Why does math exist? | Stephen Wolfram and Lex Fridman 

to see the ideas begin to emerge during the first couple minutes is wonderful

I feel so lucky to live in this amazing time! Such incredible ideas in my pocket!🤯😂

Thank you so much, Lex and Stephen. This is what traditional tv failed to offer us.

this thumbnail wins life

3:47 From what I understand Wolfram is saying is: All that we know/experience is what there is. If there is computation such as basic mathematics, its apart of our consciousness's imagination, due to OUR interpretation of the universe. (from out point as humans) Well, maybe, a way to step out of this (a very small way) is to study other consciousnesses. Such as animals. Of course there isn't a whole lot to gain studying a goat. But if you can study something with a mental prowess that rivals that of a human. You can get a pretty interesting insight...Take a magpie, with its superior memory. Or even a chimp who has better short-term memory than most human adults. We really question what our own capabilities are... our intellect is top on this world. But there are animals who have better memory, better reactions, better problem solving. Better mental capacities in a lot of ways. Take an octopus who would lay eggs and may wait years just starving to death until the conditions in nature are perfect for the eggs. Risking all harm and death until they, who once hatch leave the mother nothing else to do but die in peace. That mental prowess is rarely witnessed in humans. A goat has a very small brain. It is know as one of the more stupid mammals of this earth as according to us humans. I myself made the connotation, saying little is learned from studying them. Yet a newborn goat is brought into the world with its food source being that of a pasture(after its rearing is finished). A pasture has many different plant species. Many of them are toxic. Some would easily kill a goat if it ate to much. Some even if it ate little. So tell me, how does a newborn goat, or any goat know exactly which plants are toxic and which are not. It knows which plants have more nutrients in general and will favor them. How is it that they know this? Instincts? Okay but put a human in a pasture and tell them this is all their source of food. That human dies quicker than a goat. What is intelligence worth, where instincts and heartiness easily compensate and then some. Goats have won a very very niche branch of this world's game. We humans are stuck on this intelligence path and we are burning in the late game... smh...

These are the questions whose answer I'm always searching for. Nice work Lex sir!

Stephen Wolfram is easily one of the greatest scientific minds alive. I am personally thankful for his work. His wise thinking helps me clarify my own thinking.

Fun conversation!!

been rewatching 1:30 to 3:20 over and over and i get glimpses

I've only watched the fist 7 min and will need to finish it later, but my first thought is that 'stuff' does have relationships to other 'stuff' and math is the language we created to describe relationships.

A grande Nazaré pensante!

Perfect thumbnail

Settle this in the Octagon….Wolfram v Fridman…Let’ssss Go!

brain hurty

I suggest to the esteemed interviewer and interviewee to read GODEL ,ESCHER ,BACH The meaning of the + sign stems from the fact that there is an isomorphism between its mathematical meaning and reality as we understand it.

Math exist in our minds and in our reality. So powerful yet eternally elusive.

Fantastic interview, but I have the distinct impression that Lex isn't understanding what Wolfram is saying half the time--like when he says it seems like you should be able to "step outside the Ruliad." This indicates to me that he isn't correctly modeling this idea that "formal definition" and "actuality" are indistinguishable. I.E. If you can imagine something, it means it can be formally defined through some set of rules that construct it, because imagination itself is a form of computation. From there, we simply recognize that all of our experiences of the universe amount to imagination, which is why none of us can say that we aren't living in a simulation. Our reality boils down to the things we can perceive, whether externally or internally. That perception is a feature of the formal system, because the perception itself is a computational process that is embedded within the structure. It need not be "instantiated" anywhere for that relationship to exist. This instant you are experiencing right now could be sitting on a hard drive stored away in some alien's basement, and the next instant could be stored on another hard drive in some other universe. And it wouldn't actually matter if it was stored anywhere, just like both of those hard drives could store portions of the sequence of integers, but that sequence itself exists independent of any particular substrate that models it. It simply exists in the space of possibilities that emerge from formally definable rules--i.e. the Ruliad. We only perceive anything because portions of the Ruliad have the intrinsic property of self-reflectivity--just as some cosmologists have said: We are a way for the universe to reflect upon itself.

There is the logical aspect and the quantitative aspect. Logic exists because people found that they needed a reliable framework with explanatory and elucidatory power when taking for object the universe as we experience it. Quantities exist because not everything is one, at least on the surface.

excellent thumbnail, kings

0:16 - The moment I heard that statement, Godel's Incompleteness Theorems came to my mind. Am I the only one? Is there anyone that I can discuss this?

0:03 me in math class be like

Dammmmm tou put Nazaré meme in the thumbnail :OoO

Tried to watch this during lunch, my brain hurt.

If there were no determinism (plus, zero, one, axioms) at all, then we certainly wouldn't exist to wonder about it.

Mr.Wolfram needs a course in logic and declamation--he obfuscates when it isn't necessary.

Dig It

drink every time he saids mathematics 👀

New drinking game: Take a drink for everytime he says mathematics.

This could be the fundamental foundation and natural theory of Fissucks

Why wouldn't it?

It's probably me being a bit thick, but I got the impression he struggled to answer this question.

I think it started once we began living in larger and larger groups, over time. Naturally counting all your siblings, children, and neighbors.

Mathematics is a language. Mathematicians understand the language and use it to describe phenomena. It is a condensed language; so for example the word 'plus' in english translates to + in maths.

blackholes are a CPU crash in the simulation.

I'm probably wrong, but I think there's a much simpler explanation for the invention of math. I think humans started to realize that there were plenty of recurring patterns in nature and also in human interaction. Therefore, humans needed a system of language that defines and records these recurring patterns. Hence, the creation of math. Of course, since it's inception humans have gotten really creative with math and have experimented with it and pushed it to learn all that it can do and it's limits, at the end of the day it started as a system of language to define and record recurring patterns.

They ask questions beyond my comprehension.

Reminds me of an Avril Lavine song.

Why do people keep answering questions like what is math in one short comment? Can't you clearly see that brilliant minds are struggling with it?

lex i can tell you EXACTLY why math exists that you could not refute but you'll never see this

Mathematics is a language to describe a subjective reality...

This is how far a Brazilian meme can go...

What is the relation between math and logic? I tought math was a subset of logic but not a synonym; however, that might be untrue.

Math doesn't exist, but mathematics or maths does.

Nazaré

Math is the beginning and the end of all things. Math is the onl thing that is certain to exist. The real question is how, from the abyssal eternities of uncomputability, universes like us become possible

Math exist in our attempt to better understand the workings of our universe

Lex 'that's what a human would say' Fridman

If math didn't exist, the universe wouldn't be able to exist. But, if there is a place where math doesn't exist, physical existence itself would be impossible, so, life wouldn't develop, and there would be no conscious observers to see that there is no such thing as math. It might be a bit lazy of me, but if we apply the anthropic principle here, we can allow for a possibility for a reality without math, but in such a plane of existence, life would be impossible.

Math is the stuff of nightmares lol

Hahahaha what gets you excited dude haha!

mathematics

Math rules!

Why does math exist??? Easy. Blueprints to understand this thing we call universe

Seems like they're over thinking it. Math is a language that was invented by people to describe the universe. It doesn't exist in anything but people's thoughts. The universe doesn't use math to do what it does.

I actually think the opposite. If mathematics exist, universe has to existm

Math is universal.

Solved ages ago.

Take a shot for every time we hear the word "mathematics".

Math is man made it's nothing but human expression same as time these two aspects are human constructs

Hahaha ape float on rock ahahahahaha

It exists because you have to do taxes every year.

Elephants are NOT necessary objects

Why is math? Is my stripper name

"В начале было Слово, и Слово было с Богом, и Слово было Богом. Оно было в начале с Богом. Все, что существует, было сотворено через Него, и без Него ничто из того, что есть, не начало существовать." Lex, you really should have someone on the podcast who can talk knowledgeably about the religious implications of physics and math. At the core, the universe is just a set of abstract rules. "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was with God in the beginning. Through him all things were made; without him nothing was made that has been made. "

I think it was "invented", not "discovered". It doesn't need to exist for the universe to exist, it's simply the best representation we have been able to come up with to describe many of it's complexities.

This recording studio is tribe members only

Is this guy a lawyer?

Lol, math exists so humans can build things that work, that is why math exist 🤣 😄 😂, such a complex answer to answer a fundamental question

Yeah Mr.White.....Science!

Shorter answer: Mathematics shows us how God does things

incredibly hard to follow mr. wolfram cuz in the middle of every sentence he interrupts himself and starts of smth else instead of completing the though

Not very original, nothing new

Is this not a waste of time, shouldn’t you be taking this moment to solve actual problems? So many resources are wasted in pointless pursuits and useless outlets

lex i can tell you EXACTLY why math exists that you could not refute but you'll never see this