTheSillyGoose bill literally had to dumb it down and give him examples of it
@lolhinon3713
@lolhinon3713 3 года назад
@@SlimbyTheSillyGoose well if tucker would've let bill finish all of his responses he would've already answered the question, he is trying to explain the situation and how they got to the answer before answering the questions, like most intellectual people do, unlike other people, it is important for one to do this when explaining a topic in science
@arizona_sunshine128
@arizona_sunshine128 3 года назад
@@SlimbyTheSillyGoose Bill answered the question, he just didn't answer it the way tucker wanted.
@Primus54
@Primus54 Год назад
Bill asserts cognitive dissonance is the problem and he’s correct. The comments in this thread prove it. Bill deflected questions with irrelevant bullSchiff like wine growing instead of answering it scientifically, such as what the average global temperature would be today if not for human activity. 🙄
@ComicCub
@ComicCub 3 года назад
bill: says something in a slow and concise manner tucker: "WAIT WAIT WAIT, STOP STOP STOP, SLOW DOWN"
@webguy943
@webguy943 3 года назад
STOP STOP STOP WAIT WAIT WAIT SLOW DOWN.
@airbornewarningandcontrols396
@airbornewarningandcontrols396 3 года назад
SOTOP SLOW DOWN SLOW DOWN YOU ARE GOING AT THE SPEED AT LIGHT
@kjartanruminy6297
@kjartanruminy6297 3 года назад
wdym the guy is speaking 400 words per second
@edwarddongres7866
@edwarddongres7866 3 года назад
Comic Cub , where is any climate denier? Name one.
@edwarddongres7866
@edwarddongres7866 3 года назад
Comic Cub , name one climate denier.
@ewoudalliet1734
@ewoudalliet1734 11 месяцев назад
Dude had to measure how long it took for Tucker to interrupt him...
@Dudemon-1
@Dudemon-1 10 месяцев назад
Tucker should have shown the clock on how quickly Nye evaded the question.
@nervousbunnygaming
@nervousbunnygaming Год назад
That’s so weird… bill nye gives answers and then tucker Carlson doesn’t agree with the answers…. So he says bill nye isn’t giving him real answers…. What is going on
@consciouspresence5880
@consciouspresence5880 Год назад
did we watch the same debate. Bill Ni the appeal to authority guy said he wants to imprison people who disagree with him then when tucker questioned him he started talking about grapes.
@poke_warrior
@poke_warrior 3 года назад
"Tucker takes him on in an unforgettable debate". What? That wasn't a debate. That was just a guy who has no idea what he's talking about shouting louder than the guy who actually does.
@samuelboggs3108
@samuelboggs3108 3 года назад
FACTS!! 💯
@redmosquito2173
@redmosquito2173 3 года назад
Just like the presidential debates
@nj4l30
@nj4l30 3 года назад
@@redmosquito2173 one time biden roasted trumps response to the pandemic and called him bad a golf at the same time...madlad
@jordyjustine
@jordyjustine 3 года назад
Bill Nye is legitimately an actor, not a scientist. Thats a tv show to assist in indoctrinating the youth. He obviously couldnt explain one of his so called "scientific" concensus "facts". You cant just say that it is and it does. Thats not science; that is scientism otherwise known as authoritarian bs. If you cant explain your position on something without just regurgitating that its an "established fact" than you dont know your position very well and are most likely a paid actor. Of which he actually is.
@jimmyphelps7460
@jimmyphelps7460 3 года назад
@@jordyjustine he literally has degrees and is well respected in the scientific community. Try again.
@timharris618
@timharris618 4 года назад
Nye: I love you as a person Tucker: BEFORE WE START NAME CALLING
@wq198mnr
@wq198mnr 3 года назад
Tim Harris why couldn’t Bill Nye answer simple questions? What degree is climate change caused by human activity? Why can’t the scientist answer? Because they don’t know.
@TheA10Phonex
@TheA10Phonex 3 года назад
@BRO SKI You’re joking, right?
@KickinAss1000
@KickinAss1000 3 года назад
@@wq198mnr when u r such an inbred sumbfuck, you can ignore the answers and listen to the host shout over him in the middle 'WHY CANT YOU ANSWER MUH Q" and you drool and repeat it mindlessly in the comments LOL
@KickinAss1000
@KickinAss1000 3 года назад
@@wq198mnr they do know and the vast majority of overall rising tempature is caused by us.
@undefined5083
@undefined5083 3 года назад
@@wq198mnr you shouldn't be allowed to speak your opinion anymore because its hurting people with common sense brains
@1johnnyangel
@1johnnyangel 10 месяцев назад
Bill is the perfect example of, im not a doctor but i play one on t.v lmfao
@sillkthashocker
@sillkthashocker 9 месяцев назад
How's that
@ohyea456
@ohyea456 9 месяцев назад
Except I doubt that Bill Nye himself reached out to the station to do an interview. They, most likely, reached out to him. So, if anyone is to blame for a poorly represented argument, it's the news network. However, they had an agenda to push, IE that climate change has little/nothing to do with humans and so they found someone willing to represent the argument that would fall short. Bill Nye isn't specialized in climate study. He has merely done "some" studying of it and drew conclusions. As we all do when we research something for a short period of time. The station prepared questions for Bill to answer full well knowing that he most likely would not be able to regurgitate numbers and statistical data. If anything, this showed Bill's tolerance for being lambasted in front of million of viewers and he took it in stride. It showed character.
@bruhbaboiey6284
@bruhbaboiey6284 9 месяцев назад
You watched tucker carlson cry on tv but nah its Bill Nye whos stupid
@adiathubendre24
@adiathubendre24 9 месяцев назад
if you think tucker really believes all the crap he peddles on FOX then you are just plain misguided. The same goes for any "news" anchor or host of any main stream media.
@joeburton1232
@joeburton1232 8 месяцев назад
EXACTLY
@ben-9123
@ben-9123 8 месяцев назад
‘I will not be shouted down by people like you,’ says the man who is getting visibly frustrated by a scientist who is a lot calmer than I would be in that situation.
@SweetTodd
@SweetTodd 8 месяцев назад
I guess that people working in retail and fast food not being happy-go-lucky is still a mystery to you.
@ben-9123
@ben-9123 8 месяцев назад
No, I don't get angry at fast food and retail workers, because 1) I rarely eat fast food, and 2) they're not Tucker Carlson.
@SweetTodd
@SweetTodd 8 месяцев назад
@@ben-9123 hm, don't think they are related.
@ben-9123
@ben-9123 8 месяцев назад
Am I missing something glaringly obvious about by comment? Everyone seems to see something that I don't. All I was saying is that Tucker is the one shouting at Bill while Bill remains completely calm, making his statement deeply ironic and making him seem even more obnoxious.
@SweetTodd
@SweetTodd 8 месяцев назад
@@ben-9123 Oh I'm sorry. I forfeit. Your prize will be a $5 Applebee's coupon.
@ambianceansley
@ambianceansley 3 года назад
my dad watches tucker carlson daily, and he argues exactly like this. imagine how frustrating a conversation with him is
@jasonthomas6096
@jasonthomas6096 3 года назад
I am so sorry if you have to hear someone argue like this. If someone said “wait wait wait, slow down” to me that many times I would probably ask then if they needed me to break out the finger paints.
@zparparz5620
@zparparz5620 3 года назад
He probably comes at you with logic and wisdom and you're mad that you can't play victim around him
@ashton803
@ashton803 3 года назад
@@zparparz5620 dad destroys daughter with facts and logic headass
@zparparz5620
@zparparz5620 3 года назад
@@ashton803 talk like an adult or don't address me. I don't deal with ignorance.
@sethc195
@sethc195 3 года назад
Lmfao
@scottk1525
@scottk1525 3 года назад
Whenever Carlson stop talking, he enters low power mode to extend battery life.
@matthaynes2761
@matthaynes2761 3 года назад
😂
@nerdly44
@nerdly44 3 года назад
lmao
@leahmay1506
@leahmay1506 3 года назад
LMAOO
@boxwold9425
@boxwold9425 3 года назад
you should put that on r/rareinsults
@WBKimmons
@WBKimmons 3 года назад
Lol
@Cannabeknown
@Cannabeknown 10 месяцев назад
“To what degree?” “It’s super cereal”
@SuperWearethed
@SuperWearethed Год назад
Tucker: “Ask honest answers” Bill: I don’t think you meant ask Tucker: I did mean ask. 🤣🤣🤣 he just arguing to argue because he has no argument. He even argued that he meant to say ask😂😂🤣
@elithepotato6481
@elithepotato6481 3 года назад
Bill: I love you as a person Tucker: ok before the name calling begins...
@neceon4586
@neceon4586 3 года назад
If someone says that about Tucker something's wrong
@TheJrak47
@TheJrak47 3 года назад
😆
@nathanyoung3483
@nathanyoung3483 3 года назад
That was just Tucker signalling that he was about to start the name calling.
@jordanghost26
@jordanghost26 3 года назад
U caught that too? 😅🤣🤣🤣🤣💯
@luckyduckydaisyflower2344
@luckyduckydaisyflower2344 3 года назад
Yea umm. I wonder..is he a genuine philanthropist?? Can someone make sense of that interaction. I think im right. I think he saying he loves people 🤔 or was that to make fun.
@miceymen1503
@miceymen1503 4 года назад
4:41 thank you, camera guy, for giving us all what we really wanted.
@twinglocks9304
@twinglocks9304 4 года назад
Toori Baba quite random too. i was confused
@unapproved-apples809
@unapproved-apples809 4 года назад
Caught me off guard. Was getting pissed and just made me laugh real hard lol
@Dgrishark29
@Dgrishark29 4 года назад
Exactly I was just commenting to myself how fantastic the cameraman's work was. Psychology dictates that when you are losing an argument like that you have a lot of physical tells. I'm sorry Bill Nye I used to like you old boy but you're losing this argument pretty bad m
@user-il5hy5tr5z
@user-il5hy5tr5z 4 года назад
Johnny Boy not really bruh..
@Dgrishark29
@Dgrishark29 4 года назад
@@user-il5hy5tr5z and how's that?
@_SeeIt
@_SeeIt 7 месяцев назад
He answered the question. Tucker pretended not to hear it.
@Megadevilsman
@Megadevilsman Год назад
the only reason they have guest on this show is not to inform or hear a new opinion, it's just to talk over them and not let them speak then call THEM stupid and say see we won that debate because I called him dumb. it's like a kindergarten playground for adults. THIS IS WHATS DESTROYING OUR COUNTRY! don't have guests if you never let them speak it's a disserves to everyone.
@lyndsay369
@lyndsay369 3 года назад
this is literally just tucker carlson being unable to comprehend science for 10 minutes straight
@julie-di1si
@julie-di1si 3 года назад
literally he's so close minded
@---di7hj
@---di7hj 3 года назад
Literally, even a 5th grader could understand simple climate change on earth
@jonathanperry8331
@jonathanperry8331 3 года назад
Watch John Oliver's last week tonight about him came out yesterday
@christopherclan07
@christopherclan07 3 года назад
Tucker isn't denying climate change at all! He is simply asking bill if human interaction has had any significant influence on climate change in which he bill can't seem to answer.
@konvicti94
@konvicti94 3 года назад
@@christopherclan07 you right, wikipedia says, People are responsible for climate change only for 1%.
@owolff4314
@owolff4314 3 года назад
“Without being shouted down by people like you!” shouts Tucker Carlson
@chill7135
@chill7135 3 года назад
I officially hate Tucker now, f*cking hypocrite
@oscargreat1657
@oscargreat1657 3 года назад
Tucker Carlson is right though and commie Bill is wrong. Climate threat was 100 % fake aswell. LOL
@oscargreat1657
@oscargreat1657 3 года назад
@Reid Elson It's not about opposing anyone which, by the way, is a communist thing too. Being allergic or immune to facts. That's what happens when group identity is paramount. The left are commies 2020, they even turned on their own people. Like you did. =) It's about following the truth. No lefty can do that. They are, knowingly or unknowingly, following lies and propaganda. Nothing good *ever* came from the left, at least since WW2.
@chrisramos3454
@chrisramos3454 3 года назад
@Reid Elson r/woooosh?
@gynekcham9018
@gynekcham9018 3 года назад
@Reid Elson They like make rules "based on whatever"(some kind of pretended science) without folks agreement. To get at least some agreement they spread lies..grew up inCzechochoslovakia
@mrwifi1206
@mrwifi1206 Год назад
4:41 that is just perfect Haha
@raisinbran3736
@raisinbran3736 10 месяцев назад
"Without being shouted down by you," Carlson shouts at a placid Nye
@AidenCassaroArt
@AidenCassaroArt 3 года назад
Tucker: What is your name? Bill: I am Bill Tucker: No, that's who you are, but what's your name?
@AidenCassaroArt
@AidenCassaroArt 3 года назад
kittypie i swear I made that up tucker 😂 I was high af man when I made it. I used to do that to my lil brother when he was younger. Don’t take it the hard way tucker.
@RenegadeShepTheSpacer
@RenegadeShepTheSpacer 3 года назад
@kittypie Cry more.
@callactm14
@callactm14 3 года назад
Idiot
@captainjeanlucpicard3700
@captainjeanlucpicard3700 3 года назад
@kittypie well obviously it's wasn't that bad
@lordvoldemort5725
@lordvoldemort5725 3 года назад
I don’t get this joke.
@_wade_morgan
@_wade_morgan 3 года назад
“This is how long it takes for you to interrupt me” - amazing
@carolyntorres4538
@carolyntorres4538 3 года назад
he’s so petty i love it
@our_comrade
@our_comrade 3 года назад
It’s like taking us back to the T.V. show
@subswithoutcontentvid_at_k
@subswithoutcontentvid_at_k 3 года назад
Funny coz bill did most of the interrupting and he didn't even last a second
@inspectasexy1264
@inspectasexy1264 3 года назад
@@subswithoutcontentvid_at_k wym
@zolnsalt
@zolnsalt 3 года назад
@@subswithoutcontentvid_at_k exactly, the only difference was Tucker didn't ask Bill Nye how long it took to interrupt him, from the very beginning Nye was interrupting.
@jebus9303
@jebus9303 Год назад
Show me a picture of Tucker on his show where he doesn’t look confused and bewildered by absolutely anything. It can’t be done.
@KristBoston
@KristBoston Год назад
The fact that the title is Tucker vs…. Shows that Fox News literally just wanted to put out content of division… it’s been exhausting at this point 😓 honestly
@dylanhilliard
@dylanhilliard 3 года назад
Tucker literally can’t even let Bill finish a sentence. This is embarrassing on Tucker and Fox’s party
@jonathanperry8331
@jonathanperry8331 3 года назад
Watch John Oliver's last week tonight about him came out yesterday
@marshmallowvampire8503
@marshmallowvampire8503 3 года назад
I agree, but I still love that he's not letting Bill give vague answers.😄😄 He's like if Bill knows he can explain it clearly and concisely, as Bill goes on a whole tangent about "we're not certain that ____" and humans cause this and that bad (which I'm not denying). Honestly it's awesome to be a skeptic b'coz I'll rarely be spoon fed anything. I am a skeptic about the whole humans call this and that terrible thing, b'coz while it might be true, it's immoral. For years scientists have had to come behind each other and correct something, the way the dinosaurs look have changed every 5 - 10 years almost, and at one point we didn't even know the concept of germs.😂😂😂 I take everything with the word "theory" in the name with a grain of salt. Half of the theories will be proven wrong in the next hundred years, anyway.
@ethangaines2658
@ethangaines2658 3 года назад
How is it embarrassing? They do it all the time, it's why people watch the channel. It's an engine that supports far-right opinions, and 99% of far-righters deny climate change.
@Globerson
@Globerson 3 года назад
False
@jonathanperry8331
@jonathanperry8331 3 года назад
@@Globerson fake news
@firstname3359
@firstname3359 3 года назад
I love how tucker claims “bill is shouting over the people with questions” as he is continuously shouting over bills response to them
@NewEra90000
@NewEra90000 3 года назад
Ikr f them republicans
@duncangilpatric987
@duncangilpatric987 3 года назад
And Bill says, "I love you as a person more than life itself" and Tucker goes, "before the name calling begins" I mean I know toxic masculinity is his thing, but come on
@tommurphy4770
@tommurphy4770 3 года назад
I was literally about to write this, how can you expect someone to have an open and honest debate as he kept going on about when you don't even let them talk for six seconds.
@profcastle
@profcastle 3 года назад
Exactly. All the while tucker is shouting and Bill never raises his voice.
@escapedfromnewyork
@escapedfromnewyork 2 года назад
@Dunxan Gilpatric....my that comment about "love you more than...." was starting the conversation with dishonesty. Tucker was getting flabbergasted because Nye couldn't answer. It's simple If the climate we have now is what it is solely because of man, what should it have been EXACTLY, because if you don't know, there's no way to know that it has changed solely because of man.
@michaelkilgoresr.8361
@michaelkilgoresr.8361 12 дней назад
The "IDK what that means" at the end says it all. Tucker wouldn't let the man speak. That wasn't an adult conversation. Jesus that guy is something else. Poor Bill, did great trying to explain things to this over grown child.
@mixwell12333
@mixwell12333 11 месяцев назад
Why can you hear sirens in a news studio????
@laurac7081
@laurac7081 3 года назад
bill: "hello-" carlson: "wAIT- waitwait hOLD oN"
@amitfihman7342
@amitfihman7342 3 года назад
Crowley ❤️❤️❤️❤️
@haruhirogrimgar6047
@haruhirogrimgar6047 3 года назад
Basically every time Fox has a guest that isn't a hardcore conservative. They will invite on everyone from doctors to economists like Richard Wolff to various scientists and Bill Nye, and then talk over them the entire time. Only to at the end go "I am right but you are wrong but I keep an open mind unlike you *supposed* experts."
@schizofrz
@schizofrz 3 года назад
Nathan Jung he’s Is a scientist he has a masters degree
@vickydaboi4034
@vickydaboi4034 3 года назад
@H N hwo could you compare bill nye to sean hannity
@burths7984
@burths7984 3 года назад
You're a dickhead
@justinday8392
@justinday8392 3 года назад
Typical Tucker, so “open minded.” Just interrupt and talk over everyone that has something real to say.
@hanslander2849
@hanslander2849 3 года назад
Lol because people refuse to answer his questions.
@nickyoung6110
@nickyoung6110 3 года назад
@@hanslander2849 how so? Tucker asks irrelevant and off topic questions, the man clearly doesn’t come prepared 😂🚮
@ACampbell
@ACampbell 3 года назад
@@hanslander2849 because his questions are just deflecting blatant facts
@DwarfProblemz92
@DwarfProblemz92 3 года назад
Dude is a moron.
@eagdhj
@eagdhj 3 года назад
@@hanslander2849 Troll?
@red..riding..hood..
@red..riding..hood.. 5 месяцев назад
“You want to know when the next ice age will be…?” 😭 GOD I LOVE BILL NYE
@bikepacker9850
@bikepacker9850 10 месяцев назад
11 thousand years ago I could walk from mainland Australia to Tasmania. There is now a sea that is around 90 meters deep seperating the two lands.
@Ev0l_Prod1gy
@Ev0l_Prod1gy 2 года назад
This sounds like a skit that might've been on GTA 4 radio.
@Nightowl7982
@Nightowl7982 2 года назад
Haha i used to love listening to that station.
@10whiten99
@10whiten99 2 года назад
That’s so true haha
@shamoo3500
@shamoo3500 2 года назад
I sorted through tons of comments have have yet to find one as accurate as yours.
@hockeyfan131993
@hockeyfan131993 2 года назад
LMAO
@ericginpa
@ericginpa 2 года назад
Best comment ever!
@BrickTamlandOfficial
@BrickTamlandOfficial 7 лет назад
This is what happens when you have a Scientist talk to a Simpleton.
@TheAmericansinger
@TheAmericansinger 7 лет назад
Brick Tamland Now to be fair, Bill isn't a true scientist... However he might as well be with the amount of honorary scientific rewards he has. No joke, Bill is highly accepted as a scientific mind amongst the scientific community.
@vandy3427
@vandy3427 7 лет назад
ArgusOfNight you obviously have no understanding of the word scientist...
@aaronm1081
@aaronm1081 7 лет назад
he asked him to what degree do humans affect climate change. then couldnt answer and said it was 100 percent. then goes on to smell his own farts and sway around his engineer title to end the argument.
@IMBIue
@IMBIue 7 лет назад
True, and Tucker doesn't even have a science background! That's how bad Bill looked. Also, I like how people keep defending bill for being a "science" guy HAHAHAHAHAHA You guys need to stop being deepthroated by your childhood heroes. Bill says the science is settled! The biggest lie in the internet! It's like saying CNN is real news!
@TheAmericansinger
@TheAmericansinger 7 лет назад
+Aaron Mendoza Well little boy, time to rewatch and educate. Here's a little guide for your underdeveloped mind. Tucker: The debate isn't settled, is climate change human caused or not? Bill: The debate is settled and it is human caused (see 90%+ climatology reports taken worldwide every year since 2007 for that answer to be explained) Tucker: To what degree is climate change occuring? (Question you want answered.) Bill: Well, instead of thousands of years, it's happening in decades. (You expected a percent, Bill gave you a different answer.) Tucker: To what degree is human activity responsible for that speed up? Bill: 100% Tucker: At what rate would it have changed without human activity? Bill: Here's a normal climate cycle. Think tens of thousands of years ago with the ice age. Now compare that to millions of years ago with the age of the dinosaurs...(bunch of facts about what time would be like if we lived in a similar climate, like being underwater)... But that's a million year gap. Tucker: You said thousands Bill: That's the ice age, I'm talking about the rate. There are a large people living on coasts (Remember those prehistoric conditions?) Tucker: What would the climate be like if humans weren't involved? Bill: The 1750's. (Proceeds to describe a world that would've been possible) IMBIue​ Those people include the majority of the scientific community who have graciously given Bill several honorary doctorates. Something that is unique in the community, but to be heavily honored, as his accomplishments have earned him that.
@volta2aire
@volta2aire Год назад
7:36 Nye is a popularizer of science. That is not a bad thing. Tucker interrupts guests trying to speak. We must look at the transcript to find Nye's answer. Nye said, "the climate would be like it was in 1750".
@Commonsensible918
@Commonsensible918 Год назад
As a scientific researcher and member of the scientific community, I feel bill nye could have done a better job at explaining. Sometimes you gotta explain these things in layman’s terms to other people because most people don’t understand it. The fact is the question tucker asked has no straight answer. The climate change rate without human intervention is not easy to quantify. There can be a thousand factors associated with it. Bill nye could have clarified that. In stead they went after each other.
@bigverybadtom
@bigverybadtom Год назад
Bill Nye is a TV scientist, the way Telly Savalas was a TV policeman. A real scientist would have come up with graphs and other hard data and Bill Nye provided none.
@wurstbrot1772
@wurstbrot1772 10 месяцев назад
Soooo.... you have no idea how the climate changes because there are a thousand factors assiciates with it, but when the 1001st factor is mankind all of a sudden you know exactly what is going to happen and why? Also: would you agree to Nyes statement at 5:10 that humans prevented a new ice age? If so, do you consider that a bad thing?
@notakobold5792
@notakobold5792 9 месяцев назад
@@wurstbrot1772please do some actual research. We could estimate it pretty well, but it is impossible to predict exactly what would happen. The climate is a chaotic system (look up the double pendulum and how even a tiny difference in input can completely change how it swings, this is an example of a chaotic system). To simplify, the main changes would be due to solar cycles (11 year periods of hot and cold due to solar activity), slight changes in the earth’s orbit and a yearly fluctuations due to different weather patterns (Look up the el nino southern oscillation), also volcanic eruptions have a slight cooling effect (can see some dips in annual temp due to this, it’s quite interesting. If we extrapolate these effects (extrapolation is taking data and estimating what it would be like in the future, it’s very simple, you can look it up, children are taught it in high/middle school (uk/us I think)) they would be very small compared to the observed change over the past few decades. Just look at any graph and see the increase since the industrial revolution. The evidence is there, the evidence is clear, all you need to do is look into it. You can even look at scientific papers on the subject (use google scholar, although I’d recommend only looking at the abstract and conclusion, they use a lot of technical jargon, science and maths that is difficult for non specialists to understand. But if evidence doesn’t interest you, I ask you this. Who has more to gain from lying, Tucker, a rich right wing presenter who relies on support from his climate denying base, or scientists who are looking at evidence to try to answer a question. You seriously don’t think that if scientists found climate change wasn’t real, they wouldn’t report on it? They would. I hope you look into it. This mindset is why we have antivaxers (the autism paper had falsified data, and was produced by a conman paid to diacredit the mmr vaccine so a company could sue them. He also released his own vaccine after releasing the paper on gut disease causing autism, caused by vaccines. Watch the hbomberguy video on antivaxers if you are one, the founder of the movement was a truly evil man who even paid children at a birthday party to draw their blood (he boasted about this and it was caught on camera)). But that aside, I hope you and others like you can look into it, it’s just the future of the world at stake.
@zarodgaming1844
@zarodgaming1844 6 месяцев назад
yours is probably the smartest comment. i see everyone, even "important" people just repeating what bil says and calling tucker names, when every respectable scientist would not call you evilz instead just go through the data WITH YOU! instead of saying "it's settled" when every sientific paper in the world starts and ends with "it isn't. we can't reasonably predict how the climate will evolve"
@zalaxii4032
@zalaxii4032 4 года назад
You can slowly see bill regret coming onto the show
@dakodabaldur3037
@dakodabaldur3037 4 года назад
Yeah I would too with how misinformed these people are on Fox News and those who watch it.
@dakodabaldur3037
@dakodabaldur3037 4 года назад
@You Know? It's facts
@saltynutsman1
@saltynutsman1 4 года назад
Zalaxii ...oh, I thought Bill was going to talk about multiple genders, guess he can tell me about climate change instead.
@dakodabaldur3037
@dakodabaldur3037 4 года назад
@@saltynutsman1 that's actually a misquote
@saltynutsman1
@saltynutsman1 4 года назад
Dakoda Baldur ..what’s a misquote?
@gunandbomb4637
@gunandbomb4637 7 лет назад
The sad thing is that the average person watching Fox News thinks Tucker won the debate.
@barbarakozlowski2642
@barbarakozlowski2642 7 лет назад
GunAndBomb thats the really sad part.
@TimeToJoe
@TimeToJoe 7 лет назад
walliser15 ha!
@gunandbomb4637
@gunandbomb4637 7 лет назад
walliser15 nope
@markd5625
@markd5625 7 лет назад
Think God we have you delusional libtards to keep straight. SMFH, MORON!
@justinnink2396
@justinnink2396 7 лет назад
Please go on, I'm curious about your drive by insult.
@annafromtheblock2224
@annafromtheblock2224 8 месяцев назад
How much are people responsible for climate change? Why doesn't he answer that question?
@Soundslikekong
@Soundslikekong 8 месяцев назад
He said 100%. He said we should have a climate similar to 1750… he answered it in numerous ways… “hurrrr, why won’t he answer?!”
@annafromtheblock2224
@annafromtheblock2224 8 месяцев назад
@@Soundslikekong 100% ok. 30 years ago they told us we'd freeze and they put celebrities to advocate for it. Do you realize these claims are insane? Especially since they don't go after the countries who cause the most "global warming" why?
@Ben00000
@Ben00000 8 месяцев назад
@@annafromtheblock2224 They didn't, though. Global freezing was a fringe theory even in the 1970s and was overwhelmingly rejected in favor of the same sort of climate change we warn about to this day. Anybody (yourself included) that throws that out there to discredit scientists is falling for the same propaganda they accuse others of falling for. And, we do go after countries that cause the most global warming. The idea that it's up to the consumer to reduce their usage while megacorps pollute en masse is propaganda BY those megacorps. The purpose is twofold: it shifts the burden from the culprits, and it makes pro-environmental efforts look like a joke by association. And it works! Here you are. Two examples of you taking BP Oil talking points hook, line, and sinker while complaining others are too gullible...
@ohyea456
@ohyea456 9 месяцев назад
For all those who deny Bill Nye is a scientist... sci·en·tist noun a person who is studying or has expert knowledge of one or more of the natural or physical sciences. Bill Nye has a degree in engineering. en·gi·neer·ing noun the branch of science and technology concerned with the design, building, and use of engines, machines, and structures. He studies and has expert knowledge of one or more sciences. He is a scientist. Spelled out like a 1st grade teacher for you. Stop trying to discredit someone's character instead of their arguments.
@epicgamermoment5068
@epicgamermoment5068 3 года назад
tucker is the least open-minded person I have ever seen
@liamgross7217
@liamgross7217 3 года назад
He is one of Rupert’s puppets
@boxxboyy3879
@boxxboyy3879 3 года назад
You haven’t met my dad.
@sneke4429
@sneke4429 3 года назад
tucker talking about open mindedness while shouting down bill nye and telling him he doesn't know what he's talking about.
@LibertyFascism
@LibertyFascism 3 года назад
It's not closed-minded to be skeptical.
@sneke4429
@sneke4429 3 года назад
@@LibertyFascism has he ever considered.... Looking at the statistics and data? Or doing his own research? Instead of doing nothing and being skeptical towards a scientist?
@nickpaganini
@nickpaganini 3 года назад
unsure whether to like or dislike this video of Carlson getting absolutely eviscerated by Nye
@brunobucciotti7198
@brunobucciotti7198 3 года назад
I was unsure as well, so I will like your comment instead
@ronaldfarber589
@ronaldfarber589 3 года назад
Dislike because it's posted by fox
@Pyranders
@Pyranders 3 года назад
@@ronaldfarber589 Like, because more people need to see it.
@connormartin5053
@connormartin5053 3 года назад
carlson was asking such weird questions
@yaelfeldman6965
@yaelfeldman6965 3 года назад
@@connormartin5053 Yeah. What % down to the 3rd decimal digit did humans affect climate change. Let's skip for a sec the fact that it is not a % affect, I mean what does it even mean to affect 50% on climate change if you have no baseline..., Just the fact that humans deffinatly changed the climate, and by a factor of 1000s of years should matter...
@drabberfrog
@drabberfrog Год назад
The intelligence gap between these two men is astonishing.
@consciouspresence5880
@consciouspresence5880 Год назад
yeah one is part of the criminal democrat party
@drabberfrog
@drabberfrog Год назад
@@consciouspresence5880 the guy that actually knows what he is talking about? The mechanical engineer, the scientifically literate person?
@consciouspresence5880
@consciouspresence5880 Год назад
@@drabberfrog If you didn’t see the first 10 seconds, he wants to imprison anyone who doesn’t agree with his “theory” and saying engineer though is an appeal to authority
@drabberfrog
@drabberfrog Год назад
@@consciouspresence5880 you're right, him being a mechanical engineer is an appeal to authority, and Bill has made some pretty extreme comments about people who don't think human caused climate change is real. But I do think there is a reason Bill is smarter than Tucker, it's because Bill can do a very simple, but at the same time difficult thing which Tucker cannot. Bill can recognize scientific consensus and change his views accordingly. Over 99% of climate scientists agree that humans burning fossil fuels is causing climate change. And I will appeal to their authority because they have spent their entire careers studying the earth's climate. They know what they are talking about and if you think you understand the climate better than them as a non expert then I'd read a paper written by David Dunning and Justin Kruger. And at the end of the day, these are just two men talking about climate change on TV. Bill honestly didn't do that well in the debate because I have seen him debate against intellectuals and Bill definitely stands his own against them but against the science denying village idiot? He kept falling for the logical fallacies Tucker kept throwing at him because Bill wasn't prepared for someone use dumb, illogical arguments against him because intellectuals don't do that because they know they are stupid, and as Mark Twain said "Never argue with an idiot. They will drag you down to their level and beat you with experience". And that is exactly what Tucker did when he kept asking what percentage of climate change is caused by humans because"the climate is always changing ". There's no number for something like that but Tucker knew that if he asked him a very specific question like that Bill would not know it and I'm not sure anyone actually knows it other than just saying 100%.
@consciouspresence5880
@consciouspresence5880 Год назад
@@drabberfrog yes on this subject it was a verbose game of trivial semantics and no actual points were made in the debate or discussion
@midnightmcguire9897
@midnightmcguire9897 10 месяцев назад
“There would of been an ice age without human activity” “Oh when” “That’s irrelevant” 😂
@Dudemon-1
@Dudemon-1 10 месяцев назад
He doesn't even know the timescale of the last glacial retreat. Nye is a hack.
@tiramisu7544
@tiramisu7544 9 месяцев назад
tucker is no better either. Climate change and global warming are both observable phenomena and he thinks like an 8 year old here.
@midnightmcguire9897
@midnightmcguire9897 9 месяцев назад
@@tiramisu7544 but there’s no proof that anything we do can change it
@tiramisu7544
@tiramisu7544 9 месяцев назад
@@midnightmcguire9897 we can slow it down or at least start to build seawalls around us like the dutch are doing…
@havu2236
@havu2236 9 месяцев назад
@@tiramisu7544 Yeah but Nye saying there would have been one is all BS because he doesn't know. He made it up.
@fomofud9479
@fomofud9479 3 года назад
Tucker always falls apart against educated confident people. His bully tactics just expose his extreme stupidity
@chasepotter2376
@chasepotter2376 3 года назад
Nye literally didn’t answer Tuckers actual question and the things he did say weren’t even scientifically accurate.
@fomofud9479
@fomofud9479 3 года назад
@@chasepotter2376 oh come on, Tucker didn't even attempt to give him a chance to reply. Did you just say, none of his answers were scientifically accurate? On what authority can you confirm that?
@chasepotter2376
@chasepotter2376 3 года назад
@@fomofud9479 fight me
@fomofud9479
@fomofud9479 3 года назад
@@chasepotter2376 you're clearly too stupid to debate and you know what they say ....... you can't fix stupid
@Lionclawbeast
@Lionclawbeast 3 года назад
@@fomofud9479 yeah man, chase had about as much response to your argument as tucker did!
@bend5963
@bend5963 3 года назад
Carlson: “you shout people down when they disagree” Also Carlson: *Shouts and interrupts the whole time.*
@GlennWidick
@GlennWidick 3 года назад
Okay but Bill Nye didn’t answer the question
@Notadragon621
@Notadragon621 3 года назад
Glenn Widick 2003 he never let him finish lmao
@ajgillies
@ajgillies 3 года назад
@@GlennWidick yeah... pipe down.
@venomman
@venomman 3 года назад
@@GlennWidick yeah he did, you're just too stupid to understand or you're not listening.
@GlennWidick
@GlennWidick 3 года назад
@@venomman ohhhh really I’m to stupid to understand okay tell me why global warming has been disproven 3 times in 30 years. Tell me why the Earth is actually cooling down. Don’t you ever call me stupid I’ll put you in your place in a blink of an eye
@Rydonittelo
@Rydonittelo 10 месяцев назад
During the the Roman era in the British isle 2000 years ago, the climate in Britain was similar to what northern Italy is today and it was perfect for growing grapes.
@bonebones8999
@bonebones8999 Год назад
Partisanship before common sense. Ideology before logic. Woke adherence before following facts
@rosietoms8068
@rosietoms8068 3 года назад
This is embarrassing and painful to watch.
@bdw592
@bdw592 3 года назад
Extremely
@3matcha
@3matcha 3 года назад
@star cruiser oh did you do research on reliable and informational websites and study that topic for years or did you search up "Why is global warming real" and called it a day after the first website. Seems like the 2nd one to me.
@woill8477
@woill8477 3 года назад
star cruiser what evidence, do you mean about climate change? and if you do ask any scientist who studies it and they will give you more than enough evidence. you can also look it up, idk how that’s so hard for you to do
@balanceharry8068
@balanceharry8068 3 года назад
@star cruiser Do you know what greenhouse gases are or the ozone layer or did you not pass eighth-grade science? It must be infuriating to people who study topics for years and get people who claim they are wrong. Especially with doctors and scientists with COVID.
@peterjones4180
@peterjones4180 3 года назад
Yes indeed Bill Nye clearly does not know much climate history either that or he is blatantly trying to deceive.
@nickkaley5779
@nickkaley5779 3 года назад
Carlson "answer this question", Bill answers question, Carlson "you didn't answer my question"
@Poopopotamusgaming
@Poopopotamusgaming 3 года назад
No. Tucker is saying you can’t know definitively what the weather would be like if humans werent affecting the climate. While you can predict and reasonably assume what the climate would be like without human interference, you cant be definitively sure.
@crimson2209
@crimson2209 3 года назад
@@Poopopotamusgaming we actually can, because if we couldn’t we also wouldn’t have been able to figure out that ice ages happened in the extreme past
@Poopopotamusgaming
@Poopopotamusgaming 3 года назад
@@crimson2209 Yeah because thats something that actually happened. We cant know what would have happened if it hasnt happened.
@crimson2209
@crimson2209 3 года назад
@@Poopopotamusgaming no we didn’t actually have records of it happening, so we had to use fossil records to notice dips in populations and judging off of the patterns, it’s actually really easy to predict when it would’ve happened if there were no human intervention
@ejshsvevwnhehehsb2669
@ejshsvevwnhehehsb2669 3 года назад
Yes you can, that’s like saying if I throw a apple off a roof you can’t be 100% sure it will break, it will almost every time but there’s always a tiny tiny little chance it won’t,
@porkteriyaki8621
@porkteriyaki8621 Год назад
Bill: talking about grapes Tucker: YOURE BRINGING UP POLITICS
@TheYoungFactor
@TheYoungFactor Год назад
Yikes! I wonder if Tucker ever rewatched his interviews and thinks maybe he should let his guests speak more.
@bigverybadtom
@bigverybadtom Год назад
Bill Nye never gave straight answers. That was the deal.
@uselesspotato9056
@uselesspotato9056 4 года назад
Tucker Carlson looks like his mom just told him he can’t eat candy
@callmekermit1339
@callmekermit1339 3 года назад
Processing.............................................................................
@gravity_mxk5663
@gravity_mxk5663 2 года назад
“Ok, it only took you 6 seconds to interrupt me” Oh my God I’m dying
@qscott777
@qscott777 2 года назад
Absolutely the best moment of the video. Carlson's eyebrows raise and he grins briefly at having been slammed for his disrespect. Carlson's foundation was to gaslight and be the "reasonable" one. So when he foundered, he knew it.
@auspiciou.s8339
@auspiciou.s8339 2 года назад
@@privatename2426 improv actor amongst dozens of other things, tucker carlson is an elitist who acts like he’s working and asking questions for the people lmfao
@qscott777
@qscott777 2 года назад
@@privatename2426 lol says the Trump supporter.
@AirashiiTiayou
@AirashiiTiayou 2 года назад
@@privatename2426 Do *you* realize that he has a degree in mechanical engineering and studied at Cornell University and the Sibley School of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering? Not to mention his continual involvement in so many science related educational and advocacy things that I literally couldn't list them all in this comment, how is that not enough credibility for you? Plus, it's not like all of the stuff that he is saying is only his opinion and is only based on his research; he is getting his information from, I have honestly no idea how many, but a large number of sources of research that you are more than welcome to look up for yourself as well to confirm what he is saying, but considering how little bearing you put on his education I doubt that you think they are any more credible.
@AirashiiTiayou
@AirashiiTiayou 2 года назад
@Donald Ring ​ Seriously? It's a saying that a large majority of people use, except for some who are religious. They aren't saying that they know God, it's just a phrase.
@tmb3131
@tmb3131 8 месяцев назад
Jim Jones looked less annoyed when he was questioned about his cult.
@jorgenpersson662
@jorgenpersson662 10 месяцев назад
How was the climate during the medieval warm period or the Holocene climatic optimum and how many industries and cars was around during these periods?
Далее
Most HEATED Moments From Bill Nye Debate with Ken Ham
22:03
100 Детских Страхов за 24 Часа!
24:14
Bill Nye: Creationism is Bad for Us
24:01
Просмотров 252 тыс.
Bill Nye vs. Ken Ham - The Short Version
3:43
Просмотров 1,4 млн
Global warming:  why you should not worry
5:20
Просмотров 836 тыс.
Tucker: This is spectacularly absurd!
13:56
Просмотров 2,2 млн
Professor calls to tax the rich at 80 percent
6:21
Просмотров 2,2 млн
The Last Time the Globe Warmed
10:54
Просмотров 9 млн