Thanks to Mannar kudumbam. Excellent interview. We miss the great Mellisai Mannar MSV. We salute you Sir. Given so many wonderful and evergreen songs Sir. அதற்க்கெல்லாம், நாங்கள் அடிமை அய்யா. இசைக்கு கடவுள் கொடுத்த கொடை மெல்லிசை மன்னர். நம் இந்திய அரசு, தேசிய விருது வழங்கி கௌரவிக்காதது ஒரு பெரிய வருத்தமே. அவருடைய இசையில் பாடியவர்கள் விருது பெற்று இருக்கிறார்கள் என்றால் அதற்கு அவரின் இசைதான் முக்கிய காரணம். அதை யாராலும் மறுக்க முடியாது.
am not a critic of music, as I don't have even the basic knowledge on music ; rather I don't deserve to comment on the compositions of MSV; but neither I am a fan of any of the Music Directors , but has been a regular listener of great Global Music -of Baroque, Classical, Disco, Country, Waltz, heavy metal and Pop music. Most of the directors of Tamil, Hindi film industry of yester years and the present day including Ilaiayaraja and AR Rahman lift the tunes / beats from the albums of the geniuses like Jim Croce, Antonyn Dvorac- New World Symphoney-- Allan Jackson and such other legends; but the tunes/ beats of MSV are still unique and could not be imitated; the present generation should listen to extensive genres of music to have the feel of uniqueness of the Cre
Krishnan Saikumar Watch the full interview. He didnt anything against Ilayaraja, why u r using the word 'Naaye'? That's why u r fan for Isai boani Ilayaraja
M.S.V the Original Real Maestro, unique, perfectionist, ultimate Music Director of the universe. Fans of all other music directors listern the at least 1000 songs by (only by M.S.V , not with TKR) and criticise M.S.V. See Aayiraththil oruvan M.G.R film for the background music of the full film. The great music director Raveendran, Singer P.Jayachandran commented M.S.V the topmost, pioneer and Greatest university of Music
I can associate with YGM AS I am also a diehard fan of msv sivaji and tms Ivangallam greatest nu puriyuthu... Aana eppadinnu akkuveru aanivera therivikka YGM pondravargal vendum Hope YGM make more such interviews and programs for us to enjoy the nuances of mannars music
This program of ygm might turn out to be a monumental and unerasable program of mannar kudumbam. The anchoring presence of lalitha mam and a thoughtful camera work of babujee sir have given flavour to the episode. If there is one person who has got the stuff to go deep into msv work its YGM only. Not because he's a great fan of msv. But he has the enough technical and aesthetic knowledge on music, instruments, expressions of singers and cinematic situations of the songs . He was at the plum stage (mid 60s) when a great transition was ushered into tamil film music in particular and indian film music in general, by msv. Being a "live" theatre personality , ygm knows exactly what an ordinary rasigan and elite rasigan would expect from the drama. So he was able to visualise msv at ripe age both as an ordinary rasigan and as an elite music lover . So, his views on msv and tfm , carry extra wide angles and taste buds of representing a generation as a whole. Its a triple tamaakka that he has similar knowledge bank on kannadasan and NT sivaji ganesan. Msv was the common factor for this trio and msv, vaalee,mgr trio. None in the world music would run parallel to msv's music travel ,as pointed out by ygm as.....either before or after msv. The nuances of msv was clearly pointed out in each word of ygm. It was a big disappointment that he couldn't dwell upon the work of mid 50s msv, although he was able to explain the domain dominated by great GR and KVM mama. But we need a minimum 3 hour detailed episode with ygm to understand msv music to satiate our expectations on msv and to hear that from "a horse's" mouth. A sumptuous meal overall. Its not that easy to interview a free flowing, thoughtful and tasteful outpouring person like ygm. But our subhadra mam has carved a niche for herself in this episode too as does she with every other program of mk... Doesn't she ?. May be, this is why she is so indispensable in the mk group. Thanks everyone.💐💐💐💐
இசையின் ஆதாரஸ்ருதி ஐயா msv அவர்களின் பின்னனி இசை பற்றிய தகவல்கள்,அவர் விசிலை பாடல்களிள் பயன்படுத்திய விதம்,மற்றும் கதை கதையாம் காரணம் படத்தின் கம்போசிங் பற்றிய தங்களின் விளக்கங்கள் மிகவும் அருமை. நிறைய msv ரசிகர்கள் இளையராஜா மேல் வைக்கும் விமர்சனத்திற்கு அருமையான விளக்கம் கொடுத்து இருந்தார். இப்படி ஒரு அருமையான பேட்டியை நமக்கு கொடுத்த சுபத்ரா அம்மா,லலிதா அம்மா,பாபுஜீ சார் அனைவருக்கும் நன்றி
ஜி.ராமநாதனுக்கடுத்து சினிமா இசையில் ஏற்பட்ட சிறு மாற்றத்தை கே.வி.மகாதேவன் வழியாக விஸ்வநாதன் மேலும் வெஸ்ட்டர்ன் சாயல் கலந்து மெருகேற்றினார் என ஒய்.ஜி.கூறியிருக்கவேண்டும்!
Excellent interview. It shows YGM's deep love for MSV. I have seen & heard many times his whistling too. In the interview he has spoken about the interview he did with MSV in salem. Is this available in RU-vid?
am not a critic of music, as I don't have even the basic knowledge on music ; rather I don't deserve to comment on the compositions of MSV; but neither I am a fan of any of the Music Directors , but has been a regular listener of great Global Music -of Baroque, Classical, Disco, Country, Waltz, heavy metal and Pop music. Most of the directors of Tamil, Hindi film industry of yester years and the present day including Ilaiayaraja and AR Rahman lift the tunes / beats from the albums of the geniuses like Jim Croce, Antonyn Dvorac- New World Symphoney-- Allan Jackson and such other legends; but the tunes/ beats of MSV are still unique and could not be imitated; the present generation should listen to extensive genres of music to have the feel of uniqueness of the Cre
MSV's music was great. But nothing can match Viswanathan - Ramamoorthy music. I have heard thousands of songs by various musicians in tamizh and hindi cinema. Viswanathan Ramamoorthy music was the best.
Dear Brother & friend , all Viswanathan Ramamurthy songs and all MSV Ilayaraja songs ( except குழலூதும் கண்ணனுக்கு) are tuned by Mellisai Mannar MSV alone.
கண்ணதாசன் பாடலுக்கு, எம் எஸ் வி இசைக்கு, சிவாஜி நடிப்புகளுக்கு மிகவும் பக்கபலமாக இருந்த ஐயா உலகக்குரல் இறைவன் டி எம் எஸ் அவர்களை சொல்லாமல் என்ன இரசிகனோ ?? திரை உலகில் முதலாவதாக நான் இரசிப்பது டி எம் சௌந்தரராஜன் குரல் அதன் பின்னரே எம்ஜிஆர் சிவாஜி மற்று யாவரும் . இசையால் திரையுலகை எழுப்பியவர்கள் - ஜி . இராமநாதன் - கே வி எம் - எம் எஸ் வி மற்றும் அக்காலத்து இசையமைப்பாளர்கள் யாவரும்.
Very interesting anecdote about singers not able to reproduce what MSV could do. Sachinda was reportedly like that. He was such good singer, Dev Anand said once only Lataji could do what he wanted. Rafi once forced himself to record several takes of one song just to try get the way SDB could easily do. Finally he couldn't and Burmanda said he's happy and stopped it.
I am not a critic of music, as I don't have even the basic knowledge on music ; rather I don't deserve to comment on the compositions of MSV; but neither I am a fan of any of the Music Directors , but has been a regular listener of great Global Music -of Baroque, Classical, Disco, Country, Waltz, heavy metal and Pop music. Most of the directors of Tamil, Hindi film industry of yester years and the present day including Ilaiayaraja and AR Rahman lift the tunes / beats from the albums of the geniuses like Jim Croce, Antonyn Dvorac- New World Symphoney-- Allan Jackson and such other legends; but the tunes/ beats of MSV are still unique and could not be imitated; the present generation should listen to extensive genres of music to have the feel of uniqueness of the Creativity of MSV.
YG அண்ணா, நானசிறு வயதிலிருந்தே் உங்களின் ரசிகன்.எனது பதின்மூன்று வயதுகளில1975,76்களில் ரேடியோவில் அந்தாக்ஷரியில் உங்களிடம் lr.ஈஸ்வரி பற்றி கேட்டபோது அவர் வேறு நாட்டில் பிறந்திருந்தால் பெரிய pop singer ஆகியிருப்பார் என்று பதில் சொன்னீர்கள். அதே போல் 1986ல் தூர் தர்ஷனில் "பல்லெல்லாம் மேனேஜர் பல்லாகுமா," மலர்ந்தும் மலராத பாட்டை லூஸ் மோகன் போல பாடியது எல்லாம் இன்றும் என் நினைவில் இருக்கிறது. திரைபடங்களில் light ஆக double meaning joke அடிப்பீர்கள் அதையும் அந்த வயதில் மிகவும் ரசிப்பேன். ஆனால் உங்கள் மேல் ஒரு சின்ன வருத்தமும் உண்டு. சில வருடங்களுக்கு முன்பு ஜேசுதாஸ் படு கேவலமாக மலையாள musicians வைத்து தமிழ் பாடல் களை கொலை செய்த போது compiar செய்த (இசை கலைஞரான) நீங்க அதை ஆஹா என்று ஏன் புகழ்ந்தீர்கள் இன்று வரை விளங்கவில்லை. இந்த பேட்டியும் நன்றாக இருந்தது. என்ன கொஞ்சம் ராஜாவை மட்டம் தட்டுவது போல் உணர்ந்தேன். அது உங்கள் கருத்து. நன்றி அண்ணா. April '19
@@mahendranrajah7481 I have the total list of 7500 songs created by The Greatest Tunesmith M.S.V (oru padaththukku 10 , 15 paattellaam thandhavar M.S.V mattumdhaan-eg.Ulagam sutrum vaaliban, Ninaiththaale inikkum, etc.) Can you give atleast 4000 songs by Ilayaraja? - Trichy Haja from Qatar 00974 30647425
Y g mahendran many of the music lovers have different opinions from you. Yes msv is one of the best composer on his time especially old with rama moorthy no doubt on it. But don't forget Ilayaraja gave another transformation of cine music for eg. his songs interludes and preludes and background score he is no1 if at all you don't like IR music don't under estimate him it before IR and after IR, so IR is equater
If you listen to music, MSV laid down very good base from the then cinemas. Ilayaraja is improved it. Ilayaraja himself says MSV music is "Aathara sruthi". Improvization is tough only. the basic is the base. MSV and Ilayaraja are great in their own Era. But MSV transaformation is great. MSV is the greatest. Ilayaraja comes next because he started from MSV style then he improvised. guess who is the base. After Ilayaraja no more musicians. Just a note - I am great fan of Ilayarja. Ilayaraja himself is greatfan of MSV. I leave it to you who is "Aathaara Sruthi"
Who is this guy YGM? Never heard of him!!! Most importantly, who is he to say the MSV is the "Yard Stick" for music and Sivaji is the "Yard Stick" for acting? It his opinion only!!!
can you please provide your opinion of the same yard stick? Just opinion only. Since you never heard of YGM, it does not mean that he is "NOT" famous. your knowledge of movie industry is that munch only (I agree on the fact that knowledge of movies is not at all necessary for life). You may have to listen more to the music to come up to your opinion according to me.
