Тёмный

Why Were The Soviets Ineffective in 1941? (ft. Potential History) | Animated History 

The Armchair Historian
Подписаться 2,3 млн
Просмотров 1,6 млн
50% 1

Make sure to go to harrys.com/the... to get your trial set for $3 bucks
Potential History: • Operation Barbarossa P...
Dien Bien Phu: • The Battle of Dien Bie...
Watch the video uncensored on the Armchair Historian website!
The Armchair Historian Website: thearmchairhis...
Discord: / discord
Ironside Computers - Click here to customize your own PC: ironsidecomput... USE DISCOUNT CODE "History" FOR 5% OFF!
Sources: docs.google.co...
Music:
Dawn without End by Zach Heyde
The Raid by Zach Heyde
Soviet March by Shane Ivers
Long Note Two by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
Source: incompetech.com...
Artist: incompetech.com/
SFX by SoundRav
soundrav.com/ - Game Audio - Sound Design - Post Production

Опубликовано:

 

23 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 3,7 тыс.   
@TheArmchairHistorian
@TheArmchairHistorian 5 лет назад
ONLY 3 DOLLARS for your trial set. Go to Harrys.com/thearmchairhistorian Razors have never been this cheap. Dien Bien Phu: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-vAVYfh2_GTE.html Support us and other history channels struggling with demonetization: thearmchairhistorian.com/
@engleberteverything421
@engleberteverything421 5 лет назад
Good luck with sorting out the demonetization
@randomperson1029
@randomperson1029 5 лет назад
Its already demonitized. Rip
@robot6654
@robot6654 5 лет назад
@RandomPerson how do you know?
@EmperorZelos
@EmperorZelos 5 лет назад
can I downvote this more than one time?
@randomperson1029
@randomperson1029 5 лет назад
@@robot6654 no ads on the video
@GP090
@GP090 5 лет назад
Next vid: Why was youtube so ineffective in 2019
@what_have_you_done
@what_have_you_done 5 лет назад
RU-vid has been ineffective for alot longer than that.
@toastytoast9800
@toastytoast9800 5 лет назад
The employees were purged
@KaladinVegapunk
@KaladinVegapunk 5 лет назад
I know, this channel, mxr, like 6 other channels getting challenged and demonetized, it's fucked Runaway greedy corporate stooges suppressing what made their platform huge Just want mindless top ten lists and trendy unboxings or bullshit pop/rap videos
@starcoism56yearsago28
@starcoism56yearsago28 5 лет назад
That sounds like a job for the Internet Historian
@derekkoch8777
@derekkoch8777 5 лет назад
Though keen historians, they are traitors.
@vadimuha
@vadimuha 4 года назад
Germany: Literally bombs soviet cities Stalin: It's just a provocation
@Inquisitor6321
@Inquisitor6321 3 года назад
They weren't bombing cities at the start of Barbarossa. They were bombing airfields and supply depots.
@acanadiancapitalist2107
@acanadiancapitalist2107 3 года назад
@@Inquisitor6321 you know what he means
@DinsRune
@DinsRune 2 года назад
"That guy only punched me in the face so I would start a fight" No dumbass he started a fight
@toxicman9128
@toxicman9128 3 года назад
Zhukov: “hey, they’re shooting at us” Stalin: *breathing* Z: “Did you hear me?” S: *still just breathing* Z: “Can we at least shoot back?” S: “No”
@jalonmstevenson1508
@jalonmstevenson1508 3 года назад
lol
@jmsgridiron5628
@jmsgridiron5628 3 года назад
S: "niet cyka"
@eln5343
@eln5343 3 года назад
Zhukov: "Our people are dying by the thousands. It's a slaughter." Stalin: breathing intesifies Zhukov: "What are your orders?" Stalin: "Wait... are we not doing phone sex here?" Zhukov: "No! Listen to the screams and gun fire." Stalin: "Oh god, I'm so close..."
@lorenzoabanes6351
@lorenzoabanes6351 2 года назад
@@eln5343 sussy stalin
@AlexPovolotsky
@AlexPovolotsky Год назад
Nice fantasy
@petartoshkov2076
@petartoshkov2076 4 года назад
Hitler logic: *expects France to fall in 6 months* *expects the Soviet Union to fall in 3 weeks*
@thewingedone1172
@thewingedone1172 4 года назад
Well nobody expected that the mightest military nation in the history will fall in 5 weeks
@thewingedone1172
@thewingedone1172 4 года назад
@@petartoshkov2076 Because he was stupid fanatic?
@thewingedone1172
@thewingedone1172 4 года назад
Which might enemy USA ever fought?Third Reich when it already collapsed on Eastern Front?
@linhhoang1363
@linhhoang1363 4 года назад
In late 1941 Hitler was in shock and awe with his army's success he became quite delusional
@linhhoang1363
@linhhoang1363 4 года назад
​@ Agree with you. But the last point I would argue it's like Hitler's biggest gamble. Like he must have concluded "This is it. For everything or nothing!" and there he went to war
@jaztin7197
@jaztin7197 5 лет назад
RU-vid, don't censor history. This is gold content.
@mabussubam512
@mabussubam512 5 лет назад
RU-vid: *ERROR_404_History_Not_Found*
@turnyourwifioffatnight7848
@turnyourwifioffatnight7848 5 лет назад
He needs to keep the word 'war' out of his titles and tags. I think that's what it's about
@mrkraffbs9583
@mrkraffbs9583 5 лет назад
censor*
@jaztin7197
@jaztin7197 5 лет назад
@@mrkraffbs9583 Sorry! From the Spanish word "Censura" I got confused.
@mrkraffbs9583
@mrkraffbs9583 5 лет назад
@@jaztin7197 No worries man I'm just pulling your leg :)
@HWDragonborn
@HWDragonborn 3 года назад
Stalin did learn his lesson tho. After World War Two, he purged the Red Army again. But instead of killing the generals, he simply demote them to unimportant roles so that 1) generals were unable to oppose him from their lowly positions and 2) the generals can be used again if another war broke out.
@rpm_chiron5985
@rpm_chiron5985 Год назад
If Stalin did this during the 30s instead of killing his generals admirals and officers the Soviet army coulda been in a better position in the war and coulda inflicted more on the nazis
@owentill
@owentill Год назад
That’s really interesting
@bingbongbongbing5932
@bingbongbongbing5932 5 лет назад
The animation for this video, especially the starting animation showing the Soviet tank being attacked by the stuka and panzers is unlike anything I have seen. Amazing work
@TribuneAquila
@TribuneAquila 5 лет назад
Why was the armchair historian so innefective against demonitization (2019)
@Cje233
@Cje233 5 лет назад
Because he keeps putting ads in his videos while doing the video. That is why RU-vid is fighting him.
@TehUltimateSnake
@TehUltimateSnake 5 лет назад
Conrad Eiban more like the other way around.
@alphagamma1289
@alphagamma1289 5 лет назад
Conrad Eiban you mean sponsors? That’s usually quite acceptable
@Gerbs1913
@Gerbs1913 4 года назад
Stalin: Purges his officers Also Stalin: "Who killed my officers and made them so ineffective?"
@cantutmez8854
@cantutmez8854 4 года назад
Not all of them got killed,instead most of them were arrested
@dart2475
@dart2475 4 года назад
Can Tütmez « He didn’t kill all of his officers in a paranoid tantrum, just most of them »
@kaibotski4939
@kaibotski4939 4 года назад
Who didn't tell me they were going to invade??? We did. Who told me their sources were unreliable??? ......
@calebdouglas2512
@calebdouglas2512 3 года назад
@Auxiliary Stream Services He killed everyone he THOUGHT was trying to kill him, which from his perspective was everyone
@calebdouglas2512
@calebdouglas2512 3 года назад
@Auxiliary Stream Services I know that there actually WERE people trying to kill him, all I was saying was that he was paranoid and thought EVERYONE wanted him dead.
@achken1
@achken1 5 лет назад
One does not simply.... deletes facts and horrors of history. Dont let the RU-vid garbage win over quality.
@GarrettMerkin
@GarrettMerkin 5 лет назад
Kinda like memory holes...
@cisco8257
@cisco8257 5 лет назад
U do know your giving them money by watching ads if you really hated them you would go to a different website
@GarrettMerkin
@GarrettMerkin 5 лет назад
@@cisco8257 I just pay for Premium. No ads.
@benchmarking6875
@benchmarking6875 5 лет назад
@@GarrettMerkin lol
@conesinker_4209
@conesinker_4209 5 лет назад
You realise this video was posted on RU-vid
@phumjaisodsee7464
@phumjaisodsee7464 5 лет назад
This video is amazing the animation was so good. Thanks for the good content.
@MrGamePlayer1000CHNL
@MrGamePlayer1000CHNL 4 года назад
Stalin: kills all of his officers also Stalin: why are we getting pushed back?
@saint_alucardwarthunder759
@saint_alucardwarthunder759 4 года назад
>Kills all his officers Zhukov, Rokossovskiy, Katukov, Konyev, Vatutin and a fuckton of others have left the chat.
@TheKingpool7
@TheKingpool7 4 года назад
Its surprising how incompetent this is. He did kill some officers but fact is amount of officers was higher after the purge then before the purge.
@benashurov7434
@benashurov7434 4 года назад
@@TheKingpool7 only because they lower down officers were upgraded up. You could go from a captain to a general in the span of a year. For example, i think about 2/3 of the "marshalls of the soviet union " where shot.
@dart2475
@dart2475 4 года назад
King Pool Ah yes, because officers just spring from the ground, more officers doesn’t mean better officers. It just means that the officers are bigger fans of Stalin
@brianhum8765
@brianhum8765 4 года назад
@@TheKingpool7 Yea because turning 3 lieutenants into generals definitely > Erwin Rommel.
@TGChaplain
@TGChaplain 5 лет назад
RU-vid, leave history alone! This is quality educational work.
@cisco8257
@cisco8257 5 лет назад
It be nice to see comments on the actual video tho
@TGChaplain
@TGChaplain 5 лет назад
@@cisco8257 Sadly, I'm still at work, and they frown on watching videos (I'm sneaking in this comment) but rest assured, once I blow this joint, a thorough viewing will prompt a well placed comment from me.
@kabloosh699
@kabloosh699 5 лет назад
Ha! This video offends people's safe spaces though so it needs to be demonetized or out right banned.
@dillonc7955
@dillonc7955 5 лет назад
It's probably hidden on the algorithm because it uses the word "bad". Meaning that someone doesn't think something is good and might offend someone with a differing opinion. It's absolutely ridiculous.
@muchentuchen6592
@muchentuchen6592 5 лет назад
You tube is more into promoting porn industry. Shame on you tube.
@williamclark4816
@williamclark4816 5 лет назад
Armchair Historian: Posts educational WW2 video. RU-vid: "U GO TO GULAG!"
@trollege9618
@trollege9618 5 лет назад
Stalin: No u
@poliestotico
@poliestotico 5 лет назад
Malaysian Mapper no, we
@jtim83
@jtim83 5 лет назад
poliestotico no, us
@kylernguyen2317
@kylernguyen2317 5 лет назад
yes
@jonvro4022
@jonvro4022 5 лет назад
John Ratican lol YT actively demonetizes commie YT channels.
@Michael-wn3rh
@Michael-wn3rh 3 года назад
That bit about the lack of radios inside tanks- major reason French armored divisions were so ineffective during the blitz as well.
@jaysinha0
@jaysinha0 3 года назад
Although French tanks were usually superior to German tanks.
@BaconSlayer69
@BaconSlayer69 Год назад
@@jaysinha0 😂😂😂lol
@miketacos9034
@miketacos9034 4 года назад
Zhukov: pls let us fight Stalin: HEAVY BREATHING Zhukov: Is... is that a yes?
@BenLynch1
@BenLynch1 3 года назад
I was waiting for him to say he was snoring looool
@Joseph_Stalin1940
@Joseph_Stalin1940 3 года назад
Yes.
@Rao54168
@Rao54168 3 года назад
@@Joseph_Stalin1940 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@missymiami6798
@missymiami6798 3 года назад
@@Rao54168 Your eyes must be really dry and sore after laughing and crying so much.
@rdaltry777
@rdaltry777 5 лет назад
Great video, love your channel. Down with mindless censorship and up with awesome cartoon educational videos!
@FreedomFox1
@FreedomFox1 5 лет назад
These big corporations are happy to profit off of war, but when it comes to educating the public about the horrors of war they suddenly start to worry. The sad reality is that RU-vid wants an audience of mindless consumers and nothing else.
@i_smoke_ghosts
@i_smoke_ghosts 5 лет назад
reporting your offensive comment for saying mindless ! jokes :)
@i_smoke_ghosts
@i_smoke_ghosts 5 лет назад
reporting your comment for sensationalistic effect.
@i_smoke_ghosts
@i_smoke_ghosts 5 лет назад
reporting your comment for reporting.
@adas1988
@adas1988 4 года назад
People that comment on RU-vid"censorship" are fucking retards
@blandbread5616
@blandbread5616 3 года назад
Soviets in 1941:im to weak Soviets in 1945:unlimited power
@Mabbdaa
@Mabbdaa Год назад
Soviets in 1991:💀
@Basedlocation
@Basedlocation Год назад
@@Mabbdaacope communism is rising
@The_whales
@The_whales Год назад
@@Mabbdaaalso Soviets in 1991: a just let a LITTLE bit of nationalism
@MeikZoo
@MeikZoo 6 месяцев назад
​@@MabbdaaIf we talk about military power, then even in 1991 the USSR would be of any country in 2024, except probably the USA, Russia and China
@KarlPHorse
@KarlPHorse 4 года назад
"RU-vid has demonetized and shutdown the video for a reason they won't tell me." The reason is that they are utterly incompetent at programing their algorithm and are too pathetic and arrogant to admit it.
@pebblepod30
@pebblepod30 4 года назад
So yeah, Google is an extremely powerful and unethical company. I try to do what I can to get away from their toxic company and not buy from them anymore if I can help it.
@TheDirtysouthfan
@TheDirtysouthfan 4 года назад
The algorithm, from what I understand, is built with Machine Learning. That means they don't exactly "program" it per se, as in tell it exactly what to censor or flag, rather they teach it what to flag or censor. They feed it a ton of data saying "this is good" and "this is bad", the machine learns this and tries to establish patterns. This is faulty of course, and in the present is very far from being an effective technology, hence why self driving cars are still many decades away.
@Lowlandlord
@Lowlandlord 4 года назад
@@TheDirtysouthfan They are actually spending a lot of money on AI systems, like AlphaGo.
@Doughboy842
@Doughboy842 4 года назад
Yup. That's google for ya. Living in their silicone valley bubble.
@meinenapkinen9167
@meinenapkinen9167 4 года назад
@EmperorJuliusCaesar Nah dude Adam caught your ass
@swisscheese9540
@swisscheese9540 5 лет назад
The Germans couldn't make mistakes. The Russians learnt from their mistakes.
@agentc7020
@agentc7020 5 лет назад
SwissCheese more like : the Russians learnt from their mistakes. The Germans didn’t.
@OmarSlloum
@OmarSlloum 5 лет назад
@@agentc7020 they did though, by 1944/45 their anti-Soviet tactics had improved massively
@agentc7020
@agentc7020 5 лет назад
Omar سلوم not really by 44/45 the Russians were unstoppable so they didn’t learn from their mistakes, they tried other things that also failed
@OmarSlloum
@OmarSlloum 5 лет назад
@@agentc7020 yes the Soviets were unstoppable, but no amount of skill on the German side could have changed it at that point, so that's not an indicator of their tactics against the red army.
@floydlechner2445
@floydlechner2445 5 лет назад
cesar febres you mean the perfect russian tactic of sending more soldiers in war then the germans got bullets? Yeah pretty damn strategly. Allies did the same tactic on D-Day. Worked out well.
@-----Alcatraz------
@-----Alcatraz------ 4 года назад
Never heard any thing about that German soldier who deserted. What was his backstory?
@someonedraws4208
@someonedraws4208 4 года назад
He deserted
@slimebor7059
@slimebor7059 4 года назад
I heard that he was one of the "ss'ians" (army of people in russia baltics and other states but it was made by germans and they also had to kill jews and ro what hitler wanted) and he was afraid for his life because tommorow there was a fight and the man was a youngling and he thought that soviets would help him or something
@iileross8398
@iileross8398 4 года назад
According to a Russian documentary, he was a sapper and was a secret communist.
@nerdomatic2489
@nerdomatic2489 3 года назад
@@someonedraws4208 *Thank you mr helpful*
@breadbowl1215
@breadbowl1215 3 года назад
His name was Alfred Luskow.
@animer8316
@animer8316 5 лет назад
RU-vid is hitting history channels hard and it makes me sad.
@RobynneMerguerdijian
@RobynneMerguerdijian 4 года назад
you haven't seen the worse of it, 10/December is around the corner and the "Silly-Cone[Head] Valley" is irretrievably eager to impose total far-leftist-Berkeleyan conformity, ironically brought to you by international-mega corporations. ( remember all the anti-corporationey corporation screeds during the Occupy days? --being consistently inconsistent is now the new normal)
@Jonesyful10
@Jonesyful10 4 года назад
It's almost like giant media conglomerates are trying to control everything you see and hear. Pfft nah that's just conspiracy talk
@s.sradon9782
@s.sradon9782 4 года назад
@@Jonesyful10 what do you mean by "deus ex(1) predicted the future" not again!
@leviwilliams9507
@leviwilliams9507 4 года назад
They don't want you to learn about history....
@derekkelley7490
@derekkelley7490 4 года назад
I agree the radical left is the only group powerfull enough who is currently engaged in a totalitarian rewritting of history
@todo9633
@todo9633 5 лет назад
Zhukov: Dude they're attacking us. Stalin: Nah fam, that's just Hitler playin.
@Eclipselfish
@Eclipselfish 4 года назад
to do Stalin knew that Hitler will attack USSR and Stalin was also preparing for the incoming war
@todo9633
@todo9633 4 года назад
@@Eclipselfish He was, that's why Hitler attacked so early while the Soviets weren't ready. It's just that when Hitler attacked Stalin wasn't anywhere near prepared so he had a bit of a mental breakdown.
@Eclipselfish
@Eclipselfish 4 года назад
to do lol and why then did Stalin pushed the borders with Finland and annexed Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania? He also concluded a non-aggression pact with Hitler and secured this with a pact on the division of Poland. Not because Stalin was an invader and he needed Poland, but in order to secure the western front and gain time in order to better prepare. Stalin was already ready, just stop believing in the propoganda that rewrites history
@todo9633
@todo9633 4 года назад
@@Eclipselfish He conquered other countries because he was trying to spread Communism and his own power, because that's the ultimate goal of Communism, world domination. Stalin ordered his soldiers to not fire back since he thought Hitler was just trying to provoke him and locked himself away for days after the invasion started. The army might have been somewhat mobilized, but even then the T34 production was still pretty low and most equipment in general(Tanks/Planes/Artillery) was pretty old and outdated and the army was untrained and inexperienced, which is why the Germans managed to push them so far back. Stalin on the other hand was obviously absolutely caught off guard when Hitler attacked him and reacted in pretty much the worst way possible.
@Eclipselfish
@Eclipselfish 4 года назад
to do lol and why then did Stalin pushed the borders with Finland and annexed Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania? He also concluded a non-aggression pact with Hitler and secured this with a pact on the division of Poland. Not because Stalin was an invader and he needed Poland, but in order to secure the western front and gain time in order to better prepare. Stalin was already ready, just stop believing in the propoganda that rewrites history. Also the official position of the Russia is that the accession of the Baltic countries to the USSR did not contradict the norms of international law as of 1940, and also that the accession of these countries to the USSR received official international recognition. This position is based on the de facto recognition of the integrity of the borders of the USSR as of June 1941 at the Yalta (1945) and Potsdam conferences (1945) by the participating states. You wrote nonsense about the troops not shooting at the Germans. Do you even understand that this is complete nonsense? The main forces of the Soviet Union army were in Siberia, in the middle of the country, since on the other hand, Japan could attack from the east and there were no allies from the east. Hitler also began to make his plan for the quick capture of the Soviet Union "blitzkrieg". So the troops of the Soviet Union simply did not have time to redeploy. HAHAHAH u r so low brain Jesus... You humiliate Stalin that he did not prepare anything, but Germany was a capitalist country for that and at the moment, and it had more money for production. The USSR is a country of workers and peasants. After the revolution, they had nothing - emptiness. In the periods of 29-41, the country was industrialized, villages turned into large cities. The country was still at that time, not because Stalin wanted it that way, but because such a country went to it. At the time of 43 years, the level of production of the USSR was the same as in Germany. In the period 41-42 years, 6 and a half thousand T34 tanks were produced, and Germany in the period 41-42 years produced only 1.3 thousand vehicles. After the war, the T34 was recognized by many experts as the best tank of the Second World War.
@Vertically-challenged-
@Vertically-challenged- 3 года назад
You forget history, then you’re doomed to repeat it
@kasrkin100
@kasrkin100 3 года назад
Meanwhile Turkish, Japanese, and CCP: what accurate history
@deriznohappehquite
@deriznohappehquite 5 лет назад
The Maginot Line was actually very effective in its intended purpose.
@zztimelapsezz
@zztimelapsezz 5 лет назад
John D. If a wall is meant to keep people out, is it’s purpose fulfilled if the people can just go around it?
@ChristianChalliner
@ChristianChalliner 5 лет назад
zztimelapsezz the issue isn’t that they went around it but that French command was incompetent and elected to abandon the fortifications
@deriznohappehquite
@deriznohappehquite 5 лет назад
@@zztimelapsezz The argument I often hear is that the French made a mistake in focusing on the Maginot Line. The Maginot Line kept the Germans from crossing the Maginot Line, and forced them to go around it. Thus forcing them to attack on a very narrow front. The issue wasn't that the Maginot Line was built. The issue was that the French didn't have significant forces defending the Ardennes. With the benefit of hindsight, we can see that the French should have built the Maginot Line all the way to the sea, behind Belgium. The Maginot Line freed up enough forces to defend the entire northeastern border, but the French commanders used those forces incompetently.
@arthas640
@arthas640 5 лет назад
Their failure was in either not including a northern line or maintaining good relations with Belgium
@TheManofthecross
@TheManofthecross 4 года назад
@@deriznohappehquite true but if they did that it would be as far as I saw in Hoi4 it would show a diplomatic issues with belgum that they would not be trusted with defence etc and some other issues with that.
@jeffh9427
@jeffh9427 5 лет назад
Hitler 1941: BLITZKRIEG CARD!! Stalin 1945: UNO REVERSE CARD!!
@wwvvvvvww
@wwvvvvvww 5 лет назад
More like: Hitler 1941: BLITZKRIEG!! Stalin 1943: REVERSE CARD!! Stalin 1945: WILD DRAW FOUR!!!
@_Abjuranax_
@_Abjuranax_ 5 лет назад
After the Soviets initial losses, the Red Army was able to replace its equipment losses, and it learned from the Blitzkrieg tactics from the Germans and how to defeat them. Soviet spies in Japan had also told Stalin that the Japanese had no designs for war with them and were able to bring fresh divisions from the East for the defense of Moscow.
@Nikkimond
@Nikkimond 5 лет назад
@@wwvvvvvww Hitler managed to play a card in 1942 and surprise Stalin again by attacking south instead of center.
@kalks4334
@kalks4334 5 лет назад
@@Nikkimond Yeah, but the operation was a fail
@Membrane556
@Membrane556 4 года назад
@@_Abjuranax_ Another thing the Nazis over extended their supply lines and were ill equip for cold weather warfare.
@jacobbailey849
@jacobbailey849 3 года назад
Yes you should make a video about “how was the Soviet effective in WW2”
@AYToaster
@AYToaster 5 лет назад
Love your videos about history. Hope things get better for you. Keep up the awesome work.
@luciusverus7697
@luciusverus7697 5 лет назад
Zero justification for censoring this video. Incredibly uncontroversial. Great stuff as always mate. Cheers from an Aussie fan. 👍
@bing4126
@bing4126 5 лет назад
its because It criticizes comrade Stalin!
@jonathand3842
@jonathand3842 5 лет назад
@@bing4126 because most of his rethoric is based on nazi Propaganda narrative. The Soviets weren't prepared in the begging but destroy the Germans 2 years later.
@MoffatLee
@MoffatLee 5 лет назад
@@jonathand3842 It's not based on nazi propaganda, it's based on the reality that the soviets weren't ready for war with Germany... yet.
@kevinhunter6457
@kevinhunter6457 2 года назад
I, a history buff, loved watching this documentary, you did a great job. But I also was not prepared for the meme at the end, it was hilarious!
@catholicdad
@catholicdad 5 лет назад
I'm a 56 year old man with a College degree who studied history extensively with some of the best Europen History minds in the 20th Century. Kid, your stuff, thus far, kicks ass!
@pillbox2079
@pillbox2079 5 лет назад
That is truly great to hear. Allways good when generations respect each other.
@Minuz1
@Minuz1 5 лет назад
I think history has created a myth about the purges though, Marshall did very simular things to the US generals, threw out the old ones and brought in new guys.
@catholicdad
@catholicdad 5 лет назад
@@Minuz1 Marshall?
@Minuz1
@Minuz1 5 лет назад
@@catholicdad en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Marshall Mostly known for "Marshall Plan" He's pratically THE guy who made the US armed forces in WW2.
@moregrapespls4469
@moregrapespls4469 4 года назад
TheWersum still got raped tho
@HistoryHustle
@HistoryHustle 5 лет назад
The one and only person Stalin put his trust in... betrayed him.
@RedMcCarl
@RedMcCarl 5 лет назад
That's fascism for ya
@StandingTNT
@StandingTNT 5 лет назад
Top one anime betrayals. Number one won't surprise you at all
@ln7929
@ln7929 5 лет назад
Stalin predicted that war between them would happen in 10 year's
@RyoKasai25
@RyoKasai25 5 лет назад
Can't blame the guy for his trust issues.
@jacobsarvathayaparan2337
@jacobsarvathayaparan2337 5 лет назад
Stalin didn't trust Hitler he just overestimated him and didn't expect him to be idiotic enough to start a war with the USSR whilst he was still at war with the Western powers, Stalin was hoping Hitler would destroy the west leaving Stalin with one easy target.
@Alkivo
@Alkivo 4 года назад
That part behind the credits is golden, I love it
@the.amazing.spatterman
@the.amazing.spatterman 3 года назад
soooo happy I let it play til then lol
@goldenfiberwheat238
@goldenfiberwheat238 5 лет назад
“I’m declaring war on you” “No you aren’t.” Reminds me of a Seinfeld episode where George’s girlfriend refuses to let him break up with her
@filipealves1982
@filipealves1982 4 года назад
LOL😂😂😂
@Ivanus59
@Ivanus59 3 года назад
Well Hitler attacked 1st and declared war later but I get what you're saying. 😅
@matth7952
@matth7952 3 года назад
“I’m breaking up with you.” “Nah.” “You can’t ‘nah’ me any more. How does it feel to be single?” “I really wouldn’t know.” “LET ME BREAK UP WITH YOU!” “Nah.”
@OmarSlloum
@OmarSlloum 5 лет назад
Anyone else suddenly feel like playing HOI4?
@بدر-ف1د6ه
@بدر-ف1د6ه 5 лет назад
Yes
@sid2112
@sid2112 5 лет назад
Indeed
@stopefinaround
@stopefinaround 5 лет назад
The more history vids I watch, the more I itch for HOI4
@dookiejuju192
@dookiejuju192 5 лет назад
i always use console commands so that hitler wins
@OmarSlloum
@OmarSlloum 5 лет назад
@@dookiejuju192 r/IamVeryEdgy
@user-jq2iz9zn4p
@user-jq2iz9zn4p 3 года назад
The Red Army was quite effective when it kept the Wehrmacht out of Moscow in 1941。That upended the Wehrmacht's entire plan。The next year the Red Army caught up with the Wehrmacht's Sixth Army in Stalingrad and destroyed it。
@Valaens
@Valaens 5 лет назад
We definitely need more videos like this one on RU-vid! I'd watch it over and over again :)
@rahulsingh-dm4rc
@rahulsingh-dm4rc 5 лет назад
Please do a video on the Indo-Pak war of 1971 which resulted in the formation of Bangladesh.
@Shivom.Parihar
@Shivom.Parihar 5 лет назад
Yes!
@itsDeliciouuss
@itsDeliciouuss 5 лет назад
There is not enough content to make a video on that. India just intervened and captured Pakistani soldiers without warning. Pakistani and Indians wars are too small scale in general. An interesting video would be China vs India 1962.
@rahulsingh-dm4rc
@rahulsingh-dm4rc 5 лет назад
The Sino-Indian war of 1962 will be an interesting video too!
@SuperLeosid
@SuperLeosid 5 лет назад
Yes please. Indian wars are severely underrated in spite of their effects and influence.
@Squirrel_Xi
@Squirrel_Xi 5 лет назад
Pakistan Zindabad India Murdabad is what I always say!
@spacefishaviation276
@spacefishaviation276 4 года назад
Finally a history channel that uses accurate maps for the time!
@parkerzhang5959
@parkerzhang5959 5 лет назад
Let's hope that this monetization issue gets fixed ASAP. Love your videos
@WarReport.
@WarReport. 5 лет назад
It wont. All history channels are being smoked.
@petesrinual3407
@petesrinual3407 5 лет назад
Yes, I also want to see "Why Was Russia so effective in later part of the war?" please. I think this is important because this is how Soviet doctrine was developed to be used in Cold War. Thank!!
@Sorain1
@Sorain1 4 года назад
I think that's a worthy follow up to this video.
@seancascanet3428
@seancascanet3428 4 года назад
They were so effective because of the huge population and Americas lend lease literally funding the soviets war...
@Gabriel-sdf
@Gabriel-sdf 4 года назад
@@seancascanet3428 I respectfully disagree, I think that due the the size of the Red Army, the Americans would've had to use most of their industry towards the Soviets ALONE, to influence it that much, however they did something MUCH MORE important, and that was to supply the Soviets with.... information! Yes every single major Soviet offensive after 1943 was based off Intel gathered by USA or UK, when to attack, where to attack, enemy troop movements, well everything, don't you agree that Intel/Information was much more important than Lend Lease?
@ifyourmarriedyourasimpandacuck
@ifyourmarriedyourasimpandacuck 4 года назад
@@Gabriel-sdf yeah the real reason the allies won ww2 British broke the german code US broke Japans Code US and UK gave Russia information on germans due to code breaking Otherwise the war would have lasted longer and been way bloodier
@CM-ve1bz
@CM-ve1bz 4 года назад
Gabriel Soares The Intel was of course very important but without the lend lease agreement, the Russians wouldn't be able to put the information to use. The US sent Russia over a half million trucks and tracked vehicles and Britain sent a considerable amount also, so the Russians could make the push. The US sent 2000 locomotives and 11,000 boxcars along with the trucks to better transport troops and supplies. Most don't consider the fact that for every man with a rifle, it takes 10 men in support to make him effective. Without good troop transportation and the ability to constantly resupply the men with the rifles, the best fighting men in the world would be hard pressed to win on a major front. The Germans lack of resupply and the Russians growing ability to quickly resupply was a major factor in the defeat of Germany.
@datman3416
@datman3416 3 года назад
I was always a little confused as to how the blitzkrieg worked. I would think moving at such a fast speed directly into enemy territory would leave you vulnerable ooutflanked and encircled by the enemy
@hb2495
@hb2495 3 года назад
not if everything is going at once
@Bighawkeye46
@Bighawkeye46 5 лет назад
Fantastic content, keep up the good work! (On in background 😉)
@DavidWesley
@DavidWesley 4 года назад
Your videos are great! I hope you’re able to get to the bottom of the demonetization nonsense!
@christopherdickinson4291
@christopherdickinson4291 3 года назад
It's because youtube is going woke and woke doesnt agree with history that isnt happy happy good times... woke isnt on board with anyone knowing any history period. Like history??? *you damn racist*
@dirtypimpbird
@dirtypimpbird 3 года назад
@@christopherdickinson4291 Sad, but True.
@mpforeverunlimited
@mpforeverunlimited 3 года назад
@@christopherdickinson4291 can't really feel bad for him when there are alternative sites that he refuses to use. If everyone that complained about RU-vid just uploaded on RU-vid and over there then it wouldn't be a problem
@deuslaudetur2451
@deuslaudetur2451 3 года назад
@@mpforeverunlimited he since has began his own site, but I think his willingness to stay here is due to us not moving away from RU-vid. The vast majority of online video seekers for anything end up here.
@PolishBehemoth
@PolishBehemoth 3 года назад
There is several conspiracy's behind this. Some of them might be true. I hear on the underground that the left (which youtube is controlled by) wants the history of WWII to be atleast partially shut out because it points to a positive message of masculinity and american triumph, and they want people to feel bad about WWII even though it accomplished the greatest peace in world history. I should make this a stand alone comment.
@Ramiobomb
@Ramiobomb 4 года назад
Yes, great video and upload the effectiveness video! Gotta mention though, Stalin in disgrace went to his HQ to think of his failure after the Nazis invaded, then some officers came to take away Stalin, he thought they came to arrest him but the officers instead told him they're in need of a leader of which, Stalin accepted the task.
@MrStolboy
@MrStolboy 5 лет назад
that was the whole reason behind the pact with germany, they weren"t ready for war
@MrStolboy
@MrStolboy 4 года назад
@Ordinary Sessel you mean the same pact that whole europo had with hitler, even poland had non aggression pact in 1932 with nazi germany, then in 1938 poland invaded czech slovakia and took their land. speaking of hypocrise, but nobody talks about that tho.
@MrStolboy
@MrStolboy 4 года назад
@Ordinary Sessel of course soviet union rather had it under their sphere of influence then nazi, britisch or french. it is not all that simple, russia has been invaded plenty of times by western nations, so it was in their interest to secure those countries. and again nobody has a problem with poland taking a part of czech slovakia when nazi germany invaded it, nobody had problems when united states were doing busniss with nazi germany, everbody was shady.
@mrunseen3797
@mrunseen3797 4 года назад
@@MrStolboy cheeky try to make NAZI Germany (holocaust, mass murder on industrial scale, war without declaration of war, suppression of Jews, Sinti, homosexuals, etc) look less bad, comparing to other countries...but it's not true.
@MrStolboy
@MrStolboy 4 года назад
@@R0ZEN7 it was taking that part of poland or leaving it to nazi germany, what would make them even closer to the soviet borders.
@MrStolboy
@MrStolboy 4 года назад
@@R0ZEN7 Yeah gtfo with your conspiracy bullshit
@pawenawrocki5554
@pawenawrocki5554 4 года назад
5:17 - word is written on tank is "Teafucker", lmao
@aenelle7370
@aenelle7370 4 года назад
Close enough, but not exactly. 'Teafucker' would be ЧАЕЕБ. Also, this is hate speech against the British :P
@maratimus
@maratimus 4 года назад
It have to be "Чапаев"
@khamulthewack4732
@khamulthewack4732 4 года назад
This video just went from a 9 to a 10
@ryanedwards805
@ryanedwards805 4 года назад
and we have our reason for demonetization
@user-jo1bs9hl5x
@user-jo1bs9hl5x 4 года назад
@@aenelle7370 calling a British person a tea fucker does not offend them 😂😂😂😂😂
@Expocat69420
@Expocat69420 4 года назад
5:19 BT tanks were actually very effective tanks... when not on the defensive. They were meant for offensive operations and faired well in that regard.
@mooneyes8995
@mooneyes8995 5 лет назад
Can't wait to see its continuation! Awesome narration by the way.
@danillorippel
@danillorippel 5 лет назад
I'm so glad you're been sponsored! You channel deserve every kind of support possible. The content is amazing and the animations are very good! Thank you so much for your hard work!
@cunuchc6153
@cunuchc6153 4 года назад
Great video. Keep up the work man. Also, to add to the discussion, the Soviets were in the middle of rearmament and rebuilding operations; that was also a contributing factor. This was especially evident with the reserve airports being under repair and unable to host any sorties. P.S.: those captions, 11:23; why youtube?
@bluedog843
@bluedog843 5 лет назад
The after credits scene was beautiful.
@javi5296
@javi5296 4 года назад
a bit irritating IMO
@nelsontorres6820
@nelsontorres6820 5 лет назад
RU-vid: I serve the Soviet Union
@yakovgrynewicz4394
@yakovgrynewicz4394 4 года назад
🤣🤣🤣
@yakovgrynewicz4394
@yakovgrynewicz4394 4 года назад
It was sarcasm?
@teoborges3949
@teoborges3949 3 года назад
@@yakovgrynewicz4394 yup
3 года назад
Trash I rep the germans
@commoncents7330
@commoncents7330 3 года назад
RU-vid serves Socialist and Communist ideologies.
@captainprice9240
@captainprice9240 4 года назад
The sad thing is, Stalin knew war was coming, and before WW2 he asked France and Britain how many combat ready-divisions they could field and he was appalled when Britain replied with 16 seeming as he had roughly 150 (I think, might be more). Stalin was hoping the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact would last long enough for his army gain enough equipment/manpower, and US/British lend-lease was very important at the beginning of the war. The rest is obviously history, with their now-moved industry greatly helping the Soviet Armed Forces
@User-cq1ri
@User-cq1ri 5 лет назад
Your artist and animator nailed it on this one, absolutely beautiful
@jesuslovesgunviolence2718
@jesuslovesgunviolence2718 5 лет назад
I guess you would know Heinz. Nice username.
@motorTranz
@motorTranz 5 лет назад
"He who laughs last laughs best....."
@freehorizons9491
@freehorizons9491 4 года назад
well, germany is a way wealthier country and a much better place to live than russia.... so yeah.. i guess they do laugh the best.
@HistoricScents
@HistoricScents 4 года назад
New sub here, this is exactly the type of history channel I've been looking for. Time to binge!
@takeminakata3317
@takeminakata3317 5 лет назад
16:06, that was absolutely brilliant!
@jeddkeech259
@jeddkeech259 4 года назад
Take Minakata agree 😂
@somerandomguyfromthebeyond1821
TL;DW: the Germans caught the Russians with there pants down, almost literally
@BatCostumeGuy
@BatCostumeGuy 3 года назад
@ a small dong
@boriszawotski1392
@boriszawotski1392 3 года назад
@@BatCostumeGuy Stalin unleashed his big one on germany in , 45
@BatCostumeGuy
@BatCostumeGuy 3 года назад
@@boriszawotski1392 a big shot but a small dong
@dreamihad
@dreamihad 4 года назад
Such a good channel , just brought a shaving kit. Mad respect for getting ads vs begging for money
@cattledog901
@cattledog901 5 лет назад
RU-vid blitzkreiged the original video harder than the Germans did to the Soviets in 1941.
@scottlarson1548
@scottlarson1548 5 лет назад
Not only were Soviet tanks spread out, they were sent into combat in small piecemeal formations as soon as they arrived at the front. It took the Soviets a while to figure out that you needed to mass tanks to overwhelm formations, and even when they did that the tanks often ran out of gas and were left helpless because the tank commanders had absolute orders to keep driving forward no matter what.
@RylanVG
@RylanVG 3 года назад
Definitely would like a Part 2 to discuss how Stalin turned things around. Great video overall!
@juozasluksa9967
@juozasluksa9967 5 лет назад
Would love to see more on the Eastern Front, including the Soviet effectiveness, but also looking into how Baltic partisan efforts affected the Soviet advance, and their later ineffectiveness against the occupying Soviet regime (particularly in Lithuania and Latvia).
@blehnder5431
@blehnder5431 5 лет назад
So excited for this video! ACH videos are great to watch/listen to while studying
@Dragon_of_1984
@Dragon_of_1984 4 года назад
Whenever I see someone's content getting demonetized, I know there's a chance that it's good content and subscribe to the channel. Hopefully that problem gets fixed, bruh.
@driskan6945
@driskan6945 3 года назад
Low IQ huh
@JulianLopez-nd9ts
@JulianLopez-nd9ts 5 лет назад
Love this channel, it has inspired me to look into history as a potential major. Please don't leave!
@zelex112
@zelex112 3 года назад
Главное не смотреть такие видео, а читать нормальную историческую литературу.
@dylanmilne6683
@dylanmilne6683 5 лет назад
Wow that stereoscopic view of the Panzer III combined with the cutaway at 6:20 is grade A
@bucket1442
@bucket1442 4 года назад
plays hoi4 once* Watches historical videos for next 2 weeks and becomes ww2 historian*
@daviddavidson8039
@daviddavidson8039 5 лет назад
Im glad to see you upload agian! Keep up the good work.
@steinistbaum2236
@steinistbaum2236 5 лет назад
Please all support our favourite Historian! Our support needs to hit him like the german blitz!
@b.patrickbrowning2349
@b.patrickbrowning2349 4 года назад
Please make a video detailing Soviet effectiveness later in the war. Kursk, Bagration, The Berlin Strategic Offensive, the Soviet invasion of Manchuria, etc. are all of interest.
@zelex112
@zelex112 3 года назад
Никому не интересно слушать про победы СССР. Это противоречит идее - советское значит плохое
@cl5728
@cl5728 5 лет назад
These plane noises are definitely from the end of "In the Flesh?" You can hear the instrumental (keyboards etc.) very faintly while the plane is flying. (0:55)
@doctorx2105
@doctorx2105 5 лет назад
Where the hell are you, Simon??
@armaholic5949
@armaholic5949 5 лет назад
Good to see this back
@Legio__X
@Legio__X 4 года назад
I love the heartbeat in the background of the opening tank crew scene. Well made video !
@avzzor2731
@avzzor2731 5 лет назад
"Why Was Russia so Ineffective in 1941?" Stalin
@avzzor2731
@avzzor2731 5 лет назад
Because Georgy Zhukov actually knew what he was doing
@AlbionSupreme
@AlbionSupreme 5 лет назад
Communism
@hauntologicalwittgensteini2542
@@namesurname-1488 Zhukov
@TheChuckfuc
@TheChuckfuc 5 лет назад
I thought that was a pun. Lol
@typograf62
@typograf62 5 лет назад
Why was France and the UK so ineffective in 1940? Not Stalin.
@lol101lol101lol10199
@lol101lol101lol10199 5 лет назад
The non-aggression pact wasn't a very effective stallin' tactic
@DiMas-kt8jk
@DiMas-kt8jk 5 лет назад
Actually it was. It alowed USSR to prepare to upcoming war. Here is list of events wich led to WW2 ( en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Munich_Agreement#Resolution ). As you can see there Molotov - Ribentrop pact is last one. British Royal house was flirting with Nazi Germany, which is put USSR into corner.
@fatdaddyeddiejr
@fatdaddyeddiejr 4 года назад
Stalin was honoring the pact. Stalin didn't think the Germans weren't going to attack the USSR until England was defeated. For Hitler. The non agression pact was a means to an end. The pact served it's purpose while France was beaten and England was all alone. It was time for the Soviet Union to fall.
@MD-iw2vt
@MD-iw2vt 4 года назад
@@DiMas-kt8jk 23 August 1939 - Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact 11 February 1940 - German-Soviet Commercial Agreement (supplies from USSR were essential for Nazi Germany military) 25 November 1940 - Stalin sent proposal to join Axis powers. He is ignored. USSR was not "in the corner". Stalin deeply believed he can rule Europe alongside Hitler.
@DiMas-kt8jk
@DiMas-kt8jk 4 года назад
@@MD-iw2vt so what? Give me same list of agreement between germany and poland, england and usa. German-Polish Non agression pact January 26, 1934 was signed earlier than molotv pact. And Poland at that time was considered by soviet goverment as the biger threat due to strong British influence in the goverment. And you should understand that main idea of bolshevik revolution was to unite working class people in the whole world by removing capitalistic elites. Ofcourse country with such ideology gona find itself surounded by enemies. Also keep in mind that example of Octobre revolution in Russia inspired a lot of working people all over the world to start movements for social justice for working class people, which is deffenetly dangerouse for one whose profiting from current state of society. Basicly what I am trying to say. In situation when you are surrounded by hungry lions, maybe hiena is a good ally. There is not so much options to choose from
@ukaszw6623
@ukaszw6623 4 года назад
@@DiMas-kt8jk maybe you give this list hmm? If you deny his facts then show it.
@ArustwatDaGoat
@ArustwatDaGoat 3 года назад
Instead of Raiding Area 51, this guy teach us History.... Epic
@sam-i-am1060
@sam-i-am1060 5 лет назад
As always love your videos and the incorporation of memes 👍
@Dumpstermuffin1
@Dumpstermuffin1 5 лет назад
16:07 Hitler is like "they got wrekt by Finland LOL"
@jasonleung665
@jasonleung665 3 года назад
Oh my, that was a dope visual to the Panzer III’s interior.
@ryanmurray7941
@ryanmurray7941 5 лет назад
Wonder if this will be taken down again from all the inappropriate content.
@Xaiff
@Xaiff 5 лет назад
Which inappropriate content, though?
@ryanmurray7941
@ryanmurray7941 5 лет назад
A. Musthofa history.
@LisaBowers
@LisaBowers 5 лет назад
@@ryanmurray7941 In a community post yesterday, Griffin said he wasn't going to take this video down.
@Xaiff
@Xaiff 5 лет назад
@@ryanmurray7941 I see. Sorry, mate. Didn't realize it was sarcasm.
@ihatecabbage7270
@ihatecabbage7270 5 лет назад
I think is something about the things he said during the sponsorship.
@frederickg4536
@frederickg4536 5 лет назад
I love the closing scenes in the end of the film! Timelaps of Soviet reconquest all the way up to 1945 while playing the glorious anthem together with some "memeing"... this is why Armchair History is so great at retelling history 😂😂😂
@Wet_Sandwich
@Wet_Sandwich 3 года назад
Zhukov: Sir, Are You ok?- Stalin: *Cries Severly GET OUT OF MY OFFICE! *throws Vodka Bottle
@TheChuckfuc
@TheChuckfuc 5 лет назад
As a Ukrainian Canadian. The eastern front fascinates me. I'd love to see more videos about it. Again great video.
@aadpiraat7126
@aadpiraat7126 5 лет назад
Off too the gulag with you And you too mr/mrs reader
@justsomeguy8849
@justsomeguy8849 5 лет назад
aad piraat jokes on you, im at gulag 5 days a week for 8 hours.
@byproductofcheese
@byproductofcheese 3 года назад
11:30 damn that gunner did not like that guy just chilling on the tank.
@РоманАндреев-в4з
One point you missing out on - red army was in the middle of modernization. New planes and tanks you mentioned should have been produced by following 1-2 years and replace the obsolete machine's. Also, personal weapons, like self-loading rifles and machine pistols of new generation were being developed/produced as well. It's also true for defence line's. Stalin hoped that Hitler is not dumb enough to fight on 2 fronts, both with Russians and British. He thought that he had time to prepare. About soviet command being removed. It wasn't only due to political reasons, but also due to lack of their ability to command. Previous conflict shown that they were not qualified for they roles. So - they needed to go, usually someone else took they role.
@jackparker8602
@jackparker8602 2 года назад
This is just objectively wrong, and reeks of Stalinist revisionism. Instead of going after the old school and outdated officers, he actively promoted them and went after the more modern thinking ones. See Tukhachevsky and Budyonny for evidence. And even if we give Stalin the benefit of the doubt, which we shouldn’t, how is shooting your supposedly incompetent officers and replacing them with inexperienced ones any better? That’s the very definition of taking one step forward and two steps backwards. Not to mention the gross inhumanity of shooting someone for the crime of not meeting your arbitrary, and ultimately incorrect, ideas of military efficiency.
@РоманАндреев-в4з
@РоманАндреев-в4з 2 года назад
@@jackparker8602 that's the thing about history - you would never understand why someone did this and that if you look through glasses of hate or adoration. One of my history professors told me that at the start of his class - you gotta let go all of your previous believes and try to be as objective as you can. I wasn't pushing any agenda, just offered another point of view, even if I do believe it's more accurate About his policies - it was one of the angles his was playing, but not the only one. Army is a force to be reconed with, even in normal countries, but there, in the early SU - it was a real threat. Even if those officers were the best in the world, literally genius commander's and tactician's - the fact that they were disloyal to the regime was all it took to reduce their value to none. They could defect, they could stage a coup, all kinds of harmful things could come of this. Look up Vlasov, it perfectly illustrates dangers of those kinds in an army. A loyal officer would be better simply because he's loyal, even when he's less experienced. About moral side of this - you can condemn him as much as you want, and you will be in the right, most of the time. But, I couldn't think of anyone who would do better job. Doesn't mean he's done great, it's just every time I imagine later SU leader's in Stalin shoes - it would have been a disaster, on a whole different scale. None of them could have done the 1/3 of his accomplishments, none would be able to stand up to the same challenges. As much as I would try - I simply can't deny him that. And I can't deny him responsibility for his crimes, either. I just hate when people go out of their way to paint him evil and bad, to an extent of misinformation and flat out lies. He has enough dirt on him, there's no need for that
@Soundwave3591
@Soundwave3591 5 лет назад
I actually started using Harry's because of the recommendation of this video.
@kampfkatze6092
@kampfkatze6092 4 года назад
Very interesting video ! Thank you !
@netrolancer1061
@netrolancer1061 5 лет назад
Stalin was slow on implementing proper military doctrines, economic, and factory/production policies which also contributed to the Soviet ineffectiveness during the early stages of the war.
@blahlbinoa
@blahlbinoa 5 лет назад
Soundtrack for when Stalin turned things around Night Witches Panzerkampf
@Roberto-REME
@Roberto-REME 4 года назад
Your videos are excellent. My appreciation to your great narrative and fact gathering.
@TheRealCharlesDarwin
@TheRealCharlesDarwin 5 лет назад
5:24 i think you meant "Чапаев". "чаиаеб" is something waaaay different :D
@rizz2pro
@rizz2pro 5 лет назад
Turn on subtitles (Gear icon --> Captions) and skip to 11:21
@TehUltimateSnake
@TehUltimateSnake 5 лет назад
In an effort to prevent *b i g c o c k*
@bigguacamole6921
@bigguacamole6921 4 года назад
Stalin: we must prevent BIG COCK at all costs
@davidvasquez08
@davidvasquez08 4 года назад
This definitely needs more likes
@xhell247x7
@xhell247x7 Год назад
That has got to be the funniest and best ending to a history video I’ve ever seen 😂
@mihanich
@mihanich 5 лет назад
5:30 "Чаиаеб" Sounds something like "tea-fucker" in Russian
@_arthur_360
@_arthur_360 3 года назад
It's "Чапаев" ffs
@jakobwebber2547
@jakobwebber2547 5 лет назад
11:33 my gawd, that was disturbing 😂
@YourNeighborhoodCIAAgentN5
@YourNeighborhoodCIAAgentN5 3 года назад
During the war thunder sponsorship, the ticket counter at the top showed that the friendly team was winning. Highly unrealistic as seldom will you ever win because your team is always filled with glue sniffers.
@alexanderballa6152
@alexanderballa6152 3 года назад
Thats all game one team has tryhards other glue sniffers
Далее
Распаковка #MonsterHigh Potions №5
00:55
Просмотров 180 тыс.
Battle of Moscow | Animated History
14:52
Просмотров 1,9 млн
Soviet-Afghan War
17:58
Просмотров 434 тыс.
DEADLIEST Battle of WW1: The Somme | Animated History
15:51