Тёмный

Why You Can't Remake Lord Of The Rings 

Jedwerd
Подписаться 118 тыс.
Просмотров 6 тыс.
50% 1

Lord of the Rings is the greatest film trilogy of all time, and I truly believe that it will never be beaten. In this video, I showed why it is better than the Hobbit and The Rings of Power. Frodo, Aragorn, and Legolas make it great.
This content is similar to content made by The Critical Drinker, Disparu, and The Cosmonaut Variety Hour.
#Jedwerd #LordOfTheRings #TheHobbit

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

 

8 мар 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 162   
@Deadeye-bl9if
@Deadeye-bl9if 3 месяца назад
I really don’t want them to remake them because it’s perfect the way it is
@Triforce1018
@Triforce1018 3 месяца назад
Bro just summarized the entire video
@iamnojedi99
@iamnojedi99 3 месяца назад
The Lego Ninjago theme for Legolas jumping up the falling stones would have made that movie top tier. Honestly adding the Leo Ninjago theme to anything would make it better
@ncxksphirxe6945
@ncxksphirxe6945 3 месяца назад
Just got home from my cousins, got my ps4 on just ate some watermelon… jedwerd uploads it’s a great day
@famalex6325
@famalex6325 3 месяца назад
6:15 Look at this - Yes I am looking at you Jedwerd
@Mr.anomas
@Mr.anomas 3 месяца назад
The magic was lightning in the bottle they can NEVER get that effort and that love and care especially with modern Hollywood
@Melikesushi-yo782
@Melikesushi-yo782 3 месяца назад
Love your channel Jed
@pancakegaming77
@pancakegaming77 3 месяца назад
The Ninjago Rant is Incredible, Keep up The Good Content!!!
@solidsnake9898
@solidsnake9898 3 месяца назад
The last time I came this early, I had to pay child support.
@solidsnake9898
@solidsnake9898 3 месяца назад
@TheRandomGuyInYourWalls229 xx
@Pasta-la-pizza-baby
@Pasta-la-pizza-baby 3 месяца назад
Wtf this is the craziest comment I’ve ever read. Pretty funny
@solidsnake9898
@solidsnake9898 3 месяца назад
@@Pasta-la-pizza-baby :P
@user-oy1jw2wg6h
@user-oy1jw2wg6h 3 месяца назад
I heard the Ninjago song and felt so much joy. So much joy.
@iamnojedi99
@iamnojedi99 3 месяца назад
The Orcs in the Hobbit made me chuckle. The Orcs in the Lord of the Rings kept me up at night.
@Jedwerd
@Jedwerd 3 месяца назад
alternative title to this video: don't frickin remake Lord of the Rings 😡
@nomam529
@nomam529 3 месяца назад
Pls shout out Star Wars are probably one of my favorite sagas
@nomam529
@nomam529 3 месяца назад
Lord of the rings also
@MissiMissiMissi
@MissiMissiMissi 3 месяца назад
Respectable opinion
@Nijeldagamer
@Nijeldagamer 3 месяца назад
Agreed, but listen; the only person I would trust to make a remake would be Denis Villeneuve, who directed Dune.
@user-tj3to6ps9t
@user-tj3to6ps9t 3 месяца назад
Yes! We don't want a sequel of this legendary trilogy. We already know that Amazon failed to create a cool Middle Earth series (The Rings of Power).
@Balazar16
@Balazar16 3 месяца назад
I have never watched lord of the rings so should I watch it
@HCKRBRO
@HCKRBRO 3 месяца назад
Dew it! You will not regret it
@KALtheHighstorm117
@KALtheHighstorm117 3 месяца назад
Best movies ever!
@Darth_yapper
@Darth_yapper 3 месяца назад
Yes U really should tho all the 3 movies are like 3 hrs long but I got thru it fine
@benfranklin2024
@benfranklin2024 3 месяца назад
Wow, to heard jedwerd playing the NInjago theme is amazing. wonder if he will make a video on Ninjago.
@ceesvanrijckevorsel8454
@ceesvanrijckevorsel8454 3 месяца назад
Small correction, LOTR definitely uses CGI, but they use it for the right reason: to improve details of already great practical effects. The Hobbit uses *only* CGI for wayy too many scenes
@Melikesushi-yo782
@Melikesushi-yo782 3 месяца назад
This is a. Great triligy
@noobmaster69426
@noobmaster69426 3 месяца назад
My reaction to LOTR: it was perfect. Perfect. Everything, down to the last minute details.
@micahsoda
@micahsoda 3 месяца назад
very good.
@Mewingman45
@Mewingman45 3 месяца назад
R.I.P akira toriyama 🕊
@caoimheh-pd7bw
@caoimheh-pd7bw 3 месяца назад
Lord of the rings is one of the best film series ever to be made and will stay that way forever
@Ploenator
@Ploenator Месяц назад
There is no reason to remake perfection.
@blues2339
@blues2339 3 месяца назад
The weekend whip hits hard, why did they not put it in the hobbit. Kai would agree
@johannesbyfield7397
@johannesbyfield7397 3 месяца назад
Lego-las. Am I the only who it took this long to realize that? Legolas is a master of spinjitzu.
@blues2339
@blues2339 3 месяца назад
@@johannesbyfield7397wait no way, legolas is the real ultimate spinjitzu master
@johannesbyfield7397
@johannesbyfield7397 3 месяца назад
@@blues2339 Fr
@fregley19
@fregley19 Месяц назад
I just finished watching The Two Towers and I'm right back into it, and now I'm gonna watch the extended edition. I did this after a month of burnout from LOTR after watching Fellowship for the first time about a few months before. What am I gonna do after Return of the King? The animated one? The Hobbit?
@user-gg9pp5lm1c
@user-gg9pp5lm1c 3 месяца назад
What you think of ninjago
@Jedwerd
@Jedwerd 3 месяца назад
fire show
@user-pc1qg5tn5p
@user-pc1qg5tn5p 3 месяца назад
Agreed
@lucyc7785
@lucyc7785 3 месяца назад
It's for children
@Pk-glitch
@Pk-glitch 3 месяца назад
@@lucyc7785 Ok and?
@HeroQuestFans
@HeroQuestFans 3 месяца назад
in ROTK the scene where Legolas mounts the Mumakill (Oliphant) and takes it down like Luke Skywalker in Empire Strikes Back... in the theater I thought it looked very cartoony. on a small screen CRT with the Extended Edition DVD it wasn't so bad, but watching the Blu-Ray EE on an HD tv it once again looked just as silly as I remember in the theater. it stuck out like a sore thumb, and unlike the Matrix Reloaded, I couldn't fall back on the idea that they are cheating at video games inside the machine world. "magic vision." they could re-do that scene today and it would look much more realistic (compare to the best CGI in the Hobbit) but yes, otherwise 100% agree, the best stuff in LOTR trilogy were practical and CGI was only used when necessary (to mixed results of course in a few cases... people accepted Golum because he was so weird and they spent the most time trying to make him seem real).
@epicthings4805
@epicthings4805 Месяц назад
To be honest though the music for both are really good
@LellowDood
@LellowDood 3 месяца назад
i would add one scene which is in the book though with realistic deepfake or something of saramaun attacking hobbition like in the book. I think they could add those scenes into the original and dvds and then maybe premire the movies with the book scenes
@VaderBrickStudios
@VaderBrickStudios 3 месяца назад
I agree! LOTR is unbeatable! I really hope they don't remake the trilogy. But if i'm being honest I thought everyone liked Rings of power, I didn't think it was bad and I think desolation of Smaug is the best hobbit movie. Sorry about my bad opinions
@docice2930
@docice2930 3 месяца назад
If they do it is probably going to end up like the like star wars
@CornerstoneWorshipTutorials
@CornerstoneWorshipTutorials 3 месяца назад
It's BOLG! 😅
@masterevenpiell
@masterevenpiell 3 месяца назад
Totally agree, you cannot remake LOTR. They're way better off launching a Silmarillion Cinematic Universe or something. Also Jedwerd, Top Gun Maverick is riddled with CGI, they just didn't overuse it like the Hobbit, they used it how CGI is meant to be used, sparingly. Great video Jedwerd!
@Darth_yapper
@Darth_yapper 3 месяца назад
Ive only seen the lotr trilogy should i watch the hobbit?
@Pasta-la-pizza-baby
@Pasta-la-pizza-baby 3 месяца назад
I believe in remakes (if there’s talented people involved) but that’s if there’s another way to tell the story. Like with Batman and James Bond but I don’t see anything new to do with this story.
@Jedwerd
@Jedwerd 3 месяца назад
Exactly
@ClayStorm-yk4sz
@ClayStorm-yk4sz 3 месяца назад
what happened to jed week
@zionwilliams179
@zionwilliams179 3 месяца назад
that was last week
@samwisethebrave4627
@samwisethebrave4627 3 месяца назад
The critics don’t like to actually do their job when it comes to things like Rings of Power
@Bistrik-yl2di
@Bistrik-yl2di 3 месяца назад
Make a video about. the hobbit next.
@Wtvifeellike
@Wtvifeellike 3 месяца назад
7:32 BASED BASED BASED
@dominionraptor954
@dominionraptor954 3 месяца назад
Why would people WANT to remake them when the one we have is perfect.
@kris1908
@kris1908 3 месяца назад
Where is the top 10 villains video
@Hulpower3
@Hulpower3 3 месяца назад
9:57 actually amazon didnt have rights to the silmarillion so they couldent have done that
@anakinskywalker2142
@anakinskywalker2142 3 месяца назад
Is one of the few trilogies i know where the third chapter is the best. I like the hobbit movies, it was never gonna be on the level of lord of the rings, the book wasn't on the level of the others.
@StanKIrby-lw8vh
@StanKIrby-lw8vh 3 месяца назад
I agree that The Hobbit had too much cgi looking like a Ps5 game, but it’s not as bad as the sequels!
@AdTaylor2
@AdTaylor2 3 месяца назад
15th comment I didn’t watch the video yet
@Bistrik-yl2di
@Bistrik-yl2di 3 месяца назад
I kinda disagree with you saying that an unexpected journey is the best, desolation of smaug has the greatest fight scenes with scene barrels out of bond.
@CornerstoneWorshipTutorials
@CornerstoneWorshipTutorials 3 месяца назад
Yeah I just rewatched the series and I like the second two in terms of fight scenes. I feel Unexpected Journey had the greatest story line, though. The rest was all kind of mumbo-jumbo...
@Bistrik-yl2di
@Bistrik-yl2di 3 месяца назад
Yes, I agree woth you that an unexpected journey has the best story, but think deslolation of smaug has the best fight scenes @@CornerstoneWorshipTutorials
@dragonsman4733
@dragonsman4733 3 месяца назад
The Unexpected journey is a very good start to the trilogy, but yeah the second one is my favourite mainly due to the added characterization for Fili, Kili, and bard. that although we never got in the books, was pretty good. As well as the actors performance for Thranduil, he was only there for a short time of the film, but it was a great short time.
@Ben_sul
@Ben_sul 3 месяца назад
I hope it doesnt happen im sick of seeing my favourite things ruined
@BrickmotionStudios862
@BrickmotionStudios862 3 месяца назад
I understand what you meen with the hobbit trilogy, but when you first watched the movies, were you really dissapointed or did you like it? I think that it is fun to watch and a cool story. that's my opinion. Love your content, but think better about the hobbit❤
@Jedwerd
@Jedwerd 3 месяца назад
When I was younger I liked them, but watching them now just pisses me off. The first one is good, and I like Marin Freeman as Bilbo, but most of the rest of it is not up my alley
@BrickmotionStudios862
@BrickmotionStudios862 3 месяца назад
I understand, Bilbo was one of the best parts of the trilogy😂
@elderadult8544
@elderadult8544 3 месяца назад
There is a good movie in the Hobbit trilogy it's just got a bunch of other bad stuff hiding it all. Some of the good is casting! Martian Freeman as Bilbo and Benedict Cumberbatch as smaug are amazing! So are the dwarves to bad they got sidelined for a terrible love story.
@brythegamerguyYT
@brythegamerguyYT 3 месяца назад
Best trilogy ever made no doubt! Do not remake it!
@pressy-fb1hs
@pressy-fb1hs 3 месяца назад
Me personally I like the lotr movies better than the book the 1st book took like 120 pages to get into the journey
@vojixd3560
@vojixd3560 3 месяца назад
the lotr trylogy is just the best movie trylogy ever
@natobricksYT
@natobricksYT Месяц назад
Why is their sans music playing in the background........its the memes isn't it
@Bistrik-yl2di
@Bistrik-yl2di 3 месяца назад
That girl is also in the books, have you ever read the book?
@elderadult8544
@elderadult8544 3 месяца назад
Are you talking about Tauriel? Because if you are Tauriel is not in the book. The real question is have you ever read the The Hobbit?
@Bistrik-yl2di
@Bistrik-yl2di 3 месяца назад
yes I have @@elderadult8544
@Bistrik-yl2di
@Bistrik-yl2di 3 месяца назад
I can take a photo of it and post it on my community page
@elderadult8544
@elderadult8544 3 месяца назад
@@Bistrik-yl2di I would love to see that! Especially since Tauriel was made for the films because there wasn't a female character in the book.
@Bistrik-yl2di
@Bistrik-yl2di 3 месяца назад
um the 1937 revised edition does have a girl in it.@@elderadult8544
@Bistrik-yl2di
@Bistrik-yl2di 3 месяца назад
What do you mean by Legolas ain't a main charatcer, they go to riverdell and he is in the book everywhere, I have the original hobbit countless times. If you want to say it that way then The Lord of the Rings have way more messups in the movie.
@HCKRBRO
@HCKRBRO 3 месяца назад
He means that legolas is NOT a main character and that bilbo is the main character. Also do you mean, “you have read the hobbit countless times”?
@Bistrik-yl2di
@Bistrik-yl2di 3 месяца назад
yes i did mean that, and legolas is in the fight scenes many times, they dont directly metion him though @@HCKRBRO
@elderadult8544
@elderadult8544 3 месяца назад
If you have read The Hobbit countless times you should know Legolas doesn't appear anywhere in the book. He isn't even mentioned by his father. Also why would Legolas be at Rivendell in The Hobbit? He is from Mirkwood. Also Legolas is not a main character even in The Lord of the Rings.
@Bistrik-yl2di
@Bistrik-yl2di 3 месяца назад
So I read the original book of the hobbit and that is just how. the book is. Check my community page.@@elderadult8544
@AdTaylor2
@AdTaylor2 3 месяца назад
14th comment
@user-tj3to6ps9t
@user-tj3to6ps9t 3 месяца назад
To be honest, Hobbit of course isn't as good as LOTR but it's not that bad.
@dragonsman4733
@dragonsman4733 3 месяца назад
Agreed. My personal reasons why: It gave more characterization to the dwarves, the actors performance especially thorins, Bilbo's, and Thranduils was amazing, the voice acting for smaug was also very good, the fight scenes were well choreographed, we got added scenes of Saurons return, we finally got Radagast to appear since he never did in the lotr movies, etc.
@user-tj3to6ps9t
@user-tj3to6ps9t 3 месяца назад
@@dragonsman4733 Yeah, the CGI was bad in some scenes and I didn't like mostly two things, the first one was adding Tauriel, or however she's called and making Legolas fall in love with her and the second was making Thranduil look like a jerk.
@UKStudiosNE
@UKStudiosNE Месяц назад
Scale models is a dead art that is by far better than cgi in most cases
@A-The-Great
@A-The-Great 3 месяца назад
To Be honest lord of the rings is better then star wars
@Levi-zr4dq
@Levi-zr4dq 3 месяца назад
😂😂😂😂😂😂
@A-The-Great
@A-The-Great 3 месяца назад
@@Levi-zr4dq What?
@Hulpower3
@Hulpower3 3 месяца назад
Yep
@yodalog202
@yodalog202 3 месяца назад
I thought of another positive about remaking the trilogy. (Fixing galadrial horrible cgi)
@landonsshortstopmotions1555
@landonsshortstopmotions1555 28 дней назад
I don’t like The Lord of the Rings movies
@jaypeadieL611
@jaypeadieL611 3 месяца назад
Oh no another shite remake
@UKStudiosNE
@UKStudiosNE Месяц назад
I will not be watching the remakes i know that for certain, they will most definitely race swap and change things for the worse
@user-pc1qg5tn5p
@user-pc1qg5tn5p 3 месяца назад
Nah, hobbit trilogy was fire, just not as fire as lotr
@DabigJK
@DabigJK 3 месяца назад
Star Wars og trilogy is better
@HCKRBRO
@HCKRBRO 3 месяца назад
Nope, sorry to break it to you, but lord of the rings is better, even jedwerd agrees
@dragonsman4733
@dragonsman4733 3 месяца назад
The star wars og trilogy wouldn't exist without lotr
@Darth_yapper
@Darth_yapper 3 месяца назад
​@@dragonsman4733how?
@DabigJK
@DabigJK 3 месяца назад
@@Darth_yapper idk, it has lightsabers
@DabigJK
@DabigJK 3 месяца назад
Lord of the rings doesn’t have ligthsabers
@Athyxer
@Athyxer 3 месяца назад
The books were better fr
@user-bc8ww4ky1r
@user-bc8ww4ky1r 3 месяца назад
If you continue to make mean-spirited videos on your channel then you have failed as a youtuber.
@elderadult8544
@elderadult8544 3 месяца назад
I didn't realize him taking about how good Lotr was is a mean-spirited video?
@user-bc8ww4ky1r
@user-bc8ww4ky1r 3 месяца назад
@@elderadult8544 If he's talking how bad the sequals are. Then he has failed as a RU-vidr.
@elderadult8544
@elderadult8544 3 месяца назад
@@user-bc8ww4ky1r RU-vidrs aren't allowed to say anything negative about something? Even if it is really valid criticism?
@user-bc8ww4ky1r
@user-bc8ww4ky1r 3 месяца назад
@@elderadult8544 By being bullys and talk down other people's opinions.
@elderadult8544
@elderadult8544 3 месяца назад
@@user-bc8ww4ky1r Having a differing opinion is bullying. Got it
@avonleakrueger8317
@avonleakrueger8317 3 месяца назад
starwars is better
@JoshuaMemeCo7
@JoshuaMemeCo7 3 месяца назад
I agree it’s so sad seeing him do other crap
@williamstormo2922
@williamstormo2922 3 месяца назад
@@JoshuaMemeCo7he should be allowed to do other stuff than just Star wars
@JoshuaMemeCo7
@JoshuaMemeCo7 3 месяца назад
@@williamstormo2922 I don’t give two shits
@SnorgYippee
@SnorgYippee 3 месяца назад
​@@JoshuaMemeCo7 Cry about it
@Levi-zr4dq
@Levi-zr4dq 3 месяца назад
Yes
@Levi-zr4dq
@Levi-zr4dq 3 месяца назад
Star was better
@SnorgYippee
@SnorgYippee 3 месяца назад
No
@CHEESY_SOUNDW4VE
@CHEESY_SOUNDW4VE 3 месяца назад
Yes
@user-bc8ww4ky1r
@user-bc8ww4ky1r 3 месяца назад
This channel is wrong. And as a person with autism. It's painful to watch.
@user-bc8ww4ky1r
@user-bc8ww4ky1r 3 месяца назад
@NicoPopescu-yl3fh He never makes a harry Potter video.
@user-bc8ww4ky1r
@user-bc8ww4ky1r 3 месяца назад
@NicoPopescu-yl3fh I'm Surius black. Potter heads are the nicest people on RU-vid. They give good comments. Like and dislike ratio and they're so nice. And for youtubers like Jed Ward are not Potter heads. That's when you know theres a problem.
@user-bc8ww4ky1r
@user-bc8ww4ky1r 3 месяца назад
@NicoPopescu-yl3fh He hates the sequals out of spite. Much like like the youtubers don't make harry Potter videos.
@user-bc8ww4ky1r
@user-bc8ww4ky1r 3 месяца назад
@NicoPopescu-yl3fh Just look at the entire star Wars cast and crew. There going through so much bullying right now. But that's what they agreed to do when signing up. I try to use my platform to stop this bullying of these cast and crew as much as I can. I did it for the percy Jackson cast and I did it for rachael zeglar after the snow White fiasco for hunger games. But there's only so much One person on RU-vid like Jed Ward can do.
@user-bc8ww4ky1r
@user-bc8ww4ky1r 3 месяца назад
@NicoPopescu-yl3fh No It's not goddamned okay. People are already comparing the awful prequals to the originals and the sequals. The prequals suck and are so unfaithful the cosmanout channel dislike them.
@KatakuriUchiha22
@KatakuriUchiha22 3 месяца назад
Lord of the Rings was horrible, i was simply not dropping it because i thought, at least im gonna see Sauron in the last film... Hobbit is leagues above Lord of the Rings realistically. I dont see argument for LOTR. There was literally NO pay off in that trilogy what so ever. I think most people wouldnt even like it watching it again without nostalgia, but i still want to read the books sometime because no shot the books are so badly written
@Jedwerd
@Jedwerd 3 месяца назад
Just so you know, I respect your opinion, but this is perhaps the hottest take k have ever heard in my entire life, and you are in the VAST minority here
@KatakuriUchiha22
@KatakuriUchiha22 3 месяца назад
@Jedwerd 😂I know, but to be fair I'm gonna read the books, because I want to like it, it has a lot of good things about it, it just wasn't it for me yet. ONG Hobbit is way better.
@Darth_yapper
@Darth_yapper 3 месяца назад
​@@KatakuriUchiha22ok I think Ur just saying this for attention or your on drugs ngl
@KatakuriUchiha22
@KatakuriUchiha22 3 месяца назад
@@Darth_yapper right...
@tropical_george666
@tropical_george666 2 месяца назад
the skibidi toilet trilogy hahahahahahahahahahahahaahahahahahaahahahahhahahaahhaahahaha
@Darth_yapper
@Darth_yapper 3 месяца назад
Ive only seen the lotr trilogy should i watch the hobbit?
@zionwilliams179
@zionwilliams179 3 месяца назад
yes
@elderadult8544
@elderadult8544 3 месяца назад
Sure why not. Just don't get your hopes up. There's a good movie somewhere in there
@zionwilliams179
@zionwilliams179 3 месяца назад
@@elderadult8544 i honestly don’t think they’re bad movies just pretty cheesy and not good to the books sometimes but if you like lotr it’s worth a watch
Далее
220 Things You Somehow Missed In Star Wars Films
2:49:14
Просмотров 703 тыс.
HUMAN BASKETBALL! 👀🏀🤣 | Triple Charm #Shorts
00:15
Ayollar orzusidagi er😂😂
01:01
Просмотров 781 тыс.
The 10 Greatest Film Trilogies Of All Time
9:55
Просмотров 15 тыс.
How Star Wars RUINED Great Characters
15:07
Просмотров 126 тыс.
Megamind 2 Is Embarassingly Bad
8:06
Просмотров 10 тыс.
NOT what I EXPECTED from these TOLKIEN EDITIONS
7:46
Marvel Is DYING, And This Is Why
8:41
Просмотров 19 тыс.
Edoras | LOTR's Most Insane Location
9:49
Просмотров 735 тыс.
Why the Lord of the Rings Trilogy is a Masterpiece
18:11