Who Sang The "Seventeen" Climax The Best? 

I don’t know if this would be a good idea but could you do the part from Heathers in meant to be yours when JD yells “VERONICA!!!! Open the open the door please.”?

Ugh, I hate how fast some of these performances are going. This is supposed to be an emotional love ballad. Slow down and savor it for god’s sake.

I dreamt I could belt like Barrett and I was so disappointed when I woke up.. I’m so quiet on high notes lol

We love a belting queen YAS BARRETT

Barrett and Ryan will always be my favorite ❤️

UMMM, were is illegal heathers 😡😡

I already know before watching: The answer is: Not riverdale

Did anyone else feel like a great deal of these were off pitch on "tonight"? On another note, Wendell Scherer's high note at 8:37 gives me chills. Absolutely amazing.

Barrett is hands down my favourite Veronica, but I think Carrie HF and Jamie Muscato's voices sound really well together.

You should do who did the best "Shut up heater" 😂

barrett and dan: HoLy sHiT i LoVe tHiS aNd BarReTt taylor and chet: it was okay, it was a bit rushed and this is supposed to be a powerful song. dave and cait: kinda sounded like opera singers to me lol. but pretty decent stephen and jaz: it was great :) and this jd is so hot like wtf michelle and jonathan: its good :/ veronica was a little flat annaleigh and jeremy: again, rushed. its supposed to be a sorta slow paced song with passion. thomas and nicole: i honestly love thomas and this was great. but thomas was a tiny weenie flat lol hannah and jon/jan idk: its okay. little rushed but it sounds great barrett and dave: barrett makes anything sound good so its great LiKe yEs hIt tHeM hIgh NotEs shelby and charlie: it was really good c: christine and kamyan: it was okay. zachariah and hayley: it was soooo good. like GOoD and like the emotion is just UgH dave and charissa: it was supa nice 👍🏻 love the high notes that charissa hit jamie and carrie: its nice. it makes my ears happy olivia and wendell: its really cute. i like it a lot barrett and ryan: HOLY SHIT MY FAVORITE ITS LIKE PERFECG AND THE EMOTION IS GREAT AND I JUSY LOVE THESE TWO TOGETHER IT SOUNDS LIKE HEAVEN

Hey! That’s me! Cool! I just sent this to Wendell so he’ll see 😊 PS I like how you included all the making out. Definitely interesting to see everyone’s version, haha.

holy shit i was NOT expecting that high note from wendell scherer, deadass rewound the video like 3 times and gave me chills every time

What are you doing at 3 am? *Watching ART* 💯👏🏻👑💙🙌🏻

Okay, but seriously. I watched the performance with Hayley and Zachariah. They have such amazing chemistry. They play the parts so well together. I loved their performances.

I swear when I saw: Barret Dan Ryan Jeremy Jordan Thomas Sanders Zachariah Sterner I had a mini heat attack

I think we can all agree that any with Barrett in are the best ones but I've got to admit i wasn't excepting my favourite to be Barrett and Dave, but the sounded the best I'm my opinion. But Carries is amazing! Edit: Looking back at this I'm actually quite surprised how much I like Charissa's version! I've always loved her as Heather Chandler but had mixed feelings on her Veronica but seeing this definitely makes me realise why she got chosen as the Understudy for both roles.

Thank you so much again for including me at 2:54 !!! It's been about a year since I've done Heathers and it's still such an amazing dream. Jonathan was such a great JD. I also really loved Olivia and Wendell's because Wendell's note was just impressive. XD

Based on voices: JD: Thomas Sanders (absolutely beautiful) Veronica: Barrett (always. Duh)

i mean obviously barrett wilbert weed but she does it with at least 3 different people so uhhh idk but also carrie hope fletcher 👌👌👌

yo you should do a who sang “and peggy” the best lol

*ToNiGhTtTtTt!!*

You should do one for the climax of Kindergarten Boyfriend 💖

i don’t understand why people are obsessed with thomas sanders, in my opinion he sounds off key :/

Omg Olivia Rose Michaels and Wendell Scherer HANDS DOWN

I enjoyed Carrie and Jamie’s version the most (of course, I’m biased because I had the privilege of seeing that production live) but I also liked Hannah and Ian’s, Dave and Charissa’s, Olivia and Wendell’s, and the original. Ryan and Dan are both great, I’m not sure who I like better.

Olivia and Wendell are incredible. I love the way he did the high note with her. It makes the scene feel more intense, like he wants to be normal just as much as she does.

Zachariah Sterner is probably one of my favorite JDs but Barrett is always my favorite Veronica

Carrie and Jamie without a doubt, the chemistry, the way their voices blend, individually they're both amazing too

Hello, just wanted to say that these Heathers climaxes give me life😁 But could you do the Kindergarten Boyfriend climax that Martha sings? (You know the part where it says “We will fly through the dawn to a new Kindergartennnnnnnn)?

of course barrett and dan/dave/ryan are fantastic, but i also absolutely love carrie & jamie!

Barrett is undeniably amazing but Carrie and Jamie will always have a special place in my heart

This is more like who had the best kiss

Barret Wilbert Weed/Dan Domenech - 0:19 Taylor Forsmo/Chet Davino - 0:53 Dave Thomas Brown/Cait Fairbanks - 1:25 Stephen Madsen/Jaz Flowers - 2:01 Michelle "Giggles" Renee/Jonathan Markham - 2:34 Annaleigh Ashford/Jeremy Jordan - 3:10 Thomas Sanders/Nicole Visco - 3:41 Hannah Clarke Levine/Jan Smith - 4:12 Barrett Wilbert Weed/Dave Thomas Brown - 4:41 Shelby Brown/Charlie Meredith - 5:17 Christine Quintana/Kamyar Pazandeh - 5:53 Zachariah Sterner/Hayley Rosenthal - 6:23 Dave Thomas Brown/Charissa Hogeland - 6:58 Carrie Hope Fletcher/Jamie Muscato - 7:35 Olivia Rose Michaels/Wendell Scherer - 8:12 Barret Wilbert Weed/Ryan McCartan - 8:48 (If there's a mistake, please tell me!)

i've literally been obsessed with this song lately bless this video

CARRIE HOPE FREAKING FLETCHER

I have a bias towards Thomas, but I'll put that to the side. Barrett and Dan, and Carrie and Jamie.

*gotta say I really love Barrett, Charissa, and Shelby* Also could you do “who sang the Shine a Light high note best”? Tbh I really like that high note XD

Why is the band so loud... they sound like they are yelling and I know that it is supposed to sound like that but like if I can barely hear then then what is the point

A hello to the new age of Veronica, Carrie ❤️

Carrie and Jamie for sure! They sound incredible individually and together and by miles are the best here

Barrett wilbert weed Jeremy jordan Thomas sanders Carrie hope fletcher

I’m so happy Carrie Hope Fletcher finally made it into one of these.

Please don’t hurt me for my list, but: 1. Barrett and Ryan 2. Hayley and Zach 3. Carrie and Jamie Honorable Mention: Barrett and Dan

for me, besides shelby brown, i’ve listened to seventeen so many times on repeat that only barrett sounds right singing it.

2:20 THEY ARE SOOOO GOOD LOOKING OMG!!!😍😍😍 6:31 THE BEST VERSION OF HEATHERS EVER!!!

Barrett and Dan will always be my favorite although Ryan McCartan does a pretty good job to.

West End Cast Recording. No joke, I love Barrett, but Hope did it. P.S.: I think Jamie Muscato is the thing there, he does it so right. And WECR has the best tempo and speech speed.

i miss barrett singing this song :(

Barrett and Dan 😍❤❤❤

I just think that Jamie Muscato​ is phenomenal

Y'all are sleeping on Thomas's harmonies.

Barrett is love, But my smol bean Thomas Sanders is there💕

I’m not exactly a huge fan of Charissa as Veronica, but I think her singing Seventeen with Dave Thomas Brown was amazing (I also loved him with Barrett more than Dan or Ryan tbh). Also Wendell and Thomas’ harmonies were amazing omg.

Oh no, the audio quality of Stephen Madsen and Jaz Flowers did NOT do Stephen Madsen justice!! I’ve had the fortune to see him live a couple of times in a number of different musicals and he has a GORGEOUS voice. His rendition of Seventeen with Hilary Cole (in the 2016 Australian production of Heathers) was, to this day, one of the best I’ve ever heard! But I was still so glad to see him in the compilation 😊 love your channel!!

i just love me some barrett and ryan

Barrett and Ryan and the Best ever but I love Hayley And Zach!! They’re probably the best small theater production of JD and Veronica!! 💚❤️💛💙🖤

Thomas Acting straight is the weridest thing.

I mean I may be biased because I am from the uk. So I am going to say carrie and jamie. But I also liked barrett and Ryan

7:35 must I explain myself? If I really must, too bad, because I MUST NOT- Carrie and Jamie will forever hold a special place in my heart.

The one at 2:35 seem extremely choreo based and stiff, anyone else agree??

Carrie and Jamie will always be my fave and I stand by that!❤️💙

I honestly have to say any with Barrett are my favorites, as well as the one with Thomas Sanders and the one with Jeremy Jordan

I haven't even seen the whole video but the originals and Carrie and Jamie from the UK production

8:32 was amazing stop sleeping on them

This is one of my favourite musical theatre songs ever! Thank you for this video!! Faves: Barrett and Dan, Taylor and Chet are awesome her voice is so strong wish we could hear him more!, I love Jaz Flowers' voice so much, Michelle and Jonathan sounded great together, Annaleigh and Jeremy literal icons how can someone not love them they're perfect!!! it was really fast tho, Hannah and Ian are so clear and gorgeous her voice is stunning, Shelby is very emotional and Charlie has a gorgeous tone, Zachariah and Hayley was the first production I watched on youtube after hearing the soundtrack so I love them for sure!, Carrie and Jamie I LOVEEEEEEEE ♥ ♥ ♥, WENDELL AND OLIVIA OH MY GODDDD YES? HIS NOTE I REWINDED HE'S SO GOOD I HAVE ChILLS!!!!!, of course Barrett and Ryan is so dear to my heart I love em.

carrie 👏 and 👏 jamie 👏 are 👏 everything 👏

My fave is definitely Olivia rose Michaels. That girl can hit some notes and it is very easy on the ears to listen to her. ❤️❤️❤️

Carrie Hope Fletcher, not doubt

Carrie is the best when you're not dealing with OfficialLondonTheatre's awful audio quality

My favorites were Barrett and Dan, Carrie and Jamie, and my surprise favorite Charissa and Dave

WOW 8:39 WAS SO SATISFYING TO HEAR. I am a fan of Wendell!

barrett will always be the best veronica in my opinion, but the performance by olivia & wendell was AMAZING

WENDELL THAT NOTE THOUGH

Have some of these been sped up? It seems like it but it may just be me😂

Olivia Rose Micheals and Wendell Scherer were reallyyyyy incredible

Okay, but Zachariah and Hayley are my favs

Haley and Zach for life!!! Although I do love Barrett and Ryan.

CAME FOR THOMAS AND WAS NOT DISAPPOINTED

I mean, shelby and charlie KILLED it! but Wendell’s extra harmony with Olivia caught me so offguard holy shit... but honestly Barrett and Ryan are my og characters ❤️

Can you do a comparison video of the ending climax of “Out There” from Hunchback? 😁

Barrett and Ryan are unbelievable, their voices match so well, but as does Carrie’s and Jamie’s, so i’d say them two!

CARRIEEEE AND JAMIEEEE👌🏼❤️

Each Time Barrett sung was the best

Barrett my queen!!! When did Annaleigh sing this tho?!

I love Barrett and Ryan’s version the best because I think Barrett just slays everything and acts it so well. Ryan compliments her voice beautifully and just makes it sound so soothing and it looks amazing

1. Hayley and Zachariah 2. Barrett and Ryan 3. Olivia and Wendell

Best to Worst: Barrett and Ryan Annaleigh and Jeremy Carrie and Jamie Barrett and Dave Barrett and Dan Olivia and Wendell Stephen and Jaz Dave and Cait Dave and Charissa Thomas and Nicole Zachariah and Hayley Christine and kamyar Taylor and Chet Michelle and Jonathon Shelby and Charlie Hannah and Ian(the speed ruined it)

I want to do a cover of this with my friend and can I just say JD's part is HARD here. He doesnt even get a break before the super long note so MAD props to anyone who plays JD

4:14 wow o wow slow down there

7:05 I cant help but imagine ghost Chandler telling JD not to kill anyone nicely

I love Haley Rosenthal and Zachariah Sterner. idk, maybe its because i saw them sing it first.

I’m a sucker for some Carrie’s voice, so hers is probably my favorite out of the Veronicas. Barrett Wilbert Weed is a close second tho.

Zachariah will always be my favourite JD!

Barrett and Dans will ALWAYS be my number 1🤧❤️ literally the og

Barret and Ryan is always gonna be number one for me. Just mainly because of the emotion in their singing and not to mention their harmonies.

ARE WE JUST NOT GONNA NOTICE HOW WENDELL JUST BUSTED IN AND STOLE THE SHOW

Yassss Carrie and Jamie😍😍

CARRIEE!!!!

I know who did it the best Mariah Rose Faith and Robert Manion