Why The Fire Nation Killed Katara's Mom [Avatar: The Last Airbender Theory]

Подписаться 2,2 млн

Просмотров 429 тыс.

50% 1

Today J dives into the world of Avatar: The Last Airbender to address one of the shows longest unanswered mysteries. Why did the Fire Nation suddenly decided to kill Katara and Sokka's mother Kya after just capturing water benders for so long?
Carlin Brothers Coffee ►► www.CarlinBrothersCoffee.com
Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► www.SuperCarlinBrothers.Store
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
J's V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
T W I T T E R➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Intro Music Created by RKVC
/ @rkvc
Intro Animation Created by J. Cutt Productions
/ @j.cuttproductions
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)

Кино

Опубликовано:

5 окт 2020

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 1,9 тыс.

@SuperCarlinBrothers 3 года назад

What other Avatar mysteries should we look into!?

@noahhammond1088 3 года назад

love your channel who else does 👇

@masonrobson1944 3 года назад

More information on avatar wan please 👍🏻👍🏻

@rockstarfreddy762 3 года назад

Zuko's mum

@masonrobson1944 3 года назад

SuperCarlinBrothers more information on avatar wan

@foreverbroken98 3 года назад

What has happen to uncle iroh? And what happen to his build?

@TheAres1999 3 года назад

Plot twist: Imagine if Aang was wiped out with the other nomads, and the next Avatar was a swamp bender

@allisonromano235 3 года назад

😂

@dansattah 3 года назад

Seriously, were the fire benders even aware of the swamp benders? 😁

@allisonromano235 3 года назад

@Dan Al I don’t think so

@allisonromano235 3 года назад

@Art Sparks Fly 😂

@dansattah 3 года назад

In fact, what about a theory of the history of the swamp benders? How did those water benders get from the poles to the tropics?

@creategenius719 3 года назад

Kya's death is even darker when you consider that little Katara saw her mother's corpse in the tent.

@pedro55845 3 года назад

Actually no her mother told her to called her dad. Katara then says "when we got there she was gone" meaning they took her and killed her hence why their is no graveyard in southern water tribe

@peachcherryblossom_8264 3 года назад

Simply Era Katara and Sokka visit Kya’s grave the comics wdym

@creategenius719 3 года назад

If her body was gone, Hakoda would have suspected she was captured like people in pass raids; not killed. They only way they would have known if she was killed is if they saw the body. Also, Katara has her mother's necklace, which Kya was wearing at the time of the raid.

@SpiderSmoothie 3 года назад

@@peachcherryblossom_8264 the grave could just be a marker. People do that all the time when there is no body to bury. I would also imagine they wouldn't deal with their dead in such a cold climate in the same way they deal with them in warmer climates. Whatever was left of her was probably cremated.

@evn3585 3 года назад

And had to take the necklace off of her body.

@malcfoy 3 года назад

I hate how everyone just calls her Katara’s mother, she’s Sokka’s mom too!

@ijimenez1951 3 года назад

even Katara says Sokka and I

@asonzegreat226 3 года назад

What you what? "Katara and sokka's mom?" Thats too long

@charmedrools1 3 года назад

i mean we could just call her Kya since that's her name... (pronounced Kai-Ah)

@Fawnfreckle 3 года назад

Potato potahama

@shalomlevlederman5124 3 года назад

Well sokka clearly didnt love her as much

@depressedonion9080 3 года назад

When hama spent 50 years kidnapping citizens when all she had to do was roll up one night to the fire lords house

@pininja4981 3 года назад

@Balance of The hill i get that. But killing isn't always the best choice. But it sometimes is

@konanxhidan3202 3 года назад

@Balance of The hill Killing Hama ? This is just disgusting... Hama did terrible things, but she was still a *victim* ! Her life was a nightmare. All her brothers and sisters, her beloved friends, Hama watched them all slowly rot and die.. How could someone not became insane after such a traumatic experience ? They even mentioned that EVERYONE of them was dead and Hama was the last prisoner.

@sock2856 3 года назад

dddd

@lillilly8453 3 года назад

Hehe true

@arriibacon531 3 года назад

Facts 😂😂😭

@AverytheCubanAmerican 3 года назад

Air Nomads: exist Fire Nation: I'm about to end these nomads' whole career Aang: Whoops you missed a spot

@robinsonbright2671 3 года назад

Lol

@jacobw4612 3 года назад

Chong the Singing Nomad: Me too!

@noahmareschal389 3 года назад

That's even funnier when you stop to consider how Aang looks like Mr.Clean 😂

@superbeltman6197 3 года назад

I feel it would have been better if they got aang since it would be faster only 20yrs max to have the new avatar take on the fire nation

@esqimo6647 3 года назад

There’s is an imposter among... no one left

@super-weirdo5219 3 года назад

I never really questioned why they killed Kya, but this theory is pretty good. As always, you guys have convinced me.

@sorayacatfriend 3 года назад

This is actually a really old theory. First read it on Reddit in 2013.

@dika_hilman 3 года назад

same

@Trithis2077 3 года назад

@@sorayacatfriend it hit the top of r/TheLastAirbender again just two weeks ago.

@heavenlyeji2176 3 года назад

They killed it for plot convenience

@elistringfellow2151 3 года назад

This is actually already explained in the show, they show that Kya was the last waterbender in the southern water tribe, however we know that was a lie because Katara could waterbend

@finnbruton7274 3 года назад

Alternative theory: The policy of capturing water benders changed to killing them because Ozai had just come to power. We see after Iroh’s sons death that that the previous fire lord Azulon was not as bad as Ozai. Judging by Katara’s age when her mother died, the timings add up.

@Nubin2000 3 года назад

Katara is Azula age so it would still be Azulon era probably.

@TheRunningLeopard 3 года назад

I agree, we also see that Azulon actually cared to some degree about Iroh’s wellbeing, especially after loosing his son. Ozai never shows that sort of empathy, even if it just for performance.

@justinbuckner4568 3 года назад

If that were true, why would they still take earth kingdom prisoners and have high security prisons like the boiling rock?

@eriks1765 3 года назад

Maybe. I think it's just a little before |Ozai, based on the ages of Katara and Zuko in flashbacks, but who knows

@nionashborn7626 3 года назад

It could also be about taxes, or some other boring reason, I imagine anti-waterbender facilities are expensive to maintain and whatnot

@brysonstevens2520 3 года назад

“No air nomads to teach the avatar air bending... win-win” Or one could almost say it’s a Wind-Wind?

@matthiasnguyen1329 3 года назад

It’s so bad it’s good

@athenebujard9819 3 года назад

Welcome to puns

@omnical6135 3 года назад

i like it but i don't want to give you the win, you don't deserve it

@esqimo6647 3 года назад

Get out.

@tylermartinez3068 3 года назад

🤦

@Cress453 3 года назад

Also Hama was friends with gran gran if you look at the scenes of the raids Hama is talking to a girl that has katara’s hair loopies

@iamagirl9938 3 года назад

Woah! I never realized that.

@DrowsyKodi 3 года назад

Small problem gran gran didn’t come to the southern water tribe it’ll her late teens early twenties when she was supposed to be betrothed to paku

@lucyandecember2843 3 года назад

@@DrowsyKodi truee, also i think the hair loopies are a common watertribe hairstyle so other people besides Katara may have them too.

@peteryanes9339 3 года назад

Wow I didn't know that n that makes sense because they from the same place I thought they would have but wasn't sure because they don't say In the show

@ljchallengerz4922 3 года назад

I just wanna appreciate that we all call Kataras hair “kataras hair loopys”

@franzkissel1369 3 года назад

In 100 years, the Fire Nation took over most of the Earth Kingdom, except Ba Sing Se and Omashu and some other small areas. They also nearly wiped out the Southern Water Tribe, which was probably once nearly as powerfull as its northern counterpart. That's not nothing, considering they were facing two nations at once and that they couldn't use the power of Sozin's comet.

@shreshthadavi141 3 года назад

Exactly! World domination is a HUGE goal, and the Fire Nation was playing the long game. They had to be smart about it, otherwise they would lose what they had and run out of resources to fuel imperial expansion.

@dika_hilman 3 года назад

Nice! 👍🏻

@robertgarcia6610 3 года назад

Yeah he said the Southern Water tribe has not been conquered, but it looks like it to me. The Fire nations regularly patrol the southern tribe and have a constant presence in the south. And the comics said the Southern Tribe used have cities like in the north but they have all been abandoned after constant attacks from the fire nation

@miszpnay7392 3 года назад

Completely agree! Ba Sing Se was difficult to siege. Even the Dragon of the West couldn’t hold it down. Also, we learned that there was another Day of Black Sun. It could have been within those 100 years. The Fire Nation had to protect themselves. They needed some time to focus on building their defenses i.e. Gates of Azulon.

@robertgarcia6610 3 года назад

@The Joker they only controlled Ba sing Se for a couple of months and earth bender rebellions made it impossible for the Fire nation to completely control the earth kingdom. And General Iroh only broke through the outer wall but never managed to make it into the city

@sthelenskungfu 3 года назад

I always thought it was Iroh's influence on his father, and then when Iroh lost his son and went into seclusion and Ozai took the throne, then they started killing instead of taking prisoners. Sozin actively wanted to share the wealth and propriety of the Fire Nation (by conquering everyone else... it's all the same thing, right?) For Sozin, everyone in the Air Temples were just unfortunate collateral damage in his pursuit of the Avatar. Azulan wanted to fulfill his father's dream (of conquering everyone.) Iroh wanted to create a lasting peace (at first but conquering everyone, but when he did a spiritual quest after losing his son he decided it would be best to create a peace maker out of his nephew.) Ozai actually believed that only the Fire Nation citizens count as people worth saving or helping.

@Moakmeister 3 года назад

Ozai was only Fire Lord for six years. Did he assume the throne before Kya was killed?

@sthelenskungfu 3 года назад

@@Moakmeister No, but with Iroh leading the army as a general, Azulan would set Ozai up to run other day-to-day events. He's not going to send Iroh to be a general and then say, "But Ozai, you just relax in the palace." He's going to give him a job to do.

@atheoristspointofview7059 3 года назад

Sozin wasn't ozais father.... that was azulon

@sthelenskungfu 3 года назад

@@atheoristspointofview7059 I mentioned Azulon. I never said Sozin was Ozai's father.

@marlonpineda2980 3 года назад

@@Moakmeister wait actually if he was fire lord for 6 years, katara would have been 8. She was 8 when her mom died. I like this theory WAAAAAY more. It also cements the Fire royal Fam was getting worse and worse.

@dripdoriya1707 3 года назад

Me: Iroh how did you get so buff Iroh: Every time my nephew talks about his honor, I do one push up Me: 👁👄👁

@JAleck 3 года назад

People: how do you get so buff? Katara: every time I mention my dead mother, I do 1 push-up. People: dang.

@drlc6051 3 года назад

Hah, amateur. Do a pushup every time Zuko mentions his honour.

@joeyb.5310 3 года назад

But imagine that. Do a push-up every time aang says he's the avatar

@thewonderlander1372 3 года назад

* Daang

@Bahle_Gaji 3 года назад

@@thewonderlander1372 get out

@treesovo2322 3 года назад

@@Bahle_Gaji get in

@zionsalakaia5090 3 года назад

Why does every avatar we know of have no siblings.

@rosemaryaragon2917 4 месяца назад

Because they’re poor parents can only keep up with one magical bending child 😂

@cyborgstar 3 года назад

I never expected Katara to actually use bloodbending, which made that scene where she attacked her mother's killer that much more intense.

@masynsmith4566 3 года назад

Others have mentioned that the math doesn’t add up for them to mistake Kya for Hama. Hama would have been an old lady at the time Kya was killed, but they didn’t necessarily have to be looking for a child either. If it’s been 50 years since their last raid a new water bender could be anywhere from 0-50 years old

@ckl9390 3 года назад

A Fire Nation fishing trawler could have witnessed some water bending at a distance. Possibly among a group of people so the report couldn't pinpoint exactly who did it, but they would know where the nearest village was and figure that's a likely place to look first. We, the audience, are mostly concerned with what the Fire Navy was doing, but there would have been other Fire Nation endeavours on the ocean including fishing and commercial transport.

@taylorschott4659 Год назад

That makes sense. maybe they thought Hamma died of old age and Kya was her daughter or something. Its even more believable when you consider that Kya,s ACTUAL mother,s name is incredibly similar to Hamma,s and they were friends.

@cytomplayz 3 года назад

0:02 "One of the most emotional episodes of avatar is when katara confronts her mother's killer" Me: *cries in appas lost days and tales of ba sing se*

@Engardian 3 года назад

I’ll make a prediction: keeping waterbenders captive was too dangerous. The learned that after Hama escaped.

@lostschedule51 3 года назад

"It will be long over... feels like what I said in March" - I need a break after that comment hit me.

@-gemberkoekje-5547 3 года назад

Havent wached the vid yet, this is my theory: Hamma escaped, the fire nation didnt want to take any more risks.

@DeathGodRiku 3 года назад

Before I watch: Hana is why. I'm betting that's the answer

@cloudfan228 3 года назад

@Art Sparks Fly pretty sure film theorists already covered this

@sirmyself 3 года назад

Doesn't make sense though And it's Hama

@frostyskeletons8950 3 года назад

Art Sparks Fly same, I used to watch MatPat but at some point his cadence in those videos started to sound like nails on a chalkboard

@btskpopjimin3106 3 года назад

Incorrect it was actually Hama was why

@samiranghosh9535 3 года назад

@@cloudfan228 No

@mithical4750 3 года назад

Katara: imagine how aang must have felt when his whole colony got whipped out..... that’s nothing compared to my mother

@ellevlogg 3 года назад

I'm so mad because Hama can create a BENDING FEARED BY THE WORLD, meanwhile, she didn't try Pee bending. I am SHOOK-

@josephsullivan6422 3 года назад

Guys take a moment to think about a Avatar from the Foggy Swamp Tribe and he or her animal companion is a Catgator Or and sand bending Avatar who has a Buzzard wasp as their animal companion

@DVankeuren 3 года назад

both of those are considered earth benders.

@wolfman2.055 3 года назад

@@DVankeuren foggy swamp style is more or less a blend of water and earth bending .

@ckl9390 3 года назад

@@DVankeuren The Foggy Swamp water benders are part of the Water Tribes, they've just been forgotten by the rest of the world like the Sun Warriors were for the Fire Nation. It is perfectly plausible for a water bending Avatar to be born to them. It is the primary bending that follows the pattern, the Avatar could be born anywhere there is the potential for it. However, statistics would tend toward the Northern or Southern Water Tribes by population. And yes, it is possible that there is a geographic pattern to where the Avatar is born in a particular nation, but we don't have a large enough sample size to meaningfully make that determination.

@jackreed8538 3 года назад

Not an avatar theory, but I’ve always wanted to know if you make a seed a horcrux is the plant it makes also a horcrux. And since trees can spread their seeds are those seeds also horcruxes. Could there be a horcrux forest!😄🌳

@frostyskeletons8950 3 года назад

I love this theory for some reason!

@aimeea.3775 3 года назад

Nightmare fuel

@PerovNigma 3 года назад

... Forbidden Forest?

@kierstencobb5517 3 года назад

That's a scary thought

@madelinebutler3088 3 года назад

I feel like if you made a horcrux from a seed it wouldn’t be able to grow

@jessicadougherty771 3 года назад

I've always wondered this: if she was really the last water bender why wouldn't she be fighting back with you know...water bending

@reaglecart3827 2 года назад

uhm are you talking about kya? cuz i think she.. isn't the waterbender, katara is. if you're talking about hama she only has the bloodbending power on the full moon and i believe at other time the fire nation cold just demolish her with sending a few people or maybe by ambush. if they could capture her once before why couldn't they do that again? so yeah

@d4rling.see-see._ 2 года назад

@@reaglecart3827 I think she meant "Why didn't they make her prove her waterbending abilities?".

@reaglecart3827 2 года назад

@@d4rling.see-see._ ooooh it make sense now... sorry my mistake

@One_Last_Time 2 года назад

@@d4rling.see-see._ because Yon Rha didn't want "Kya" to launch a surprise waterbending attack that could kill him.

@lethal1ty38 3 года назад

Katara : MY MOM WAS KILLED BY THE FIRE NATION Aang, whose entire race of air benders were killed: am I a joke to you

@theskiesbelongtome2029 3 года назад

Wait did you say katana. Idiot it’s katara

@sock2856 3 года назад

i mean aang's parents were never there and none of them were related sOOOO iDk

@sock2856 3 года назад

My rumor: since they think aang died they think he was reborn into the water tribes since water Is the next element and since the northern is too protected they go to the south and kills kya because she said she was the bender and the only bender in the tribe and every avatar can bend each element so they took a chance to think she was the avatar and killed her.

@alexren6277 3 года назад

you should talk about aang's mom

@allisonromano235 3 года назад

We don’t know anything at all about her

@gustavogoikoetxea4524 3 года назад

Air nomads grow up without parents

@SpiderSmoothie 3 года назад

@@gustavogoikoetxea4524 they grow up without parents but they were still born to parents. They still have a mother and father out there somewhere.

@unkle_iroh 3 года назад

Maybe the dad or mom was a bender and the other wasent so they had to leave each other and the other who was a bender died and so he went to a place that the people who don’t have parents go to so they don’t make him feel left out and they did not teach them about parents

@gustavogoikoetxea4524 3 года назад

SpiderSmoothie but if we are told about the people Aang was birthed from, there is no mother-son or father-son story to tell...we already got told a story about one of his parents Monk Gyatso

@JohnJohnson-tx1kr 3 года назад

Hey guys just an idea, there’s a RU-vid channel called screenrant, they do a series called theory battle where they each have a theory about a topic and try to figure out who’s theory makes the most sense. Then they let the comment section pick a winner. I think if you guys did something similar, it’d be really cool and fun to see, especially on topics where you have come out with a few theories (cough cough elder wand)

@Jamie-fw3kz 3 года назад

Yesss they should totally do that!

@beatrizribeiro2417 3 года назад

YEESS OMG YES a different J vs Ben type of thing omg yes

@beatrizribeiro2417 3 года назад

If u dont mind, im gonna comment this just to have more probability they will see it but i will give u credit

@th3kng276 3 года назад

Nah I don’t think they should take anything from screenrant. As far as I can tell, it’s all click bait. Except pitch meetings. Pitch meetings are TIGHT

@beatrizribeiro2417 3 года назад

@@th3kng276 yed pitch meetings is awsome but its just the concept and they could do their own spin and not click bait u know

@mandylovescanada 3 года назад

Katara: *My mother is DEAD* Aang: Has his whole species gone

@miriamrosemary9110 3 года назад

This explanation is sooo fitting! I always assumed that it was just a sadistic showing of power, that he murdered her just because he wanted to, or that it was less trouble than carrying a prisoner back. And with Hama leaving her fellow prisoner waterbenders behind - that was something I always wondered about. Thanks!

@anniebuck3248 3 года назад

Here’s an Avatar question: Why does Jun say Aang doesn’t exist when he’s on the lion turtle?

@MrEffectfilms 3 года назад

Because the Lion Turtle was covering Aangs scent. Her animal (I forget it's name) wouldn't have ever been in contact with a Lion Turtle before and since they live out in the ocean the water is likely covering his scent too.

@Delsin4077 3 года назад

@@MrEffectfilms the shirhsu's name is nyla and it can track people over water

@MrEffectfilms 3 года назад

@@Delsin4077 but can it track a lion turtle?

@singingwolf8997 3 года назад

My theory is that because the lion turtle is such a powerful and spiritual being, Aang being on it is akin to Aang being in the spirit world, only now it's his physical body rather than just his mind. So that spiritual presence masks his scent to the point that it's like he's no longer on this plain of existence. If that makes any sense?

@MrEffectfilms 3 года назад

@@singingwolf8997 Ya know what, yeah that makes a lot of sense, especially since until he tried his bending Aang thought he was in the spirit world.

@sfsin3380 3 года назад

Did they know how Hama escaped? I always thought the Fire Nation believed she escaped because she was the Avatar and thats why they stopped capturing Water Benders.

@freddymeng 3 года назад

The guard probably told them that he was being controlled by her

@sfsin3380 3 года назад

@@freddymeng I must be miss remembering I thought she killed him

@singingwolf8997 3 года назад

@@sfsin3380 No. She just kinda slammed him to the ground, but he was still alive.

@Engardian 3 года назад

I always thought that Hama was the last waterbender left when they escaped. Like, the rest of them died or were killed in captivity. Also, the obviously couldn’t show this, but I think it makes sense that Hama probably killed all the guards while she was escaping.

@reginaprince3020 3 года назад

If they are looking for Hama, them taking Kya doesn't make sense either. Hama could easily be Kya's mother, if not grandmother by age

@SpiderSmoothie 3 года назад

I don't agree with the theory on that point. I think the most likely scenario is that they believed the water bender was Hama's child or grandchild and that she had passed along the knowledge of blood bending.

@asmith8692 3 года назад

Hama was friends with Katara's grandmother. They looked the same age during that flashback episode.

@pigeon2503 3 года назад

@@asmith8692 I reckon the orders on age were unclear. It was probably "an adult female waterbender from the southern tribe" and that's it

@firstnamelastname6016 3 года назад

That moment where Katara froze the rain was just *chefs kiss* Perfection

@wyldstealer 3 года назад

Ayeeeeee made my day seeing this pop up

@Sports-fk9fm 3 года назад

Who else noticed that J had a scull on his shirt and the vid is about why someone died

@ambert.lawson4085 3 года назад

What's also interesting is that Rah is retired when he meets Katara again after all these years. He's empty and tells Katara to take his mother in order for them to be even. It makes you wonder if he starts to feel bad about killing kya when you can assume word got back to him a few weeks ago that Hama was captured after like 30+ years and realized that he had a mistake because he killed the wrong person completely unaware that Katara would face him one day and make him pay.

@joshuaharden8345 3 года назад

didn't watch the vid but i'll tell you why: hana escaped so they didn't want to take prisoners because it was too much of a liability so they killed her instead thinking she was the final southern water bender.

@hannahjohnson6940 3 года назад

I love that you guys are exploring the wonderful world of Avatar: The Last Airbender and expanding your horizons! Could I also suggest that you explore the Dragon Prince on Netflix as well? It is also very good and I would love to see all your theories and your take on the series!

@SeraphimCramer 3 года назад

The Dragon Prince is also made by the same people who did Avatar, & Sokka's actor voices one of the leads :)

@hmmmm2824 3 года назад

I stopped watching on season two. Should I continue?(the dragon prince)

@hannahjohnson6940 3 года назад

@@hmmmm2824 You definently should its soooo good and the last season ends with an awesome battle!!!

@SeraphimCramer 3 года назад

@@hmmmm2824 I would definitely recommend it.

@hmmmm2824 3 года назад

@@SeraphimCramer ok thanks!

@petertracycarroll 3 года назад

The scene where katara forgives zuko is one of my favourite in the show

@ousmanewheeler3944 3 года назад

"you don't know how i feel" Sokka in the background who had the same mom and aang who lost his whole nation which was his family.

@DenDave_ 3 года назад

I always thought this was obvious, but J just had to proof me wrong and make me think about Avatar in entirely new ways

@sirmyself 3 года назад

If they were looking for Hama when Katara was like 10, they would look for an aging woman about 80 years old... Definitely not Kya's age. The theory doesn't make sense to me at all.

@GhostW1thTheMost 3 года назад

0:36 she tortures the guy who didnt do it thinking it was him, then discovered it wasnt him and didnt do anything to the actual murderer, who admits it.

@malcolm32 3 года назад

Hmm. This is interesting, though thematically I like the idea that there was no greater plan or series of events that led to Kya's death. She was the victim of one man's cruelty and she died because Yan Ra felt like killing her. Also if the Fire Nation no longer thinks the Air Avatar is alive, then why is Zuko looking for an Airbender? Yes, he's searching the Southern Water Tribe when he first encounters Aang, but he was looking for an Airbender and we learn in a flashback later on that he started his search at the Western Air Temple, and then continued to the other temples before scouring the rest of the globe, which considering the timing, means that Zuko must have encountered the Mechanist and his band of refugees living at the Northern Air Temple, which isn't really relevant, but it's fun to think about.

@lukeroberson2115 2 года назад

Knowing Zuko and Iroh, Iroh made friends with the mechanic, and Zuko didn't do much once he knew there were no airbenders.

@scoldize 3 года назад

4:25 Dumb question: how did he find out how Aang got out alive?

@SpiderSmoothie 3 года назад

The fire sages told him I believe.

@scoldize 3 года назад

@@SpiderSmoothie I was talking about the fire sage.

@bharathram8848 3 года назад

Alexander Taylor They have that unexplained magic stuff. Like how in episode 3, their statue’s eyes light up when Aang goes into AS after seeing the genocide’s effect.

@lossymotsei6377 3 года назад

The only reason I see them attacking the southern water tribe is because The Last Avatar before Korra that was born from a water tribe was born in the South

@samgoose1160 3 года назад

"'this war isnt gonna last THAT long, right?' ....sounds like what i said in march" THAT HURT

@wafflearegood 3 года назад

so Hama technically killed Katara's mom because the fire was looking for HER

@cece4855 3 года назад

This is my favorite theory for avatar!!!! It all fits and makes perfect sense to me!!!!

@dheendabean 3 года назад

Last time I was this early the Air Nomads were alive.

@florenceb1031 3 года назад

I just happened to have started rewatching Avatar: The Last Airbender yesterday.

@katetanner28 3 года назад

But Hama's age doesn't line up with Kya at all? Even if she was a generous 15 when she was captured (despite not looking anything near the ages of the main characters), that would make her 75 during the events of the show, as she was captured 40 years into the 100 year war. Let's assume, based on the approximate ages of Katara and Sokka, that Kya was killed 10 years prior to the show. That would mean, if they were looking for Hama, they're looking for someone who, at the very youngest, is 65. Kya doesn't match that profile at all. If anything, it would be more likely that they thought Kya was the child of Hama, but definitely not Hama herself.

@TheRibottoStudios 3 года назад

I never really thought of Bloodbending as DANEROUS so much as INVASIVE AF but....yeah one wrong move and uhhhh....you dead. Or one right move and you dead. Depending on your point of view.

@piercecrist4433 3 года назад

Ribotto Studios watch legend of Korea and you’ll see

@TheRibottoStudios 3 года назад

@@piercecrist4433 ohhhhhh I've seen it. Ehh

@DVankeuren 3 года назад

Dangerous for two reasons, you can control people, and if you want, probably rip all the liquid out of their body.

@fireycard9338 3 года назад

Bloodbending is the most powerful, feared and darkest of all bending technique, that 's why It became illegal

@peteryanes9339 3 года назад

@Balance of The hill they couldn't show that it was a nick show

@jeremy1860 3 года назад

Did we ever find out who this "source" was that told the Fire Nation of this supposed final waterbender? 🤔

@guthixrests6453 3 года назад

The most emotional episodes by far was the library of wa shi tong where appa gets kidnapped by sand benders and toph has to choose who to save and Appa's lost days where it shows appa being lost, bullied, scared, injured and worried.

@amyloucurtis 3 года назад

I love that you do Avatar content!! This is truly a dream come true for me!! I'd love to learn more about the old members of the white lotus. Any theories about how they know each other? How did this society get started? Or maybe just an episode about King Bumi (cause he's nuts man! and can you imagine what he's seen in his lifetime?) Or maybe Guru Patik -- what nation is he from? how is he so old? how can he do "avatar magic" (looking in Appa's mind) without being even a bender? Anyways, I've got lots of questions about him.

@dylancronin4057 3 года назад

Could the execution of Water Bender prisoners could be that they thought Hama was the Avatar and then searched the southern water tribe searching for Hama there.

@aravpyati6344 3 года назад

This was the only episode where I despised Katara because of how she treated Sokka in the beginning.

@singingwolf8997 3 года назад

Didn't she basically act like he didn't care about their mom?

@Santoskc61 3 года назад

She said that because Sokka for some odd reason didn't want to find out who the killer was. This was a chance for Katara to get closure but Sokka was unsupportive of it so she said that in the heat of the moment. It's the same way Aang blew up and accused every Gaang member of not doing anything when they were looking for Appa even though Katara was trying to keep them all together and Sokka and Toph were doing what they could.

@singingwolf8997 3 года назад

@@Santoskc61 Sokka didn't want to go on a revenge mission. He knew that if they went after their mother's killer, Katara was very likely to do something she'd regret, so he was ready to leave the past in the past. He'd already gotten closure, in his own way.

@danieljay6196 3 года назад

Great theory! Idk if it can be answered but one thing I’ve always wondered is how the White Lotus was formed and how it’s members are selected?

@minor5027 3 года назад

Sokka: you know she was my mother too right- Katara: *MY MOTHER!!!*

@Jacel_Varela 3 года назад

I JUST GOT A NEW THEORY Are we gonna sit here and not see that Hama could've somehow ended the war Like she could've taught the other Waterbenders how to bloodbend and they could've all fought against the fire nation Imagine having more then one bloodbender they could've easily controlled a few soldiers to attack the rest of the other soldiers Too bad Hama didn't think of freeing and teaching her brothers and sisters

@sarahconlon2495 3 года назад

There’s actually a theory that if Aang say did not leave 100 years ago & survived the raid on the air nomads & ya know lived his life fully, that Yue was supposedly set up to be the next Avatar. It makes sense & honestly is just cool to think about.

@the-nina-beans88 2 года назад

I remember the theory that Katara was supposed to be the next Avatar after Aang

@tecknifer5503 3 года назад

SCB. Why did only Zuko and not Azula struggle with his legacy being great grand son of both Sozin and Roku?

@gagevannuys1586 3 года назад

Every theory video you guys make I pretty much always start the video having know idea knowing the answer or not believe the theory but by the end you always give the answer or convince me of the theory. That’s why you guys are my favorite RU-vidrs

@dripdoriya1707 3 года назад

The fire nation is the hand sanitizer and the air nomads are the germs. Aang is the .001% germ 🤣🤣

@JoanneEra15 3 года назад

I saw this theory the other day actually! Can’t remember who actually came up with it, you guys should totally try to find them and give some credit! 😁

@sirderp9219 3 года назад

Wasnt this a video of Hello Future Me?

@jamiegeorge1605 3 года назад

Do they not know how old hama is?

@hruyle93 3 года назад

Yea i also saw this the other day and couldn't believe there's already a video about it lol. I saw it on a random post on Instagram though

@ophirwesley4424 3 года назад

Ye, I just commented that's I found a reddit post with this theory on reddit from 6 years ago.... I thought to look because I also just saw a video on it the other day, but I can't remember where... If someone finds this video, send a link!

@jamiegeorge1605 3 года назад

@@ophirwesley4424 I like the theory, but personally I don't belive it because of the age difference. It is so obvious how old hama is. Even if we say at most Katara was 4 at the time, that's only 9 years. Hama is like 75-80. Kataras mom isn't even in her 40s I belive, so no way she would be hama

@angiewagner9232 3 года назад

I hope we’ll be getting Legend of Korra theories soon too!

@DownWithBureaucracy 3 года назад

New question: if the air nomads stayed eliminated, would the cycle skip to the next group or cease entirely? And could that avatar ever become fully realized? Maybe taught by past lives

@andrewdowns3673 3 года назад

I have a question: What would the Fire nation have done if the Avatar was reincarnated into the Fire Nation. Would they still try to capture and keep him/her prisoner, or would they have instead not killed him/her and raised him/her to be a weapon?

@thatoneguy5343 2 года назад

Likely indoctrinate them into the Fire Nation’s beliefs. They’ll be idiots to turn down brainwashing their world’s equivalent of Superman into a weapon.

@neon-leon- Год назад

Second opinion I think

@trentonalberts262 3 года назад

But wouldn’t the southern raiders realize they looking for a 65+ year old woman? Not a 25-45 year old mother of 2 😅😅

@nicolebayless 3 года назад

wait this is exactly what i was thinking too and i feel like it’s the most obvious flaw with this theory are we missing something?!?! lol

@nozomiac 3 года назад

this channel is the actual best. it explains everything in great detail and easily simplified so you don’t have go watching other theories and look for detail yourself when watching the shows. you just watch this and understand everything. thank you so much for that.

@lc2341 3 года назад

I can never get over Zuko's face at 0:35 when he's like *oh my god I could have died she could have killed me I'm so glad I'm on her side now*

@Hani-nw4qh 3 года назад

Yes a Avatar video I’ve recently watched this show on Netflix

@mazvirataaja9397 3 года назад

Imagen if fire nation kiled the air avatar, then the water avatar and the avatar would be reborn in basingsay.

@hannahsonnenburg7718 3 года назад

Your Harry Potter J vs. Bens and the new avatar theories are the best! You should start making Percy Jackson content too!

@chloec4009 3 года назад

It’s so interesting that at the start of the series, Zuko and the rest of the Fire Nation are technically looking for Korra.

@lilacflower50 3 года назад

Me: "hey fire nation, would it be easier to find the avatar if you finished conquering the world while he's gone? Fire nation: "nah, we're just going to do nothing until we find him like a 100 years later" Me: .....

@TheDjbz 3 года назад

The whole point of the raids on the Water tribes were to catch Aang’s successor before they could be trained. Under the assumption he was probably dead. (Since no one had seen or heard of him in years)

@cometmoon4485 3 года назад

They were hardly doing nothing, it's just that Earth Kingdom territories fought back so hard for the hundred years that they couldn't take the whole continent. Not sure why they didn't just conquer the entire Southern water tribe, though.

@alx_writer6257 3 года назад

Cometmoon448 it probably didn’t have any resources they wanted in conquest the fire nation always wanted control of places that had resources that could benefit them but the southern water tribes just had ice and water and fish which since the fire nation is an island they probably had no interest in.

@ophirwesley4424 3 года назад

@@TheDjbz ישראלים בי לייק

@DVankeuren 3 года назад

They were looking for at least some of those 100 years.

@zackbutt6822 3 года назад

I've still haven't watched avatar. What about the really tall blue guys that live on Pandora?

@coburngadberry265 3 года назад

6:05 it’s actually because the avatar alternates between north and southern water tribe since Kuruk was northern water tribe

@alina-87 3 года назад

Im so glad you guys are making Avatar videos now, this makes perfect sense.

@tamzjd 3 года назад

Nobody: Katara to the Gaang: YoU wOuLdNt uNdErStAnD

@SarcasmKing23 3 года назад

My question is,( and I'm sadly taking the fire nation's side here) when the general killed Kya, I think Kya should've protected herself, right? Like if I'm an waterbender, and I'm almost killed, I would fight back. So when she was killed, and didn't use waterbending to defend herself, wouldn't that raise his suspicion that she wasn't the waterbender? OOOORRRR that general was pleased with killing somebody. I wonder......

@varunnathamuni5540 3 года назад

I swear, when J posted put up that picture of Hama looking all creepy, my heart literally stopped in my chest for a good 2 seconds. Terrifying. Good theory J. Hope you and family are safe and healthy. Love your videos and keep it up!

@kittyjen9301 3 года назад

all this back and forth on who they're looking for reminds me of sleeping beauty a little bit "A cradle?!" "An airbender?!"

@l0velyfrogg132 3 года назад

Let's not forget that the man killing Kya had no weapons meaning he had to have burned her alive so Katara probably was really traumatized seeing her mother burned alive when she was only 9.

@the-nina-beans88 2 года назад

That would also explain when Aang accidentally burned her hands. She definitely started crying after getting burn. The sight of the flames probably triggered the memory

@LordKuzon 3 года назад

No one: Katara after she meets a new person: *tHe FiReNaTiOn KiLlEd mY mOtHeR* 🥺 ****touches the necklace****

@bradynlabbe6264 3 года назад

I love these avatar theories keep up the good work!

@Lilly_Israel 3 года назад

NEW THEORY IDEA: WHERE THE FIREBENDERS AWARE OF THE SWAMPBENDEDERS!

@sheriftamer2296 3 года назад

Im guessing they were looking for hama

@sheriftamer2296 3 года назад

I didnt watch yet hopefully its correct 😂😂

@robinsonbright2671 3 года назад

@@sheriftamer2296 good theory

@justtaurus2750 3 года назад

My theory is they were afraid that she could give birth to more water benders this is before watching btw

@BRDNN 3 года назад

Just Taurus my prediction before watching is because Hama bloodbender

@dbyrd92 Год назад

Perfect explaination! Good job 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

@dijonmayo3348 3 года назад

I've always wondered about this!!! Thank you for the video explaining it, it never made sense to me before

@kjs22 3 года назад

Me: stretching while watching super carlin brothers J: they think Karata's mother was Hama!!! Me:"*gasp!* wow I finally got my splits!!!! Oh sorry what where you saying J??"

@lilliemillward4870 3 года назад

Kenna Scott you got flat in your splits? Good job! 👍😄

@caitlyngallagher3830 3 года назад

I need to know more about Zuko’s mom and what happened to her

@lordofninjas1 3 года назад

It's actually been officially stated what happens with her. Not gonna spoil it just because it's something everyone should experience themselves, but they did do a video about it, or if you are more of a reader try looking into the Avatar books that have been released, I believe what happened to Zuko and Azula's mom is in the 3 part story named "the Search" but I could be wrong on the title.

@caitlyngallagher3830 3 года назад

lordofninjas1 thanks I will have to look at that

@lordofninjas1 3 года назад

@@caitlyngallagher3830 no problem.