Wrangler ® has the best fit. It was kind of unfair comparing a chambray western shirt with a rigid dark western shirt. As far as styling is concerned, it depends on what you decide to combine with the shirts; pants color; shoes etc. BTW: Wrangler also has dark denim/rigid western style shirts. Overall in my opinion, when it comes to western shirts as well as anything western wear related Wrangler® wins most every time. Also Wrangler western shirts almost always have a little slot in the left pocket to hold a pen or small thermometer.
I bought a couple new wrangler shirts and they look identical to these but the shirts are pretty long in the back unlike these that are almost straight across on the length front to back.
