That, and watch thier faces when he hits the fry haha. Goosebumps every time and ive seen and heard it at least 500 times. Sometimes 20 times in a row watching these guys haha
@@arze1226 When you ever tried autotune..you have to sing really well to the notes, else it will sound fucked up. SO...he sang it well. I couldn't do it better..not within a million miles.
"Because, I'm not into heavy metal..." yet it was the heavy metal that brought you the full emotion including the rage and pain, that brought you to tears. This is beautiful.
Always LIKED the ORIGINAL by Simon and Garfunkel, but never paid much attention to the Lyrics. Along comes DISTURBED w David Draiman and DEMANDS me to LISTEN to the songs' MESSAGE. Music touches and changes us in an instance. Davids voice is one of those vocalist who's tone of voice touches our
@@protospace270 y, I guess that's a way of looking at it, but I haven't come across any interview where David Draiman has said those words. I have to say, I haven't listened to every interview of him...
It's called "pathos". Most artists can't do it in their own music. People who live Edgar Allan Poe performance get it. It's digging deep and pulling the guts out of the world to make people feel the spade digging your being out of the words. If you aren't ready to sign commitment papers on a Poe performer, they failed. David did this to Silence.
The reason why his voice moves people so much in this song is not simply vocal proficiency and talent, but it’s his PASSION. He sings with an immense amount of emotional intensity and he sings from the HEART. While he’s singing, he looks like he’s getting lost in the story and feels the message that’s being portrayed. When someone sings in this kind of way, it causes the listeners to feel all kinds of things!! Bravo David Draimen 💕
I've been in this rabbit hole for days and it doesn't get old watching that wow moment or multiple wow moments which this song has, but I truly loved watching your expression at the very beginning of the song the first 60 seconds it was pure excitement and then about minute 1:08 you went from excitement to wonder and amazement I literally watched your eyes light up and that was priceless, also even after many many times listening to this song I still get emotional at that same part it never fails.
I'm currently in the same rabbit hole, having just discovered David's cover a day ago. I also love to see those reactions when other people become moved by his performance. I could see the moment her eyes welled up and it was beautiful
I have fallen down the rabbit hole of watching everyone react to this. I love that every reaction is just stunned silence. Speaks volumes of how incredible this rendition is. Especially since he was sick when he did this live. You should listen to the recorded version as well.
The first time I EVER heard this song I was sobbing like my dog died. I always knew David was talented but THIS hit my heart in such an intense way I couldn't hold it. My girlfriend witnessed my first reaction and she was like "What's wrong? Babe what's wrong what happened?" I said "Oh you gotta hear this. Disturbed out did themselves." She listened and she MELTED. She started crying just as hard. 😂 David is amazing
When David adds the gravel to his voice really makes you feel the emotion of the lyric. I've heard this cover many times and I never fail to get chills.
Wow! The best live performance i have ever heard. Better than the studio version. You don't just hear his voice.. you 'feel' it. I've got goosebumps and tears in my eyes...
David Draiman comes from an orthodox Jewish family and was classically trained as a cantor. In my opinion, there is no other male vocalist alive whose voice compares with David's on this track. He gives quite simply, an amazing performance here. Serene, your reaction to this song is exactly the same as mine and probably millions of others on first hearing, and when you see how many people have checked out the official video, you can see how popular this version is around the world. Apparently, Paul Simon loves this version too, and that's a hell of a compliment.
Both of those are practically must-see videos for any reaction channel. Also both bands have large dedicated armies of fans and both songs are ones that fans and non-fans alike actively seek out because they are epic songs that evoke powerful reactions. GLS goes a bit long, but even though I'm not really a NW fan, I gotta say it is well worth the slow burn. ;) There are two official live videos with exactly the same title, but fans prefer the Wacken one with 4x the views. Personally I find the earlier one incredibly charming when the lead guitarist is fanboying over the new singer at the end, but you'll get a ton of people saying you did the wrong one if you do that one. And pro tip: when you see the girl looking like she's having a religious experience at 8m 27s do any comments you want then let the rest play out. ;) Pisces is different - it says it is a live session but the live session was to record the drummer, still worth doing but plan to follow up later with a concert performance if you don't hate it and the fans will give you plenty of suggestions. Or you could cut to the chase with Perennial live at Wacken but you'll miss a lot of views and there is a twist that will be spoiled if you don't do Pisces first. };D>
you might think so, but then there is Henk Poort ^^ ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-q_BJaM-UrXc.html the richnes of his voice is on a whole other level than Davids. and he learned to use distortion just a few hours ago. as an opera singer, he never did that before.
People can cover this all they want David controls his magnificent voice better than anyone I've ever ever heard.. Period one of a kind superbly trained vocalist. He can hear notes we can't.
David was classically trained prior to going to Heavy Metal. He's well known for his raspy sound, not as well known for his classical training...until now. I love watching reaction videos to this track because it has ushered in a new era of Disturbed's music. They have a couple other touching tracks you might want to check out. 'A Reason to Fight' has an important message to it, strongly recommend that one, both the live and music video versions are important in their own way. Another good one would be 'Hold on to Memories' Enjoyed your reaction :) this is the first I've seen your channel
After this performance, Paul Simon himself messaged David and said "It's your song now." I can't imagine higher praise than that. Disturbed did for this song what Johnny Cash did for Nine Inch Nail's "Hurt."
Absolutely true! You could actually FEEL Johnny Cash's actual and personal 'Hurt' when he sang it. Have you listened to David singing 'Hold On To Memories'? The official edition may be a be 'off putting' to some but I believe it blends with the lyrics quite well.
I absolutely agree. I think Sounds was written for David.. He explained it's true meaning through his performance.. Just like Johnny did for Hurt. I didn't much like the Nin version.. For me, they belittled what they were singing about... There's so much more to music than just singing or playing an instrument etc... There HAS to be emotion invested in it, you have to pass that on through the music, otherwise it's just an empty vessel. Like a lot of the music has become these days.. A means to make money.. Me personally? I like to connect with, and feel the music.. With Johnny, His investment in that song was pure. he's telling a story of his experience with it..
No, Paul did not message him and say that "It's your song now". So many people spreading this misinformation. Paul sent this "Really powerful performance on Conan the other day. First time I’d seen you do it live. Nice. Thanks.” To which David replied back “I am honored beyond words. We only hoped to pay homage and honor the brilliance of one of the greatest songwriters of all time. Your compliment means the world to me/us, and we are eternally grateful.”
@@JuanHughJorgan I watched an interview with David where he said that is exactly what Paul said to him. And since he was the one who actually conversed with him, I'll take his account over yours any day.
@@riffgroove It's easier to just do your research, instead of believing what you want just because. Link to video source for proof? I'll wait. What I posted is the entire email between the two and it was on Disturb's website.
I can see from your playlist that you have not found Floor Jansen or Nightwish. Do yourself and your subscribers a huge favor and listen to anything by Floor from Beste Zangers 2019 or Nightwish, Wacken 2013. I guarantee that you will not only love it but they will become your new favorites.
I fourth the motion - MOTION CARRIED. Floor Jansen and Nightwish - Ghost Love Score. She is one of the most talented singers (male or female) on the planet, and the band is the best band that you have never heard of. I warn you though, it is a rabbit hole - if you listen to one song, you are instantly addicted and must listen to all of them. I DARE YOU TO LISTEN TO IT :D Ghost Love Score, Live at Wacken. PEACE
One thing I absolutely adore about the live version is the very end when he holds "soooooooouuuuuuuuund..." Then pauses and let's that echo hit... Man it's perfect.
I agree with almost every comment here. It's true because I've seen it happen over and over, when people hear David sing, they are mesmerized! when I heard David sing this song, I fell in love with him within 30 seconds
And I'm even more in love with him 6 months later!! There's something so commanding about him, his power and charisma force people to open up their minds and hearts to the message he's delivering! Disturbed is 2nd to none!!
The studio performance is so much more intense. If you enjoyed this, you should watch that version along with the music video. You can hear so much more of what's going on in his voice and it hits you even more. I'm willing to bet you would really enjoy that one too.
Having listened to the studio version first and then seeing this performance, I LOVE how much he really dug into the "praaaaayyyed" at 4:56 - It almost felt like fanservice to fans of the studio version.
I'm a 67yr old man (with a manly beard), walking through HomeDepot, getting materials for an electrical job...and I'm trying to hold back the flood of tears from flowing. Such a very thoughtful andl beautiful rendering of this song.
I’ve listened to close to one hundred reactions of this version. Even after 25-50-75 etc listens, (yours right now), I cry every time. I’m a 56 yo Army vet but also a musician. His version just speaks to my soul. I wish Disturbed had more songs really show casing his beautiful voice.
You need to be introduced to one of the most versatile women in metal right now. The classically trained Floor Jansen turns anything to gold that she touches. She is the current lead singer for the "Symphonic Metal" band Nightwish. Please check out Nightwish - Ghost Love Score(live in Wacken 2013) Link: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-JYjIlHWBAVo.html
The band he's in is metal, but David is a classically trained opera singer. His ability to go between clear vocals and the grit without hurting his voice is something special. This performance is something that people should never forget. It's truly special. The tears start to fall because of the lyrics of the song, there is something about the emotion he throws into the 2nd half of the performance with the grit that just speaks to your soul.
Late to the party. I grew up with the music from the 60s and 70s thanks to my parents. I am horrible listening and hearing lyrics to songs. Simon and Garfunkel have wrote some of the greatest songs in the 20th century. I love the sound and harmonies from them. Disturbs version of sound of silence actually let me hear and understand the lyrics. The way they put this together and just spread what this song is all about is amazing. It is my dad's favorite song and he loves the original song.
His voice has the ability to not only bring a song to life, but he makes you FEEL the lyrics. Almost like he his begging you to listen and its an overwhelming thing so it touches you to the core. His voice plays beautiful to this version.
From the simple crescendo of the orchestra to the different styles of voicing and use of his skilled voice the fact this song has soo many elements that were assembled perfectly... with a voice on loan from God this has to be one of the finest covers ever created... I think more people have covered Disturbed-The Sound of Silence than Simon and whats his name LOL... very nice insights and thanks for the thoughtful review. see you soon as you tube algorithms allow... lol (new sub...)
It took a classically trained voice to pull this off, plus an understanding of the angst, loneliness and anger the lyrics demand of its expression. It doesn't get much better than this.
When Mr. David Draiman sings, that is when your ears sit up and beg you to hear more, he has the kind of voice that creeps up on you, and that's when the tears start. David has this special touch in his voice. You hear the song and you feel every note that he is singing, it buries itself into your brain in a kind way, it touches the maternal/paternal feelings that you have for a new-born baby in your head. It's a voice that you love or hate. I was around when Simon and Garfunkel first sang this song way back in 1965 when I was 14, I am now 4 months away from my 71st birthday, what can I say, I am a music lover, I appreciate good music, I listen to all things music, from Mozart to Adele, Vivaldi to Status Quo, my record collection starts in the 1940's and heads up into the 2010's.
There's a moment in this song, a little different for everyone, but a moment where you have stopped listening to it and have begun to experience it. Incredible vocals.
I do have a metal band recommendation, or rather symphonic metal, which is an amazing genre of mixing metal music with elements of orchestral classical music together. Nightwish - Ghost Love Score live at Waken 2013. Just to warn you if you do the Nightwish army will decend upon you, lol! They are a bunch of nice but very passionate fans
Too late. ;) The army has arrived and look to be about 90% of the comments here. :D Everyone's suggesting Ghost Love Score @ Wacken 2013 (as they should), but I'd also add The Phantom of the Opera (Marko & Tarja) - another brilliant performance that shouldn't be forgotten.
He began young as classically trained ..and he uses that to completely bring the song..the message to a new life for a new time. He is absolutely 💯 amazing. I have been listening to Disturbed since they came out..im older(46) I'm a biker ..a father.. this cover is the most prevalent showcase of David's mastery of vocals.. he is angel & demon in one and I can never hear it enough..goosebumps every single time..and it's been hundreds
The original was a warning. This version seemed more of a condemnation. I think this arrangement gave the lyrics the gravity that the original couldn't as a folk song.
Want to be blown away by this all over again? Watch the official video for this song and watch David's face as he sings. My eyes leak every time, snot bubbles and everything.
You should do a reaction to Nightwish - Ghost Love Score (live at Wacken 2013). You will find out that not every metal subgenre is just loud mess :) (warning: your mind might be blown)
It's the intent and the power that he has behind that part of his voice the emotion he puts there I've seen him alive 13 times and they are just like that
Ms. Serene, love your reaction to this amazing rendition of S & G's original hit. This song has special meaning to me because the first time I heard it, I was on my way to the hospital to see my mother, who the doctors had informed us 2 hours earlier, had 3-6 months to live... That was over 6 years ago. I can't listen to it without tears welling up... I love this version! I would love to see your reaction and your thoughts on Shinedown's, "Simple Man".
The clarity of the singing is unmatched anywhere in rock music. The build and impact of the music and lyrics is in such amazing sync that if you’re paying attention at all, you can’t help but be affected.
The "Gritty" part of his voice is how David normally sings. "Down With the Sickness" is a song you should listen to. Make sure you hear the whole thing, some versions edit out a key part of the song.
The pan-out at the end of the song was amazingly well-timed! It did a constant zoom-out, yet hit all the key framings just as they were needed. The first tampini was fully in pic just as it was hit, the second tampini was in pic just as it was hit. The left guitar just got in frame for his last lick. And the zooming ended the very moment the song ended into an epic end framing. That is a cinematography feat well beyond what you would normally see on TV.
I saw this comment somewhere and I agree a 1000%: The original conveys the message in desperation to be heard. This conveys the message angrily, no one heard him.. and now he roars.
I wish I could go back in time and listen to this song for the first time. When I first heard it, I was driving in the car with the radio down, and I just wish I could have given myself the experience that this song deserves. I love watching people like yourself, Serene, listening to this for that precious first time.
He captures the lyrics....When a artist with his talent manage to connect to the emotions a writer intended.....this is what happens. It hits you in a special place.
I am in love with this version of the timeless song. I fully believe there will never be a better rendition ever of this song than what disturbed created. Pure genius. Pure admiration of David in this song. Not a fan of his other music but will have ever lasting love for this 1 specific song that he sung.
