Who Did It Best? | Amazing Grace 

Honestly Phantoms "park and bark" version is FAR SUPERIOR to anything on this video. All fine corps, they just can't beat the horn choir that is Phantom Regiment.

Cadets is my favorite by far of these 5, but agree nothing will ever top Phantom's audio recording of Amazing Grace...

I'm with some of the others - no one come's close to Phantom Regiment with Amazing Grace. I guess they haven't put it in a field show, but it's the one that gives me chills - every time. I miss hearing that in the old school retreats!

Nothing like the Phantom brass choir. Chills every time I hear it. These just don't compare.

Definitely Phantom!

PR. Love the recording, BUT the best experience was playing it as a member, of course!

Having marched Cadets 2011 definitely partial to Cadets. I always got chills during the ballad and it was always such a great feeling when the crowd clapped for the demon pitchfork

Easy - Phantom Regiment!

Me when Phantom Regiment isn't listed: sad

It's Boston all the way for me. Seeing S.O.S. in person was absolutely incredible. The clean and consistent sounds they were producing spead out all over the field was impressive. They sounded and looked incredible. Not to mention their color guard being the best.

Hands down, without a doubt, always Phantom Regiment

PR did it best :) but I do love the whole Cadets 2011 show!

Phantoms was beyond awesome nobody cant touch it. Truely breathtaking

Man the royal crusaders had some soul

1)PR- Well bc they’re PR 2)Spirit- It’s southern & the “Gods trying to tell you something” intertwined in it. 3)Cadets- Because I’m a sucker for great mello writing. 🤷🏼‍♂️ 4)Boston- For the artistic take on it 5)’75 Crusaders- Similar to Atlanta Just my opinion 😊

Blue knights! Loved the low brass

1. Boston Crusaders (the percussion line is awesome) 2. Cadets

The fact you dont have phantoms take on amazing grace is a crime.

Have to agree with Scott on this. Phantom all the way!!!!

So, being a part of the Best Guard (Spirit of Atlanta, '87), I must vote for Spirit!

I’ve been waiting for this one 😩

In order Regiment Boston Royal Crusaders Cadets Spirit Blue Knights

Boston

Cadets 2011....in a class by themselves. However, having said that....IMHO, it's almost impossible to do a tune like this justice with Drum Corps. ALL the corps, except The Cadets, "Drum Corps-ed" it WAY too much. Jazz? I don't think so!

Trick question. These are all nice, but the correct answer is "none of the above". Phantom's version will always be tops.

The video I'm watching right now is the best and the best. Thank you for making my everything so happy for a little while because of one reason I watch your video. Your video under the cold winter sky at dawn is so beautiful and enchanting. Your video really touches my heart. It is your video that I want to watch over and over again, even if I watch it over and over again. How did you have such a wonderful talent that is full of the mysterious charm of your video? I am amazed at the excellence of your skills and thank you for taking the time to warm my heart and make me feel comfortable with your sincerity and hard work in watching the video. I hope your video will bloom as a flower in my heart and stay as a flower of undying love for a long time. As the algorithm introduced, I just looked down and suddenly the first picture caught my eye, so I looked up again and it was your video. The moment I saw your video for the first time, my heart went up and it was so good. I'm looking at your video like a dream. With a precious relationship, my heart is sincere. I'm going to give you praise and support with full sincerity. Sit alone by the window and watch your videos. My sad tears that burn silently....I illuminate the video of you in longing, and if I float my small boat in the distant sea of ​​reminiscence, will I hear your voice? Someday I want my heart to reach you...

nice!!!!!!!!!! i wish they would bring back band uniforms with the band hats. there's some DCI groups that almost bend in with the color guard

Boston 2018 for sure. One of the most beautiful shows I’ve ever seen

Best Hornline hands down The Cadets. Best hit overall Boston! All were unique and creative.

they're all perfect

As a Spirit alum (1980) gotta go with Hotlanta. All are good, but this is just such a soulful rendition. Takin' it to church.

BAC, no question

Phantom Regiment and it's not even close. Cadets was really good and that was a great show, but no one can touch PR on this one. I suppose that's why they weren't on the list. The idea is to find out who was second.

Cadets

I prefer Boston Crusaders, but all of them were great, honestly.

Cadets! I told my kids to play it at my funeral along with Free Again from the Golden Knights (BS)

Obviously Phantom Regiment, who can doubt that

2005 cavaliers

87 Spirit for me.

Gotta go with Boston Crusaders

1975 👍

Phantom Regiment, who are not included in this video

Spirit of Atlanta....spirited tempo, easy to understand.

Cadets!

Phantom Regiment hands down

No body ,bests Phantom #1 .

1993. Phantom Regiment.

i wanna hear crown play phantom reg version

And who was serenading to close it out ?? Bring it home for us, Bruce.....

PHANTOM REGIMENT NO Contest

Spirit of Atlanta was the best.

2011 Cadets...

Vista Ridge did it better in 2018.

Boston crusaders duh

My ranking: 1. Cadets 2. Blue Knights 3. Royal Crusaders 4. Spirit of Atlanta 5. Boston Crusaders

How about East Coast Jazz 2005 as an option? Oh that's right Div II/III doesn't exist to you.

Phamton is better than all of them

None. To jazzy. Phantom Regiment the Best.

Boston