What are the Pros and Cons of The Deckorators Voyage Line? 

They are comparable to a traditional WPC and less springy than PVC. As always, 12" framing is best if you're sensitive to sponginess.

Everything scratches. Some easier than others. Deckorators performs fairly well compared to other companies and PVCs...but there certainly are more scratch resistance options if you're willing to forgo some of the other benefits!

Thanks for the feedback! If you're concerned about the large dogs leaving their mark, then of all the options you listed, Trex Transcend would be your best bet. It's more durable than the others. Now you may be giving things up, like traction, thermal stability, warranty, etc by doing that - but if scratch resistance is #1 on the list, then Transcend performs well there. NOW THAT SAID. EVERYTHING SCRATCHES. Nobody warranties scratching, and eventually they will all get some scratches. Just the time, amount, and severity will be less on more durable boards. Redwood would not be a great option as it's a soft lumber that scratches quite easily - HOWEVER, you do at least have the option of sanding it down and making it look new again every few years. But keep in mind, it's the one that's most likely to scratch early and often, so it's only going to look new for a short time. Trex Transcend, Fiberon Promenade, or VEKA Deck all boast fairly good scratch resistance. Good luck with the search!

@@TheUltimateDeckShop, thank you *SO* much for your detailed response! Someone pointed out to us the composite decking gets hotter than wood. We used a device to test the composite samples in different colors and a piece of bare wood. We discovered that it is indeed true that the composite gets quite a bit hotter and we've decided to go with redwood. Our dogs are out outside a lot and our deck is fairly big, so, that was the deal breaker. Dogs rule in our house. 😂 Thank you again, you are knowledgeable and nice. *ADDED:* We are ordering the B heart grade redwood, is that a good choice?

@@justmyopinion2 You're welcome and glad it's been helpful! Redwood is not a common product in our area so while we are familiar with its characteristics, I can speak to what to expect with the different grades. Sorry!

​@@TheUltimateDeckShop how about the Tanzite Stonedecks, any reviews with that product?

They do on their primary lines, NOT on box store exclusive lines. 25 year removal and replacement warranty. And no, the warranty doesn't care who installs it as long as it's installed in accordance with their installation instructions.

For composite, probably Trex Transcend line. For PVC, VEKA and Clubhouse are very scratch resistant.

It definitely is a little harder on saw blades than the WPC or PVC options are.

No. Same warranty, same MBC makeup. There are 2 differences... 1. Voyage has a linear grain pattern, Vault has a Cathedral style grain pattern. 2. Voyage has "enhanced traction" so it's a 10/10 for traction, while Vault would be like an 8/10. Aside from different colour options, that's the only difference.

@@TheUltimateDeckShop that’s very helpful, thank you for your quick response!

Sorry for type oooos

Deckorators doesn't perform any better or worse than comparable products with regards to heat. A heat gun will also help with minor scratches in Deckorators.

We don't have any real world experience with it... just at trade shows. Seems to be a very strong board, but at least up until current, only solid colour boards with no variagation. Most who have used it, like it.

@@TheUltimateDeckShop thank you for the reply. I have a customer asking about it and I don’t have any experience with it.

How did your lawsuit turn out?

Sounds like you've had a bad experience. I would submit a warranty claim. The issues you've described on these last 3 comments are not typical from what we have seen over the past 4 years as a dealer.

I did file. We are still battling because they won't send a technician to install a 20 foot board. They want me to find someone for $25!! I can't get someone in the 9th grade to cut my lawn for $25.@@TheUltimateDeckShop

We'll agree to disagree. Deckorators is one of the most consistent dimensioned boards out there. While we have seen up to 1/16" variances in rare cases, it's much better than the 1/8" variances that we seem to see from Trex, Fiberon, and TimberTech and in much more common occurrence - especially Trex. It's also not any "extra money". The lines are all comparably priced.