What If Qui Gon Jinn Was In Revenge of the Sith? 

Hey in you f.s. Series can you do what you did with Harley Quinn or the joker again Can you try adding other batman villain to other batman films like I would like to see Harvey dent From batman 1989 in Bat man forever Or I would like to see joker in batman returns or Penguin in bat man forever or even riddler in batman and robin Please respond

Channel Awesome I love Channel Awesome

Would you consider adapting a new hope with this version of the prequels as your foundation? But when you make that keep this in mind that even a minor change in the timeline can have unforeseeable consequences as the years spiral out. It was only about 13 years since the death of Qui-gon Jinn and the Battle on Mustafar in the original continuity and while the event itself still happened in the changes in the timeline the events leading up to it were quite different, even going so far as to have Grievous die first. It probably goes without saying but the events we saw change in this version are but the tip of the iceberg I mean what about the clone wars Kenobi's death prior to the clone wars changes the events on Mandalore durring the lone Wars and possibly Mandalorian Civil War that happens later, in fact depending on how much it changes the clone war it may even prevent the Mandalorian Civil War entirely. Not every change has to have a negative outcome on the timeline, but that actually brings up an interesting point anyways, because with an entire chapter in history being deleted something has to take it's place, (I think the best example of just how fast a minor change can damage the timeline happens in the arrowvers in the 2 part episode "Out of Time/Rogue Time") long story short the fact of the matter is that by the time of the events of A New Hope came along the timeline would be almost unrecognizable. If I were to pick up where you left of I would have it that something happened in his past that saw Galen Erso be loyal to the empire and not a rebel spy mascaraing as an imperialist to the point where even the people he's trying to help don't realize that he's in fact on their side, and no spy Galen Erso means no Death-star Weakness. but that is just one way that this universe can change going forward. The possibilities are essentially limitless. Still I hope you continue. maybe retcon out Duku's death so that it only seemed like he died.

Dude, bit random... But you should review "furry vengeance" the brendon Frasier one, not the porn. Its gotta be his worst film. I just watched it and immediately thought you should be subjected to it! Just an idea

@@newbienoobframebyframe4108 you just wanna see that thicc brendan fraser botty again

LMAO XD

I saw what you did there. Is that from Taken? Or whatever it's called?

@@DavidRay39 Yes

I doubt that I'm pretty sure on this theory qui Gon can turn Anakin back from the Darkside

Victor Bruant Yeeees!

Marcos Simian some twist

@@srstriker6420 a much stranger twist.

Rick Sanchez yeah, if Snoke was Darth Plagueis

SR Striker Which he should have

Tim Stutz of course he should have and they didn’t bother doing that

I think we all agree. Something tells me that's not the route ChannelAwesome wanted to go...

I think Qui-Gon was truly the only one to SUCCESSFULLY trainer Anakin and keep him on the right path.

Agreed

@@alexbasha0508 I think that id Anakin was trained by Windu or Yoda he would have never turned.

@Seamus McBratnie He means if he never died in phantom menace dude You trolling?

That's impossible!!!

Fantastic Caleb too common

Big question is if his half brother is Luke then that would mean his father would’ve been His uncle Lars having a Bastard child from Shmi

The funny part is that I already say that as an inside joke whenever I put ROTS Anakin and ROTJ Luke side by side Since they physically look more like brothers than a father and his son

Why is Luke her brother?, they is the son of Beru and Owen.

They would all be dead or old as hell by the time of the sequels

Battlefront Warrior well no I just meant like how this timeline would impact the sequel’s stories, still the same characters and stuff but how different it would be

Me too!!!

I support this

I support that.

The Separatist would most likely still form but under different leadership with someone else

did count dooku turn after episode one? i thought he was sith before episode 1

@@fryanbeef178 No, it was Qui Gons death that essentially pushed him over the edge

@@pelicanking9596 o okay thanks

@@pelicanking9596 He'd probably still turn. The Death of Qui-Gon was the final push, not a catalyst for the whole transformation. He'd no doubt have had some other event serve as that final push.

Timo B so did I

Not gone but shifted. It probably wouldnt be as powerful a thing but as someone with a few syblings meeting a older brother I know either nothing about, next to nothing about, or only knew that he was a Jedi and an Hero as they try and kill me would fuck my head up.

Like I'm not saying your completely wrong I'm just saying done right Vader and Luke's encounters would still have emotional weight

@@auroradragen5920 I agree. The story could play on the fact that neither really learned of each other until their confrontation in the next movie. Imagine how Luke would feel to find out he's Darth Vader's younger brother. That could mess up his confidence in ways that being his son never could.

Tbh the whole story is messed up then bc anakin is the chosen one bc he brings balance to the force aka luke and Leia are those balance ones a force user and ones

@@pandawolf5990 what?

The Young Obi-Wan books were the EU "Source" on what Qui-Gon was like, and they had a few familiar names, but the characters were different from the versions Disney introduced. One of these was Satine Kryze, who again was Obi-Wan's girlfriend. In the EU, Qui-Gon quite literally leaves her in a situation where her death is inevitable (one he could have stopped) and when Obi-Wan goes to save her, leaves him to die with her. Obviously Obi-Wan survives, but there's no way Qui-Gon could have been sure of this. Qui-Gon's motive, by the way, was that he never truly lets himself get attached to people, and their deaths are (his would also be, at least he's not a hypocrite about it) secondary in the grand scheme of things. tl;dr EU Qui-Gon would totally leave Shimi to her fate.

@@trianglemoebius Yea that book sounds like trash. What we see on screen Qui-gon isn't like that.

I like the spelling Padmay

*Padmè

Strangely, I think this actually makes more sense. Think of it this way. Palpatine shows that Darth Maul killed Qui Gon, then Dooku would have presumably learned about Maul's connection to Palpatine? Wouldn't Dooku realized that Qui Gon's death was his master's fault? If so, wouldn't that mean that Dooku would want to avenge Qui Gon and/or return to the Jedi. And if not, doesn't that make Dooku a horribly stupid character?

@@TheHero136 dooku was fighting palpatine with half the republics might, his goal was subterfuge to kill palpatine, palpatine knew and wanted him to try to, that enabled his plan for anakin who he met after mauls death before dooku fell etc

Then dooku could reshape the jedi as he saw fit, as the figurehead and leader of a new republic, and supreme master of the jedi, not a jedi master, but a master of jedi

Aurora Uplinks nothing against you but can I please say how much I hate this way of writing. Where we can just ignore all plot holes or logic and say it’s part of Palpatine’s plan. It’s just so ridiculous to let all these leaps in logic just being written off as “part of the plan.”

@@TheHero136 ok....well then...palpatine corrupts and recruits dooku after the phantom menace, after he met anakin saying, he was looking forward to his careers future. All. In. The. .... future.... yes the script was augmented but anakin's future was being planned by palpatine after he met him and heard all about his potential, birth, and quigons demand he be trained against all customs and rules, after Qui gon and his apprentice killed the emperors apprentice, so presumingly the emperor values quigons opinion on the boy and became determined to have one capable of beating his former apprentice as his future apprentice. That's manipulative planning, every war and political leader does it, search for the best assets then plan how to maintain and use them cost effectively. I hate to say it, but regardless of how we feel, every movie has planning, just like this one, it's not ad-libbed in after, it's based on film events and dialogue, and I agree it's not the film Lucas planned on initially, jarjar was supposed to be a secret sith altering events but that had to be put in the background, otherwise we would have had a more fulfilling trillogy

Also don't forget before he went to the dark side was the jedi code when mace windu wanted to kill Palpatine instead of being tried in court that what send him to the dark side

@@cnabutler07 that was my edit 1

Probably not. I don’t think that would have worked.

Joseph Agar I hope so until they reach the sequel trilogy by making Darth Plagueis or Darth talon as the main antagonist

Obi Wan hadn’t really completed his training though, he was still an apprentice when Jinn died.

@@alexman378 I agree, Obi-Wan took on training Anakin way before he was ready to do that. Had Anakin been trained by Qui-Gon instead he would have become a very different jedi, probably a lot less susceptible to the dark side.

@@MrAranton The people who run this channel don't know their lore smh

Obi Wan wasn’t *flawed* he was just young and was stuck with a particularly difficult pads wan. Anakins choices were his own and you can’t blame Obi Wan, especially considering that Obi-Wan did love Anakin and trained him the best he could.

@@Elnont cap

There’s plenty of “qui-gon raised Anakin” where everything changed. You can look those up if you want.

Well this is more a light rewrite than a contemplative what if

Remember: this is just one event changing. Yes, there is butterfly effect, but remember also: a lot of cards were already in place, and there was someone (Palp) already with plans to manipulate circumstances. The idea that a lot of things wouldn't just be somewhat altered versions of what we know is somewhat silly, if you ask me.

I mean as Screenslaver she did almost everything right Make sure your identity stays a secret. check the patsy pizza man and never actually being at the scene of the crime gives almost no evidence to her being the screenslaver Use your power/tech/abilities correctly. Check like I said before the patsy but also using the mind control on all the powerful pieces in the game whilst also not actively hindrancing yourself The only thing she didnt really account for was the kids being so resourceful and to be honest lucky She was very very close to success in both her plan and getting away with it Scot free.

Like it was only a twist villan cause we knew her out of screenslaver mode but if we never met Evelyn in the movie it really wouldnt have been a 'special' secret identity just a regular one. So I wouldnt think that the story would change almost at all

北岡霊人 what about the tragedy of Darth Plagueis the wise?

SR Striker what about the droid attack on the Wookiee’s?

Dad well I don’t mind, but what do you think about Darth Plagueis?

What if R2D2 have voice circuitry which can able to speak? He'd have gotten shot in the fucking dome for mouthing off one-too-many times, no doubt. He was a sarcastic little shit, according to everyone who could understand him, he just got away with it because most people (and even those who could sometimes USUALLY) couldn't.

Uh huh. Definitely was the broken leg and not the racist thing where he said he wanted to kill random black dudes for an incident he wasn’t even a part of and Disney scrapped his part to avoid a serious foot up the ass by the black community for working with Neeson.

TheNerdyBirdyShow This happened way before that confession and it was a confession of how messed it was and the remorse he was feeling. The media took it way out of context and used it as a way to attack him. They used the black community as a scapegoat to cancel him.

Really? I heard it was because his wife had died.

@@Tahkaullus01 She died in 2009

but batman begins came out in the same year and he was Ra's al Ghul

... I'd watch that.👍

The story is how they got there, and their enemies are basically everyone that are fanatic for the light or dark.

@@archibald_raven EU had a lot of situations where Luke had the Jedi on the right path but still things went wrong. The most famous (and largest) is probably the Yuzon-Vong, but there are tonnes of others. Just because the Jedi are on-track isn't gonna stop everyone in the galaxy from doing bad things. Some of them will succeed, given probability.

Part 1's dialogue was MUCH better than what Lucas wrote for the Prequels, especially the arena scene...

TV and film kid too 🧹 under the carpet

Who the fuck is Quai Gon Yi

Kaleb Barber 💀

@@kalebbarber2527 lol im laughing so hard

@@kalebbarber2527 Ikr? I was asking the same thing, 😂🤣

Dooku could easily have adopted maul as his apprentice to lessen the blow from the realization that qui-Gon would NEVER join him Like a coping mechanism

They do that with almost every fanscription which makes it more fun imo

Prolly cuz even in canon, he doesn't die and becomes a cyborg. He just doesn't show up in subsequent movies, and I think a lot of what-ifs try to fix that.

@@lpatterson787 The question was rhetorical. Everyone acknowledges that killing him off in Episode 1 was a stupid decision

Part 1 says shmi just gave birth to a new child. So Owen was lukes older brother.

@@abhisargupta8234 But who is Luke's father, then? Is he half-human, half-Force the way Anakin was?

@@abhisargupta8234 If Shmi gave birth to Owen that means he is Anakin's brother, not Luke's. Unless you are insinuating that inbreeding happened.

@@SeasideDetective2 Luke's father is Anakin as in the original. Owen was birthed by Shmi after her owner fell in love with her. He married Shmi and paid to have her slave title removed. Sometime before Episode II, Shmi gave birth to Owen. This was before Anakin returned to find her kidnapped. In the original story Owen is Anakin's brother and Luke's uncle. I think the narrator miss spoke. I can't see why this would be done deliberately.

Also no, that was not Watto. lol He sold her to the man who would become Owen's father.

Will Rawson yeah

I loved ROTS, and I kinda agree

Honestly they didnt need Jin in this. They needed Darth Maul. They ruined the prequels really by killing off Darth Maul in the 1st movie.

Brett T You must not have watched the Clone Wars.

@@Josh-The_Spooky_Bastard- clearly did. the movie needed maul

no, this contradicts the original trilogy.

I thought it was Anakin yelling ”PADME!”

I think that happens in part 1

The good star wars wouldnt make any sense

Jaden McKillip 1. Harry would have been an asshole 2. Harry would have been an asshole

Jaden McKillip what about Daniel Bruhl played Grindelwald instead of Johnny Depp

TheCreepypro and maybe till the sequel trilogy where Darth talon or Darth Plagueis are the main villain

Swifty Solves for new hope

PopCultureFan XXI Chris Judge

SR Striker Yep

PopCultureFan XXI yeah I can see that

Jack Reacher Reviews and Gaming and the sequel trilogy

Jack Reacher Reviews and Gaming and the sequel trilogy?

Gang of Heroes he ether die a hero or live to become a villain