Why Don't Wizards Use Muggle Technology? - Harry Potter Explained

Подписаться 659 тыс.

Просмотров 119 тыс.

50% 1

Welcome to Harry Potter Theory. The wizarding world has captivated our imaginations for decades- a realm filled with magic, wonder, and extraordinary beings. But have you ever noticed that in this vast Magical World, there is a distinct absence of Muggle Technology? While the functionality of muggle tech may PALE in comparison with the capabilities of magic, we do have to remember that the Wizarding World is host to all kinds of magical beings- Muggle Borns included.
And while the wizarding world may sometimes seem like a separate realm altogether, the surprisingly high number of Muggle-born witches and wizards that find themselves integrated into this enchanted society do bring with them a distinctly UNIQUE type of knowledge.
Where Arthur Weasley (A PURE-BLOOD wizard) may find himself entirely preoccupied overanalyzing the functionality of a Rubber Duck, a young Muggleborn wizard may be versed in an entire world’s worth of advanced tech.
I wonder- with SOME knowledge of modern technology from the Muggle world, why don't we see the use of more Muggle technology in the wizarding world?
And if Muggle Tech did make an appearance in the Wizarding World, would it be a net NEGATIVE or net POSITIVE?
And is the distinct lack of Muggle Tech a deliberate choice made by the Wizarding community, or are there inherent limitations that prevent the incorporation of such tech?
Today, we’re going to be exploring these very topics and attempting to decipher whether or not MUGGLE TECH has a place in Wizarding Society.
Let’s dive in.
▼ PODCAST (SPOTIFY)
open.spotify.com/show/6EELBIY...
▼ PODCAST (APPLE)
podcasts.apple.com/in/podcast...
▼HARRY POTTER THEORY EXTRA CHANNEL (MORE CONTENT!)
/ @harrypottertheoryextra
▼MYTHOLOGY CHANNEL
/ @mythologyexplained
▼ Instagram - / hptheory
▼MAILING ADDRESS
HP Theory
PO BOX 37584
North Vancouver RPO The Quay
BC
V7M 0G4
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @harrypottertheory
Please LIKE / SUBSCRIBE / SHARE to support the channel
Leave your video ideas down below!
Thanks!
All content falls under fair use: any copying of copyrighted material done for a limited and “transformative” purpose, such as to comment upon, criticize, or parody a copyrighted work. Such uses can be done without permission from the copyright owner.

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

19 июн 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 994

@HarryPotterTheory 6 месяцев назад

MORE LONG VIDEOS: ru-vid.com/group/PLB5djWCQq2_e0UCOmVbhRP8HkxetpzXUV

@user-ln1iy7oq6j 6 месяцев назад

hello, can you please do a video on the religious beliefs of the magical world?

@TempOne-vh4fd 6 месяцев назад

What is the source of magic in HP? and how was that magical history started?

@StephenLawson 5 месяцев назад

Harry pulls out a machine gun on voldemort. Pop pop pop pop pop!

@Watcher1134 5 месяцев назад

Tbh this kinda feels like Slugterra. Two worlds (Slugterra and the Surface) which know almost nothing about each other and must remain seperate.

@amaxwell7333 2 месяца назад

I don't know it kind of feels like they are integrating muggle technology but it's just been kind of slow because of prejudice against muggles. As the Hogwarts Express is obviously muggle technology integrated into the wizarding world. Personally I feel like there's also a lot of benefit for The wizarding society to integrate muggle technology and ideas. As I think it would be awesome if they made magic videogames. As I would imagine it would probably end up being like the sword art online anime.

@hughbrackett343 6 месяцев назад

I find it difficult to imagine that muggle-born witches and wizards, upon getting their Hogwarts letter, would abandon their Playstations and never touch one again.

@LisaG442 6 месяцев назад

Agreed! Hermione seemed quite content to use owls .. ?

@heylolp9 6 месяцев назад

Well Book 1 took place in 1991, The first Legend of Zelda Game was released 1986 Just for perspective

@JuanRodriguez-jb9ru 6 месяцев назад

My nephew would melt his PS5 in a pool of lava under a blood moon if it meant he could go to Hogwarts.

@LisaG442 6 месяцев назад

@@JuanRodriguez-jb9ru 🤣😂🤣

@Buttz2Buttz 6 месяцев назад

Not gonna lie, if I found out I was a wizard, and could go to Hogwarts, I would hate my "off summers". That being said, when I went back to the muggle world I would still use a phone, or a television. But I can say, I would never be able to get enough of the magical world. And the "normal" world would never capture me the same ever again.

@TheTheowl360 6 месяцев назад

"Guns don't exist in the Wizarding world" *texas wizards enter chat*

@ederavila9206 6 месяцев назад

Hermione Granger mowing down deatheaters with a GAU-17 vulcan minigun at the battle of Hogwarts: "I've always wanted to do this"

@SoldierOfGodwyn 3 месяца назад

"I've been looking forward to this"

@zachtwilightwindwaker596 2 месяца назад

If Jedi can use guns in Jedi Survivor why not wizards?

@iio_moon Месяц назад

@zachtwilightwindwaker596 I mean, blasters are lightspeed atleast, muggle guns are supersonic and that isn't really fast for wizards or compared to spells.

@zachtwilightwindwaker596 Месяц назад

@@iio_moon They're still technically human aren't they? I don't recall them having superhuman abilities.

@iio_moon Месяц назад

@zachtwilightwindwaker596 They are human with magic. They are more resistant to non magical meanings(physical and physiologically superior) and brtter at sensing supernatural stuff due to their magic.

@Melhaven1 6 месяцев назад

Did you get my owl? Bro, did you get my INSTANT text message?

@ThatDamnedGamer1 Месяц назад

Feel bad for that owl by the 16th message containing "lol"

@docbrown2045 6 месяцев назад

If only Voldemort sought .44 Magnum instead of Elder Wand

@aceofconquest5745 5 месяцев назад

Haha :) True!

@SonOfIzalith 2 месяца назад

I'm pretty sure a good enough Protego can stop bullets soo

@zachtwilightwindwaker596 2 месяца назад

Snape killed Voldemort with a handgun. Snape: Ah, Muggle weapon.

@Debianz 6 месяцев назад

Just setup a master marksmen up in the hills or mountains around Hogwarts a mile away from voldemort (battle of Hogwarts, post destruction of his horcruxes). If a wizard can see or anticipate a muggle using a fire arm, then sure they have a chance. But if your a mile away and can make the shot, well.... voldemort can't defend against what he doesn't know exists.

@susangardiner 6 месяцев назад

Say the same thing.

@edschramm6757 6 месяцев назад

"we don't need to beat him. we need to get him to wait long enough for the sniper to get in position."

@Debianz 6 месяцев назад

@@edschramm6757isn't the whole point of the battle of Hogwarts to give Harry enough time to destroy the rest of the horcruxes? I don't think time is really an issue in this case, especially if a Marksman starts looking for a position at the very beginning of the battle. Ultimately it's a fictional scenario though.

@jakejohnson2334 6 месяцев назад

Why wait to destroy the horcruxes? battle of seven potters, harry pulls out a 9 and plugs him. Just keep shooting him every time he shows up, maybe even steal his dads bones... buy some time to track down the horcruxes. But that should have always been Dumbledores plan, keep killing him and making it as hard as possible to come back.

@SoraMatt 6 месяцев назад

Just one problem with that: Distance. Even a sniper has his limits because the range of magical protection can often run for several miles and the one time they had time to prep for his arrival? It was the one place with magical protections that prevent muggles from even coming close by several miles. And then you add the modern tech that go INTO sniper rifles? That will go haywire because of the magic in the air which means you need to go analog. But that crack shot needs to be a wizard himself because the sheer volume of passive anti-muggle magic is off the scale. Even Jacob Kowalski had to be brought within the barrier via magic so he didn't just up and run or spot ruins in places of a castle and grounds. But wizards do not care very much for this since they can literally enchant the world itself to come to life and be as deadly as any machine gun.

@hardpack187 6 месяцев назад

Magic could be used to greatly improve Muggle technology. For instance, enchant a gaming computer to never overheat, then shrink it down to the size of a PSP.

@masterpython 6 месяцев назад

They did figure out how to use a still frame camera to print .GIFs.

@kazekagekid 6 месяцев назад

I like to think they’d run into the same problem of the logic gates being limited on how thin they can get by electrons’ quantum tunnelling.

@lilarrin1220 5 месяцев назад

And muggle approach to tech can be used to greatly enhance magic. Magic clearly follows a set of (natural) rules, otherwise users would not be able to actually use magic in any systematic way. This means magic can be studied scientifically, and by extension, engineered in a way that exploits the natural rules. A rigorous, scientific study of magic should lead to huge advances and could probably make magical tech that far exceeds what is shown in the books/movies and is available to everyone including muggles.

@Ixmore 5 месяцев назад

the shrunken computer would likely not work properly due to the transistors within it approaching the size of atoms

@masterpython 5 месяцев назад

There is a well written Hermione centered fan fiction called Arithmancer that explores the idea.

@rambofan334 5 месяцев назад

*pulls out glock* You've Wingardium'd your last Leviosa.

@OfficialDropRate 6 месяцев назад

I like to imagine Voldemort angrily tweeting about Harry and his search for the deathly hallows. Always gets a chuckle out of me when I think about that

@mrwittyone 3 месяца назад

Or angrily posting on Facebook. Only Harry and his generation of wizards have stopped using FB and have migrated to TikTok, where they do dances mocking Voldemort

@rizkyadiyanto7922 2 дня назад

voldemort: "cofveve!"

@macwelch8599 6 месяцев назад

“What is the function of a rubber duck”? 😂

@vaelegoro7782 6 месяцев назад

"What exactly is the function of a rubber duck?" Mandela effect

@user-ey2om4qb9e 6 месяцев назад

A toy ?

@jordanbenoit8868 6 месяцев назад

What EXACTLY?

@darrannash7452 6 месяцев назад

To lead a trucking convoy across the USA?

@ArnoldOverwater 3 месяца назад

A concealed remote explosive

@gilbertthemeow481 5 месяцев назад

Wizards do use Muggle technology, the ministry uses cars. There is also the Hogwarts express, which is a train. Also, Colin Creevey uses a camera, which, by the way, works just fine at Hogwarts. I say that because Hermione says that technology and magic don't mix.

@jasonp1162 5 месяцев назад

Mechanical technology works just fine in the wizarding world. Old cars, clocks, steam engines, old cameras, and Filch used a canon during the Tri-wizard tournament (so guns could be used as well). Magic can be used to enhance these types of machinery. I believe magic interferes with electronics. The more complex, the more problematic it is. They did manage radio transmissions in Deathly Hallows, but they had a limited time to broadcast and the quality wasn't so great

@kagewaters397 5 месяцев назад

The cameras in the wizarding world are enchanted.

@BedyBARNARD 5 месяцев назад

Apparently you didn t get the world of wizardry, the movie was about witchcraft in modern times, so they obviously focused on the magical side more than on the modern aspect of the world. They did showcase the power of magic upon technology, that not only it uses technology easily, but adds charms to it, the flying car is an example. To ride a car you obviously need to have both the mechanics and the knowledge on how to ride a car that flies lol

@Unfixingalloy1UA1 5 месяцев назад

@@jasonp1162 "Master gave Dobby a Glock"

@Pandemos 5 месяцев назад

@jasonp1162 thats how they deal with it in the Harry Dresden universe. Complex electronics can fry in a stray magic field. Old, simpler mechanical designs do better, as well. Dresden's car is an old VW Beetle, because it has one of the simpler, more robust engines and very little electronics. He uses an old S&W model 29 revolver because it has less small parts than a more complicated handgun.

@chad63 6 месяцев назад

voldemort: AVADA KEDAVR-- random dude: *pulls out gun*

@N4m3lesS_1 3 месяца назад

except the random dude normally doesnt have a gun (and just to clarify, i think that is a good thing - there is a reason most wizards dont know about or cant / wont use avada).

@Shadowcat561 2 месяца назад

Talk about america In majority of world citizens cannot keep guns

@demoncore5342 Месяц назад

Random dude would master avada before getting his hands on a gun in the UK.

@somedandy7694 5 месяцев назад

I wanna see the series where a squib (wizard born magic-inept) goes to a muggle school and is utterly blown away by the magic of the muggle world.

@pathendlem 6 месяцев назад

Having re read the books I was wondering how they prep and store food? Do they use ovens? Stoves? Grills? Do they use refrigerators? And also the fact they primarily communicate via snail mail just seemed archaic when phones are much faster

@leonwatkins5072 6 месяцев назад

Very true since hogwarts has a kitchen u think they would 😅

@tamarasmith9060 6 месяцев назад

Before the invention of electric refrigerators people had "ice boxes" & such. Cool dry cellars to keep some kinds of produce, cooking & canning other produce in glass jars just like many people still do today, salt as a common meat preservative, & so on. Even today there are places that naturally "dry age" meat by just hanging it out in the sun to dehydrate, which will make it be good for months. People still use wood stoves to both cook on & heat their homes. (Seriously, a lot of people do this where I live. They use it alone or in addition to natural gas central heating, as it cuts down on the use of gas & can double as a small fireplace depending on the model of stove.) Oh, & in the Goblet of Fire, Sirius uses magic to talk to Harry in real time through their fireplaces. So magical FaceTime exists!

@robertmckenna3994 6 месяцев назад

You never talked about the variety of muggle technology that has been enchanted or altered by magic. Mr Weasley’s car, Ludo Bagman’s brother Otto that got in trouble for a lawnmower with unnatural powers. Not to mention the Knight Bus, the WWN, and the Hogwarts Express that everyone has used. Muggle technology has been slowly seeping into the magical world over the years.

@GipsyDangerfan 6 месяцев назад

WWN?

@robertmckenna3994 6 месяцев назад

@@GipsyDangerfan Wizarding Wireless Network.

@gilbertthemeow481 5 месяцев назад

Wouldn't Voldemort know about guns? He did grow up in an orphanage.

@CyanideAndSeratonin 3 месяца назад

Ofc he knew about them XD

@alexturlais8558 Месяц назад

There aren't any guns in orphanages!

@Jebu911 Месяц назад

I mean he lived during ww2 so sure he did. Alltho i assume voldemort would have been too pretentious to use muggle tech to achieve his plans.

@eclipseflare3486 6 месяцев назад

If I'm remembering correctly there is a reference in I believe book 5 to guns. It's in The Daily Prophet where they refer to guns as "Metal wands that Muggles use to kill each other." *edit* As johnny pointed out I was likely thinking about the article about Sirius from book 3.

@johnnycage112 6 месяцев назад

Book 3 too. They said Sirius Black had one.

@eclipseflare3486 6 месяцев назад

@@johnnycage112 Actually that may be the article that I was thinking about.😂

@johnnycage112 6 месяцев назад

@@eclipseflare3486 Ha! Sounds like it.

@markwalker4485 6 месяцев назад

I would definitely use a wand in UK. Only because the laws are to harsh with firearms ans a wood wand will escape metal detectors

@Gr3nadgr3gory 6 месяцев назад

Not a bad description. Some are more like staves, though.

@kencrum2524 6 месяцев назад

I don’t think even even Dumbledore and Voldemort would hold up well against a sniper rifle when they didn’t know it was coming

@Jebu911 Месяц назад

I mean in voldemorts case you would still have to get rid of his horcruxes as he would still be immortal. Alltho every time he showed up if you got to him by surprise i guess he could have just been gunned down again.

@anantkumar5376 6 месяцев назад

Some of the muggle tech is far superior than magic. Like communication, military, space techs .

@SoraMatt 6 месяцев назад

According to lore? Military is debatable because wizards infiltrate all levels of government for security purposes. They are aware of it and work to subvert it on a literal daily basis to avoid discovery. That includes fucking with tech to prevent it detecting magical creatures and places like Hogwarts.

@rrinterieur6842 6 месяцев назад

Snipers, airforce, navy, drones, machine guns, ballistic rockets

@martneb 6 месяцев назад

Ballpoint pen. Think about all the minor things we take for granted.

@shawn1900 6 месяцев назад

Obtuse, rubber goose, green moose, guava juice Giant snake, birthday cake, large fries, chocolate shake!

@perseusurbano9645 6 месяцев назад

whats the difference among protego, protego totalum and protego maxima?

@talonblack8250 6 месяцев назад

can you imagine when dumbledoor was fighting valdamort if harry pulled out a 45 and started filling valdamort with holes.

@vaelegoro7782 6 месяцев назад

Voldemort

@vaelegoro7782 6 месяцев назад

To fear the name is to increase the fear of the thing itself

@ssotka 5 месяцев назад

Dirty Harry Potter

@88COR88 6 месяцев назад

I think it's the overall arrogance of wizards. Only Arthur seems to have any respect for muggles, with the rest treating them as a bother and overall beneath them. Hagrid brushes it off as "people will want a magical solution to everything" like that's a bad thing. When someone has the ability to save lives and ease suffering for hundreds or thousands of people but chooses not to they are seen as selfish at best, evil at worst. Yet wizards give themselves a pass..... The fact is Rowling made an amazing fantasy world for kids. She tried to make it seem more adult as the popularity of HP grew but that is not the kind of world building she excels at. As a result it falls apart quickly if you pull at the threads. As much as I enjoy this channels content, the more I watch the more it takes away from the stories by pointing out the holes.

@KibuFox 5 месяцев назад

Eh, I'd say it's much simpler than that. They're largely in the UK. So, they don't have a firearms culture like the US has. I mean, firearm ownership is flat out illegal in the UK, barring some very specific types. Even the police there are generally unarmed. So, Wizard culture reflects muggle culture in that regard.

@B33z1ng 5 месяцев назад

@@KibuFoxif HP took place in the US… surely the OP military would’ve found Hogwarts, and drone bombed it by now😭

@Felnal 4 месяца назад

@@B33z1ng If Hogwarts was located in the US, they'd likely have protection spells against No-Maj weaponry set up at all times in addition to the disillusionment charms already in place.

@Crafty_Spirit 4 месяца назад

@@B33z1ng Lol 😂 reminds me how Pettigrew killed 13 at once with an explosion

@ceu160193 4 месяца назад

@@B33z1ng Idk, Hogwarts has concealment spells against muggles.

@theycallmejodamo 6 месяцев назад

1.) Guns aren’t used, but remember Hagrid did bring a crossbow when he went on dangerous missions sometimes. 2.) As per game canon, disarming charms do work on basically anything in an opponent’s hand, from wands and swords to crossbows. It’s not that much of stretch to assume this also applies to guns. 3.) Why would you need a computer when you’ve got ghosts who retain all their memories up until the time of their death? 4.) I think the lack of phones is more about secrecy than usefulness. With landlines, you’d need wire to be strung. With cells, you’d need towers. Plus, you run into the problem of Muggles knowing where things are with satellites and GPS. Sure there are concealment charms, but there’s no guarantee they’d work on Muggle devices like that. 5.) I’m sure Muggle-born witches and wizards must retain some knowledge of muggle devices at least to the point where they can interact with family. 6.) They do use technology to an extent, as evidenced by the Ford Anglia, radios, and cameras, albeit those are bewitched items.

@mastercheif1225 6 месяцев назад

Ive always wondered about this. As I do realize magic makes certain things like planes perhaps obsolete if you can apparate or use the floo network. And I do supposed smart phones weren't really a thing when the books were written but I always thought "why not have a computer to at least be able to get that potion recipe from aunt frida across the globe without having to wait on an owl?"

@marhanen 6 месяцев назад

magic interferes with electricity and the electromagnetic spectrum resulting in them not functioning properly or even at all

@siracha4956 6 месяцев назад

Because as Sirius does in GoF, you can use fire as basically an instant messenger, so you don't need to wait for an owl.

@michelveenstra9906 6 месяцев назад

They can only apparate in a certain distance

@iamwhoiam7887 6 месяцев назад

Same reason Jews don't eat pork... culture.

@robertbeisert3315 6 месяцев назад

The Floo Network is a network. It has its own infrastructure, and there are both regulations and material restrictions on its use. Imagine if a Russian witch could just barge into a Ukrainian home through their fireplace at their sole discretion, or if a Chinese wizard could just invade the White House. It'd defeat every notion of nations and security.

@Sexynes 6 месяцев назад

In an increasing digital and electric world, I wonder if the magical world would even be able to adjust to the muggle world. Do wizards watch movies? How would they watch movies when theaters are closing?

@aleximalmgren5301 6 месяцев назад

I love how low tech Harry Potter is low tech I love the retro artistry .

@robertasmith7780 6 месяцев назад

They are using trains, buses, and cars…muggle things that have been modified

@cherylalikhani5957 6 месяцев назад

I thought guns weren't used in the UK with the exception of rifles for game hunting and crime. Plot hole: Diagon Alley, MOM, Sirius's home, mixed villages, etc are all highly magical areas close to or adjacent to muggle areas yet none of those muggle areas are affected by the magic.

@llewcunedda4528 6 месяцев назад

The Wizarding World reminds me of the Amish and Mennonites. Some parts of life are limited to past technology and largely keep to themselves yet, there's some integration into the wider world and utilisation of "English" (muggle) technology but, it's limited depending on the philosophical perspective of each community.

@hiddentruth1982 6 месяцев назад

I would think it's because muggle tech that would be viable for mages , such as cell phones , can be traced and would lead to the discovery of the wizarding world.

@nealmaxwell790 5 месяцев назад

One of my favorite fan characters I’ve made is a Squib who served in the British Armed Forces. His brother is an Auror and they occasionally fight dark wizards together. And so many wizards are detached from the muggle world that they can’t defend against modern tactical warfare, that and his brother has trained him in basic DADA

@nickmadsen3479 6 месяцев назад

A Boeing AH-64 Apache appears on the horizon, fully decked with AGM114 Hellfire missiles, Hydra 70 rocket pods and the M230 of 30mm chain gun with auto target capability. Potter: "expelliarmus!" Pilot: "lol..."

@N4m3lesS_1 3 месяца назад

i think that could actually work given that its meant to disarm your opponent. In a fight with a wizard that would refer to their wand but if you are strong the spell can have an effect on the other person and if you consider something else their weapon... But i think in the video it was made clear they didnt want to fight /be part of the "muggel" world and naturally never developed spells to work against more advance technology.

@Jebu911 Месяц назад

@@N4m3lesS_1 Yeah i think it was obvious to wizards that if the muggles knew about them they would just force them to do all sorta magic for them while having their boomsticks pointed at the wizards heads.

@GISP 6 месяцев назад

I think you missed out the key difference between guns and wands. Thier general usage. A wand is a wizards tool to all kinds of magic, while a gun has but a single purpose. The virsatility of the wand has to many benefits.

@Kyleplier 6 месяцев назад

Versatility is how that’s spelled. Just FYI

@Princess_Celestia_ 6 месяцев назад

I can think of a hundred different uses for a gun and none of them involve making things take the forever nap. You really need to think outside the box, mate.

@shawn1900 6 месяцев назад

@@Princess_Celestia_ Really, please do tell...

@blackforest_fairy 6 месяцев назад

@@Princess_Celestia_tell me more...

@Uragan00829 6 месяцев назад

@@Princess_Celestia_Enlighten me, please. I would really like to know what the tools for killing people have going for other than, you know? Killing people? Please educate me.

@grawp45 6 месяцев назад

They do use the radio even though with magic but that is muggle technology

@jeffhenrichs3867 6 месяцев назад

They also use toilets and sinks and that could be considered muggle tech.

@IlTrojo 6 месяцев назад

Interesting as always. I still believe that a "Muggle-Wizard multiclass" would be able to overthrow the system, like Harry plans to do in HPMOR. In addition, the explanation about a broom rigged by a rocket engine flying partly according to Aristotelian principles and partly according to Newtonian physics is the one of the most hilarious things I've ever read.

@bellicosepariah6609 5 месяцев назад

A few claymore land mines would have truly fucked up Voldermorts attacking forces in the last battle.

@CommanderHuggins 6 месяцев назад

I think it’s worth mentioning that a lot of muggle tech relies on pre-existing infrastructure. Cars are typically built for roads. Cell phones require cell towers. Electrical devices connect to a power grid. Building that kind of infrastructure requires a lot of knowledge that just isn’t taught in magical schools. I mean sure a wizard might be able to shoot lightning from a wand. But can they do it on a large scale and maintain it at the 230 Volt 50 Hertz alternating current used by electrical devices in the UK? Are there any Witch or Wizard electrical engineers who know what that means?

@dannybonsai7102 25 дней назад

who installed Hogwarts' plumbing? the castle predates indoor plumbing but I wonder if some wizards took the time to learn the engineering involved or did they hire muggle plumbers?

@kaimagnus5760 6 месяцев назад

I've always assumed that Guns were developed as a muggle counter to Magic. Guns date back to The Middle Ages so they would have been making their way into Europe around the same time as The Hogwarts Founders were starting their school. With that time period having large scale unrest between the two I can definitely see the rapid advancement of Firearm Technology being fueled by an Anti-Magic arms race to fight against Magic that could cause instant death and destruction at long range.

@vdoggydogg3922 5 месяцев назад

Who assumed this? Just you?

@kaimagnus5760 5 месяцев назад

@@vdoggydogg3922 well considering I started the very first sentence off with "I'VE ALWAYS ASSUMED" very astute observation skills. You want the cookie or the gold star?

@vdoggydogg3922 5 месяцев назад

@@kaimagnus5760 you know what they say about people who assume.

@kaimagnus5760 5 месяцев назад

@@vdoggydogg3922 So the cookie then? 🍪

@morwickchesterham3875 4 месяца назад

What about Chinese wizards? I wonder how they dealt with gunpowder and the first bamboo guns...

@troymoore0 6 месяцев назад

Muggles have tamed one king of magic.... Electricity. The practical uses of electricity has transformed the world. Yet, it's not totally understood. I'm an EE and I still find the field still somewhat mysterious , and .... well. magical (although we have become quite used to it).

@user-xl8ll8tj2g 16 дней назад

You are electriacal ing. ? Omg I thought about that too..its really bizzare when you think deeply. How signals go trough thick stone walls...etc Its bit magical

@nanabutner 6 месяцев назад

Remember in book 5 where Mr. Weasley is attacked by Nagini and muggle sutures were used to try to close the wounds -- remember all the infections and other problems those sutures caused until they were removed? It is also possible that there is some kind of barrier that prevents muggle technology from working in the wizzarding world?

@jaredjadlowski2433 6 месяцев назад

I know they mention that Hogwarts has a spell that makes muggle tech not work on the grounds

@MikeDCWeld 6 месяцев назад

That instance is slightly misrepresented. They had tried several different magical healing methods first and nothing had worked so far, so they figured that stitches were worth a shot. The stitches didn't really cause any additional problems, but they ended up getting dissolved by something in Nagini's venom.

@annasolovyeva1013 6 месяцев назад

Nagini's venom actually disdolves magic, unallowing healing to happen. They used stitches to stop the bleeding

@nisar8009 6 месяцев назад

I think the reason guns aren’t used in the world of magic is because they are deadly. After all, it’s a crime to use the unforgivable curses. And you can always just use a minor spell to disarm your opponent with magic without hurting them.

@krispy3790 6 месяцев назад

i feel like pointing a gun at someone could convince them to disarm themselves

@nisar8009 6 месяцев назад

@@krispy3790, you’re forgetting that witches and wizards can use spells without speaking them. The person with the gun wouldn’t know that the witch or wizard was cursing them. And I know that you’re going to say they have to have a wand, but if that were absolutely true young witches and wizards wouldn’t be able to do magic before they enter school. And if they were in a situation where danger existed they would have their wand handy anyway. You’re thinking like a small town southern American. Not a true reader of the series.

@Princess_Celestia_ 6 месяцев назад

@@nisar8009Yes and no. Magic cast by kids without wands is done subconsciously making it random at best and not at all very useful for self defense. And while wand less casting is a thing, it's not very common, think we only see Doby, Dumbledore and Voldemort doing it which would indicate that it is very difficult to learn, otherwise Whiches and Wizards wouldn't have a need for wands, would they? Maybe you shouldn't knock small town southern American thinking, eh?

@nisar8009 6 месяцев назад

@@Princess_Celestia_having lived in a few small southern American places, I can accurately say that my judgement is pretty spot on. And considering the magic world is completely made up from the beginning, the fact that children can use magic it’s not unfair to say that adults could use it to some extent as well. Albeit, it would be diminished to that that could be achieved with a wand.

@krispy3790 6 месяцев назад

@@nisar8009 do you think you could say expeliarmus before he pulled the trigger?

@Larka661 6 месяцев назад

Even JK Rawling said that if wizards went to war with muggles, the muggles would destroy wizards due to technology and creativity. Magic has its limits, but technology doesn't.

@Kalahridudex 5 месяцев назад

My money is on the muggleborn faction which weaponizes both magic and technology. Imagine an arithmancer corps destroying muggle millitary and banking encryption.

@Syphaxis 5 месяцев назад

@@Kalahridudex Now there's a story I would read.

@Alknix 5 месяцев назад

JK Rawling also said that wizards shat on the floor. It's safe to say that this woman is [REDACTED]. ... ... ... Wow, turns out it was not safe to say that at all. Anyway, your claim is backwards. Technology is limited by laws of physics. Magic isn't. Technology needs to be devised, manufactured, tested, implemented, mass-produced. And obviously wizards, who have all their assets literally in their pocket, will not allow time for any of that. What is technology going to do against people who can teleport, turn invisible, fly and take control over minds of people? What is it going to do against invisible immortal soul-sucking depression-inducing demons?

@davehogg63 6 месяцев назад

What about Muggle-born Wizards/Witches from the peerage or royalty, worth researching?

@davidpumpkinsjr.5108 6 месяцев назад

I've often wondered why wizards use parchment on the regular. They have books and newspaoers, so they're clearly aware that paper exists (the first commercial papermill in Europe opened in the 16th century, if i remember correctly). Paper is lighter, cheaper and easier to use; sure parchment is more durable, but it is far less practical.

@ceu160193 4 месяца назад

Wizards often just too stuck in traditions. Why, for example, Hogwarts doesn't use proper insulation, so some classrooms are ice cold during winter? It still uses materials from medieval ages.

@XX___ 6 месяцев назад

Wizards with guns would give the deathly hallows a whole different meaning

@kenschortgenjr7540 6 месяцев назад

I think there has to be a scenario where one could walk in both worlds. First, it is likely that there are many instances where wizard/witch trained individuals choose NOT to live in the magical realm, and instead live a life in the mundane world... going back occasionally for either training, demands from the Ministry, etc... They of course couldn't use magic in the muggle or mundane world, but would instead be proficient in whatever mundane career they chose to endeavor in. Secondly, I suspect there have been quite a few individuals who had to go to a school like Hogwarts for primary training to be able to learn to control their abilities, but never really bought completely into that world. Think for example someone who was strongly spiritual or religious and while not necessarily outraged at the thought of using a non-canonical methodology, they did not desire to use the power as their primary walk through life. Of course there are also those predisposed to magic in a culture where magic isn't frowned upon... like Native Americans who hold Shamans or 'Witch Doctors' in high reverence. What would be their requirements under the auspices of the Ministries oath of secrecy? On a side note, could you imagine today a young half blood bringing a tablet or laptop into a Hogwarts class in order to help compile schoolwork like in a potions class? Or to program it with knowledge to help create new spells that were inconceivable to a cadre of wizards stuck in a paradigm of 'tradition'?

@AugustusR 6 месяцев назад

The poor tablet would melt the moment the kid sets foot in Hogwarts if not during the train ride; magic and electronics just don't mix, and the stronger the magic, the stronger the effect. And maybe that is the reason wizards, even muggle borns, don't bother with modern techonology, all reliant on electricity... why spend all that money when it is all going to short circuit if you cast one too many spells around your house, or get in a wild or bad mood, never mind if you have kids with their even more chaotic magic.

@kenschortgenjr7540 6 месяцев назад

@@AugustusR Perhaps, and more towards the likely HOWEVER, they did take a mundane automobile which had a gasoline engine and runs on electricity and turn it into a magical transportation device. Which begs the question then... taking mundane tech and using magic to fuel its functionality.

@annasolovyeva1013 6 месяцев назад

@@kenschortgenjr7540 they mimic muggle electric tech with magic instead, but it's difficult. Non-electric though, works.

@ceu160193 4 месяца назад

@@AugustusR Unlikely, as long as you don't attempt to enchant it. It would eventually run out of battery though, and you are likely to melt it yourself by attempting to recharge it with magic.

@JamesMiller-ou1wr 6 месяцев назад

If it gave them a significant advantage getting past the defenses of rival wizards it’s not had to imagine evil witches and wizards having a concealed fire arm at their disposal and using it for deadly effect if they were losing.

@edmorris4103 5 месяцев назад

I think it important to consider muggles from other areas of the earth as well. Certainly those attending Hogwarts are unlikely to have experience with firearms, but a muggle from rural America will almost certainly have been shooting firearms long before they get their letter from the Ilvermorny School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. They would then be far more likely to attempt to integrate firearms into their magical life.

@Xhalo1183 6 месяцев назад

I imagine that since this takes place in the UK guns aren't as big a thing there and that helps as to why they aren't talked about. I imagine the US based magic school would very much have some kind of gun culture.

@kitop310 6 месяцев назад

Exactly what I was thinking!

@venator-fb7yy 6 месяцев назад

The american metro wizard school system...💀

@MisterSynonym 6 месяцев назад

I like to think that we the audience have only seen a tiny percentage of what the wizarding community experiences with their magic. There's probably all sorts of escapism and social activities they have access to, that completely blow muggle tech out of the water. It really could just be the case that they're not interested.

@matthewpatrick7263 6 месяцев назад

Imagine this: Rather than watch a dvd of a concert, entering a pensieve memory of that concert. You could even walk onto the stage during the performance and pretend you're part of the band.

@MisterSynonym 6 месяцев назад

@@matthewpatrick7263 Yes! That's a great example! Even a simple game of truth or dare could go in all sorts of wild directions.

@matthewpatrick7263 6 месяцев назад

As far as electronic devices go, magic seems to act like an EMP. As far as guns go, I expect that a wizard that uses a gun would be persona-non-grata. In other words, it would be a societal taboo that would make you unwelcome. Regarding guns versus wands: If the wizard casts a shield before the trigger is pulled, it might block the bullet. However, if the shield isn't up in time, the bullet would do the same thing it does to anybody else. Regarding quills and parchment, they ARE muggle technology, just from a long time ago. One thing that wasn't brought up are communication mirrors, like Sirius gave harry in OotP, but wasn't used until DH. I wonder if they could make a whole phone-like system with that. How about if they used the vanishing cabinet spellwork for mailboxes? The biggest problem with the wizarding world is that it doesn't advance its spellwork. While muggle technology keeps on being improved upon, magic isn't. You may recall that as a boy, Snape came up with improvements on potion making, but 20 years later, those improvements have not been adopted into the curriculum. Snape should've published his improvements, perhaps in a companion to that potions textbook, but, like most wizards, he didn't. In other words, individual witches and wizards that invent something new don't share it, so it dies with them. Regarding muggles wanting magical solutions - what's wrong with that? Imagine a completely pollution-free generator powered by magic. Imagine witches and wizards using simple repairo spells to fix broken streets, etc. Think of all the good magic could do in this mundane world, if it really existed.

@somebodykares1 5 месяцев назад

In the situation between a wand and a gun I think is reaction and speed. We can see that cast spells can be out maneuvered and countered very quickly and that some spells seem to have limited speed, while a bullet travels fast always, so unless a Wizard has the ability of foresight to dodge or shield a spell can be just out paced depending on which spell is used.

@danielgodfrey4415 6 месяцев назад

Would Tom Riddle survive a pew pew shot.

@alexartiga1218 6 месяцев назад

“I am lord Volde-“ … empties the mag lmaoo Harry could’ve ended the terror years earlier if bro owned a 45

@baddmatt9588 6 месяцев назад

The wizarding world is not entirely opposed to muggle technology. They use trains (Hogwarts Express) and Hagrid uses a motorcycle.

@venator4838 3 месяца назад

The ministry also uses cars.

@masterpython 6 месяцев назад

Someone understood both chemistry and potions well enough to make magical developers for muggle film.

@yuilo7872 3 месяца назад

That was a part in the books about Fudge saying Sirius Black held a gun to convince the muggle minister that Sirius is dangerous. But Fudge only said it was a black “probe” or something close. That showed that most wizards and witches don’t acknowledge guns.

@leegaul2161 2 месяца назад

Wizards : "You can not win Voldemort! We are all armed with wands!" Voldemort : pulling out his Avada Kedavra 47.

@thorpizzle 6 месяцев назад

I think it is helpful to also talk about the rare cases in which wizards have actually adopted Muggle technology. You featured the Hogwarts Express in this video, for example. another example is indoor plumbing. That definitely is not wizard technology. I think if wizards can adopt things like that, I think some other technology might have made its way into the wizarding world, like ball-point pens. I think at some point a Muggle-born or half-blood would have gotten fed up with quills and ink and just started using ball-point pens. I believe quills work in a similar way to calligraphy pens. I happen to be lefthanded, and a calligraphy pen is almost impossible to use with the left hand. I would imagine writing with a quill would be very difficult for a lefthanded wizard.

@kaimagnus5760 6 месяцев назад

I've never understood why Electric Lighting and The Ink Pen were never adopted by Wizards. Especially the Ink Pen since that was invented in the 1800s.

@Inquisitor_Vex 5 месяцев назад

I mean, Rita Skita had an enchanted quill that didn’t need ink and wrote by itself. I’m sure that if they wanted, they could do the same thing with pens so it must be a personal preference/cultural thing.

@Vulcanfaux 6 месяцев назад

Here is my guess, another reason they don't use guns is because guns can only really harm or kill someone. Sometimes you just want to capture a person and there are many spell that can help you do that that won't result in the accidental death of the target. Now if the goal is to kill, guns probably would just be out right better, just about anyone can pickup a gun and shoot it, ignoring aim for now, a bullet travels pretty fast and would likely be hard to dodge. I'm sure many spells could deflect or block a bullet, but the speed at which the caster would have to not only react to but use the correct spell for the job would likely end up with a dead wizard. That said I'd think the gunman would only have 1 chance to win in this what if scenario. By the time they try and shoot a second shot the wizard will likely already have a spell in place to deflect any further shots. But again, i think it really does come down to wizards usually wanting to do more than just kill their targets. Disarm, bind, capture, stun, you get the point.

@alwaysplotting2096 6 месяцев назад

Maybe the next Dark Lord should find a way to mix technology and magic?

@nocturnalverse5739 6 месяцев назад

Yeah. Next Big Bad Evil Guy should definitely look into Fission and Fusion. Get rid of that troublesome Hogwarts region altogether.

@machiavelligaming9755 6 месяцев назад

I’d clap Voldemort w a drako

@user-rg6um2ri1x 6 месяцев назад

Nuke hogwarts to oblivion. But no ; his plan was to take over hogwarts. Not make it Chernobyl pt2

@nocturnalverse5739 6 месяцев назад

@@user-rg6um2ri1x *In a snobby voice that sounds like King Edward Longshanks from Braveheart* "Yes, but there are other things to nuke as well!"

@mateuszkozowski5824 5 месяцев назад

Maybe he or she will not be a "dark lord" or just a new magical political power :P

@deathinabox9100 6 месяцев назад

Guns absolutely beat wands. The Killing Curse is more lethal than a bullet, but it's incredible anyone ever hits anything in HP. Wands have a weird hold. In order to "shoot" you have to speak an incantation and wave the wand in a specific way. With a gun you can keep a steady aim and control your breathing for better accuracy. Put a rifle in the mix and suddenly guns outrange wands by a ridiculous degree. We see Voldemort and Dumbledore use some actually effective spells (glass barrage, fire wave, summoning creatures) that would be more effective than a pistol, but most combat spells seem to be point and shoot and guns are just better at that.

@jaredjadlowski2433 6 месяцев назад

What about the cameras they use to take the pics that can move and some even talk? And I always found it odd that they believe waiting on an owl is sufficient for all inquiries, seems like they would have some kind of instant messaging or talking for personal and widespread information

@Ben-tp2fr 5 месяцев назад

Portraits. The Order of the Phoenix uses them. So I'd imagine they'd use that for more urgent messages. But even then, a phone call is better. They have radios, but seemingly haven't figured out two way radio yet...

@michaelhowell2326 6 месяцев назад

I've always wondered if radio signals or cell signal work in the magical world.

@Ben-tp2fr 5 месяцев назад

They do have radios so we know that works. I remember JK writing about a snobbish pure blood minister arguing something should be done about radios because he believed it would interfere with wands.

@Dalinos 6 месяцев назад

We already know what happens when you mix Magic and Technology. You get Hextech. Some examples of in-universe Harry Potter Hextech that could be made: Rocket launcher powered by Bombarda runes. Night-vision goggles with lenses that have been enchanted with both Lumos and Revelio. A Kevlar vest made with Kevlar fibres that have been boosted by a layer of Protego. Darts that have been laced with potions instead of poisons/chemicals. Instead of a sleeping dart for example, how about a love-potion dart? Or a Veritaserum dart? The possibilities are endless, assuming magic and tech can mesh.

@AwesomeCaden73 6 месяцев назад

Imagine getting dragged down to the Department of Magical Law Enforcement because you not only dared to use a ballpoint pen, but you enchanted it to never run out of ink.

@LyleFrancisDelp 6 месяцев назад

Slughorn had a non-electric gramophone record player. In the movies, Lupin and McGonagal use them too. Eclectic machines are covered in the books.....magic interferes with the operation of such machines.

@Princess_Celestia_ 6 месяцев назад

And? EMP's do the same thing and we successfully developed shielding to protect against that, who's to say a shielding can't be developed to protect an electronic device against the interference of magic?

@LyleFrancisDelp 6 месяцев назад

@@Princess_Celestia_ Rowling I guess, as the Potterverse is her creation.

@doomdrake123 5 месяцев назад

@@LyleFrancisDelpthat's what is called lazy writing.

@alexvanzandt8517 6 месяцев назад

As muggles get more advanced would they eventually find out about the wizarding world. Surely wizards couldn't stay secret forever?

@TheDriftingspliff420 5 месяцев назад

That be a cool spin off a breach into the Wizards world and huge war.

@mattj4226 6 месяцев назад

To be fair... we haven't seen the Wizarding world, post social media. I'd imagine it would be pretty difficult to ween young muggle-borns from their devices. But in all seriousness, I've always been curious how the Wizarding world would adapt to coexisting with the Muggle world as technology continues to progress. For instance, 500 years from now humanity is in a Star Trek like world where technological abilities have surpassed magical abilities. Could be an interesting topic.

@LordProteus 6 месяцев назад

A wizard would only beat a gun by acting pre-emptively. They're not going to dodge a bullet or cast spells in the time it takes for the bullet to go from the gun into thier bodies. Before anyone brings up Wizards moving and reacting at or above light speed because they can dodge wand spells, wand bolts/spells do not travel at or above light speed. What comes out of wands emits light, it is not light itself, in the same way a lightbulb does not move at light speed when it moves for whatever reason.

@albertusvanlubeeck9161 6 месяцев назад

Firearms don't kill instantly unless you get a solid headshot, even then you don't die instantly. From what I recall magic can heal any wounds not curse based. So as long as you have two magic wielders firearms would be more of an annoyance than an effective tool.

@masterpython 6 месяцев назад

We never see how good magic healers are. Grinderwald was concerned about Muggle weapons.

@gabesgaming7064 6 месяцев назад

Small calibers yeah, but most rifles use larger caliber rounds. The SAS with M4s would wipe out the entire death eaters

@MikeDCWeld 6 месяцев назад

They would still have to contend with blood loss and its effects. The length of time it would take to cast the healing spell would definitely be an important factor.

@Sturm01 6 месяцев назад

I'm pretty sure having your brainpan painted across a wall would keep people from escaping Azkaban. Be more humane too.

@macvirii 6 месяцев назад

Here, hold this grenade for a min, I'm going over there to watch....

@TheLegendOfRin 6 месяцев назад

Already liked the video, even tho I haven’t watched it yet, cos when potter theory uploads, u know it’s gonna be a banger

@mecahhannah 6 месяцев назад

So true

@SlipperyCastIron 6 месяцев назад

It is clear that wizard money and gold can't be duplicated or multiplied, but since there is a muggle money to wizard money exchange, what if people could multiple muggle money using magic then launder it and then exchange for wizard gold?

@dreamcream3738 4 месяца назад

With bank notes, they would be verified via serial numbers and the like. Especially with the use of magic to verify. Not to mention, the Doubling Charm had a major flaw; the duplicate would break down or tarnish much faster than the original, so it would eventually be found out.

@patrickmulligan7296 6 месяцев назад

Being that a gun can fire from a very quick and simple squeeze of the trigger, where as a wand requires flicking and swooping while yelling or announcing the spell/incantation, that a person with a gun would always win a dual. Yes, the magic could be more powerful, but the reality is that a gun wielder could get multiple shots before the wand wielder finishes screaming Abracadabra...

@Suenami89 6 месяцев назад

I just figured there were enough shield charms to block bullets so guns would be useless in the magical world

@merkel2750 6 месяцев назад

You forget it takes .2 of a second to fire a gun VS how many seconds to say a 4 syllable spell?

@davidcopeland5450 6 месяцев назад

Do you realize the speed bullets travel when shot out of a gun? Unless you’re well prepared in advance of a danger poses by an individual or group of people, good luck trying to block shots that quickly in a one-on-one duel with a wand as your defense.

@edschramm6757 6 месяцев назад

@@merkel2750 there IS non-verbal magic, but that's generally something that is incredibly high power, to my understanding. though i'd argue that the .2 seconds is giving the wizard more time than they have, by a wide margin, and any faster and you gotta take reaction time into account. unless wizards are randomly also neurologically superior, by a wide margin, they aren't going to process that the trigger was pulled before they have a new hole punched in them

@Suenami89 6 месяцев назад

@@merkel2750 1. Nonverbal spells 2. There are all kinds of charms, even ones that stay for a period of time and you don’t have to shout the incantation every time. 3. Are we able to really put that to the test in the real world? No. Don’t get so excited to shoot down someone’s theory about a fictional fantasy world next time. Pun intended

@Suenami89 6 месяцев назад

@@davidcopeland5450 nooooo, I’m an idiot and didn’t realize! (Sarcasm) 1. Nonverbal spells 2. There are all kinds of charms, even ones that stay for a period of time and you don’t have to shout the incantation every time you want to use it. 3. Are we able to really put that to the test in the real world? No. Don’t get so excited to shoot down this theory. Pun intended

@javis999 6 месяцев назад

So uncivilized.- obi wan kenobi

@sw-gs 6 месяцев назад

I think that Muggle technology doesn't work on Wizards, for example: phones. Wizards can pick them, call number but they would never hear voice from other side, but when phone is enchanted, then they can hear it. Why? Because Wizarding World and Muggle World are universes stacked on eachother with slight shift which nullify oculatory and auditory perspective (that's why Muggles can see Dementors, because they are slightly shifted from view spectrum non magic beings occupy.) But there are beings that were born from for example from Muggles or half-bloods, they can occupy both planes of existance at the same time they can use both technology and magic, but magic is more covinient and more common in magic world (it is easier to send another wizard an owl than e-mail if that other wizard can't use a computer.) Also I bet there is a low that forbids muggleborn or half-bloods use muggle technology while in magic world, due to lack overseeing that by Ministry of Magic and other gorvemental bodies in another countries. That where comes The Misuse of Muggle Artefacts Office, which in past worked as also as Ministy of Magic enforcer preventing Wizards from use Muggle tchnology, but when Weasley took over it became joke and lost it's true purpouse that was moved onto Aurors during Fudge reign as Minister of Magic. For Muggle to enter Magic World they must be either lead by Wizzard in (Hermione + her parents) or randomly stumble upon it through natural aspects of magic.

@colinmoore7460 6 месяцев назад

I think that in one of the books it said that magic interfeard with the function of electronic equipment. Plus if a wizard can replicate said function (which they dont really understand) with magic (which they do) they are going to.

@objectionable9891 6 месяцев назад

Even tho the books were written before smartphones and wifi were ubiquitous, its not hard to imagine the danger that sort of tech poses to the wizarding world, people might notice if wizards are on their wifi, there is phone tracking, our technology leaves an imprint and for the wizarding world it might be one of the more risky things they could do in terms of maintaining secrecy

@DominiqEffect 5 месяцев назад

I think the muggle tech is to easy to jam by magic. Like when Dumbledore turn off all the lights on the street.

@Dakblasta 5 месяцев назад

And??

@asgaiyawaya3973 6 месяцев назад

Imagine a wizard fighting in WW2. How that would play out while maintaining the Wizarding World's secrecy.

@robertmckenna3994 6 месяцев назад

Also it’s Britain. Even if so desired, guns are difficult to acquire in that restrictive country, even for the muggle population.

@alexartiga1218 6 месяцев назад

Makes me realize, we would SMOKE wizards if a war broke out. By the time their owl delivers the military plans, we just dropped a nuke lmao

@jakejones7235 6 месяцев назад

That would have just as bad of an effect of wizard kind than muggle kind lmao. Nuclear warfare is obsolete. Too many of them exist (nukes). It would be total obliteration of everything if we still used nukes

@mEmory______ 5 месяцев назад

A nuke... where exactly?

@Barboron 6 месяцев назад

I'd say in a duel, the wand would likely come out on top more times than not. Whilst a bullet will go fast, very fast, too fast to possibly block, it's more a question of accuracy. For a spell, how precise do you need to be to hit something? People can get hit by a bullet and not feel it due to adrenaline (watching a LOT of videos of gun useage). I think with a spell, if not fatal, can be very crippling and easy to disarm (from the perspective of a magic user). You just need to make sure your time to first cast is fast, that there won't be a shot made to disable you. However, in the instance of the battle for Hogwarts where you have a large army, a series of guns might help. But you eventually have to reload. A wand in this case though, there is significant time between spells but can deal Area of Effect damage, blasting seveal people at once. But again, bullets have penetrative power. Ultimately, I think in most situations, the wand will trump over the gun.

@augoosto11 6 месяцев назад

I get the impression you've never fired a gun before. To kill someone with a wand, you have to be close enough to see them with your naked eye. A gun can kill you from a mile away. While spells certainly exist to block physical objects, you can't keep it up forever. Generally speaking, people that did not feel being shot because of adrenaline were shot by relatively low caliber ammunition, or only grazed. There is no ignoring the bodily harm that is done by high or even mid caliber ammunition. You may not feel it, but if your organs were destroyed, that will only matter for a few minutes. Personally, I always thought it was strange that noone ever tried to enchant guns in the wizarding world. It seems to be, a rifle modified to shoot a never-ending stream of avada-kedavras would pretty much nullify all "skill" in the wizarding world. Even if it just shot low grade stupify, petrificus totalus, or virtually any offensive spell whatsoever, it would be a devastating weapon. It would totally ruin the world building aspect of the story, so I'm glad the story doesn't go there, but in a world where cars have been enchanted, it makes little sense that a gun was never enchanted during war time.

@johnnycage112 6 месяцев назад

JK herself said a muggle with a shotgun with beat a wizard with a wand.

@Barboron 6 месяцев назад

@@augoosto11 No I havem't fired a gun, but I get the impression you've never used a wand to cast magic, it's theoretical. A mile away has travel time and you're not going to get the RoF to spray at someone a mile away to stop them from blocking constantly. This is, of course assuming it isn't some sort of assassination attempt then it's going into a case of who gets the jump on who rather than weapon versus weapon. Magic users can have themselves go unnoticed, such as hiding buildings, turning cars invisible, even erasing peoples' memories. Not to mention being able to access areas via flying, giving them vantage points. On top of that, not every muggle is going to have the capability to hit a target from several feet away nevermind a mile, that's very specialist fire arms users and firearms themselves you're getting into. If we're to look at specialists wizards, you could have someone like Snape, or many of the Death Eaters who could fly without brooms. Wizards who could cast without receiting spell, speeding up their cast times. As for ammunition caliber, granted. Larger caliber will prove more fatal in areas were lower calibers would not. However, accuracy still stands. I'd be curious to know what the sort of accuracy requirements are for a wizard to land a spell, can they bend it's path while it passes through the air? Or is it a direct, unmoving strike that follows from where the wizard initially cast it? I'd defer to The Goblet of Fire for this though where Harry and Voldemort got locked together and Voldemort was trying to flick this spell away whilst it was being cast, giving more flexibility to a wand for accuracy, potentially. There's a lot of 'what if?' to it all really and varying circumstances, I just think looking at it broadly, a wand would outdo guns with the potential and variety of applications they bring should muggles and witches/wizards ever come to fight.

@melancholymelodies89 3 месяца назад

I get not wanting or needing to use muggle tech, but I feel like there are little things they could easily incorporate. Ball point pens, as an example. Eliminates the need to constantly acquire new quills and ink.

@gilbertthemeow481 5 месяцев назад

Regarding the mending charm, can it mend ageing objects. So things do age and breakdown, so can you cast repairo on them to make them good as new?

@MegaMan352 6 месяцев назад

They have anti muggle spells and shield charms. I wouldn't be surprised if there was an anti muggle bulletproof spell.

@cyberpunk-2O77 5 месяцев назад

They can only run so many active spells at a time, it typically involves active thought. You can block projectiles, but then all one needs to do is pull out phosphorus or use gas. Cant cast spells easy if youre collapsed, burning. Plus, charms that arent from equipment would need to be activated prior to the engagment. Unlikely, considering the distance an ambush could begin at.

@narutofan10036 5 месяцев назад

Magically enhanced muggle tech would be a great benefit to the world as a whole

@Goldengirl48 4 месяца назад

I always enjoy your videos. Thank you for your time and the efforts it takes to research and find credible answers to questions about how the Wizarding world works. There are two modes of transportation that your video missed - 1. Apparition and Disapparition and 2. Port keys. Instant transportation without worrying about whether someone's floo is going to be open or clean. Also there are spells to stop a person from using a gun to harm you and to disarm them - freeze charms and such. Avada Kadava the killing curse is much more effective that a gun and faster too. Guns are loud and messy. Plus if your aim is off, all you are going to do is make someone come back after you.

@kevinsimpson1609 6 месяцев назад

Bro see how McGonagall reacted to one of the twins punching Malfoy i think it was , calling it barbaric , imagine if she found out one of the DA pulled out a dessert eagle with a lightweight charm on it 😏🤣🤣🤣

@VegasMikeP229 6 месяцев назад

I've thought about the gun question too. I have several and know their limitations. For a wizard, how far can they cast a spell? Will the Avadra Kadavra spell work over 100 yards? Half mile? Binding spells or freezing spells? My pistols are very effective at 100 yards, light rifles (44/40, AR) are good to 1/4 mile, and hunting rifles good to a half mile or maybe 3/4 mile without trying too hard. Sniper rifles can be used well out past a mile. So, how effective would a magic spell be against a muggle a half mile away? We haven't even gotten into Tanks (3-4 miles), artillery (5-10 miles), or naval cannon that can do 20 miles with a one-ton projectile. Rockets? Nuclear weapons? I believe wizards would have difficulties with muggle weapons, but as noted, I'm surprised that during the last war, wizards didn't pick up some muggle weapons.

@Harry-mf6rq 6 месяцев назад

Of all those, rockets are the only ones that seem useless when there's bombarda maxima. For everything else combat, 21st century muggles have a massive advantage

@hanpol2053 3 месяца назад

The best fan theorie I heard about that is that as part of the statute of secrecy many wards or curses with basically global range were cast by the IWC and the national ministries to prevent muggle technology from working on wizards and capturing them doing magic cameras or microphones not working if a spell is cast near them and a wizard using guns or non magic communication is basically the same as a bad luck charm( nothing fatal but a bad idea if you want to capture or kill other mages.)

@BrianR246 5 месяцев назад

Imagine Harry and Voldemort’s duel with their wands locked, then Harry pulls out an Uzi with his other hand and lights him up.

@TheRoyalSkies Месяц назад

The real answer is the same reason why Jedi don't use Blasters, it's "So UNCIVILIZED" -

@6DeathRider 5 месяцев назад

The guns thing can possibly be explained due to the location that a lot of where we are set in the harry potter films and books. The UK has strict gun laws and I doubt the magical community could get them without crossing a few lines (like stealing a shipment of guns and ammo, let alone figuring out which shipments to get or where they are stored) but also the need for secrecy. Guns are loud items, even the smallest calibers can make a louder sound than a spell leaving a wand (never mind the result of an impact depending on spell), there are attachments to make a gun close to silent but that falls under knowing where to get and how to apply. Not only that, there is also the aspect of ammo to consider, the amount that can be fired before empty or the barrel deforms compared to a wand that has near unlimited usage as long as the one wielding it is still alive and able to use it. Though it could also be the aspect of magic involved, namely locations such as Hogwarts where there could be some kind of magical protection involved to prevent the gun from firing or the projectile from entering a certain range.

@KaiMoya420 6 месяцев назад

They would use smartphones for sure. The communication and research ability is too good to pass up. Plus they could make it so only magical people can see the things that are magic. Amazon could use the owls to deliver packages.

@kestrelwings 2 месяца назад

1000 years ago, there were arrows, swords, and spears. Whatever defenses wizards used against those might also work against guns. It is possible that wizards know how to remove an arrow and repair the body. There are spells not mentioned in the books that could be used against guns: 1. Shield, 2. A spell that makes guns much more visible, and 3. Something that seeks out and blows up guns.

@Jpiccinino 6 месяцев назад

Magic bullets, I can see the spell name “A-LA-KA-BLAMO”. Now I am wondering if there are Wizard Red-Necks 😂

@ladynia1203 6 месяцев назад

I think about this often. When smart phones took over I like to imagine owls going out of style.

@Bertomevi 6 месяцев назад

If I'm not mistaken there's that spell, Protego Maxima, which is very powerful shield. It can block many destructive, even small-bomb-like curses. Going with this, a well taught wizard or a witch can block almost any bullet with this. Also, if Expeliarmus is a disarming charm, I think it would also work. Bombarda Maxima is like a small explosion and you can block it, so I don't see any reason why a magic person could not block a bullet from some basic (or even assault rifle) gun

@tripleh327 6 месяцев назад

It is the old bow vs gun You need a life time of training to have a decent bowman But you only need a few hours to train someone to be a passable gun shooter A wand is more versatile and can indeed block gun bullets But is far more time consuming in training and much more slower to use A gun is a point and click A wand require a spell and sometimes complex hand gestures to activate the spell Just imagine a gun pre loaded with enchanted bullets with various effect From sleeping gas to trapping vines to bullet with a homing charm Same effect of a wand spell chant But with the semplicity of a gun use

@Bertomevi 6 месяцев назад

@@tripleh327 well damn, I haven't thought about that, good point. With this in mind, I can't even imagine the amount of destruction

@tripleh327 6 месяцев назад

@@Bertomevi I like my wand in the 9 mm caliber

@Bertomevi 6 месяцев назад

@@tripleh327 wand type: magnum eagle 9mm, core with gun powder, very stiff, capable of powerful magic xddd

@tripleh327 6 месяцев назад

@@Bertomevi so stiff that if you finish your ammo you can still use it as a blunt object to subdue dark wizard differently from your typical wooden wand

@itzrozati4091 6 месяцев назад

"Why dont wizards use guns?" Protego. Protego im pretty sure deflects all projectiles. Didnt protego block physical objects in Deathly Hallows when Harry and Ron were arguing? Or am i misrembering this?