Why Is Nagito Komaeda So Lucky? 

Well he was the ultimate adventurer the reason he became the ultimate survivor was cause he choose to sacrifice himself and do another killing game so he only survived on a technicality he wasn’t one of the two winners who got to leave and return to the real world

If you interpret v3 logically, we don't really know Rantaro's ultimate talent, I mean, the only "proof" we have about everything being fiction are the words of a known liar/copycat (Tsumugi) and things she calls "evidence", instead if you pay attention, there's a lot of circumstantial evidence pointing to everything/everyone being real (excluding absurd lies and/or contradicting arguments like the goffer project), everything happening in the same verse, hell, they were actually kidnapped at the beginning of v3 (the real prologue is enough to know about the contradictions in Tsumugi's words/evidence), Shuichi even closes the Epilogue with his monologue about the (very) likely possibility of Tsumugi lying, and that they can only know the truth when they leave that place.

We know that. You're too down to earth, it kills the fun. He was saying that Makoto deserves more the title of the ultimate survivor than rantaro, because he survived more stuff. Nothing less, nothing more

Also, SPOILERS, His OG talent is the Ultimate Adventurer, not Lucky Student

@@vladimirlong7125 wow that's rude and unnecessary

naegi has a permanent buff in minimum luck (he has miserable luck, but never gets to the point of getting harmed, his luck affects others, but is way less random than nagito's), he'll avoid danger more as it comes close to drop his luck scale too low nagito has luck scale rigged to go higher (he has amazing luck, after going through something bad, his luck is chaotic, and affects others alot) he'll not avoid danger, but he the scale rises twofold when that danger is dealt with Celeste has a permanent buff in luck (above average luck, destiny itself bows to her, and she had to get confronted with another person with the luck talent, the ultimate detective, use hifumi to make it harder for her, and kill two people at once for her luck to run out) she won't be saved from certain death, like naegi, but her luck is way higher than the other two's in most scenarios

How is celestial luck higher lol

@@-hello6177 well funny thing canonically they played a game against eachother to see who was the luckiest out of the three and the game ended up getting locked before any of them could lose so yeah they are all at varying levels of luck that work differently but the main thing that links them all is they can’t lose nagito killed himself So his luck was that he got poisoned , makoto wanted to live and survived a drop into a pile of trash with sharp stuff everywhere, as for celest she hates her luck and sees it as a handicap for her gambling skills so for her kills she used hifumi as a partner so her luck couldn’t play a part in it which is why she ended up losing

@@makotonaegi4419 she's a gambler, she never lost a bet, so it's obvious that she has good luck

In my humble opinion, Naegi Makoto's ultimate luck is the most ludicrous and broken talent in danganronpa verse, nobody even understands it (not Junko, not Izuru, not Makoto, and even irl people don't really get it), and because of that, there's lots of people just calling it plot armor lol (if that's true, the guy must have a full time on and invincible plot armor then :v)

Whos munakata-

@@jirairaikei white-haired guy from the anime

In my humble opinion, Naegi Makoto's good luck works on a metaphysical level, and it's the most ludicrous of all talents, the guy has the longest chain of luck I have seen in the verse (it starts before the events on DR0, with makoto's worst day ever, and continues after the end of the tragedy arc, I mean, he spared the bad guys and that somehow ends up saving the whole world? Wtf? How the heck is Makoto even alive at the end with such questionable choices lol, I mean, for example, he takes the fall for Kyoko in DR1, survives an absurdly long fall to a trash pit full of sharp objects just after surviving his own but undeserved execution, yeah, super logical, bruhh... nobody else could make that choice and survive, and that's one of his first steps to saving the whole world, a very important step)

@@miguelsalas555 Makoto didn’t take the fault for Kyoko, she blamed him. All he did was choosing not to do the same to her because BELIEVE. It’s not actually Makoto’s luck or character, it’s Kodaka’s favoritism towards Kirigiri. If Makoto did the logical thing and didn’t hide stuff because BELIEVE - they would still won. All Kirigiri had to do was excepting the fact that she can no longer push shit on a guy and giving him the key. I don’t know how the fall wasn’t bad. But even Monokuma didn’t expect him dying from falling. I think that the fact of him surviving this is not something special and everyone on his place would’ve.

@@ryzhik9608 except that he is the only one who survives his execution, Kirigiri dies if charged guilty, even Junko dies by that execution, Naegi Makoto is the only one of the whole danganronpa verse to survive his execution lmao

I don't know whether this applies in anyway but isn't it confirmed that he only got in because the other higher contestor for the raffle got her offer ruined due to his luck or something? I read something about that, might be wrong though.

That wrench pierced the wall he'd be super dead.

Makotos luck is disguised as being really bad luck while nagitos luck is in a constant cycle of extremely good luck and chaotic bad luck but whatever happens nagito has an outlook that he is always lucky in a good way even if someone else would think of it as bad luck

@@Someone-or8tp yes, a bus Naegi took got highjacked by a luckster (well, not the previous winner) but failed due to naegi accidentally destroy his bag, took naegi as a hostage, got took down when naegi accidentally stepped on the accelerator pedal. Had enough the thief stole a motor from a postman. As he runs away, the motor tipped over,launching the theif and exploded because of a coffee can makoto dropped earlier and lost. The supposed to be Ultimate Luck died on the explosion of the said motor.

In my humble opinion, Naegi Makoto's ultimate luck makes him, by all purposes, impossible to kill, instead Komaeda can be killed with extreme difficulty as seen in DR2 (for example, he can kill himself, or he can help another person do it), but his luck is a lot more direct sometimes even looking like he can manipulate probability (unlike Naegi, who has metaphysical luck which people can't really understand nor analyze, I mean, not even Naegi himself thinks that he is lucky, bruhh...)

Monokuma, how do you feel about hosting another killing game? 😉

@ᑕOOᒪ_ᘜᒪITᑕᕼ sorry, I’m already working on it, but if you want to you can subscribe to despair melody! I’ll be working on it there with a few friends!

@ᑕOOᒪ_ᘜᒪITᑕᕼ Bro, wanna be the only good double murder/third case in the franchise? What we'll do is, we'll get the killer to hide one of our bodies so they'll be so focused investigating half of the evidence, not even realising that TWO PEOPLE HAVE DIED. And then in the last few moments of investigation time they'll find the other's dead body and have like 2 mins to investigate. Then we watch the chaos from beyond the grave.

Someone Lmao yes

Me!

@@kristenbrinn3940 this is an extreme case that happened: i was being pinned down on the ground by my ex and i didn't like it and when he was abt to touch me the school bell rung, i was saved by the bell (:

@@yonglixiepop damn... that’s some *mad* luck .-.

@@yonglixiepop I'M GLAD HE'S YOUR *EX* AND NOT YOUR CURRENT PARTNER... HOLY SHIT. Are you doing okay?

Same! One time my brother talked shit about my hairstyle (it was two buns btw) and then he stepped on lego block,I don’t know whether i felt bad for him or felt extremely great about it

Yeah. Unlike Nagito, he wasn’t expecting his luck. So he interprets his luck something like just a coincidence.

@@fritzi.4679 yea but nagito earns his luck unlike makoto

@@-w-4252 what do you mean earn?

@@IIBADDYLANII I think he means that nagito puts himself in a position, like the russian roulette, where his luck will be triggered while makoto, for example with the bathroomdoor in case 1 he didn't like did something so the door broke and it would be of help in this case it just so happened to be there so his luck comes rather coincidentially

thanks appreciate the support!

@Jerick Munoz sameeeeE

Yes I'm not sure what you mean by secret file on Makoto but in the short novel, Makoto Naegi's Worst Day Ever, they thoroughly explained how a number of coincidences resulted in Makoto being selected for the redraw

That's right!!

That doesn't even make sense but hey, Naegi is the Ultimate Lucky Student of 78th class, so why not? Lol

Juzo saved him

And he was lucky he did See what I did there Ha Ha I'll show myself out now

@@wowitsportal5225 and it was his lucky, like, he had to go trought the pain of watching that horrofying video, but then, juuzou came out of nowhere and saved him, like, he could had been too late or used another path

The V3 survivors were spared by Kiibo and he made sure they stayed alive. Kaito didn't exactly survive since even if he wasn't killed during the execution, he still died.

and what about Komaru Naegi

@@professoraristotlemeans8860 you could argue she survives because she *IS* Naegi Makoto's sister (his absurd luck saves her for a greater purpose)

@Sophia Degand yeah, but when ultimate despair is doing the sh*ts they do, she is just held captive for a whole year, instead of dying by the incident, just because she is Makoto's sister... and then, she is saved by Byakuya (who survives and gets out to the world thanks to Makoto), and the rest of the game she is with Toko (the same logic as Byakuya). I mean, her plot armor is being her sister bro

@@miguelsalas555 I headcanon that Makoto's actual ultimate talent is Ultimate Hope and his luck is just a byproduct of this. His luck makes it so that things happen that will end up resulting in hope. Komaru survives the entirety of udg because she was needed for the hopeful ending of udg. Makoto's luck makes himself survive too since HE is needed for hope. Maybe that's why his parents don't survive/are never found since they aren't actually needed for creating hope

I did read it. I'm honestly not as big of a fan of the "luck" element in these games as I used to be so I didn't love the story but I did like it because there were some interesting things in there nonetheless. Who knows I might dedicate a video to it

TO ELABORATE ON THIS: Monokuma also had *Absolute Omniscience* of everything that transpired within the simulation. He admits that he doesn't need the cameras at all, that he could just know when an object became into possession of one of the participants without having to see it directly. He can just _know_ it.

Monokuma is a virus, and assumedly as a virus he is able to see as well as manipulate the Neo World Program code. A mere examination of the code, which would likely include the HP statistics and the actions of the players involved would reveal who actually killed Nagito.

@@AndrewColomy Rather than the HP, he'd isolate the bottle with the "Poisoned" condition, and then take note of who was in possesion of the "Poisoned Bottle" when it was thrown. It's all Ones and Zeros, and easy to follow by carefully watching the mainframe itself, rather than the video feed.

Can I get a sprite cranberry

I mean, looking at the killing field trip... it seems that Nagito is able to manipulate and use advantage over his luck. So i guess he did perfect his talent? Afterall, he pretty much understands how to use his luck for his own advantage.

@@miyakibd957 *that makes nagito a OP anime character

@@somerandomnamehere6011 In the hope arc, he DID kick a pebble down a mountain which knocks down a rock knocking down a bigger rock, knocking down even larger rocks and boulders and took out 50 opposing soldiers, helping out Makoto Naegi

@@miyakibd957 WELL-

I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE.

One of my favorite comments low-key🤣🤣🤣

Is basically what you said. He is just so confident in his luck that happens.

Probably dead

I’m guessing they would have a lot of consistent, small unlucky things happen to them and nothing lucky in the long run, rather than the extremes that Nagito went through with good and bad luck

me

@@ltna15 long story short nagito in the OVA

Actually he didn't need the cameras since he was a AI that could just look the log of the simulation and se who killed nagito

Yeah I thought it was implied or at least explained that Monokuma is basically a god, and his only limit was the rules set by the world and the killing game.

Glad to know I wasn't the only one who thought of this

WHAT IS ×lOvE× *LUCK*

Duikiyo💀💀💀 It's fuyuhiko btw He did yeah

No, Nagito was definitely aiming to keep only Chiaki alive. He wanted the traitor from the Future Foundation, who he believed to be working with Hope, to survive and everyone else to die. Though, technically, his overall goal was to eliminate Despair from the Island. And though he didn't do that directly, his luck *did* affect that outcome to some extent and so his luck was an active participant in the ultimate despairs recovering. So I'd say, even if he wasn't aiming to keep the Despairs alive, the fact he killed Chiaki is what led to Chiaki being able to share some of the truth, resulting in everyone being united under their trust for her in the final trial and thus begin their journey towards Hope. So he did help, in some ways, eradicate Despair from the island, which was his overall goal ^^

@@Someone-or8tp welp we can all analyze it differently I believe,

@@ralunix4612 Nagito wanted to kill the "traitor". Since the Ultimate Despairs and Izuru were working with Junko, Izuru couldn't have been the traitor. He was working with Junko. Chiaki was the one working with the future foundation and against Junko and the Ultimate Despairs. ^^

@@Someone-or8tp I know. So from your point of view why would he want Chiaki to live?

@@ralunix4612 I think there's been a bit of a miscommunication here. He wanted Chiaki to live because he figured out that everyone except the traitor were the Ultimate Despairs. The traitor was working with the Future Foundation who were working with hope and against the goals of Junko. He realised this after getting the book of info on the students from the octogon. His goal was to eradicate Despair from the island. The only way to do that, in his eyes, was to kill the remnants of despair: aka all the students except the traitor- Chiaki. After his death, he very clearly explains that this was his goal. He wanted to kill everyone except the traitor from the Future Foundation so that he could become the Ultimate Hope. Because Makoto became the Ultimate Hope by killing Junko, the Ultimate Despair. He thought he could mirror what Makoto did and kill the remnants of Despair who worked with Junko, thus giving him the same title. In a way, the failure of his original plan worked in his favour. My point is that his plan failed, but was a vital stepping stone in the return of Hope to the remnants of Despair. Thus, in that way he did help eradicate Despair from the island/programme. But his original plan to kill everyone except Chiaki to eradicate Despair that way failed. Edit: so my point here is that he wasn't aware that Izuru was the mastermind. Izuru was technically not the traitor, as he worked with Junko and the remnants of Despair. Chiaki was the traitor that Nagito intended to have live. It was double luck, I agree. Just I agree in a different way. His original plan failed but resulted in an even better outcome: the survival and restoration of his friends.

There is a camera in plain view

@@AVA-ee4pk i know- i was joking-

He didn't need this, the second game is a game inside a game and monokuma was a AI that could just look the log files and see what just happened he was omniscient on this game

he is basically nagito with that luck

@@arthurdias6860 I like to think of him as simultaneously nagito and kazuichi