Story wise, she tells you where she would go if she left John Marston some time in the main game. Game wise, her and Jack more than likely despawn from the epilogue world until you get the ranch.
Abigail makes me mad a hell of alot! Leaving John becouse, he defended the Ranch. John was forced into defending the Ranch. What else can John have done? Watch his job, or Family burn? How else was he suppose to do, when those man, fellowed him, and his son? If anything Abigail should be happier that John is put them first, and is doing things her way.
You should make a video about where Mac and Sean went before the game or where the gang was before blackwater or where Dutch and micha went between chapter 6 and epilogue
I don't know nothing about Micah and Dutch, but I know that Mac was caught and killed after the robbery by Agent Milton and Sean was caught by bounty hunters.
The biggest flaw I see in the Strawberry theory is that John and Sadie hunt a bounty there, they ask all around town, bust down a door in the hotel and make a pretty big commotion, but Abigail had no idea Sadie was alive, much less that they were working together. It's not impossible, but it would pretty hard to miss that
Literally when I was watching the cutscene. I forgot I was watching the actual video and thought I was watching a playthrough. This shows how much he stretches his video with unneeded cutscenes. Just show a little bit of the cutscene not the whole lot of it. Looking at John shoveling shit in a stable does not show where Abigail and Jack went.
Honestly if their would be another RDR it'd probably go back to playing as Jack like in Red Dead Redemption. But I'm not for sure what the story line would be
abigail said in the letter that she wrote to john that a nice lady wrote the letter so here’s what i think might of happened the nice lady that abigail mentioned in the letter to john probably said to abigail that her and jack could stay with her at her house for a few months.
It couldn't have been the MacFarlane ranch because Abigail and Bonnie meet for the first time in RDR after John reunites with his family, and neither of them mentions having met the other before. Still, you offered some plausible possibilities, with the Strawberry doctor being the most likely one (for the reasons you mentioned: source of income, fairly safe place to live). Armadillo, on the other hand? No way. I know you think John and Abigail are bad parents, but you'd have to be a special kind of awful parent to take your kid to live in town that has been decimated by cholera, even for just a few months.
They didn’t stay with the McFarlane’s cuz if I remember correctly they didn’t meet until years later in RDR1. They most likely stayed in Strawberry where she worked for the doctors office and rented a room in town.
They went to strawberry because earlier in the prologue Abigail says she bought 2 packages and she sent you to pick only ONE package so she had to have gone to strawberry for at least a few days.
He hasn't 100% completed this game at all 😂 he doesn't even play it as much as you think these videos are all the same recorded bull shit... only a hand full of people have 100 percented this i'm one of them 👍
I love this game. They've done such a great job on the story. So much heart mixed with whatever u want to do in life at that time. My guesting for you mrboss is. We have the last of us being developed as a TV show but what if they make red dead as a show aswell. I can see it happening kinda. What could be better as a show. Red dead or last of us. I think its a think win for the last of us.......
This is probably how that necklace that jack made for his mom got on that cross cause you said they came back from the south area where the cross with the necklace would be right?
Maybe Amarillo? Because if you think about it, they returned to John due to cholera hitting and they were out of resources and places to go/ couldn’t afford to go another place 🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️
Is John the father? I heard a conversation with John where he says hes unable due to issues. Maybe ED? And Abigail according to Dutch was passed around.
Lenny explains Micah was already drunk before they got to Strawberry. I just replayed that part last night. LENNY MAH BOI!!!!! HA HA!!!! FOUND YA LENNAY!!!!
I had thoughts of black water, but other then that I dont think jack looks anything like jack in the first RDR, and I like him in the first more then the second.
She lived in a tent for years to be with him thats hardly a fair statement. She just wanted a better life for her son. And in the end she was right, John's life got the both of them killed and Jack turned into an outlaw
She ain't a gold digger she wouldn't have gone lived in tents for years for John she just is very concerned for Jack as a mother should and wanted to be safe but sadly it didn't go well 😢
The gal who married john of all members for the majority her life and lived in the woods, how is she even a gold digger hell, even her bed price is cheap
They'll never know he was part of the Van Der Linde gang... I wish they were all still together, I wish Micah died, I wish... Atleast Arthur will have his own little Tahiti...
If you go to the pig farm ran by the brother and sister as Aurthur and let them rob you before the last train heist and don't go back until you control John, you can get all of Aurthur's money
Just thought of this Abigail said woman in a "village" and there's a bounty not to long from strawberry called 'Yukon Nik'. He lives in a in a place that kind of looks like a village that belongs to a native tribe. Maybe an old lady lived there and talked to abigail but I could be wrong
If I am truly honest I would imagine either blackwater or strawberry because they came back without a horse so they didn’t go far and they came back with a dog so they must’ve been to a place with animals because they came back with a dog so I would think blackwater or strawberry But also great video keep it up
Anyone else realize how the ranch that abel is staying in is the one where you help Sadie attack the O'driscolls? Edit: The mission is Sadie the Widower-II in chapter 6
You're always saving sadie in this game... how does even become a bounty hunter years later when she was once an outlaw with a violent gang of thieves, why does she put herself in charge of john and charles like she was this massive part of the gang when she rode with them for a month or two. So yeah the epilogue should be called sadie adler widow saver simulator.
Well, they probably came from New Austin or somewhere where the trail leads because they'd have to follow the trail to get there. And they couldn't have been far, because they walked. They're poor and cant afford the supplies for a long hike.
I reckon she stayed in a room in strawberry. She was working at doctors so it's possible she rented a room from the doctor himself, since he was away fishing so often
I wanna see all the moonshiners scenes. I've done 5 n it's good money but I think there's more. 1 was behind six oaks above valentine, one was by hanging dog ranch in that mountain, 1 was across the chapter 3 base in that path there, ran into one by the legendary boar in lemoyne, every encounter the reward gets better just for some herbs. Indian tobacco, berries, milkweed, etc. Since the new update I cant seem to find them or the clan. Were they erased?
I know this is pretty late but it’s just a thought. What if they went to blackwater or somewhere close by? I mean she is the one who discovered Beechers hope
If you had paid attention to the first game Abigail is jealous because she thinks it’s something between Bonnie Mac garland and John. When they get introduced there is no hint at them meeting before
Funny part is that, when Abigail leaves with Jack. She goes to StrayBerry at the doctors office 😆 some how you can't go inside there when you try looking for her
She goes to that doctor in Strawberry she got a temp job from. Also, the "gone fishing" sign in the window is never taken down. Quite possibly he fell a$$ backwards into John's path one day. On a good day any random person has a 50/50 chance at surviving an encounter with him... Just sayin'.😕
I was sorta mad at abgail, she got mad that John defended the ranch which if he didn't he would've lost his job, they'd be back on square one. Also I highly doubt she stayed at Mic farlenss ranch as she's introduced to her in red dead redemption one
Wait a sec the way John checks the ammo in the cattleman revolver, at the beginning, isn't how that type of revolver works. You can even see how the revolver is really handled when you are reloadeing in-game. Somebody at rockstar was sleeping during that cutscene, exspecially compared to the rest of the details in the game, I just thought Americans would know better is all :O
