Hi Sir i bought your book Punjab bloodied partitioned and cleansed in punjabi. i can say you did lots of hard work to collect all the valuable date. I want to give you thanks for that.i never read a book before but you and your book turned me into books.i first saw you in aftab iqbal’s show and now i try you watch all your videos on youtube. My mums dad came from jaranwala so my mum is more interested in this book then me. Sir please do more podcast with shakil chaudhary.
The partition of Punjab and Bengal was a human tragedy, so much of human blood was shed . Why the leaders of those days couldn’t foresee it ?? Were they blind or what they achieved worth it ??
Thank you very much Sir for this invaluable historic information. Being a student of science, I'm getting interest to learn partition history from your lectures and book on Jinnah. I bought that book from Park Street, Kolkata last year.
My grandparents moved from Rasul Pur Village in Ferozpur to Kasur district. Since my childhood, I have heard many life stories from my grand maa and always thought about how difficult it was for them to leave a place to leave their fatherland forever. May their soul rest in peace.
once again such a tragic vlog and sometimes we new generations believe that nobody wanted partition but only british and muslim leaders. but sir you didn’t mentioned about the role of American Army in indian subcontinent during those days because once i saw a vlog where someone was also telling that there were american troops also in india who were helping british
All in all, partition was unavoidable, but such madness where everybody became a killer should not have happened. Even worse than that, what is tragic is that Hindus and Muslims who remained in harmony for centuries became, more or less, permanent enemies of each other. Recent provocative statements from some Muslims from Bangladesh are indicative of that inborn animosity. Is there a solution to that, now or in future, probably NOT. My grandfather used to be a cloth broker in Delhi and used to host Muslim merchants from erstwhile Afghanistan as well as now Pakistan and spoke of friendly nature of Muslims who were his clients.
Not to put any pressure on your shoulders respectfully 'Sir', always wanted to ask you would ever be interested in doing specific research or even a book on the partition of Bengal as in Punjab. I know research requires a resources and access. I know you are getting on now with age which I hope keeps your great self healthy and with us to a 100. Albeit this is why I don't know 😢 whether you'll ever be able to take up this project. This is a genuine "greek tragedy" for me since i enjoyed greatly you style of writing. Thanks
I am working on the partition of Bengal but the source material is not as vast as on Punjab. For example, I could not find original documents on the arguments put before the Bengal Boundary Commission. Only Joya Mukherjee has written an article about it and that is all.
A request. Is it possible to find the original written memorandum in full submitted to Boundary Commission by ML, Congress and Sikh sides. I searched through Internet but all that was found are the individual report of the members of the Commission and the final Award itself.
sir i want you make a video how and why in 1937 India and myanmar divided because we all know 1947 partition but only some people know before 1947 one partition already happen so please make a video
Gora line draw karey ga Indo/Pak fauj. ...Indo/Pak politicians will dance to their tune.....They are doing this up to this day. Not an inch has been changed after the orders of the gora Saab.
Sir Aap Se Ek Sawal hai Bharat ka partition mein Punjab aur Bangal ka bantwara hua Punjab Mein 8 lakh log Mare Gaye to Bangal mein kitne log Mare Gaye yah Bangal mein Khoon kharaba kam hua kya Bangal Mein kam log Mare Gaye
اسلام علیکم سر! میرا ایک سوال ہے کہ پاکستان کی پہلی قانون ساز اسمبلی جس کے 69 ممبران تھے ان کی تقسیم کس طرح سے ہوئی تھی کیونکہ 1945-1946 میں جو الیکشن ہوے وہ مرکزی اسمبلی کے لئے 102 نشستوں کے لئے ہو ئے تھے اور مسلم لیگ نے سرف 30 ارکان تھے جو الیکشن بھی جیتے تھے بس اس بات کی سمجھ نہیں آتی کہ 69 نمبر ہمارے حصہ میں کس طرح سے آئے....... سر میں کالج لیول پر ہسٹری پڑھاتا ہوں مجھے اس سوال کا جواب سیکھنا ہے... شکریہ
The 69 members of the Pakistan Constituent Assembly were those who had been elected to the Constituent Assembly of India but now they belonged to areas which were given to Pakistan. As a result Congress Hindu members of East Bengal were also members of the Pakistan Constituent Assembly. They left however because in 1948 and again in 1950 they were attacked in East Pakistan and more than 10 thousand were killed.
Respected sir, The problem with Pakistan or Bangladesh is religion. They have adopted step religion, same as step father.. Religion is making them voilent and poor. Bangladeshi or Pakistani were hindu, return home don't become Somalia. Step religion is heading towards Somalia. Jay bharat.
