Тёмный

WORST CALL IN MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL HISTORY 

League Bat
Подписаться 6 тыс.
Просмотров 8 млн
50% 1

MLB should be ashamed.

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

 

30 июл 2014

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 10 тыс.   
@claytoncopeland3969
@claytoncopeland3969 6 лет назад
The worst call in MLB history is the not-even-close play at first base which cost Detroit Tigers pitcher Armando Galarraga a perfect game in June 2010.
@jamesray7413
@jamesray7413 4 года назад
Or the cardinals Atlanta infield fly rule
@jamesray7413
@jamesray7413 4 года назад
I’d say the blown perfect game was a little worse tho
@preyzcruz
@preyzcruz 3 года назад
Agree
@ericwilliams398
@ericwilliams398 3 года назад
Agreed
@mikegriggs2291
@mikegriggs2291 3 года назад
@@ericwilliams398 I immediately thought the same thing when I saw the clip title. The perfect game call was like stealing a guy's winning lotto ticket.
@KingCitaldo125
@KingCitaldo125 9 лет назад
"He didn't even slide!" Wtf there's no rule that you NEED to slide to home if the catcher has the ball.
@isleyrichardson2194
@isleyrichardson2194 9 лет назад
yeah there actually is
@RagingTalen7s
@RagingTalen7s 9 лет назад
Isley Richardson in little league
@samiswhoa
@samiswhoa 9 лет назад
The rule is, The catcher can not block the plate PRIOR to recieving the ball. The catcher doesnt have the ball and is in front of the plate which is why the call was made. If he impedes the runner then the runner is safe. It is a horrible rule that has since been recognized, and now umpires do a better job at analyzing the situation as it unfolds
@schelbboy22
@schelbboy22 9 лет назад
exactly^
@alexbeaulieu9292
@alexbeaulieu9292 9 лет назад
samiswhoa have you ever played baseball??? do you know your arms only have a limited reach and if you want to catch the ball you have to move in front of it!!! human being arent really like the rubber guy in the fantastic four. you see the catcher looking down at the plate to know where he is (5:45) the as the ball approaches he moves towards the ball to catch it.
@bigson1973
@bigson1973 6 лет назад
Worst call in baseball goes to Jim Joyce calling a guy safe with 2 outs in the ninth costing Armando Gallaraga a perfect game when he was clearly out.
@juliepeterson488
@juliepeterson488 6 лет назад
I agree
@Larry29873
@Larry29873 6 лет назад
He ruined a shutout not a perfect game. A perfect game is when you face 27 batters and no one reaches base. The bases were loaded on that play.
@sayhey7482
@sayhey7482 6 лет назад
that ,my brother ,is a FACT ,im a yank fan so the call didnt effect my season BUT it effec ted me to the extent that if ,like you just did ,lol,mentions ANY error being bad or missed ,etc that is and will be FOREVER # 1,even ryte NOW my adrenaline is pumpin so high feel like snapping the keyboard ,lolol
@sayhey7482
@sayhey7482 6 лет назад
im not sure of the teams larry BUT it was a perfect game ,no one was on base ,im talking about the game when the ump who called the runner safe appolized in tears ,like the next da y ,and i do kbow it was detroit as miggy caught the throw that was an out
@sayhey7482
@sayhey7482 6 лет назад
if not perfect then a no-hitter
@recoveringbaptist2749
@recoveringbaptist2749 3 года назад
Let us not forget 1985 WS and Don Dinkinger's missed call at first base!
@socaljarhead7670
@socaljarhead7670 Год назад
To me, that’ll always be the worst call ever
@metropod
@metropod 8 лет назад
I don't know, I still think Jim Joyce's screw up on Armando Galarraga perfect game was worse.
@salamat_osu
@salamat_osu 8 лет назад
+metropod true dat.
@s10akland
@s10akland 8 лет назад
Yea that call was terrible, but imagine they review the play and still fuck it up, then you feel like fuck baseball... I fucking hate replay
@Cesar-Avila
@Cesar-Avila 8 лет назад
Easy
@fleagle66
@fleagle66 8 лет назад
+metropod Well, it's all about context. Think about the rule they they're trying to enforce here. It's an interpretation that, in a sense, completely changes the game for lack of a better word. What Jim Joyce did was simply miss a call. Just botched it. Nothing 'changed' per se. Yes, it was awful, but just shows that umpires aren't perfect. This was looked at for a VERY LONG time in New York and they STILL came up with that call? INSANE.
@metropod
@metropod 8 лет назад
+Fleagle the Command center crew relies on the footage from the TV cameras and admittedly, the catcher's foot was blocking the plate before he caught the ball. Joyce was standing feet from the bag when he screwed up, and anyone with the gift of sight could tell that was an out.
@Captain_Pudding
@Captain_Pudding 8 лет назад
In my day you had to touch home plate to score a run . . .
@DonkeyDong69
@DonkeyDong69 8 лет назад
The rule assumes the runner was unable to touch the plate
@Captain_Pudding
@Captain_Pudding 8 лет назад
John Smith The rule also says you can't block the plate when you don't have the ball, but when you're playing the ball you can. He starts with the plate completely open and only steps into the path when he's playing the ball
@DonkeyDong69
@DonkeyDong69 8 лет назад
Captain_Pudding Yes, I know that. I don't agree with the call. I was just telling you why the plate didn't need to be touched for a run to be awarded
@Captain_Pudding
@Captain_Pudding 8 лет назад
John Smith Agreed
@theswamp8870
@theswamp8870 8 лет назад
haha
@cybernautsterranautsandast2151
Dang, the whole line at the concession could have been served by the time they got the call.
@jasonlopez8053
@jasonlopez8053 3 года назад
They did because firsthand I was there in the concessions thing lmao
@liveandlearn4042
@liveandlearn4042 3 года назад
Not at Dodgers Stadium
@Jason-qu4fe
@Jason-qu4fe 3 года назад
i was there i went twice for a beer
@kevinmiller6324
@kevinmiller6324 3 года назад
@@Jason-qu4fe Did they settle the call then?
@Dblwinster221T
@Dblwinster221T 3 года назад
Lol
@aaronm.3581
@aaronm.3581 3 года назад
If by worst call, you mean the broadcasters calling the play, I agree.
@moviescatsmargs
@moviescatsmargs 3 года назад
These commentators are so annoying. Mostly the color commentator, he is literally the embodiment of every old man watching baseball
@doesnotexist305
@doesnotexist305 3 года назад
@@moviescatsmargs why? Because he’s calling it as it is?
@robertbrown380
@robertbrown380 3 года назад
They whine like parents at a club baseball tournament
@aaronm.3581
@aaronm.3581 3 года назад
@@doesnotexist305 Please do more to make your name fitting.
@robmorrison1043
@robmorrison1043 3 года назад
If you look at the stands, they are already practicing covid precautions!
@12kevinnivek21
@12kevinnivek21 9 лет назад
ply-by-play guy is really upset about him not sliding...
@JaaySanchez
@JaaySanchez 9 лет назад
Because the rules of baseball are under bases loaded the runner on third must slide at home. Otherwise they're automatically out.
@seanbrower6738
@seanbrower6738 9 лет назад
***** I've never heard that. Interesting.
@Mar218100
@Mar218100 9 лет назад
***** The runner is not required to slide the catcher is required to tag the runner on a non force out, the controversy stems from the new rule that the catcher must provide a lane for the runner to touch the plate if the catcher doesn't have possession of the ball. I do not like the rule and think the interpretation of it is fuzzy at best. but no where at any base is a runner ever required to slide that is not a rule.
@seanbrower6738
@seanbrower6738 9 лет назад
Mar218100 That's what I thought.
@waynedurham6436
@waynedurham6436 9 лет назад
Mar218100 No the runner is not required to slide however in certain cases such as a double play if the runner gets hit with the ball coming from second to first, if the runner at first would have been out it is declared a runner interference.
@TheoneandonlyEETFUK
@TheoneandonlyEETFUK 7 лет назад
I'm not even a marlins fan and this pissed me off
@jameshetfield5382
@jameshetfield5382 7 лет назад
EET FUK Fuck yeah, me too.
@dylanjohnson613
@dylanjohnson613 7 лет назад
EET FUK right
@emilyb9189
@emilyb9189 7 лет назад
EET FUK yeah like wtf how was he safe he got tagged the catcher moved legally he was not blocking home plate and plus the runner never touched home plate
@gh0styzz-_-459
@gh0styzz-_-459 7 лет назад
Dean Winchester yea
@ee138
@ee138 7 лет назад
I guess im just going to haft to go be an umpire and say when i see that call "well there was this gaming in 2014 that this happened and they called him safe without touching home plate." and then eject the coach when he tells me that its bullshit
@TGDylan96
@TGDylan96 5 лет назад
They called Angel Hernandez
@c-3p0needshumanjoystick57
@c-3p0needshumanjoystick57 5 лет назад
TGDylan96 ikr lol
@virtualairracingseries
@virtualairracingseries 5 лет назад
Love how I can read the Mangers lips when he say "Ohh Fuck That, this is Bull Shit!"
@nipawe
@nipawe 8 лет назад
I still can't believe Seattle didn't run the ball
@HEADBANGERSBALLER
@HEADBANGERSBALLER 8 лет назад
Lol. You're awesome!!! Too funny.
@eb121209
@eb121209 8 лет назад
I can't believe you're still dwelling over that. Get a life.
@deeander6156
@deeander6156 8 лет назад
Get over it
@timhb3064
@timhb3064 7 лет назад
nipawe The Deflatriots wouldn't have let Seattle score anyway.
@patrickculleton5046
@patrickculleton5046 7 лет назад
awesome.
@brianakinyele1804
@brianakinyele1804 8 лет назад
Who else thinks that 1 announcer is super annoying
@mr.dolphingamer7437
@mr.dolphingamer7437 8 лет назад
I do! He is so annoying and stupid. The Reds are my second favorite team too!
@juliangarcia449
@juliangarcia449 8 лет назад
But he's right tho in everything he said. It's the Marlins network he's a fan and he works for the organization so he has the right to be pissed off. As a baseball lover if you weren't pissed off after watching this video you don't respect the game enough lol
@ArtisticJunkie
@ArtisticJunkie 8 лет назад
omg... I wanted to bitch slap the announcer... that was a god call... I'm not for either team... it was a good call... clearly the catcher was blocking the path
@alexfife3594
@alexfife3594 8 лет назад
+Ashley Taylor are you stupid that catcher was not blocking the plate until he had the ball which is okay
@ArtisticJunkie
@ArtisticJunkie 8 лет назад
Alex Fife​ don't call me stupid... dumbass
@kidranmienko8887
@kidranmienko8887 5 лет назад
"Which leaves me to believe, Tommy, there's a discussion going on in New York..."
@mikeepp70
@mikeepp70 6 лет назад
The guys in New York should have to show their faces. Stupid call.
@Jivvi
@Jivvi 6 лет назад
They made the correct call. The announcers are clueless. They even read it the rule that explains why he should be safe, and then acted all surprised when he was.
@RLoz76
@RLoz76 9 лет назад
Worst call in MLB history?! I was expecting to see Jim Joyce blow the final out of Armando Galarraga's perfect game.
@SPRPhilly
@SPRPhilly 9 лет назад
+RLoz76 Yes! Now THAT one would be a definite candidate for the worst call ever.
@bjhorton45
@bjhorton45 9 лет назад
+RLoz76 No question - absolute worst call ever!
@AndrewL31413
@AndrewL31413 8 лет назад
+RLoz76 Agreed. It wasn't even close. To take away a perfect game....what a shame.
@wb805
@wb805 8 лет назад
+RLoz76, that call was responsible for Jim Joyce being the father of instant reply in MLB.
@TheBigjohn527
@TheBigjohn527 8 лет назад
Yep, I agree. Rewarded by umping National League games afterwards.I guess because of the backlash. One of the worst umps I've ever seen.Jerry Meals is another bad one.
@Robology13
@Robology13 9 лет назад
There's 2 kinds of sports people. 1) - Book people who believe 1 sentence can cover eeeeeevery possibilty. 2) - Common sense people who use their eyes and multiple factors before deciding. You want to know what's wrong with sports in general these days? ... Every player in every sport trying to become an Oscar nominee by exploiting the rule book and over-officiating to get a call from the ref and/or ump. I will hand it to baseball (and even hockey) however, their umps don't mess up perfectly good games like the refs of the NBA & NFL. Almost every NBA & NFL game is decided by calls. If you're a nerdy calculator loving geek .... you probably think he's safe, cause afterall, a rules a rule right? If you're a human being ... dude was out by 10 feet and just the fact that he pulled up like a chump and immediatly started acting like a child who was told it's time for bed .... you think he's out. IMO
@ethanwilkes3612
@ethanwilkes3612 9 лет назад
same thing with targeting in football
@dzanier
@dzanier 9 лет назад
You are right about everything. This guy is out. Aside from not being a fan of this new rule, the fact of the matter is that he moved towards the runner to get the ball. The throw took him in that direction. But he wasn't blocking the plate anyway.
@Mar218100
@Mar218100 9 лет назад
Actually the rule has been tweaked for 2015, This year Cozart(runner) would be out because he did not slide or attempt to touch home plate.
@caucasianboyz
@caucasianboyz 9 лет назад
That's stupid too, the rule should be, " if the runner plows into the catcher then the runner is out" that's it. Because all they want to Do is stop collisions. Its their option weather to slide or just give themselves up.
@schelbboy22
@schelbboy22 9 лет назад
Mar218100 whether its been tweaked or not they would still look to see if he was blocking. but yes. its a more chasing the throw friendly version this year which should theoretically stop arguments. "theoretically"
@parkerflis551
@parkerflis551 6 лет назад
you know this video is old when stanton is with the marlins lol
@mattsharpe2861
@mattsharpe2861 5 лет назад
Lol . “This call will change the game of baseball forever”.... 2018 and this call has long been forgotten. And, absolutely NOTHING has changed. Relax announcer guy
5 лет назад
Cold Snap if that were true you would see it being exploited, I think this was a bad call but it didn’t mess up the game. The only part is do you truat Joe Torre saying the catcher is allowed to move? he looks so much mafia that I gotta admit it’s hard 😆
@galactic_clashx4056
@galactic_clashx4056 4 года назад
Umm please stfu the call was awful they broke the rules and if they broke the rules clearly everyone thought they were gonna change them after that
@TZ61
@TZ61 2 года назад
Wrong.
@nateboy1489
@nateboy1489 2 года назад
Alec Bohm would like a word with you.
@mattsharpe2861
@mattsharpe2861 2 года назад
@@nateboy1489 Lol
@RonBurgundy33
@RonBurgundy33 9 лет назад
Two words: Armando Gallaraga.
@agustinmartinez3398
@agustinmartinez3398 9 лет назад
God don't even get me started on that play.
@GingerJesus28
@GingerJesus28 9 лет назад
It was a terrible call, and I hope I can offer an explanation that defends Jim Joyce (the best ump, voted by mlb player). Umpires are taught to close their eyes on bang-bang plays at first and listen to the glove catch the ball and the foot hit the bag. This is because on plays that close, your eyes will decieve you and create indecisiveness in your brain, which is the last thing an umpire needs. What happened was, it was a soft throw and it was hard to hear the catch, so when Joyce heard Gallaraga's foot stomp down on the bag in excitement of throwing a perfect game, he thought it was the runners foot and called him safe because he never heard the ball hit the glove. Even though he was out by a lot, it was too close for Joyce to realize his mistake and change the call directly after (which is allowed). It really sucks, hopefully at least you can understand why and have some sympathy for the umpire.
@SSchus87
@SSchus87 9 лет назад
Horrible call, but handled with the utmost class. Joyce and Gallaraga will go down as two of the classiest guys in the history of the game.
@seancochrane3478
@seancochrane3478 9 лет назад
GingerJesus28 If I can slightly teak your explanation: Umpires are taught to watch the foot and listen to the ball in the glove, not close your eyes. I'm a huge fan of Joyce (best strike calls in the game IMO) but in that situation unless the runner was clearly safe, he should have called him out. You can even tell by the runners reaction that he knew he was out. But when he apologized that is one of the most ballsy moves I have ever seen. Heck the guy couldn't walk to his mailbox without a police escort from all the death threats
@eastbaycommuter
@eastbaycommuter 9 лет назад
GingerJesus28 ... '' . . . Umpires are taught to close their eyes on bang-bang plays at first and listen to the glove catch the ball and the foot hit the bag . . . ''. Hello ??? !!! ~~~ '' ... taught to close their eyes ... '' ... Are You Nuts ??? !!! ... Please do not be one of those '' Functional Illiterates '' ... [ These Folks are apart of the General Population that Doesn't KNOW what's Happening, AND it Doesn't even Know that it Doesn't KNOW !!! ] ... They do Exist, And to Prove my Point : THEY VOTED FOR PRESIDENT OBAMA ... Enough Said !!! ...
@KZ3fps
@KZ3fps 9 лет назад
Is this what other team's announcers sound like? I've never heard a more irritating voice in my life.
@ericalexander3246
@ericalexander3246 9 лет назад
KZ3fps Ever heard the White Sox announcer? Or Ernie Banks calling baseball?
@KZ3fps
@KZ3fps 9 лет назад
Eric Alexander as a Tigers fan, I know all about the White Sox terrible announcer
@ericalexander3246
@ericalexander3246 9 лет назад
KZ3fps You poor, poor man. I hope you usually get to hear the Tigers announcers instead of The Hawk.
@KZ3fps
@KZ3fps 9 лет назад
Eric Alexander luckily I never have to listen to him, but I've heard from others how bad he is as well as hearing him in some highlight clips. Just terrible.
@HubbaPlaysMC
@HubbaPlaysMC 9 лет назад
KZ3fps I'm a cubs fan and I don't really hear any bias from our play-by-play guys at all. I didn't know a commentator could be so biased and annoying.
@boristheamerican2938
@boristheamerican2938 3 года назад
The worst call ever was when that pitcher had a perfect game taken away from him.
@seamustard0394
@seamustard0394 5 лет назад
You see the catcher tag him on the back of the leg and the runner doesn’t even touch the plate anyway
@ryanchase5535
@ryanchase5535 4 года назад
seamustard 03 not what there debating
@chadmilligan342
@chadmilligan342 4 года назад
No he didn’t but he never touched the plate. But he was blocking the plate.
@WARTHOG_BRRT
@WARTHOG_BRRT 8 лет назад
Let's just agree he didn't even touch the fucking plate...
@Landon21racing
@Landon21racing 8 лет назад
Yep
@michaelvento7950
@michaelvento7950 8 лет назад
yea
@licensedblockhead
@licensedblockhead 8 лет назад
+Anthony Diaz yeah, i was fine with the whole he didnt get touched but he didnt touch the plate come on
@colinmcfarland3515
@colinmcfarland3515 8 лет назад
Exactly
@yourmainstoplight4187
@yourmainstoplight4187 8 лет назад
TRUE!! That's why I'm thinking
@gunz300
@gunz300 8 лет назад
Apparently you can be safe if you don't touch the plate.
@madjayhawk
@madjayhawk 6 лет назад
Pete Rose would have knocked that catcher into the stands.
@bluesmax1336
@bluesmax1336 6 лет назад
Yeah, but he'd still have been out! Well, at least till New York fucked up!
@strikefirst5650
@strikefirst5650 6 лет назад
cant do that anymore thanks to buster Posey
@zurfer11
@zurfer11 5 лет назад
Can't be more right
@rickn.backer1087
@rickn.backer1087 5 лет назад
Id' PAY to see CHARLIE HUSTLE DO THAT AGAIN. He's done it before. Pete Rose was one the most passionate ball players I ever saw and TOUGH AS NAILS. You just would not want to be on his bad side. I've done trade show circuits with him as a guest autographer and hes as tough as they come!
@prestonstauffer3771
@prestonstauffer3771 5 лет назад
That’s why Charlie Cheap Shot isn’t in the Hall of Fame
@xeugl
@xeugl 5 лет назад
He Didn’t even touch the plate
@FlyingRKennelsofMissouri
@FlyingRKennelsofMissouri 5 лет назад
irrelevent, supports the call of safe as blocked the plate purposely by moving left before possession!!
@ShortRound42
@ShortRound42 5 лет назад
Bad rule 'cause the catcher had to move into the path to catch. Hate this rule.
@JamieSmith-fz2mz
@JamieSmith-fz2mz 5 лет назад
He didn't have to because he already had it in his mind that he would file a protest and ask that it be reviewed. Plus, he was tagged out before that anyway, so it was immaterial.
@cogaming3925
@cogaming3925 8 лет назад
Sounds like the announcer is routing for the marlins
@ryank6557
@ryank6557 8 лет назад
obviously
@brandonyates5128
@brandonyates5128 8 лет назад
+Jedi of awesomeness well he is a marlins announcer...
@STLFANPhillips
@STLFANPhillips 8 лет назад
Right
@quintonhershonNY
@quintonhershonNY 8 лет назад
+SergeantRAZOR how much do you hate your life??
@StraitCHRIS067
@StraitCHRIS067 8 лет назад
+Land Sucks exactly
@abbeyjewart75
@abbeyjewart75 7 лет назад
He didn't even touch home plate.
@jaydeeification
@jaydeeification 6 лет назад
That doesn't matter- he's safe due to Catcher Interference. (I think it's a bad call myself) If it's interference, whether he touched the plate doesn't matter)
@jvm1166
@jvm1166 6 лет назад
Are you stupid
@TheUnknown1709
@TheUnknown1709 6 лет назад
It does matter, he at least has to make an attempt... if he collides with the catcher then still does not touch the plate then your point would be valid... but that is not what happen
@ocsurfer411
@ocsurfer411 6 лет назад
That's not true. If the runner is obstructed by the fielder, the runner doesn't even have to make an attempt, the runner is protected. It's very important to understand the rules of MLB and the consequences of breaking the rules. Also, the runner must "Slide or Avoide Collision" they're not permitted to Pete Rose themselves into the Catcher like they used to be able to do.
@TheUnknown1709
@TheUnknown1709 6 лет назад
New rule on home-plate collisions put into effect 7.13, intended to increase player safety by eliminating "egregious" collisions at home plate was jointly announced by Major League Baseball and the Major League Baseball Players Association on Monday. 7.13.b.The catcher may not block the pathway of a runner attempting to score *unless* he has possession of the ball. c. Runners are not required to slide, and catchers in possession of the ball are allowed to block the plate. However, runners who do slide and catchers who provide the runner with a lane will never be found in violation of the rule.
@larrywest538
@larrywest538 4 года назад
The catcher moved to his left 'in the base path' which did block it. He still could have moved left but in front of the base path ...
@coreyandnathanielchartier3749
@coreyandnathanielchartier3749 6 лет назад
"new york' is probably on the phone to Vegas.
@SRP3572
@SRP3572 4 года назад
And when it's the Yankees, they're on a conference call with Vegas and the Mafia
@austinjones7452
@austinjones7452 8 лет назад
The announcers are so biased it's not even funny
@MyMegaKid
@MyMegaKid 8 лет назад
these commentators talking like it's the end of the world "it's gonna change baseball forever" it's not that big of a deal
@user-gy7qx3sl4p
@user-gy7qx3sl4p 8 лет назад
they're a big fan
@onlyds0822
@onlyds0822 2 года назад
7:07 The announcer went from 1-10 “I FEEL LIKE DOING THE SAME THING!”
@superjagarloser3984
@superjagarloser3984 5 лет назад
The first one even if it was safe he didn’t touch the base
@MeecosMeh
@MeecosMeh 9 лет назад
This rule is fucking bullshit. Literally you have players running in crying that he was blocking the plate instead of fucking sliding.
@jannecechmanek
@jannecechmanek 9 лет назад
***** Well if you get rid of the rule, then the catcher would have simply been smashed by the runner.
@chrisb6900
@chrisb6900 9 лет назад
jannecechmanek Better home plate collisions then the catcher not allowed to try and tag the runner
@jannecechmanek
@jannecechmanek 9 лет назад
It's obvious you meant than.
@chrisb6900
@chrisb6900 9 лет назад
wtf are you talking about
@djmsong
@djmsong 9 лет назад
With the catcher where he was, the runner had three choices: 1 Slide and be blocked (a side would've potentially injured the runner too) 2 plow over the catcher to open up the way to the base (now illegal) or 3 make a case to the umpire that the catcher was in the way The runner did the right thing according to the newest rules. The catcher could have moved toward right field a step or two to open up the lane and make the tag with ease.
@tomada36
@tomada36 8 лет назад
In all of baseball history, this is the worst call? When did you start watching baseball, last year?
@keithdixon2300
@keithdixon2300 7 лет назад
It's top 3 tho
@fngaming5064
@fngaming5064 3 года назад
Keith Donaldo definitely not
@TechBrosGamingChannel
@TechBrosGamingChannel Год назад
I remember watching this game live on TV with my dad when I was young and us both freaking out about how horrible this call was. We aren't even fans of either team, we were just killing an afternoon watching a ballgame.
@KevFactor1966
@KevFactor1966 8 месяцев назад
What's bad is the runner never touched the home plate so why wasn't he out for that reason 🤔
@jimmyneutron2254
@jimmyneutron2254 5 лет назад
Anyone here after the 2018 postseason, full of *cough* *cough* great calls and umpires?
@LeagueBat
@LeagueBat 8 лет назад
Its just f'd up lol. Not the play but how many views this got. Thank you guys. Kappa.
@joelt7869
@joelt7869 8 лет назад
+Bear Udyr yea lol
@elvicare35
@elvicare35 8 лет назад
+Bear Udyr Is this your version of the misdirection play?
@cryzl1515
@cryzl1515 8 лет назад
he didn't even touch home plate
@thatchermain7274
@thatchermain7274 8 лет назад
+LowkeyXSpirit Exactly! So it wouldn't have mattered anyway.
@francobobfred
@francobobfred 8 лет назад
+LowkeyXTiger never read the rule book but I think obstruction automatically awards you the base you were going to even if you never touched it. But im not sure
@mixedreactions714
@mixedreactions714 9 лет назад
It is a bad rule but why are they so upset about him not sliding? He obviously knew he was going to be out so why potentially injure himself or the catcher when the rule says you are not supposed to run into the catcher and the catcher should stay out of the way?
@mrjimi1
@mrjimi1 9 лет назад
The rules say nothing about sliding into the catcher. As long as you are obviously attempting to get to the plate, you can do more or less whatever you want.
@kaylacorcelli9703
@kaylacorcelli9703 9 лет назад
***** that was legendary. hahahhahahha
@joshkaplinger1382
@joshkaplinger1382 9 лет назад
I believe the runner ran around him to try to convince the umpire that the catcher was blocking the plate and that he should be safe. If he slid, it would look like he wasn't blocking the plate, and since the throw would have been a lot earlier than the slide, he would've easily been out.
@SpartanR
@SpartanR 9 лет назад
***** Again, there is NO rule that you must slide. If you're going to spam this page with garbage and lies you're going to hear from me on every post. I repeat, there is NO rule that says you must slide...EVER!! Go read the rules.
@10000bambam
@10000bambam 9 лет назад
Dude. There may not be a rule saying you have to slide. But anybody who has ever played baseball at any level knows that's how you play the game. He knew exactly what he was doing, I mean he practically through his arms up before Mathis even tagged him. I'm not gonna jump on the umpires for making a bad call. It's a new rule , calls like this happen but if you are gonna play baseball play it how it's supposed to be played.
@dennisfalan1623
@dennisfalan1623 6 лет назад
They're ruining all sports
@brianlewis4063
@brianlewis4063 5 лет назад
Please rename video, "Worst Announcer in MLB History"
@claudev6708
@claudev6708 5 лет назад
I agree. He must be a home fan...
@lilpity
@lilpity 5 лет назад
ok he had no lane to slide because the catcher had to move to the 3rd base side of home plate cause if he didnt move, what would happen? he wont catch it, so you get some baseball* iq.
@matthewplotnick750
@matthewplotnick750 5 лет назад
Brian Lewis If it were my team, I would be saying the same types of things. That was an awful call
@andyshepard4309
@andyshepard4309 5 лет назад
That fumblin Dublin needs to just shut up
@e2go
@e2go 4 года назад
Then you don't know dog sh*t about baseball, fool.
@johnthemonsterjamdude2534
@johnthemonsterjamdude2534 9 лет назад
I honestly hate this fuck!ng rule it just messes up the sport! Cosart barely gave effort to slide. Mathis barley blocked the plate. At that moment I would love to be Redmond. 😡😡😬😬 even if your a reds fan you can admit it was an out and credit to Stanton. One of the reasons the Marlins don't have the luck they deserve. I hope this doesn't happen. Screw that rule!! If they remove it, life would be better. Anybody agree??
@seanbrower6738
@seanbrower6738 9 лет назад
I agree 100%! Why can't it just be the umpires officiating the game doing what they did, when it was just a fair/foul home run situation?
@johnthemonsterjamdude2534
@johnthemonsterjamdude2534 9 лет назад
Sean Brower yeah they should bring the classics back otherwise what's the point of being an umpire
@seanbrower6738
@seanbrower6738 9 лет назад
JohnTheMonsterJamDude 25 What do you mean by the classics?
@johnthemonsterjamdude2534
@johnthemonsterjamdude2534 9 лет назад
Sean Brower what I mean by classics is the an umpire makes one call wetter out or safe
@seanbrower6738
@seanbrower6738 9 лет назад
JohnTheMonsterJamDude 25 Ah ok. So we agree.
@oldhamegg
@oldhamegg 9 лет назад
I like how the announcer is crying...."He should have slid, He's not a pro...A Man would slide there...Whaaa Whaaa Whaaa."
@Wolf-sd8fr
@Wolf-sd8fr 9 лет назад
Oldstuff Man no he said he didn't even slide to show that he was trying to get a challenge about it, he said," hes trying to play the challenge game."
@TheSubmissionChannel
@TheSubmissionChannel 9 лет назад
hunter yognaut What's the challenge game? And, whatever it is, he won. Another run on his baseball statistics record. Suck it ....
@Wolf-sd8fr
@Wolf-sd8fr 9 лет назад
TheSubmissionChannel well its a made up name that the announcers came up with and also, he did win the challenge, but thats very shallow for a mlb player to do that.
@SonVegeta23
@SonVegeta23 9 лет назад
Like the rule says he has to be in possession of the ball, but he wasn't in possession, therefore he is safe
@hexoson
@hexoson 9 лет назад
+Carlos Colon You're a special kind of dumb, aren't you?
@TheRomundus
@TheRomundus 5 лет назад
Don Denkinger calling Jorge Orta safe at first in Game 6 of the 1985 WS will forever be the worst call ever.
@songmanl1480
@songmanl1480 6 лет назад
This should have been a 60-second video LOL
@tampabayproductions7934
@tampabayproductions7934 6 лет назад
That commentator was so triggered lol
@MrMdrscream
@MrMdrscream 9 лет назад
Catcher was in the path BEFORE having possession. And CLEARLY could have received the ball OUTSIDE of the path as well. Seems like a good call to me.
@matthewhermes8839
@matthewhermes8839 9 лет назад
The dude wasn't anywhere close yet, so, when he did get close, guess what? The catcher had possession of the ball. By the way, I'm not a Marlins or reds fans, go Astros!(even though they lose every season 😔)
@MrMdrscream
@MrMdrscream 9 лет назад
Matthew Hermes Is there going to be a rule of about how close the runner has to be in feet or seconds before you can be in the base/plate line without possession of the ball? (Even this would not be legit since some players are extremely faster than other players. When are you going to rule it OK or not?) My points are VERY clear... He WAS in the base/plate line BEFORE he had possession of the ball. He WAS FULLY capable of retrieving the ball OUTSIDE of the base line as well. (He had plenty of time to move outside the base/plate line to make the play on the ball WITHOUT being within the base/plate line.) He waited WITHIN the base/plate line for the ball to come to him. Which was NOT necessary to make the play. So, I agree with NY... Make the plays OUTSIDE of the base/plate line and then come WITHIN ONLY with possession of the ball. Then there is NOTHING to argue about. With the new rules catchers are going to have to be more proactive and not lazy waiting on the ball within the base/plate line. It's that simple... :-) P.S. The rule is there to protect the catcher as much as the runner. So they will have to adapt to the new rules and learn to make plays outside of the base/plate line UNTIL they have possession of the ball. Again, I agree with NY. They made the right call. If the runner was only a second or two earlier. The runner would have had no choice but to run into the catcher. (So, he was putting himself and the runner at risk.) If you watch closely. The catcher makes 2 steps from the plate to be in a better position to retrieve the ball. He was FULLY capable of taking 2 more steps infield or outside of the field to be OUTSIDE of the base/plate line to get possession of the ball. He FAILED to do so. So, again, that's why I agree with NY... On another note. The worst call in MLB was when the referee took away that guys Perfect Game at first base. (The guy was out by a mile.) This is no where near the worst call in MLB.
@matthewhermes8839
@matthewhermes8839 9 лет назад
Just giving my opinion
@ricardovivas7686
@ricardovivas7686 9 лет назад
It was a bad call . I'm a Marlins but I respect your opinion.
@knzboii
@knzboii 9 лет назад
Matthew Hermes No matter where the guy is he can't block the plate until after getting the ball, the issue is that he could have fielded the ball out of the way before moving into it but didn't so he violated the rule.
@trickshotrory5960
@trickshotrory5960 5 лет назад
I ALSO FEEL LIKE DOING THE SAME THING!!!
@Excitavit_Unum
@Excitavit_Unum 5 лет назад
This isn't even close to the Don Dekinger call that cost the Cardinals the world series where the guy was out by a full step
@joybarnes4253
@joybarnes4253 5 лет назад
Yep. Denkinger
@matthorowitz1861
@matthorowitz1861 5 лет назад
Omg you’re right - that was the worst call in MLB history and I’m not even a Card’s fan. Worse yet the other umpires didn’t overrule the call
@joshuafuller9898
@joshuafuller9898 5 лет назад
It was a shitty call, but they Royals would have won that game anyway. The Cards hit, like, .157 in that series. 33 years later and they're still butthurt in St. Louis. The 7th game was hilarious.
@LilTaco-_-
@LilTaco-_- 6 лет назад
Geez, the announcer had quite the opinion on that...
@CapnCook-mr6yc
@CapnCook-mr6yc 6 лет назад
FlamingTaco Thank you I highly agree
@dannycurtis2591
@dannycurtis2591 6 лет назад
Flaming Taco I agree! Who IS this guy, anyway?
@gmcwest2267
@gmcwest2267 6 лет назад
Danny Curtis He’s 100% right though. Passionate about the game and that was the worst call in history
@ytbraydenhiles6983
@ytbraydenhiles6983 6 лет назад
FlamingTaco I know I hat them
@bipbong2906
@bipbong2906 6 лет назад
Brayden Bernhardt Welcome to the pussified present that we live in, where being passionate about the game “should get you fired”. What the hell is wrong with you? “Mad because he never made it to the majors” yeah, and I bet you’re mad that you never made it out of high school, you dumbass. Go back to the drive-thru window at McDonalds.
@alanhicks5729
@alanhicks5729 8 лет назад
This is a good example of getting a play right after review.
@johnbishop6890
@johnbishop6890 3 года назад
Almost as bad as the infamous “infield fly” call against the Braves in the playoffs when the ball was caught clearly in left field, not the infield. Cost the Braves the game
@jimhart7242
@jimhart7242 3 года назад
Here's the infield fly rule. An Infield Fly is a fair fly ball (not a line drive or bunt) that, in the judgment of the umpire, can be caught by an infielder, pitcher, or catcher with ordinary effort and when there are runners on first and second or first, second, and third and less than two outs. Notice it doesn't say 'caught in the infield', it says 'caught by an infielder.' They call it on balls in the shallow outfield all the time.
@senator558
@senator558 3 года назад
Or the play where Kent Hrbek lifted Ronny Grant off the bag and they called him out.
@alanhess9306
@alanhess9306 2 года назад
John Bishop. Wrong answer. The infield fly call was 100% the correct call. Show us where the rule says the ball must be caught in the infield. You should learn the rules before commenting. The play did not cost the Braves the game either.
@nateboy1489
@nateboy1489 2 года назад
Was it "ordinary" that an infielder was playing that deep into the outfield? Sounds like you're a Cardinals fan, my dude. That doesn't seem "ordinary" to me.
@jimdep6542
@jimdep6542 5 лет назад
That call was total crap. Who made this decision in New York....Deblasio and Chuck Schumer ?
@LeagueBat
@LeagueBat 9 лет назад
One final thought, the ball takes the catcher into the pathway of the runner, what is he supposed to do? Not move, not catch the ball, and let 2 runs score? In addition, the runner was out by a mile, it wasn't even close.
@LeviStutzman
@LeviStutzman 9 лет назад
Bear Udyr I think the issue was that he just sat down after he caught the ball.
@knzboii
@knzboii 9 лет назад
Bear Udyr He is allowed to catch it in the line if he has too BUT if he could have caught it out of the way then he is at fault. This is an instance where it looks like he should be able to step up and field the ball without blocking the plate. That is what the ump saw. Right call.
@J4zzyDrummer
@J4zzyDrummer 9 лет назад
knzboii Fuck you... this isn't teeball it's the fucking MLB. They should be able to do what it takes to make the play, this was a ridiculous call...
@kadrianstahley1241
@kadrianstahley1241 9 лет назад
Tyler599xx tyler, you are an idiot.
@Swordsfor200Alex
@Swordsfor200Alex 9 лет назад
Kaden Stahley I can tell you before the play is reviewed that the catcher blocked the plate - illegal now with the new rules.
@paulmuzzy3414
@paulmuzzy3414 6 лет назад
This could've been a 1 min video...
@AdamWasHere
@AdamWasHere 6 лет назад
Uploader probably doesn’t know how to edit.
@therealdoge7594
@therealdoge7594 6 лет назад
This shouldn’t have been a video, unless they are showing like top 10 throws home
@mattdelacoma1025
@mattdelacoma1025 6 лет назад
But then you wouldn't get to hear the announcers make idiots of themselves. It wasn't the wrong call. They even put the graphic up and highlighted it. The catcher was blocking the plate without the ball. Pretty clear. If he wants to rant, he should do so about the rule. Not the call. The call was made correctly by rule
@harperandhenleysvlogswerco5276
Matt Delacoma yes the call was correct
@notpsychic
@notpsychic 6 лет назад
if they cut the middle part and only showed the "overturned" part
@airportchronicles199
@airportchronicles199 5 лет назад
I'm confused on this play, the runner never tried for home base, never touched it, the catcher tagged the runner clear as day, and finally the ump called the runner out....end of story or am I missing something....? Please help
@jasonparkes4008
@jasonparkes4008 5 лет назад
as a non baseball player looking from the outside.... the rules say the player cant block the path to a plate if he doesnt have the ball. the catcher didnt have the ball when he stepped across and blocked the path even though the runner was miles away. i think what they are trying to say is the catcher could've stepped forward to catch the ball and not block the path. just my interpretation of it anyway
@TampaJohn
@TampaJohn 3 года назад
“He should be out anyway! He didn’t even slide!” I must have missed that rule. The worst announcers in the game.
@doesnotexist305
@doesnotexist305 3 года назад
Missing the point my friend.
@TampaJohn
@TampaJohn 3 года назад
@@doesnotexist305 No......I’m actually not.
@chrismcgeshick5517
@chrismcgeshick5517 3 года назад
I do not recall this rule... where the hell was i at? Hmmm
@garfieldttr8238
@garfieldttr8238 3 года назад
If the runner cared about the rules, he would have avoided contact by sliding. He is a hypocrite for not doing so and then complaining the catcher was blocking the plate.
@JayitInc
@JayitInc 9 лет назад
I am an umpire myself and he should be out. I don't however blame the umpires on the field. In fact they called him out! It was the umpires reviewing the play in New York that called it safe. The umps of the field had to go with that decision. So to the Marlins coach, you have the right to be be pissed off, just not at those umps on the field.
@zeroeffects88
@zeroeffects88 9 лет назад
Those two dozen fans in Miami are VERRRRY ANGRY.
@rowdycmoore
@rowdycmoore 3 года назад
I'll still say the worst call was in a 1998 game between the Yankees and Orioles at The Stadium. Yankees were up by 1 in the 9th but Orioles got first two batters on. Next batter tried to bunt them over but bunted right back to Rivera on the mound, who threw to get the lead runner at third. Brosius at 3B CLEARLY closed his glove too soon and the ball bounced OFF his glove... and the 3B ump, standing BEHIND Brosius, called the runner OUT. Then he ejected every single person on the Orioles who argued, and refused to check with the crew chief who was working 1B and had a better view. He makes the right call, Orioles have bases loaded and the tying run at third with no out. Instead it's now 1st and 2nd with one out... and the next batter grounds into a double play to end the game. Absolutely horrible.
@schelbboy22
@schelbboy22 10 лет назад
The reason this is the right call is because he purposefully moved into the path of the baseline when he squared up. he could have caught it out of the baseline just fine. He moved into the path and didn't give Cozart any of the plate. These announcers are so biased. He had to go that way to get the ball but not into that path of the baseline. Safe! Right call whether they like it or not.
@LeagueBat
@LeagueBat 10 лет назад
I'm not gonna argue with you or anyone anymore, if you are out by 10 feet, you are OUT, the catcher has the ball WAY before you get there.
@schelbboy22
@schelbboy22 10 лет назад
Rex Iustus but its a new rule so you're wrong. he blocked the plate before he went to get the throw. new rule states that that is not allowed. old rules you're right. new rules not so much. he couldn't slide because there was nothing to slide into cuz the catcher was blocking it. by no means it it right. but it was the correct call
@coconutsmasher
@coconutsmasher 10 лет назад
Agree to disagree.
@ryankeough7010
@ryankeough7010 9 лет назад
***** Actually -- and factually -- you are wrong. The catcher is ALLOWED to go into the baseline to catch the ball. AKA the catcher can go into the baseline if the throw takes him into the baseline. The throw took him up the line -- AND he was still out by 10 feet -- he's out. You are factually wrong Andrew.
@schelbboy22
@schelbboy22 9 лет назад
Ryan Keough FACTUALLY SPEAKING.....he was blocking the plate before he got the ball. the throw did not take him into the line. he was already blocking the plate before he went into the baseline even more for the throw. FACTUALLY SPEAKING he is safe. The marlins radio is basing on him not sliding and that he did should be out. that wheat everyone else is saying too. he doesnt have to slide if the plate is blocked and guess what it was. you are wrong... this call was right.
@guadaluperodriguez4216
@guadaluperodriguez4216 7 лет назад
3 years later and the game hasn't really changed because of this play.
@qwilliams1539
@qwilliams1539 6 лет назад
You call that padding armor? How dense are you? Those pads only reduce impact from a foul tip, they are utterly worthless when a full grown man hits you running full speed. They are not football pads. You want to see people tackling each other, stick to football.
@PaMartin123
@PaMartin123 6 лет назад
YOUR COMMENT IS REPORTED
@PaMartin123
@PaMartin123 6 лет назад
Black Mamba The Umpires will come to get you.
@randallrichnow6648
@randallrichnow6648 6 лет назад
Guadalupe Rodriguez that's how we know the league knows it was a BAD call.
@joeproderick7778
@joeproderick7778 6 лет назад
Two shit teams
@sentientmlem727
@sentientmlem727 2 месяца назад
The worst call of all time took place in Detroit in June of 2010 when Jim Joyce called the runner safe despite the ball reaching the glove of the first baseman a week and a half before the runner reached the bag.
@noellaoreilly1716
@noellaoreilly1716 5 лет назад
Hr acted like the plate was his mother 😂😂😂😂😂
@kimcafran-lilien8515
@kimcafran-lilien8515 9 лет назад
I honestly think this whole "replay" thing shouldn't be used for everything. Cozart is out. Man I wish MLB would bring back the collision rule. So dumb how you can't knock into the catcher. I think this replay thing should just be used for calling home runs and tagging players.
@sammacfarland3165
@sammacfarland3165 9 лет назад
The most amount if challenges there can be is 4, and I don't event think that has ever happened. Therefore, the challenges are useful and they aren't used that often.
@seanvanzummy5468
@seanvanzummy5468 9 лет назад
The rule of running into the catcher is to protect the catchers
@reavesmo8060
@reavesmo8060 9 лет назад
Kim Cafran-Lilien Does it maintain the purity of the game if the Buster Posey, Mauer, or any other catcher that hits well is moved to another base because teams are afraid of them getting injured? Posey already had a broken leg from a collision before the rule came in effect. I mean, I think if we have coaches refusing to send runners because they're afraid a catcher might block the plate dangerously well and if we have teams not putting the best catchers at catcher, that's a pretty big hit to the integrity of the game. We've already diluted the regular season down quite a bit, to the point that fans of good teams pretty much figure, "Oh well, it's just April" when their team loses early on. Honestly, if I was managing a team with a superstar catcher and the collision rules were eliminated right now, I'd tell him not to block the plate off. It's April. Why lose him for the rest of the year just to get an extra out at the plate here and there?
@rogertrew
@rogertrew 9 лет назад
Kim Cafran-Lilien Blocking the plate didn't help Ray Fosse in an All Star game when Pete Rose bowled him over.
@bigman7293
@bigman7293 9 лет назад
You are smart everyone else is retarded smart man
@ethanbates7734
@ethanbates7734 6 лет назад
Imagine having to listen to this announcer every night my god I would switch teams
@Jivvi
@Jivvi 6 лет назад
Just watch the other team's broadcast. 😂
@Troy24768
@Troy24768 6 лет назад
Ethan Bates I am a reds fan and marlins fan I’m lucky I don’t live in Miami and have to listen to this guy
@George50809
@George50809 6 лет назад
Well, he had time to fill, but I think he was a little too emotional.
@Marvinthecoinhunter
@Marvinthecoinhunter 6 лет назад
I think it’s funny
@samsterling1462
@samsterling1462 6 лет назад
no kidding, what a cry baby bitch.
@ambrosesantinac3196
@ambrosesantinac3196 3 года назад
Why was that one commentator so pissed😂😂
@robmorrison1043
@robmorrison1043 3 года назад
They should have checked with Angel Hernandez, his calls are always spot on!
@jonb2911
@jonb2911 3 года назад
Lmao
@knightsareamazing1564
@knightsareamazing1564 3 года назад
@Paul Kostiak You’re missing the point
@easypickens13
@easypickens13 8 лет назад
Comments be like "He should be out because he didn't touch home" or "he should be safe because he wasn't given a lane" or "I hate those announcers"
@juanquiroz9990
@juanquiroz9990 8 лет назад
he is out the catcher moved for the ball and he had ball in hand so he can do anything he wants to tag
@owenb3962
@owenb3962 8 лет назад
+Bmill plays Nobody is worse than Hawk Harrelson
@rxpro19
@rxpro19 8 лет назад
those are the marlins announcers....the guy yelling was tommy hutton
@GreenDay1981
@GreenDay1981 8 лет назад
+juan quiroz Learn the rules. Pause it at 1:25. The catcher's left leg is in the basepath and the ball is nowhere near him. That's interference. The catcher cannot move into the basepath until he has the ball. Not 1 second before. Not 1/10th of a second before.
@JimWhitakerMusic
@JimWhitakerMusic 8 лет назад
These are the Marlins announcers
@MLBHighlights2012
@MLBHighlights2012 9 лет назад
I don't like either team, but that's an awful call. Blocking the plate or not, with the ball beating cozart to the plate by that much, it shouldn't even be a discussion to whether he's out or not. He could be out by 80 feet, but if you think the catcher was in front of the plate and blocking it, what are you gonna do, call him safe? This game has been around for 150 years. Stop changing it.
@bobbackwards18
@bobbackwards18 9 лет назад
That has to be one of the best analogies I've read, hands down. Call on the diamond should not have been reversed for the simple fact that the runner would have been out no matter what, and it looks like (in my opinion) that the runner had a lane to the plate anyways. Bad call. Coming from a Jays fan
@Stangil1
@Stangil1 9 лет назад
***** He also never touched the plate.
@cinci4life116
@cinci4life116 9 лет назад
Jett Lennox Like i said in a post above, i don't like this rule either but it was the right call by the rule. The moment he stepped over the 3rd base line without the ball he was in violation of that rule. And saying he would be out no matter what is stupid because if it was still legal to run over the catcher, i'm sure he would have and possibly knocked the ball loose.
@bobbackwards18
@bobbackwards18 9 лет назад
Okay yeah I see what you're saying. All I'm saying that if the catcher gave him the lane to the plate according to the rule, he would've had plenty of time to tag him, I just don't agree with the call. It's kind of like that interference call against the cardinals in the World Series two years ago. The ump projected that he would've been safe...here he could've projected him out. But I see what you're saying. Dumb rule no matter what haha
@TheAhursh
@TheAhursh 9 лет назад
Cinci4life ok but the rule is that if a throw takes the catcher up the line he can do whatever he wants with it
@harlembaseballhittingacade4998
@harlembaseballhittingacade4998 3 года назад
he sounds more pissed off that the runner didnt slide than if they got the call right
@djbeezy
@djbeezy 3 года назад
This is why they need to get rid of replay. This took waaaay to long.
@DietBIeach
@DietBIeach 6 лет назад
I'm no baseball fan, but aren't you supposed to touch Home Plate?
@AndyQ191
@AndyQ191 6 лет назад
Diet Bleach but the call was if it was abstruction, if the catcher was blocking the path of the runner so he had to swerve out of the way
@frankg9027
@frankg9027 6 лет назад
Diet Bleach yep
@frankg9027
@frankg9027 6 лет назад
andrew but he didn’t slide either so it’s hard to call
@MsTooncesthecat
@MsTooncesthecat 6 лет назад
Diet Bleach what would we do without you?
@paulnowak3100
@paulnowak3100 6 лет назад
Diet Bleach in
@KOSmadden
@KOSmadden 8 лет назад
these announcers are horrible
@pwnn00bzorz1
@pwnn00bzorz1 8 лет назад
yep
@paxtayer1355
@paxtayer1355 8 лет назад
Why?!?! Because they're loud and correct?
@PappyWoods
@PappyWoods 8 лет назад
+NeXa Gaming they were Marlins Announcers. :P
@baum6721
@baum6721 8 лет назад
Doesn't mean they weren't 100% correct. That call was completely wrong.
@kennyhundertpfund2283
@kennyhundertpfund2283 8 лет назад
No they're not. Everything they said was the truth
@richardlundberg1111
@richardlundberg1111 3 года назад
Just wondering, what if a runner on 3rd base tried to steal home, does the catcher have to move out of the way so the runner has a clear path?
@smasher.338
@smasher.338 6 лет назад
Horrible call. The catcher was in no way blocking the runner before possession. How can you block a runner who is 5 steps away? He did not change his pace or stride until well after the catcher had the ball, and he whined his way past the plate. The runners path was not obstructed until the catcher had the ball. Given the way this was called, now if a runner is still on third and a catcher crosses the baseline to catch a throw from the outfielder, he should get a free run because his "pathway was blocked". It was a ridiculous call, and that doesn't even take the fact he was moving to catch the ball.
@huskyfaninmass1042
@huskyfaninmass1042 6 лет назад
You can block a runner 5 steps away the same way if he is 1 step away, by standing in his pathway. It's a poorly written rule. It should say that the catcher can't impede the runner.
@joybarnes4253
@joybarnes4253 5 лет назад
Bad call man, bad f****** call.
@secondstring
@secondstring 5 лет назад
Smash Er - Dead on. The catcher HAD TO MOVE into the path of the runner to catch the thrown ball. Then, once he caught the ball, the runner was dead, not even close to home plate, so how in the hell was he ever "obstructed"? Answer: He wasn't. He was out and he knew it, just like everybody else in the ball park knew it. Those guys in New York making these judgments are so clueless, they've made a farce of replay review in MLB. They're fucking up the game.
@jmulchino
@jmulchino 5 лет назад
Oh, what a sucker I am for headlines! 1) Not the worst call by far, in baseball. 2) The announcer is a loud mouth. Calm down and watch the replay. 3) Runner was SAFE in my opinion. And I agree with New York. Catcher set up across the base path blocking it, independent of the throw. The runner was two strides away, a nanosecond from home plate, and the catcher still did not have possession of the ball. The catcher did not have to move into the base path to catch it. In the old days, the runner would have simply knocked the catcher over resulting in possible serious injury. The new rule was brought in to stop that. Parents who coach Little League are quite familiar with the rule. The announcer seems to display ignorance of the new rule.
@secondstring
@secondstring 5 лет назад
Mulchinock: "Catcher set up across the base path blocking it, independent of the throw." - WRONG on count #1 "The runner was two strides away, a nanosecond from home plate, and the catcher still did not have possession of the ball." - WRONG on count #2 "The catcher did not have to move into the base path to catch it". - And WRONG on count #3 Try again idiot.
@RomeoAlphaDelta
@RomeoAlphaDelta 7 лет назад
lolz at the announcers aneurysm. Homers. :)
@trevonburtch4014
@trevonburtch4014 6 лет назад
I don't blame him, call was terrible.
@hector3310
@hector3310 8 лет назад
Not agree. Worst call un MLB history was Jim Joyce in Armando Galarraga's Perfect Game. Was so easy and means damn a lot
@seanpavich3445
@seanpavich3445 8 лет назад
I agree!
@critter2
@critter2 8 лет назад
+H-Account oh for hte love of GOD DROP THE NONSENSE MOVE THE FUCK ON
@hector3310
@hector3310 8 лет назад
***** WTF dude?
@JerkyBoyBri
@JerkyBoyBri 8 лет назад
Yes, I agree on the Jim Joyce blown call being the worst in history. I also believe Joyce owning up to it, and Gallaraga bringing out the line up card to Joyce the very next day, who was the home plate umpire that game, were the greatest examples of sportsmanship in history.
@kennatiousc
@kennatiousc 8 лет назад
+H-Account or how bout when they took the home run away from george brett for having too much pine tar on his bat.
@davidmendez3659
@davidmendez3659 5 лет назад
"it'll be like T-ball pretty soon"😂
@josephanthony8585
@josephanthony8585 5 лет назад
Sometimes even the guys in New York can be blind.
@greasytony9727
@greasytony9727 3 года назад
Or have $$$$ on the game.
@trifecta9810
@trifecta9810 9 лет назад
be like T-ball pretty soon.
@ricardovivas7686
@ricardovivas7686 9 лет назад
Lol
@Flench339
@Flench339 9 лет назад
George Valkhoun HE DIDN'T EVEN SLIDE
@reindeergaming7990
@reindeergaming7990 9 лет назад
George Valkhoun yep this is getting ridiculous.
@A.C31
@A.C31 8 лет назад
The funny thing is Redmond throwing a fit at an ump in Florida, when the call came from New York!
@dLimboStick
@dLimboStick 8 лет назад
+Jeff Brown I'm not saying this is the way it is, but it seems to me the final responsibility for the call should be with the head ump on the field, not some committee back in NYC. So a team can ask for a call to be reviewed, and NYC can give their opinion to the ump on the field, but the ultimate decision should belong to the ump. If committees of umps in NYC are making calls on the field, then there is way more effed up with MLB than just this call.
@A.C31
@A.C31 8 лет назад
dLimboStick I agree but there is no way he's not going with what the replay officials in New York say. It would probably be his last game to ever umpire in the majors if he did that.
@dLimboStick
@dLimboStick 8 лет назад
Jeff Brown When he makes a call like that, it SHOULD be his last game ever as an umpire.
@A.C31
@A.C31 8 лет назад
dLimboStick Lol. So true! I honestly believe this, "bad call," is more of a bad rule of baseball, that stems from the Buster Posey injury and subsequent overreaction. Just like awful NFL rules that define whether certain plays are actual catches or not (think of the Megatron and Dez Bryant nullifications, etc.). Certain bad rules need to be changed and the refs and umps might not look so incompetent.
@jamestowmsn
@jamestowmsn 8 лет назад
+Jeff Brown Agreed!
@alcostello6114
@alcostello6114 6 лет назад
“If this call is changed it’s going to change a whole lot of baseball” no
@galactic_clashx4056
@galactic_clashx4056 4 года назад
No what?
@jamesray7413
@jamesray7413 4 года назад
It did tho
@galactic_clashx4056
@galactic_clashx4056 4 года назад
James Ray yeah
@banjohero1182
@banjohero1182 5 лет назад
"It'll be like Tee-ball pretty soon" ... haha, silly tv man! What do you think will happen, like they'll make an intentional walk automatic? That's crazy talk!
@greasytony9727
@greasytony9727 3 года назад
Lol. So true. MLB has caved into pressure from corporate giants, social justice warriors, and Marxist organizations. RIP MLB born 1869-killed 2020
@maxtovella8273
@maxtovella8273 8 лет назад
He didn't even touch home
@cameronshutwell7673
@cameronshutwell7673 8 лет назад
+Max Tovella i know
@counterstriving
@counterstriving 8 лет назад
+Max Tovella If the catcher is illegally (that is, without having the ball in his possession) blocking the plate then the runner is called safe automatically.
@angelodarden342
@angelodarden342 8 лет назад
+counterstriving " The Buster Posey Rule" 10 years ago there would have been a collision at the plate.
@Brammy007a
@Brammy007a 8 лет назад
+counterstriving You are not "blocking" the plate until the runner is in the immediate area. By the time the runner got to the immediate area the catcher had already received the ball in plenty of time. What the hell was the catcher supposed to do? If this is the way baseball is going to be ruled then the catcher would have no choice but to just get out of the way and let the runner score. This was in 2014..... has there been clarification since then?
@Brammy007a
@Brammy007a 8 лет назад
+Max Tovella >>>>> He didn't even touch home............... True, but once he gives up on the play and goes to the dugout he is out. I'm not even sure the tag was ever made for that matter. Totally horrible call.
@alexbarlow1614
@alexbarlow1614 8 лет назад
Totally not bias announcers or anything....
@A.C31
@A.C31 8 лет назад
They're Marlins' announcers so they are expected to be a little biased but still should be objective. I agree they went overboard.
@pookied.7738
@pookied.7738 8 лет назад
+Alex Barlow He was out tho. You could plainly see he was out. He didnt even touch home.
@Klote3241
@Klote3241 8 лет назад
+Pookie D. thats not even the issue they are ruling him safe because his walking path was obstructed by a player even tho he had the ball :/
@pookied.7738
@pookied.7738 8 лет назад
Uhh...thats what a catcher is supposed to do.
@Klote3241
@Klote3241 8 лет назад
Pookie D. not according to the new rules.:S
@pablopereira8711
@pablopereira8711 6 лет назад
I remember being at this game. Hated it.
@larrywest538
@larrywest538 4 года назад
The catcher blocked the plate before the ball got there...
@fatheroffab
@fatheroffab 9 лет назад
The runner is out. Cut and dry.
@Astrobrant2
@Astrobrant2 9 лет назад
Jim Hayes Apparently not.
@alexlalonde202
@alexlalonde202 8 лет назад
The announcer is HILARIOUS
@Pat597674
@Pat597674 5 лет назад
that was the best call in baseball that i have seen the catcher was indeed blocking the path great call
@senator558
@senator558 3 года назад
Nonsense. The rule states, “ *Unless the catcher is in possession of the ball* the catcher cannot block the pathway...”. And, “If, in the judgment of the umpire, the catcher *without possession of the ball* blocked the pathway of the runner...” If the catcher didn’t have possession of the ball then the umpires can apply this rule and you are right. Did the catcher have possession of the ball in this play?
@curtisjacobson7338
@curtisjacobson7338 3 года назад
You saw him slide over you catch the ball, did you expect him to back off so the guy can score?, there is alot of bad calls out there.
@tnwhiskey68
@tnwhiskey68 2 месяца назад
Looked like he was blocking the lane to me..
@Jm11101
@Jm11101 8 лет назад
To score a run, I though you actually had to touch the plate. Damn guess I'm wrong
@Jm11101
@Jm11101 8 лет назад
Thought*
@Silur
@Silur 8 лет назад
+Jqred He couldn't because the catcher was blocking it, at least that's the only thing I could think of
@johnburk2355
@johnburk2355 8 лет назад
If their is a obstruction call it doesn't matter if you touch plate or not
@adryningle5176
@adryningle5176 8 лет назад
It isn't obstruction if the ball is in front of the plate. The catcher had possession of the ball
@liamcringeworth525
@liamcringeworth525 7 лет назад
If obstruction is called, you're not required to touch it
@secondkyle8797
@secondkyle8797 8 лет назад
Why is this under review? Even if the catcher wasn't "blocking the plate," Zack Cozart didn't even touch homeplate LMAO..
@secondkyle8797
@secondkyle8797 8 лет назад
+SecondKyle Basically saying, he was out either way
@rindgeleaphart6494
@rindgeleaphart6494 8 лет назад
what do you mean? if the catcher wasn't blockingz then he's out. if he wasz which is what the umpires decided, then it's illegal and the runner is safe
@12033552
@12033552 8 лет назад
+SecondKyle i was thinking the same thing but the rule says that if the catcher is blocking the path the runner automatically gets the base, the dispute is not weather its safe or out its about the carcher blocking home plate which leads to if the rule applyes or not
@secondkyle8797
@secondkyle8797 8 лет назад
Rindge Leaphart No, he wasn't blocking the plate though, they explained that in the video. It was a clean call and Cozart never touched home plate anyway so he was out anyway.
@12033552
@12033552 8 лет назад
+SecondKyle of course, i agree he was not blocking home plate it shoud have been an out, but what happened is that becuase the humpires decided that he was blocking home plate the runner doesnt need to touch the base he just gets it thats why he scored wihout touching the base, its really simple to understand really
@OLDUSAFMedic
@OLDUSAFMedic 11 месяцев назад
This is amusing hearing the view from the Cincinnati announcers. It would be interesting to hear what Miami's announcer is saying about this at the same time.
@marcusmacdonald5277
@marcusmacdonald5277 2 месяца назад
This is the Marlins Announcers. Not the Reds.
@TheBboytwister
@TheBboytwister 4 года назад
What are the umpires listening to? The umpire manager? Lol
@carltonbanks6677
@carltonbanks6677 6 лет назад
*He DiDnT eVeN sLiDe*
@mattdelacoma1025
@mattdelacoma1025 6 лет назад
Carlton Hanks He didn't even (have to) slide
@emi9643
@emi9643 6 лет назад
thats what i was thinking, announcer kept talking about him sliding maybe making a difference here but you dont ever have to slide, its just an option
@happytappyslappy
@happytappyslappy 6 лет назад
POV: he didn’t touch home plate.
@MetalMaster49
@MetalMaster49 6 лет назад
So he did not slide. There is no rule that you have to slide on any base, so the announcer is wrong. That he should had been called out? Definitely.
@masonparis8423
@masonparis8423 6 лет назад
How’s he gonna slide with the catcher there lol? That’s feet first into the mans chest there. Catcher was in the way. Sorry about it but there’s many ways to make that play differently
Далее
Top 10 Outfield throws in MLB History
9:30
Просмотров 3,1 млн
Каха заблудился в горах
00:57
Просмотров 597 тыс.
MLB - Lack of Hustle
5:53
Просмотров 529 тыс.
MLB | Reckless Fans
8:59
Просмотров 3,8 млн
The WORST Umpire In Baseball History
6:56
Просмотров 2,4 млн
Best Triple Plays in MLB History!!
10:29
Просмотров 5 млн
MLB | Awful Umpiring | Part 2
17:40
Просмотров 4,8 млн
MLB | Oddities
15:15
Просмотров 23 млн
MLB Runners missing Bases
6:11
Просмотров 1,5 млн
Aaron Boone's 10 Best Ejections
9:27
Просмотров 121 тыс.
Top 10 Worst Calls In MLB History
10:40
Просмотров 2,5 млн
MLB Creative Plays
7:52
Просмотров 16 млн