Who wrote the Pink Letter?

Подписаться 729 тыс.

Просмотров 119 тыс.

50% 1

Explore the best of fantasy and sci-fi in depth, with analysis of the worlds of Lord of the Rings, Game of Thrones, The Witcher and more.
For more A Song of Ice and Fire content: • Secrets of Winterfell ...
Join me on Patreon - / indeepgeek
My channel for live content, including interviews and weekly livestreams - / @idglive
My audiobook channel: The Well Told Tale - / thewelltoldtale
Follow me on:
Twitter - @indeepgeek
Instagram - indeepgeekofficial
Facebook - / indeepgeek
TikTok - @indeepgeek
For merch, audiobooks, and all things In Deep Geek, explore my website - www.indeepgeek.com
Thank you to the talented artists who allowed their work to be featured in this video. You can find them and buy your own prints by following the links below:
Ertac Altinoz - www.inprnt.com/gallery/ertaca...
Amok - / amokrus
This video was brought to you with support from my amazing Patreon community - special thanks to
Stephanie Frederick, Joshua Clark, Maura Lee, Rabbi Rob Thomas, Amelia Scales Brooke Geer Person, Josh Bielemeier, Jane, Vance, Amy Southerland, Ivie Hilburn, Jimmy, Vercingetorix, John-Paul DeLuca, Filbert, Frank Glad, lemmy101, The Lady Gordon, Edward Ryan, Stephanie B, Coleen, Ben Androvich, Nana L, Brennan Barnes, Ivanka Hainzl, Howland’s Little Sister, Charis Messalina de Valence, Donna Daley, Cade Norman, Murray D, NOscar, Rick Hoppe, Leathery Wings, James Pisano, Bridget Boyle, TheStarkInWinterfell, Ellemcee, Alannah Prestayn of Braavos, Raymond Joy, Jonathan Harrison, Petyr Pebble, Jason Mauleon Rosario, Milton Christopher Appling, Edward Ennett, Katy Smith, 26Artgirl, Karen Thomas, Rickon, Cathrine Furseth, James Fitzpatrick, Doug Hughes, lawnduck20, Perseffanie, Emily Mole, Lady Dane, The Late Escapist, Natalie Donald, J. Gregory Henderson, whalawitsa, Luna Cascade, Dan MacKay, Johnny Targs, Kevin Warner, Julie Bernard, Bear, Susan Lonergan, Bo Riley, Lyle Hammac, Alex Butter, Pam Peterson, Bettina Charlotte Nielsen, T boz, Angela Marie Young, Sarah Awesomesauce, Stephanie Erickson, KaliKo_Jack, SeaGreenMango, GeorgeRRTolkien, Antihero Association, Richard Woodard, Caiden Timmons, ThatVBGuy, Tyler Barnhart, John H. Austin, Jr, NikFromNJ, Ty Farnsworth, Beesman, EJ, Willow Button, Julia Kendall, Jonny Ceriani, Mary Frances Angelini, Emma Sheiman, Joseph Jones, Christine Denny, Julien Dubois, Leland, Max Kingdom, Tricia Brady, LiK, Simen Dalstein, Scott Maraldo, Shelley J, Karen Wennerlind, Nathan Drumm, Martin Sjöstrand, Kristen H, King of Imps, Minerva Gale, Eric Nelson, Michiel Venema, Kate, Brandie Roberts, Kendra Summers, reed m, Commander Ray, Mayra Lawson, Lola Roebuck, Mark P, Nicole Stewart, Norse Sultan, Rasler, Steven Spaulding, Your Last Great kNight, Patrick Ward, Amy vh Hines, Slippery1989, Una Haller, Almo71, Ravi Kakarala, Jacob Culp, Janet Lyn, NikFromNJ, Magepie, Ms. Fox, Jon Greenwood, Jahan, Justice, Courtney, Biscuit Jones, Biscuit Jones, Cookie Tywyn, Ranabir Mitra, CRChesnutt, Kip Ingram, Savannah Smith, Tadeo D'Oria, Mario Murray, Leland, AaronM127, Denis Warner, Callie Summers, Gena Z, Joseph Barresi, Karen, KGO and Martin Maleček
Affiliate Links - (buying books from our Bookshop.org shop supports this channel and local bookshops at no extra cost to you.)
Books for fans of A Song of Ice and Fire:
uk.bookshop.org/lists/a-song-...
Other books we love:
uk.bookshop.org/shop/indeepgeek
Thanks for watching!
(All pictures used are in the public domain, or used under fair use copyright laws, or with the express permission of the artist).

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

4 апр 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 461

@dabestestgoblin8495 2 месяца назад

George RR Martin wrote it.

@AshwinMisra 2 месяца назад

r/technicallythetruth

@austinhall3937 2 месяца назад

You beat me to it by 4 minutes

@dabestestgoblin8495 2 месяца назад

@@austinhall3937 I mean, its not like we invented the joke, it had to be commented eventually.

@asmundfryen7636 2 месяца назад

Hot take, Doubt tbh

@elbruno3515 2 месяца назад

It is known

@pbDEMON 2 месяца назад

My favorite theory is that Ramsay wrote a letter, but not the one that Jon actually received. Bowen Marsh and his cadre were becoming increasingly pissed off at Jon for his decisions regarding the Night's Watch, and were looking for an excuse to stage a coup. Ramsay wrote a letter to Jon containing MOST of what was said in the pink letter, but it was intercepted by Bowen Marsh and re-written with new details and more inflammatory language in a bid to get Jon to do exactly what he did. This explains why the pink wax was smeared instead of a nice button, why the letter was in the wrong handwriting and in maester's ink, and why there were details that only Ramsay could have known, and also details Ramsay could not possibly have known. It explains why Clydas was terrified of giving the letter to Jon. Marsh probably made him write the doctored letter. Plus, it just seems in GRRM's style to have a clever explanation to a mystery like that.

@finhese 2 месяца назад

Very plausible

@yorletsinnavtube 2 месяца назад

@@finhese This is the best theory amongst all of the ones that are out there. Every other theory has some kind of flaw in it. It's just too bad that we're never going to be able to know the truth.

@Munax. 2 месяца назад

I never heard of this before but it makes a lot of sense.

@hounsdjentlow3074 2 месяца назад

I've never heard this but to me this literally makes PERFECT sense

@Rougarou99 2 месяца назад

Just to add to this, learning via Ramsay’s real letter that Mance was, presumably, alive, might have been the straw that broke the camel’s back.

@derekcampbell4209 2 месяца назад

I thought it was kinda known or accepted that Hodor is the only person that makes sense

@greengenes5129 2 месяца назад

it is known

@mrx2817 2 месяца назад

Dear Hodor, Hodor. Hodor . Hodor . Sincerely, Hodor

@ThailandOutsider 2 месяца назад

Yeah but these mad tinfoil types just won't accept the obvious 😅

@reidcacaro2919 2 месяца назад

“Hodor hodor”-Hodor Jon snow-“WHO FIGHTS WITH ME”

@user-qv4bp7vg6u 2 месяца назад

@@greengenes5129it is known

@eric2500 2 месяца назад

I admit I did not think that Mel as a candidate for the letter writer, though she is the ONLY one who knows for sure about Mance NOT being burned, aside from John and Mance himself.

@fal2218 2 месяца назад

But how she could know about reek?

@dougdupont6134 2 месяца назад

IDG says it was Mel's idea but Mance actually wrote it. So Mance would know about Reek

@JunMoo1993 2 месяца назад

Who's John ?

@danielriley7380 2 месяца назад

@@JunMoo1993Jon Snow. Don’t be pedantic, that’s my job.

@danielriley7380 2 месяца назад

@@fal2218Melisandre does in fact possess magic, but she’s been trained in tricks to enhance people’s belief in it. She could possibly have seen Theon in the flames. Let’s not forget Thoros has resurrected Beric several times, Moqorro heals Victarion’s hand, and Beric revived the dead Catelyn Stark. So there is probably some ability to see visions in the flames, though not perfect.

@kriegsmaschine4050 2 месяца назад

A schizo theory of mine is that the letter comes from someone within the night's watch. They wanted to bait Jon into breaking his vows so they'd have an excuse to kill him. The guy delivering the letter was shaking because he knew he was now complicit in a conspiracy

@Poindexterous 2 месяца назад

Except they don’t know who Reek is or the fact Mance is alive.

@user-fv4fm5qm1u Месяц назад

@Poindexterous there was another comment saying Bowen Marsh received the letter and changed it a bit to get Jon to take the bait. So Ramsay did write the letter, Bowen Marsh added to it.

@Matty-pn9fy 19 дней назад

@@user-fv4fm5qm1uthat sounds like the best theory to me

@alexjames7144 13 дней назад

@@user-fv4fm5qm1u I'd imagine it must be more than just Marsh working alone, the watch respond very quickly. Almost as if they were ready.

@markshepherd4791 2 месяца назад

Literally looking at my bookcase a minute ago deciding if I read the series again, guess the universe answered it😅

@kanjil110 2 месяца назад

I’m reading it again after listening to these videos so much has become clear!

@ashleyofnaath 2 месяца назад

Ultimately I believe Lady Barbrey Dustin penned the letter, but Melisandre is my dark horse. For all the reasons you mentioned, and one you didn't- to precipitate the rebirth of Azor Ahai; something she believes is necessary to save mankind. When Mel says she "prays for a glimpse of Azor Ahai but R'hllor shows her only Snow", the 's' in "snow" is capitalized- implying she's referring to a person, ie Jon Snow, rather than the weather. It's possible she came to her senses and realized Jon is the savior rather than Stannis, and decided to act after seeing Jon transition from "man to wolf to man again" because that depiction showed him "coming back", so she know her resurrection ritual would be successful. Plus if she saves Jon, then how could he question his need of her anymore? Anyway, those are just my thoughts. Great video!

@KingSlayer_. 2 месяца назад

It's a good theory for Mel. Though I'm not sure what would make her change her mind on Stannis. I think eventually Mel will realize Jon is Azor Ahai, but it probably won't happen until it's revealed that his true parents are Rhaegar and Lyanna. I think Ramsey probably did just write the letter. Barbery Dustin doesn't know Jon. The night lamp theory is probably what's really going on. 7 days of battle!?! That's the part that really stands out for me. It would have been an hour of battle given the forces. Stannis is no fool and he was confident of victory in the Theon sample chapter. The Freys were lured onto the ice and once it started to break because of the catapults, the white harbor men kept them from retreating by taking them in rear. It's almost too perfect. This victory will be a massive and well needed morale boost to Stannis's army. After that they take Winterfell unawares, sending in there own men through the gates disguised as the Frey army. By the time Roose Bolton and Ramsey realize what's happening it'd have already happened. It's going to epic

@ashleyofnaath 2 месяца назад

@@KingSlayer_. Well, in my head, what makes her change her mind is realizing that R'hllor never shows her Stannis when she asks for glimpses of Azor Ahai; she only sees "Snow", meaning Jon Snow. That's what I meant by highlighting the importance of the 's' in snow being capitalized, because it changes the connotation of the vision/the passage explaining it. Something else that's noteworthy- the Pink Letter uses the phrase "false king" to reference Stannis. Melisandre is one of only two characters in the story to use that phrase in her speech (the other is Wyman Manderly). So it's another indication she could be the author. As it pertains to Lady Barbrey, she doesn't need to know Jon to have written the letter. For a variety of reasons, I think she wrote the letter on behalf of Lord Wyman and the other co-conspirators within Winterfell, and Rowan the spear wife (whom I believe is Rowan Umber, long-lost daughter of Crowfood Umber) was their source for intel about events and people at the Wall. In other words, because Barbrey's co-conspirator Wyman needs Jon at Winterfell, she'll write the letter to Jon since Wyman can't. Wyman is watched by Roose and doesn't trust his maester; Barbrey has been given free reign in Winterfell because Roose needs her alliance, so he does things to keep her "happy". She'd need that "freedom" to access the ravens undisturbed. Also, Barbrey writes her own letters so she wouldn't need to make end-runs around a maester she can't trust to do it. Lastly, I believe she sent the letter during Lord Wyman's skirmish with the Freys after Little Walder's body was found. She was conspicuously absent from the Great Hall at that time, so I'm betting that whole thing was a diversion so she could send the letter undetected. The timing lines up perfectly with Jon receiving the letter several chapters later.

@Dapryor 2 месяца назад

I never considered Lady Dustin but that’s an interesting thought. I enjoyed her minor storyline in Dance.

@aes0p895 2 месяца назад

@@ashleyofnaath unless she wrote the word Snow out, and the capitalized version was an in-world quote, then I wouldn't assume that. Although I admit it's hard to think of a reason it would be capitalized by Martin otherwise, except as a red herring.

@MDMDMDMDMDMDMDMDMD 2 месяца назад

Any theory that requires Mel to competently interpret her visions is a stretch

@pyropulseIXXI 2 месяца назад

That letter made legitimate threats to the Night’s Watch. Taking care of that threat is not breaking vows. That said. I think the anti-Jon Night’s Watch wrote the letter and Clyde knew this or was even forced to write it, which is why he was terrified. The smeared wax means it was open and resealed as best as possible. A real letter came in and was opened and manipulated to get Jon to go south.

@alexjames7144 13 дней назад

It is still breaking their vows as their prime objective is to watch the wall. Politics comes second, protecting the wall will always come first

@AshwinMisra 2 месяца назад

One of my favourite topics of discussion in ASOIAF, Robert. Thanks for another one. :)

@muffingfx 2 месяца назад

One interesting candidate I've seen rarely mentioned is Lady Dustin, she at one point I think had an opened letter and Bolton seal in the snow. Her being with Theon and him telling her she is still a contender against Roose could make her write it, but I don't see any reason why she would

@TheIndieKitten 2 месяца назад

Does she know about Mance's fake death though?

@muffingfx 2 месяца назад

@@TheIndieKitten The only way I can see her knowing about that is if Mance as Abel was captured and tortured, or one of his spear wives if they know. The only problem with this is that this can be said also for Ramsey being the author

@lanestapp2 2 месяца назад

Her and mance are working together. Along with the knowledge of what the umbers and manderlys are doing. Wyman didn't have a singer and that's how mance got in.

@Enbionic_Titan 2 месяца назад

Mance definitely wrote that letter. That's where I'm at

@simontaylor2143 2 месяца назад

I agree, though Mel might have ordered him to do so. Either that or this is his scheme to break free of her, possibly even in the hope the wildlings will now mutiny and free his family

@GoogleUserOne 2 месяца назад

Preston Jacobs wrote it

@jamesgabrielson473 2 месяца назад

Yeah, from the Tower of Whatever before it was torn down to build a rock-boat-rocket that picked up fish men from somewhere.

@clownpendotfart 2 месяца назад

Ramsay writing it is entirely consistent with Stannis surviving the battle, since in the Winds of Winter preview chapter Theon I he told Justin Massey that news of his death in battle may arrive, but to continue his mission regardless. Melisandre herself wouldn't know the name "Reek", so I agree she wouldn't have written it herself. The problem I have with the theory that it was intended to get Jon to join Stannis in battle is that if Jon believed Stannis was already defeated, then he had terrible odds for victory himself as Ramsay would be able to accomplish a defeat-in-detail like Robert Baratheon did repeatedly in one day near Summerhall (only Ramsay has more time to recover). Since Ramsay would expect to win such a battle, and he would control Winterfell's rookery from which letters are sent, the simplest answer really is the best one: he wrote it. He keeps talking about Mance because it is so shocking to Northern sensibilities for the Lord Commander of the Night's Watch to spare the wildling king who attacked the Wall and send him south against a Northern lord. Since Jon is murdered by watchmen who hear about this, Ramsay's calculations of its political implications would appear to be correct.

@darkwolve114 2 месяца назад

May be why she ultimately decides to resurrect him. If it was her direct deceitful actions that got Jon killed then she might've been required to by her religious beliefs and practices. It wasn't her intention to cost his life but she was responsible. Knowing that would make her wanna balance all that out somehow.

@aes0p895 2 месяца назад

Or more importantly, it may be why the God decides to.

@leandrocastello309 2 месяца назад

Many of mely's powers are unknown to even herself, maybye she gives him the same fire funeral that the lighthing lord recived and resurrects by accident.

@awesomehpt8938 2 месяца назад

It was either Barbie, Hodor or Mord. Maybe even Sir Pounce.

@second_floor_basement 2 месяца назад

Probably Moon Boy for all I know

@Hero_Of_Old 2 месяца назад

Nah, Mushroom.

@kasparkrycek7953 2 месяца назад

Ser Pounce definitely needs more page time imo

@sirius9423 2 месяца назад

It was Shagga. He fed the goats and only then did he send the letter.

@johnpotts8308 2 месяца назад

Euron. I mean, he's done everything else...

@richardtabor8686 2 месяца назад

Yus! I like how you made it a a story and lead us through your thought process. ty again.

@JervisGermane 2 месяца назад

I don't think we have enough information to know who wrote it yet. It's chronologically the latest chapter we have, which means it could be motivated by things we haven't seen happen yet. Not to mention characters could have the knowledge to write it who don't have that knowledge "yet". The inclusion of Reek is confusing for everyone. As I just said in another comment, not only has Jon never heard of Reek, but all the potential writers would know that. There are basically enough details included to rule out all of them, until we get more information.

@benkellman4577 2 месяца назад

This is why I think it’s Mance. He’d know ‘reek’ escaped winterfell and was on the way back to the wall

@melissaisloud7404 2 месяца назад

Love these revisits!

@xenosaga8436 2 месяца назад

Sadly, we'll likely never find out who wrote the letter. It's been around 13 years since A Dance with Dragons came out. Some of the samples chapters that have been released were originally in Feast for Crows/A Dance with Dragons and were cut at some point, so Martin has been writing it for over 13 years.

@juanetenecio 2 месяца назад

It's the anti-Jon faction of the watch, with information and recycled pink wax they got from a real letter from Ramsey. Clydas is one of them.

@dustinhamilton2816 2 месяца назад

Well that's a good one.

@FlorianMark 2 месяца назад

I was to write it was Marsh but I comment to push your answer. I may add it is very possible they saw thrue the glamour of Mance when he didn't wear the bones. Mel mentioned to him how important they are and the next time we see him he has but it on. Mance doesn't follow commands easily but maybe he thought someone was suspicious of him.

@DavidbarZeus1 2 месяца назад

How would they know about Reek and the faked death of Mance though?

@lanestapp2 2 месяца назад

The warm cloak line between barbrey to theon a few chapters prior about the crypts that also appears in the letter seem to be a dead giveaway about who is behind it.

@dim391 2 месяца назад

With the Pink Letter theory, over time I feel that whoever wrote the letter wanted to get Jon killed, not really encourage him to head to Winterfell to take back the castle from the Boltons. My issue with the theories that it was Mance, Melisandre, Stannis, etc., is that it implies that their intentions were to simply ‘motivate’ Jon to leave in order to “rightfully” take back Winterfell. The problem I see with this is that all of them (and most characters in general) should be aware of the oaths that brothers of the Night’s Watch take; one of the main ones being that abandonment of the Watch resulting in execution. So why would any of them risk Jon’s life when they know that creating a fake Ramsay letter will just trigger Jon to leave Castle Black and get him killed for leaving the Wall? Would any of them not consider the repercussions of having Jon being motivated to join in the conflicts of the South when he is the Lord Commander of the Night’s Watch? It just doesn’t make sense that any of those characters would assume everything would just go smoothly if Jon just got up and left the Watch. And for those that might say that if Melisandre wrote the letter, it was because she saw it in the flames and was just giving the push Jon needed to leave, that doesn’t add up because she would still be fully aware of the Night’s Watch oaths - or those that say Mel needed to intentionally get Jon killed so that he can be resurrected, become R’hllor’s champion, and fulfill the Azor Ahai prophecy; for one thing it’s obvious that Mel still sees Stannis as Azor Ahai (despite the visions she gets of Snow), and there’s no indication that she knows that she has the capability of resurrecting anyone. Lately for a while now, I lean more towards the possibility/likelihood that whoever wrote the Pink Letter was a member of the Watch who was angry at Jon for everything he did up until that point (big one being the passing of the Wildlings through the Wall), and gathered other brothers who felt the same. I know it simplifies this whole theory and makes the result feel “underwhelming,” but Martin is an intelligent writer that would rather create a scenario that makes sense, than a situation that is simply for shock-value.

@lastofgiants 2 месяца назад

The only hole that would need filing is how one of the black brothers knew Mance was not only alive (they saw "him" burn) but that he was sent on a secret mission to Winterfell with exactly 6 women. It's definitely possible for someone to learn these things, but who and how?? I've been thinking about this a lot lately

@colincarmello9751 2 месяца назад

How would they know about Reek?

@dim391 2 месяца назад

@@lastofgiants Very true. That would be one of the flaws in the theory that it was one of the brothers. Maybe they overheard that conversation. I really don’t know.

@dim391 2 месяца назад

@@colincarmello9751 Absolutely true. Maybe there was some interaction between the Night’s Watch maester and Stannis’s camp through ravens? Or maybe Stannis has a mole at the Watch. Really not sure. It’s frustrating how even the simplest theory that a brother of the Night’s Watch wrote the letter still has as many flaws as other theories 😅

@Mwezi828 2 месяца назад

Why would Mel have an issue with Jon breaking his oaths? She doesn’t know he’s Azor Ahai. She’s concerned about his life because she believes from the flames that he is crucial to Stannis’s fight. Specifically, she has seen him fighting in the flames at Winterfell. As Robert explained, the letter is a way for her to achieve this goal. She isn’t a black brother, and has no reason to care about Jon keeping his vows or about any repercussions he might face after he has done what she believes she needs him to do to help Stannis. Even if she did want Jon alive, she would probably expect Stannis to pardon Jon and make him Lord of Winterfell after they win - he already made the offer, and a king has that power.

@gaghhuh2943 2 месяца назад

One thing that I havent yet heard mentioned is that it might have been someone from the watch. One thing that is very obvious to me is that they wanted to kill him before the letter (there are many proofs including ghosts behaviour or that the wun-wun incident seems staged) so maybe they decided to write the letter to convince everyone else in the nights watch that jon is a deserter. Because jons reaction to it would be obvious to everyone who knows him. I feel like the person who wrote it had to know that jon would be in danger. I still think that Mance is more likely but it is possible...

@samuelleask1132 2 месяца назад

Great stuff as always robert

@youcefmoulla1828 2 месяца назад

We need more videos like this, before the winds of winter ❤

@RoxanneLaWinSTABBY 2 месяца назад

I like this theory. I’ve *only just* finished ADWD a couple of weeks ago, so it’s fresh in my mind, and my own theorising is recent. I like this one, except for one line: ‘and I want my Reek’. Who knew about Reek outside the Bolton coterie? Yes, Melisandre could pooossssibly have magicked that information to herself, but from what we know, her messages come from deciphering images in the flames, not names and not something as unexpected and complex as ‘your foster brother, who as far as you know killed your brothers and burnt your home down, was being kept as a plaything by this PoS, but he escaped’. And even if she had somehow found that out…in the letter it just says ‘Reek’. Why would Jon care or even know it was Theon, if it was part of a means to get him down to winterfell? I don’t have any solid theories myself, though, so this is more than I’ve come up with. My initial thought was it was someone he was beefing with within castle black, who wanted reason to get stabby on Jon…however the Reek thing, and also knowledge that Jeyne had escaped put an end to that line of enquiry. Who also knows they’ve escaped and seems to be an ally to The North though? The hooded man?

@ragingcyclone369 2 месяца назад

This is the detail that I get stuck on myself. Who at the Wall would know about Reek?

@Mwezi828 2 месяца назад

The idea is that Mel sent Mance with instructions to write the letter, she didn’t write it herself. That’s why there’s the wildling lingo and all the Mance talk. Mance knows Reek - him and the spearwives have been interacting with him in disguise and ferreting out gossip and rumours from the people in Winterfell. He also knows that Theon escaped with fake Arya. So it’s possible that Mance is adding all of this as realistic flavour to make the letter convincing, or more likely the letter is also supposed to serve as a way of communicating to Melisandre some important information he’s learned.

@RoxanneLaWinSTABBY 2 месяца назад

@@Mwezi828 Oh yeah, I’d forgotten that the spearwives had made it inside and to Reek already. Menopause is a hell of a drug. Ok that’s something for me to ruminate on now

@JervisGermane 2 месяца назад

@@RoxanneLaWinSTABBY This is the most difficult detail for me too. Jon's never even heard of Reek. Not only would Jon not know who that was, but all the potential writers would know that. It's a weird inclusion for any of them. That's why I still say we don't have enough information to know who wrote it.

@carlrood4457 2 месяца назад

@@JervisGermane I think the why of it might be of less importance. Before we ask why, who needs an answer. At this point, the only ones who potentially have ALL the information contained in the letter is Mance. Sure he or the spear wives might have broken under torture and revealed the information, but there isn't much reason for him to be that detailed about Mance in the letter. From his standpoint, "Arya" would be Jon's greatest motivation to come south, not Mance. If the writer really believed "Arya" was in Jon's custody, they'd know he'd have LESS reason to impulsively ride south. If Ramsay wrote it and believed that, then the jig was up. Jon could send ravens to expose the lie. There's also the meta question is why would George spoil so much in advance? That's the question if Ramsay were the author.

@badgoosegin 2 месяца назад

Your videos are always a blessing 👏

@louiscassis3426 2 месяца назад

I tend to think that it was Stannis. Mainly because he said to Dareon that “you may hear that I am dead”. He knows that there will be some false news of his death.

@BenMedia7 2 месяца назад

But he goes on to say that it might be true. Besides, Stannis doesn't seem the type to emotionally manipulate Jon instead of just asking for help

@louiscassis3426 2 месяца назад

@@BenMedia7 You May be correct. Although, Stannis knows that he could die at any time from battle. He could be growing more desperate with his situation and decided that he needed to up the ante with Jon. Once again, you may be correc but……

@edwardslater2252 14 дней назад

"And I want my Reek" He's like what Daryl was to Negan. I gotta get me my Daryl back!

@blacksheep9505 2 месяца назад

It was Patchface. “The shadows come to dance my lord, dance my lord, dance my lord. The shadows come to stay my lord, stay my lord, stay my lord...”

@kneau 2 месяца назад

"come and see"

@daviejohnstone12 2 месяца назад

I love idg. Preston nailed this!! Where are we going?

@lyarrastark6254 2 месяца назад

Thank you, Robert.

@AndrewK23777 2 месяца назад

Great vid as always IDG , look forward to more and more of these redone versions of previous videos of yours. And i do agree, surely Mel seems like the brainchild of this operation / letter. It fits her motivations and methods like deception , manipulation , fear / playing on emotions. The motivation obviously to get Jon to help her champion / claimant Stannis who is absolutely up against it facing oblivion at Winterfell. Especially without Jon's potential help / aid. The knowledge of what the letter mentions seems to line up with Mel as well. The repeated use of "false kings" also a bit of a giveaway and points to Mel as she's used that phraseology previously (sounds like Free folk terminology as well). Mance I agree with IDG could be the actual writer , it does seem extremely Mance centric the contents of the letter, the knowledge of such goings on especially after being down in Winterfell for a bit and vernacular lines up with Mance as well. Not sure if Mance ever referred to the NW as "black crows" but certainly would have the knowledge of that term having been among the Free folk for so long and a former NW brother himself as well. Plus could have chosen to incite extra anger out of Jon by using that term. And i do agree Ramsay is very unlikely , the knowledge of certain concepts & events doesn't line up with Ramsay so much , the vernacular and the the physical writing seems off. Also the lack of the proper Bolton wax seal , it was clarified as simply a smear of pink wax. Some of the methods and threats don't really line up with Ramsay either. Some departures from previous letters of Ramsay shown as well. Think you are spot on Robert as usual.

@TheRamsesII 18 дней назад

Very interesting analysis. I'd always taken it at face value, but you make a very good argument. Hopefully, we will all find out for sure one day.

@danydandany2640 2 месяца назад

Game of Thrones still going on with u Thanks man 😊

@jackcoogan310 2 месяца назад

Maybe, just maybe… it was Bloodraven/Bran. Maybe Jon dies at Hardhome, maybe he needs to unite the north first

@lqnumber1 2 месяца назад

Love in deep geek forever

@thehonestaspy102 2 месяца назад

I love this theory as it makes far more sense than Wyman sending it and it would mean Mance is, for the moment, alive and well as I find him a fascinating character.

@BasicallyBaconSandvichIV 2 месяца назад

Hey, this is a bit unrelated. But have you ever considerd doing a video on the Discworld?

@eric2500 28 дней назад

I am convinced now, it starts with Stannis and the letter gets intercepted by Watch dissenters who want to make Jon angry enough to quit the Watch, which is punishable by death, so they rewrite and reseal it. Poorly.

@elizabethford7263 2 месяца назад

If Bran is eventually King because he is the memory of the world, then Nan held those memories and passed them to him until he could reach Bloodraven.

@marjoe32 2 месяца назад

Okay now we are getting DEEP

@Moos398 2 месяца назад

Amazing video! Will you be making videos on Dance of the Dragons? Any how, looking forward to all future videos!

@Ivbo 2 месяца назад

I always thought it was the nights watch men who were growing to hate Jon, they wanted him dead, they just needed an excuse to kill him.

@lawrencereid2767 2 месяца назад

You saw they casted dunk and egg 🥚

@alex39786 2 месяца назад

This is the one. Ladies and gentlemen, we got her

@willu842 2 месяца назад

Another fantastic video, as always. But can you please answer what happened to your playlist "Robert, Lyanna and all that"? I was like halfway through watching those videos and now they've disappeared :(

@MatthewBester 2 месяца назад

My money is on Ser Alliser. He was sent away by Commander Mormont but only temporarily. Plenty of time to learn the goings on in the rest of Westeros along his journey and he loved saying BASSted!

@andrewward5891 2 месяца назад

In the books Alistair was executed with Janos Slynt for disobeying Jon’s orders after Jon becomes Lord Commander. So he’s off the list of suspects

@goldenvrpca7962 Месяц назад

@@andrewward5891 No, he was not executed, he refused to protect Slynt.

@WhoIsCalli 2 месяца назад

I always thought it was Mance. But what’s funny is this was the first ever mystery I got into after reading the books. Fun to think this consumed my mind directly after finishing the books for the first time 😅

@inquisitorgarza312 2 месяца назад

It probably was a group effort on everyone parts and it probably will nevertheless be a mystery which Jon will be very eager to solve once he returns.

@leomesser415 2 месяца назад

This video was so good

@ebonywilliams5116 2 месяца назад

Love the videos ❤❤❤ what happened to the Travelers Guide videos

@AlexBB77 2 месяца назад

Robert recently announced he took them down and redoing the series. Not sure if the old ones still available on Patreon or not.

@wobblesman4316 Месяц назад

Lady Dustin conspired with Mance to write it. That’s why the black crows terminology is there.

@petemtb9637 2 месяца назад

In Deep Geek: Who wrote the pink letter? Show version Alliser Thorne: I did. Book fans: Who will write The Winds of Winter? Arya Stark: No one.

@stephaniefrederick1180 2 месяца назад

Nice job, Also… 700k In Deep Geek…..10k In Deep Live…..congratulations 🌝

@osirisrexx2336 2 месяца назад

Whenever I see an In Deep Geek video starting with "who", a part of me expects the answer to be Littlefinger. Are we sure it's not Littlefinger? 😆

@ThailandOutsider 2 месяца назад

I like the idea that that Mel had something todo with it, im pretty convinced it was Mance acting alone but if Mel put him up to it I wouldn't be shocked

@andrewward5891 2 месяца назад

Slightly off topic but I think the show did a much better job with Jon’s murder than in the book. In the show Jon’s assassination is masterminded by Alistar Thorne (who in the book had already been executed by Jon for disobeying orders. Thorne sets up Jon by having Ollie (who is Jon’s steward and has Jon’s trust) that a wildling has info on Jon’s uncle Benjen (which Jon would be very interested in). In the Book Jon Is just gang stabbed by a bunch of stewards angry at him for abandoning the watch.

@stanisawjarczyk5995 2 месяца назад

Wasn't this video realese earlier? I ask becouse i remember that i watch thos video once but i couldnt find this video.

@BigRob1994 2 месяца назад

Is this a reupload? I feel like I’ve heard this video before, still worth revisiting though

@flairian4528 2 месяца назад

I think you really glossed over Manderly being the possible sender. Ur reason that the letter knew too much about manse is dumb, because if manse was caught there are fair chances that there was some sort of hearing or discussion amongst the lords, where this information would have been given to manderly. Also how would manse have gotten a raven? Or gotten that raven to mel only? Manderly would have access to the ravens because hes a lord. Also why would mel want to send john away from the wall, when it’s heavily hinted that by the end of dance she thinks he is azora ahai? Also, how would mel or manse have access to the wax of the boltons, Manderly would more likely be able to get some. And more easily be able to mimic ramsey’s mannerisms, because although the mannerisms aren’t exact in the letter, they at least seem to be decent at mimicking ramsey, so how would manse or mel be able to do that?

@erikr2252 2 месяца назад

If you’re revisiting old videos relating to Mel can you look into what she meant by “waking stone dragons” next haha?

@ThommyofThenn 2 месяца назад

Interesting how there are several mysterious letters in ASOIAF which contain stuff so proactive they elicit some very passionate responsds. I like to think Aegon's dorne letter is a lil nod to Jon's true heritage

@jordanbauman-putnam9524 2 месяца назад

Probably the biggest inplication for ramsay not writing the pink letter is there is no mention of asha greyjoy...like at all. The biltons would surley want asha grayjoy as a prisoner, if they captured her they would have bragged about it in the letter, if she escaped they would have demanded her too.

@BenMedia7 2 месяца назад

I think GRRM had different ideas about who wrote the Pink Letter, so he kept it ambiguous about who wrote it. If I had to pick though, Mance seems like the most likely option.

@Ruosteinenknight 2 месяца назад

I was first thinking littlefinger, but then it hit me: wouldn't he try to set Jon and Stannis against each other, rather than bring them into an alliance? While using Stannis's ambition get rid of Ramsay would serve littlefinger's aims in short term, in long term there's a possibility of grateful north emerging to support Stannis's claim. Littlefinger is out to get it all, and getting rid of one obstacle and replace it with a huge one doesn't bode well for those plans. It would be far better for him to keep Jon away from Stannis. So Melissandra seems far more likely candidate.

@goon8058 2 месяца назад

I was under the impression Jon has already seen a letter from Ramsay's hand. If that is the case the omission of him not mentioning that the handwriting is different suggests that it is the same jagged scrawling handwriting.

@Efreeti 2 месяца назад

I've been thinking Mance.

@whiskeybravo91 2 месяца назад

my money's on The Three-Eyed Raven, he knows they're running out of time and he's trying to speed things along

@rachelhithere8768 2 месяца назад

My just-kidding mental gymnastics guess is Littlefinger bc it would be Funny and on-brand. Seriously, I want to believe Mance wrote it specifically that way to signal to Jon "hey its me, where's my people"; maybe I'm underestimating Melisandre but she doesn't strike me as THAT clever, although I do concede that the evidence is definitely there.

@richardtabor8686 2 месяца назад

I'm intrigued by this so much. I think it was someone at Castle Black. Very interested in what IDG has to say on the subject. ty so much for the content.

@RoxanneLaWinSTABBY 2 месяца назад

I’ve landed on the same theory myself, that it came from Castle Black, especially with how ready they all were to get stabbing. The one thing stalling me, though, is who would know there’s a Reek, and that he and Jeyne have absconded? I might re-read that chapter again, even though I only finished reading the entire series a couple of weeks ago.

@richardtabor8686 2 месяца назад

Hhhhhmmm...all I can say is if Mel WAS corresponding with Mance at Winterfell, that would be the source of the "There's this dude named Reek who just escaped and Ramsey is FURIOUS." But...hhhhmmm...Great question. Thinking on it myself now...

@RoxanneLaWinSTABBY 2 месяца назад

@@richardtabor8686 Someone in another comment reminded me that the Spearwives had made it into Winterfell, and they were likely reporting back to Mance outside the walls, who then sent the letter. They could have told him about Reek, and that he escaped with fake Arya. He could’ve added those details to make it look more authentically from Ramsay…but…Jon doesn’t know about Reek and the escape, so it would’ve been pointless flavour? I need to re-read the chapter and have another think about it myself. In this process though, I’ve been wondering more about The Hooded Man. Could he have sent the pink letter? Could he be Mance?? ETA: WAIT!!?! Can Mance read and write? I know he was a Black Brother, but I’m not sure of his background before that? To the wiki I go.

@johnnytakisawa 2 месяца назад

@@RoxanneLaWinSTABBYyou might wanna re-read those chapters again....

@TravisBrady-wn8fr 2 месяца назад

Kidney pie crumbs curiously stuck on the letter

@Casper_That_Guy 2 месяца назад

love your videos! wish they were longer than 14 minutes

@AlexBB77 2 месяца назад

Robert does 2.5-4 hour livestreams / deep dives on his live channel IDG Live most weeks. And some of his older content used to be 30-60 minutes the non-live vids. So seems like he is changing it up with much of the new content or redone versions of videos he has done before , like this one.

@michaelbayer5094 2 месяца назад

I love the videos too, but they only need to be as long as necessary. IMO, shorter works better. He can always do add-ons and follow-ups.

@JDempsterRacing 2 месяца назад

The final chapter, little did we know it would be the last ever

@natie3322 2 месяца назад

Bowen Marsh. The Assassins were ready and waiting for the excuse. He and some Crows found out about Mance, and Bowens old friends were killed by Jon. B had access to all old letters. He got access to the new real Ramsey letter then forged one tailor made to give them a reason to kill Jon. Then he had that letter delivered. The man who delivered it to Jon was very upset….But jokes on them. Jon had Mel glamour Tormund and Jon to replace each other. They killed Tormund while Jon’s shadow was attached to him.

@SennaHawx 2 месяца назад

Wyman Manderly, Barbrey Dustin & Mance Ryder wrote it together.

@eric2500 28 дней назад

Think Mel dictated the letter to Mance long distance via her neck ruby?

@walterattridge1637 2 месяца назад

Excellent vid and a testament to the depth of GRRM’s writing. But ultimately I think it’s from Ramsay because of the mention of Reek. Reek is a particular fixation of Ramsay. Someone using Ramsay’s name for political reasons would have no reason to mention a superfluous slave. Ramsay, in a psychotic desperate rage, would demand Reek be returned

@neodigremo 2 месяца назад

I would presume the letter (assuming it is not Ramsay) was written by Mance Rayder for Melisandre in a type of code. The length of the battle etc would be about setting up a meeting point. The reason for the code is to not give it away to Ramsey if he intercepts the letter. That is the letter is not exactly about getting Jon to do anything. It is about telling Melisandre what needs to be done in order to help them get "Arya" out of Winterfell. It was addressed to Jon only so it would definitely be read and to avoid the awkward suspicion of "why is someone like Ramsey writing to Melisandre?" I kind of hope so as well, as I like it more when things are not about Jon and when the characters don't care about him so much.

@LSK1 2 месяца назад

Great

@Andystuff800 2 месяца назад

What's the reason for the repost? I know you've made a video on this before.

@greghurlbut7017 2 месяца назад

Question: Of the following characters, who knows about "Reek"? Melisandre, Stannis, Mance, Alliser Thorne? If Alliser knows, then I'm pretty sure he's involved.

@Rigel560 2 месяца назад

Another great video, buckets

@avielp 2 месяца назад

You're amazing

@mrsnulch 2 месяца назад

Ooohoho mama I've been waiting for this video.

@JimmyLundberg 2 месяца назад

The pink letter was written by a horse.

@yohbre799 2 месяца назад

And it's probably Bojack horseman

@chpet1655 2 месяца назад

It’s been so long since I read this book and even cared about the books that I haven’t a single emery of any of this lol I’m sitting here watching this video saying t9 myself what ? Did this happen ? I suspect I’m not alone. JRR Martin has severely tarnished his reputation and legacy as an author outside of the HBO series.

@lanestapp2 2 месяца назад

It's Lady Dustin with mances help. She's one of the only people that know ravenry which is necessary, has the Bolton seal, it uses the term crows, had theon show her where mances was hiding along with the warm cloak reference, seemingly is secretly pro stark, as she always wanted to be one, hates Ramsey, spearwives calling theon kinslayer. Really there's only a few people who can be involved just based on being able to send a raven.

@rbparks 2 месяца назад

I think it’s as simple as it appears, it’s just Ramsay is lying that he defeated Stannis.

@ThommyofThenn 2 месяца назад

7:10 when you inspect your optronic data rod more closely

@CJusticeHappen21 2 месяца назад

John is "Good Snow", and Ramsay is "Bad Snow." The Strong Reap what they Will, and the Weak suffer what they must.

@rycolligan 2 месяца назад

The most convoluted plans having the most disastrous unintended consequences is very much in keeping with the themes of the series. I could buy Mance writing it with Melisandre’s instructions. It’s even plausible she could dictate it to him via the ruby bracelet. If only Winds would come out. Ever.

@elbruno3515 2 месяца назад

14 Minutes ago, nice Thx for uploading

@V-is4Val 2 месяца назад

I feel like Mel of all people wouldnt have missed the detail of the other letters being written in blood....

@sackal86 2 месяца назад

Jon wasn't stabbed because he broke his oath. The reason was that he read the letter and told everyone that Stannis was dead. Marsh and the others had not killed him before because they knew Stannis would definitely kill them if they did. As soon as they learned of Stannis' death, they assassinated Jon.

@Loreweavver 2 месяца назад

Edit: nevermind I commented before the end of the video. I agree with you. :Edit It wasn't Stannis. It would completely go against his character. It may have been someone from his camp but not him. I suspect it was Mance Raider after infiltrating Winterfell and getting access to Ramses seal. I'm not sure what exactly his game plan is but I think it was him.

@Alsadius 2 месяца назад

Is this a re-upload? I feel like I've seen this video before.

@SamButler22 2 месяца назад

I'm pretty certain it's Mance. That it was Melisandre's plan? I'm not as certain, but I hadn't previously considered it and it is plausible.

@ewdew1386 2 месяца назад

Im Sorry but i want to ask something unrelated to this Video; am i just stupid or is the playlist about Roberts Rebellion no more? I recently wanted to rewatch it but couldnt find it, is there a reason?

@rasmusasd3868 2 месяца назад

26 seconds ago is crazy

@lluewhyn 2 месяца назад

I must confess that I believe it was always Mance, but I didn't consider that Melisandre might have been involved. There's just too much there that Ramsay wouldn't know about, or even care about if he did. This is where the defense is "He was tortured for the information" comes in. But, when would he have had time? Why would Mance *volunteer* information that Ramsay wouldn't know to even ask about, like his SIL or infant son? At best, Ramsay might have gotten "Who sent you?" from torturing Mance. From a narrative perspective, why is the letter so friggin' long? If George intended Ramsay to be the writer and wanted us to believe it, he could have just included a single paragraph. Instead, the letter goes on and on and on, and Reek and his "Arya" are almost afterthoughts. Also from a narrative perspective, why did George bring back Mance at all if he was going to have such an ignominious end (giving up his SIL and child just to stop the torture)? We're led to believe Mance is executed, and then find out that he actually survived and has quite a few talents and skills. Why all the mess with the spearwives? Some of the details mentioned in the letter also sound like a misdirect by George. "Of course, Mance was captured and the spearwives slain! We saw where an alarm went up while Theon, Jeyne, and a couple spearwives are up on the battlements trying to escape". But why was Mance still sticking around able to be caught in this scenario? As soon as Theon lied to Jeyne's guards about Ramsay wanting Jeyne bathed (so they could start the escape plot), the clock was ticking. At any moment the ruse could be discovered, and the guards would point directly to Mance and his "Washerwomen". So, it seems more likely that as soon as Theon and crew were headed up towards Jeyne's room, Mance was already on his way out, possibly to the crypts he's so concerned about. We also know that one of the six washerwomen (Squirrel) has likely already escaped before the alarm goes up, as she was going to descend from the window as soon as everyone else left the room. Why would Mance write it? Well, we know from TWOW preview that Stannis seems to be preparing some kind of ruse where he wants to let Ramsay think he was killed in battle. What if Mance is in the castle and believes it as well as Ramsay? If he can get Jon Snow to march down and do something about it, Mance can capitalize on it. That's why he also demands to have his SIL and son brought with Jon. We also know from Melisandre's POV that she very specifically points out that wearing a symbolic piece of attire of the one you're attempting to mimic will aid with the disguise glamour (i.e. Rattleshirt's armor). So, Mance might be wearing the chains of the Maester in Winterfell, which is why he would have access to writing a letter.