Тёмный
No video :(

Why Starmer must lift the two-child benefit cap | Stephen Flynn Interview 

PoliticsJOE
Подписаться 571 тыс.
Просмотров 16 тыс.
50% 1

Keir Starmer is close to failing the first test of his leadership, the SNP's Westminster leader has said, if he does not commit to abolish the two-child benefit cap.
It was hoped the policy would be announced in Wednesday's King's Speech, in which Labour will lay out its plans for the first 100 days of its government.
Enacting the plan would benefit around 1.6 million children, who are missing out on thousands of pounds a year due to the two-child benefit cap.
Subscribe to our new podcast now, or you're a silly goose:
linktr.ee/pubcast

Опубликовано:

 

27 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 368   
@jimmyandrews3963
@jimmyandrews3963 Месяц назад
Proud to have Flynn as my MP. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿💛
@Fountainwell49man
@Fountainwell49man Месяц назад
2 child cap is a devolved issue. It's the SNP who are choosing not to.
@regfairbairn6272
@regfairbairn6272 Месяц назад
@@Fountainwell49man no it isn't, you should check your facts before commenting, scot gov has limited social security powers
@keirmitchell5560
@keirmitchell5560 Месяц назад
he is a muppet
@Mr-Foad
@Mr-Foad Месяц назад
@@keirmitchell5560 who do you support? farage? starmer? sunak?
@paulgibbons2320
@paulgibbons2320 Месяц назад
If you kept the cap in place but agreed to pay the free school meals for all children, then responsibility to children would be met without huge cash payments to those with huge families. Looking at policies in isolation sometimes does not give a true picture.
@user-yo4js7vc7v
@user-yo4js7vc7v Месяц назад
Great comment. And ensures that the spend is going towards bettering he living standards of those children not paying for dads sky sports subscription. Which in turn builds support for future policies aimed at tackling child poverty
@thepap000
@thepap000 Месяц назад
I'm 24, a father of 3 and the Scottish child payment is a game changer
@andrewferguson9823
@andrewferguson9823 Месяц назад
If you can’t afford kids don’t take them into poverty, think of the kids and not of yourself. Take personal responsibility and don’t expect others to sort it for you!
@gravijax
@gravijax Месяц назад
I bet you're the type to also complain about immigration. British people cannot afford to have kids in current society as work does not pay what it used to. As a result we have a declining population and a growing ELDERLY population. We then need immigrants to fill jobs. The solution is to make having children as easily affordable as it was in the 80s and 90s.
@broccolibabe6765
@broccolibabe6765 Месяц назад
TAX THE RICH, FEED THE KIDS! jeeez how hard is it
@sciencefliestothemoon2305
@sciencefliestothemoon2305 Месяц назад
That needs elaboration, tax asset income.
@thepepper191
@thepepper191 Месяц назад
The rich control the media, and the media decides who is in power
@user-ch7ri7sm7h
@user-ch7ri7sm7h Месяц назад
Absolutely spot on
@keirmitchell5560
@keirmitchell5560 Месяц назад
Reduce tax, stop having kids if you cant afford them
@lastlast2078
@lastlast2078 Месяц назад
@@sciencefliestothemoon2305 Asset income is already taxed. What is not kept in check is excessive asset wealth, families of aristocracy keeping gifted assets in the family for centuries and living off the wealth they generate. Holding assets in trust and avoiding inheritance tax time and time again due to loop holes created for farmers. These people are not farmers, they just rent land.
@vongoethe111
@vongoethe111 Месяц назад
One of the few voices of reason in Parliament.
@davethepieman12
@davethepieman12 Месяц назад
For real on the disappointment when you don't get fajitas for tea. 😢
@ajrh82
@ajrh82 Месяц назад
Never wanted fajitas as much as I do right now
@NeonVisual
@NeonVisual Месяц назад
When I was a kid we occasionally had to go without Fajitas and sky TV, so of course I know the difficulties families are facing.
@LimeyRedneck
@LimeyRedneck Месяц назад
​@@NeonVisual With, or without your plastic blanket to watch 'Baywatch' on?! 💔
@mikeb7379
@mikeb7379 Месяц назад
What's a fajita?
@paulgibbons2320
@paulgibbons2320 Месяц назад
15.4 billion paid to private Landlords in 'housing benefits'. Only 12.6 billion paid in 'child benefits.'
@TomChambers-dz7cy
@TomChambers-dz7cy Месяц назад
Isn’t it funny that a lot of Tories are land lords
@paulgibbons2320
@paulgibbons2320 Месяц назад
@TomChambers-dz7cy I never said different. Labour is at least equally guilty. No renters are represented.
@davidatkinson5858
@davidatkinson5858 Месяц назад
Maybe if they made a conscience decision to limit their families to the amount they could financially subsidise like everybody else has to might mean they could pay their own rent or mortgages?
@paulgibbons2320
@paulgibbons2320 Месяц назад
@@davidatkinson5858 They already do exactly that. White British families restrict themselves to 2 kids. The larger families are imported foreign families.
@davidatkinson5858
@davidatkinson5858 Месяц назад
@@paulgibbons2320 which was my point exactly.👍
@user-ch7ri7sm7h
@user-ch7ri7sm7h Месяц назад
Well said Mr Flynn absolutely spot on mate
@SheilaBloom.
@SheilaBloom. Месяц назад
What we forget with this evil policy is that a working parent could have been recently diagnosed with cancer & become unable to work and & would not receive full support for a third child. Why would anyone vote Labour?
@user-ei8eo6qz8o
@user-ei8eo6qz8o Месяц назад
What did Conservative do???
@SheilaBloom.
@SheilaBloom. Месяц назад
@@user-ei8eo6qz8o Have you forgotten Labour is now in Government & is making a choice to keep this cruel policy
@BumbleyBoo
@BumbleyBoo Месяц назад
It's a Tory policy changed in 2012 by Cameron to reduce to the 2 child policy, furthered by Osborne in 2015 to include tax credits. "Why would anyone vote Conservative?" - Is what you meant?
@SheilaBloom.
@SheilaBloom. Месяц назад
@@BumbleyBoo I agree but why would vote for a party that is choosing to keep a brutal & cruel policy of Osbourne & Cameron? Let me be clear it seems you've forgotten labour is in Government!!!!
@Weakeyedominant
@Weakeyedominant Месяц назад
If they were in that situation £40 every 4 weeks will do bugger all to improve their situation. Responsible parents should have a life insurance policy that pays out when diagnosed with terminal cancer. These policies are available for £10 a month, relying on the government for anything is foolish.
@user-yo4js7vc7v
@user-yo4js7vc7v Месяц назад
Is it awful to suggest not having a third child if you can’t provide for it?
@ASHEN_ONE_GAMES
@ASHEN_ONE_GAMES Месяц назад
No I really don't believe it's awful!!
@johnnygringo2239
@johnnygringo2239 Месяц назад
How dare you mention personal responsibility this is a labour country now.
@craphat1873
@craphat1873 Месяц назад
Why should i pay for more children that parents cant afford. Do not scrap the cap.
@user-oo6ef4ho4r
@user-oo6ef4ho4r Месяц назад
How many children shall be funded6,7,8,9,10? Wheee shall the numbers stop, Labour didnt put children in proverty, i am sorey this man is wrong, what happens in Scotland doesnt happen all over the world, the money for child proverty is not small. I thought you all didnt want Labour to put up tax. Does parents have no responsibility in this? I am sorry I am not here to work and pay taxes for people who just sits and make babies, I pay tax for older people woulf cannot work and need help, i work for peolpe wirh disability, illinesses etc. You made your children take care of these do you know many country in the world dont give benefit and people are not complaining about it as the UK does
@user-ch7ri7sm7h
@user-ch7ri7sm7h Месяц назад
Mr stalrmer keeps talking about funding for war defence but we are not at war.... taking children out of Poverty must Must be A first priority for the labour government with immediate effect
@nathanaelsmith3553
@nathanaelsmith3553 Месяц назад
Children should choose parents who can afford them - its called personal responsibility.
@user-oo6ef4ho4r
@user-oo6ef4ho4r Месяц назад
Thank you
@user-yo4js7vc7v
@user-yo4js7vc7v Месяц назад
I know you think that’s a clever point, but family planning is key to addressing child poverty. No third child is going to benefit from their dad getting a bit of extra cash to put towards his sky sports subscription
@nathanaelsmith3553
@nathanaelsmith3553 Месяц назад
@@user-yo4js7vc7v why do you assume that they wouldn't spend the money on their children? Also why does your name appear in the Russian alphabet in my alerts? Are you a Russian troll trying to cause division and instability?
@LimeyRedneck
@LimeyRedneck Месяц назад
💯
@nathanaelsmith3553
@nathanaelsmith3553 Месяц назад
@@user-yo4js7vc7v I know who you are
@knowlex3787
@knowlex3787 Месяц назад
Where do you draw the line, certain communties in the U.K. have an average of 3.8 children I went to school with someone from that community who had 7 siblings . should we be paying for people to be having that many kids when they can’t afford it, but they willingly choose to do it anyways. Where do you call the line on how many kids the tax payer needs to support. Whilst other people who might of wanted more kids might restrain because they know it’s too much of a financial burden.
@joemarshallamp
@joemarshallamp Месяц назад
Exactly.
@Mr-Foad
@Mr-Foad Месяц назад
It's not the childrens fault if their parents are irresponsible.
@johnnygringo2239
@johnnygringo2239 Месяц назад
Lifting the cap incentivises the irresponsible.
@mollycuddle9990
@mollycuddle9990 Месяц назад
The Mighty Flynn. 💜 Thank you xx
@LeornianCyng
@LeornianCyng Месяц назад
There’s a difference between not being able to do something and choosing not to do something. Labour are just as bad as the Tories and will be seen as the same party if they don’t start changing things for the better. One of those things is lifting people out of poverty. They have the money, the means to find the money and the choice of how to spend it.
@Mrgingerdread1
@Mrgingerdread1 Месяц назад
Plenty of money for trident,.
@user-nr7cj7cu4z
@user-nr7cj7cu4z Месяц назад
If only you could be sure that it would go to feed the kids!
@RenaissanceEarCandy
@RenaissanceEarCandy Месяц назад
Ridiculous comment
@thomasmorin749
@thomasmorin749 Месяц назад
Lifting the two child benefits will only encourage more migrants .
@iamyou6555
@iamyou6555 Месяц назад
Not if it’s only applicable to British parents which is the case anyway
@Fountainwell49man
@Fountainwell49man Месяц назад
A devolved issue. SNP is keeping it in place. Bravo.
@iamyou6555
@iamyou6555 Месяц назад
@@JenniSummers-dc4hw that’s not bad is it tho good modesty. I’m looking at all the WW1 pictures English women seem to be wearing the headscarf. Better then getting country full of only fans girls.
@TomT243
@TomT243 Месяц назад
Let's encourage people who can't afford to have kids, to have more kids which they can't afford...It's ok, the tax payers will foot their bill 🙄
@kerrydevlin
@kerrydevlin Месяц назад
All MPs should try to be as honest in their answers as Stephen Flynn. Well said 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
@ASHEN_ONE_GAMES
@ASHEN_ONE_GAMES Месяц назад
The only problem with lifting the two child benefit cap is the Muslim community that have 8 or 9 kids end up costing the state an absolute fortune and its unfair on British families have one or two children
@jameslochridge4265
@jameslochridge4265 Месяц назад
This is a question when we find out how much the Scottish Labour MPs care about Scotlands people. Either they're for Scotland or their Westminster masters they can't be both. Labour in Scotland represents a foreign government they certainly don't represent Scotland and only the gullible voted for them.
@ScottishRoss27
@ScottishRoss27 Месяц назад
If Labour get in in 2026 election, Scotland can say goodbye to the Scottish Child Payment as Labour are a English based party and can't have different policies in different parts of the UK.
@kerrydevlin
@kerrydevlin Месяц назад
Spot on!
@user-oo6ef4ho4r
@user-oo6ef4ho4r Месяц назад
​@@ScottishRoss27whatever
@AlexHamilton86
@AlexHamilton86 Месяц назад
@@ScottishRoss27 absolute shite, there are already different policies for different places
@ScottishRoss27
@ScottishRoss27 Месяц назад
@@AlexHamilton86 If Labour got into government in Scotland, They'd scrap all the gains achieved by the SNP in Government. Labour are an English based party therefore their branch office in Scotland cannot have different policies as it'l undermine Labour in Government in England.
@peacelilly75
@peacelilly75 Месяц назад
Hold them to account
@user-ei8eo6qz8o
@user-ei8eo6qz8o Месяц назад
@sheilabloom labour only just taken over we cant judge yet after 14 years of Conservative.
@marty1459
@marty1459 Месяц назад
It's funny how people ask the SNP ''Because you lost so many votes have you lost the mandate for independence?''. After the last Scottish election there WAS a majority of MP's that campaigned for independence and the elected Scottish government were just told 'no' by Sunak. Starmer said he would do the same. It's just funny that journalists only ask about the independence mandate when the SNP don't have the numbers but when they do magically they don't seem to care about mandates. No voters in 2014 are responsible for the last 14 years of trash coming out of UK politics into Scotland. We would still be in the EU and would be able to press ahead properly with progressive policies instead of being chained to this center right shit show called Westminster that cares only for the private sector. Starmer's front bench literally have publicly praised Thatcher FFS! 😂😂😂😂
@ryand394
@ryand394 Месяц назад
Throwing money at the problem isn't going to make things better.
@xxg-forcexx8734
@xxg-forcexx8734 Месяц назад
Lift them out of poverty ✅ Give more cash to parents who can't afford the kids they chose to have when we have family control clinics and a 100% literacy rate ❎ Give the kids school meals free to lift the strain, give the kids discounted or free school trips, give high performing pupils who're from poor households financial reward for staying out of trouble, trying hard in school and changing the narrative. Set them up to succeed and want to succeed. Parents who can't afford kids but has them for the sake of it have already proven they're not making the best decisions so why give more cash? The kids are the future invest in them and let their hard work be rewarded
@orderbooks5789
@orderbooks5789 Месяц назад
If people want to have more children why should finances restrict a human desire? The economy actually needs ppl to have more children, hence why the topic is everywhere atm. Low birth rates = less workers = less growth = more immigration required also.
@marijo1951
@marijo1951 Месяц назад
The two-child benefit cap is a cruel, cynical and immoral policy. In practical terms it means that all the children in the family are deprived, since the available money has to be stretched further. I also hate any kind of stigma on a child that implies that he or she should not have been born.
@Believe-you-me-
@Believe-you-me- Месяц назад
Don’t have too many kids.
@inphowatcher9748
@inphowatcher9748 Месяц назад
But they chose to have that many kids…
@marijo1951
@marijo1951 Месяц назад
@@inphowatcher9748But the child didn't ask to be born, and shouldn't be punished for existing. In any case, as others have pointed out, people might be doing reasonably well and then fall on hard times. If this country learned to nurture all its children, we'd be repaid later in a more stable more productive population.
@Believe-you-me-
@Believe-you-me- Месяц назад
@@inphowatcher9748 Knowing full well benefits will only pay for two.
@alanwhite7127
@alanwhite7127 Месяц назад
how back in the day u only got money for ur second kid none for ur first so whos kids do i have to pay for??
@ShabumkinSpleen
@ShabumkinSpleen Месяц назад
This is a "New Labour" government, not a Labour Party one... Labour has not had power since 1979, 45 years ago... Be honest and use their real name.
@andreer-k6136
@andreer-k6136 Месяц назад
Why can’t we have Mr Flynn as PM? He’s got it all - and most importantly, he has integrity… it shines out of him.
@AJM-GariochQuine
@AJM-GariochQuine Месяц назад
Sorry - he's destined to be PM of the Republic of Scotland within the next 5 years!!
@jamesarnold7253
@jamesarnold7253 Месяц назад
Because his party just lost most of their seats?
@mattws5784
@mattws5784 Месяц назад
Let’s all have more kids and go on benefits then and nobody works, that way everyone can sit on their arse and be paid for doing it, fair enough right?
@samsoncooper1
@samsoncooper1 Месяц назад
Love Stephen Flynn, thoroughly decent guy
@johncarney9049
@johncarney9049 Месяц назад
Here we have the SNP once again talking sense and the Scottish electorate chose to reduce their voice down to 9 seats, it's sad that the one party who always tries to do what is right for the UK are seen as the enemy. What many fail to understand about the SNP is this: Yes they want independence BUT they also want what is best for the UK and the people of the UK WHILE we are in the union, as what is bad for the UK is bad for Scotland and they love Scotland with a passion and do not like to see it's people being mauled by bad decisions. So now they will try and put forward an amendment in WM on the issue to try get Labour to be sensible but it will amount to nothing with only 9 seats, in the meantime Scottish labour MP's "Scotland's voice at the heart of a Labour Government" (remember that beauty) will do nothing but what the whip tells them. Never forget this, there is not such thing as a Scottish Labour MP, just Labour MP's. Feel free to check the Electoral commission and search for registered political parties. They don't exist.
@heremyjunt
@heremyjunt Месяц назад
How much did the SNP pay you to write that bilge? When you lose an election, saying ‘the voters got it wrong, not us’ usually doesn’t end well
@johncarney9049
@johncarney9049 Месяц назад
@@heremyjunt What bilge? You disagree with what I said? Fine. State why and fully explain otherwise - shut the fuck up.
@user-io5tv1rv4v
@user-io5tv1rv4v Месяц назад
@@heremyjunt what part is bilge...please explain ?
@heremyjunt
@heremyjunt Месяц назад
@@user-io5tv1rv4v well for starters it’s pretty ludicrous to claim that the SNP are the only party who do what’s best for the UK when they’re literally trying to break it up…
@user-io5tv1rv4v
@user-io5tv1rv4v Месяц назад
@@heremyjunt you broke it yourselves....years of tory misrule and your idiotic brexit....
@rosyapplekitchen635
@rosyapplekitchen635 Месяц назад
Yes let’s increase taxes of hardworking couples who can’t afford children so the scroungers can keep having more, who then also end up on benefits. Well done labour
@macmachine
@macmachine Месяц назад
Don't have kids if you cannot afford them - not rocket science.
@peterdelmonte9832
@peterdelmonte9832 Месяц назад
So poor people can never have a family? Don’t be daft.
@Gamer_Sebby
@Gamer_Sebby Месяц назад
@@peterdelmonte9832 By your argument, you then expect everyone else to pay for that poor family's choices? I think not. People should be thankful that you can claim up to two children at all, if you want more than that then you should be expected to pay your own way for your own family in which you decided to make your own decisions within.
@gekzify
@gekzify Месяц назад
Also government; why aren’t people having kids 😂😂😂
@TomT243
@TomT243 Месяц назад
​@peterdelmonte9832 You can claim for two kids. If you want more kids, then work harder & pay for them yourself!
@rosarose3443
@rosarose3443 Месяц назад
84 million to Africa.
@djoldschool
@djoldschool Месяц назад
As a middle class, fairly decent earner living in the South East of the UK, I couldn’t agree more with Flynn.
@user-pp9yk3tu4z
@user-pp9yk3tu4z 28 дней назад
If you can’t afford it don’t have more children simple as. Why should someone else pay for your poor decision. Of course it is terrible seeing children in poverty but ultimately it’s their parents who are to blame. Yes there are some who are not in the right circumstances etc have kids young… but why should someone else pick up the bill.
@jameshutton3960
@jameshutton3960 Месяц назад
Sorry I disagree on this one. Lifting the cap would result in those fiddling the system having more children to get more benefits. The fix should be not paying people to have more kids.
@Tymbus
@Tymbus Месяц назад
Sir Kid Starver is doing exactly as expected
@monicas2269
@monicas2269 Месяц назад
I don't think this cap should be lifted. I had 2 children back in the early 80's and stopped because I wouldn't have been able to afford any more. I understand that families circumstances can change but you have to think about this before you decide to have more than 2.
@thatgushiekid1662
@thatgushiekid1662 Месяц назад
Yes future kids being born this should be considered, but what about the already starving families with 3+ kids??
@monicas2269
@monicas2269 Месяц назад
@@thatgushiekid1662 Some people just have too many children that they can't afford to keep. More than 3 children before the cap was in place would have cost a lot of money but they still had more. People need to take more responsibility and not expect benefits to pay for their lives. My husband is one of 10, the oldest is now 97 but they didn't have all the hand outs that are available today, they just got on with it.
@orderbooks5789
@orderbooks5789 Месяц назад
If people want to have more children why should finances restrict a human desire? The economy actually needs ppl to have more children, hence why the topic is everywhere atm. Low birth rates = less workers = less growth = more immigration required also.
@NeonVisual
@NeonVisual Месяц назад
When I was a kid we occasionally had to go without Fajitas and sky TV, so of course I know the difficulties families are facing
@charlievarley
@charlievarley Месяц назад
Child benefit does not go to children, it goes to their parents. I don't believe that the cap is the best way to get children out of abject poverty that includes hunger. Unfortunately some parents have other pressures too, ones that could mean loosing their home, expensive bills or a chaotic lifestyle. These "other" pressures often can have a priority over food. Using money that is given directly to children via breakfast clubs, free dinners and after school clubs. These, with the inclusion of better child and adult services is the better use of funding for now. More can be done to help children directly this way, which is the plan for now.
@flucazade
@flucazade Месяц назад
Utter shite
@hashburystumble8808
@hashburystumble8808 Месяц назад
Scotland has shown otherwise & has been backed by charities working in the field.
@charlievarley
@charlievarley Месяц назад
@@hashburystumble8808 Looking at the data my comments still stand. From CPAG "In Scotland child poverty remains high, but is EXPECTED to start falling significantly as a result of recent policy interventions" March 2024. " Unfortunately the trajectory is still upwards from the period 2018-2021 it has risen from 20% (before housing costs) to 24% in the period 2020-2023. After housing cost have risen from 21% in 2010 to 24% in 2023. Which indicates that other pressures as well as housing are over riding the payments from Gov to parents. Child poverty markers are from the standpoint of a family income perspective. I still think intervention directly with children will make the fastest difference. Saying that, it would be nice for the rest of the family to feel the same benefit. In the fastest time.
@kayleighphillips4117
@kayleighphillips4117 Месяц назад
I think at least 3 children. That is a start. Its the single mothers I feel for or the mothers who has to leave an abusive relationship and now has to bring up her children alone. It’s all well and good saying stop having them if you can’t afford them but a lot of women didn’t choose to have children alone.
@mattws5784
@mattws5784 Месяц назад
Should have used your brain, if your partner is abusive, why have a kid with them? No excuse 😅
@Hat101
@Hat101 Месяц назад
Labour doesn't care about the working class because Starmer doesn't.
@ScottishRoss27
@ScottishRoss27 Месяц назад
Labour keep people poor because poor people vote Labour.
@Believe-you-me-
@Believe-you-me- Месяц назад
Neither did Corbyn…..
@butternutdiabetic7984
@butternutdiabetic7984 Месяц назад
Yeah but his dad was a tool maker tho. Y'know, just incase anyone had missed that.
@ScottishRoss27
@ScottishRoss27 Месяц назад
@@butternutdiabetic7984 Make UK report the other day 34,000 manufacturing jobs in Engand lost last year.
@Eltener123
@Eltener123 Месяц назад
​@@Believe-you-me-how's that relevant?
@Ma55ey
@Ma55ey Месяц назад
will they scrap it? depends how well that policy tests on talk tv i guess...
@ronlarratt9642
@ronlarratt9642 Месяц назад
Why should the tax payer pay for kids if you can’t afford kids don’t have them.
@fireh3211
@fireh3211 Месяц назад
It's revenge, it won't actually release the hostages. In Minecraft. (I was talking about the two-child benefit cap)
@pancho1993
@pancho1993 Месяц назад
I get angry when i dont get fajitas for tea!
@Glasgow_kiss
@Glasgow_kiss Месяц назад
but labour have a child poverty strategy. what is that strategy? 🤷‍♂ know one knows and they aint saying. JUST BELIEVE where have i heard that before?
@I-OMusic
@I-OMusic Месяц назад
"fix the thing we spent 14 years breaking immediately"
@onenote6619
@onenote6619 Месяц назад
Is it a thing that needs doing? Yes. Are there things that need doing first? Personally, I think so. Can Labour do everything at once? Obviously not. And Stephen Flynn said it himself: 14 years of Tory rule. That doesn't get resolved in less than a month.
@UnwittingSweater
@UnwittingSweater Месяц назад
Yeah which is why I think this is just Politics form the SNP to get their name in the headlines. "Look we care about the kids". Labour have only been in a couple of weeks. I think they would have pull this into the Autumn budget.
@bleizthomas4707
@bleizthomas4707 Месяц назад
love stephen flynn
@paulgibbons2320
@paulgibbons2320 Месяц назад
Funfacts. Employers in the UK are not obligated to pay for children. One child or ten, your wages never change. If you asked for a wage rise because you have kids, then you would be laughed out of the office. Our system is just not set up right.
@Ktf2309
@Ktf2309 Месяц назад
Don't forget the 4 wifes
@jonathanhill9504
@jonathanhill9504 Месяц назад
​@@Ktf2309 why would someone deserve more money than another person doing the same job, because they chose to have a child
@paulgibbons2320
@paulgibbons2320 Месяц назад
@jonathanhill9504 Because most of our employers only pay substance wages, which are only enough to pay for one working adult.
@paulgibbons2320
@paulgibbons2320 Месяц назад
@jonathanhill9504 Deciding who is 'deserving" is a complicated question. Are you suggesting only people on the wage of a legal or a doctor should be allowed to procreate ? You're cheering on your own slave masters and you can't even see it.
@3d1e00
@3d1e00 Месяц назад
Yeah rightly so, you think you've earned a pay rise because you've had a child? Entitlement much?
@johnnysheen9615
@johnnysheen9615 Месяц назад
Red Tories at work.
@chester6343
@chester6343 Месяц назад
£26 a week.. game changing. Okay then.
@DW-indeed
@DW-indeed Месяц назад
Hah, I was going to make fajitas for my tea tonight
@michaelpyatt831
@michaelpyatt831 Месяц назад
I’m sorry but why am I paying for other peoples brats ?? I don’t have children because I don’t want the expense of it purely and simple. If you can’t afford 2 children let alone 3 or more then that’s on you , stop going with the begging. BOwl to the tax payers
@fayesouthall6604
@fayesouthall6604 Месяц назад
The Autumn Statement by Rachel Reeves.. she will find the cash to do it. Under promise, over deliver is their plan.
@marijo1951
@marijo1951 Месяц назад
Maybe. People kept telling me before the election that Starmer and Reeves were keeping their secret radical agenda under wraps so as not to antagonise the Tory press, but I still have my doubts. If it happens, that's great, but impoverished families could really do with the extra money from this week rather than waiting until Autumn.
@idio-syncrasy
@idio-syncrasy Месяц назад
It's imperative that the cap is abolished.
@MikeDrew-zo4kk
@MikeDrew-zo4kk Месяц назад
*Thanks for keeping us updated! I feel sympathy and empathy for our country. low income people are suffering to survive, and I appreciate Amanda. You've helped my family with your advice. imagine investing $30,000 and receiving $95,460 after 28 days of trading*
@happinesschidera2293
@happinesschidera2293 Месяц назад
What opportunities are there in the market, and how do I profit from it?
@AliceAlice-zx6vd
@AliceAlice-zx6vd Месяц назад
I began investing in stocks and Def earlier this year, and it is the best choice l've ever made. My portfolio is rounding up to almost a million, and I have realized that when a stock makes it to the news. Chances are you're quite late to the party, the idea is to get in early on blue chips before it becomes public. There are lots of life changing opportunities in the market, and maximize it
@MikeDrew-zo4kk
@MikeDrew-zo4kk Месяц назад
You can make a lot of money from the market regardless of whether it strengthens or crashes. The key is to be well positioned.
@johntyler7024
@johntyler7024 Месяц назад
I would really like to know how this actually works.
@MikeDrew-zo4kk
@MikeDrew-zo4kk Месяц назад
All you need is a good capital, and the service of a professional broker, with those your investment will most certainly produce high yields.
@fintamaria2429
@fintamaria2429 Месяц назад
👏👏👏
@smith_5345
@smith_5345 Месяц назад
He dismisses the financial difficulties around the UK government removing the 2 child policy but when pressed on his own governments policy he immediately falls back to financial difficulty.
@graemetimoney7002
@graemetimoney7002 Месяц назад
Westminster and Holyrood are entirely different in how they are funded. Westminster holds the purse strings for both and can increase spending on whatever it decides, Holyrood must work within it's allocated budget.
@gavinsmith9564
@gavinsmith9564 Месяц назад
Brexit has cost over £100 Billion so far, imagine if we'd spent that on the country instead of Brexit lies and fantasies, time reparations were paid, Brexiteers owe us £100 Billion !!!
@alanwhite7127
@alanwhite7127 Месяц назад
whos kids??
@Oniontrololol
@Oniontrololol Месяц назад
Don’t lift the cap.
@BeccaAl
@BeccaAl Месяц назад
4:23 what’s the guy in the background with the black gloves on up to? V sus.
@McLintox
@McLintox Месяц назад
Working!
@tonybrett5209
@tonybrett5209 Месяц назад
Only problem is there's about 2,000 things that need reversing/repairing. The thing is with taxing is it will still take quite some time to build the coffers required.
@4R53Hole
@4R53Hole Месяц назад
Could be done instantly.
@SlowhandGreg
@SlowhandGreg Месяц назад
@@4R53Hole They have to find 18 billion to make sure we don't have Austerity again, the Tories forward spent the NI money there was no fiscal headroom it was paid for with promises of more cuts
@literallyJoel
@literallyJoel Месяц назад
@@SlowhandGreg Yeah but the 18 billion figure comes from the fact that Labour have committed to sticking with the Tories arbitrary fiscal rules. Choosing to stick with conservative economic policy is a political choice that they are making, and it is fair to judge them on that decision.
@BumbleyBoo
@BumbleyBoo Месяц назад
@@literallyJoel For now at least. I'd give them some headroom as we're finding out more sticking plasters the Tories kept quiet. Like the state of the prison system being considerably worse than expected.
@woofpet
@woofpet Месяц назад
@@tonybrett5209 of course it doesn’t quite work like that, does it? The government doesn’t collect pennies in s jar and break into it once they’ve filled it up. It’s a matter of telling the BoE to add some zeros to a figure and THEN working out how much tax is needed to balance that figure in order to prevent galloping inflation and deciding what to tax and by how much to make that happen. But I suspect you knew that all along.
@coderider3022
@coderider3022 Месяц назад
Glad labour and conservative are of one mind on this. It’s not a spending priority and need the grownups to take difficult calls. I agree on tightening up CGT and dividend tax and offshore bonds. Plenty of cash to fix the urgent stuff.
@milesshelbourne394
@milesshelbourne394 Месяц назад
Stephen - why don't you lot focus on getting our national debt down. LIke the rest of us you all want a positive personal balance sheet - why don't you run the country in that way? It's atrocious - forcing us all to keep paying for your wasteful spending. You would never run your own affairs like that!
@alexanderprice6612
@alexanderprice6612 Месяц назад
No he musn't. If people want more kids they can go to work and stop relying on the taxpayer to fund their choice in lifestyle. Having a baby is a CHOICE. Choose BETTER.
@rickparkinmoto
@rickparkinmoto Месяц назад
Which will mean that we need to bring more workers in from abroad. Judging by your ignorant statement I'm guessing you're the type who wouldn't be too keen on more foreigners coming here.
@clemdarkstar
@clemdarkstar Месяц назад
Fajita Flynn
@cellocase7148
@cellocase7148 Месяц назад
What about the father getting their kids out of poverty?
@bigeein
@bigeein Месяц назад
I wish , after 17 years the SNP would do something good for the country they are meant to represent. Que the standard excuse, it’s no us it’s Westminster
@AmandaJAart
@AmandaJAart Месяц назад
What are you blethering about? The man is right there telling you what's being done in Scotland, with progressive taxation.
@AlexHamilton86
@AlexHamilton86 Месяц назад
Oh poor wee Flynn - Scotland being embarrassed by Germany hardly registered on England fans' radars. He should have some great housing policies, seeing as how England football lives rent free in his head 🤣
@IndaloMan
@IndaloMan Месяц назад
Does the UK need to increase the population?? If yes, let the immigrants stay, much cheaper than raising babies....
@craig3533
@craig3533 Месяц назад
Now tell us what your plan is to pay for it. I get wanting it gone - a lot of people want it gone, as it's a policy which punishes people for changes in circumstances. The problem is that if all you do is say "Make it go away", you're not solving a problem, you are carping from the sidelines and trying to sabotage a new government, rather than acting as some sort of moral leader. Of course, the latter is really the priority here: the SNP want the gloss to come off any new government before there's Hollyrood elections - they're perfectly allowed to do that, but let's not dress it up.
@Skygrey2943
@Skygrey2943 Месяц назад
He said they could increase taxation on the wealthy.
@tomfinney3416
@tomfinney3416 Месяц назад
craig , on the never never mate ,its just going from 104%of gdp as a national debt to 105% of gdp , the banks print it out of thin air , we live in a fiat economy , so we go to the money tree give it a shake and our kids are fed , there should be no reason for keir starmer to wear the tory tag kid starver , he could easily stop kids going hungry
@marijo1951
@marijo1951 Месяц назад
@@Skygrey2943 One specific policy which has been recommended by Richard J. Murphy, is to start taxing capital gains at the same rate as income tax, which would net the Treasury £12bn a year. It seems very unfair that a person on very ordinary earnings pays a higher rate of tax than somebody who gains their income from investments.
@woofpet
@woofpet Месяц назад
He literally just listed a bunch of things that could be done to raise the sum required. It’s a choice. If Labour chooses to prioritise the desires of their donors over the needs of the voters, so be it. They will be out on their ears - and perhaps we’ll before 2929. Meantime, children remain in poverty.
@craig3533
@craig3533 Месяц назад
​ @Skygrey2943 What he gave is the crowd pleasing first line of an answer. What route, what methods, do they have a plan for knock on effects? How about dealing with the inflationary pressures of increased spending on staple goods? Do they mean asset rich or just people who have a high income? If it's asset rich, is there a plan to deal with asset owners upping charges on things like rental property? If it's income rich, does he understand that's a tax on well off workers, not the truly rich? How will they deal with the political fall out of one of Labour's first moves being a tax raid, because it will be significant and lasting (which may be the SNPs goal). It's not a one line answer policy solution. I really wish it was, but it's not.
@timarmitage8538
@timarmitage8538 Месяц назад
What next! Pay for extra wives!! Oh wait a minute that actually exists 😮 LOOK AFTER YOUR OWN KIDS OR DON'T HAVE THEM!
@Revolutionary1449
@Revolutionary1449 Месяц назад
Isn't this the infinity immigration guy?
@LimeyRedneck
@LimeyRedneck Месяц назад
🤠🍋‍🟩
@millllbs
@millllbs Месяц назад
Steve Flynn acting like a child on Twitter
@Lawrence-ui1hv
@Lawrence-ui1hv Месяц назад
Where's the money???
@tonybrett5209
@tonybrett5209 Месяц назад
Ask Michelle Mone.
@4R53Hole
@4R53Hole Месяц назад
Cayman Islands
@keithparker1346
@keithparker1346 Месяц назад
We have money to increase "defence" spending...
@SlowhandGreg
@SlowhandGreg Месяц назад
@@keithparker1346 we don't, the 1st priority is finding 18 billion so we don't have another round of cuts to services.
@HA05GER
@HA05GER Месяц назад
Exactly that we had money to send to Ukraine but we don't have money to look after our own.
@dangwyther8980
@dangwyther8980 Месяц назад
The other way to look at it is that parents are choosing to bring those children into poverty. 2 child cap is realistic, affordable and manageable.
@tomfinney3416
@tomfinney3416 Месяц назад
times change , a family grows but one or both parents lose work , incomes are shortened by no choice of their own , then there is divorces , and a parent left to raise the kids alone , all by fate falling foul of the 2 child benefit cap , passed by mps who claim so much in expenses ie benefits for them and their never ending line of kids
@HA05GER
@HA05GER Месяц назад
As a parent that's got ill so currently don't work we don't all pick to be in the situation. I'm lucky and I already had my finances in good order and have a council property that we survive perfectly fine even with the cap but that's not the case for many many people.
@DavidZ4-gg3dm
@DavidZ4-gg3dm Месяц назад
@@tomfinney3416 Most are poor all along.
@jim-es8qk
@jim-es8qk Месяц назад
How is this guy still leader? He lost the majority of his seats. And anyway, no one is stopping them having children. They can have as many as they want. Just dont expect me to pay for them. Its called personal responsibility.
@CaptainQuo
@CaptainQuo Месяц назад
The leader of what? What the fuck are you talking about?
@arbbr9397
@arbbr9397 Месяц назад
This guy isn’t the leader of the SNP he is their Westminster representative. Also, discouraging people from having children is a ridiculous sentiment. We have a rapidly ageing population because people can’t afford to make good money and raise children at the same time. If you’re against immigration too then you’re truly lost. An ageing stagnant not working population places high demands on taxes and on the NHS. Get your head sorted pal
@jim-es8qk
@jim-es8qk Месяц назад
​@@CaptainQuoHe is the leader of the SNP in Westminster. He lost 84% of their seats!!
@jim-es8qk
@jim-es8qk Месяц назад
​@@arbbr9397They are not capping the benefit. They are capping the amount of money someone can claim.
@DavidZ4-gg3dm
@DavidZ4-gg3dm Месяц назад
Don't have kids you can't provide for.
@jamesannetts4449
@jamesannetts4449 Месяц назад
The point of government is to help ppl who can’t always provide for their families each month
@DavidZ4-gg3dm
@DavidZ4-gg3dm Месяц назад
@@jamesannetts4449 There are millions of people who irresponsibly have kids they know they can't provide for at any time.
@DavidZ4-gg3dm
@DavidZ4-gg3dm Месяц назад
@@PlutoPhobia-qg6wn People should be responsible. Having several kids when you're broke is clearly wrong.
@sam.dubya420
@sam.dubya420 Месяц назад
​@DavidZ4-gg3dm what if they had say 3 kids when they're doing well then a family tragedy meant they were without the same income? Too late to not have the kids then!
@nathanaelsmith3553
@nathanaelsmith3553 Месяц назад
You mean don't have parents who can't afford you
@nomoreheroes93
@nomoreheroes93 Месяц назад
Good to see the wind taken out of his sails - lots of good intentions corrupted by the bs which is Scottish independence. He should switch over to Labour.
@shinydarknight01
@shinydarknight01 Месяц назад
Don't agree - if you can't afford more than 2 kids, don't have them.
@petersmith6678
@petersmith6678 Месяц назад
Ever occur to you that maybe when you get pregnant you can afford it, then life changes and suddenly you can't? It's such a stupid argument made by stupid people. I'm sure you're not one of them though, right?
@shinydarknight01
@shinydarknight01 Месяц назад
@@petersmith6678 no, Im not, it's called forward planning. I don't make dumb long term financial commitments. But people like you blame everyone else for your poor decision making and expect other taxpayers to prop you up. If I can't pay my mortgage in a few years, is the state going to pay it for me? No.
@loganjeffrey4136
@loganjeffrey4136 Месяц назад
​@shinydarknight01 you do understand that they might of been in a good financial point in there but then there rent could go up they could of lost there jobs?
@shinydarknight01
@shinydarknight01 Месяц назад
@@loganjeffrey4136 I lost my job, I got a better paid job 🤷🏻‍♂️. My mortgage is prob going up next year, but I get rid of debt to cover it. It's not rocket science.
@shinydarknight01
@shinydarknight01 Месяц назад
@@loganjeffrey4136 I lost my job. I got a better paid job. My mortgage is prob going up next year, but I pay down other debt to cover it. It's not rocket science
@markrichards8946
@markrichards8946 Месяц назад
Labour can find money for weapons and war, but not for children in poverty, says everything about Kid Starver and his party.
@Zoro007
@Zoro007 Месяц назад
Hmmmm..now...who demographically would benefit from lifting the two child benefit cap 🤔🤔🤔🤔......hmmm... I wonder 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔....
@HA05GER
@HA05GER Месяц назад
Pretty much all low income families whatever their background.
@thomasmanning477
@thomasmanning477 Месяц назад
Children?
@Believe-you-me-
@Believe-you-me- Месяц назад
Vasectomies are free in England….
@Believe-you-me-
@Believe-you-me- Месяц назад
@@PlutoPhobia-qg6wn my parents could afford me. You can still have two kids and receive benefits for each.
@jennywelch9331
@jennywelch9331 Месяц назад
Sorry but after two thats it the goverment really shouldnt be giving anymore and before anyone comes at me no im not rich and yes i have 2 kids and if i had a 3rd id still feel this way SNP sitting talking like they know how to look after there people when we are sitting here with high drug deaths and poor kids and schools 🏫
@jonathanbennet2580
@jonathanbennet2580 Месяц назад
why outta interest?
@jamesannetts4449
@jamesannetts4449 Месяц назад
Ppl who say the same thing usually cry about white brits not having enough kids and then complaining when more immigrants r brought in to make up for lack of workers
@4R53Hole
@4R53Hole Месяц назад
So reduce support to... ...make more kids poor?
@cellocase7148
@cellocase7148 Месяц назад
The more poverty the higher the birth rates.
@jennywelch9331
@jennywelch9331 Месяц назад
@@4R53Hole ever herd of work ? How about they sort it so we can work to feed our family's and not pay threw the noses or here's a bright idea use condom and other kinds of protection to not have a 3rd kid cos you can't afford it they are all free for you 😉
@susanthompson5381
@susanthompson5381 Месяц назад
We can’t afford to pay for extra children the parents should look after there children they decided to have them they should be able to afford to look after them not the tax payers
@HA05GER
@HA05GER Месяц назад
Its not perfect however our birthrate is on the floor. Hence why we need alot of immigrants to fill the void. Until that is addressed it will carry on.
@SpeculativeConjecture
@SpeculativeConjecture Месяц назад
SNP currently can't field an 11 man football team with their MPs so they need to be quiet
@graemetimoney7002
@graemetimoney7002 Месяц назад
Ridiculous attitude, their job is to speak for those who voted for them.
@davidhamilton7020
@davidhamilton7020 Месяц назад
Let's interpret the real meaning of this statement.. 'get back in your box you Jock bastard' speak plainly you colonial 🤡. :
@matthewmcveigh2122
@matthewmcveigh2122 Месяц назад
Don't have kids you can't afford to have. I'm the eldest of 4 siblings and my parents did not receive handouts. My dad worked with the same company my entire life and put himself through college while I was a baby. Working the fruit market in the morning, college during the day and work at night. He built his way up through his work and has remained through 3 seperate takeovers of the business. My mum worked 3 jobs at one point. Self employed with each one. Working from early in the morning to late at night. If they stopped working, even for a couple of weeks, they wouldn't be able to pay the mortgage. Improve sex education in schools and make vasectomies more widely accessible.
@literallyJoel
@literallyJoel Месяц назад
I would argue that no-one should have to work 3 jobs just to make ends meet. An arguments about whether someone should have had another kid or not aside, at the end of the day the kid wasn't chosen to be born, and they are being condemned to poverty for something they have no control over.
@YA-hm5zy
@YA-hm5zy Месяц назад
On one hand you want people to have less kids cos it's impossible to raise them in a society where everything costs a fortune. Therefore there is a shortfall of people paying into the system..and on the other hand you want to stop immigration.
@matthewmcveigh2122
@matthewmcveigh2122 Месяц назад
@@literallyJoel They didn't do it to make ends meet, they did it to provide a quality life for their children. They could've moved us to some council estate which is exactly what they worked so hard to get out of.
@rickparkinmoto
@rickparkinmoto Месяц назад
If you struggled in life and want other people to struggle in life because 'you turned out fine', you did NOT in fact turn out fine.
@matthewmcveigh2122
@matthewmcveigh2122 Месяц назад
@@rickparkinmoto amazingly, my siblings and I all have degrees and don't live with our parents. Seems like my parents hard work paid off. But hey, I didn't turn out fine because I believe in working for a living.
@julielawlor5482
@julielawlor5482 Месяц назад
Your kids are your responsibility not every tax payers What about the millions of invisible people single or those who chose not to have kids who get no help struggle but are taxed to the hilt to pay for other peoples kids
@gravijax
@gravijax Месяц назад
meanwhile, you probably complain about the immigrants we NEED because British people are not having enough kids.
@robertdodd8312
@robertdodd8312 Месяц назад
Kids wouldnt be in poverty if people stopped having too many if you cant feed them dont breed them. Take note all you muslim brethren.
Далее
Woman = best friend🤣
00:31
Просмотров 2,1 млн
Keir Starmer on far-right riots
0:39
Просмотров 13 тыс.
Keir Starmer probed by journalists over cronyism
19:40
Economist explains why Britain is poor
32:23
Просмотров 1,3 млн