What If Anakin Skywalker Let Mace Windu Kill Darth Sidious 

“He’s too dangerous to be left alive!” “You’re right. Kill him. Kill him now.” “No, please!” *lightsaber swing* “You are on this council. We grant you the rank of master. Take a seat, young Skywalker.”

All too often these stories go "and the war instantly ended and all was well", this is very refreshing.

Sounds like Order 66 was triggered as a fail safe if Darth Sidious was killed.

A better title would be Anakin finally comes to his senses and starts thinking.

About five seconds after the end of their call with Mas Amida Anakin should’ve been on the com to Padme immediately. Mas IS NOT the supreme chancellor, and therefore could not execute order 66. There’s no way he would be able to activate the clone armies against the Jedi without confirmation from the Senate.

Man this guy is PUTTING IN THE WORK.

What if the Kaminoans actually cared about the clones so they didn’t put the chips in them What if Jango Fett wasn’t killed What if fox only stunned Fives What if Greivous was killed on Kamino by Obi Wan

I just hope Anakin says “Dew it” 😂

The way I saw that opening scene ending was this: Windu: "I am going to end this, once and for all!" Anakin: (using Palpatine's own words from earlier against him) "Kill him. Kill him now." *Anakin gives Palpatine a sarcastic "what goes around comes around" smirk right before helping Windu kill him

What if Anakin accidentally killed both Palpatine and Mace Windu? - Order 66 would never be activated. - Anakin would be put on trial. - Anakin's allies would defend him. - Maul could testify. - Padme would survive giving birth. - Anakin telling the truth about his marriage with Padme.

Alternate title: What if Anakin wasn`t an idiot? What if Darth Zannah was a Jedi? Either she refrains from killing the Jedi who originally comes for her, or another Jedi takes her instead soon after, assuming Bane doesn't find her or a twin of some kind exists. She undergoes training until she becomes a Jedi Knight or perhaps even a Jedi Master. Then, she receives one of two visions. The first vision portrays Anakin or Luke as the chosen one. She believes in the prophecy and enters stasis, intending to train them to confront Palpatine during the Clone Wars or the time of the Empire. The second vision involves Palpatine himself, maybe as the Emperor. Believing that she is the chosen one due to this, she enters stasis until the Clone Wars, awakened by the Force or some other catalyst. To fight him herself. To maintain her characterization as the Zannah we know and love, she excels as a master of Form Three and is proficient in Jedi Alchemy or sorcery, perhaps even both. I think the second vision would make for a better story, as training Anakin/Luke videos are already abundant on your channel. (Day 54)

"Simioa was hidden through a space anomaly, and the only way to reach it was by trusting the Force." Qui-Gon Jinn would be proud of them. I wonder if this space anomaly might reappear with other Jedi- or simply Force-Sensitive worlds in the galaxy.

*What if Anakin was born in the unknown region* *What if the jedi counsel had visions of darth Vader when they first met Anakin*

Continuing with my ideas day thirty-four of asking. 1) what if the Sith Empire returned during the High Republic era? 2) what if Avar Kriss and Elzar Mann had a child? 3) what if Starlight Beacon was saved? 4) what if Jyn Erso survived the battle of Scarif and went on to meet and fall in love with Luke Skywalker? 5) what if Luke and Leia found out they were siblings earlier? 6) what if Han was saved from Jabba but Leia failed to kill Jabba and was left behind remaining a slave? 7) what if Padme was enslaved during the Clone wars? 8) what if the Combine from Half-Life invaded the Star wars Universe? 9) what if the Daleks invaded the star wars universe? 10) what if Rey became a slave? 11) what if Luke was put in charge of the Rebellion? 12) what if Din Djaran and Bo-Katan fell in love and became joined leaders of Mandalor? 13) what if Leia finished her Jedi training? 14) what if the Cybermen invaded the Star wars universe? 15) what if Cal and Merrin had a daughter (Jedi nightsister hybrid) 16) what if Luke and Leia weren’t separated at birth? 17) what if Ahsoka found Shin Hati before Baylon Skoll? 18) what if Kylo Ren and the Knight of Ren didn’t destroy Luke’s Jedi order meaning that the Resistance and New Republic had the Jedi during the war with the first order? 19) what if the ones survived? 20) what if the Aldani heist went off without the Empire knowing. Some of these I would make on AO3 but I don’t know how I am doing 1, 2 and 4 and I plan to do 15

Yesss! This is awesome! (I knew that Anakin would change his mind when he thought of Padme.) Can you please do these videos for me? •What if Anakin vowed loyalty to the Zygerrian queen? •What if Dooku didn't go to Zygerria and Anakin couldn't escape? •What if Ashoka fell in love with Anakin, but he didn't fall in love with her? •What if Ezra and Leia fell in love? •What if Anakin trained Ezra during the Clone Wars? •What if Ezra save Mace when he was trying to save Ashoka (World Between Worlds)? •What if Vader killed Ezra when he tried to kill Ashoka? •What if Anakin was a full blood Sith? •What if Ashoka pulled Anakin (from the clone wars) through the World Between Worlds? •What if Anakin was accused of the bombing at the Jedi temple? •What if Barriss' goal was to kill Anakin instead of bombing the temple? •What if Padme adopted Anakin •What if Maul killed Anakin during the Phantom Menace? •What if Riff Tamson killed Anakin and Kit Fisto (but Padme, Ashoka, and Prince Lee Char live) •What if the Son took and turned Obi Wan instead of Ashoka? •What if Anakin was Jabba the Hutt's slave? •What if Sabine was unable to get Ezra from Gar Saxon? Thank you! Please do the 1st & last video ideas for me. God Bless!!! :)

I like that this is actually just kind of a "CIS wins" ending. Because ultimately, signing a treaty to end the war with recognition from the Republic as a separate, sovereign state was exactly what they wanted. They never wanted to conquer the Republic, just for the fighting to end with their new state intact and not being reabsorbed into the Republic.

Noice as always Pente! Day: 90: What if Talzin raised Maul? Day: 21: What if Darth Plagueis trained Maul?

What if Yaddle became a Sith Lord. What if Yoda followed Dooku instead of Yaddle. What if Satele Shan killed Darth Malgus.

I swear to God that GranDaddy Bane used to be Pimp Daddy Bane

1. What if Darth Revan won and conquered the galaxy? 2. What if Count Dooku was the Galactic Emperor and not Palpatine? 3. What if Darth Nihilus had been able to fully satiate his insatiable hunger for force energy? 4. What if Valkorion should have been a separate character? 5. What if The Mandalorians had won The Mandalorian Wars? 6. What if the Sith Empire had remained in power after the Great Hyperspace War? 7. What if Alderaan was never destroyed? 8. What if the Rule of 2 never existed? 9. What if Mandalore the Ultimate united all Mandalorian Clans and factions? 10. What if Mandalore the Ultimate had survived the Mandalorian Wars?

What if Anakin saw clear what Palpatine was?

I'm loving that thumbnail. "Come oooon Anni, it's me, Poppa Palpatine. Cahm aaaaaaahn!"

How the Tables Turned

I love these happier endings for the Skywalker Family.

Anakin: Good, Mace, goood! ....Kill him. Kill him now. Mace: I shouldnt... Anakin: Dew it

What if the jedi moved their temple to a different planet before order 66

Anakin Skywalker Staying on the path of a jedi And no doubt he'll be a legend knight Jedi Master

Thank you for another well done story. The bond was a fresh, yet comprehensible direction to take with the Mas power grab coming across as a natural progression. What if (and this will sound wild) R2 had a secret droid army he used to help the rebellion? It is an expansion of the situation from the Citadel rescue where he reprogrammed the Battle droids who, at the end, said it was an honor to serve with him. Go to R2's mission with D-squad infiltrating the Separatists fleet, he discovers the shut down code and adds a restart one that places that fleet under his command. A fleet "General R2D2" could summon when the rebellion needed it most. An alternate or additional story might be told with R2 using his droid force to defend the temple and what Jedi his forces could from Order 66. Evacuating the temple while droids fight the clones. Just a few wild ideas.

What If Obi-Wan was rebellious like his mentor Qui-Gon Jinn and Jedi Master Dooku

I liked some of the directions this story went in. Especially Anakin n Mace becoming Besties. Awesome story PP. 😊😊

I think this is the best tumb that you ever made

What if Anakin could instinctively use force heal

This is my new favorite Pente video

Can’t wait to listen to this later at school/work on Spotify!

This is my new favorite! Thanks

"What if" The Jedi before the Clone Wars discovered that the Dark Side Nexus under their temple on Coruscant was draining their Strength in the Force?

What if the Jedi were secretly Sith, had a bigger and longer endgame than Papa Palps, and let Palpatine go through with his plan just to trick HIM in the end?

This about to be one of the best timelines

I’m glad you didn’t have them go to Tython again. The last few dozen videos have had a Tython twist to them

Fire story bro keep this up 🔥

Thats was really great! I enjoyed that what if story

Thank you!!

Thank you for everything you do. These What If's are a highlight of my day. I got some interesting What if's that could be fun. • What If Luke and Leia were switch - Luke goes to Alderaan and Leia goes to Tatooine. • What If Luke stayed on Dagobah • What If Anakin Skywalker and Padme Amidala assassinated Palpatine. - Anakin could become suspicious of Palpatine and does some detective work and discovers he's a sith so he and Padme kill him in secret. • What If Rey was Kylo Ren's sister. • What If Anakin Skywalker was made Battlemaster during the clone wars. - Cyin Drelic(can't remember how to spell his name) could die and the council votes for Anakin to replace him. • What if Kylo Ren was Luke Skywalker's son instead of Han and Leia • What If Count Dooku was made Grandmaster of the Jedi order - this would happen before his turn but could be interesting. • What if Anakin Skywalker was sent to Malacore(the planet in Rebels s2 final) during the clone wars. - Palpatine could send him their to turn him. Maybe he makes a cross-guard lightsaber. • What If Anakin Skywalker created the Knights of Ren. • What If Anakin Skywalker and Obi-Wan Kenobi were Half Brothers. - Shmi could have been married and had Obi-Wan but they separated then Anakin was born as normal. Over the course of the story they discover the truth. Be cute to see Obi-Wan refer to Padme as his sister in law. • What If Palpatine and Sidious were two separate people. - Palpatine could be a caring Chancellor who sees Anakin like a grandson. Sidious is someone else trying to manipulate Anakin. I could see Anakin having an "I told you so" moment to the council. Maybe Palpatine retires after everything and helps raise Luke and Leia as a great-grandfather. • What If Luke and Leia were raised by Uncle Owen and Aunt Beru • What if Anakin Skywalker was born during the Old Republic. • What If Anakin Skywalker was a Mandalorian Jedi. - I know you did one with him being a mandalorian but seeing him become a mandalorian jedi would be cool. He could be discovered during Satine's rule and the jedi take him to be trained. Who would his master be? Would he find the Darksaber? How would Palpatine try to manipulate him? Would he still fall in love with Padme? • What if Anakin Skywalker was made Grandmaster of the jedi order. - Yoda could die in the Battle of Coruscant and his dying wish is for Anakin be succeed him. I could see Mace hating the idea and how would this effect Palpatine's plan. May the force be with you.

"What if" Qui-Gon's lover didn't die?

every time I watch ROTS, or at least see this moment in the movie, I am always like "please stay in the council chamber anakin" then every moment where he goes to palpatine's office, I am like "please mace kill the emperor before anakin arrives" then after he does arrive, it is another moment where I am like "anakin just watch please, do not do anything rash here" hoping that he does the right thing this time even though I should know this is a movie and it is already set in stone what will happen...is it just me?

I love this scenario. XD it's like I said in a previous one: without the Separatist council being destroyed, they'd use the Republic turning on the Jedi as a rallying cry.

Welp... things didn't go well... i mean, you did kill the chancellor What if Steela Gerrera survived? What if the Kaminoans managed to flee the empire? What if Tarkin Destroyed Lothal instead of Alderaan? What if Hondo discovered Ezra before the ghost crew? (Pirate Jedi!) What if Ezra's parents, or at least his father, was sent to the Narkina 5 Imperial Prison Complex? What if Palpatine lost his connection to the force? (When trying to turn Yoda, the force would push back.) What if Ezra joined the empire? (Like the what if Luke joined the empire.) What if Dooku owned a tusken rifle for home defense? (Three ruffians break into his home.) What if Cham Syndulla was made Senator? (Instead of trying to get rid of Cham Syndulla, the empire gets rid of Orn Free Taa and makes Syndulla the senate leader. Using his popularity with his people to control the population and the semi unspoken threat that his daughter could be considered an accomplice to Gobi Glie's vile act of murdering Orn Free Taa if he didn't.) What if Imperial Bio-weapons project I71A was run by dr Nuvo Vindi? What if Sabine Wren stayed with the Empire? What if Haji fired on the escape pod? (First off, Bolvan would have to do some paper work and then be told later it wasn't necessary anymore as the imperial senate was no longer a factor.) What if Captian Tarkin died at the citadel? What if Asajj Ventress and the Nightsisters successfully assassinated Dooku? What if Anakin was born a women? Kendall Skywalker. What if Anakin died to torture? (I don't know what you mean. -Dooku)

Thanks!

Great stuff

I do love great stories like this one that help tell the logistical story of what’s happened after killing palpatine. A whole galaxy with a messy war is gonna have it grind to the stagnant end.

everyone after watching this video: _We were on the verge of greatness...we were THIS close...._

What if the Jedi command the droid army? Like something happens years before the war and it makes the jedi end up protecting and helping the CIS during the Clone Wars?

The obvious play here that has been completely ignored, and I understand why narratively, Anakin would’ve been on the phone to padme five minutes after this whole thing went down with commander Rex explaining the situation, and then Padme would’ve rallied the delegation of 2000 explaining why the Jedi had just killed the Sith Lord who had started the entire war…. 10,000 years of Jedi service to the Republic coupled with their service as the generals of the army, and the fact that they would be able to show the history of the Sith attacks on the republic over the centuries would have easily explained their actions that day.

oh I got another good one What if all the long distant communications failed during order 66 (the clone commanders couldn’t understand what palpatine was saying so the order didn’t work ) but only the coricaunt clones activated

Fantastic!

Alternate title: Anakin gains 100 IQ points.

This is the story we all wanted to hear.

Wow! Great story!

It be awesome to see a what-if clone wars alternative story for this videos "What-If" be awesome af animated!

Where are these "Tropical Temple" Pictures from?

What if Luke Skywalker didn’t have a vision of Ben Solo turning to the Dark side? What if Luke Skywalker married palpatine’s secret daughter? What if Caleb Dume died during order 66? What if Anakin Skywalker interpreted the chosen one prophecy as him needing to start his own order of Gray Jedi like force users? What if Luke and Leia (post return of the Jedi) were sent back in time to the clone wars? What if Ahsoka used the world between worlds to save Anakin?

I have to say this, this is one of your best stories on par with sideous trying kill anakin on mustafar, vader upgraded suit and jedi satine.

What if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Pong Krell. Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda. Also what if Anakin looked after Bobba Fett after genosis

If Moss isn't the Supreme Chancellor how did he activate order 66? Why did Fox just attack first without questioning what he was seeing? I've never liked the inhibitor chip story since the original idea was they were bred to be soldiers to follow orders but have questions if it didn't feel right. In the novels many didn't understand the order but still went through with it because of how they trained. The only ones that really fought against it where the messed up ARCs and Omega Squad.

This was a really great video. It would have been a different story if Anakin had let Mace do away with the emperor but then that would’ve meant he would’ve witnessed the birth of the twins.

Sidious in the thumbnail is looking like "bro, really?"

I'm only sad that they didn't use the jedi temple to fly away, but i hope you will use that for another scneario

What if darth vader went to darthomir to learn. New suit or perhaps more unique powers. Resurrect talzin maybe. what if Vokara Che became a mentor to anakin as anakin was being treated for bullying and trauma from being a slave. What if anakin fell in love with luminara unduli, serra keto or bultar swan. What if anakin was taught by agen kolar or sasee tin or adi gallia.

Ideas for videos Darth Vader getting the Mandorian Saber during Revenge Of The Sith is idea no. 1 no2: What if Aniken Skywalker was the master of all form

What is the Kaminoans went to war with the Empire after order 66? You could potentially have just the first few generations of clones possess the chip. And incorporate another persons “What is the Kaminoans actually cared about their clones and didn’t put chips in them?” I feel like it would be interesting.

I loved this story! Ecstatic how I would have wanted it to end.

What if anakin was killed by the bounty hunter sniper and when Ahsoka finds out that the jedi council made that plan she turns to the dark side and at the end of the war ahsoka becomes the emperor's apprentice.

What if Anskin was enamoured with Jedi powers, science, history and war and he led to many expeditions and change in the jedi order fibding anomalies unecplainable things and holes in the force, interesting alien planets and structures, old jedi wars against gods/powerful beings beyond living or force comprehendsion?

More accurate title: What if Anakin used common sense.

What if Padmé joined the Separatists on Geonosis, in return for Anakin and Obi-Wan's freedom?

What if Anakin had a zygerrian Padawan after ahsoka left

You said as a throw-away line, "And Anakin would train another Padawan." It would be very interesting if *this* version of Ani were to find and train Galen/Starkiller.

I do think a new Sith would form somehow. Maybe via Darth Maul or Asajj Ventress (if she was alive at this point) or perhaps a Jedi traitor. I also think a reckoning with Anakin and Padme's relationship would have happened and was inevitable. It could split the Jedi with a new order forming more in line with the order Luke started. I feel like the breakdown of the old order was inevitable as Star Wars hints the old order wasn't 100% in line with the intention of the Force. The Jedi Order wouldn't have a live Civil War but it would definitely be split and I see Mace Windu (with new found friendship, something I see happening as well), Obi-Won, Ahsoka, and others joining Anakin while the other faction maybe led by Yoda (Yoda did see the wisdom of the change eventually if you take in The Last Jedi analysis but it wasn't until he saw Luke change Vader that his true perspective changed).

Trophy unlocked: “problem solved, series over”

What if Obi wan took the deathsticks in AOT ? What if Ventress defeated Grievous on Dathomir ? What if Savage and Maul Killed Sidious ? What if the Yuuzhan vong came during the clone wars ?

What if anakin skywalker was trained by jorus c'baoth and obi-wan kanobi was his training partner/big brother. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.

What if the Jedi remained Neutral during the Clone Wars?

what if anakin told mace about what happened on tatooine and mace decided to help him

What if Jango Fett freed Shmi Skywalker instead of Cliegg Lars?

"What have I not done?"

I wish you had talked about Anakin's relationship with Obi-Wan more in this.

What if Anakin had visions of himself burning on Mustafar instead of Padme dying?

"What if" Obi-Wan and Yoda tried to bring Dooku back to the Light?

20:16 why would Ashoka been assigned , she wouldn’t be privy to these meetings she is only a padawan not even a knight, why would baylon be with this mission , this would only be privy to council members

What if Luke Skywalker had heeded the words and warnings of Yoda and Obi-Wan's Force Ghost on Dagobah, remaining there to continue and perhaps ultimately complete his Jedi training? How would Empire Strikes Back, and everything after, be different? Would Leia, Lando Calrissian, and Chewbacca still manage to successfully and safely escape aboard the Millennium Falcon? Would Han Solo still somehow be rescued? What would Vader do if his plans to lure his son into a trap unexpectedly failed? What about the fate of the Rebel Alliance, and the Star Wars galaxy as a whole?

What if the kaminoans gave themselves control of the chips in the clones

man its just so sad that it was allways possable to end with happyness its just tragic

What if Planet SpaceBalls was involved with the empire.

Tbh. Anakin saving Palpatine showed me this. -losing millions of men under his command over 10 years -losing his Padawan Ashoka All because his connection to Padme clouded it

Omg, let's crowdfund this movie!!!

I enjoy your story telling. One thing I feel that I would point out is the use of “ de ignite “ is not correct also it is not a word. The opposite of ignite is extinguish. Other than that minor error the creativity of your storyline tangents and the story telling itself are enjoyable to listen to.

How I would change Star Wars 1. The Phantom Menace - would be a condensed version of The Phantom Menace and Attack of the clones. With Maul being a major antagonist still along with the reveal of Dooku thought as the Sith Lord. In the end it would be revealed while Dooku takes his last breath after a fight with Obi and Anakin that it's not him. 2. Revenge of the Sith - Would be largely unchanged but Anakin thinks he kills Maul and instead of Mace dying, the emperor gets away and it's Windu that chops up Anakin (no high ground) and it was an explosion that Anakin was in. 3. Would be called The Rise of Vader. There is no order 66. Instead it's revealed that the rule of two had been scrapped and a multitude of Emperor's Hands and Inquisitors are sent to kill the Jedi and it's revealed that Anakin is now Vader. Vader kills Windu much the same way Anakin met his fate. Chopped and explosion. 4. The sequel trilogy is The New Jedi from Legacies, or ummm EU.

Just a random thought; What if Palpatine was the chosen one?

0:00 never gets old

I know you did a crossover what if with marvel before so… What if the Anakin were to stumble upon the Omnitrix?