Alan is in the wrong, it's Charlie's house, he can't just do whatever he wants... what sucks more is that at the end of the episode, Charlie was the one apologizing to Alan to come back (because their mom and teddy wouldn't leave the house lol) if this was real life, Alan would've been kicked to the curb... but ofc this is TV land and we need it for the plot
Isn’t real life sad if a brother kicked his own brother out...I don’t think I’d be able to kick my brother out. Plus it’s just a bowl lol people need to chill out
@@fayemckither3107 its a case to case basis and the bowl is a symbolism and the point of this scene/episode was that if alan wanted something, he should have told or asked permision from charlie out of respect
@@redozmasoma please Charlie didn’t even notice it was there until Alan pointed it out! It’s just Charlie being petty. But I agree with the asking first, since it is Charlie’s house...but Alan and Jake made it a home lol jk
If it was real life Charlie would not have slept with Judith sister, with Alan's lawyer, with Jake's teacher, things that contributed to the downfall of Alan's life
@@AveLukas42 well Charlie sleeping with Judith’s sister didn’t really affect the marriage just the relationship between Judith and her sister, Charlie only slept with the rest cause Allen’s marriage fell and he introduced those women to Charlie
@@BeautifulSpirit-kf5ld he didn't invite them, they asked him for a place to stay and even if he did invite them, they have to understand about boundaries the owner clearly set forward multiple times
@@dannysilva3210 I mean Charlie did say near the end of the episode that Alan was right about the marriage, that he (Charlie) actually got “cold feet,” and used Jake and Alan as an excuse to not marry Mia. Mia had brought up kicking out Alan and Jake and Charlie used that a cover for getting out, which Alan had accused him of.
Remember when Charlie hit it & quit it with Alans lawyer thus causing Alan to lose everything and did nothing to make up for it say getting a new lawyer and suing both Judith & the other lawyer?
@@sanzianagoglinache8696 Alan marrying Judith isn't the problem. The problem is that Alan, despite living there under Charlie's generosity without paying rent (inferred) and going so far as to skimp out on paying numerous times as shown in many episodes, will decide things to do with the house that he has zero right to. Charlie is the one who pays for the house, electricity, water, and entertainment. The most that Alan is able to do is minor things to the room he's given, and offer suggestions. The instant Charlie says no to those suggestions, Alan has to either accept it or find a way to convince him that the suggestions are worth implementing. Child-lock on the TV channels? Sensible, hence why Charlie presumably has them for Jake. That bowl? Charlie said no, but Alan decided to use wordplay to impose his way of things. Alan's failure of marriages has no bearing on this, it's his ego and minor sense of importance that, because he's Charlie's brother, he has a right in the house.
@@arjun9339 None of that would've happened if Alan hadn't married Judith in the first place. Everyone including Charlie and Evelyn tried to talk Alan out of marrying Judith but Alan claimed he saw things in Judith that no one else did. But honestly, Alan married her out of desperation as he does have a poor track record with women.
@@alexanderpytko5394 everyone marries when they see something in the spouse-to be. Chances of a marriage going south are pretty even. But one takes that plunge. Surely that move cannot be equated to messing with your (brother’s) divorce lawyer to the extent Charlie did ! To go by your illogical reasoning, Judith also married a hopeless person (Alan) whom she shouldn’t have, why then wasn’t she harmed from the divorce in the way Alan was ? Cause Charlie fcuked and dumped Alan’s lawyer and not Judith’s !
Charlie is more in the right than Alan was. Yes, Alan and Jake helped make it a bit more of a home than just a house. However Charlie took them in mainly because of his love for Jake, his nephew more than his brother. His brother, Alan did become a freeloader as time passed. It’s sad. Thanks for uploading.
I mean yes Alan has a somewhat repulsive personality, but he moved in because of his alimony fees which is due to Charlie fucking the lawyer and she held a grudge big enough to sabotage the divorce settlement. So in a way Charlie do have at least some responsibility if not most of it.
Alan's life was messed up and he realized it. Charlie's life was messed up and he was in denial about it. People always argue about who was right and who was wrong. They were both messed up......
The way I see it; Alan is wrong for the right reasons (you can’t just bring shit into someone else’s house without consulting them) and Charlie is right for the wrong reasons (acting childishly angry over a simple bowl instead of being upfront and honest with Alan).
Alan was not wrong. He was living there now for years, and he is not even allowed to set a bowl on the table? Charlie is an asshole here. Everything Alan said was right.
They always repeat girls. Walden's exwife is Herb's sister. Also Walden dated a girl who wanted to be a fashion designer (when he pretended to be Sam), but Charlie dated the girl seasons earlier.
I used to think Charlie was a bastard and Alan cannot catch a break. While that is somewhat true, Alan was in the wrong. He is an ungrateful freeloader with bad social skills. Charlie let Alan stay unconditionally and that in my books is a great brother. I know that feeling first feeling.
Alan is a huge freeloader and Charlie should have thrown Alan out after six weeks. I had a similar issue with a friend, tried helping him out and had to throw him out.
Never help anyone, the revenge will be brutal and they will never be able to respect you again. To use a very true and accurate example from a sitcom - when Penny borrowed money from Sheldon she was always annoyed at him, the difference in real life is that it never stops.
The only thing alan wanted was to have something that belongs to him so he would feel like he belongs in the house more..... The fact that all the comments agree with Charlie and say that he should have kicked him out is just sad coz I can't believe someone would treat their family like that kept alone sibling
I guess Jake wasn't enough for him. No, he also has to invite strangers in without asking Charlie and to add insult to injury he nearly burns the house down like Lindsay's house and still doesn't pay rent. Seriously, would you take that off of someone related to you?
@Samí Warrior Some people pulled some kind of Twisted scam and I was told that I need to talk to the FBI and I keep seeing weird stuff happen and more stuff making sense and I really need to talk to someone
I see your point. Although I sympathize with Charlie, it's his home and Alan can not come to do whatever he wants, Alan does not pay rent or help with the expenses of the house (from what I can see). Charlie might be a little rude, but still, it's his home.
@@exodustimes4266 Yeah but to be fair, Charlie wouldn't really be complaining that Alan's staying with him if he hadn't have slept with and dumped Alan's lawyer...
Breaking the bowl might have been uncalled for but it’s his house still. If he doesn’t like it, he doesn’t have to tolerate it. Alan is an ungrateful drama queen who seriously lacks perspective on what his brother had been willing to put up with for him.
@@dez3540 Alan got a new lawyer and scrapped the agreement. Alan as finding out about the affair should have screwed the lawyer over for her unprofessionalism. Alan’s real issue was his lack of confidence and spine, not putting his foot down with Judith
Me biggest fan never liked or understand this Skitt.its i taught they were depleated an ran out of ideas.this is y som (big ones) Grumble an hav issues wit the script--writer i would lable it as Dumb time-space fillings..spoiled my St.coom wit garbage..up to this day i sayin Go-figure..wat sence did it make10yrs ago i still fumin as it showed up
