Tyrannosaurus rex vs Giganotosaurus | Who Is The True King? 

As the strongest megatheropod Tyrannosaurus fought the fraud the King of the South, he began to open his domain. Giganotosaurus shrunk back in fear, then T-Rex said: "Stand proud Giga, you are strong"

This really is a very interesting battle! What would a meeting between Carcharadontosaurus vs Giganotosaurus be like or if Mapussaurus lived with Giganotosaurus and got into duels?

Most accurate Tyrannosaurus vs Giganotosaurus video & the correct verdict.

This is so close that regardless of the victor, both animals would ultimately lose. I do feel you are overplaying the rex's bite and underplaying the giga's. One thing that commonly isn't mentioned about the rexes bite is that it likely took time for the bite to reach bone shattering power, akin to a hydraulic press. So if the rex doesn't land a proper bite on the neck or a leg from behind, the giga would be able to land multiple bites of its own before the rex could apply enough pressure and all it needs is one to pierce an artery for it to lethal. It would at worst, force the rex off before any serious damage is done to either animal. However, I do agree that the rex likely wins more due to the other reasons you mention. But with how close they are in size and how deadly they are, anything less than a near perfect bite could lead to both animals dying regardless of who wins.

Still know so little about the Giga and it sucks, while the Rex has been studied to death soo much so we know at this point a lot and enough. Yet other Apex theropods outside of North America, like South America, Africa, Asia, and Europe we still hardly know as well. This video does well to inform we still hardly know as much about the Giga as we do with the likes of Rex, yet this fight is probably the closest and finally, someone without Rex Bias doesn't just say oh Rex bite force is best therefore it wins. This video does justice to the topic of Giga vs Rex. So props The Overseer keep this up, comrade!

Easily one of, if not, the best take I've seen on the subject. Versus battles are always a weird animal (pun intended). I agree that using average sizes and stats for both is the best objective way to look at things. Great video my friend, looking forward to the next.

I’ve always thought that the trex had a power bite and good endurance because of some goji centre videos and thought the giga was more of a slicer

The tyrannosaurus artwork in 6:38 looks like the stare meme makes it unnerving to look at

Dinosaur matchups are always inaccurate because while we have a good idea of what t rex is we dont have a good idea of what giga, carcharo and spino are apart from large carnosaurs. A few remains are relatively useless for a median size as the individuals found could have been freakishly large or sub adults. Like the variance between carcharos was it couldve been either a 10 ton ot 3 ton predator. Same with spino where people constantly use old measurements for it although the creature was probably heavier and stockier based on evidence of pachystosis of its bones recently. Its basically people trying to matchup a well historied and documented wrestler versus a guy we aren't even sure what they look like 😂

Slight nitpick: The Giga you show on the thumbnail isn't actually Giganotasaurus. The special where that image if from, and the animal that's shown, is more closely synonymous with the closely related Mapusaurus instead. Just wanted to point that out.😅

The big issues I see with people discussing this matchup are a) people comparing a (relatively) accurate Rex to a very inaccurate image of Giganotosaurus, resulting in the latter being badly nerfed due to basically everything in its arsenal being either flat-out ignored or badly underestimated (as with the idea it’s bad at killing quickly based on inaccurate information about how predators that bleed out their prey actually operate); and b) even very recent paleontological research being out of date when it comes to things like eyesight (the idea of Tyrannosaurs having far better eyesight than other theropods is based entirely on its greater field of binocular vision: not only is that not the only relevant metric in animal eyesight, it’s been shown to be basically irrelevant in living theropods as per Martin 2009 and other studies done on living birds) or intelligence (the idea Tyrannosaurus has any significant intelligence advantage here being based on decades-out-of-date notions about how intelligence works in living animals and debunked assumptions about the capabilities of “primitive” croc-like brains). So what ends up happening in most videos like this is that Tyrannosaurus gets *slightly* overrated due to people consulting paleontological research that doesn’t stand up to scrutiny once we look at relevant data from living animals, while Giganotosaurus gets horribly underestimated because the videos basically ignore its adaptations (an extremely common mistake being only looking at bite force to argue Tyrannosaurus had a far more dangerous bite while ignoring that Giganotosaurus relied on vertical head movements to impart additional force during a bite, meaning its bite actually had just as much physical power behind it even with its much weaker jaw muscles, and also having much sharper teeth to boot). And then everyone thinks Rex stomps because it had useful adaptations and Giga (allegedly) doesn’t, and refuses to accept that Giganotosaurus actually has advantages in other areas to make up for its disadvantages in bite force and overall physical strength. This happens to be one of the only videos that actually isn’t incredibly biased, but it does omit a key detail, which is that Giga would have a somewhat better chance of getting a critical blow to a vital area than assumed here. Part of this has to do with, as mentioned above, binocular vision (or lack thereof) not being that relevant in theropods, but two other things that play into this is that a) Giganotosaurus has a more flexible neck and is much more suited to accurately and quickly moving its head around (see Coria & Currie, 2003) which would help it line up for precise bites to vitals; the other thing is that even ziphodont theropods were equipped with stress-dissipating notches in their teeth, which functioned less like a steak knife and more like a set of surgical saws; as such they could (and based on coprolites and bite marks from the Morrison, did) bite through bone, just not by outright obliterating bone like the much more robust jaws of tyrannosaurids were suited for doing. This fight is basically an 50/50-the first good bite is going to decide the outcome, if not kill the loser outright, and it’s hard to argue which, if either, animal would have the better shot at that first bite (Tyrannosaurus has the agility advantage-though issues with that study indicate this would be by a smaller margin than often assumed-while Giganotosaurus has that increased head/neck mobility and is better at biting into broad surfaces, which might give it more places to bite).

I, for one, love how close this fight is. After all, a hero is only as good as his villain. T. rex was my superhero growing up… it’d be pretty boring if it was a bully that no other theropod could challenge.

good video but i think the answer will be more clear and more to discuss when we have studied Giganotosaurus more.

Amazing what a difference even a few months can make. With a huge specimen of t rex recently exceeding 13 metres, and being said to reach over 25km. This news just in from a week ago! So what does this mean? its as capable of a running speed, just as long and tall- and likely heavier than Carolinii. Its agility/locomotion was also downplayed or left out in this upload- for more on that i recommend the Goji center video "t rex vs palaeoloxodon". It shows visual animatics of how the t rex uniquely with its own centre of balance is able to sidestep, turn sharply to reposition with speed to reassess or create a vulnerability in an opponent- something no other large theropod has been proven capable of doing.

Not mention animals would prefer to avoid conflict as much possible. But even if engage for territory , defend there young, or other resources these two big predators would try intimidating behavior like sizing each other through low grunts , below and hissing sounds until one back downs.

Just by reading the comments, it's devolved into "my favorite is better than your favorite.". Honestly, these were living animals that 9/10 times would've never fought in the first place. Since predators know even a small injury could lead to death due to infection or the inability to hunt and then would starve. Unfortunately until more research is done on other megatheropods, we won't know as much as we know about T.Rex. Not to mention, they were designed to hunt completely different prey and had different hunting tatics. I hate these "debates" because dinosaurs are not custom-made cage fighters. Who cares who is stronger? Better yet, ask why that particular dinosaur is your favorite? Hopefully, you'll get a better answer than "cause it's not T.Rex.". Lol, ya'll have a good day.

To be honest that Trex would win even if I like the giga more but Trex has stronger bite which I don’t like but that’s how life between the Giganotosaurus and taranosaurus.

I agree with you. The Giga is a capable and dangerous opponent, and it's fighting style involves running in and escaping danger repeatedly to deliver multiple bites to bleed and wear down its kill.... this would be effective against a Rex due to its higher speed and lighter weight with 3 noteworthy exceptions. 1, Rex has binocular vision and can pinpoint incoming danger and attacks with accurate depth perception, and extremely well developed hearing. 2, Rex has faster reflexes and mobility, allowing rapid and accurate responses or counters to Gigas incoming attacks. 3, the rex is a heavier set, with a bite capable of inflicting fatal damage in a single attack. So basically, the Giga can't sneak up, and its only hope is to repeatedly attack (rexes are known to survive bites from other rexes) something that has faster reflexes while escaping a devastating likely fatal counter attack. Sure the Giga could get lucky and hit an artery while escaping the first few times and win, is this likely given the specific strengths of the Rex? No, not really. and Given the Giga's lighter skeletal frame, a bite to the neck or body is likely to crunch straight through and prove catastrophic, While the Rex will more than likely be enraged after a bite or two from the Giga.

There is a reason why the T-Rex was called the Lizard King

Theres also 2 important factors to keep in mind when it comes to giganotosaurus which seem to go unnoticed in almost every hypothetical clash scenario. 1: The Giganotosaurus size average is determined by only a handful of fossils (chances of finding the average sized fully grown adult isnt all that high) its a bit like going to your local cemetary and diggin up 5 random human skeletons vs diggin up north of 100 graves in the next town over (which would be the t-rex source material in comparison) 2: Carcharodontosaurids are believed to have grown pretty much until they died while T-Rex had a growth cycle more similar to Humans reaching its max proportions some time in its early 20s... so the fully grown individuals would also be the most battle hardened. As for the outcome it would pretty much be a cointoss. A broken neck, severed muscles, tendons and blood vessels aswell as crushed windpipes all have the nasty sideeffect of ending up in death

What if rex uses its bone crushing bones to digest, similar to hyenas, while the serated part is use to hunt.

Please do Utahraptor vs Polar Bear or Kodiak Bear

Do you play path of titans? Just asking bc you used the path of titans giga for the thumbnail

❤

T.Rex: *”Stand proud Giganotosaurus, You are strong”*

Guys, T-Rexes are taller than giganotosaurus! when they founded Giga the femur was longer, yes. But the complete femur + tibia length is actually longer on t-rexes plus their pose is more upwards than the gigas

Well if the giganotosaurus is smart and is able to get to the Trex neck…Giving the giganotosaurus an advantage of winning…..but who knows.

I dont think it is even close when you just look at their skeletons, the T-Rex is so much larger and robust

Yo overseer can you do majungasaurus crenatissimus vs arctotherium engustidens or carnotaurus sastrei vs arctotherium engustiden or could you do livyatan melvelai vs otodus megalodon or otodus megalodon vs mosasaurus

If you guys in the comments are gonna make arguments about either dinosaur winning, I’d recommend not having the dinosaur in your username or profile pic because you will not look reputable

Sure, Trex would likely win against spino... unless of course... Spino got him in the water lol. Now Rex vs Giga, i still feel could go either way.

I am a bit confused why people thinks that large predator dinosaurs like T-Rex would have been unable to kill prey much larger then themself? Plenty of modern predators are capable of taking out prey many times their own size and they don't even have the over sized bite weapons of a T-Rex.

Top 10 largest Theropods dinosaurs 2024 1. Tyrannosaurus rex- 11.7 tonnes 2. Giganotosaurus- 10.2 tonnes 3. Mcraeencies- 8.8 tonnes 4. Mapusaurus- 8.4 tonnes 5. Spinosaurus- 8.3 tonnes 6. Saurophaganax- 8.3 tonnes 7. Carcharodontosaurus- 8.2 tonnes 8. Sauroniops- 7.6 tonnes 9. Tyrannotitan- 7.5 tonnes 10. Bahariasaurus- 7.1 tonnes

Good video and far from another rex bias spree I've seen parroted over and over. It's very good to see notation that there is that giant titanosaurs potentially up to Argentinosaurus' size did exist with Giganoto as the "T-REX Mafia" as I call the extreme fans seem to have taken to parroting that Giganotosaurus was only hunting small game. The earlier argentine giant just hasn't been classified. Last I am aware, it likely was the case they coexisted.

Good analysis ultimately the giga had speed and the T-Rex 🦖 had bulk it’s very close but I agree T-Rex 🦖 wins atleast mid-high difficulty

I'd say the T.Rex wins 55-65% of the time. I would not give the Tyrant Lizard King agility, agility is also determined by speed and also since the neck and head movements are quicker on Giga it would show better agility.

But Trex would probably low diff or medium diff

How much force would it take to permanently warp a modern MBT’s barrel? Just curious 👀

bro this mf is just making piece with all t-rex vs giga fans not just these fans even other mega therapod lovers i love you man keep up the vids

I reckon it's completely 50/50

U got 1 THING wrong and thats the height, Trex is currently tought to be taller with giga being 3.7 and rex being 3.8

Always good dinosaur content here, Don't even need Netflix for it

Spinosaurus is looking at this fight, knowing its a fight for second place . Spino number 1, it lived with (basically) a giga , in charchar, and spino is now back to being a land based predator , yet it even outlasted the charchar, showing its land dominance. And in the water it had to compete alongside sarco sized crocs, yet it STILL thrived for 10 million years, TRIPLE that of rex, and TWICE that of charchar. There is also a private specimen of a spino tooth embedded in an ADULT charchar vertebrae, with tooth and claw marks that showed NO SIGNS of healing, meaning the charchar was killed. That tells it all. People might not like it, especially after the 2014 study that has been completely debunked in almost every way now. Spino fights megatheropods for a living.

I would say tyrannosaurus wins mid-high difficulty

Suggestion Lion vs Gorilla, Tiger vs grizzly bear, Lion vs black bear and Polar bear vs Bison

Many of the info you told were wrong.

Tyrannosaurus vs Giganotosaurus is *NOT* close

Yellowstone hyperpredator vs Meg when?

one more thing about speed is explained by Paleontologist David Hone during a lecture that the foot of the T Rex is differently designed than every single theropod closer in weight to T Rex, as the center part of the foot shrinks in the upper end, that type of foot is called the Arctometatarsalian Condition, and only 3 groups of dinosaurs have these feet, and all coelurosaurs, the Troodontids, the Ornithomimids, and the Tyrannosaurs, these feet are perfectly adapted for the animals to be extremely efficient in quick turns, energy saving, maintaining one speed consistently for several hours, the best feet for long distance travels and etc.

T rex by 10% but its close.

In Dino Crisis 2, the Giganotosaurus dwarved the T-rex enough for it to carry the T-rex into its mouth and beat it in a battle.

giga=20+ mph, Rex=17mph

I vote for the REX.

Giga gang

First up I'd like to say great video mate, love ya stuff! Secondly I value everyone's opinion. But I'm a simple man and what I see before me are two monstrous skulls, one a giant rock with bollards for teeth the other a gargantuan set of slashing scissors. Rock beats scissors.😊

There are some folks here who think that the study which found that Tyrannosaurus is twice as agile as Giganotosaurus isn't accurate or is a stretch due to one of the paper's sources being the outdated 4.2 tonne estimate for Giga; people like this conveniently ignore the fact that the Giga's mass in the paper was stated to be ~7 tonnes - and while it is outdated it still isn't that far of a gap from the 8.4-tonne estimate used for the holotype today. In fact, more mass would equate to Giga's agility suffering even further due to needing to overcome that extra mass lol. The conclusions of Tyrannosaurs turning 2x faster than Allosaurs and other Theropods mostly stems from the actual fossilized evidence on their legs and tails and gauging ideas of muscle attachments and ligaments - the skeletals are just add-ons. It doesn't matter if we use a 5 tonne Giganotosaurus skeletal or a 7 Giganotosaurus skeletal with muscle attachments (Or if we use a deflated 8.4 tonne Tyrannosaurus or a 9.5 tonne Tyrannosaurus, or a 10.2 tonne Tyrannosaurus), Tyrannosaurus' actual fossilized evidence and attachment gauges makes Tyrannosaurus more agile, and by twice the amount. Therefore, a 2x difference is not a "Stretch" as some people here like to claim.

50/50 as the Giga & T rex both weights 10-11 tons and both are very strong predator for their sizes and weaponrys to kill each other. E. D. Cope wins . 10.5 tons Giga slams mcraeensies rex mid diff as it has been downsized to 8 tons and it's a much smaller and nerfed T rex and Giga destroys any other Tyrannosaurids ( Tarbo, Zhucheng, Alamotyrannus etc) low to no difficulty.

Trex is heavier yet more agile? Is that a joke?

I don't normally think of battling dinosaurs. When I do, I think of something like lion prides facing down packs of hyenas - the potential violence is there, but whoever has a significant mass/ratio in the confrontation is going to chase off the other with minor issues. Predators avoid being hurt, when they can. Your real dangerous confrontations come, not over food, but mates... And that's iffy with different species. Still, most battles I've seen between various birds are over mating privileges and nesting territories. I've found male hummingbirds impaling each other. And watched a Robin beat its rival to death over a solid ten minutes of combat.

People really need to understand it takes more than bite force to win a fight. T-Rex do have more than that to win but it’s also smart. Seeing an animal almost equal to it in size and dimension would not want to risk it

Roland Tembo stomps both.

I agree, Tyrannosaurus Rex would win. However I don't think this would be very close.

I will note an error you made, We technically have zero evidence of a giganotosaurus over 9 tons, The other specimen with the piece of jaw and teeth is beyond unreliable for weight, Therefor it’s not very fair to give it a 10.4 ton weight the same way it isn’t fair to give a tyrannosaurus a 15 ton weight Also tyrannosaurus had sharp teeth, Which means it could have bled out prey easily like giga🤷 It’s not a video game either these battles go out beyond quickly so that “Bleed” Wouldn’t matter

I think I'd rate T-Rexes vs. Giganotosauruses, the same way I would rate Smilodons (or other Sabertooth cats) vs. Panthera big cats, such as American/European lions or tigers. Sabertooth cats (and T-rex) were build for fighting. They were stronger, bigger, heavier, more dexterous etc. Where as, Panthera cats (and subsequently Giganotosauruses) were build for more efficient hunting.

Carcha better than both

How about a video about Appalachiosaurus? Eastern dinosaurs are underrepresented. Western dinosaurs are highly overrated.

And when did rexs bite get buffed to 13,834

Given the size and bulk of these animals, I imagine they would just go direct jaw-to-jaw at each other, sort of like how Jack and Stumpy was fighting in Dinosaur Revolution. In that scenario, it is difficult to imagine any Theropods would be able to stand up the T-rex. T-rex's massively-built jaw and neck, significantly more so than any Theropods in its weight class, are perfectly designed for this sort of frontal and direct confrontation. The best chance for the Giganotosaurus is to outmaneuver the T-rex and latch on its side. However, the Rex is much more agile and has better eyesight, so I am not sure how the Giga could pull this off. Maybe if the Rex accidently trips on a rock or something, then the Giga could win.

smh smh... Deviljho Victims. But for real here, rex wins 55-60% of the time. BUT, 55-60% is basically still a coin toss, both animals only need 1-3 bites to kill the other, if either carnivore can bite into the other's neck, the battle has ended. Even giganotosaurus with a lesser bite force can still crush rex' jugular in a single blow. Though, if you have different opinions, or facts that disprove my belief, than be free to criticize!

Tbh I would’ve liked to see great white vs salt water croc far more to be fr

I thought this was made year ago lol

There are too many things you glossed over with more to it. For starters: 1) Why didn't you use the speed study by Van Bijlert? It's the latest one and it estimates Tyrannosaurus at 4 - 6 mph with 11mph brisk speed bursts. 2) There is no evidence that Tyrannosaurus hunted Alamosaurus. Same thing going head to head with Triceratops or Ankylosaurus. Pack hunting is theorized given how dangerous those herbivores were. 3) Tyrannosaurus had a large brain mainly because that majority portion was dedicated to smell. I remember the intelligence papers that came out for Baryonyx and it was that far off from Tyrannosaurus. 4) It's highly likely than Carcharadontosaurids are heavier than Tyrannosaurids based on the Fabbri 2022 bone density study. The estimated mass for MUCPv-ch1, using a density of 0.95 kg/L (Larramendi, Paul, & Hsu, 2020), would be around ~8.17 tonnes which is higher than other average sized Tyrannosaurus. (Stan is 7 tonnes) MUCPV-95, it's latest measures are 6.6% at bare minimum bigger than the holotype, which gives a weight that rivals, if not exceeding Sue/Scotty. Giganotosaurus is overall the larger theropod between the two.

My favorite part of these videos' comment sections is scrolling down from the multiple paragraph long comments explaining the science and modern research behind each competitor, then getting an immediate shift to "[insert unrelated fighter here] victims" comments. Jurassic Park Dilophosaurus piloted by human level intelligence victims, btw.

While I would give it to T-rex by a very slim margin, I would say T-rex is not leaving the fight in a good shape either. But realistically if these two did size each other up, likely they would not have a fight, maybe a stare down and then back away. Since well Real Life animals don't get into unneeded fight to the deaths unless it's a hunt or have no choice. It's a more of a human thing to go have fights which can cripple you.

You highly overestimated Giganotosaurus's weight.

Holotype Giganotosaurus is 12.7 metres & 9.02 tonnes not 12.4

The giga in a way was built to be a glass canon

Even though I like both animals a lot, the T. rex wins indisputably. It can incapacitate and kill the Giganotosaurus carolinii with one or two bites. It would be extremely painful to have his bones broken or exploded by this Tyrannosaurus.

I wouldnt say its close at all Biggest Giga is about 8.5 tons not counting the fragmentary dentary 10,1 ton giga biggest rex is 11,4 tons thats almost 4 tons difference rexes are bigger, stronger, smarter, more battle experienced, more agile and just more evolved you can say giga dosent really stand much of a chance against a rex, if its max size rex and max size giga (without the dentary one as its very fragmentary and pretty unreliable pretty sure) then rex wins with low difficulty if its average 9 ton rex and a max size giga then its a mid maybe medium high diff for rex

gigas probably came in packs, the rex aint...

I love how this debate is more civil with people actually using real stats and studies Way better than the Rex vs spino debates from the early 2010s 😂

"Let's push out the clear loser?" EH!?! Spinosaurus would WRECK T. Rex just by being confusing and shape-shifting the whole battle lol

I'll never get used to his british accent.

giga would win

Tyrannosaurus rex vs Giganotosaurus carolinii 2024 Tyrannosaurus rex stats Specimen- BHI 6248 Height- 4.1m at the hips Length- 12.8 meters ( 42 ft) Weight- 11,740 kgs ( 11.7 tonnes) Bite force- 7 tonnes Era- Late cretaceous America Giganotosaurus stats Specimen- mucpV-95 Height- 4.2m at the hips Length- 13.5 meters ( 45 ft) Weight- 10,260 kgs ( 10.2 tonnes) Bite force- 4.3 tonnes Era- mid cretaceous South America Tyrannosaurus advantages- bigger, bulkier, more muscular & stronger, more agile, more powerful bite force , intelligence Giganotosaurus advantages- taller , faster, more experience, Serrated teeth Verdict: Tyrannosaurus rex- 65% Giganotosaurus- 35% Winner- Tyrannosaurus rex 🦖 🏆 ( 65% chance or mid-high diff)

Giganotosaurus carolinii stats Height- 4.1m at hips Length- 13.6 meters ( 45 ft) Weight- 10.4 tonnes Bite force- 3.9 tonnes Specimen- Mmchpv-95 Giganotosaurus chances against other megatheropods 1. Carnotaurus~ 2.2 tonnes ( Giga wins no diff) 2. Allosaurus~ 4.6 tonnes ( Giga wins neg diff) 3. Torvosaurus~ 5.5 tonnes ( Giga wins no-low diff) 4. Acrocanthosaurus~ 5.8 tonnes ( Giga wins low diff) 5. Spinosaurus~ 7.8-8.3 tonnes ( Giga wins low-mid diff) 6. Deinocheirus~ 8.4 tonnes ( Giga wins low-mid diff) 7. Carcharodontosaurus~ 8.2 tonnes ( Giga wins mid diff) 8. Saurophaganax~8.3-8.9 tonnes ( Giga wins mid-high diff) 9. Mcraeencis rex~ 8.8 tonnes ( Giga wins mid high diff) 10. Final round Tyrannosaurus rex vs Giganotosaurus Stan~ 7.6 tonnes ( average Rex) ( Giga wins low-mid diffs) Sue~ 10 tonnes & Giga~ 10.4 tonnes ( Giga wins extreme diff) Scotty ~ 10.4 tonnes & Giga~ 10.4 tonnes ( 50/50) or Tyrannosaurus extreme diff. ( E.D. cope is an unreliable fragmentary+ it's size hasn't confirmed yet so should be ignored).

Nah, T-Rex one shots mid

Trex wins neg diff

It's only close if you know next to nothing about either animal. It's not close. At all. Trex wins. Every time.

T rex wins mid diff It's too overpowered for a giga to handle

This fights always annoyed me because of how most people act like it's always a low diff for the rex they're both large predators around the same weight and the giga is slightly taller and longer bite force isn't the end all be all to determine this they had different hunting styles trex needed it's bite force to be that powerful giga didn't I say this fights as 50/50 as 50/50 can possibly get

I would love to see how these 2 amazing apex predators would have interacted with each other. Now obviously these animals would avoid conflict whenever possible, and even if they did get into a conflict with one another, it would have most likely been a threat display until one of them backed down (which I’m curious how that would go). But if a fight were to break out, it really is a SUPER close fight. Both have distinct advantages over the other that can end the fight in a single bite. Certainly would be a battle for the ages. Also why Spino gotta catch the stray 😭. He good boyo doing good boyo things like eating pheesh

Bruh giga fans are seething

Hard to keep your distance and land bites on an opponent that's both stronger and more agile than you. Giga's all hype, where T-Rex just keeps delivering year after year. Every time we think we've figured out its limits, we find a bigger one. We have so much T Rex material, and so little material from other mega-therapods like Giganotosaurus that any kind of intelligent comparison is impossible.

It’s actually not close at all. They have about 22 million years and several thousand miles between their battle.

I would like a battle between some prey animals that T Rex hunted and have them fight Giganotosaurus, Spinosaurus, and Carcharodontosaurus, such as Spinosaurus vs Triceratops, Mapusaurus vs Ankylosaurus, Carcharodontosaurus vs Torosaurus(dinosaur related to and coexisted with Triceratops, but had a bigger head and frill).

I´m gonna sound like a fanboy, but i don´t see any good advantage in a Battle situation in favor of the Giga, whats´he gonna do? try to land a lot of bites and bleed the tank? Rex needs one good bite, ONE, and is more agile, smarter and had better vision. Also, remember it could ram with his head, unike the Giga. The size factor is also a big one, back some years ago we thought Sue was the biggest Rex and Rexes that size where highly uncommon, fast forward some years and we have scotty, Cope and Bertha wich indicates giant rexes where not that uncommon. Take Cope for a second, do people realize we have way more evidence of Cope been 11.5t+ than we have of a 10t+ Giga?, and that is not the upper (or max) limit... and it´s said Bertha was bigger. For the Giga to equal in mass Sue, the dentary specimen would have to fit whitin the margins of max estimate of 13.5 mts and still Sue would have some extra kilos on it, given 10.4T is the max estimate done for the animal, been more likely about 9.5... For the Giga to equal Cope it´d had to be way long, like spinosaurus max estimates of long. And in a battle where your foe has all of the advantages over you SIZE MATTERS.

Bleed damage advantage to Giga? If T-Rex bit down on something - it is incapacitated if not mortally wounded immediately - it wasn't a bite like the shark toothed Charcaradontosaurs, it literally exploded tissue like a melon in a hydraulic press. All the fighting advantages are in favour of T-Rex - sheer mass, strength, close quarters agility, endurance and it appears - most importantly - intelligence and actual fighting experience against other massive therapods ie other T-Rexes. Don;t think a Giga would even engage in this conflict beyond just a token display gesture- there would be a pretty well understood hierarchy present - like a average hyena simply runs off an average cheetah after it hisses a few times in annoyance first.

Considering Carcharadontosaurs lived in North America during the Cretacious along with early Tyrannosaurs. I'm sure there were conflicts between the two species. But it does make me wonder what happened to the Carcharadontosaurs.

A good take Tyrannosaurus should win about 65% of the time due to superior agility mainly, but it would not be easy and no matter who won, they’d be walking away with some nasty wounds. I’m a giga fan but yeah it would lose more often than not to Rex.