U.S. military would conduct war against Hamas ‘much differently,’ says Sen. Kelly: Full interview 

Who are we to instruct Israel in warfare. We lost in Afghanistan. We blundered 9/11... And we attacked Iraq who was not complicit in the 9/11 Saudi influenced attack. Who are we to advise any country in warfare.

Israel is subjected to a standard that no other nation has ever been asked to uphold in warfare, even while Israel exceeds every other nation on earth in its concern for civilians resulting in the lowest ratio of civilian casualties of any other conflict. Kelly's lecturing on this subject is pure politics with no basis in military reality.

What is the civilian/combattant ratio on the american wars??? Israel is doing a far better job at this than the US has ever done in any of their urban wars!!! The US can give no lesson to Israel on this!

I mean he is right. If the US was the one doing this the casualty rate would be a lot higher that's for sure.

Sen. Kelly and President Biden haven't ever dealt with the Middle East mentality that Americans have absolutely no understanding of at all.

Guys, 400K Afghans and Iraqi have been killed in US wars following 9/11. Did anyone think that the US was committing Genocide ? What is the base to think that the US would have conduct this war differently?

I think its horrible that people tend to not care about the killing of men the way they do about women children and elderly.

This is pure propaganda. Tired of the dishonesty.

None of this is true. The IDF is doing way more for Palestinian civilians than the USA did for Iraqi civilians and Afghan civilians while we prosecuted our wars in their country.

This is not journalism

Cant watch this copaganda crap any longer.

Goal No mistakes - name the country that makes No mistakes in war?

This woman is the best person for propaganda news

*USA, UK, Germany, France double standarts 😂🎉*

Yes, I agree. The U.S. military would conduct the war against Hamas much differently than Israel. Just look at how the U.S. military conducted the war in Iraq and Afghanistan, in which they fled with their tails between their legs, leaving numerous soldiers and civilians dead, and leaving billions of dollars worth of military equipment behind for the enemy to use or sell. Yeah, the U.S. military would definitely show Israel how to lose a war. I am glad Israel is not going to listen to the U.S. Oh, and the U.S. military killed hundreds of thousands of innocent Iraqi and Afghani civilians in the wake of these two wars. Shame on these liberal/leftist Israel-hating news media outlets and shame on the Biden administration and some democrats like Bernie Sanders and Chuck Schumer

Critics of Israel always use the same formula: "(1) There are too many civilian casualties in Gaza, but I will never mention the actual civilian to combatant ratio. And (2) Israel should be fighting this war much differently, but I will never tell you how."

"Israel should do a better job". Sure. Thanks for mentoring. Just remember that for US forces in Afghanistan and Iraq the ratio of civilian to combatant casualties was 6 : 1, while Israel got to the ratio of 1.5 : 1.

I have block this news media. I don’t want such a propaganda anymore.

Jewish and Palestinian kids need to be safe but both rights to protest must be protected too

Free America from AIPAC!

the us doesnt share a border with hamas

Those young people were not out of control.

That's AIPAC'S money Talking

AIPAC contributions of $496,271 to Senator Mark Kelly are really paying off here.

Apparently America can't change

On the campuses, CAIR and QATAR money talking

Senator Kelly would you allow “ peaceful protests “ calling for extermination of black or Hispanic or Asian Americans ? Why don’t you condemn the protests themselves and not just the violence ?

Why are we talking about the national guard? Let's be clear, the national guard is the military. Calling in the US military against US citizens should never happen because of words or hurt feelings.

Ladies and Gentlemen, what happened to the announcements that civilians should move to a safe place to prevent civilian casualties in Gaza?

How about pro peace students can they get their freedom of speech without name calling them

It is sad and disappointing to see senators and congressmen like him who are unquestionably and blindly loyal to a foreign state of Israel instead of being loyal to their constituents at home

Listening to this BS PROPAGANDA, IS DISGUSTING.

Is US military is so efficient, it won't loss so many American soldier in Vietnam, Afghanistan and Iraq war.

It's OK everyone! CNN, MSNBC, FOX NEWS, JOE BIDEN, AND DONALD TRUMP all stand for the RIGHT of Israel to protest Free Speech in AMERICA!

I don't believe the US would appreciate it if Israeli decided to tell us how to conduct our own combat operations, and that relationship holds true in reverse. Does President Biden support Israeli or not? Is US support unconditional or not? Biden's withdrawal from Afghanistan was disastrous, passively arming the Taliban with abandoned weapons and munitions stores as well as the repetitional loss and doubts raised by strategic partners regarding US commitments- so I'm not convinced of Senator Kelly's claims about how the US would conduct operations against Hamas. Sen. Kelly never discusses specific metrics about what would constitute improvement in the IDF's ability to limit civilian casualties, and despite his acknowledgement that Hamas is the most substantial threat to lasting peace in the region, the UN just voted to expand Palestine's observer state status. His suggestion that Hamas would abide by any binding treaty is absolute folly. Why doesn't he just put on a top hat like Lord Chamberlain and proclaim, "peace in our time"?

yes these war-pigs are chilling

It was barbaric. Oct 7th was barbarism.

How's that working for us? Our track record is pathetic.

Such a one sided man ,he is another AIPAC lobbiest.

Very disappointed.

How? By giving them more weapons? ….then beg them for peace billions worth of weapons?ok then let me help my obese son with M&M candies and sodas pop

Im so tired of these bs interviews. What's the point of an interview with no pushback? You might as well just publish their opinions as fact. Jewish students are part of the protest. Stop the gaslighting.

They would do a Mosul and Fallujah and not care one iota how many civilians are supposedly killed

"If we don't see changes, it is appropriate to put conditions on aid". Really? How many months, years will u give Israel to fo better.

Oh he fought in Iraq and speaks about that like it's a good thing

the military's campaign in afghanistan was conducted differently and was a massive success, for the taliban.

Maybe we would. Maybe we wouldn't. We don't have the best track record.

«My hope here is that in *the coming days,* there could be some change, you know-we will have to see but we continue to have these ongoing discussions with Hamas towards *some kind of* a ceasefire; Hamas has traditionally rejected them...And what I would like to see is that *things settle down.»* Meaning-if the protests persist after those "ongoing discussions," then it would be okay to unleash the *National Guard* on protesters?! "I want this, I want that"-does Mr. Kelly consider what the protesters are asking for besides what "he wants."

Sorry, Hank, Mark, whatever, but the ratio of civilian deaths to combatant deaths in Gaza is lower than in ANY conflict involving Muslims or Arabs in history, and a FRACTION of the deaths of civilians when the USA CARPET BOMBED Mosul, Falluja, Ramadi...Lets recall the time the USA bombed a school full of children hiding in Baghdad, or the thousands of Iraqi children who died from lack of medicines and foodstuffs during the #USABlockade...Do better? USA should be learning from Israel. How much money did Qatar and Iran donate to your campaign?

America take care of your peoples, before Israel

LOL!!! They'd spen 2 trillion over 20 years and lost, then leave the equipment behind for hamas.

Don’t remember warning civilians about bombings in Iraq or Afghanistan or supplying humanitarian aid or evacuating civilian population from the active military zone. He has no right to teach Israel. Such a bogus interview

America and Gaza both should be free

The military needs to explain who authorized a pier when that isnt Americas land and why the presidents kids victim has a foreign disinformation task force

Of course. Campaigning time, so they need your vote, and then see you in 4 or 6 years. It's like these people aren't getting the message of the protests.

Oh yes and the US has always played by the rules of international law, haven't they? Just like in Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan for instance.

None of the armed factions are fighting alone. Hence, the intervention of the US army in favor of Israel is not a crime, as Iran and other parties support Hamas. Any of these parties make wars looking for both the short and long term bad consequences against themselves and their respective relatives.

With all due respect to the senator, he is a navy vet, he knows minimal about ground operations and logistics

"For to us a child is born, to us a son is given, and the government will be on his shoulders. And he will be called Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, Prince of Peace."

why do these interviews sound like speeches? Speeches with some other person filling the gaps for them? lol

Why should we care what he thinks he has no decision-making in the matter

Do you think if the border presented earlier in the foreign aid package would pass a stand alone issue now?

He is losing support from young voters.

We don’t need more Biden John. Elect a moderate. Libertarian. RFK Jr. Biden is OLD. Anyone who thinks Biden, is out of their mind in November.

Student protest is Americana as apple pie! These folks have forgotten when they were students during Nixon in Nam!

Isr has absolutely not responded in an appropriate way. How many videos of injured and dead children in Gaza do we need to watch live-streamed before change is made.

This man's intelligence is so high that all his hair fell out because it couldn't withstand the pressure of his intellect.

You mean like attacking Haifa (as Biden just said not to do? ) lol

No violence needed. Breach of duty is punishable in court as this administration tells me the international court has no authority in gaza

Oklahoma state is a gynocological and obstetric healthcare desert since the magas running the state passed the strictest anti-abortion laws in the nation. Gov Kevin Stitt has a TASK FORCE to monitor all pregnant women from conception through giving birth. Doctors are required to give the Task Force information on all their pregnant patients.

Well for a start no one will be monitoring your every move.

Kelley is bias and dishonest in his framing …

Gaza has long ago become violent and out of control. How many lives, Senator, does it take to constitute revenge?

“Protesters are violent, Jewish students need to feel safe” “Hamas is the reason why there isn’t a ceasefire” 2 mins in and just from the framing of his responses I can tell he has a major pro-Israeli bias.

Wonder who is President of the USA Netanyahu or Biden ??

The Pentagon is sometimes slow to learn, but they DO learn. And they do a much better job of analyzing reality and recognizing past errors than does politics at large, or for that matter, journalism.

Please. If women in Arizona are in danger it is because of the laws in Arizona, not in Washington DC. Women in Massachusetts, California, NY, have not lost any rights because their states protect women's rights. Your state does not, and that's on your state, not Trump.

the PPalestians would also like to continue their education but all their Universities / Schools have been demolished....and don't even try to get medical help...so by far the West is so naief it is unbelievable

It is tempting to be in awe of the Senator's military record and hold him as some kind of authority on waging wars. However, I suspect he would be the first person to tell you that there is a huge difference between being a "flyboy" like he was versus being a "boots on the ground" foot soldier.His claim(s) that America would fight this war differently and that Netanyahu has made mistakes are not coming from a position of relevant/current experience. Not very credible.

How dare him say ‘Israel has a right to defend itself…‘Oct 7 and 911- this is everyday for the Palestinians.

35,000 people in a small piece of land of 360 km2 in a short period of 6 months...

When did tjos MOG became a senator?!!

according to Donald Trump Arabs r leaving life like kings, but i see Israelis r having royal life, the r enjoying other peoples land, having USA and European's unconditional money to enjoy life even they don't have to spend on security or health or education even they don't have to earn enough to spent more then any USA or European citizen can dream of.

Too many "experts" on the Israeli military engagement in Gaza like this TV announcer suddenly appeared out of thin air.

«The police have *conducted themselves appropriately.»* What does that mean? Using pepper spray, beating people with batons, tasing people, kneeling on people in prone positions and pressing their heads against the ground, attacking teachers protecting students, violently shoving and grabbing people in locked arms and dragging them on the ground, firing gaseous weapons at the crowd, etc.

"The bipartisan border security bill was blocked by the Republicans." Clearly we are not dealing with a genius here.

Kelly is rather dense.

US never face such w0r where the enemy was too happy to sacrifice their civilians during cross firee fight

admitted dropping same weapons in Iraq?

Seriously? When US Military fought a war, the casualties were 1:8, IDF have casualties 1:1.5. What gives you a reason to believe US would do better?

THEY HAD A AGREEMENT TO GIVE HOSTAGES BACK

bachelor party Quiz: 1. How many Egyptian soldiers have been killed by Palestinian terror in the last 10 years. 2. Why did the Christians in Lebanon flee the country? Who conquered Lebanon? 3. How many Palestinian terrorists were killed in Syria by the Syrian army, and why? 4. Why did the State of Kuwait expel 400000 Palestinians after an attempt to occupy Kuwait. 5. Who tried to assassinate King Hussein and to turn Jordan into a state of Islamic law. The Palestinians are not welcome in any Muslim country. Only the West embraces Islamic terrorism. Because of a common hatred for Jews. and will pay the cultural price. The West is killing itself

0:38 Osama bin violence so shut it all down in other words you're a bum mister

If Mexico did to the US what Hamas did to Israel - well let's just say the conflict would have ended within 48 hrs - would've/should've/could've🙃

Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Syria... Of course, the US would make war differently. 😅😊😂

Far left news you stated this

Kids who are too emotional and too uneducated. I bet the parents are proud

It would be interesting to see the US military performance in Gaza as compared to IDF. So far we saw it recently in Iraq and Afghanistan. It was not impressive.

Free America from Hamas!

Where is Blinken 😎🎸 on the pier 😎🎸