Тёмный

Why The Rebel Alliance Criticized Their Leadership  

Star Wars Insider
Подписаться 264 тыс.
Просмотров 63 тыс.
50% 1

The Rebel Alliance High Command was frequently criticized by soldiers for managing the Rebellion as more of a government than a military force. We see this in Rogue One when there is a heated debate on whether to attack the base of Scarif or let it go. This was probably due to the fact that the Rebels High Command was mostly Senators and government personnel.
Social Media 📱
📸Instagram ➡️bit.ly/38XiI4q
🕊️Twitter ➡️bit.ly/2ZuQISt
✅Subscribe if you like Star Wars! 👉bit.ly/2ZUF3eJ
Personal discord 👉 / discord
Check out the Galactic Republic discord here 👉 / discord
#starwars #shorts #starwarsfacts

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

 

10 сен 2021

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 97   
@xuefei738
@xuefei738 2 года назад
3
@StarWars_Insider
@StarWars_Insider 2 года назад
4
@chunkvader473
@chunkvader473 2 года назад
@@StarWars_Insider 5
@CamRayGames
@CamRayGames 2 года назад
6
@thatsaboat2882
@thatsaboat2882 2 года назад
7
@m.taufiqnurwansyah6607
@m.taufiqnurwansyah6607 2 года назад
Stop
@DawidKov
@DawidKov 2 года назад
Makes sense. Where are you gonna find military opposition in this time period? The Republic High Command was almost entirely Jedi. A few mid-level commanders were experienced officers like Yularen or Tarkin - pretty much all of them got good positions in the Empire, and are unlikely to oppose the Emperor. And all lower command was clones. There are only a handful of military commanders from non-Republic groups like Saw Guerrera and Cham Syndulla. Most of those likely died early during the Empire's rule. So you've got very, very few military leaders in the Rebellion. Most will be politicians.
@rev0568
@rev0568 2 года назад
Well, Cham survived over a decade into the Empires reign and long enough to see the creation of the rebel alliance, same for Saw. Saw only dies shortly before the events of a new hope, and was seen even by other rebels as a radical.
@DawidKov
@DawidKov 2 года назад
@@rev0568 Yes, but my point is that people like those two are extremely rare, and it makes sense that the Rebel alliance would be mostly composed of politicians, not military leaders.
@RoyalLegend1000
@RoyalLegend1000 2 года назад
@@DawidKov it was some military leders, like the Commander for the Alice that Ezra was in
@DawidKov
@DawidKov 2 года назад
@@RoyalLegend1000 They were few and far between, most of them rather inexperienced. Really, the fact that the majority of commanders during the Clone Wars were clones kinda stripped the galaxy of competent officers once the clones died off.
@RoyalLegend1000
@RoyalLegend1000 2 года назад
@@DawidKov true, but the was still there, and many hated the Empire
@chunkvader473
@chunkvader473 2 года назад
Love hwo the rebellion wanst just a classic "where the good guys" thing but a legitimate rebellion with infighting, different cells and more
@qcycl1c898
@qcycl1c898 2 года назад
Where are the good guys?
@gilowar
@gilowar 2 года назад
Still better than the Empire
@thisdarkone996
@thisdarkone996 2 года назад
@@gilowar x for doubt
@2011-X
@2011-X 2 года назад
@@gilowar ah yes the rebels who killed many miljons of people and 2 death star with even more
@paulhindenburg1460
@paulhindenburg1460 2 года назад
“The Empire did nothing wrong” -Some wrinkled old guy wearing a black hood, probably
@carsenmaxwell3336
@carsenmaxwell3336 2 года назад
They needed military leadership not some politicians
@clonesolar
@clonesolar 2 года назад
I mean they are rebels, not A GOVERNMENT. Also I think the empire was better.
@kamalalsb7292
@kamalalsb7292 2 года назад
The Empire, an interstellar fascist dictatorship that practiced Slavery and Genocide as pretty much standard operating procedure was better than the Rebels. God people like you are concerning.
@carterskindle7086
@carterskindle7086 2 года назад
Yeah, the empire was worse. But the rebellion has people like Saw Garrera that were terrorists. But I still prefer the rebellion.
@kamalalsb7292
@kamalalsb7292 2 года назад
@@carterskindle7086 It doesn't, though, they literally stopped working with him because his methods were too extreme - and it's ridiculous to be like "But they're Terrorists". The context of what the Empire is makes almost any action against it justified.
@brineherotg7375
@brineherotg7375 2 года назад
I agree
@carterskindle7086
@carterskindle7086 2 года назад
@@kamalalsb7292 I just said that Saw was a terrorist, not the entire rebellion. My point is just that not the ENTIRE rebellion are entirely good.
@milan.980
@milan.980 2 года назад
This scene changed the rebellion for me....cus rebellion is like perfect in New Hope...a week after Rogue
@richardched6085
@richardched6085 3 месяца назад
By then, most of the Senators had left or were dead. Plus the Senate had been dissolved, rendering their power nonexistent and a mere formality.
@alejandroelluxray5298
@alejandroelluxray5298 2 года назад
In Legends this wasn't a Big problem, but I can see than this did happen Every once in a while, specially during the more critical moments
@postapocalypticnewsradio
@postapocalypticnewsradio 2 года назад
PANR has tuned in.
@tunderstorm2769
@tunderstorm2769 2 года назад
As a rebellion they should have used non simmetrical warfare
@mcshane191
@mcshane191 2 года назад
Very relatable
@1wolftank
@1wolftank 2 года назад
Rebel command: we need to be all on the same page Rebel soldiers: point me at the enemy
@RoyalLegend1000
@RoyalLegend1000 2 года назад
I am the 69 person here, I'm just going to say The rebels still did better that the jedi ordrer did, the jedi ordrer was not able to see there enemy in front of them
@Seho2024
@Seho2024 2 года назад
They did make better decisions than the Jedi council though
@RoyalLegend1000
@RoyalLegend1000 2 года назад
Yeah, the kedi Counchil was dumb, the was even able to say the enemy literally in front on them
@Deadmonk5242
@Deadmonk5242 2 года назад
Then u realize they can change the fucking plot at any time
@cytrogenisexplorer2272
@cytrogenisexplorer2272 2 года назад
Wich is why the new republic got curropted so fast
@johaneslerius9074
@johaneslerius9074 3 месяца назад
We need clone trooper join the rebel alliance
@magicmariotv7772
@magicmariotv7772 2 года назад
501st
@nouon9988
@nouon9988 2 года назад
yoooo
@StarWars_Insider
@StarWars_Insider 2 года назад
Yooo
@blackops0UT
@blackops0UT 2 года назад
second
@StarWars_Insider
@StarWars_Insider 2 года назад
👍
@sammydserenity3849
@sammydserenity3849 Год назад
Saw was right about mon mothma in rebels unfortunately.
Далее
The Secret Nature of the Rebel Alliance | Star Wars
7:42
Brawl Stars Animation: PAINT BRAWL STARTS NOW!
00:52
The Republic commiting warcrimes for 8:17
8:17
Просмотров 5 млн
I Forced Myself to Collect the Most Boring Army
26:07
Просмотров 323 тыс.
De-Infantilizing STAR WARS (It Works)
27:05
Просмотров 2,4 млн
Clarkson , Hammond and May's Best Jokes
35:13
Просмотров 1,3 млн