Tudor Pelagos Vs Omega Seamaster 

Somebody called the Pelagos a “poker chip” and that kinda ruined it for me. 😂

I’m a simple man. I like watches, I like coffee and if I see a Bark and Jack video I click play.

I’d like to correct you on just one point if I may. I think we do need watches that slide under the cuff - if they don’t how else can they perform the dual function of a) being able to wear a beautiful new watch and b) hiding it from the wife 🤔

Anyone else suffering from lockdown hair!?

The Omega is a real looker. The dial sometimes is shiny, sometimes not. The ceramic details on the bezel really pop, even better than the sub and are flush which is a real bonus. Just an all around more fun watch to look at in different lighting conditions. Let’s face it, we all love to look at our watches and on the front and back, the Omega is just better looking.

As consumers, we should be thankful to have excellent watches like these that are available.

What’s a cuff? Oh man, it’s been a while 😅 Great video!

I feel like I say this every video Adrian but seriously dude your production quality and B roll are top notch

Great constructive review Adrian. I've tried both watches at an AD (the pelagos was an LHD in black) and I really like the Pelagos in blue from photographs but prefer the LHD version in black and for what it is, a tool watch it does all that I'd want. No pizzazz it just does the job incredibly well. The bracelet is incredibly functional and easy to use for us mere mortals as well. The lume of the hands and ceramic bezel it incredible . The in house movement with 70 hours reserve and COSC certification at the price is a real plus also. This watch does what it needs to do for a purpose and it does it really well. The Omega is something different though, that white dial with the waves is something that you really need to see in the flesh, it's simply a work of art in different lighting conditions, the black skeleton hands, the black ceramic bezel with white inlay is just gorgeous in my humble opinion. The bracelet with the on the fly push to fit is great as well. The Omega is the more versatile watch given the case and lug shape along with that dial with the date at 6. The tooth paste cap at 10 is easily forgotten on the wrist. It;'s a heritage thing at the end of the day. In summary, if you need a watch to do the job the Pelagos would take my hard earned cash. But if you want something more versatile and have the extra money the Omega would be the one to shrink my bank account. Given a choice I'd want both.

I’ve owned a Pelagos and currently have the black dialed Seamaster. I love both, but the Omega is technically on another level with the coax. I agree that Tudor has the better bracelet, but the Omega is still quite good in that regard. I think the Omega is significantly more wearable and flexible. Also, I think you may have missed a trick by not showing either on their respective rubber straps. The Omega is KILLER on its OEM rubber

There’s such a tool appeal to the Pelagos. Simple and to the point. Could do without the five lines of text though.

Pelagos all day every day. Omega needs to ditch those silly design cues like the ugly HEV and hands

I would go for Pelagos, specially the LHD, the escape knob of Seamaster is just useless and odd looking, also prefer the oyster case and bracelet of Tudor, so hot looking!

I'd struggle not to pick the Seamaster here even though the Tudor is great. In my opinion, the Seamaster with a black dial can from beach to tux. With the white dial, it's definitely staying the more casual/sporty realm.

In the beginning of my hunt for a top level watch I was all about the Omega Seamaster but when I first saw the Tudor Pelagos I couldn’t stop thinking of it… Why did I change my mind… frankly, I feel the Pelagos is more of a tool watch than the Seamaster… Plus all Titanium doesn’t hurt either… Soon the Pelagos will be on my wrist and most probably all my other watches will just collect dust…

I have Pelagos from 30.12.2020. I was heading for North Flag, but I tried Pelagos and Black Bay P01. I was surprised at how light Pelagos was, despite his size. I haven't had a titanium watch before. Pelagos is not my type of watch, but something happened. I liked it and with each passing day I like it more and more. This is not a watch like love at first sight. However, it is its simplicity, which you can not get enough of, that makes you like it more and more. It is obvious that it is made according to all the rules of perceptions - reduce to the maximum. What is most impressive, however, is the accuracy of the movement - in the first month it worked with an accuracy of -1.4 seconds. per day. Now he is 5.5 seconds behind for 16 days, regardless of the position in which he lies. Unbelievable.

I'd go with a white Seamaster with a black rubber strap. Love that look.

I enjoyed the comparison. I bought the Pelegos LHD, because I’m a lefty-at least that’s how I rationalized it. It’s “look” is entirely different than the blue one, and just instantly resonated with me. It’s my “daily driver” for 1.5 years now, and it still brings me enormous pleasure.

I traded my two tone Seamaster years ago and kick myself every day.

Omega, SMP 300M Diver, no contest here! As far as I’m concerned, the Seamaster even gives the Rolex Submariner a ‘Serious’ run for the money! Few watches wear as well in the wrist for all the tech and packaging!

I'd go for the Pelagos! Throw a Planet Ocean in the mix and I'd be singing a different tune.

Agreed COMPLETELY! Something so dang charming about the Pelagos. Would love to add one to my collection one day. I freaking love some of the Tudor offerings right now.

I own the blue Pelagos -- There is something about the stark simplicity and contrast of the dial and bezel. It also feels rugged and reliable. It's my go-to tool watch. It also keeps miraculously impeccable time. That said, I do admit to checking out the white seamaster videos. I love everything about it - except that helium escape valve at the 10 o'clock position. It's the one visual feature that I can't get past. Also - like you, I'm not a fan of the non-tapering braclet. Cheers - Dennis

Looks like “Flock of Seagulls” hair do.

I have the black dial Pelagos and no joke, that blue is reeeeeaaaaally starting to tug at my heart strings! I feel like having both can be in my future.

I love Omega, I love Rolex but can't stand Tudor there are so many small things I just can't handle!

I have the Omega Speedy ( 1861 ) for suits and the LHD Pelagos for Leisure.

Hi Adrian, you mention the higher jewel count in the Omega translates into a movement with less metal rubbing on metal compared to the Tudor movement. In the long run (150 years), will this mean that the Omega will have required less servicing and potentially still be in working order? Thanks.

I recommend owning both.

UH? You Totally missed one of the most Important Points. I Just purchased the Omega, my AD Gave me a 15% Discount. 15% Off of $5200 IS A NICE CHUNK OF CHANGE!

I would say that, even if the Tudor cost as much as the Omega, there's a cigarette paper between both watches in terms of quality. It's really down to personal preference. In terms of the movements, the METAS certification was announced about 6 years ago, and, to my mind, is as much a marketing exercise (as much as anything) initiated by the Swatch group for Omega watches.This is why only Omega watches are METAS certified - because this is (essentially) an Omega certification done "independently" through METAS. Hence, why would any other brands want/be able to do the same. Brands like Omega, Rolex and Tudor usually test their watches above and beyond COSC level anyway.

How about both?

Love my 300m. I’ve got the blue and I’ll never get rid of it. Brilliant construction and movement and I really appreciate Omega as a brand. The Tudor is great but I’ve got to pick the Omega for this one

After reviewing the Seamaster it has become a favourite of mine. The quality that is built into that watch truly is something else. Especially when you tend to concentrate of more affordable watches.

Adrian, if you put out another white dial Seamaster video I gotta buy one!

The Tudor is simple and functional, while the Omega is more styled in looks.

Both are great watches indeed. I do prefer Seamater esthetics though. I’d love to see a comparison between Seamaster and BB58.

Pelagos all day long for me. The flush HE valve, tapered bracelet and non-skelton hand set are the main reasons. Would take a 38.5 Aquaterra over either of these (although not really a diver). Just my 2c worth :-)

1. Advantage Pelagos for weight on the wrist (titanium vs. steel). 2. Advantage Pelagos for better integration of the HEV. 3. Advantage Pelagos for better legibility (snowflake vs. skeleton, tho both polarizing). 4. The Pelagos is actually 41mm at the case. You stated such in your review. The 2-liner is also thinner if you can find one. Advantage Pelagos. 5. Not sure why you gave the plus to Omega's 25,200 BPH over Tudor's 28,800 BPH. A higher beat rate AND 15 more hours PR is damn impressive. 6. I think 22mm straps are as ubiquitous as 20mm. 18mm, 19mm, 21mm and 24mm are where you see a tapering off. Ultimately, I own one of each... although my SMP is the 2230.50 so I get the benefit of sword hands AND applied indices, in a thinner case without sacrificing a COSC movement. Also added the micro-adjustable clasp to the tapering Speedy bracelet, so no loss of usability there.

I’d love to see/hear your take on the Seiko SPB143. Specifically, can it be a true one-watch collection?

Great video review with a non bias approach. I am an Omega man but really drawn to Tudor since in-house movements. I could sway either way with those two models, the Pelagos definitely has a more Tool watch ego compared to the more stylish in white Seamaster. If I had to choose between those two models, probably the Pelagos…..but then again maybe not 😂😂🤷🏻‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️

I wish we could go back to the days when we could realistically say: “I’d rather just save up a few more bucks and get a Sub”; because that would be my choice in this scenario.

I think you definitely sell the submariner short in your categorizing . I always dive with a watch . It's how I was trained in the military years ago. I own both a Seadweller as a couple of submariners. I've dove far more times with a sub than any other watch that I own with exception, maybe , of my Barracuda. The pelagos is an awesome dive watch , designed with pure function in mind , much the same as the submariner. From a divers prospective, the omega suffers from design flaws that make it less diver friendly. It's a beautiful watch and I happen to own 2 omegas , but when it comes to actually diving , they're not in my top 10 that I would pick . Pelagos

I've learnt to cut my own hair ("thanks Covid"), and if I made it, you can do it too, man!

Recently had this debate myself when I was looking for a new watch. Went with the Pelagos, why? Because of the LHD version.

I have to admit my friend, I disagree with what you said about the availability of 20mm straps vs. 22mm straps. Most companies I’ve had interest in, had 20mm & 22mm in abundance above any other sizes.

I don't understand the Seamaster bracelet and helium escape valve. There's too much stuff going on with the design. It's too busy. And really busy designs are usually reserved for watches that are cheap, but try to look expensive. That being said the dial is beautiful on the Seamaster. In contrast the Pelagos is a bit too stark, too surgical and cold.

No way: Nothing can defeat your Omega Seamaster… 😎 or maybe The Seamaster 300… 😏

the hell with tudor its a rolex stepchild. fuck the lockdown!!! SEAMASTER FOR THE WIN!!!!

Seamaster all day long. Though I do love how Tudor integrated a spring into the Pelagos clasp for the perfect fit.

Pelagos without a doubt. the omega looks outdated. I got my dad the LHD and it's a stunning watch. thinking about getting one myself

Seamaster ✌️🇮🇹

Probably going to buy the white Seamaster on the black rubber stap. Both watches are great. Dislike very much the "too much" text on the Pelagos dial.

I really wish you left your hair all crazy for the duration of the video 😂

Problem with Tudor is that unlike Rolex and Omega, they do not service vintage watches. Rolex and Omega service all their watches, irrespective of age at their HQ in Switzerland. I have a 1952 Tudor Oyster that I wanted serviced, but Tudor do not have the facility to do so. Hence, for me Tudor is out as it is not a heritage watch but like any other ordinary watch that one buys, wears and discards.

I like the Omega better, but if I’m being honest, its the white dial that does it for me!!

The only Tudor i would like is the black bay gmt with the Pepsi dial. Just because for me its better looking than the equivalent Rolex with the Cyclops. I still don't know if i want a watch with a swiss lever escapement though. Coaxial all the way

Pelagos for me. Because of the blue color and because of its cleaner design. Its just so contemporary, not trying to be vintage. The clasp is cool, but i never micro adjust.

You didn't mention Omega's magnetic resistance which beats not only Tudor but also Rolex. I got my Omega with "standard" 20% AD discount so cheaper than Tudor's rrp. Better watch for less, Omega all way to go.

I got the Pelagos LHD, supremely happy my choice.

After this day i can proudly comment, why not both? I have the excact same Omega, i just bought the pelagos but in black. I love your videos Adrian, they help me a lot.

I’ve owned both piece’s, blue pelagos and black sea master. The Pelagos was much more enjoyable to me. I think it came down to the bracelet and wearability. The initial honeymoon with omega was fun with the presentation and certifications/website, but at the end of the day I just never bonded with it. First, the bracelet drove me BONKERS. I didn’t like the aesthetic of it, particularly the railroad appearance and no taper. Granted I had owned the pelagos and several rolex and Tudor watches prior so I think my expectations were high. Second, the skeleton hands. Not for me. Surprisingly, I actually otherwise enjoyed the more jewelry appearance of the shiny ceramic face and bezel which I know is polarizing. The pelagos was a joy of a tool/dive watch, and actually the most accurate of all watches I have owned to this day. My only real knock is the titanium is just soft and prone to bumps and bruises. It was also a bit hard to dress up, particularly in the blue variant. Otherwise great value IMO, with a suppper bracelet. Now that I’ve picked up a bunch of straps and gone away from being almost exclusively a bracelet guy maybe I’ll revisit the omega. I do like what omega is doing with the bracelet on the speedy, as that was another watch where I didn’t love the bracelet.

I have the black Seamaster 300 and after three years, I still can help, but just look at it. I love my black sub, but it doesn't have the same wearability,. My Seamaster is everything I look for in a watch from beach to office it still says style.

Tudors just somehow look better to me, cool, sophisticated and don't have to try as hard as the Omega.

The raised markers on the dial seal the deal for me. Love the Seamaster!

Pelagos as I dive it’s superior to the omega. I also prefer a 70hr reserve compared to omegas 50. My pelagos is currently losing only 1 sec a day and competes with my Rolex.

The Pelagos in terms of case design and materials is exceptional. However, few brands are showing the technical prowess of Omega’s movements at the price point. You can’t go wrong with either.

I think Omega is better if money wasn't an option. Omega are trying to compete with Rolex, Tudor is a little more lower end.

Great review, thank you. I'd go Seamaster. If the Tudor were steel and maybe finished the movement like Breitling does, it might be a different story.

I’m sorry... But I have yet to sea a Tudor that doesn’t look cheap and just plain ugly. I fail to see the point of buying a new watch that looks 15-20 years old...

For the price difference I’d rather have the better time reserve over the extra accuracy......let’s face it for the average person the Pelagos is going to be more than accurate.....plus it doesn’t have that atrocious escape valve.

I am probably alone in hating the Seamaster bezel. I have the Pelagos,

this omega is just awesome... simply mind blowing dial, love it!!

Both are beast of watches! You can’t go wrong with either one!! I choose the Omega in blue dial on bracelet!!! Believe me, one day I will have the Pelagos in Black (Charcoal gray the new antricite)!!! Great video and straps also!!!

I’ve chosen Pelagos LHD over SMP simply because you can se SMP everywhere, it has become so popular that it draws me back from this watch although I love it still. Another thing in Pelagos’s favor is It’s lack of shine that is more my style than Omegas glossiness.

I don’t understand the appeal of the Pelagos. The 70 hours of reserve is great but looks wise it’s muted and unoriginal. I’d much rather have a Ball diver.

I choose the white Seamaster as well and absolutely love it. Great video!

The helium valve hate is something that was created on social media and outlets. Reality is the average person on the street doesnt care for this nor if you are wearing a 55mm Invicta that you bought at Walmart. I have the Omega polar and love it and it's my daily wear (and yes, I do wear it with a suit when the need arises). Tudor are great watches but I prefer a dress diver over a tool diver anyway. To each his own, I guess.

Great vid. Love these two watches. I wonder how the Pelagos would do going through METAS testing. Very well I think. I suspect the reason not to put it through is COSC is already a high standard, and the expense it would add to the watch, as it does with the Omega. My Peli is my fav watch 😁👍🏻

I like both but pelagos wins for me, the Tudor bracelet is the best in the business no questions. The tudor helium escape valve best in the business. If you compare just these elements it like comparing the engineering of a Ford Anglian vs a Tesla. Yes Omega movement is better but to me personally i don't care about movements until they need a service. Omega also looks better on a strap but it needs to as the bracelet is so ugly

The white dial of the Seamaster is what makes the difference aesthetically (even among the Seamaster line). it's just stunning. Also, the finish of the dial. The printing on the Pelagos is a bit 'fluffy' - admittedly not very obvious with the naked eye and from more than a foot away, however there is a reason the Omega is pricier.

The Seamaster is far too ugly with it's ridiculous HEV, case geometry and a comic handset.

Had my heart set on a seamaster, tried on quite a few then tried a Pelagos. Both are really great watches but I bought the black Pelagos. For me the seamaster was just a little -dare I say -tarty.

Pelagos all day! Having numerous Rolex ss tool watches, the blue pelagos is a terrific addition and timeless. My Sinn ezm 9 rounds out my collection and after owning an omega seamaster I wouldn’t go back.

Oméga seamaster for me. I love it and I bought it

I’ve got an Invicta 1953 that compares pretty favourably with the Tudor. NH35 movement. Cost just over €100.

Honestly I think everything about the Pelegos is hideous! And Everything about the SMP 300 is amazing! black or white dial. There is no comparison for me.

I'd go with the Omega......nicer design, nicer bracelet, great movement.

Yeah I was off for 3 weeks over Christmas, I'm really regretting not taking an hour of that time to get my hair cut. I think if the pelagos was more of a petrol blue or sea blue (little hint of green in it) I think it would look brilliant. Dislike the seamaster.

Old school, bro! Get a Seiko spring drive it's +/-1. Seiko is the best!

I would go for the Seamaster. It is more "emotional" to me and has a more stylsih look. The Pelagos is simply to cold and hast nothing special to me.

I love my Pelagos Blue, i haven’t worn my Seamaster since i bought the Tudor and that was a year ago, a truly stunning watch, better than my Rolex Sub that i had to sell in 2013 for my house purchase.

Pelagos wins in my mind. Can’t overlook HE valve and bracelet of Seamaster.

sorry i don't understand why the rate 25,200 bph is better than the 28,800 bph??

Both great watches but I went with the Seamaster, blue dial and love it to bits...Enjoyable video, thank you.👍🍻

Seamaster just has another luxury watch feel, the box and the experience is much better

That helium escape valve on the seamaster is an eye-sore

I’m a pelagos man myself 7 years now almost I think. I’ve never “gotten” the sea master. Ugly bezel font. Bracelet looks like a 200$ beater from costco, hands aren’t particularly legible. It just doesn’t really hang together. I like a few other omegas but seamaster is no go for me.

It's like you read our minds then incorporate it into a video. Amazing video sir thanks for your time!

yeah unless I wear my watch on my bicep it's nowhere near a cuff - lol. With that said, if I had to pick one, I would go with the seamaster. I just wish they made one with regular sword hands.