We Team Up Against You! | Commander Clash S15 E30 

Loved this idea! Your contrasting playstyles create this hilarious sort of decision paralysis that wouldn't exist in a normal game

Everyone roasting Seth on the way he zooms in on cards for like a microsecond, but shuffles his virtual hand endlessly has to be my favourite moment 😂

Even more bickering than usual 😂😂😂

This idea is absolutely amazing, but I think it would be even funnier if next time each person was assigned a specific color to add to the deck, so everyone knows EXACTLY who to blame or thank for any specific choice lol

The calls in this game were insane, from card draws to opponents plays, you guys called them all

Fun concept. Hope to see it again next season

Love this concept! wouldn't mind seeing some more multi-man one deck action across more MTG content

The mana tithe was the only thing they agreed on lol

Idk how many times y’all can do this sort of content, but this was one of my favorite videos mtggoldfish has put out in the many years I’ve been watching. The clashing of playstyles and game philosophies to make interesting content as well as just generally decent gameplay was just peak mtggoldfish content to me

Remind me to not give tomer nuclear launch codes with how often he said “wrath the board now!”

I appreciate Tomer emphasizing reading the cards so viewers like me who don't know most cards by heart can know what's going on lol

I'm 5 minutes in so far and im already loving the "old married couple" energy of the crew.

As a mana tithe apologist, that was incredibly satisfying.

Phil is actually the best at looking at cards for the viewers.

Please do this again. This was insanely fun to watch. Keep up the great work guys

*One turn from dying* Richard: "We can just pass"

This is a great format. Not only do we hear more of your tactical thoughts but it gives you a way to play with patrons and encourage more people to join.

This is so interesting to hear your decisions, play patterns, and the reasoning behind them clashing together ! I want more of that ! You're all so experienced in this format, this is gold :)

This is such a hilarious concept

You guys have such contrasting opinions on almost everything that this could never be anything but chaos and I am here for it. Great episode 🤣

The bickering on this episode is unparalleled to any other 😂

i love this format!! it’d be so cool if you guys did a collab w 3 other channels doing the exact same concept, all playing each other. each channel will post their own POV taking part of this challenge

I recently had another idea for collaborative deck building: Each player picks their own commander, but the other three players each pick 33 cards to put in the deck. (Duplicates are replaced with basic lands)

I really enjoy this style of video in conjunction with theoretical analyses. We get to learn so much more about everyone’s thoughts, especially Richard’s, when it’s in the middle of an actual game. Please do more of this!!!

18 minutes in and I've never heard the word "Farewell" so much in my life. Yep, it's the mtggoldfish crew 🤣

this was really fun, please do this again. i really enjoyed hearing you guys argue about which play to make, and "who added this card!?"

Great idea. Too funny seeing yas fight over what to do even more than usual. Probably not something to do too often but definitely again at some point. Also agreed that it was a pretty darn good example of why some land hate or disruption is becoming necessary as soon as you hit a reasonable power level.

An excellent concept, both in the deck building and the co-op playstyle. It was also hilarious to watch because of all the bickering. More please!

Funny how Richard has become the bigger troll than Crim with his takes

Just want to give a shoutout to Crims joke "I though this was MODO not Arena, when sefris goes into the arena part of the dungeon. Kudos, you got a snort from me.

I don’t think Richard knows that farewell doesn’t hit planeswalkers

Great Video! Was so cool to see the crew bounce different Ideas off themselves and come up with different lines of play, very entertaining!

I loved this, so I'm really hoping you do this format again sometime (hopefully not too far off). This Commander Clash had me enthralled in a way that many others don't.

This was awesome! Love hearing y'all debate different plays :)

This was fun and a great idea! I feel like those cardmarket guys have rubbed off on you a little bit. I also feel like this was a therapy session for the group like those work retreats where they make co-workers play trust games. I'd love to see more attempts and try splitting the responsibilities in different ways: maybe each builds a color, or each person gets a card type, or mana amount like Crim 0-2, Seth 3-4, Tomer 5-6, Richard 7+ etc, or each person gets a creature type. There could be a lot of interesting ways to explore collaborative deck building. Also take turns on who controls the game, I want to see what happens when it's Crim's turn!

This is actually really interesting. There are two very different playstyles here and its cool to see those come into play

I'm less than 10 minutes into this game and it's already my favorite. More hydra pilot games.

This is super fun and entertaining. It's great to see everyone has a different play style even pivoting the same deck. I feel like Tomer's plan will lead us killed sooner. Richard and Crim played safe but ended up with better value. I also agree with Crim we don't have to cast spells every single turn. It is okay to hold back.

More of these in the future please! This was awesome to see

Definitely revisit this concept! It was super fun to watch and think about.

this might be one of my favourite episodes so far. really enjoyed watching this one and hope you do this sometime soon again! would also be fun to see you play like this against random MTGO opponents instead of patreons/viewers, to see you guys go up against people outside of your own meta.

The concept of this episode is hilarious! Great job! Is there a way we can vote on the next commander of the deck you guys play at the same time?

Favorite video so far. Hilarious and fun to see everyone contribute and bounce ideas back and forth while piloting a single deck.

That sound Richard makes at 34:13 killed me

This was incredibly fun to watch lol. Like a podcast episode mixed with a clash episode.

I loved this concept! Listening to you guys debate what to play on each turn was hilarious! Great insight into how you guys play as well. I hope you revisit this idea.

There is nothing funnier than watching 4 grown friends bicker over hyperspecific lines of play that probably affect win percentage by decimals. Great episode, please bring this back next season boys

Interesting idea, I really love that once you se a card we exactly knew who added it hahahahaha

This was fun! Commander co-op would be an awesome series on its own, in addition to clash. Maybe rotate 2 man crews and each does 50 cards. :D

It's nice seeing there different playing styles come up against each other

This is what i imagine piloting the super megazord would be like 😂😂 great episode guys! Definitely find other 4 headed giants to play against in a pod!

This is probably my favorite thing you guys have put out please make this a series

This was BRILLIANT! But my only comments are a) I didn’t understand the title until I clicked and b) I wish I saw the banter in the beginning. More banter would be great. We listen to podcasts about you guys, we love the commentary before the game starts

I like this game. It reminds me of a collaboration with a team while going too a ptq. Well done gentleman.

This episode is amazingly fun! Please do this more often 😊

We need a return of this sometime. So much fun to watch

Commander by way of committee is such a good idea! 😂

"They would time walk us into another realm" and "We would get emotionally isekai'd" 😂😂

This is the best episode yet 😂 I hope this becomes a returning theme!

Such a neat concept! I like this idea!

I would love to see this concept again!

This concept is great, it was entertaining to watch would love to see a couple of these a season moving forward.

This was really cool to see you all talking about the decisions!

This was so fun to watch! I'd love more games like this

Amazing idea for a video! Amazing execution with the banter between the crew over plays to make! Loved this! There a way we could get the deck lists for the viewer player decks? Would love to see what kind of shenanigans the crew was up against

You guys should do this again! This was extremely fun

This is so fun! Sounds like the inside of my head 😂

This was super fun to see your guys ideas clash, you should do this again for a podcast episode or something

I must say, running Temple of the False God in a 4 colour deck with under 40 lands is a really interesting choice. I sneak it into some decks, it's a lot of fun to Crop Rotation into a Temple and go off because your Crop Rotation was mana positive! Recursion is a thing I often neglect, but if it's in your colours (and your win cons are permanents) Mythos of Brokkos is pretty cool, I usually try to build decks that have more than one way to win (to the point where my decks sometimes have too many win cons and not enough actual cards), but some ideas just require recursion effects because they lack redundancy.

I would watch, "Crim and Richard Win By Doing Absolutely Nothing." That sounds like a great show.

This was a fantastic idea. I would watch every episode if this kept going.

Awesome concept hope to see it again!!

I know this was probably a TON of work to put together, but real talk, I would watch one of these every week before I watched the regular commander game lol Also it makes me think it's just one very ingenious person doing fun things before we have "twitch plays commander" against random mtgo opponents, which I'd probably also make room in my schedule to watch lol

Idk who’s idea this was, but it was amazing. Please more please.

I'd love to see more games with patrons, good content

I saw the thumbnail, then a member of my discord mentioned they were in this game, so i had to come back in and watch. Edit: OMG there were so many good moments in this game. I did not expect him to shift from Maze's End to Meathook victory. Crazy.

I agree with everything Richard said in this video

20:25 the immediate consensus is hilarious

Very different video. Would love more like this to come :)

I really enjoyed this episode! I hope you'll do something similar in the future. Maybe you can structure it so that everyone has some free picks and some role picks, for stuff like ramp, card draw, and lands.

Very entertaining. Seems like the most words per minute spoken of any game on the channel too. Fun idea for sure, I think you should do it more.

So... we learned that Crim, Richard, and Seth can work together really well and compromise to serve the best interests of the team, while Tomer is incapable of working with others and will drag everyone around him down throwing a tantrum when he doesn't get his way. Neat.

Very neat episode. This was amazing content. Being able to hear each of your opinions in the moment of all of the different options available was really neay. I think next time you guys should collaborate a little better to make a functional deck. Nice job!

More of this please! So fun

This was absolutely amazing and hilarious. Please do this more! 🙏

I'd love to see more of this madness 😂

Fun concept, what if you did something similar where you all build a deck together and then do a 4-way mirror match with that same deck?

Only 15 minutes in and already loving the new format

This was chaos from the word go and I love it

Every game of command needs to be 4 headed Giant. You never finish a game, but it’d be fun to watch.

You guys should do this again but everyone plays on a different turn cycle

19:55 Tomer always so scared

This took less than one minute to get hilarious 🤣 Great video idea

This was an amazing idea for an episode.

I really like the hive mind idea - would prefer a 2,2, 2 guest, 2 guest if possible. Though it would probably make the editor explode

I wanna see them all pilot a Control deck next time just to confirm Crim always has Counterspells and Cyclonic Rift in his hand.

Atraxa reveals all of the top 10 cards of their library, not just the ones they took. You have to check the game log to see which ones they actually chose. You guys thought they had an Ulamog all game, but they revealed it alongside Tiller Engine and Crucible, both of which they then played. (EDIT: Y'all finally figured it out.)

This is somewhere between Three-Headed dragon meme and the boat crash meme.

Great episode, fresh idea, more of this!

I'm getting vibes similar to when the three fates drive the taxi in Percy Jackson while sharing only one eye. Very specific reference - but it feels apt.