Why Floods in MUMBAI are NOT MUMBAI'S Fault ! 

I was in Mumbai on 26th July. Our unit tests got cancelled and we played in the rain for the entire day. My father stayed in his office for 2 days though.

The only solution is to pump the whole water to some other district than the sea, even Nitin Gadkari suggested the same

No mumbaikar would agree that Mumbai have good drainage system and BMC have good flood management

BMC is only innocent when a certain party is in power😂😂

in sort baki ke city ka 100% matlab Mumbai ka 10%

Mumbai Chawls in Summer 😭 Yaar Ajj Ghar mai Pani Nahi Aya Mumbau Chawls in Monsoon Yaar Ajj Ghar mai pani agaya 💀

No matter how you justify it... BMC have never managed to get Mumbai prepared for the rains. Whether its bad roads or floods we citizens always suffer. It still floods at the same spot where it flooded 10 years ago. Adding to that the rampant constuction at multiple spots at the same time have made difficult for water to drain away. Bmc has the highest budget among all municipality... no one knows where all this money is wasted.

BMC need heavy investment on smart drainage system

Whatever the reason i don't think the richest city of india should face such problems and be shamed every year due to waterlogging and potholes

Thanks for such an informative video

#Ask_Pt why don't Maharashtra government encourage tree planting on walls of concrete buildings like singapore

Finally someone is highlighting this

Informative video👍also they should cover the drainage system properly since it looks very dirty

No we can't blame nature ❌ Mumbai can at least manage to stop heavy water flooding. Japan also gets too much rain and even tsunamis but they built giant underground tunnels to divert heavy rain water. You can see how robust Japanese drainage system is. Even Netherlands defeated heavy sea tides by building artificial dams around it's coast. So mumbai at least can get rid of man drowning floods. If the richest city in India with a gdp greater than Pakistan which belongs to a civilization who created the first sophisticated drainage system of human race then it's an utter shame for us

I heard that Paris had underground water reservoirs to prevent flooding in certain areas i don't think same thing can be applied to Mumbai directly but if we could pump water can be piped to vidhava region and have reservoirs there.

Finally someone talking about this point. Great video mann

Agreed 💯❤ Nice research

We need the data on the current performance of all Vande bharat trains in the country!

Pure facts 👌👌👌

Chirapunji - jungle me mahazood kuch gao! Mumbai - samudra kinare me mahzood kuch city! 😂

Thanks for Video, Agreed with you and Kudos to BMC to taking steps to avoid flood situation. We are located in tropical region so tackel situation in different way. Small things and changes can matter like 1.Stop cement jungle 2.Convert slums in good areas for better garbage and drainage management 3.Citizens should not neglect own created trash 4.Allow work from home or hybrid policy in rainy season for Mumbai and metropolitan regions (really difficult to commute in this season) and will effect traffic too. Nature is wonderful as well as worst too, depends on how you treat.

Good Information 👍

I like this kind of research he does w video

Jai Hind Vande Mataram⚔️🙂🙏🚩

#Askpt Why is the quality of products and service low in India? Even products of foreign MNCs sold in India are of lower quality as compared to the same products sold abroad.

We can’t change geography and climate of a city but we can change infrastructure. Mumbai should learn from cities like Singapore about their deainage system

Bro every city has it's own special problems. That doesn't mean it's not bmc's fault if Mumbai floods

Japan is prepared for tsunamis, which aren't timely expected but rains are expected every year thus bro I think it may be a will problem and I don't know what cost is gonna come for handling such large volume but it can be built definitely.

Nice 👍

bhai voice ko thora clear kro.. or loud voice rkho headphones nikalna pdta h video k liya.. or speed thoda kam rkho.. baki sab ok h

#AskPt can we seed the clouds near Lonavala and flood it instead?

Bhai I come from Indore reffered as cleanest city of India...No storm water drainage line which results in local level flooding every now and then

Thank dada

Get well soon💪

kabhi kolkata ka barish ko bhi dekhiye

I do not agree Maharashtra government can build a underground water line to draught hit regions and pump water there in the dams. Also make rainwater harvesting compulsory to a deep level No point in excuse mongering

In Cherapunji rain per year is 1000 cm and not mm. Please correct it.

Mumbai mein pure drainage system development karo taki mumbai mein flood na ho.

Abhi k videos m .. Wo music miss karta hoon.. Jo aap k pahle videos m hoti thi... Fir se ..

Mumbai & Karachi have almost same issues in urban flooding

Even in Bengaluru its the lakebed areas on which illegal encroachment has taken place where flooding happens during heavy rains. Ye sirf Mumbai waala bias mat dikhao bhai

Thank you Delhi for proving this video is correct

Flood drainage system and more water absorbing infrastructure like grass wetlands etc

Ek video jara ye bhi bana dena "Is Delhi's air pollution Delhi's fault?"

#MumbaiHack: Mumbai has an excellent drainage system. Flooding happens only when heavy rain coincides with high tide. There is no flooding when there is heavy rain and low tide or light rain and high tide. I always check the tide and venture out only during the low tide timing. The above trick/hack has never failed me; despite severe rains, trains and other modes of transport work fine as long as it's low tide.

Papa papa mere fail hone me meri galti nahi hai wo to question paper hi mushkil aata hai me kya kru 😢

If mumbai gets so much rain every year ..why there is shortage of water every year in the month of april may.. this includes navi mumbai as well

Everyone need to understand that comparing Mumbai to Tokyo is incorrect. Mumbai is built on reclaimed land. Which means that if we want to build anything, would have to be very expansive as well as expensive, much more expensive than building something underground in Tokyo. Amsterdam is also built on reclaimed land, but it does not rain as much.

पावर बेटे चाय में थोड़ा अदरक,इलाइची, लॉन्ग डालके पीले सर्दी छू मंतर।

We shouldn't blame nature for it though Japan has been experiencing earth quake more than the world's average but they aren't complaining rather they are building solution for it we still have a lot of time if they have to do it they will do it

Why doesn't Mumbai invest in good weather prediction including top class radars? It was well known that the 2005 flash rain wasn't predicted due to lack of doppler radar in Mumbai. Did we install one? We can easily declare 5 days of RAIN holidays every year in Mumbai (abroad they have snow holidays like this, but they are announced early in morning). As long as by 5AM this is announced, people will not leave their homes to work.

Why doesn't bmc build Tokyo-like massive underground water tunnels ??? It has the money to do so. It will also solve fresh water requirements for people of Mumbai.

normal cars to thik ho jaiga lekin lithium ion cars agar flood mai fas gaya fir to kabariwala hi varosa ha

Is Mumbai government funding you😅 ?

Only corruption make mumbai worst

Local people are responsible, for concretization of every inch of land of their society and no space left for water sepage , also causes underground water shortage in many society

Sabhi samajdar sirf baatein karte hai aur sujhav dete hai par groundwork koi karta nahi.

They could have build system like in Japan

#Askpt Mumbai ke log itni gandgi kyun pasand karte hain ?

I would suggest Indian government with The Netherlands as they have mastered flood control by building dykes and are world class in canals, marine engineering and flood control. It's time to think out of the box to come up with a solution.

Good

May be not fully but BMC is responsible for getting flood situation worst. 25 years of mismanagement is simply just too much.

gutter me plastic phekna band karo chaal wlo waste management pe dhyan do thats all will solve much of the problem.

Still Mumbai/ BMC is to blame, not nature

I’m sorry, I don’t agree with you. While it is true that Mumbai receives a lot more rainfall than the other cities in India and beyond, that’s the norm. So if BMC plans and works to reduce the impact of flooding, that’ll happen. The problem is exacerbated by incompetence and corruption. This year, BMC said there will be no flooding from monsoons. Day damn 1..there was flooding. Yes, rainfall was high, but it’s not so high that it couldn’t be prevented. Navi Mumbai is better off because of better planning. However, due to corruption and lack of oversight, mangroves are being encroached upon even in Navi Mumbai. So give it time, this too shall pass.

#Ask_PT Why vertical growth in India is not considered, considering India is the most populated country and developing rapidly more and more people will come from Rural to Urban and to big cities like Bengaluru, Aren't we destroying more forest and agricultural land by horizontal growth.

Mumbai: Jo Tera torture hai wo mera warmup hai

Ambernath ❤❤❤❤

It looks like we have raise this issue in parliament now as it’s not BMC fault ???

try / think fixing the faulty parts of infrastructure ❌ , It's not my fault at all 👍😁👍✅

Yeh sab water store krna chahiye

don't act like a mouthpiece for Shiv Sena just cuz, many RU-vidrs have been asked to shower their influence on the NDA-led alliance as lately in the news. BMC is horribly corrupt and they are solely responsible for the mess. They have a revenue bigger than many countries there are in the world. Shinde or Thackeray, they are all to be blamed

Tokyo se seekho kuch dharavi/Mumbai walo

Why not pump water out . china has transferred river water from south to east .

Kya hi bawasir hai? Bhai Tokyo, Singapore in cities me bhi aise hi barish ata hai? Waha to manage kar lete hai?

Hey

#askPT why are locals shut down in rain, whereas metro still works? 4:23

Maza ayega dekhne jab UP Bihar mein Baad aajaye aur ye politicians apna saara kaala Paisa kharch kare unke logon ka madat karne keliye. Aur agar vo Aisa na karein toh dusre states ne sab UP Bihar ke migrants ko vapas unke staaan bheje taki pressure create ho aur Yogi and Nitish aur saare IAS officers apne kaam par lag jaaye janta ki seva mein😊😅

Ya toh Arabian sea bol le ya fir saurashtra Sagar , arabi Sagar kya hai

Itna baarish hone ke bawajood Mumbai ka log ko paani ke liye tarasna padta hai aur baarish ka paani ke liye bheekh maangna padta hai. 🤬😡🤬😡🤬😡🤬😡

Stop spreading unjust idea, Har city apne rain quantity k hisab se planned hona chahiye, agar RAJASTAN k city me chirapunji jise planned kiya to kya faida, Aise he, agar mumbai me zyada barish hoti hi to, uske hisab se plann karna hoga.

We cant blame nature. We have to deal with the situation, no matter what, and for starters lets stop comparison. There is money and solutions its just people love the misery, & i wont blame the politician coz politicians derive their power from people, so we are responsible for what we face.

Sponsored videos by BMC😂😂😂

Korea flooded because they aren't prepared as they are not used to that level of rainfall. You cannot compare us to them. Don't compare us to Bangalore, I don't think we should be comparing us to other Indian cities rather than comparing us to International Standards. BMC had YEARS to prepare for this. They never do. It's not the same

Mumbaikar defending their problems which can be solved

BMC is highly corrupted. we Mumbaikars strongly disagree with you when you say "BMS IS Innocent". NO, NOT AT ALL. They can do many things but dnt bcz politicians and BMC r just filling their pockets.

British were the true pioneers of modern city planning, you would hardly see flooding in south Mumbai which was mostly developed during British raj itself but same can't be said about ever sprawling urban Mumbai which is one of the most horrendous example of city planning on planet earth !!!! British left India with so many amazing things right from world class universities to nation wide railway network and much more but we Indians literally f**ked the whole thing by first blindly following suicidal path of socialism for so many decades after 1947, followed by our ability to beat wild rabbits quite consistently when it comes to reproduction !!!! Even today the bimaru states of f**ked up backward cowbelt of ni continue to breed at speed that would put even wild rabbits to the shame with absolutely no contribution to nation's GDP/development or total tax collected (direct as well as indirect). I would not talk about corruption here as its omnipresent (public as well as private sector) in India. BMC itself is corrupt to the core just like any other state or central gov administrative entity. All this rain water must be conserved in reservoirs, the whole MMR (Mumbai metropolitan region) is facing water scarcity like never before, in March 2023 there was a news that some pvt builder had damaged main pipeline that supply water to Mulund water treatment plant and the whole MMR had to face severe water shortage. Builders continue to build more n more concrete jungles and have gone even beyond Virar now as there is huge housing demand due to ever exploding influx of migrants to MMR from all corners of the country. But the water reservoirs that supply drinking water to MMR remains the same, how can it cater to the need of so many millions ? there is hardly any space in whole MMR to build an artificial reservoir, the regions where rains downpour to its max is already being utilized by British to built those existing reservoirs which continue to provide fresh water to MMR.

Learn from TOKYO and how they handle floods.

Too many village bumpkins migrating and occupying administrative jobs.Sometimes, software and hardware are not compatible.

Japan laughing at the corner

We need to learn from other countrys how they are managing this kind of calamities if we don't have solutions. Next year it will happen the same nothing will change 😂

I have been telling people about this for very long. BMC can't be fully blamed for flooding. You just can't stop Mumbai from flooding due to its geography.

Mumbai was made by the British to loot Indian goods to Britain and we considered it as a mega city.geographycaly mumbai is at the wrong position to be mega City

Mumbai is such a overrated city. Too overcrowded, narrow roads, heavy traffic,noise pollution, hugh property rates. Government should focus on inner cities like Nagpur, Pune, Bangalore rather than already overcrowded metros.

If 6 people lost there life's bmc failed stop defending garment bodies

Until and unless there is a Congress government all these events will happen due to natural calamities , day bjp came to power you people suddenly became logical.

mumbai me BMC sirf election ke time kaam karti hai Jaise notice period ka employee kaam karta hai BMC IS WORST

Maharashtra politics crisis

One thing...just learn from tokyo

Not sure why you are being so lenient to BMC. Look at Netherlands and see what they have done to prevent flooding from sea water. Clearly heavy rains is something Mumbai has to deal with it and BMC must take all measures to keep it to a minimum.