It's there is freedom of speech, BUT private property prevails. The activist has not right to protest on private property. I support the UC Berkeley Law Professor, and that's not assault at all.
@@disham Putting your hand on someone isn't fucking battery, oh my lord. Suppose I'm standing around in a crowded place and someone goes, "Hey, let me squeeze through" and they put their hand on my shoulder for half a second. Is this assault and battery? Can I sue this individual for assaulting me? No, fucking obviously not. Now imagine I'm trespassing in their house and they tell me to leave and put their and on my shoulder. It's not assault.
@@zarki-games battery requires physical contact AND intent-- the "hey, let me squeeze through" random stranger in a crowded place most likely has no intent to touch you so not considered battery. This old woman clearly had intent to touch the speaker as she verbally announced her intent followed with her physical horse collar -- so yes, this is by definition battery.
@@disham U can keep leaving ur comments all u want but the fact is the girl talking was in the wrong & the old lady did nothing wrong 2 try & stop her, as long as the young girl was on the old ladies private property!
@@MimiKeel Israel is fought for that land they bought that land so shut your mouth and Jews have been living there for a long time not just Palestinians it’s both their homes
If a lawyer told her she was free to protest there, she wasn't informed of her first amendment rights or laws regarding trespass. No one, absolutely no one, with a law degree would tell her she has a right to protest on private property
well but a public event for students on a private property, is it then private or public playing the game as usual some people seem to get very upset about private property rights shame they don't say that to the West B settlers!
@@frankbardon Yeah in America! you shamefully do not respect foreign countries to have self determination, and you do not have workers right medical rights prisoners rights there is a lot of work to do before being a fully fledged civilised country.😁
@@Faby-tp7hz private property remains private property. An individual has no constitutionally protected right to free speech on private property, that does not change because of an event being hosted there
Guys. If this was in public, it WOULD be wrong of the older couple, but this is quite literally their home and the young lady and her friends had no right to do what she was doing
@koreannyangtigeractually, she doesn't. It's private property. Free speech only applies to public places. Also, this extremely rude and entitled young woman had lied about this incident in interviews. As a guest in this home her rights extend to her freedom to leave as she was told to.
@koreannyangtigerI think the cameraman was invited( as the gentleman said to the cameraman “you are my guest”), but she was uninvited…I think she has every right to speak out her voice in the public, but it is kind of rude to do such thing in someone’s private property…what’s the point of giving such speech here, when there was hardly any audience outside the house….it seems she just wanted to post it on social media…Yes, it was wrong that innocent people were killed in Gaza, and the war should be stopped as soon as possible. But we should not spread hate to innocent Jewels and they are also supposed to live a normal life in the university and anywhere in the world…we really need love and peace for each other!
The man clearly stated that she was a GUEST at their home. She didn't invade their home and start trouble, yet she was assaulted. I am a Christian and don't side with Israel OR Islam, but I DO stand for truth and justice.
Why did the intolerant professor feel so alarmed & threatened ? The student was only making a speech in trying to make a point. She wasn't coming to illegally squat in the house nor did she force her way in. She wasn't pulling our a gun & intending to kill anyone or using violent gestures like Israeli IDF Terrorists routinely do or the typical American cops or trigger happy rednecks. If she had just listened patiently like all teachers should all the hype could have been averted.
@bobbyf3887 Typical colonialist mentality! No, THAT IS NOT YOUR COUNTRY, ESPECIALLY IF SOUND AMERICAN; which is occupied by genocide and ethnic cleansing of the Natives! OFFENDED BY EVERYTHING, ASHAMED OF NOTHING!
Go and listen to Golda Meir, one of the founders of Israel, who said: "I am a Palestinian, and have carried a Palestinian passport for several years under British mandate of Palestine. Palestine was the area between Jordan River and the sea." She also said: "One cannot and must not try to erase the past merely because it does not fit the present." Now, we have a conversation with a bunch of either ignorant Zionists or liar propagandists, who even don't have the honesty of early Zionists.
"Matti (Mattityahu) Peled in San Francisco May 1992 (you can watch the video on YT"), said: "This is the situation we have to live with and I have no doubt that direct consequence of the occupation anyone, who said occupation corrupts, was absolutely right, and we are occupying the West Bank and the Gaza Strip for the last 25 years, and this is corrupting us maybe even more than the American Aid ..."
You learned American Law and order is only designed for kind,honest, hard working,Christians who knows how to be grateful only. Any other cultural or religion will only create chaos. New blood will bring in creative people but they must be tested of understanding of American values and morality.
@@msierox She was not trespassing. She was invited, talked against the genocide, therefore was interrupted by genocide supporters, and asked to stop and leave, and she refused to give up! You miss the main point, which is: - on one side, being against genocide! - on the other side, supporting genocide, by interrupting actions against the genocide! Haven't you seen, how they always invent a fake reason, to interrupt and prevent anti-genocide peaceful protests, by hateful violent genocide supporters!
She actually thinks she’s right, and she’s clearly wrong . Remember that next time you argue with an Islamist. They are always convinced they are right. Different culture.
If she is protesting on someone’s property then, the lady has every right to kick her off the property. If that is public property then, the protestor is doing nothing wrong
I dont agree with the obnoxious behaviors of either party, but I will say that it's obvious the "protesting" or whatever they are doing is clearly happening in the backyard. Yes, they do need to leave.
@Obvious4everyone not on private property. This is happening in the owners backyard. Now if the Muslim woman was doing this same thing on the sidewalk out front then that is public and she is legally allowed to do that. She cannot do anything like this in the backyard, on there driveway or front lawn. But again the sidewalk is 100 percent legal.
This is what Palestinians have been dealing with for 75 years by the Israelis, yet Americans support Israelis when they trespass and steal Palestinian land.
@@tye8149speak on it!! they’re all hypocrites that act like they can’t understand shit when 40,000 people are murdered in 6 months but can recognize trespassing just fine. sick in the head.
In fact, it is a humanitarian issue. Secondly, these people could not bear to hear the sound of a microphone, so what about the Palestinians under the rubble of their house???
@@PoPo-io8ts The girl making a speech was an *invited guest* at a private, nonpolitical event hosted by the professors- which makes her behavior grossly rude. The location is the professors’ backyard where they were hosting a dinner for students.
I'm a Muslim, but it is very wrong to go into people's homes to voice your opinion or protest. When you're not invited to. Once they ask you to leave, you should leave. It is a sin to restraints.
Correct, not long ago I was invited to a dinner party and the host asked us not to talk about politics or religion and we respected that wish, and had a great night
they were invited, if they say leave our home, aren't they proving Palas tine right or teI avev should go to n. poIe and leave ppl alone in that logic, no?
they were invited, if they say leave our home, aren't they proving Palas tine right or teI avev should go to n. poIe and leave ppl alone in that logic, no?
they say occupying is Zl0 defense not offense. False. Pre & post 1948 Zl0 oppressors Iie on Arabs, etc. Key incidents include 1948 K. David HoteI, 54 Iavon affair, Iiberty & O9 - OlI, lraq wmd Iies etc. Bibi even said the last 2 are good for us answering the qui bono w/ audio on yt! Some ppl claim the bible says it's their land, 1st it's no authority & what verse? Read point 4 and rev 2.9 & 3.9. The children of Abraham are Ismailis who learned Arabic and jues who learned Arabic and became Muslim. Even eldest lsraeIi prime m's have Palestine certificates ...
🤔🤔🤔 think about what this old lady said about palestinians before this incident....i'm pretty sure this young Muslim lady choiced to do This in front her house because something like hatred against palestinian's ppl occured with this old lady before
@@Bryan-cd9clthis is America. The professor is allowed to say mean things about whomever she wants and the protester was on her property. Not in front.
California law and jurisprudence seems to recognize front yards and driveways that aren't fenced as public places because members of the public can come to your door without restriction. Solicitors, neighbors, fundraisers, candidates, the mailman, or anyone wanting to speak with you can just come up and knock.
The 42,000 people giving a thumbs up above you are too rabid/crazy to get this concept in America. They live safe little lives here in the U.S., never too far from a Starbucks, instead of actually fighting for something on the other side of the world. If she actually believed in her convictions she would be in Palestine instead of doing performance art in Berkeley, CA.
The title of this video is misleading & mischievous. The girl has no right to be doing her protests from private properties. The professor is not assaulting but stopping the girl, which is her right.
Stopping the young girl from talking about a religious holiday really was so important to this professor, that she had to interrupt, grab the girl's phone and tell her to leave. What a freak. #FireHer
@@david_a_uno Whatever the girl wants to speak about, she has no right to do it on anyone's private property and the professor has every right to stop her. In fact it is the student concerned who should be taken to task for breaking the law. Of course most of this lot don't care about secular laws.
@@david_a_uno lmao she doesn't have a right to do that in precious Palestinians That freak would get stoned to death and you know but keep turning the other way and keep reporting others comments cuz it's the truth
I have seen worse. Such as the victims of IDF soldiers and Israeli military which the activists are speaking on!! Also 30 year old men punching female protesters at a college they don't attend.. just came to hurt someone
This is why none of their brother Arab countries will let them in. Jordan sent 20,000 back to Palestine a few years ago. Hamas even turned down land for a 2 state solution. The Arab world is tired of Palestine ( Hamas ) actually making trouble.
"Matti (Mattityahu) Peled in San Francisco May 1992 (you can watch the video on YT"), said: "This is the situation we have to live with and I have no doubt that direct consequence of the occupation anyone, who said occupation corrupts, was absolutely right, and we are occupying the West Bank and the Gaza Strip for the last 25 years, and this is corrupting us maybe even more than the American Aid ..."
The situation we see today in Pakistan, increase in prices & inflation, civil & political chaos and destabilisation at our borders, this was all shown to Muhammad Qasim in his blessed dreams years ago. #MuhammadQasimDreams
@@alcazargr.3886 apparently leftists think they can do whatever they want with zero repercussions. And when there's repercussions they scream racism or whatever ism they think fits the scenario.
I mean this exact situation been happening in Palestine why the double standards why the hypocrisy you don’t call the Zionist what they are occupying lands that is not theirs
So, u do understand that others can’t do as they feel like in the professor house but u fail to understand when a Zionist takes over a house of a Palestinian
@@honor6004 It is quite clear she does not consent to the woman doing this on her property, I merely used “asked to leave” as shorthand! Btw, learn your grammar, it’s question not exclamation marks.
@kathym.248 The girl reading in a very monotone voice with a bored and blànk look on her face seemed highly sedated. That maybe why she sounded like that. She did that while a guest in the home of that couple, - unless she broke in uninvited -- like Hamas did when they decided terrorize the peacçe loving in Isràel.
She wasn't trespassing when she started the speech. She is a law student and was invited with other law students to the Deans home. Florida has enough nonsense the way it is.
The same ones saying it’s her freedom to stand on private property and support terrorist are the same ones who would squat in someone else’s home and call it their own
Stick to your day job which clearly isn't criminal law. Whether you think it was violent enough to rise to the level of an "attack" the younger woman was assaulted. As for the private property bit, the homeowners should call the cops to have them removed or trespassed. Speech is zero excuse for putting your hands on anyone.
@@TheVuduYuDuactually, if you have told someone to leave and they failed to do so you can use the least amount of force necessary also, she was causing a disturbance with her microphone on their property. I don’t think any court would side with her.
as mentioned by others, its an event held by the dean, which he chooses to hold in his backyard rather than on campus. since its related to the school and not a personal event, if they are part of the guestlist he has no right to remove them for speaking an opinion he doesn't agree with due the protected principle of free speech and protest that a core aspect of American universities. Funny how your freedom only seems to be something to be proud of when it comes to arming mentally ill teenagers
If you're invited over to someone's house, and you're talking to someone else because a number of you were invited, the host does not "have the right" to come and assault you because they don't like what you and the other guests are talking about. If she wants to come and say, "Hey, do you mind turning off the microphone for a second so we can talk?" And if the person doesn't do that then she can say, "Alright, if you don't want to be reasonable, then I'm going to have to ask you to leave." And at that point if she doesn't leave, the host can call the police. Honestly, all she has to do is say, "I'm a well off white boomer and the person who is trespassing is brown skinned" and the cops will be there so fucking fast your head would spin. To reiterate: speaking is not a threat, even if someone is saying something you don't like, unless what they're saying is LITERALLY a threat, like "I'm going to cause you bodily harm." If I'm invited over to someone's house and I say, "I like pineapple on pizza" and the host tackles me, they're in the wrong. Home owners aren't de facto kings/queens. They still have to live under the law. They don't get to invite people over and assault them if they disagree. Not ok.
@@nathaniel1670 Cuz they have a different mindset: *Qur'an 4:59* “O believers! Obey Allah, the Messenger and those in authority among you” *Qur'an 5:101* “O believers! Do not ask about any matter which may disturb you.” *Qur'an 8:13* “Whoever defies Allah and His Messenger, ˹know that˺ Allah is severe in punishment.” *Qur'an 3:151* “We will cast t_____r into the hearts of those who have denied the Truth *Qur'an 5:33* “Indeed, the penalty for those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger (Peace Be Upon Him) and cause mischief is that they be k___ or crucified or that their hands and feet be cut off from opposite sides”
I hope the people who care so much about the ownerhip right of the genocide supporter pfofessor to expel the invited student who speaks against genocide, SHOW THE SAME CARE ABOUT THE OWNERSHIP RIGHT OF MILLIONS OF PALESTINIANS WHO'S HOUSES WERE DEMOLISHED AND OCCUPIED!
As university staff hosting a university event they extended their house into a part of the university. They used their class and race privilege to silence a justified, peaceful protest.
I am a Muslim, but will not support what the Muslim lady did here. You can express your opinion in support of Palestinians, but it shouldn't be in front of her house. It's their space. So go somewhere else.
@wemibright2470 In the United States it our first amendment right and if she is not on her property she can say it any where . I would also say the professor has no right to put her hands on another person or the professor could go to jail .. our laws in the United States
@@cynthiabragg2611 if someone protest in front of ur house where ur kids stay ,about black lives matter and grab all the media attention, imagine reporters gathered around ur house where ur kids are playing and you lose your privacy...
It's unacceptable to protest a genocide? Are you for real? And yes, it is assault. You don't get to invite someone onto your property, then change your mind because you didn't like their behavior, and then physically assault them when you did not feel like you were in danger. Basic law.
Free speech is a protection from the government taking it away and it occurs on public property. This lady’s house is private property. Please read a book why don’t you. Or better yet the constitution.
@shaydelre1898 If my grandmother grabbed someone's neck, she would be wrong also. The law is clear. Don't put your hand on somebody else when they don't want you to do that. Just call the police ,why is it, a point as simple as this, is so difficult to understand by some.
@@beadsy-dl5up Trespassing is being anyone else's PROPERTY. Are you that dense? Do I need to quote the law, or are you intelligent enough to read and comprehend yourself? 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Colonizers don't know that. They have no idea there could be a property they have no right to. In their minds, they have a right to every property they fancy.
@@annakirshenbaum1458um, I don’t think you understand. This is THEIR house where some dumbass student is yapping about “genocide” they have the right to tell them to leave.
The older woman was NOT assaulting her, nor was she being aggressive. The student was clearly misappropriating the First Amendment. Most people would probably have thrown her ass out of there.
@@shovanbijoy7136 Actually, the true Palestinian land would be southern Saudi Arabia and Northern Somalia. Palestinians go back to Abraham. Ishmael did not settle in Israel.
Learn the story behind the situation first. This professor is a Jew but he is also kind enough to invite student over to have a dinner at his home no matter religion or race. So don’t let edit videos control your mind. Sad that the world has come to short clips and not the full story also sad when a student abuses opportunity for other people to learn more from this professor. She could have denied the invitation if she didn’t want to be there but chose to use this as a protest opportunity. Sad world we live in now.
Israelis were very kind to Palestinians before 7th October. Giving them jobs, treating their sick in Israeli hospitals, etc. Be careful what you invite in.
Thanks for sharing. I realize that many of the protesters are letting their emotions causing them to forget that Hamas started this war. They share an equal blame for the loss of innocent lives. They really care about what's happening in the region, turn some of that energy towards asking Hamas to be honest and do the right thing.
@@AaronfromEngland1989 Too bad you live in communist England or else I would come onto your steps and protest you. I have read the entire most unholy Qur'an and my wife grew up in Algeria and Morocco so I know how evil Islam is!
Muslims here. This girl was in the wrong. You DO NOT take advantage of someone’s hospitality like that. How pathetic and embarrassing. Always the worst among us that get the most publicity and it infuriates me.
Partly because the so called moderate Muslims do NOTHING to police those among you who are extremists. Assault? That wasn't assault! Women don't/cannot commit assualt.
I am Christian. Brother you don't need to apologize that girl doing her protest needs to apologize to her hosts. Thank you for being objective and speaking truth. Peace be with you. Salam alaikum...ok I can't spell LOL.
@@zariftanzil1175 There are no settlers in Gaza. The Israeli government forced them to leave in 2005. Gaza is essentially a nation governed by Hamas that launched a terrorist attack on Oct 7th. Sucks to be stupid.
@@JohnJ469 If they're a nation, Israel shouldn't control their borders and infrastructure. That would go a long way to disarming Hamas. Also, more than half of Palestinians in Gaza weren't old enough to vote in the last election in 2006. An election that Israel hoped Hamas would win, and worked towards that end. Hamas was less threatening to them than the PLO
OK, this has NOTHING in common with what is happening in Palestine. You cannot go to someone's home and make unsolicited speeches. If you do, they have the right to kick you out.
In fact, it is a humanitarian issue. Secondly, these people could not bear to hear the sound of a microphone, so what about the Palestinians under the rubble of their house???
If you're a human you don't need to defesive with anything if u have humanity. WE are the ppl we need to respected and valued is justvwestern ppl are only value their lives.onother nations their lives non matters.
هم خارج المنزل و يحتجون و هذا ازعجها، فماذا إذا بالنسبة للفلسطنيين الذين يعتدي عليهم الصهاينة و يقتحمون منازلهم بالسلاح و و يبقون في تلك المنازل بالقوة و لا يحق لك قول شيئ علاوة على ذلك سرقتها و طرد سكانها ، كما اجبروا الملايين بمغادرة فلسطين منذ1948
What they are doing is wrong, here’s a verse from Quran: “ Enter not houses other than your own, until you have asked permission and greeted those in them; that is better for you, in order that you may remember. And if you find no one therein, still enter not until permission has been given. And if you are asked to go back, go back, for it is purer for you”
So the male law Professor is Jewish, his wife is also a law professor. They opened their home for students to have a BBQ. When the girl started out the wife came down the stairs after the husband was telling the girl to stop and leave. It was a publicity stunt and was the most egregious thing to do at your professor’s home. Now the girl wants to sue the couple and demands that U Berkeley should fire both professors!!!🤦♀️🤯
@@MONKEY.D.LUFFY67She didn't get permission to touch, but she touched because the other didn't have permission for a political speech in a privat property which means you need to follow the rules of that owner and don't necessarily have free speech.
Doesn't matter. If the property owner asked speaker to leave, and she didn't owner can call police, or document it and later have her dealt with legally, but does not have the right to assault anyone.
@@scpsoto1576actually you are wrong. Trespass is both criminal and civil. If I ask you to leave my house and you don’t I DO have the right to remove you. If you don’t believe me go trespass. Tell me how the goes for you
This isn't assault. Show me the injuries. This is someone trying to speak up over an unruly child. Grow up, people. Not every unwanted touch is the mark of a psychopath.
unless they can establish that prior to this video they've made a reasonable effort to inform this woman she must leave their property it's 100% assault.
