Why does this balloon have -1 holes?

Подписаться 1,2 млн

Просмотров 1,3 млн

50% 1

Thank you to BetterHelp for sponsoring this video! To get 10% off your first month of therapy, go to betterhelp.com/standupmaths to sign up today.
If you are need of urgent mental health support please check for crisis help lines available in your country.
USA: www.mentalhealth.gov/get-help...
UK: www.nhs.uk/mental-health/advi...
Do check out Jordan Ellenberg's book Shape. This video was inspired by Chapter 2.
www.nytimes.com/2021/06/21/bo...
www.jordanellenberg.com/book/...
Support me on Patreon and I will post you a free torus balloon. I hope I don't regret this. / standupmaths
Here is Sam Hartburn's geogebra file: www.geogebra.org/m/yjtjxr2n
Trouser animations thanks to:
Bentley Davis BentleyDavis.com
Em Raymond / techcavy
Kalina Panteleeva kalinadoesc...
Thanks to Visual Topology & Geometry for "Punctured torus homeomorphism". • Punctured torus homeom...
Me cutting two joined cylinders in half way back in 2015. Good times. (At 29:29.) • Four Dimensional Maths...
CORRECTIONS:
- When talking about the Euler Characteristic of the torus at 16:29 I say the value of zero is "only on our friend the torus" which is technically wrong. In the moment I was just talking about the sphere and the torus but loads of other shapes have an Euler Characteristic of zero. Like the cylinder.
- I'm undecided if the string method of thinking about holes at 17:04 was helpful. I could have talked about the dimension of the boundary manifold, but that felt like I was repeating the previous bit too much and wanted a different way to think about it. Not sure if this counts as a 'correction' per se, but I just needed to talk to someone about it. Thanks for listening.
- Let me know if you spot any other mistakes!
Filming and trouser sewing by Alex Genn-Bash
Editing by Michelle Martin
Graphics by Sam Hartburn
Doughnuts later eaten by Matt Parker
Music by Howard Carter
Design by Simon Wright and Adam Robinson
MATT PARKER: Stand-up Mathematician
Website: standupmaths.com/
US book: www.penguinrandomhouse.com/bo...
UK book: mathsgear.co.uk/products/5b9f...
Nerdy maths toys: mathsgear.co.uk/

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

29 июл 2021

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 3,5 тыс.

@standupmaths 2 года назад

It's true. I have the world's supply of torus balloons and I'm posting them free to all of my Patreon supporters. Sign up before 7 August and get a balloon full of holes! patreon.com/standupmaths

@theBestInvertebrate 2 года назад

I see what you're up to, buying up the supply of torus balloons so that the only way to topologicaly indulge is to go through you, nefarious.

@theBestInvertebrate 2 года назад

I jest.

@derekkuldinow5790 2 года назад

Where'd you get that shirt, Matt?? Is it something particularly interesting or just a nice design?

@mikeblank8034 2 года назад

I'm curious because you label the toroid loop as both a 2d hole and a 1d hole, is that correct? If that is the case then does the straw have both a 1d and 2d hole also? Love your videos! 😊

@feliciabarker9210 2 года назад

Controlling the world's supply of toroidal balloons is the next step in your descent to maths supervillainy.

@collin4555 2 года назад

"Topology is a very big area of mathematics" Yeah, but it's continuously deformable into a small area

@simono.899 2 года назад

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

@zeus1962 2 года назад

Good one.

@timwest788 2 года назад

Boom

@archivist17 2 года назад

Badoom tish!

@archivist17 2 года назад

That's a bit of a stretch!

@johnbeauvais3159 2 года назад

“The jam inside this donut is not mathematically relevant” this might be my favorite line ever

@KrackerUncle 2 года назад

Because we cant answer if there is any. Its schrodingers jam.

@jmr 2 года назад

That could have been a line from an episode of "The Big bang Theory".

@jmr 2 года назад

@@KrackerUncle Your response could have been a second line

@olliephelan 2 года назад

The jam fills a hole though. Or at least it should

@ainidirieiais 2 года назад

@@KrackerUncle in this case, it is mathematically relevant :)

@BlankPicketSign 2 года назад

Captain: "HOW MANY HOLES DO WE HAVE IN OUR AIRSHIP?!" Me: "Well first let us explore the Euler Characteristics of the..." Also Me: *Gets thrown off to my death

@LAK_770 2 года назад

I’m liking this steampunk novel so far, keep it up

@arrowed_sparrow1506 2 года назад

@@LAK_770 unfortunately it becomes very one dimensional later on.

@datpudding5338 2 года назад

@@arrowed_sparrow1506 at least the flight path has double the dimensions xD

@gildopesce Год назад

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH

@mihailmilev9909 Год назад

@@LAK_770 where is the rest of it lol

@grug57 Год назад

The jokes, the maths, the visual aids - I just love this video as a whole.

@K1lostream Год назад

You missed the opportunity to say the ways you love this video are many-fold.

@grug57 Год назад

@@K1lostream the math in this video is so great - you couldn't poke any holes in it

$@fractional_factorial1539$

@fractional_factorial1539 Год назад

As a hole*

@E-AnyaForger Год назад

Me smirking at the thought of visual aids :)

@grug57 8 месяцев назад

@@dot1298 thats what im sayin

@kitludd465 2 года назад

dont apologise for confusing trousers and pants, after all topologically they're the same

@OriginalPiMan 2 года назад

I was thinking the same. I'm glad I scrolled far enough to find someone with the same idea.

@rhamph 2 года назад

Don't forget the g-string! Trousers is pants is g-string.

@andrewsparkes8829 2 года назад

@@rhamph Ah, but that depends on how lacy the g-string is.

@vigilantcosmicpenguin8721 2 года назад

Just wearing my favorite punctured torus.

@OriginalPiMan 2 года назад

@@andrewsparkes8829 Well if you're getting into those kinds of specifics, then jeans have belt loops that are holes, and then pants and trousers are not necessarily topologically synonymous.

@subnatural5341 2 года назад

Topologist jokes before: "Topologists can't tell a doughnut and a mug apart." Topologist jokes now: "Topologists can't tell jeans and g-strings apart."

@vigilantcosmicpenguin8721 2 года назад

Topologists are never going to see anyone in a g-string anyway.

@badlydrawnturtle8484 2 года назад

@@vigilantcosmicpenguin8721 That's just it, though; they see EVERYONE in a g-string.

@skyjoe55 2 года назад

@@badlydrawnturtle8484 if there wearing a skirt wouldn't that be the same as wearing a mug?

@FireStormOOO_ 2 года назад

@@skyjoe55 I can see the animation in my head now. Send help

@dielaughing73 2 года назад

@@skyjoe55 that'd be an annulus

@GiatrasKon 9 месяцев назад

Man, Swiss cheese must be the bane of topologists' existence

@frankhooper7871 2 года назад

It took me a while to realise that you were using the balloon as a model of a sphere - my first thought was that the balloon was in essence a disc as I was considering that it could be flattened topologically once you untied the place where you blew it up.

@RobertShippey Год назад

Yes I was the same.

@MrEscape314 Год назад

Yea I agree. The balloon was a disc to begin with.

@gw6667 Год назад

Yup, he started cutting a hole and I was like, "hey, wait, what? Oh, sphere."

@danieldaugherty918 Год назад

right I was like "no the balloon is a disc and now it has 1 hole"

@spicyoreos74 Год назад

Me too

@firestormdb 2 года назад

"I have bought the world's supply of toroidal balloons" sounds like the world's daftest supervillain plot

@darksoles1305 2 года назад

Or a math word problem

@jorgepeterbarton 2 года назад

Or a fetish

@danielled8665 2 года назад

@@jorgepeterbarton that was literally in a show about weird fetishes. Ah, balloon guy…

@sweetpot8a 2 года назад

Underated comment

@dak_black 2 года назад

Doofenschmirtz

@SquareWaveHeaven 2 года назад

"When you put a hole in something, the number of holes goes up"

@standupmaths 2 года назад

- Matt Parker, 2021

@michaelhutson6758 2 года назад

Unless... there's such as thing as a NEGATIVE hole...

@EphraimP 2 года назад

Unles you add a hole to a net then you have less holes

@ManjotSingh-sf2ri 2 года назад

@@EphraimP well u can still have more holes if you drill a super narrow hole with a needle into the threads so that they dont break

@Smitology 2 года назад

@@michaelhutson6758 There is. If you add a "cavity" in something, kinda like a cyst, that's not exposed to the surface, that's a negative hole.

@JollyGreenWizard Год назад

What this video really teaches us is how to turn the decorations and snacks for a small party into a tax write-off

@mbyard356 2 года назад

Well, now I know why I wasn’t able to find any “donut balloons” for my kid’s birthday party. Gee, thanks Matt! 😂

@tuffcat8572 2 года назад

True story? He ruined so many plans with that.

@pyglik2296 2 года назад

The worst thing about topology is drawing with markers on doughnuts.

@oldcowbb 2 года назад

i literally screamed NOOOOO

@deyesed 2 года назад

Squeak squeak

@tremkl 2 года назад

I was terrified he was going to do that, but he only drew on a bagel, which is slightly less bad.

@anuragjuyal7614 2 года назад

@@bland9876 damn! 😂😂

@guepardo.1 2 года назад

Not to mention ruining a pair of perfectly good trousers.

@Xalies 2 года назад

I think he's ability to break a bagel perfectly on the line is underrated

@dandynoble2875 2 года назад

I think that speaks more to the low quality of the bagel than his ability. Pretty easy to break the yoga mats they call bagels you find at the grocery store.

@necaton 2 года назад

*his

@Lampe2020 2 года назад

I also wondered how he got that perfectly flat breaking surface!

@theentertaner 2 года назад

I read this before i watched the video and was waiting for him to split a bagel down the middle but as a normal person would if they were to eat it

@mattomanx77 Год назад

He knew EXACTLY what he was doing bringing in a torus balloon and saying "Things are gonna get a lot worse" Things always get worse when you start bringing those in

@themightymcb7310 2 года назад

Whenever the "holes" type questions came up, my first critical thought on the question was immediately to consider that straws and clothing are 3D objects, which immediately complicates things for me in such a way that I'm honestly just out of my depth. This video helped me work out some of the more abstract ideas around topology. Good stuff!

@ahorribleperson3302 2 года назад

"Things are gonna get a lot worse" *Ominously brings out a second balloon*

@jeremiahevans4175 2 года назад

Oh no...

@brandon.duffany 2 года назад

I laughed so hard

@embers_falling 2 года назад

A hole lot worse

@mr.johnson3844 2 года назад

I can't believe he established a temporary monopoly on the distribution of *torus* balloons in order to make being his Patreon supporter more desirable. This is peak economics.

@user-pr6ed3ri2k 2 года назад

taurus balloons

@wcbq Год назад

taurus balloons

@user-pr6ed3ri2k Год назад

@@wcbq i agree

@omegonchris Год назад

@@user-pr6ed3ri2k the shape is called a torus. Taurus is a zodiac sign and constellation derived from the Latin word for a bull.

@user-pr6ed3ri2k Год назад

@@omegonchris ur late to the convo he said taurus balloons before probably hinted by the fact that the comment was edited and the word torus is bolded out

@dinoeebastian Год назад

I'm astonished at how he's able to hold a doughnut in his hand without eating it

@jaisenroa4219 Год назад

you could tell that he wanted it when he was holding it

@reaganduggins5279 2 года назад

This is easily one of the best, most intuitive explanations of any topological concept that I have seen.

@MmKayUltra1 2 года назад

You keep asking about the pair of trousers but never told us the number of belt loops which I feel are important.

@theBestInvertebrate 2 года назад

I mean he kinda did, as you can see from the animations and it's euler's characteristic it has no belt loops.

@H2SO4pyro 2 года назад

@@theBestInvertebrate Then you'd have to wear them with suspenders, which add 2 additionnal holes. So they'd be equivalent to 2 trousers glued back to back, or a 4 legged trousers

@ericbsmith42 2 года назад

Also, almost every pair of trousers has at least one button hole.

@FineOtter 2 года назад

Maybe they were jeggings the whole Time?

@mydemon 2 года назад

Its a mathematical pair of pants.

@DeathlyTired 2 года назад

If the barrier to entry to a subject is that you've got to be as smart as Poincaré , Riemann, Betti & Noether, I think, at that point, it's acceptable to simplify things a bit.

@jako7286 2 года назад

Yeah, people like me, who don't know their asymptote from a hole in a graph need to keep things simple.

@MrAlRats 2 года назад

Most people believe that P is not equal to NP. Which means, in essence, that the ability to verify the solution to a problem is trivial compared to actually coming up with the solution in the first place. Developing the mathematical framework for studying a class of problems is considerably more difficult than merely understanding it after it has been fully developed. More or less, what one person can understand any other can as well. The only barrier to entry to any subject are having access to content created by those who understand the subject and self-motivation.

@angelmendez-rivera351 6 месяцев назад

The entry barrier does not require you to be as smart as Poincaré, Riemann, Betti, and Neother, just as how the entry barrier to using a computer does not require you to be as smart as Claude Shannon (there are plenty of idiots who know how to use a computer).

@wombat4191 2 года назад

30:00 and it becomes even more creepier when you imagine how someone would wear them when treated as the same shape as regular trousers.

@Martin_Huetter 5 месяцев назад

as a 3D artist working with 3d objects and surfaces every day and "morphing" them into flat 'sweing patterns' (UVspace) this is in a very weird way super fascinating. Explains really well how you would map a flat texture (a plane) onto a torus.

@pauldubois0 5 месяцев назад

This is my problem with the jeans animations. The original jeans can be uv mapped with no seams, which I guess is another way of saying they can be embedded in the 2d plane. The sewn-legs jeans cannot. So, if they are modeled as surfaces rather than volumes, they must be different shapes.

@DrTrefor 2 года назад

This is such a fun intro to the Euler Characteristic! I think it's kinda sad that so often we don't expose students to these accessible ideas from topology until late in an undergrad program, but there is no reason it can't be explored way way earlier.

@MuttFitness 2 года назад

I got a BS in math and learned none of this

@Necrotoxin44 2 года назад

@@MuttFitness As it turns out, mathematics is full of a lot of different disciplines, haha. I also got a BS in math, but at my university I concentrated in 'pure math', and so I did learn this stuff. It would depend on your concentration, but I could also well imagine a more general and spread out math curriculum might miss some of this stuff.

@MikehMike01 2 года назад

probably because it’s totally useless outside math

@jajssblue 2 года назад

Completely agreed!

@zacharym7000 2 года назад

I've always found maths sorta dry but stuff like this makes me genuinely interested. I love seeing people take complex subjects and break them down for the laymen like me.

@mokopa 2 года назад

11:51 Matt apologises to blue balloon for being mean to it about calling its homology class horrible 13:18 Matt continues insulting balloon's homology class right in its face

@Scootfairy 2 года назад

Yeah Matt really tore him a new hole.

@krzysztofwysocki76 2 года назад

Hi, regarding 2-d holes mentioned at 18:00, how about explaining this as "how many gases you can fill in the spaces created by manifold without mixing them together?" for instance you can have oxygen inside the sphere and nitrogen outside, which defines the number of 2d holes of sphere as 2.

@blackmber Год назад

You might have to subtract 1 because the sphere and the torus each have 1 two-dimensional hole and can separate 2 gases.

@angelmendez-rivera351 6 месяцев назад

This is mathematically inaccurate. As demonstrated in the video, the number of 2D holes of a sphere is 1, not 2. The Euler characteristic of a sphere is 2, but this is because spheres include 1 0D hole. 3D space can always be filled by 1 gas without mixing, in the absence of higher dimensional holes. Introducing one 2D hole allows 2 gases, but it can get complicated once you also introduce holes of other dimensionalities.

@ar_xiv 7 месяцев назад

I like that the hand drawn animation actually got it the most correct by showing the transition to the figure 8 “cord”

@ThePlacehole 2 года назад

Patreon exclusive: Matt wears the mathematically "equivalent" trousers.

@dathaniel9403 2 года назад

He’d be an honorary member of the Ministry of Silly Walks.

@dwagincon4841 2 года назад

You been the onlymaths exclusive

@MuzikBike 2 года назад

jesus

@katyungodly 2 года назад

Someone would be into that 😂

@ashtonhoward5582 2 года назад

I think you'll find that that's on his OnlyTopologists channel.

@Devlinator61116 2 года назад

"Whenever you put a hole in something, the number of holes goes up." *Nets have entered the chat.*

@parodoxis 2 года назад

You'd have to stick a needle into the rope to split it in two, yes forming another hole. Just tearing the rope in one spot is tearing the net, not really "putting a hole in it" though we say it that way

@TatharNuar 2 года назад

Fabric is just a really tight net.

@parodoxis 2 года назад

@@TatharNuar by a loose definition, yes, and in that sense the fabric of reality is nets all the way down. But if we don't stop somewhere and just call it a "surface", none of the stuff in this video applies.

@karl810 2 года назад

@@parodoxis fish net tights get holes all the time, I cant think of any other way of explaining it, they're definitely holes.

@parodoxis 2 года назад

@@karl810 if you consider the fishnet to be one fabric, sure. But if you see the net as a bunch of holes, then no, you have not created a hole, you've actually joined two or more holes. Thus the number of holes goes down, thus you're losing holes not adding them.

@valentincorman1578 2 года назад

Now I wonder how the machine to make the toroidal ballons looks like. Great video, super interesting content, as always. Thank you!

@syriuszb8611 8 месяцев назад

As engineer I often encountered word "manifold", especially in CAD programs. I never could get a solid explanation, and after a while I just assumed "it's just a thing, a shape" but never thought it was actually correct enough to have mathematician agree with that poor definition! But I learned today that it unifies shape name between dimensions.

@Sicarine 2 года назад

And then the sequel. "How many holes does a punctured Klein Bottle have?"

@theBestInvertebrate 2 года назад

I think 0?

@BlueBeBlue 2 года назад

It's a really good ideia, maybe it has a 3d hole? Idk

@Nerketur 2 года назад

Given that it's made from connecting two mobius strips of opposite directions, I think two. Puncture and it becomes two joined mobius strips. So from 0 to two

@samuelthecamel 2 года назад

@@Nerketur You can't put one hole in it and get two more holes! (Or maybe you can. Idk, I'm not a topology expert)

@Noname-67 2 года назад

2 holes, it'd be 2 mobius strips or an annulus and a mobius strip, it hard to imagine but 2 holes either way

@rickseiden1 2 года назад

"So it's like they're all the members of the same one terrible homology class." "There is only one true parabola!"

@nanamacapagal8342 2 года назад

Cue the illuminati-esque spiritual experience.

@quacking.duck.3243 2 года назад

Gloria in x-squaris.

@nanamacapagal8342 2 года назад

@@quacking.duck.3243 NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

@GaryFerrao 2 года назад

😂 that was his best video ever. his beginnings of video editing. look where he is now 😎

@sankang9425 2 года назад

@@GaryFerrao lol. He basically shoved in every sound and video effects that he could use

@Mr_pumpkin_ 2 года назад

🤣 7:26 "have some fun with the trousers up and down"

@angulinhiduje6093 10 месяцев назад

i do a bit of 3d modeling, i used terms like "non manifolds" without every questioning them. to me it was just the software term for "mistakes" that created holes. very good video

@leorussellmoore3329 2 года назад

"Now, from personal experience, it's pretty hard to draw on a doughnut. It's a lot easier to draw on a bagel. Although technically, still a doughnut." - think this has to be my absolute favourite Matt quote now. Had to pause the video cause I was laughing too much.

@nixel1324 2 года назад

I'm pretty sure I remember the video where he learned that, the one where he turned a bagel into two interlocked rings.

@TheTallCurlyOne 2 года назад

"Ignore the fact that there may or may not be jam inside of this doughnut, that's not mathematically relevant." You say while not confirming the jam status so it's now in some schrodinger's doughnut superposition shenaniganry. Which to be fair is still not mathematically relevant.

@hyperfox0934 2 года назад

*exasperated physicist sighing*

@grepgrok8735 2 года назад

Actually, if there IS jam and we consider the doughnut to be exclusively dough, then the jam creates a void (aka 2d hole) which would make the doughnut a sphere instead of a solid ball, which is extremely mathematically relevant. Thus, a doughnut hole (aka a solid bit of dough) is what he should have used to represent a ball.

@brendanh8193 2 года назад

So, to say this poetically, "is the jello hollow? Such states set said Schroedinger superposition shenanigans sour." Or to quote that great poet, Homer, "Doh!"

@joewilson3393 2 года назад

I wonder if I can look up any of my old math teachers and get their opinion on the mathematical relevancy of jam? I'm sure that won't be a strange question coming from a student 20 years later....

@ReimerGodt 2 года назад

#AlfFromMelmac would love Schrödingers cat oven backed, filled with plum jam. I believe.

@jakecarpenter1838 Год назад

A topologist dips his mug into his doughnut

@stephenj9470 2 года назад

I understood very little from this video. And yet I watched it to the end, because Matt is so mesmerizing.

@craigstephenson7676 2 года назад

I would recommend you don’t get sponsored by better help again. The organization is very shady and overstates the level of involvement actual experts have. There are plenty of RU-vid videos explaining this in further detail

@MarieKaltoft 2 года назад

Bumping this in hopes he sees it!

@vladimirlenin843 2 года назад

It's alright No one is gonna use it

@cretinousmartyr3522 2 года назад

Yeah just let him collect these paychecks and skip the ad if it bugs you, but since it does matter, I think the message he delivers during the ad read feels more like a "seek counseling in if you feel you need it" more than "go use my better help link" compared to many other ad reads and that's a respectable message I'd say

@Applecraftpro 2 года назад

@@RobABankWithABagel The problem isn't as bad anymore, if you watch the phillp defranco update he did at one point he says they have majorly improved and have made there marketing clearer so while he still wont be doing sponsorships with them he doesn't think other creators should be discouraged from doing so. If you want more info you can watch his video but basically while they still have a bad rep and honestly I probably wouldn't use their services, they have fixed the issues so there isn't really any moral problems with taking a sponsorship.

@5h4d0w5l1f3 2 года назад

@@Applecraftpro sure would be great if they put effort into proving that and explaining the changes that they've made rather than continuing ad campaigns totally not acknowledging that. but cool, you go fight for this unknown internet business. they probably need and appreciate it.

@CRASDFGH 2 года назад

I remember when this video was titled "How many holes do things have" It was a simpler time.

@standupmaths 2 года назад

It was a more simple time when everything was smooth and closed.

@sven_lu_ 2 года назад

@@standupmaths *clothed

@EebstertheGreat 2 года назад

It was a more path-connected time when every loop could be contracted to a point.

@p0gr 2 года назад

@@EebstertheGreat you mean simply connected.

@slarzyer 2 года назад

there is no wholes in 2d ....a pair of pants has 3 holes one for each leg and the hole around it

@black-snow Год назад

Waiting for the children's book "How many holes does it have?'

@AlexanderWC Год назад

Just burst out laughing at 4am because of that damn balloon noise with no warning

@GwynPerry 2 года назад

14:00 Matt tears a perfect slice across the bagel with his bare hands. I couldn't make a cut that clean with a bread knife.

@plackt 2 года назад

I didn’t “flatten” the straw to get “one hole”, I just started with a solid cylinder and drilled… one hole.

@grantnichol4496 2 года назад

Or cut two holes in the balloon and stretch. -1 + 2

@ANDELE3025 2 года назад

So you bore in a entrance hole and a exit hole.

@henrik.norberg 2 года назад

@@ANDELE3025 So by your definition you can't bore one hole i a wall or anything with a thickness? You always get one entrance and one exit hole. How do bore one hole then? A pit has to be a hole then? By you definition a hole can not exist, only two holes.

@plackt 2 года назад

@@ANDELE3025 No, I bore a hole which has two entrances and two exits, neither of which are, in and of themselves, holes.

@ANDELE3025 2 года назад

@@henrik.norberg A hole by (functional) definition a lack of material on a section of a object. This is relative to the context of the type of object. Surface topology doesnt account for that because in pure algebraic topology you only care about the relation of manifolds to declare something a hole. However even that is a field specialized definition as really any manifold border to nothing is in practice a hole. The relation to context of the object is the crucial part as its why a cylinder in which you bore a relatively wide hole from whatever side you decided to be a top, you can also no longer define it as a cylinder but as a cup. But that cup has technically no hole then as a cup with a hole would leak. Similarly a ring is technically just a hole. And a pit isnt a hole in the planet earth but it is in the ground when you walk next to it (you know, why holes in the ground on the street tend to get repaired). Its why we set axioms and why the entire section on defining number of holes by counting odd and even ones was relevant as it can have -3, -1, 0, 1, 2 or 3 holes depending on how funky you wanna get (tho i believe most people would say 0 or 1 when we are talking about it in practice).

@nugboy420 Год назад

That balloon noise is so outrageously loud hahahaha

@kennethmitchell1960 2 года назад

I cannot describe the levels of discomfort each time that marker touches that poor precious bagel

@DrakiniteOfficial 2 года назад

I appreciate the explanation of the differences between torus and doughnut, ball and sphere, and circle and disk. I didn't really consider that there was such a rigid difference between the definitions of each two.

@zlac 2 года назад

So, when you deform a square, do you get a circle or a disc?

@twt1524 2 года назад

It’s about dimension ex 1d, 2d, 3d. Circle 1d. Disk 2d. Torus 2d(only has surface area). Donuts since they’re solid objects are 3d. A sphere is the 2d surface of a 3d ball.

@twt1524 2 года назад

“Flatten” a square you get a circle . The 2d surface of a cube can be “flattened” into a 2d disk

@zlac 2 года назад

@@twt1524 So square is just a perimeter - just like the perimeter of a disk is called a circle, right? How is a surface surrounded by a square called?

@iain_nakada 2 года назад

@@twt1524 I'm not sure you do. The 2d surface of a cube has a 2d hole in it, a 2d disc has no holes in it. (If we're talking topology and holes still.)

@ReyMysterioX 2 года назад

Oh yes, topology, the best meme-able field of mathematics. Seeing people argue wether a pair of trousers has 2 or 3 holes is literally one of the funniest things ever because you can clearly see how it breaks their minds…

@arididomenico6974 2 года назад

can it have one hole?

@LeeSpork 2 года назад

@@arididomenico6974 No, that would be a skirt

@Ditocoaf 2 года назад

Problem is that the definition of "hole" used in topology isn't the only definition. If you dig a classic "hole in the ground", topologically that isn't any hole at all. To most people in casual situations, a hole is a break in the *visible outer surface* of something. Like most endless internet discussions, it would go away if there was a separate word for every imaginable concept, but alas that is impossible.

@40watt53 2 года назад

It's 2 right?

@quin2910 2 года назад

Why are there 2 arguments? My first thought is to mould it into a double torus for 2 holes. But google says 3 holes sphere

@Almrond 2 года назад

This is the content I truly love. Your title made me think, and I continued to do just that throughout watching. Thank you for the thought.

@komicalican 2 года назад

That is just amazing. Great work!

@photelegy 2 года назад

PLEASE: Let there be an astronaut currently on the ISS, which is a patreon ... I want a video of Matt explaining how he had to manage to get a balloon on to the ISS 😂

@garychap8384 2 года назад

I want Matt to explain what he was doing with a childs pants. Where's the child??? This video is deeply disturbing.

@petemagnuson7357 2 года назад

He could probably back out by saying that aren't "anywhere in the world", but I don't doubt he would find a way

@stevenutter3614 2 года назад

Patron*, not patrion.

@brendanh8193 2 года назад

Don't worry, he can easily change his question into how many holes in a saxophone. See the Olympic closing ceremony for proof. While we are at it, what shape can be made from the Olympic rings?

@GummieI 2 года назад

Easy fill it with helium and just send it away at the right moment, and they will be able to catch it at the ISS

@alancash6420 2 года назад

I hired Matt to do balloon animals at my kid's birthday party. Reception was mixed, but they liked the n-dimensional hyper-sausage dog

@miriamrosemary9110 2 года назад

I love this comment so much 🤣

@schnitzel9003 2 года назад

*Torus balloon enters the room* Looners: *Heavy Breathing*

@gsittly Год назад

"Have fun with the trousers up and down" 😆👌🏻

@Quantris 2 года назад

you need to animate that deformation with someone wearing the pants the whole time

@columbus8myhw 2 года назад

Wearing pants normally corresponds to having one leg through the sewn-together pantlegs and the other through the space between the pantlegs

@Quantris 2 года назад

@@columbus8myhw indeed, but I want to see the inbetween states in their full glory maybe it would lead to a fashion revolution

@TechCavy 2 года назад

Challenge accepted

@worstuserever 2 года назад

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Y-Hml5Qgrs0.html

@johnchessant3012 2 года назад

Fun fact about Jordan Ellenberg: He has one of the lowest Erdos-Bacon numbers, having cameoed as a math professor in the film 'Gifted'.

@matthewevans7703 2 года назад

I remember seeing that cameo, he seemed like he was genuinely excited about the math that he wasn’t even teaching to a class

@noahdoss1967 10 месяцев назад

I’m glad that topology has left me with the ability to know how to put on trousers where the legs have been sewn together

@nateleavy5189 19 дней назад

“The Taurus has two holes: one in the center, and one in the middle” thank you Matt

@gordonwiley2006 2 года назад

Topology is my favorite part of math that I constantly feel like I *almost* get.

@sixstringedthing 2 года назад

Back in highschool I felt that way about quadratic equations, now I'm not even close. 🤔

@98danielray 2 года назад

that may as well be the case forever if the only exposure to it is random youtube pop-sci-esque videos.

@DeclanMBrennan 2 года назад

Said the sphere to the torus: "I don't like your holier-than-thou attitude."

@slarzyer 2 года назад

a hollow sphere has 1 hole in the center ..this entire math is fake cause it assume there is a hole in a 2d object that has no thickness

@davidwuhrer6704 2 года назад

@@slarzyer Not all holes are one-dimensional. Matt explained it: The empty volume inside the sphere is actually a two-dimensional hole, and you could thread an area through it in 4D.

@slarzyer 2 года назад

@@davidwuhrer6704 a balloon is only a deformed disc not a sphere with a hole in it...so once a hole is added it can be reformed into a disc so not a hole just a dimple on the surface... such as the surface of a golf ball where the dimple fills the the entire center... so a solid sphere with a dimple on the surface is not a hole its just a big dimple so to get a hole in a golf ball it must have an exit point giving 2 holes to the surface so to have a "hole in a balloon" it must pierce both sides leaving one hole behind after deformation

@oxey_ 2 года назад

@@slarzyer I think what you're saying is true in 3 dimensions but not in all dimensions

@slarzyer 2 года назад

@@oxey_ i was finding it hard to put words to it....and was referring more to the theory of holes not topology...i believe the fault comes with the definition of what a hole is not that a balloon has negative holes....

@placeboantwerp4312 2 года назад

Great work Matt. Love this one.

@WindyNight114 2 года назад

I’m loving this channel!

@shaunsaggers 2 года назад

"Ignore the fact that there may or may not be jam inside this doughnut, that's not mathematically relevant" One of my favourite statements ever.

@youtubersingingmoments4402 2 года назад

You have successfully semantically satiated the word "hole" for me. Thanks.

@chuckghaly 2 года назад

Loved the animation 👌 great presentation

@firstlt2 Месяц назад

Did he really say that topology is a relief?! Awesome!

@saxbend 2 года назад

Euclid: Square the circle? Good luck with that. Topology: Hold my beer!

@lightspiritblix1423 2 года назад

"From personal experience, it's pretty hard to draw on a donut. It's a lot easier to draw on a bagel."

@jonpatchmodular 2 года назад

44:00 this video is blowing my mind. At first I was annoyed that you said a donut is not a torus, but then you proceed to demonstrate their different amount of holes

@gradyjones7017 8 месяцев назад

12:48 I thought the sharpie on the blue balloon was a hair on my screen

@CaptLoquaLacon 2 года назад

Buys a reusable straw Makes it impossible to re-use Matt, you're a monster!

@theBestInvertebrate 2 года назад

Indeed far worse for the environment than just using a single use straw.

@mestiarcanus 2 года назад

No, he just made it possible for multiple people to use simultaneously by making more (shorter) copies! If he'd cut along the length and ended up with a disc, then he'd be a monster.

@notmyname327 2 года назад

How many holes does a turtle have? How about a turtle with a straw?

@fi4re 2 года назад

Just use a homeomorphism to stretch the straw fragments back into whole straws!

@turbofjes2021 2 года назад

That's not how reusable straws work, thankfully.

@BrainyBrunetteBarbie 2 года назад

Matt saying “that’s a relief” whilst talking about topology made me chuckle.

@davialves5264 2 года назад

Video: "Why this baloon has -1 holes" Me: *"How to turn a sphere inside out" flashbacks*

@gerrykavanagh Год назад

Wonderful synergy between this video and a recent Mathologer video on hypercubes

@luca6819 2 года назад

So now when asked how many holes does a straw have, I can fearlessly answer: "There are two holes!". Thank you zero dimensional holes for existing

@gregoryfenn1462 2 года назад

If you swish and then stretch a straw you can get a disk with one puncture in it easily, so by the opening assumptions in the video that means it has one hole 🕳?

@waterierStone 2 года назад

It's OK just cover one side you still have a hole. Cuz English or maybe topology who knows

@vaclavjebavy5118 2 года назад

@@gregoryfenn1462 i think that's the real scientific answer

@VivekYadav-ds8oz 2 года назад

Then there's not one zero dimensional holes, there's infinite of them. So technically you can always answer infinite. Don't thank me for making topology the easiest branch of mathematics 😎

@lantami1199 2 года назад

@@gregoryfenn1462 There is one 1-dimensional hole (where the liquid flows through) and one 0-dimensional hole (cause the straw exists)

@aaronbredon2948 2 года назад

My father specialized in Sheaf Theory within Algebraic Topology. He had some fun math jokes based on topology (including capturing a lion in the desert by erecting an empty cage then performing an inversion on the desert to put the lion inside the cage, if I remember correctly) Of course I can barely follow the concept, let alone the actual math.

@fuuryuuSKK 2 года назад

Said inversion is left as an exercise to the reader

@aaronbredon2948 2 года назад

@@fuuryuuSKK and technically, you should lock yourself inside the cage so you end up outside after the inversion, rather than inside with the lion.

@eekee6034 2 года назад

Ooh! I'd forgotten that joke. (It's been a loooong time.) It's a great one if you want weird looks and very confused people. :D

@nikkiofthevalley 2 года назад

All I can imagine an "inversion" would look like is a mesh (the computer graphics definition) flipping into the shape of the cage. Is that right or is it some wacky BS thst looks like it's travelling into the 4th (spatial) dimension?

@studentjohn Год назад

@@aaronbredon2948 This is why you have engineers whose job it is to actually apply the maths.

@leuenbergemo 2 года назад

He re-used the hell out of that re-usable straw ... good luck re-using that annulus! :)

@DevynPlaysGames 2 года назад

I forgot the joy these videos bring

@Bare_Essence 2 года назад

"Ignore the fact there may or may not be jam inside this doughnut, that's not mathematically relevant" lol I'm going to mention that at the doughnut shop when they try to charge me more for that type.

@AlRoderick 2 года назад

I don't envy the people working in donut and bagel shops near college towns, everyone working in them has definitely heard an unsolicited topology lecture.

@sixstringedthing 2 года назад

It may not be relevant mathematically, but it's hugely relevant on a personal level (jam/jelly filled is my favourite and now I want one).

@ashtonhoward5582 2 года назад

There's also a hole that they use to fill the donut with.

@highpath4776 2 года назад

@@sixstringedthing I like custard ones

@carlosgomez2305 2 года назад

11:35 Matt: *draws a point* Matt: "the pointless"

@mattglandon3923 2 года назад

"Am I a joke to you!" -the point 2021

@scottytremaineplays9461 2 года назад

This is the best explanation of Euler characteristics I’ve ever seen - and it’s what my masters was on

@ItsFoxPlays3 7 месяцев назад

The line at 11:48 "I know I was mean to you about your homology class" was perfect

@Lykrast 2 года назад

A straw actually has an infinite number of small holes stacked on top of each other.

@standupmaths 2 года назад

This is my new favourite take.

@boynamedcate 2 года назад

Similarly, a balloon is actually just the outer shell of an infinite number of balloon-shaped holes which are nested like Russian nesting dolls.

@vigilantcosmicpenguin8721 2 года назад

All matter is just an infinite number of quarks, which are topologically balls, I think.

@samuelthecamel 2 года назад

@@vigilantcosmicpenguin8721 They are not balls, but are instead point-like objects which wouldn't have any holes.

@menyazavutdavid 2 года назад

@@vigilantcosmicpenguin8721 balls lol

@delecti 2 года назад

Wait, is there controversy about whether "0" is even? How is that ambiguous, of course it is. It's a bit of a weird case, but it passes all of the tests of evenness, and none the tests of oddness.

@MuttFitness 2 года назад

I don't know. It seems odd to me.

@Happy_Abe 2 года назад

@@MuttFitness odd that you think that way

@arnauds2222 2 года назад

0ddly enough, it does.

@MuttFitness 2 года назад

@Jacob Coblentz that's odd

@Happy_Abe 2 года назад

@Jacob Coblentz I don’t think anyone “even” feels it should be odd People probably feel it should be neither and that eveness and oddness only apply to nonzero integers I don’t feel this way just sharing what these maybe think

@noahweinrich6779 2 года назад

Take a shot every time Matt says the word hole

@JamesF0790 2 года назад

Aw, I missed out on a toroidal balloon :( Still, such is life. Thanks for the mind bending holes talk Matt!

@Joe_Payne 2 года назад

He missed the joke "Its a torus you donut" 😂

@davidwuhrer6704 2 года назад

These jokes donut seem funny torus.

@tsawy6 2 года назад

Hey, I appreciate the honesty with the therapy recommendation! Yet another thing to put on the list of "Reasons Matt Parker is a cool dude"! ...it's a long list! Including the fact that he's able to whip out a toroidal balloon, and it's utterly unsurprising.

@thaddeuscosse9527 2 года назад

Do your research before going to better help. They were just involved with a scandal with the quality of the therapists.

@erikswanenberg8719 Год назад

great channel really enjoying

@berrycade Год назад

My brain has an Euler Characteristic of 7 after watching this video

@whee2390 2 года назад

I didn’t expect stand-up comedy and mathematics to merge so well, but you definitely make it work!

@xanthoconite4904 2 года назад

wow, I saw the title and was like: ok, I need to see this

@rhandhom1 2 года назад

That first animation is satisfying to watch. Also, who else expected him to bite into one of the doughnuts?

@poppetjes Год назад

“No one got upset when I made it a bigger hole” illustrates that I don’t usually think like a topologist.

@Relkond 2 года назад

‘How many holes does a balloon have?” Me, pre video: the one you inflate it with. Me, post video: uh........

@flexico64 2 года назад

My first thought on reading the title: "Oh, if you poke a hole in it, it has zero holes, so mathematically has to have -1 before the zeroth hole is added!" My thoughts after watching the video: *rummages through the medicine cabinet looking for the words, 'headache relief'*