What if Anakin Beat Obi-Wan and Palpatine Beat Yoda - Star Wars Theory 

I really think Padme would have changed him back, I don't think Anakin as Vader would of put up with Palpatine manipulating his children that long.

Haven't finished the video but this just made me think. What if to Yoda won against Palpatine and Obi Wan lost to Anakin. Would Anakin go further into the Darkside to replace Palpatine or would he have turned back to the light given that his master had passed and he didn't have the knowledge to save Padme? Would Yoda try to restore the Jedi order and hunt Anakin down for all he's done? So many possibilities which I think would make a great video

Vader was so powerful in the OT, but imagine if he hadn't been restricted by his suit; he would be unbeatable!

I think Anakin will always be the most powerful, especially at full potential, not even the twins could rival him

Anakin's suffering is like a fixated point in reality. He has to suffer for the better of the galaxy it feels, it is very sad.

It'd be interesting if we get to see the Skywalker family becoming a Sith family.

Anakin: I am going to end this, once and for all! Mace Windu’s ghost: 😡😡😡😡😡

To this day this video is probably the best if not THE best piece of written fan lore I've ever or will ever see. Outplays every disney lore and just is overall accurate

What if: order 66 was executed before grievous died? Would obi wan and grievous fight side by side?

I don't think Palpatine would've still been alive by the time Luke and Leia were teens and old enough to be trained. Anakin would've ended up being far stronger then Palpatine and would've ended up betraying him far earlier then this. I say the betrayal would've been around at the latest ten years after Palpatine became emperor, or right when Anakin first sees Palpatine manipulating Luke and Leia. I also don't really think Anakin would be a tyrant per say, there wouldn't really be a need for it since with Anakin not burned the Empire would more stable. But please do a part 2.

What If: Kit Fisto was sent to fight Grievous (the Jedi Council knew Fisto had held his ground against Grievous before), leaving Obi Wan on Coruscant who would then take Fisto’s place beside Mace Windu during the arrest of Palpatine. Or Fisto could fail to kill Grievous as Grievous may decide to have the droids around the platform fire at Fisto, most likely killing him. Fisto may also think more strategically than Obiwan did and wait until Grievous is more alone before engaging. The amount of possibilities are extreme.

This fanfic was really interesting, with Palpatine manipulating Luke and Leia, and how Anakin felt hurt with Vader unleashing his anger against Sidious. If there will be a part 2, I can't wait for it

Theory: what if Anakin tracked down the darksaber, killed the Jedi who wielded it, and made the darksaber crystal bleed as his "rite of passage" to become a Sith Lord? I can't think of a more prolific saber to use for this purpose.

You should definitely do a part two. My thoughts would be Padme would be the difference. Qui gyn obi wan or Yoda couldn’t have been talking with her about what has happened so far. And her love for Anakin and the kids would be what the differences to break the cycle and eventually bring everybody back to the light

This is brilliant! The Vader-Senate-Padme-kids dynamic is so gut wrenching. Hoping for a part 2

This video was FIRE! Super entertaining, but I am stoked with how far your audio/visual production has come, the quality is tremendous! A part 2 would be amazing to see.

We're SO used to Luke and Leia being good, that this....was really disturbing O_o Well done! We need part 2!

Anakin should go back to Padme and together they should get in contact with Bail Organa and start the Rebellion. I think Anakin should go into a deep meditation much like Yoda did and hear the voice of Qui Gon Jinn for guidance so that Anakin can hear the will of the force and fulfil his destiny as the chosen one using both the light and dark side to become the Avatar for the forces will.

I love how obi wan and anakin never finish a fight with one another until obi wan dies. You can see this when obi wan took anakin's limbs but never killed him or how in kenobi series vader leaves or obi wan scurries away. When vader finally swung his crimson blood red lightsaber into him. There was no Body, no trophy. How anticlimactic their end is. Such long battles, injuries all for... a robe and a lightsaber. How the force consumed him how anger swallowed him.

You have such passion for this. Bravo.

The way this came full circle was amazing Seeing anikan in windus place and luke and leia in anikans place was just wow

Great to see you back theory. It sucks that things health wise have been sucky. I’ve been having health stuff too. Excited for a new video as always!

Part 2 please! Wonderful job man! Always enjoy your fan fictions!

Loved it! I would definitely love a pt 2. These always brighten my day and get me thinking. Great job man!

Suggestion: Do a part two where vader apologizes to his children and explains the game he had witnessed and after a long conversation they team up and overthrow sidious and bring back the jedi order to the galaxy. Padmé should escape to naboo and luke leia and anakin should find her and they will rule the galaxy as jedi the way once padmé knew anakin.

The narration you showed during this video was phenomenal theroy! You have come a long way since I began watching you around 6 years ago now back in 2016, keep up the good work mate!

Bro, your acting is so good, your impressions of Sidious or Anakin are so on good! And the stories you are telling, it really feels as canon. Idk if you have kids, but if yes, they must have the best bedtime stories ever :) Even tho I'm 27 years old I feel like that kid listening to it before the sleep :D Keep'em coming brother, great job!

You’re really so excellent at every part of this! Writing it, the voice acting…. You’re really fantastic

With a good chunk of the what-ifs? you give us, I feel like they sometimes end just as they're starting to REALLY get good but this one, this one feels like it ended on a perfect note. I love these kinds of videos, they make you think. Thanks.

What if general grievous survived and escaped Utapau before order 66?

Oh my holy god. This was the best fan fiction I have ever seen. I love how it made Vader remeber that when he killed Mace and Dooku, he was in the exact same situation as his kids are in right now and that really played on his emotions. I would love a part 2. Great job Theory!

One of your greatest fan fictions yet! Really enjoyed it!

I wish there was a star wars what if series with all your theories

I love this it gives me the chills. If the story does continue Anakin should go to Padme

Continue this was really good, I usually don't like the what if's but this was good. Keep killing it.

Your videos are incredible. I have watched them for like 3 years now. I watch them every single time I eat or clean or anything. Thank you for taking the time to make them and may the force be with you

I would greatly enjoy the part 2 long version of this story! It’s so easy to listen to you and lose myself in the story you are telling! Thank you!👏👍❤️👋

Best “what if” yet. Loved it

Your Palpatine and Anakin impressions are so good man.

Dude your thumbnails are absolute gold! Good work!

This was awesome. Yes, I would enjoy a part 2. What if? Ahsoka comes in after all these years to help Anakin come back to the light side? And Ahsoka could take Luke and Leia's lightsabers like she did the inquisitors and turn the blades White, and she and Anakin both take on Palpatine

I love how literally any fancfiction, no matter how outlandish or stupid (like what if anikin liked sand) have a better story than the sequels...

Wow dude, this was so interesting, good job, this is definitely the best Fan Fic you’ve done.

What if Darth Sidious and the Jedi who confronted him decided to get high on death sticks instead of fighting and resolved their differences peacefully?

I mean if it keeps going like this and his kids replace him as he leaves. We gotta remember that Anakin/ Vader still has help on his side without his kids. Ashoka is still alive and also maul is still alive as seen in rebels and cal is also out there

This was incredibly well done. I am in awe.

Loved this one! Please do a part 2!

This was so awesome, but dark at the same time! I love it! Good Job!

What if Obi-Wan followed more in Qui Gon's footsteps by focusing on the Living Force and being a better surrogate parent to Anakin by going back to rescue his mother, but never gaining a seat on the Jedi Council as a result?

It’s so cool how you got to play as yoda in extra missions in the revenge of the sith game too.

It's amazing how well you nail Anakin with the voice acting as a mirror to Hayden in ROTS

Please make a part 2! This was such a masterpiece!

so excited for this one man, growing up I always asked the question what would happen and how would the galaxy be in Anakin won and didn’t get injured.. So many things would be different.

Your voice acting continues to impress. Specifically with palpating. Well done.

I swear you have the best fan fics i can literally see it visually in my mind

This channel deserve way more love

I don't know about this one anakin would never let Palpetine live after Padme gives birth Anakin knows Palpetine would be a threat to Padme, Luke and leia, he would kill the emperor moment he had a chance. Also Padme other than Luke and leia is Anakin main driving force to the light side she wouldn't just give up on anakin she would try to turn Anakin back to the light side to the very end no matter what. Just like in canon even on her death bed Padme whole heartedly believed there was good in him which in the end she was right Anakin love for padme allowed his children to turn him back.

I have a few theory ideas: What if Anakin and Obi-Wan killed General Grievous in the Courasant space battle in Revenge of the Sith? What if Jar Jar Binks never existed? What if the Rebels won the Battle of Hoth? What if Anakin pressed the stop button in the elevator?

The voices are soooo good in this!

Another great video! You've always put effort into your content, but I can tell you've always been passionate about the "what-if's" and it shows! I also appreciate the emphasis on narration and sound effects, since my job requires staring at a computer screen and by the end of the day, I usually end up listening to old time radio on RU-vid to give my eyes a break. Keep up the great work! And are you planning on a part 2 to "What if Palpatine visited Yoda on Dagobah?" I'm still wondering years later how that will turn out!

I would love a part two. This is incredible.

For a part 2 I dont think Padme would even speak with Anakin with how Luke and Leia are becoming I think one way to write part 2 would be Anakin is kinda falling down the rabbit hole with this realisation, knowing he is truly trapped and this is where a twist could happen, knowing a shred of Anakin is left in Vader a apparition appears in the corner of Anakins eye, at first he ignores it thinking its yet another manipulation from Sidious, he almost becomes distracted on missions with his Children, eventually he finally looks and sees to his astonishment the force ghost of Qui-Gon Jinn. Through this shock Vader let's his guard down and for the first time in years Anakin resurfaces but still there is some frustration in his voice "why did you abandon me!" He could say to the apparition. Qui-Gon looks at Anakin calmly and almost like how a father looks at his son. He tells Anakin that although all seems lost his destiny is not yet complete, there is a way to win back Padme, save Luke and Leia from themselves and finally end this nightmare, trust in the force, let it be your guide. At this point we can take one of 2 paths, path one in his arrogance Anakin rushes Palpatine only for that to be a trigger for his children who cut him down and forwarding Palpatines plans ensnearing the family forever in the trappings of the Dark side. Or path two Anakin realising this is his only chance continues on these missions with Luke and Leia whilst finding ways to win them over to his side finally becoming the father they needed and sowing seeds of doubt in their minds as to their true purpose. He can then open up to Padme admitting he was wrong and is trying everything he can to fix this. With this and a few more months of guidance from Qui-Gons spirit Anakin can then confront Sidious and no longer slaves to his will Luke and Leia with some hesitation come to the aid of their father putting and end to Sidious and bringing balance to the force.

Bro this was absolutely fantastic! I missed these! Bring on part 2! LFG!

Brilliant story telling, thank you as always!

Dude that was some awesome story, yes indeed please make a part 2. Disney should hire you to write story's

Thanks!

Your Vader and palpatine voice is immaculate

The impressions are spot-on. I love it!

Great job Theory! Loved it. I'd love to have you do part 2 with Anakin/Vader at 2x Sidious god mode & how you think that fight would go. Considering that's way more powerful than anything we've ever seen in SW, the force powers he would use could be insane. I'd love to see the Skywalker family come out of this with their god tier father leading the way. Maybe he institutes a new republic & let's the wheels of the senate TURN.

At what point in this story would have Vader become more powerful than Sidious? I feel like by the time Anakin finally turns on Sidious he would have been at least able to put up a damn good fight if not outright win. Think about how much more powerful he became simply between AoTC and RoTS.

My goodness, your voice acting and your mic quality is out of this world! I love it!

Love your fanfictions keep them coming and deffo want a part 2!!

I don’t think I can live in this world without a part 2!!! 😩 this was so good! What if in part 2, Vader Chooses to not act with his emotions and fall back into his life pattern, instead he force pushes everyone in the room and makes a run for it and escapes to a distant planet to meditate like the Jedi would, and while he does that, He turns into anakin and hears the voice and sees the force ghost of master qui gon, and has a long discussion on his life and the force. Yoda could also appear and they could both give they’re advice and guidance. While this is happening, Sidious is sending Luke and leia on more missions, this time to hunt down their father. But some time in between the hunting, Luke and leia get a chance to speak to Padme and she helps Luke and Leia see the truth about the manipulation and that causes a shift in Luke and leia. Sidious feels this and is furious that luke and leia show signs of weakness, so Sidious goes to kill padme to punish Luke and leia for doubting him, and this is when they try and stop Sidious but are no match against the emperor, until anakin shows up and helps bring balance to force by killing sidious and saving his children and wife. That’s my very basic plot idea for episode 2, obviously you can go a lot more in depth with the details, but I think this could be a cool idea, but I think the ending could have a cool plot twist where it turns out date maul is still alive and since he never died to obi wan in this time line, I reckon he could have an apprentice that could be a threat. But yeh that’s it lol

Can you do a part 2? I wanna see what Anakin would do next. Literally anything could happen.

This was really good... you have a gift..I usually watch your videos enjoy them and wait for the next, but this time I really wanted you to know how talented and gifted your are sir...thoroughly enjoyed

Definitely make a part 2; that was great. And I honestly didn’t predict it going in that direction. Always incredible writing/imagination Theory!!!

WE NEED PART 2!! I think Anakin will goto Padme and tell her about whats happening. He drops to his knees in tears as ANAKIN realises what he has done and what he has become. Padme will see that the person she thought she lost is starting to come back. From there I'm not really sure. Padme and Anakin will team up and try to get their kids to turn to the light side, but Palps would've twisted their minds so they stand before Palpatine against even their parents. They may start to battle, Vader shows he is more powerful than everyone there combined which Palpatine uses against him. Padme will get injured, which Anakin then gets fuelled with rage. "Don't you see? Palpatine has been manipulating your mind as he once did with mine. This is wrong!" From there there are a few things that can happen, but I think it should result in Luke and Leia turning against Palpatine where the galaxy is returned to peace and freedom. P.S. Thank you Theory!!

Funny how you mentioned LOE, and I just started Brotherhood today, and so far it's awesome. Thanks for the content. Always hungry for more theory content. At first I thought it said what if Anakin beat Obi-wan, and Yoda put down Palpatine. Which would also make for an interesting theory.

As always, wonderful video!

Bro these videos are actually the best always so interesting and they make me so happy when a new upload comes around they aren't common but when he does a theory its so awesome

I love how you described the fight scene if anikin had won especially sending Obi’s body into the lava 😂. Love it . I think leía would turn to the dark side due to her being jealous of the fact that Luke would be favored over her by palpatine simply because he was male and physically superior to her . I think she would kill palpatine by stabbing him in the back and she would go against her own father anikin and he would allow her to kill him and then Luke would kill leía with furious anger and be the only Sith Lord alive, with a single mother . But I love this story from the video as well . Please make a part 2.

What if Obi Wan killed during The Battle over Corusant would be a good story. I also think it hasn't been done before.

This was amazing. We definitely need part 2

Dude this is amazing!!! I love this dark twist!

What if darth maul’s plan worked and he lured anakin and obi wan to mandalore in the clone wars? Would maul have been able to kill them like he planned? Or would they have finally killed maul for good? This would make an excellent fan fiction

I remember the live stream when you put this in your notes. You should make what if obi wan ans yoda both won and every commination of someone winning and someone losing.

Dude, that was excellent. Really enjoyed that.

WOOOW that was great! Good job man!

It seems to me that Padme now becomes Vader's source for redemption. He is seen that he has been manipulated and had his children turn on him. So he needs to play the game in a way to bring his children full circle back to him. Sideous would end up killing off Padme which leads to Vader and his redemption and his children returning to his side.

Wow! I would love to see how Anakin gets out of this mess. This felt like five minutes instead of nineteen. I would love a part two where Anakin has to save his children from Palpatine and keep history from repeating itself. Great videos, your uploads really make my day better (I’ve been a fan of your channel for over three years) and I can’t wait for a part two! Also, have you written any books or thought about it? I would totally read one.

Bro I love your content abd your fan fictions are always great. I would love to see where this goes from here. Keep doing your content. I binge watch your videos a lot.

You do a great job story telling. Please keep up the good work you're doing. 👍

I love the alternate ending in the revenge of the sith ps2 game. Especially when anakin killed sidious! “No! The galaxy belongs to me!” Padme wasn’t seen or mentioned at all.

This is very good. I have a requested fan fic for you: What if Ahoska Tano was at Mustafar with Kenobi?

Your creative writing is improving with every fan fiction you do.

Awesome video!!! Part 2 please!!!

I loved this what if, but im confused as to why Anakin isn't the emperor of the galaxy? By the time he beat obi wan anakin and trained for a few more months after he would of been levels above palps. But still time few watching this keep it up.💪

Great video Theory! Would love to see a happy ending for Anakin in part 2, perhaps we could see Qui Gon approach Anakin in his darkest hour? Anyways SUPER excited for part 2! 🔥

@starwarstheory this was one of your best fanfics. A part 2 - yes please

Bro your voice acting is amazing. I love your fan fictions.. they always have such interesting turns. Jon and Dave should hire you to work with them on new projects!