What Happens If You Fail the Jedi Trials? 

oh no, not the farmers!

that's like seeing your friend still in school where you teach at

Imagine being able to spell. It’s useful if you don’t want to end up mopping temple floors. 😜

@@Garrett.1111 Apologies, not a native speaker

@@skyearl1816 I’m sure I couldn’t spell at all in your native language so you’re all good, bro. 😉

Do or do not. There is no try.

Not everyone can be Jedi also I was playing Star Wars Galaxy Of Heroes they have a Non-Alinged Force User category which I found interesting

I was wondering about that myself. I'm watching Attack of the Clones right now and Anakin's complaining that Obi-Wan doesn't think he's ready for the Trials. I thought "Well, why not just let him try? If he fails, he'll get to try again, and it might humble him a little." But I guess there are no second chances in the Jedi Order!

Also weren't there two random guys dressed in red that showed up with Qui-Gon and Obi piloting their red cruiser ship at the start of The Phantom Menace? I thought I heard they were part of the Jedi Diplomatic Corps and I imagine they could have been those in charge of overseeing maintenance and administration. Also there were regular soldiers with guns and red uniform who were present inside the temple in Battlefront 2 and I think ep.III called temple guards but I don't know where they fell in the Jedi hierarchy or if failed apprentices were part of the group.

@@lazyc0mmander277 The ship crew I think worked directly for the Republic, i could be wrong though. Most of the material I've read refers to the ship as belonging to the Republic itself rather than the Jedi Order.

@@the_corvid97 Thanks, I think you're right. Though when you think about it, it's kinda dumb that the Jedi don't have at least some of their own people working those jobs. You'd think politic, diplomatic negotiations and competent administration would be complex enough to make this important.

Sidious: It's Free Real Estate

We haven’t seen the Empire clone once, so I’ve no idea where you got the idea they’re disastrous at it. If you mean Palpatine, it’s near impossible to clone force sensitives, and if you mean Mandalorian, those aren’t clones.

Well as far as droid soldiers are concerned, the security droids and dark troopers did seem to be improvements already so the empire was possibly staying up to date in that department. But the quality of those droids never was the real strength of the Confederacy. It was rather found in their abilities for mass droid productions, autonomous warmachines like spider or vulture droids and high-end hyperspecialized units like the magnaguards, droidekas, assassins and tactical droids; none of which I think were part of the imperial's military focuses. Although, one kind of droid that was still heavily used were the non-combatant kind so those probably kept being upgraded. And I imagine this would be the situation the remnants would find themselves in as well. So relying on mechanical security forces could only happen if they had or gained access to one that already existed. Otherwise they would have needed control of enough production capabilities with the ability to quickly reassign their production to droid manufacturing; something I don't think a decimated army would possess let alone prioritize over any of their other needs. Anyway these are my guesses. Though this makes me wonder the what would be the situation of the other galactic organizations' armies they were warring with at the time. I also have my own ideas about that but I'll hold them for an other time as this reply is more than long enough already.

I feel pretty confident that you can attempt the trials more than once. Failing means that you do not CURRENTLY have the balance, wisdom and skill to be a Jedi knight, but that is no reason to think that further learning, practice and meditation could not fix it. I suspect Service Corps reassignment tends to happen when you've failed three or four times, and your master has a talk with you about how maybe your talents lean in other directions.

@@zcorpalpha2462 That's messed up. And they wonder why the Jedi Order was never that big to begin with, but then again, they almost forcibly take children from their parents to train and make them there own anyway.

It’s expensive

As seen in The Mandalorian, Beskar is very rare and Mandalorian guard it jealously. It was expensive and difficult to find for just one individual, equipping an entire army would be impossible outside Mandalorian rule and culture

Only Sith deal in absolutes.

I totally agree. A show about a jedi healer would be so interesting. Or about a crechemaster or the battlemaster. Or yeah the agricorps seeing them working with the living force and providing aid to people around the galaxy. Seeing how they still use the force in their lives and likely have a deeper connection to the force than most knights. And likely the most exciting the explorer corps - travelling the unknown regions, discovering artifacts and ancient sites - kinda like doctor aphra. Could introduce feemor I think he was part of that corps. Plus any of these could be set at an earlier time in the timeline.

Yeah that would be interesting

WTF HAHAH NO IDIOT

I think that's the reason why Obi-Wan entrusted Luke to Owen lol Owen and Anakin didn't have a strong bond so Anakin has no reason to return to visit him This keeps Luke safe

Using that same logic, why did owen take luke in, since he would have no obligation to do so?

@@E.L.Tigre32 that's a good question actually I think Owen and Beru just wanted to do the right thing Maybe they and Obi-Wan knew that Luke didn't have anywhere else to go I'm actually not sure