Тёмный

Why INAV Position Hold is not working? The toilet bowling effect 

FPV University
Подписаться 48 тыс.
Просмотров 13 тыс.
50% 1

Support my work / pawelspychalski
Is position hold not working? Instead of standing still, your drone makes bigger and bigger circles? Are you unable to tune that out? You were hit by the toilet bowling effect. But do not worry, the solution is simple. All you have to do is to fix your magnetometer aka compass!
In 99 percent of cases, a weak position hold (PosHold) is caused by compass problems. You fix that, the position hold should be solid again.
✅Patreon / pawelspychalski
✅Banggood affiliate bit.ly/2P8oAxr
✅Paypal paypal.me/pawelspychalski
✅Facebook / quadmeup
✅Discord server quadmeup.com/discord
✅T-shirts quadmeup.com/merch/

Наука

Опубликовано:

 

7 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 63   
@hansleatherby1032
@hansleatherby1032 6 лет назад
Very clear explanation - thanks Pawel keep it coming
@sirglider
@sirglider 6 лет назад
Best explanation I found about issue due to compass calibration! Thanks for the video and I will keep following your channel
@Badkayne1
@Badkayne1 4 года назад
WOW, THANKS DUDE, this was exactly my problem, turned the battery and now its all working. Amazing
@dukedblu
@dukedblu 4 года назад
you're the king of multirotor inav !!! thanks a lot
@xdroner1009
@xdroner1009 6 лет назад
Thanks ! Keep up the good work !
@Ludors
@Ludors 2 года назад
Thanks, my friend!
@lucaswybrandt7058
@lucaswybrandt7058 5 лет назад
Thanks! Very helpful
@princefpv1
@princefpv1 Год назад
Love your videos brother they help alot I'm brand new to inav with drones
@FPVUniversity
@FPVUniversity Год назад
Glad to hear it
@samurphy
@samurphy 4 года назад
THANK YOU. I fought with a toilet bowlng 5" for a week. I was absolutely sure the mag alignment and compass were correct but, like a dummy, didn't even think about the fat battery wires running right over top of the compass. I used some tape to get it out of the way for a test and it works perfectly. Now to redesign my wire layout.
@FPVUniversity
@FPVUniversity 4 года назад
I'm glad it helped!
@EduardoPinOficial
@EduardoPinOficial 4 года назад
Thank you very much...
@bgr3515
@bgr3515 2 года назад
Thanks for explanation. I use a KF102 drone, so I have this problem constantly. The control of drone is impossible and few times I had a crash. Looks like I need to make a autopsy of drone to check out compass module.
@kymosabe7807
@kymosabe7807 6 лет назад
Thank you for these troubleshooting tutorials. I have been using iNAV and had issues that led me to a crashes due to a ESC malfunction. Do you know if there is a way to set the initial values for the control surfaces when the control comes back after a reset ?
@Rcschim
@Rcschim 4 года назад
Very nice explanation Pawel! Bardwell couldn't do it better ;) I think my new, rtf Banggood Inv powered drone just needs some magnetometer calibration. Greets from Austria, Mario / RCSchim
@Rcschim
@Rcschim 4 года назад
Yes, it worked, thanks again!
@evertonms2024
@evertonms2024 4 года назад
@Pawel Spychalski... Excellent video... always the best in iNAV. The power lines... when you calibrate mag are say... 1Amp... When multirotor flying are say... 14Amp. 14 Amp generate more magnetic interference than 1A.
@evertonms2024
@evertonms2024 4 года назад
So... There is some place in iNAV... that I can calibrate This? Trying to put my 9" prop longrange Li-ION quad in action :)
@paulodinis1981
@paulodinis1981 Год назад
@@evertonms2024 compass calibration
@kboo918077
@kboo918077 2 года назад
Hi thank you for the very good video. I'have an toilet bowling instead of Position Hold but the compass is working well, I did some tests with motors working at 100% thrust, and I the perturbation is very very low.... any idea? maybe I need to tuned PID? thank you very much
@MoppelMat
@MoppelMat 4 года назад
I set up INAV 2.5 RC1. My first inav installation. Went out to try POSHOLD. At first it was bowling for one round. But then it stabilized itself. Was running perfectly for the rest of the flight... does that mean that it calibrated itself mid flight, or is something else happening? Mag orientation is correct CW270 flip on the BN880 and it looks fine in the SpeedyBee app via Bluetooth on the field... thanks Pawel for your videos and support!
@Glenn.J
@Glenn.J 3 года назад
Hi Pawel, Can I place a external magnetometer on the same mast where I have put the GPS, just below the GPS? Mag is a GY273 and GPS is a BN220
@tacpreppers4906
@tacpreppers4906 3 года назад
thanks, very useful.. what about INav on Kakute F7 v1.5 is the I2C clock speed a potential problem? INav recommends 800kHz but i believe the Kakute runs at 400kHz... any insight?
@Mekanikern
@Mekanikern 5 лет назад
Today my 5" 250 did NOT go up to 25m (as put in the settings, I just double checked) when hitting RTH, more than 5m away. I've been using these settings on my 450 and 330 (my learning drone) and it's allways worked just fine. In trouble - Just hit RTH, and it would climb out of trouble and return, but this time it did not. I've moved my FC from my 330 to my fresh 5" 250, reflashed with the 5" GPS presets, but when hitting RTH today it just flew right into some trees before I deactivated it. Why would it not climb?
@divingfalconfpv4602
@divingfalconfpv4602 3 года назад
One quad I just can't get the compass reading right. Can the vista mess it up? It's own wires run under it. I have calibrated it a few times. When I look on speedy bee it doesn't seem to turn much when you turn 180. It's matek m8q-5883
@McKenzie741
@McKenzie741 6 лет назад
You should add the magnetometer orientation in the configurator as a possible cause
@danielmetcalfe5985
@danielmetcalfe5985 5 лет назад
McKenzie741 if my orientation is wrong then would that toilet bowl ?
@ruisimoes3638
@ruisimoes3638 4 года назад
yes, i think one should be able to see the magn readings. (then we could see where the FC is looking to). i just build a quadcopter, today while trying to do the position hold, i can see that the quad does the toilet bowl thing. But my mag is calibrated and the arrow is pointing the same direction as the quad. so.. what do i do now? is there a way to see the direction the mag is pointing?
@ruisimoes3638
@ruisimoes3638 4 года назад
ups.. i just found it.
@MoppelMat
@MoppelMat 4 года назад
rui simoes what was your cause?
@anuragpriya5121
@anuragpriya5121 6 месяцев назад
Thanku
@FPVUniversity
@FPVUniversity 6 месяцев назад
my pleasure
@tinorosenkranz7822
@tinorosenkranz7822 4 года назад
Hello I have two Problems first toilet bowling and a other problem is my copter is accelerate like a rocket in the air when I activate pos hold it isn't good. I need help to fix this problem.
@Rogue_FPV
@Rogue_FPV 3 года назад
Thanks for the simple explanation! Can you describe any conditions that may relate to my issue on Inav 2.6.1? Position Hold is Locked on position with no drifting, but RTH is toilet bowling. Heading check = N / 0, W / 90, S / 180, E / 270, mag seems properly calibrated. When I flash Betaflight, GPS rescue does not toilet bowl, with mag sensor in use. Using Matek f722mini fc, and matek gps w/compass.
@andyharding1514
@andyharding1514 3 года назад
sounds like you need a 'flip' in your Mag alignment configuration if it's showing W as 90deg & E as 270deg
@Rogue_FPV
@Rogue_FPV 3 года назад
@@andyharding1514 thanks!!! This is most likely it!!! Total brain fart... W = 270 not 90!! You are the man!!
@andyharding1514
@andyharding1514 3 года назад
@@Rogue_FPV hope it works for you :)
@rholt2
@rholt2 6 лет назад
i'm just finishing up a build. in the past i've used either Mags on the FC, or on my housed UBLOX M8N. for this build i'm using a Beitian BN-880. it would seem from your explanation that the toilet-bowling (an action that has plagued more than one of my builds in the past) that it would be pretty important to make sure that the Mag is properly oriented on the quad, right? I notice that when i'm testing out my Mag, when i do not have it attached to the quad & therefore independent of the FC, moving the Beitian around does not affect the movement of the "model" on the Inav Configurator. this, i'm assuming, is because those movements are being driven by the accelerometer. so when i'm testing like this, is there somewhere else on the configurator i should be looking to make sure that (after calibrating the mag) the Beitian BN-880 is truly facing magnetic North? btw, i watch literally everything you put out on your vlogs - please keep up the great work!!!! Russ from Coral Springs, Florida, USA
@FPVUniversity
@FPVUniversity 6 лет назад
Russ Holt setup tab gives heading. Including magnetic heading. The most important part is to keep mag far from electric wires. 10cm at least. This is why mag and gps should be mounted on a mast
@ruisimoes3638
@ruisimoes3638 4 года назад
@@FPVUniversity hi Pawel. Nice work!!! one quick question. i just noticed that on my INAV setup screen the avatar rotates (yaw) to the oposite side of the real quad. as if.. the gps was upside down.. . But it isnt! is there a setting for this?? Thanks in advance!! Cheers
@FPVUniversity
@FPVUniversity 4 года назад
@@ruisimoes3638 probably you have to fix mag orientation
@ruisimoes3638
@ruisimoes3638 4 года назад
@@FPVUniversity I found out that I can 'set align_mag = cw0_deg_flip'. Is this the correct syntax? Thanks
@FPVUniversity
@FPVUniversity 4 года назад
@@ruisimoes3638 You have this in Configurator GUI as well
@WRXMSK
@WRXMSK 5 лет назад
Have you mentioned that toilet bowling is possible not only with wrong compass orientation or due to interferences, but also when VelXY pid (POSR in OSD) is too high?
@WRXMSK
@WRXMSK 4 года назад
@@kemaltufan8208 I prone to agree with you. iNav as a project is still buggy and poorly documented.
@chrismasih-das5741
@chrismasih-das5741 4 года назад
@@WRXMSK do you just use betaflight instead?
@WRXMSK
@WRXMSK 4 года назад
@@chrismasih-das5741 No, I fly true long range on rather big quads, so I need navigation features. But I prefer to stay on 2.1.4 which I trust.
@rcjarvis
@rcjarvis 5 лет назад
I often say the drone goes.Fibonnaci...
@gezakopter1153
@gezakopter1153 6 лет назад
How about BB analysis of Toilet bowling? I would gladly send you logs but unfortunately Matek F405-CTR on iNAV 1.9 stops recording after violent shaking. The same FC on BF is working fine so I suspect this is the DMA issue. Is there a possibility to turn DMA off for BB SD card in 1.9 or I have to upgrade to 2.0?
@FPVUniversity
@FPVUniversity 6 лет назад
Toilet bowling is almost always about magnetometer being off.
@gezakopter1153
@gezakopter1153 6 лет назад
Mag should be calibrated correctly as cca half of the time the quad stays in place. I checked the 20-30 sec BB chunks before the BB recording stops and according to them MagX is affected by the throttle. Twisting the ESC +/- wires together could cancel each other's magnetic field like in UTP cables??? Or should I shield somehow the mag or the ESCs?
@gezakopter1153
@gezakopter1153 6 лет назад
One more thing! In iNAV forums I read that the best practice is to compare gps heading to mag heading. Unfortunately I have no idea where these data can be found in iNAV BB explorer. I found only "mag" and "heading" but the first one seems to be some raw mag data and the second one the heading computed from mag and gps heading.
@WRXMSK
@WRXMSK 5 лет назад
@@gezakopter1153Oh, it's the best kept secret of inav developers, especially when it gets to have a correct and thorough description of Blackbox variables. No documentation on that can be found on inav's page. Neither in docs, nor in wiki. The other thing that bugs me quite a lot - is a lack of description of navigation pids and possible ways how to tune them (default ones aren't good sometimes).
@princefpv1
@princefpv1 Год назад
Could a gopro recording cause this problem if gps is on top of tpu print
@FPVUniversity
@FPVUniversity Год назад
Absolutely
@princefpv1
@princefpv1 Год назад
@@FPVUniversity well that sucks only place I have to put it
@pilotlawaran
@pilotlawaran Год назад
Need 3D GPS fixed first?
@FPVUniversity
@FPVUniversity Год назад
yes of course
@Fpvlandscapes
@Fpvlandscapes 5 лет назад
N° 1
Далее
Why INAV climbs rapidly in Altitude Hold mode?
6:11
Просмотров 11 тыс.
Why magnetometer is not working in INAV?
11:32
Просмотров 18 тыс.
1❤️#thankyou #shorts
00:21
Просмотров 12 млн
🌟INAV🌟 Position HOLD 💫 Tuning 🏹
25:11
Просмотров 8 тыс.
Why is my drone toilet bowling? HOW TO STOP IT FAST!
9:40
It's over for BLHeli_32 and I know why...
9:06
Просмотров 10 тыс.
Настройка компаса в INAV
4:27
Просмотров 1,4 тыс.
8 steps to GPS Position Hold for an FPV drone
6:41
Просмотров 34 тыс.
Engineered Mini Flying Wing
9:05
Просмотров 1,2 млн
Nobody needs compass anymore
5:48
Просмотров 10 тыс.
🌟INAV🌟How ALT Hold ➡️ Works❗️❗️
22:44
Why INAV is not arming?
8:17
Просмотров 36 тыс.
Полезные программы для Windows
0:56