Тёмный

Voidfall vs Fractal Beyond the Void- which one is for you? comparison 

EZBoardGames
Подписаться 1,7 тыс.
Просмотров 3,1 тыс.
50% 1

Hi players!
In this video I'll do a comparison between Voidfall and Fractal: Beyond the Void. Hopefully by the end of the video you'll know which one is for you, or should you have both of them in your collection.
I'll just add that I haven't tried the single mode for Fractal or its campaign mode, so that's the reason I haven't mentioned this in the video itself.
Enjoy and happy gaming,
Asaf
0:00 Intro
1:01 Fractal overview
6:47 Voidfall overview
9:52 Setup time
13:41 Learning the game
16:36 Gameplay
19:23 eXploring aspect
22:22 eXploit aspect
23:38 eXpand and eXterminate aspects
24:32 Combat system
26:12 Material quality
30:29 Replayability
32:30 So which one?!
33:55 Should I keep both?

Игры

Опубликовано:

 

25 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 89   
@hendrickstrauss3311
@hendrickstrauss3311 6 месяцев назад
It's a wonderful video, and I agree with all your points. Incidentally, the combat first and art style second is the reason I personally went with Fractal. Now the game must just show up, haha.
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 6 месяцев назад
Hey Hendrick! Thank you very much I'm glad you liked it 😊, Crossing fingers Fractal will arrive to you as soon as possible! 🤞🏽🤞🏽 Please share with me your thoughts after your first game(s) 😊
@jhow1323
@jhow1323 29 дней назад
Great video! Really helpful structure and well articulated description of the differences between the two
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 29 дней назад
Thank you! I'm very happy you found it helpful 😊
@17thknight
@17thknight 6 месяцев назад
Great video, great information. Thank you so much for doing this.
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 6 месяцев назад
The pleasure is all mine 😊 Once I have a few more games and explore Fractal more I'll do a review for Fractal aswell, since I feel there's much more than meets the eye in this one..
@brykhousegames2189
@brykhousegames2189 5 месяцев назад
Great video, loved it!
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
Thank you! Very happy you enjoyed 😊
@Robert_Bryson
@Robert_Bryson 6 месяцев назад
Omg ty for this video I have voidfall was looking to get factual also
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 6 месяцев назад
Sure thing Robert! And what did you decide? Are you going to have both?
@iMann_iFail
@iMann_iFail 5 месяцев назад
I played my first 4 player campaign of Fractal beyond the void yesterday though it was only two cycles not four. I’ve played and own the Galactic edition of Voidfall. Both games I’ve enjoy playing but they play soo different, both share a simple battle mechanic, admittedly in Fractal I did enjoy the ability of upgrading tactic cards and revealing them with each phase. There’s definitely more to think about with Fractal, as it’s too easy to deplete your actions, thus occurring an influence cost at the end of the cycle, which could hinder you there after. Credits are incredibly important as they dictate how actions you can take compared to other players, more credit, more advantage. Where Voidfall, you always produce resources dictated by the amount of factories you have in place, so if you’re running low.. you have that ability for additional income. Setting up a Voidfall isn’t much of an issue, once you’ve played it a couple of times, you’ll recognise symbols, etc.. so laying out maps will be easy. It only takes time when players are sitting there discussing what map they want to play haha
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
The more I play Fractal, the more I understand that both of them are Indeed very different. Although I do understand why people would like to see a comparison between the two of them. I'm not sure I agree that there's more to think about in Fractal because I found myself thinking more in Voidfall trying to optimize the whole Cycle and maybe actually the whole game :) In Voidfall almost every action takes out resources, so if you haven't invested in your Guilds, you won't have a lot of resources. But that depends on your house as well.. As someone who already played Voidfall more than a few times I have to say that maybe the setup is getting less annoying, but it's probably the game with the longest setup in my collection. You still need to bring out the right sectors (need to check both sides), need to find the right broken houses, the right Starting Agenda cards, the right technologies... I mean come on haha it's not the easiest :) But I appreciate the comment and I'm always up for a discussion and finding out what others might think so thank you for this 😊
@TheMadzharov
@TheMadzharov 5 месяцев назад
The best comparison video I've ever watched. In your opinion is Fractal better than Empires of the Void 2?
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
Oh wow!! Thank you for the compliment ❤ To be honest I wanted to include Empires of the Void 2 aswell but didn't want the video to be too long. It is a tough question. I think I'd prefer Fractal for the cleaner and better designed. Rulebook is better is Empires. Gameplay..... I'd have to play Empires again to be certain. Can I get back to you on that..? 😅😊
@TheMadzharov
@TheMadzharov 5 месяцев назад
Absolutely I am looking forward to it. When I saw Fractal it was love from first sight 😂, however I bought the Empires of the Void 2 several months ago but unfortunately didn't have time so far to play it. And now I am wondering is it even worth it to invest time and money in Fractal if there is no big difference.. anyway I will be happy to hear your comparison between those 2. Cheers and keep up with the great videos you make.
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
I think that Fractal will give you a bigger experience. The different modes, the campaign etc.. But unless it's urgent for you, I'd suggest to wait with Fractal. In my opinion the second hand market prices will go down. Just my estimation 😊
@Grindfrank
@Grindfrank 5 месяцев назад
Just started playing Voidfall and I’m really trying to optimize how far you can advance on the map, mainly to close rifts. I find that invading at least one sector in cycle one to be primordial. After that it’s up to one two or three invasion per cycle. Not easy to expand that quick without loosing sectors along the way. Brilliant game. A real brain blender 😊
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
Ohhh I totally agree with you! I'd say that each game will depend on your house and the technology that is being offered. Some games require a blitz every time you can, other games you just need to go on strong economy. But in general, I try to invade atleast one sector and secure the others. Glad you liked the game! It's in my top 5 for 2023 (two videos ago I mentioned it..) Are you playing Voidfall only solo? What did you think of the competitive game?
@Grindfrank
@Grindfrank 5 месяцев назад
Only solo for the moment. I’ve been looking for an epic solo 3.5x space experience for a while. This is just perfect 👍
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
@@Grindfrank I agree.. What did you think of the new Kickstarter of E.V.E?
@Tolbiakful
@Tolbiakful 5 месяцев назад
Very useful video, i ended up taking Fractals because of the art and its rapidity to play/setup. I still haven't tested it tho.
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
I think that the first or even second time you'll do setup or play it will take more time than you expect. But the learning curve is smoother here even if you need to check the rules from time to time. I suggest for you to try with the smaller map rather than the large one. If there's anything I can help with while you play- feel free to drop a comment or contact me via Facebook 😊
@jacquesriahi8660
@jacquesriahi8660 6 месяцев назад
almost baught voidfall . I need to check the full video!
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 6 месяцев назад
Sure thing 😊 You're more than welcome to come over and play any one of these games 😉
@MikeMcCraith
@MikeMcCraith 6 месяцев назад
Not to tell you what to do, but you should buy the game 😂😂😂
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 6 месяцев назад
Lol!! Always on point Mike 😍😍
@clanechelon
@clanechelon 5 месяцев назад
I was interested in both of these games, but I already own Uprising and March of the ants (thanks to your channel). I try to keep my collection in check as much as possible. Is there anything mindblowing about either of these game to justify a slot in a limited collection in your opinion?
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
First of all, I'm very happy to hear that you liked my recommendations! 😊 My collection will never pass the 100 games. The more I play Voidfall and Fractal, the more I get that they are VERY different. Now, if you're more into crunchy games Euro style- take Voidfall. I absolutely LOVE this game. About Fractal, I haven't played it enough inorder to recommend one way or the other.
@clanechelon
@clanechelon 5 месяцев назад
@@ezbgames interesting! Given the playtime seems similar to uprising, would you choose voidfal to tablel over uprising?
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
Wow.. that's a tough question.. It really depends on the mood 😅 Oh my god this is tough! I'll go with Voidfall just because this is what I'm feeling now, but I got to say that's a really tough call
@clanechelon
@clanechelon 5 месяцев назад
@@ezbgames :o interesting. I was not expecting that
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
Ah yes..? Tell me what did you think I will choose..? 😊
@Biodelic
@Biodelic 6 месяцев назад
What a monumental video and analysis. Excellent job. In general l, I would agree to an overwhelming degree with your assessments. Personally, I found Voidfall to be very intuitive, once the very basics are understood. When questions arose and the documentations had to be referenced, the outcome was mostly one of confirmation of interpretation and less of clarification or explanation. This gives a tremendous boost to confidence and motivation. Fractal was very different for me. I found the rulebook and they way it was written to be suboptimal and not very intuitive. Still today, after more then 15 games, I still get hung up on rules and the iconography (which I really dislike). The more I play Fractal I wonder if it's turns / rounds structure has been shortened at a later point of development. It feels to me that it was to go longer in its initial design. In regard to combat, I am at a point where I don't understand combat in Voidfall as such. It is more the direct, depicted product of all the factors that lead up to it. Therefore the deterministic nature and not a combat per se. In the end they are both great games and will be fixed installments in my collection but Voidfall wins, for me, hands down.
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 6 месяцев назад
Oh my God yes! We totally agree.. Word for word it's what I think aswell for the things you've added. Cool!! I just feel that Fractal has the potential to be better than what it is for me right now. Just that integrating the different modes is always something that is very challenging for me. It's like I prefer to learn more rules in the beginning and not adding them later on.. you know what I mean? 😅
@Biodelic
@Biodelic 6 месяцев назад
@@ezbgames I am with you entirely in regard to implementing modes and modules at a later point. Especially when they don't become a fixed static element, as for example in a campaign setting. Modules that can be added or left out as desired, I find to be difficult elements for me personally. It's either all of them or none of them. Both in regard to learning but also playing. I am not good at establishing modules as individual entities (and all the impacts and effects that result from adding or leaving out) in my head and have them readily available from memory. At some point I just want to be done with the rulebook and enjoy the flow of the game and not being forced to look up and reference some specific thing that isn't a fixture but a possible variable within my regular gameplay. Of course this is a highly personal preference and I am sure other people don't struggle in that regard. I do and that is a lesson I had learn the hard way. Now modes are less problematic to me in the above regard although they come with problems of their own. For one, developers should generally stick to less and do that really well. More modes usually impact the quality and refinement of some of them / all of them and it is a horrible experience to come from a well working, fun mode just to find yourself in a mess with the next one. Fun usually is the first victim. Again, personal opinion. I will take 20 hours of an immersive, excellent campaign for 300€ any day over mediocre, repetitive 100 hours for 200€.
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 6 месяцев назад
Couldn't have said better myself.. 100% agree!! I wish creators will work more like that. I will do the effort with the modules that I find best, but after that I'm done and whatever modules that didn't "enter" this game at that point will probably stay forever outside. And that will ve the game for me. I will give it a chance and hope it will not be too much. Super happy to have this discussion 😊
@gamer6172
@gamer6172 6 месяцев назад
i think in voidfall it is not a live combat, but it feels like a "conquest action". But for me it feels like a combat, but a very planed one. Especially the technologies feels very thematic in my opinion and most of them do what you can imagine (shields for example)
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 6 месяцев назад
Yeah, I mean because in Voidfall you can see the outcome of the battle before you do the Invade action, it feels a bit less of a combat than in Fractal. I love tue technologies in Voidfall but also I like how the technologies integrate with the Tactic cards in Fractal. I think that I will always prefer a bit of unknown when entering a combat (which feels more real) than the deterministic system
@wholesumfunable
@wholesumfunable 6 месяцев назад
You should try the "Deep Space" module for Fractal which supposedly improves the "eXploring" in the game. It actually makes gaps in the board that you need to fill with hexes and deep space events when you explore them.
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 6 месяцев назад
I'll absolutely try it and actually super excited to discover this mode. If this actually works it will be an amazing improvement! I remember seeing also a module for Empires of the Void 2 that actually makes the eXploration part very exciting and thinking "why it wasn't just integrated as the base game?" Lol So definitely I will try it and later I will do a serious review for this game. As I said, Fractal came to me just recently so I still have much to explore in it. Thank you so much for this comment! 😊😊
@wholesumfunable
@wholesumfunable 6 месяцев назад
@@ezbgamesHopefully the mode is enjoyable! I'm very interested in seeing how much "Deep Space" and the other 10 or so modules improve Fractal. I've had the game for two months now, and have played 11 games, but I feel like I'm still just scratching the surface (I'm 2 scenarios into the campaign and I haven't tried the Automata or any modules yet). Thank you for your coverage of the game. I've enjoyed hearing your thoughts about it.
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 6 месяцев назад
I agree that Fractal has many options! Just sometimes I wished games would already integrate more modules to the base game. Every time adding more modules and adding more rules can be a bit tiring. But I think Fractal has a lot of potential! I'm setting up a 4 player game as we speak haha I'm realy flattered that you enjoyed it. It means the world to me 🤩
@alanmccappin3901
@alanmccappin3901 6 месяцев назад
First of all an excellent video helping demonstrate the differences between the two, I do feel fractal's KS campaign suffered from being in voidfall's shadow despite being a completely different game. I was actually going to mention the deep modules too but someone beat me to it. Also I guess the modules do increase the replayability of the game so would be a plus in that category. I believe the campaign has some map variations too which I guess could be utilised in future non-campaign games. I suppose one thing you could do is shuffle some of the variable tiles and put them face down so you dont know exactly what they might be. Re: learning the game, one beauty of is if you have played root, ti4, eclipse and Kemet (as in all 4) you will be able to pick up the game mechanics pretty quickly. However its biggest hurdle is learning the card and faction interactions in certain circumstances. Thankfully a lot of the answers are on the discord and a few fan made errata guides have helped resolve some of the issues as they have arisen.
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 6 месяцев назад
Thanks for the comment Alan! Yes I agree you can put the sectors face down, which is something that is possible in Empires of the Void 2. Not sure why not to integrate it already in the base game. Would have made more sense to me in the 4X category. Also, as weitten before, I prefer a heavier game to begin with rather than a game that you put a lot of modules into it. But that's totally a personal preference becauae it's harder for me to add new sets of rules. I do think that with time Fractal will see my table more and more- it has a lot of potential! I wasn't around yet when Fractal and Voidfall's campaigns were live. I got both through the pledge manager. You might be right.. it makes a lot of sense. I will continue playing Fractal and after I explore more aspects of it, I'll try to do a serious review. Thanks a lot for this comment! I absolutely love the discussions in our community 😊
@binarysun_
@binarysun_ 6 месяцев назад
Voidfall setup is the b*tch. I just takes so long and You have to still read so many details about your custom setup that when I am done I feel like I have already played the game and I am ready to pack the game up again. 😅 I usually set it up the night before I want to play. That said I don’t play the game nearly enough because setup is a real obstacle. The big advantage (like you said) of Mindclash games is that it does not need any text and once you know the icons it’s mostly a no-brained. Also the more custom setup will make for a high replay value in the long run if you don’t give up before because of the setup
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 6 месяцев назад
Yeah, the setup is... rough!! I do exactly like you the night before lol! So happy to know I'm not the only one 🤣
@johncorrigan268
@johncorrigan268 6 месяцев назад
What were your thoughts on Tsukuyumi?
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 6 месяцев назад
In all honesty I haven't gotten to it yet.. I just found a good trade (I gave Perseverance deluxe edition and received Tsukuyumi All In). But I'll get to it very soon and I'm super curious about it. You have it aswell?
@johncorrigan268
@johncorrigan268 5 месяцев назад
Yes. I have only played it once and really enjoyed it. Don't see any coverage of it and feel it is a game that deserves more attention.
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
@@johncorrigan268 I'm on it my friend. I have a few small projects to finish and then I'll dive right in. It's a promise I should have kept a long time ago .
@CristianoErre-sh8kh
@CristianoErre-sh8kh Месяц назад
can You Give Us a ranking list of 4x games that You mantioned?
@ezbgames
@ezbgames Месяц назад
There's an older video where I'm talking about 4X games, but in any case I will do another one very soon 😊
@TheShapingSickness
@TheShapingSickness 5 месяцев назад
If void fall is meant to be complex and fractal is meant to be streamlined, can we say both excel at achieving the intended goal?
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
I wish I could say that, but the problem.is that the rules in Fractal are not allowing it. I found myself going many times to the rulebook in Fractal looking for answers for things that are suppose to be more intuitive/easy to understand. That actually makes Voidfall more complex but easier to understand, if that makes sense 😅 I do feel that a better rulebook and a better player aid would have made Fractal much more streamlined.
@TheShapingSickness
@TheShapingSickness 5 месяцев назад
@@ezbgames that makes sense. I got fractal last week, but I think today I might have a chance to play it and I'm a bit nervous because some parts could be easy to forget.
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
Please let me know what did you think of it. I'm very curious! 😊
@Thesussysuscat
@Thesussysuscat 5 месяцев назад
So what one do you vote for? I own both havnt played either but im leaning toward fractal I think
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
Haha good question.. The more I play, the more I understand how different they are. For now, since the time difference between the two gameplays is not different, I'll go for Voidfall
@Selfreplyingbot
@Selfreplyingbot 5 месяцев назад
Don’t get me wrong but the expression „much more“ don’t exist in English no ?
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
You mean "doesn't exist"..? I don't know to be honest. I'll let you find out and keep me posted 😇 I hope at least you enjoyed the rest of the video
@MikeMcCraith
@MikeMcCraith 6 месяцев назад
It's like this video was made for me! Stop reading my mind! Ahhahha
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 6 месяцев назад
🤣🤣 Rule #1 know your audience 😜
@MikeMcCraith
@MikeMcCraith 6 месяцев назад
​@@ezbgames 😂😂😂
@MikeMcCraith
@MikeMcCraith 6 месяцев назад
I completely agree about the need for the rulebook during the play for Voidfall. I was super intimidated by the game, but after the tutorial, I only needed the rules once to play the first competitive game. Super intuitive.
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 6 месяцев назад
Yes!!! Exactly that.. I think that writing a rulebook is an art of its own
@somerandomperson8282
@somerandomperson8282 6 месяцев назад
I really like your content and I have subscribed. I have not played Fractal yet (will do soon) but I have played Voidfall and I really did not like it. Voidfall is overly complex with all of the iconography and rules and just feels soulless and lacking in character, I feel it's a game for Euro fans and number crunchers. I just didn't find it fun or exciting.
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 6 месяцев назад
Hello! First of all, thank you so much for joining the EZ community and welcome aboard! I think Voidfall is exciting in a way that you have a limited amount of turns and you have to make the absolutely best out of it! But I also get why other might not like it. I actually feels that Voidfall is not as complex as it might seem in the beginning. Yes, there is a steep lurning curve, but once you get it with the help of a video or two- it gets much easier! Please let me know what did you think of Fractal after you've played it 😊😊
@djtarquin
@djtarquin 5 месяцев назад
Fractal has so many edge rule cases, it was so hard to play.
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
Yes! 100% agree.. Jumping many times to the rules :/
@Intacta1
@Intacta1 5 месяцев назад
Fractal being played quicker than Voidfall? I can't agree with that. 4p Voidfall is around 3 - 3&1/2 hours. Our first 4p Fractal game was 6 hours, but we checked the rulebook a lot, so I can imagine cutting it down by 2 hours, but it's definatelly not a quicker game to play :)
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
It sounds like you played with my group our first game of Fractal!! 🤣🤣 I think that Voidfall at 3.5 hours is a good time for 4 players. I think that Fractal, after a few games will be less than 3 hours. It's all a question of how well you know the rules. And with Fractal it's going to be a tough mission. But try to remember your first Voidfall game.. for sure it was more than 4 hours! In Fractal you have less choices, and rounds are suppose to be quicker. I will be happy to review my review in a few weeks again 😅
@Intacta1
@Intacta1 5 месяцев назад
@@ezbgames Voidfall is usually around 45 minutes a player now. Our first 3 player game was 3h15m after watching tutorial video. For Fractal we will definatelly play the compact map in 3-4 players :)
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
Then you play a lot faster than our group. I find 45 minutes per player in Voidfall to be very quick. That's an average of 3 minutes per card. It's cool! I'm a bit jealous.. In Fractal we played the large map for 4 players. Yeah.. it took a while but I think because of slow(er) players than usual and because we looked a lot in the rules.
@Intacta1
@Intacta1 5 месяцев назад
@@ezbgamesIt all depends on the players. I have quite a lot of people around to play these games with. With some it's faster, but I have some AP guys around as well :) They can make the game really long.
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 5 месяцев назад
Yeah, I hear you 🤣
@Hahahahaaahaahaa
@Hahahahaaahaahaa 4 месяца назад
The actual gameplay is so unrelated that it's funny to even compare them. They are both in space, and the comparisons stop there.
@ezbgames
@ezbgames 4 месяца назад
Well, I'm not at all in disagreement with you.. But I had some requests and also that was kind of the 'thing' because both of them came out +/- at the same time so it was like 'what should I get'? But to the question "should I have them both in the collection" I think that there is some room to sort of compare (or maybe another word that I just can find due to my poor English) and ask 'which one would suit me better'. What do you think? 😊
Далее
Fractal Beyond the Void- how to play
45:13
Просмотров 6 тыс.
LISA - ROCKSTAR (MV Teaser)
00:10
Просмотров 2 млн
TOP 10 Board Games RUINED by ONE thing!!!
13:03
Просмотров 2,8 тыс.
Top 10 Solo Boardgames 2023 - Not Bored Gaming
39:40
Просмотров 16 тыс.
Voidfall Review: 4X Marks the Spot - with Jeff
24:25
10 Games you can play forever
34:51
Просмотров 129 тыс.
Last Light Review: A Cannaday Keeps The Downtime Away
26:57
NOT STOPPING TIL NEW WORLD RECORD
9:44:46
Просмотров 2,4 млн
СТРИМ ► Elden Ring - Shadow of the Erdtree #4
5:55:46