Who Is The Better Teacher? Scathach or Chiron 

"not too bad for your age grandma"

He seems like he doesn't care if someone calls him old.

wouldn't argue with that

😂 ! I can’t argue with that. You make a good point. But imagining Waver ( El Malloi II ) in competition with some of the most renown Mentors in mythology is just funny to me.

@@jamesknott5255 If he was put on the same level as the other two, I would argue he would be just as successful if not more so

Mmmmm… I don’t know about that. Chiron was also VERY fond of Jason and Heracles as well. WE’VE just been privy to seeing a flashback as well as the two ( Achilles and Chiron ) meeting up again in Apocrypha which can definitely “taint” one’s bias. With Chiron’s other students we haven’t.

Does that mean Aife is Fujimaru's mother?

I want an Aife Servant _SO BAD..._

3 if you push it, 5 if you're delusional (me)

Hah! You're right.

😂

Seems legit🗿

Greeks are the biggest rapists in mythology though.

That’s because you’ve been bonked on the head by the horni 😂 ( jk )

The Force(Horniness) is strong with this one.

There are quite a few Shishou’s at Chaldea. MY Shishou Kiichi Hogen for example ❤

Given he's trained under a Chiron that does more or less do the same training as Fate Chiron, he'd probably not pick up as many new skills/abilities with Fate Chiron, than if he trained under Fate Scathach, but who knows.

@@brockjr8040 what skill would he pick up and how strong you think he'd get

Probably Scathach. Chiron is a great teacher but he specializes in archery. Percy likely is unable to learn that. Both are masters of all weapons if we’re talking Fate though I personally consider Scathach much better at close combat. As for magecraft, Runes would probably be a bit easier to learn though I’m sure Chiron would find something he’s good at too. Under Scathach I’d say Percy would gain mastery of weapons and possibly the sling which gives him long range. Runes would be expected giving him added versatility along with water powers. He might even be gifted with Gae Bolg. Under Chiron he’d still be a master swordsman but a bit worse. He may be taught another weapon but can’t say for sure what it would be. He’d have his own magecraft but I can’t say for sure what that may be. Idk how good Chiron is with a sling so that still might be an option since I’m not convinced Percy could learn archery.

@blitz0590 It's stated Percy has gotten better with Archery, and honestly if we scale Percy and his feats up accordingly to Fate and like the counterparts, Percy would be no less than an A rank servant even arguably EX rank servant, and undoubtedly among the most skilled servants, so that's partly why it's hard to tell who would be a better teacher for him tbh, but as for skills/abilities? Most likely imo would be runes for Scathach, and Percy is...weird cause while definitely sub par with a bow and arrow, his aim when throwing shit is immaculate, so sling could be something yes, as for Chiron? Not much he could learn that wouldn't just be expanded knowledge he already has tbh...

@justinnelson1118 hard to tell tbh, but like I said Percy as he is now is much to weak for Fate, but if we scared him and his feats accordingly to Fates levels and his enemies to Fates counterparts he'd be so far above Chiron and Scathach that by the time those versions would be able to teach him stuff it may be not useless but...hardly used again other than maybe runes...

Taiga is the GOAT 🐆

"realistically", depends on the subject

Taiga obviously

For laughs and antics ? Taiga ! For an actual philosophical education and combat experience / training, Chiron. NOT to disrespect Sensei of the Tiger Doujou, just my opinion.

@@jamesknott5255 your goddamn right

The Force(Horniness) is strong with this one.

If it’s just keeping the Noble Phantasm, the answer seems to be yes, based on the example of Fate/Apocrypha’s Lancer Vlad III. Vlad dropped from a 10 to 6 after leaving Romania for Semiramis’ Hanging Gardens of Babylon. He retained his “ability” but his “original specs” dropped. His “ability” was “inhibited”. Vlad could still summon stakes from his body but even their force and sharpness had weakened. So probably anything a Servant can carry out should be kept. Vlad is only a Heroic Spirit in Romania. He’s more internationally famed as an Anti-Hero and vampire, aka Fate/Extra’s Lancer Vlad. Vlad’s situation is definitely atypical. From how I understand it, he’s not an inherently strong Servant, but he was artificially strong in Romania, so the difference is way more apparent after leaving Romania for the Hanging Gardens. I think at worst Cu Chulainn would drop from 10 to 9 or 8 if he left Ireland for mainland Europe. He’s an inherently strong Heroic Spirit that still has high fame in Europe. Let’s ignore the fortress and blessing, just focusing on the chariot which Cu can probably ride out of Ireland. The problem seems to be that Servants have some kind of carry weight or diverted output for Noble Phantasms. So, Ireland Cu has 100 carry weight, but Europe Cu only has 80. Europe Cu with his chariot is now encumbered or something. Yeah, he still keeps the chariot. But it’s hard to say if that chariot is more of a hinderance or boon.

I feel like if you posited this question to Arturia, she'd just laugh at you.

The Force(Horniness) is strong with this one.