Udio.com - AI Music Generation Comes of Age... Is it game over?

Подписаться 17 тыс.

Просмотров 19 тыс.

50% 1

In this video, I look at a new AI music generation site...
Section Timings:
00:00 - Intro
02:13 - udio.com - A First Look Around
03:35 - Example: Electronic
05:41 - Example: Jazz
07:01 - Example: Coltrane
08:18 - Example: Parody / Comedy Song
09:41 - Example: Barbershop
11:09 - Example: Broadway Musical
12:10 - First Text Prompt Attempt
14:34 - Extending - Adding an Intro
17:20 - Extending - Adding an Outro
19:53 - Summary
Tracks featured in this video:
Cheer For Kevin - www.udio.com/songs/vYXTtH1LoF...
Baby on Board - www.udio.com/songs/282ZPSyaun...
Dune the Musical - www.udio.com/songs/eY7xtug1dV...
Harmonic Leap - www.udio.com/songs/dAJrkDePXb...
Archtop Odyssey - www.udio.com/songs/4HZEp32gta...
Relevant Videos:
DemucsGUI - Free Stem Splitter - • FREE Stem Splitting So...
Stem Splitter Comparison - • Stem Splitters: Are y...
RipxDAW - • RipX DAW - A Glimpse o...
If you have found any of my videos useful, please consider supporting the production of more videos by purchasing my book "The Complete Guide to Music Technology using Cubase 13", or "Getting Started with Dorico 4.3"
Details of the Cubase book are here:
musictechtuition.com/books/th...
You can buy it here: tinyurl.com/cubase13book
Details of the Dorico book are here:
musictechtuition.com/books/ge...
You can buy it here: tinyurl.com/dorico43book
8DIO Referral Link:
If you use the following link when you buy from 8DIO, I'll get a referral fee.
8diocom.refr.cc/darrenjones
Soundpaint Referral Link
If you use this link when you make a purchase from Soundpaint, you'll get $15 off, and I'll get a referral fee.
soundpaint.refr.cc/darrenj
Buy Me A Coffee:
www.buymeacoffee.com/musictech
I'm offsetting my carbon with Wren:
www.wren.co/join/darrenjones
#musictechtuition #cubase #udio #aimusic

Опубликовано:

21 июл 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 306

@davidwright6839 3 месяца назад

My epiphany with Udio was when I heard the jazz and prog-rock tracks that no human band could play. Udio allows for very long prompts, unlike Suno. I use Claude Opus to generate my prompts, giving them the genre, style, instrumentation, tempo, and emotional quality. It can take lines like "King Crimson merged with Frank Zappa" and construct style descriptions that eliminate the artist's names. Once you find an interesting first motif, you grow it outward with extensions to create a musical arc, throwing away the weird stuff. I am a trained musician and the composer/arranger of one commercially produced album in the 1970's. It was avant-garde and soon forgotten but has recently been rediscovered by a new generation on RU-vid. My plan is to use the original recorded tracks as reference tracks in Udio when this feature becomes available to resurrect my old band. If these can be stemmed and sweetened, they will create a new hybrid music genre. Music composition is fading to be replaced by music conjuring. The prompts are your IP.

@theno.1idea938 3 месяца назад

It'll be awhile and expensive when they give you/us the real deal.. But until then the one-offs are fun..

@musictechtuition 3 месяца назад

Really interesting comment, David. I'd not thought about using another AI to help with the prompt generation, so I shall look into that! Do you have a link to your album? I'd be interested to take a listen. Also, your plan sounds interesting, as is the IP comment!

@davidwright6839 3 месяца назад

It's on RU-vid. Search for McLuhan Anomaly.@musictechtuition

@dzaxys4643 3 месяца назад

Yeah still sounds squeeky atm I'm excited to hear if it can be a real tool of creation under the human direction and presumably eventually autominusly ,I will continue to create music because I am obsessed and compelled to do so I have never made much money from it I just do it because like most musicians I truly love it and find it therapeutic

@darakuT 3 месяца назад

You think we can monetize this music? I mean if U create a track in the style of a specific artist, there is a risk that artist can make an illegal issue for that?

@R.E-O 3 месяца назад

A musician with a realistic view of the near future of AI music? Have I traveled to a parallel universe while I was sleeping? I'm talking specifically about these two points: A) a lot of work is going to disappear, and B) most people won't care whether the music is made by a human or an AI.

@WhatsThisWorldComing2 3 месяца назад

same for most jobs that use a computer which is pretty much 90 percent of jobs. The movie industry has sora the moving image version of UDIO and its already pretty amazing.

@R.E-O 3 месяца назад

@@WhatsThisWorldComing2 I know, but some professions are more delusional than others when it comes to "AI will never be able to do X better than a human".

@AllanGildea 3 месяца назад

It's very sad, the implications for artists, creatives and technicians are devastating. And perhaps beyond.

@tez4792 3 месяца назад

Is this the future? All art forms (music, movies, tv, etc) AI generated at the click of a button by big corporations and the general public pay to consume them whilst working menial jobs earning minimum wage.

@WhatsThisWorldComing2 3 месяца назад

@@tez4792 yep....but it would be countered by people doing it the old way too....vinyl has returned after the big corps dumped it. Back in 90s i pressed my own vinyl music as part of the underground scene in london. we was doing it on our terms as the big labels were not interested until they saw there was money to make.

@s.muller8688 3 месяца назад

@@tez4792 depends on what kind of human you are i suppose? you are not forced to use it.

@tez4792 3 месяца назад

@@s.muller8688 not at this point in time. What if there becomes a time when there is no alternative?

@s.muller8688 3 месяца назад

@@tez4792 you will never be forced to use it. there is no way to enforce that. it's all up to you how real you want to be. Get real.

@uniqdzign2 3 месяца назад

As an artist and a musician, (digital art and guitarist/vocalist), I'm glad I'm now retired. I have been watching this closely since its onset . . AI. I feel for all those who will definitely be jobless as AI continues its relentless dismantling of human abilities, with complete disregard to creative rights of the painters and performers it draws its data from.

@AIsymphony-lo6de 3 месяца назад

Game over

@simoncroft 3 месяца назад

I am impressed/awe inspired and appalled/fearful in equal measure! Fortunately, it all sounds like wallpaper suitable for a corporate video.

@D3adIess 3 месяца назад

I believe around three years ago was when I first ran into Ai generated music. It was called OpenAI Jukebox and it was TERRIBLE. It'd generate the most horrifying sounds, sounds straight outta hell. When it wasn't mimicking the screams of the damned, the music it'd produce was completely incoherent. The lyrics were gibberish and so was everything else but I was still pretty awed by it at the time since "AI" wasn't plastered in everyone's faces back then so it had a lot of novelty. I don't think I could have ever imagined it'd ever get this good so fast.

@musictechtuition 3 месяца назад

Absolutely - the pace of change (even over the last 6 months) has been incredible, and it shows no sign of stopping. I think the quality, scope and musical ability of these services will be drastically greater in a year's time...

@1015SaturdayNight 3 месяца назад

I remember this and thought surely it would never be good.

@atrothe 3 месяца назад

I went and put some stuff together tonight. I am completely blown away. It is a bit difficult to work it out but WOW.

@wizards-themagicalconcert5048 2 месяца назад

Great video,content and insight mate,subbed !

@filbertneon3813 11 дней назад

Very well done! Thank you.

@FazedIMusic 3 месяца назад

I just started a channel with only AI music, it’s a lot of fun in the sense that you can now create songs that talks about you want to talk about and in the style you want. But at the same time, I still need to have my own channel with my own art because the experience of making something isn’t the same a getting something instantly. as an Illustrator, I first had a bad feeling about things like midjourney, now I accept it, and understand the difference between AI and the pleasure of creating something with your own hands. The real debate and is when it comes to work, industries and the futur of art jobs. That’s the tricky part.

@esenterre 3 месяца назад

I really like your very honest review of this!

@skippyfast5115 3 месяца назад

Also the fun in making music is creating music yourself and sometimes coincidence creates awesome outcomes

@johnb2602 3 месяца назад

At the moment, ai music generation is still only of use as an ideas machine. I say ‘at the moment’ because this tech is developing at an extraordinarily alarming rate. Media composers will be the first to feel the hit ,as I can’t see why any publisher will want to pay composers royalties for 75 years, when a few clicks will produce quality and convincing genre based music for the price of a latte. I’m afraid it’s not too far away.

@Recuper8 3 месяца назад

Not far away at all

@markjackson1989 3 месяца назад

I made a full song about a cowboy that falls in love with his best friend's dad. It could definitely fool someone with its quality.

@r34ct4 3 месяца назад

Dude I've already found some songs that are amazing and I can't get them out of my head - and I'm a musician. We're screwed. This AI music is going to dilute and devalue all other music. Please explain to me the reason people will value human music over this, aside from the artist's 'personality' and 'story' and whatnot? The value of creativity is going to change forever

@markjackson1989 3 месяца назад

@@r34ct4 A real person will always find a way to make a song weird. You're going to have to learn how to make music and do something the AI can't. I'll always be more relaxed knowing someone made a song and sang it.

@musictechtuition 3 месяца назад

@@markjackson1989 I think the issue with the 'weird' thing is that there's no reason why an AI can't learn to do what people do in that respect. I don't think it's possible for us to do anything which can't be copied, ultimately. I mean, I know I've never come up with anything truly original... the nearest things have typically been mistakes which I've then honed to make more musical. And I can totally see that workflow being copied!

@inkfunk 3 месяца назад

Had a play around with Udio, impressed with what it can do

@dzaxys4643 3 месяца назад

People who are artists and are working their craft not for money or fame but because they're compelled and obsessed by from the depths of their soul to perfect their craft will never stop

@starexplorers1202 3 месяца назад

Unfortunately we live in a world that uses money. Sad But True....

@dzaxys4643 3 месяца назад

@starexplorers1202 true it's hard work getting good any craft

@starexplorers1202 3 месяца назад

@@dzaxys4643 I agree 100%.

@Riktenstein 3 месяца назад

Pay your mortgage off fast, would be my advice.

@nocturne6320 2 месяца назад

For me the moment when I realized just how good it is is when I heard some music people created in the Hands Up style, Suno pretty much doesn't know it, but Udio pretty much nails it in some cases. I've heard songs that I would not be able to tell that they were made by an AI if they were just posted on RU-vid. Now you can still hear the low quality artefacting, but since hands up is mainly synths and samples it's pretty hard to spot and I am kind of used to lower quality, since I always listened to RU-vid reuploads. I can realistically see this as a legitimate competitor to Spotify once the quality improves just a bit more

@FulguroGeek 3 месяца назад

for the equilizing of sound.. its realy depends on the generation you get... i have get some amazing result with 3d audio scaping with almost perfect eq and mastering... Also there is a way if you lcik manual that you interract directly with the model.. otherwise udio is always rewriting your prompt. My fun with these new tools is to try create something weird or something i never heared before... example i create a epic fantasy celtic synthwve song

@coldlyanalytical1351 3 месяца назад

All the AI deniers .. "MY job will be safe" .... should watch this video.

@IsraeliMusicPlaylist 3 месяца назад

The only thing that could make it perfect ,is to have "stems" automatically. And the sound quality will be "wav"

@musictechtuition 3 месяца назад

I think that may come at some point, although I'd *think* that the stems would be generated the normal way (with a stem splitting algorithm) as the training material is a full mix. Although they could re-train it on sets of stems, that would probably work... but it's probably very expensive and too 'niche' for it to be financially viable.

@FusedMusic 3 месяца назад

Agreed. I wonder if there will be a prompt concept that allows you to build a song by creating stems one at a time. So AI generates drum track, then bass, pads etc. then you combine your sets and AI mixes and masters them. It's an exciting but scary time. I wonder how producers will embrace this. There's always been a symbiotic relationship between artist and producer. Now the producer doesn't need the artist, and vice versa. The times are changing!!

@Athari-P 3 месяца назад

@@musictechtuition It isn't expensive to train on stems, comparatively. If anything, the actual training would probably be cheaper, because the models can be much simpler. The real problem is the dataset. I suspect there's not enough data to train on.

@ianbarlow4518 3 месяца назад

From what I’ve read from the devs, the aim is to create high quality stems. I agree with the video, it’s a eureka moment. But creative output will still be defined by the user curated choices/prompts etc. Myself, I’ve only been using it two days and im addicted. I’m using perplexity ai to generate prompts and lyrics as it allows use of gtp4 turbo and Claude opus, as well as ‘focus’ mechanisms to fine tune output.

@musictechtuition 3 месяца назад

@@ianbarlow4518 Interesting to hear that about the stems, Ian.

@Filtermandave 3 месяца назад

Just had some great fun inputting some crude lyrics the results had me in stitches 😂

@paulhiggins5165 3 месяца назад

Thanks for a really honest look at this issue- so many people are either totally downplaying this or hyping the tech to rediculous levels. I'm an Artist not a musician but it's striking how the same discussions we were having about AI are now being mirrored in so many other places, such as music, video production and writing. It does seem as if this tech is going to eventually create a situation in which the time and effort requried to create anything 'digital' will be vitually zero- which by extension implies that the percieved value of any digital creation will also approach zero. I suppose the question comes down to this- how many people are going to want to listen to worthless music, or read a worthless book or buy a product decorated with worthless art? The very ubiquity and volume of AI generated 'content' may in the end be both the problem and the answer to the problem as people seek value in things that are not the outputs of machines.

@Murcatto-hu1ym 3 месяца назад

People don't buy things because of the amount of work that has gone into it, they buy it because it offers them the music, book, art that they will enjoy. I mean if we would really pay, for instance, novel authors for all their time and effort, books would become ridiculously expensive. People pay for the enjoyment of the art, not the effort required.

@paulhiggins5165 3 месяца назад

@@Murcatto-hu1ym Yes- but- 'enjoyment' is not as simple as you make it seem. For example; many people enjoy watching professional tennis, so can we conclude from this that those same people would enjoy watching two robots play tennis? I don't think that's true. Even if those robots were playing world class tennis I don't think many people would show up to watch those matches. So why would this be? Well, it seems that part of the enjoyment people get from tennis is the fact that it's played by people and not machines. So it might turn out that people will never really enjoy music made by machines, or books written by machines ect because part of what makes these things enjoyable and meaningful is the fact that they are made by people and not machines.

@johnrotten4871 3 месяца назад

@@paulhiggins5165 How will you know which songs are AI generated? Robot tennis might be quite exciting if the robots have above human ability : )

@paulhiggins5165 3 месяца назад

@@johnrotten4871 Why would it be neccessery to hide the fact that a song is AI generated? Unless you think that this knowledge might impact on how people feel about the song? Robot tennis could be incredible from a technique point of view- but that's my point- no matter how technically brilliant robot tennis might be no one is going to be interested in watching two robots play. So the fact that AI might produce flawless music does not mean that people will want to listen to it, because that music will be as meaningless as watching two robots play tennis. 'Content' is not culture- and this distiction might seem abstract and irrelevant but I believe that in the end people will reject AI generated creations not because they are technically bad but because the thing that made them had nothing it wanted to say- a song created by a machine has no meaning because the machine that made it was not trying to convey meaning- it was just mindlessly running through it's programming.

@johnrotten4871 3 месяца назад

@@paulhiggins5165 Myself, I don't listen to music for meaning. Probably why I don't analyze poetry - not my thing.

@NeverheardTunes 2 месяца назад

In case you're interested to hear how various genres of music sound when produced to full tracks, check out: www.youtube.com/@NeverheardTunes

@guillermosanchez1224 3 месяца назад

The one you created sounds like something they would play on disco and everyone getting shot lol

@choppergirl 3 месяца назад

So I post my song lyrics into custom lyrics, and hit create... and it does okay... I guess. I pick out the best one after a few tries. Then I hit extend, with the same set of long lyrics... and it butchers everything and goes off on a wild confusing mishmash of words I don't understand. Does anyone know how you can post the entire lyrics of a song in there and get it to generate the frigging song from start to finish, with no insanely wild lyric improvisation? I'm not talking about repeating things as a refrain... or taking artistic licence and being creative... I'm talking about... just straight up gibberish hallucinations.

@g.p616 3 месяца назад

What!! How can it make the instruments and vocals sound so realistic?

@MrMallum 3 месяца назад

At present it's the death knell for stock musicians

@Peter-tb5vg 3 месяца назад

Appaled and impressed at the same time. Not sure where I sit on this. I've created a few, one in the style of ACDC and it was so close to Brian Johnson it was ridiculous. I can see lawyers all over this. On the flip side, one song wasn't the best but had a great hook which I'm using in something I'm writing now. So where do I sit, still not sure.

@Athari-P 3 месяца назад

I find it amusing that the developers had the balls to train the model on copyrighted music. It relies on filtering prompts and lyrics to avoid close copies. Half their budget would be spent on lawyers...

@federicoaschieri 3 месяца назад

@@Athari-P They're skilled pirates, indeed. Once copyright law will hit them, they will already have made money. So they may as well shut down their business, and dedicate themselves to the next theft. The chief of the StabilityAI audio team, for ethical reasons stepped out of the company very loudly saying this is all illegal. On the other hand, a lot of people in tech industry are not good guys at all... But I don't doubt that sooner or later they will be forced to legally license their training data.

@Athari-P 3 месяца назад

@@federicoaschieri You might be overly optimistic. Have you been following the news about visual generative models? They all started with datasets relying on copyrighted materials, with reliance on fair use etc. But once the tech progressed far enough, the big corporations like Adobe started training models on 100% legally clean content, because it became viable. The smarter the tech, the less data you need. I don't see how musical generative models are any different. The pioneers will rely on fair use and whatnot, then the competitors will come with less legally grey options. The result is all the same. AI will be incorporated into the workflow of all creative professions, the internet will be flooded with AI-generated content, and creators will get paid pennies as usual. Frankly, the only difference between the legality of visual and musical datasets is the number of big corporations leeching off creators and fighting to protect their assets for centuries to come. Being the pioneer means you'll be the one fighting them for decades.

@federicoaschieri 3 месяца назад

@@Athari-P I'm very knowledgeable about copyright. Currently the US copyright office is questioning the AI companies' claim that it is fair use to steal data to make a commercial product that competes with the stolen art. Logically speaking there is just no way this argument can pass. So it is very likely that the theft will be ended. If you want do discuss whether it's fair use, I warn you I've already read all possible arguments and counterarguments on the official documents of the copyright office (more than 500 pages 😁)

@Athari-P 3 месяца назад

@@federicoaschieri My logic relies not on what I feel is right (if anything, Disney ruined copyright laws beyond repair - I believe we need less, not more), but on what the big corporations want. Currently, every single megacorporation in existence wants AI, no exceptions. Microsoft, Google, Disney, Amazon... Disney was stopped in extending copyrights when that went against needs of other corporations. But we have overwhelming consensus now. What Disney plans in terms of AI is crazy. Even politically, restricting AI may set the country back. Do you want China to have the tech to mass-produce content of ultra-high quality at low cost, and for the US and the EU to lag behind, just to protect smaller creators? Will you take that risk as a politician? If you know all the arguments, I don't see how you can say anything with such confidence, frankly. It won't be decided by the copyright office.

@michaelwoodby5261 3 месяца назад

I couldn't pick bad techno or jazz out of a lineup. Or rather, couldn't tell you if any of it would be considered good... but these programs are pumping out some really competent coherent music. Maybe not as much variety as the top 40 of any decade but if there's a specific genre you just want more of it's shocking.

@musictechtuition 3 месяца назад

Yeah, that's along the lines of what I'm thinking - you could be (say) spotify, and just create music on-the-fly that a lot of people wouldn't know wasn't 'real' and wouldn't be concerned about that either.

@midtskogen 3 месяца назад

Coherence is still an issue with AI generated stuff, though Udio has come some way. I might be fried for saying the following. Jazz isn't really my type of music, because I find it incoherent, mainly a rambling of tunes, and perhaps for that reason will AI work better for jazz than for other genres with strict rules and formats.

@TuckRob 3 месяца назад

Well I guess cheap TV will now be cheaper to produce. Diagetic background music that doesn't steal the scene. I can see this flooding youtube as it gives vloggers/creators more control to match soundtracks to their videos and no doubt there will be a feature to add timestamped cues to sync with video. The stand alone value of the music won't matter as it will prove efficiently effective to creators who wouldn't have otherwise had the capability.

@davidgriffiths3425 3 месяца назад

Thanks for your insightful and thoughtful vid Darren. Always good to hear your point of view. I'm still making my mind up but for now at least, I'm still going to be interested in the coke addiction and life lived. I guess Andy Warhol's a bit pissed off he missed all this though ;)

@musictechtuition 3 месяца назад

That's pretty much what my wife said when we were talking about this on a long car drive after I made the video. She's very much a people/stories/emotions person. But I think if I suddenly found out that "Selling England by the Pound" was actually written by a time-travelling AI, I'd not love it any less... I think Warhol would have found this extremely interesting, for sure!

@jacquibrookes8257 3 месяца назад

Great honest review,thanks......maybe end of celebrityism? Subbed

@arpaddanos9416 3 месяца назад

As long as humans are around we are going to want celebrities. So they are not going anywhere I think. This is likely going to be the exact opposite of what you proposed. This will be the end of working (part time or full time) artists who don't have the celebrity gene, but could use their talent and work to produce things of value. Those types of people will be gone, and all we will be left with is celebrities, likely often relying heavily on AI in place of artistic talent and work.

@nicksantus5307 3 месяца назад

Doesn't work well with lyrics if you use your own I found it just keeps repeating the first verse, But maybe i am not pressing the right buttons But if anyone has worked out how you get it to follow lyrics Would be great

@WhatsThisWorldComing2 3 месяца назад

its best to do it in sections depending how much lyrics...see my CHANNEL for examples of what ive made. I paste in a verse on its own or verse and chorus, thats the first 32 seconds then you just build from there in same way. adding either before or after. spend time building. If you try and add a whole song it wont do any more then the first 33seconds as it appears you are finding.

@storiesreadaloud5635 3 месяца назад

Someone definitely fed the Prodigy singles into this

@BjoernLewin 2 месяца назад

I find Udio very inspiring! :)

@ChurchoftheIgnorati 2 месяца назад

First radio play of a Udio AI song was last night on Oystermouth Radio at just after 9:15pm. The show should be repeated tonight at the same time.

@davidmacdonald6611 3 месяца назад

Do you think this type of technology will affect electronic musical instrument manufacturing?

@musictechtuition 3 месяца назад

Ultimately, yes. I would say it's a similar (but more niche) task to create something which will be a synthesizer with a suitable interface, and then you'd be able to 'program' it via text prompts. not sure if that's viable to create a real-time VST-style synth (I'd think that's much more complex as I don't think this sort of AI has the low latency needed for real-time performance), but it may be possible for 'offline' MIDI music creation. Interesting direction that's possible, for sure...

@erikhausler6858 3 месяца назад

I think You’re right to a large extent. But music isn’t so much about music - it’s about building and feeling emotional connections. Perhaps less when you’re conversating with music as a backdrop. But I believe in getting to the stage where we, as creators use ML/AI generated tracks as a starting point, as ideas and stems modifying them to taste.

@EduardsRuzga 3 месяца назад

You are right. But I was experimenting with making music based on daily topics and events. Like life journaling but in songs. And it hits hard sometimes, in ways songs based on other topics don't... What is funny about those songs they don't hit as hard for others. They are personal. Wrote an article about that on medium, sadly one can't share links on RU-vid these days.

@jablock1 3 месяца назад

I would be interested to see how people rate the AI and human generated music in a blind test.

@taucalm 3 месяца назад

In sudio you pretty much hear AI, higher pitches break the vocals.

@groovedealerfeaturing-ashl6476 3 месяца назад

I think MANY people wouldn't notice or even care as most people, apart from us saddos don't REALLY listen to music, such as coldplay fans! It seems to partly depend on the style too. All the tracks lack emotion though, although some of them are HIGHLY impressive, frighteningly so!

@nicksantus5307 3 месяца назад

so did i so i download a few, and post them as tracks, no ref to Ai, no one noticed they where AI generated and genuinely surprised when i told them

@jablock1 3 месяца назад

@@nicksantus5307 This is what I expected, because I could not hear the difference. I have seen people comment that it’s soulless but how can you say that if you can’t tell the difference.

@SarcasticTruth77 3 месяца назад

Recorded music and Pop has only been a thing for maybe a hundred years. Lots of people say how current music has devolved in to a casserole of all the old styles, dumbed down to the lowest common denominator. Well, here's the computer to do as much of that as anyone would ever want, which turns out isn't very much. The music industry has been burning out for at least a few decades now. Guess it's time to say good by. 100 seasons turns out to have been a few too many, anyway.

@wideyxyz2271 3 месяца назад

At the moment because it's beta there is a limit on song length. I think it's something you can work with rather than against. As a musician, who enjoys playing it won't take my place, and I don't make a living out of it anyway. Like all musicians, there's always someone who is better than me, so I'm not really bothered about it. Could be good for sampling ideas?

@DJBre 3 месяца назад

hugging my guitar in despair right now

@getkraken8064 3 месяца назад

I've been in rock bands and I've home recorded but I never wanted to be Elton John, I wanted to be his lyricist, Bernie Taupin. AI generated music is the perfect Elton John match to my Bernie. I can write my best lyrics and feed them into AI and with some trial and error, out comes songs that blow me away. So the game for me has just started.

@nicksantus5307 3 месяца назад

How did you get it to folow your lyrics that was the prob i had with this Once read about prompt with as much actual muical element as poss I put in the key the chords etc mid lead etc what instruments great just could not figure the sng the next verse Yeah the sounds from this one quite impressive

@realperson3341 2 месяца назад

Wow so you're a hack. Good for you!

@getkraken8064 2 месяца назад

@@realperson3341 I love it.

@eroommy 2 месяца назад

А представьте себе: приходишь в кинотеатр, а там каждый раз другой, новый, неизвестный до сих пор AI фильм с новой, каждый раз другой, неизвестной до сих пор AI музыкой. И ты живёшь в кинотеатре, боясь пропустить что-то...

@musictechtuition 2 месяца назад

Это будущее не так уж и далеко.

@DeepSound_Music 3 месяца назад

Wowwwwwwwwwwwwwwww This is mind blowing!

@redempireproductions 2 месяца назад

We've been using Udio to do a lot of cinematic audio experiments for film scene compositions, as well as some fun cover songs (some of which are on our channel) for us, the biggest thing getting in the way of some seriously great pieces of music was the control factor. Udio only lets you output at 33s at a time, with limited adjustment features that would affect the whole segment of music. Often we found that it was only a tiny section of that 33s segment that we wanted to adjust but we had to throw away the whole piece and completely regenerate. Here's our latest experiment, a cover of Avril Lavigne's 'I'm With You', which for the most part stands up......but there's definitely some disjointed bits in there that could have used some tighter finessing ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-VeGVbdZ_vFc.htmlsi=h7WmlqKFpd0kVjJj

@WhatsThisWorldComing2 3 месяца назад

live music will not be replaced by this and playing real instruments. It will impact peoples ability to learn and earn a living with real instruments as the big wealthy scumbags that make most Hollywood films and tv only care about profit not the quality of the content.

@danielpatrickswain4338 Месяц назад

That's the worry. But in the end you make them comprimises with anything artistic and you water it down. It's already been happening for ages with CGI and other things. I personally feel like Hollywood has sucked for ages because no one's willing to make a profit risk and make something unique. (When's the last time something as brilliant as Fight Club or 12 Monkeys has been made ?) I feel AI can make this even worse and humanity will be in even more desperate need for actual human development.

@commanderbristle 2 месяца назад

A lot of this older music will sound like a second reality

@squeebbb 3 месяца назад

No, it isnt over. If anything these are avenues to provide new inspiration and creativity

@jonathanparrycomposer 3 месяца назад

Thanks that was a good summary without the crappy hype elsewhere, Apart from ethical AI use in software such as SynthV, it's all just theft. These are like Apple loops, tagged and made to work together, where the creators have not been credited. Ai is incapable of original thought. I'm not intimidated by the idea of AI because it can't do what I'm doing unless it trains on me, at which point I'll sue. But what does really alarm me - and you make this point well - is that the streaming media will flooded by AI product. The solution: I think the streaming services need to give authentic artists priority (a blue tick if you like). One final more positive point - it may be that giving everyone access to creating tracks will (like amateur piano and guitar players) give them an new appreciation of what's involved. but that may be too optimistic...Thanks again for the video

@jerrymcpommes8473 2 месяца назад

I‘m a composer. And this AI will end my life. I‘m finished.

@marcdevinci893 3 месяца назад

I knew it was coming didn't expect it to be so soon. Music library licensing is instantly dead. Just like any other creative arts, artists will become curators. Your taste, knowledge, creativity will be was set you apart and sought after. Just like in image creation, people with no imagination will generate Darth Vader or Walter White [insert your favorite character]. True artists will use these tools to generate new styles and combinations. Same for music. This is v1, as it will evolve it will follow prompt even closer, will allow downloading stems, specifying, a key, BPM etc. Production won't be the issue anymore, your own imagination will be the only thing limiting you.

@skippyfast5115 3 месяца назад

Also funny is that still people are needed for now to type in what they know to create a good Ai song and it stills copy things form what is available on this digital realm

@EricKay_Scifi 3 месяца назад

I wrote a sci-fi novel, called Above Dark Waters, set in the near future, like 20 years out about AI taking over by making infinitely addictive digital content, but lol, I should have just set it in 2025! This tech is amazing. The fact the AI can make something that sticks in my mind within 1-2 minutes is amazing. ChatGPT is just boring. This is not.

@musictechtuition 3 месяца назад

Yeah, I have to admit, I've had "Paul Atrei-deez of Arrakeen, the greatest leader we've ever seen, they say that he's the Lissan-Al-Gai-eeb" stuck in my head since Friday morning when I made this...

@EricKay_Scifi 3 месяца назад

@@musictechtuition OMG right? 😁 That Broadway rendition of Dune was a banger. I immediately wished the whole thing existed.

@SanguineUmbra-cc5hj 3 месяца назад

UDIO is very good with vocal generation. And since tracks of 33 seconds are generated at a time, over the course of a long composition the melody changes a little all the time, which gives the impression that the vocalist is constantly improvising. This sounds very interesting and lively. Here is an examples of the compositions that I generated using my own lyrics: This is a ballad in the style of the band Skunk Anansie ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-To_ZpgnUaME.html And this is track in a style of Alanis Morissette ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-_hZS6l2y39w.html UDIO even could create somewhat decent progressive rock (!) ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-NuCkiDaUykE.html

@MrNrph1975 3 месяца назад

This new generator is seriously impressive. And works great as a idea generator and considering it’s only at v1 it is insane . But in the current music industry model there is no way this will replace bands and artists as the only way to make money as a musician now is through live performance. So if they add more musical control to the generative process it will become a great writing/ producing tool

@musictechtuition 3 месяца назад

I'm not sure I follow the logic though - the music business would replace artists in a heartbeat if it could do so. Yes, the only way to make money as a musician is live, but Spotify et al don't care about that in the slightest. If they could remove artist payments but keep the revenue, they'd do it tomorrow. And probably still not make a profit!

@MrNrph1975 3 месяца назад

@@musictechtuition may be but there will always be musician’s making music especially in the more live/real genres like jazz rock and metal and th industry encompasses more than a few suits in ivory towers . You have got all the software developer that would go under if this was the future of music. It will kill music for film to and games but traditional styles will keep going and adapt to use it to write great music

@DAUBSKI 3 месяца назад

Creativity is over

@WhatsThisWorldComing2 3 месяца назад

i dont think its the case. A tool in the hands of the right person creates magic.....the tech will still need creative people just less of them. Abundance in general is a good thing but just like you tube and the internet has done to regular TV it allows 90 percent of the content be complete shite.

@dezolatestation 3 месяца назад

as electronic music producer for the club /any other clients, i didn;t know how to react to this,

@1q2w3e4r5t6zism 3 месяца назад

Use this tool!

@dezolatestation 3 месяца назад

@@1q2w3e4r5t6zism yeah haha,hope it will get stem separation soon

@buckycore 3 месяца назад

I just started watching this, and you may say this later in the vid. But I think of generative A.i. as either a launching pad or even a psudo "collaboration" where the music and/or images generated by the A.I. help me come up with new creative ideas or at least little seeds that I wasn't thinking of before. But in the end it's still ME who is doing the evolution of the idea past that. It's no different than just listening or looking at something and going AH, NOW THAT'S A COOL IDEA. And then using it to make something unique inspired by it .

@taucalm 3 месяца назад

Not actually, its more like coloring colorbook. You dont need to have inspiration, you get it by pressing create and changing prompts and styles.

@NEEDSHES 3 месяца назад

@@taucalmabsolutely 💯

@buckycore 3 месяца назад

@@taucalmman, just because you don't want to use the technology doesn't mean that you are this authority as to what it can and can't do, and how it can be useful to come up with new ideas. So, are you telling me you're this genius musician that has all the ideas ever? And that Everytime you sit.down to come up with a new song you just go BLAM... masterpiece? Or that all the music that you've listened to through out your life doesnt have any subconscious effect on what you're creating and writing? That you're this one person out of 8 billion who ONLY has unique idea no one has ever come up with before. Ever? And are you saying that you'd never collaborate? And did you even read what I said in my post. So don't come at me with your closed minded, judgmental know it all attitude, man. That's just a sign of someone who is super rigged and lacks actual creativity. You don't know me. You don't know my journey, and I'd suggest you back the F*** up with your know it all-isms, Jack.

@buckycore 3 месяца назад

@@NEEDSHESman, I see you're just as closed.minded as the other guy. Ok, boomer. Have fun thinking you know how everything works.

@federicoaschieri 3 месяца назад

Certainly we take inspiration from other, real artists. But taking inspiration from a machine that does nothing but spewing out ideas that has already stolen and straightforwardly edited from other humans doesn't seem very useful. I prefer to be inspired by going directly to the source, rather than to a derivative version of it. I certainly don't need AI to compose, although I'm not a genius 😁 But hey!, everyone is free.

@adamgardner3339 3 месяца назад

There is a few, I dunno, " musical hallucinations" where it outputs lyrical gibberish, random music like sounds, or just sounds bad. Mostly at the beginning or end of the generation time. I'm unsure what causes that artifact. So yeah it matters, but you can just discard those bits.

@jhdesigner 3 месяца назад

UDIO is a new Spotify.... just not with Revenue sharing YET

@indyartmusic1142 3 месяца назад

I think from my point of view, while i have not used or tried any of these AI music generators, i would maybe give this a go for just a bit of fun? I would NEVER publish any of this on my personal streaming platform, my music is too personal and as a result, has to be written, composed and fully produced by ME to go on my platform.... It is obvious that some people like it and some don't? Whatever thoughts and opinions are out there, one thing is certain, it is not going away, so people can either have some fun with it or just simply leave it alone?

@EduardsRuzga 3 месяца назад

But it's you. What about indie game developers for example? My feeling is that these things will find it's ways in to low budget places. There will be people using it for youtube content(where copyrighted music is not used anyways) and so on.

@danielpatrickswain4338 Месяц назад

One doubt I have is will AI in the future be able to truly generate new music that can inspire an entire generation? I can't see AI music creating a future punk rock scene for example. Also what happens when musicians cant afford to make music so then AI input has nothing new for its machine learning. It just eats it's own shit until it dies? That's what will happen. Or not. Who knows. I do get that all stock and generic music will be replaced. Of course. But does AI need to be sentient properly like we are to truly lead the way in terms of music evolution. Makes me think what seperates man and machine?

@unspeakableoaf 3 месяца назад

Bit of a mixed bag among the examples. The first ones you generated sounded like KMFDM on an off-day. The jazz I hated as much as real modern jazz (it's been downhill for 80 years), so it must be accurate ;) People will still make music because they like it.

@notnoaintno5134 3 месяца назад

Did jazz even exist before the 40s? I think it was big band / rag time back then. Some of the jazz fusion from the late 70s is my fav music, theres some good contempirary stuff too

@unspeakableoaf 3 месяца назад

@@notnoaintno5134 Something recognisable as jazz and called that started around the 1920s, but its origins were at least a couple of decades before. Blues is probably around that old too as a name and recognisable style.

@vincentizghra6144 3 месяца назад

I've not been able to write a single song since AI music started to become a thing. I found it so distasteful and misguided. Musical education, practice, and creation, has been instrumental in developing so many peoples lives, mental ability, coordination and imagination. I'm curious to what effect this will have on humanity as a whole as we get less and less of these spaces that challenge us and allow us to grow. But then I started seeing it differently. Imagine when we can train AI robots to play in the NHL or NBA instead of the players, that shouldn't be too far off, maybe decades or years. It will be fun to see the what kind of world records we can have in the Olympics when we get rid of all the limitations of the human body. Sure a lot less people will probably exercise, or be inspired to exercise. Or get better at things that we might as well use AI for because it's more efficient. Will we then merely be species that wanted comfort over all?

@skippyfast5115 3 месяца назад

Stop saying People do not care about music as a lot of people DO! That's always personal

@notnoaintno5134 3 месяца назад

The flute in the barbershop example is obnoxious

@78manem 2 месяца назад

I tried to generate a song about Sarah Connor. Udio refused...

@klaurcschwackerberg1880 3 месяца назад

It's GAME OVER NOW ! and RIP music industry ! Goodbye music producers , this is the end, Nobody will ever produce and enjoy their own music anymore ! We break all the guitars at pieces , and throw our recording equipment in the trash ! IT IS OVER NOW ! AI has taken over our music ! and here is THE END ! I threw my piano this morning out of the window ! RIP music !

@cesar4729 3 месяца назад

Now put that in Udio and make a song.

@S9MusicProd 3 месяца назад

I have little doubt soon we will live in a society where human n bot creators will exist parallely, there will be no difference in quality. However, ppl will continue to create music with all the hustle cause its one of the basic form of human expression. People who are mediocre, will have little place as freelancers. Many of the creator, will go with ai , however, making music is also a very human process...you type, and you get a , lets say perfect song, i think this will not satisfy everyone, they will still prefer wasting hours discussing and crafting ideas to perfection. Lets see at which point it gets saturated.

@coldlyanalytical1351 3 месяца назад

Bingo! Pole will work with or control AI ... BUT ... only the top 10%-20% will be needed to do this. The mediocre, work shy, family types, disabled etc will be pushed out.

@N8oRMusic 3 месяца назад

"Can't wait to catch that AI band playing live" said no one, ever.

@SarcasticTruth77 3 месяца назад

Maybe, but who admires the tallent of a band that can do what anyone can do with tap tap?

@PolarTrance 3 месяца назад

@@SarcasticTruth77 Getting on the stage and miming/lip syncing to sounds isn't the same as being able to make music and perform it on your own. So if you think you can do what a band does by just "tap tap" then you're delusional. You sound like someone whose never been to a live show. Also these generations are just built upon the theft of real music made by real people, so in reality it's even less impressive than it might first appear as.

@tylercrowley4408 3 месяца назад

@@SarcasticTruth77 Many popular festival DJs are simply pressing a play button already

@wideyxyz2271 3 месяца назад

Gorillaz!

@radatabass 3 месяца назад

No one also ever said AI threatens live bands. The main threat is to recorded music, less so to live bands.

@Athari-P 3 месяца назад

I never get the exact music I want, so Udio is useful for fixing that. If I want a symphonic power metal song with flute and a guitar solo about a snow leopard, all I need is 5 hours of free time. The song is currently far from perfect, but it ticks enough checkboxes to be enjoyable. Top tier artists avoiding AI will remain, but the competition below will have no choice, I think. Eventually. Image and voice generation haven't reached that point yet. There's a lot of pushback from artists and their supporters.

@PolarTrance 3 месяца назад

If you hate being an artist, you could just browse the endless internet for the thing you want to hear, made by real artists, instead of supporting this theft and fakery. The usual artist actually enjoys making the art they make (Shocking, I know!), at most using AI as a minor tool, not as a prompt-and-done type of thing that this is. Sure there's plenty of people who have no creativity and have no interest in learning skills to achieve something and will be satisfied with AI trash. I personally just make music for fun, and share it in case someone else likes it too, why would I ever start using this, takes literally ALL of the fun out of the process of composing, arranging, playing instruments, sound design, mixing and mastering. And unlike with a real artist, there's no emotion or anything impressive; no story to be told, it's just a lifeless prompt, can't even call it art, as you need an artist for it to be art, so there's not much to enjoy as a listener. Take the human out of art, and you lose the art with it.

@Athari-P 3 месяца назад

@@PolarTrance You'll be disappointed to learn just how much creativity, emotion and story people can see in AI-generated images and music if they don't know it was heavily AI-assisted. The uniqueness of human mind doesn't exist, It's all fake. And let's not pretend that living human artists always put all of their life and soul into their creations. 99% of everything is trash. The reality is that in several years, AI will surpass 90% of artists by all metrics you can come up with. Scary? Yes. Dangerous? Yes. But declaring it all "trash", "fake" and "theft" doesn't get anywhere. One way or another, we're doomed to deal with it, so might as well start adapting. Also, please let me know if you find a symphonic power metal song with flute and a guitar solo about a snow leopard somewhere on the "endless internet".

@taucalm 3 месяца назад

Top tier artists have decades of their own style of material to wiggle with. Starting artists might have some lyrics and few sounds.

@taucalm 3 месяца назад

@@PolarTrance You seem to have no idea what you are talking about. Its not acappella artists record, its sound shaped in manyways through analog or digital plugins that enhance that little to no emotion that artists has.

@Athari-P 3 месяца назад

@@taucalm I'm sure AI will substantially change what a newbie means for a lot of professions, be it a musician or a programmer. Chess and Go players somehow survived being completely surpassed by the computer - and got much better at their game in the process. That's probably what awaits us all.

@ThreeBeingOne 3 месяца назад

Won’t sell a ticket until band takes stage.

@Soft_Touch_ 3 месяца назад

Already happened: Hatsune Miku.

@AdamTwardoch 3 месяца назад

For 40+ years, “human-made” has largely been using electronic, synthetic, digital sound creation or modification. Practically all music published today is made with the help of software. But some musicians have been using software more, others less. The majority of the world population doesn't know the time without electronically created music. Suno & Udio are just additional software tools. Some people will use them, others won't. Same as with other electronic music-making tools in the past 40 years.

@jacquibrookes8257 3 месяца назад

Crikey 😂

@eroommy 2 месяца назад

Так нам и надо!

@RebuttalRecords 2 месяца назад

I'm not a real musician but I do look like one.

@calebmorgan6939 2 месяца назад

Wow, I'm impressed for the first time. The jazz example sounded like jazz. I wonder if it can do a complete arrangement? The lyrics still seem like the dumbest thing about this tech. Always bad.

@bobbyboyderecords 2 месяца назад

The eagles are using backing tracks now for their live shows (lip-syncing), nobody cares about music to save it. Who is gonna pay for a soundtrack or piece of music now when they can just prompt this a few times and get what they want for free. Add the video AI creations and you could flood the market. Time to sell your equipment again like those synths. As robots get better I can see a nice robot BB King playing at your local pub on a wednesday night with all the feeling of the man himself. However as all jobs get removed by AI who will pay for the AI if we don't have jobs and pay no tax?

@laartwork 2 месяца назад

That's like complaining that monks are losing their jobs because of the printing press or horse shoe makers because of the car. People will find other work.

@-Deena. 3 месяца назад

I'm not worried just yet.

@Recuper8 3 месяца назад

Denial phase

@-Deena. 3 месяца назад

@@Recuper8 😁

@tomhe286 3 месяца назад

Its game over for e-artists. No need to be worried anymore, its too late for that.

@-Deena. 3 месяца назад

@@tomhe286 There is 'art' and there are nice 'convincing' tunes. When ChatGPT can do ascii imagrs that aren't hilariously bad, then I might worry. Try it. It's very amusing.

@MrMikomi 2 месяца назад

Ironically the electronic stuff to my ears sounded worse than the jazz. Buy QQQ I suppose, hand over fist.

@davidkeller8084 3 месяца назад

Ok this is cool, no doubt. All examples sound like crap, kind of like old demo tapes from the years gone by that were produced and refined into iconic hits we all love and cherish today. Who knows?

@FlamespeedyAMV 3 месяца назад

yeah it sounds like unmastered, early songs lol

@nathanbanks2354 3 месяца назад

If you use an old style, it will mimic the sound from the training data, including the old analogue recording equipment.

@urglik 3 месяца назад

Game over? Remember, right now, it's as bad as it will ever be...

@WhatsThisWorldComing2 3 месяца назад

this is the same for all content imo....it ll take awhile to get to a level that a tv program could be made using only text prompts but it will happen and the money people will love it so the current methods will just be down scaled overtime.

@theno.1idea938 3 месяца назад

I have nearly 40 hours and hundreds of tracks from Suno/Udio.. it's a lot of fun and semi-useful for "one-offs" - but the out-put is not "Production Standard" technically speaking. You'll get some good new ideas hear and there - stretches your ears - as it were.. You can't really edit the output in any regular creative way.. I would imagine these options and a non-compressed WAV master will be coming with a price tag.. Otherwise it's back to Pro-Tools or your DAW of choice after a hopeful but otherwise fruitless vacation into AI music land - that is not nearly ready for prime time.. maybe soon... With all the editing features one might associate with a pro-level DAW or at a proper studio in the big town - available with Suno/Udio etc - then it would be over - but that might be a ways off or lots of money. I don't think they want to give away the music business to a bunch of 8th graders - not just yet anyway..

@Murcatto-hu1ym 3 месяца назад

Oh, it will cost money, but looking at midjourney, chatgpt, elevenlabs and such they are all very affordable even to just mess around with a bit.

@nakologic1 3 месяца назад

The problem is that young people do not care about production or quality. They just want a "Playlist" of their favorite style with lyrics that make them think and disconnect from work. I think AI is here to stay. The world of large productions and mastering will take a backseat. In any case, I will continue to invest many hours in creating my own music, which is my hobby.

@nathanbanks2354 3 месяца назад

Most of the top rated songs on Udio right now have clever lyrics which were likely manually written. It's powerful to have people + AI.

@PolarTrance 3 месяца назад

@@nathanbanks2354 The people who tend to use these have absolutely no creativity, so it's actually very likely the lyrics were also generated. And top rated here means a bunch of drooling idiots voting on the "work" of other drooling idiots.

@user-qu2ie1hg7w 3 месяца назад

A jazz song of 15 minutes: a nightmare Coms true😂😂😂 please don’t

@klaurcschwackerberg1880 3 месяца назад

Yes it is GAME OVER for all music lovers , music producers and entire music scene ! We all stop loving making music now ! it is GAME OVER ! Burn all your guitars drums and pianos! IT IS GAME OVER !

@rede5426 3 месяца назад

Mouth dummy music for ears.

@midnightwind8067 3 месяца назад

Machines can imitate and perhaps the zombie class may drink it up, but creativity belongs to the living soul.

@Valentininia 3 месяца назад

Physics doesn’t agree with you. And biology too

@JesusChrist-vf3xd 3 месяца назад

What makes you think you have a soul

@PaweAdamowicz1981 3 месяца назад

You are just meat robot 😅

@John-il4mp 3 месяца назад

Really bad comment, there is some super good music and dont forget this will get only better you just jaleous some people can use this.

@Valentininia 3 месяца назад

@@John-il4mp not even some people, literally everyone can use it right now. It’s free

@misterguy9051 3 месяца назад

Musicians can go back to being creative now that AI is taking care of plagiarism.

@danielpatrickswain4338 Месяц назад

Sums it up well for me. I am not convinced AI is yet able to truly invent with music. Seems it is limited by its own lack of true sentience. Of course all the generic /stock music will be all done on AI and some major.produxtions for films and games I'm sure but humans will always be needed to make the music that moves it forward.

@JoexLegacy 3 месяца назад

Whoever is working on ai development should be stopped before this goes all wrong

@weltmeisterbayernmunchen6308 3 месяца назад

THIS IS FOR PEOPLE WHO CANT PLAY MUSIC!!!!!!

@musictechtuition 3 месяца назад

Quite possibly! But a lot of the work I've had previously has been those people, who want music made for them... and in the near future they'll be able to press a button, roll some dice and then get something they approximately want. Which may be good enough for them.

@danjoseph5707 3 месяца назад

Still sounds like a tin can IMO

@mickmack9333 2 месяца назад

The Jazz tracks actually show clearly that music has been stolen. Here, the trumpet sound is copied, and also, the musical expression is far too close to the old Jazz players, judging on the sound. No way Ai starts something from scretch, rebuilding this trumpet sound. This sound is original. Good time for lawyers i would say. Also Ai music will be destroyed by Ai itself. In future, everybody has got his own ai lawyer on his mobile phone and a n ai search engine checking the www if ai created music violats existing copyrights. No one talks about this yet. Furthermore, i listened to a Havard University talk and the expert made clear, Ai is pretty stupid and the prediction model of ai is rather stealing than being creative. Here u go

@danielpatrickswain4338 Месяц назад

How can I find the Harvard talk?

@loupasternak 3 месяца назад

99% of 'artists' are hacks .

@DrMax0 3 месяца назад

For me all the "impressive" examples sound like stitched together by a machine. The melodies, the harmonies make no sense. It sounds like the real thing, but if you really listen it is just mindless babble. Not impressed at all. Ok as a tool for random ideas maybe. But I do not hear compositions, just musical stuff. It sounds like music, but isn't. May be it is just me ...

@danielpatrickswain4338 Месяц назад

To me too sounds strangely all over the place. All sounds like it's running through an eerie filter.

@Wourghk 3 месяца назад

It all sounds awful, but I've heard unanimous praise for worse. Honestly, the value of a good performance was already in the bin, but this pretty much slams the lid shut.

@Valentininia 3 месяца назад

Idk what you talking about, it literally generated me a song that sounds almost exatcly like XXXtentacion. Like even the flow/instrumental

@andrewspackman 3 месяца назад

Udio is mind blowing. Creators and musicians will seriously have to rethink where the ‘value’ is for them in the future.

@moopy6446 3 месяца назад

You probably think that this sounds “awful” because you either have much higher standards for music than the general public or you are worried about this technology taking over your job. Either way, just keep in mind that this AI stuff is only going to get better. Heck, it’s been less than two years since AI had trouble generating a somewhat coherent image and now look where it is. Reality chrck

@notnoaintno5134 3 месяца назад

The lyrics dont sound like stuff a person would write for those genres. The instrumentals are weird sounding, especially the jaź soloing and the flute in the "barbershop" thing

@Stimpy77 3 месяца назад

I still *very much* prefer suno over Udio. Yes, Udio sounds pristine. But pristine output with only training on crappy alternative British rock and EDM makes for some pretty crappy tunes, sorry.