Zadie Smith Is WRONG: WORDS Are Not VIOLENCE, Zionism Is: Briahna Joy Gray 

By the Arabs!

@leviashanken2506 Exactly! And since those Arabs took my birthright in 638, Jupiter decrees that I return to reclaim my land! You may say that sounds ridiculous... I agree. But ridiculous claims are the foundation of modern Zionism.

@@pn312 but the Roman conquerors came from Rome and had Rome to return to so this would be ridiculous but not at all comparable to the situation with Israel. And quite ignorant and insensitive, too.

@@leviashanken2506but Jews came from modern day Iraq an took the land from cannites ,an most Jews today come from Europe they are dual national so go

​@@leviashanken2506most Israeli have dual citizenship, so they can go BACK where they come from Europe Russia USA

🙌

I dont think they know what that feels like

They don’t even feel that

It’s the fact that their white supremacy is being challenged, every spokesperson I’ve listened to on the Israeli side sounds like extreme spoiled brats!

@@TechThisWayNow I agree. Someone with NO soul, a liar, a thief has no conscience, therefore has no ability to feel guilty.

Love him

He was so right about that.

You Got it !!! Great entry !!!!....so TRUE !!!

African American remember with great caution that even at the purported ending of "democractic" chatel slavery, other forms of repressive realities were adopted instantaneously to keep them a perpetual servant under class, in much the same way that Americans can now finally see and relate with the current plight of the Palestinians----there was a time in America up until 1964, when they were finally granted civil rights and quite frankly citizenship. Back then even NEW immigrants had more rights than ALL AND ANY of those African Americans. Now, we see the same thing in zionist Israel, where foreigners are granted more rights than ALL the other natives regardless of their status----which makes one question who or what in the govt determines who is or isn't a Jew worth the right of return, and if Arabs are allowed to convert to judaism, if that is the only way they can access equal rights...

💯

​@@justjunk8565 And native Americans didn't call themselves native Americans until foreign colonizers started genociding them and stealing their lands .. it doesn't negate they are native to the land we call America.. They just didn't need a unified national identity until their existence were threatened.. .. So also the native people of the land called palestine.. didn't actually need a unified identity until foreign colonisers started massacring and ethnically cleansing them from their homes and lands

​@@justjunk8565i thought a Palestinian was from Palestine. Are you saying there is/was no such place as Palestine?

Left or right BLA BLA BLA if you were in Palestine or other and you are from the west you’re human value is zero!! This will never change never!! Let’s mind our own business and care for our own country

Biden is counting on people not understanding this!

Genocide has a definition. Try looking it up sometime.

The accusation still seems to steer the conversation from ongoing war crimes to what is or isn't "antisemitism". At what point do you simply admit it's a meaningless ad hominem?

@@NickFromDetroit Your point?

@@AndrewJackson1841 , 1) No genocide is occurring in Gaza. 2) Falsely calling it a genocide is anti-Semitic. 3) No nation on earth has done more to keep collateral damage to a minimum than Israel. 4) Hamas Gazan jihadis always target civilians, which are war crimes.

Exactly!

JFK tried to ....aaaannnnd .....

1)israel is far more secular and respective of religious freedom than any arab country 2)with the treatment of kurds turkmen domari and afro iraqis in iraq,and non arabized/black people in sudan and maurtiania and sudan - the arab league and its spokespersons better be careful who they call apartheid. it has nothing to do with race and i promise we chase black islamists just as fiercely as we do blond ones. our mizrahi communities wont be subjected to another 1929 hebron and safed pogrom or 194q farhud without retaliation... 3)maybe the pro palestinians can find donors in america and not from qatari dictatorship or chinese dystopia who support their cause and then they wont be registered as foreign agents? and qatar still refuse to do so even though the DOJ ordered them to do so.

​@@MadhuKrishnaDasa...then he got shot.

The ABOMINATION is called "DUAL CITIZENSHIP"!!!!!!!!!!

Really, no Jews have been killed in this conflict? And you're also blaming Israel for that boy's death? Offensive and idiotic.

@@kovie9162come on, you get the point, no? The obviously more vulnerable people are the Palestinians. Protestors here are speaking up for them. Stop the brutal occupation and literal murdering first then we can start to address people’s unsafe feelings here.

And the Jews don’t get killed ?? You need to learn history

@@kovie9162Ah, ur offended 😢

@@kovie9162the cry in pain as they strike you

Mind Begs the Question: - If a Semitic State - Engage in Genocide/Apartheid - To speak,act against it - Is Anti Semitic or Pro Freedom?

​@cbs63 please, that garbage has been fully debunked. BTW, Israel uses human shields. Their military installations are in residential areas. But good job mindlessly parroting imperial talking points.

@@bodhisattva3774 yes, and even more so that in Israel young people are forced to join the military

Pro Reality, there is no genocide.

Lets make israel southafrica

Visit Israel, walk in the streets of any city, go to courtrooms, police stations, hospitals see how many are arabs. (Spoiler alert -a lot...!!!) Including the Knesset. So find another word to describe Israel if you don't like the way it's leaded, but apartheid is just not it .

@@a-sf6nc 🤣🤣🤣🤣 Care to tell me which streets to use. There are sure streets which are only used by the chosen ones. How many check points will I come across where I will be threatened with deportation if I bring a camera? I want to be prepared

@@a-sf6nc The leader of Israel ,Benjamin Netayahu has said Israel is a Jewish state. Also many members of the Knesset have incited genocidal intent. Not suprising that most have been from the Likud party.

from someone who doesnt even know what the word means, and probably has never even been to Israel, just uses buzz words, like other nazis.

So Palestine is guilty of that then. I mean their Christian populations have been decimated by the Muslims through apartheid like actions.

That is not his job....

This is a perfect example of why real debate is not possible with some people. Referring to robbie

Can't handle someone who disagrees with you?

@@boulevard14 he can’t even acknowledge factual historical truths about the conflict if it gives concessions to the Palestinians. So no honest discourse can take place.

Yeah. I lost much respect for him since Gaza. Many people in fact

United States of Zionism.

United Dictatorship of America

for real

AIPAC must be banned.

F USI

She’s got slot of self control I would be losing my mind

all those who think Robby lacks moral compass actually lack a brain. So there's really no solution

The claim that Robbie is the one exhausting viewers is so incredible that it immediately depletes the credibility of the speaker

Her face says “I’m a big baby and when Robbie disagrees with me at all I pout.”

​@@tonybanks1035 he has a moral compass, he is just reading it backwards. Imagine arguing for collective punishment and thinking you are in the right, truly a brain dead argument if I've ever heard one.

The truth can be exhausting

@@omahhum82 and so can bullsh*t

Zadie Smith's publisher is Penguin Random House, Bertelsmann. " Over the decades Bertelsmann and Israel have developed close and extremely stable ties of friendship." (Never Again is Now)

Strange, just 10 minutes ago, leftists were saying that things "misgendering" or "MAGA" were a form of violence. Now liberal Jews are learning what it's like to be on the "wrong" side of leftists' beliefs. BTW I personally don't think words are violence. If you believe that Israel should be a Jewish state say it. If you want to support the people of Gaza or even Hamas, say it. Free speech is clarifying.

Notice leftists will never criticize Hamas or place any blame on them? Isn’t the real crime using human shields?

Why do you thing hate speech is condem.

​@@tomasmendezdiaz9833 send an ambulance, your words have caused me internal bleeding

So does Israel

Sounds good to Izreel

@@chrismorris8847very true. It would be great if one day Israel wasn’t the attacker and oppressor. (Atleast here in the USA, a person or group cannot invade your home then claim self defense when you try your get the out of your home.)

Palestine doesn’t exist, never did, never will!

​@WhatIfWe615 Nearly every war Israel has been involved in has been reactionary. Even the 1967 war, where those called Palestinians voluntarily left their country so a number of Arab countries could attack Israel at once to exterminate the Jews.

Beautifully said. I believe this will happen too, and I stand with you! ✊🏼

@@crystalsharadin9772 thank you.

Hypotheticaly what is more likely to cause harm! or death! Drugs! or living! 🤔 Living obviously because it's 100%fatal because when you live you die??? that is fact yes??? So on that ground What do you do to drug dealers and why ?? If your the one with the elicit substance ... So does that not make people who have kids life dealers???? 😂😂😂 So, based on that, what is more hanus ???😂😂 also sober refers strictly to abstinence from alcohol and your ability to be serious or solemn Nothing else And addiction is something that you are physically or mentally dependent on and can't stop taking it without adverse effects ..... that includes food 😂😂😂😂 people are silly read a book called the dictionary this ain't pictionary

Let me guess, you and Brie are truly just. amirite?

@@wilburhornshnoggle2619, Just enough to truly understand the meaning of the word 'Amalek', used by a psychopathic leader. Amirite?

Easily the most arrogant thing I’ve seen in writing today

@@JLuisCastaneda Wow! You are so easily impressed.

When someone calls me anti semitic solely for criticizing Israel and Israeli war crimes I take it as a badge of honor, since them calling me anti semitic instead of retorting with facts shows they lost the argument

When you stop giving a s#!+ if you get fired. Good job Bri, rub their noses in the truth.

I hate how there was a ceasefire for years and then Israel broke it on October 7th with their terrorist attack on a music concert in Gaza and filmed themselves doing it.

@@Matt_H_ The idea that there was a ceasefire for years is wrong. Israel over the years has been killing and detaining people while slowly stealing more and more land, while also destroying homes , I condemn what Hamas did on October 7th, but the Palestinians have contninuosly suffered of Israeli terrorism

yA THEY GOT REALLY WORK HARD TO FIND A SCRIPT FOR ROBO BOY.

It is complicated. Thats why its been going over 70 years.

It’s always complicated when Americans see everything through a narrow “oppressor vs oppressed” lense

Don't ever compare them. Native Americans aren't terrorists 🤷‍♂️

Not really . Natives were never homogenous as a nation but 1000s of tribes that fought each other . In fact many allied with the U.S. to take down other tribes .

@@badmf7551some tribes weren’t and other tribes were .

@@badmf7551 No but back in the day Native Americans were pushed from their lands and killed, and when they fought back they were labeled as terrorists and worse. There are similarities

@@belgianbull4722Also, the way the children were removed, to “reeducate” them.

International law says Israel is a sovereign nation

Occupied from whom? Was their a palastinen state before an Israeli state?

​@@a-sf6ncgo read a book

Thank you not waiting on Robby to open his mouth before ending the video.

@@KungPowShitzu that must abide by the law they have ratified, but you fail to see that logic

Palestine is the ethno-state. Israel has ten times more diversity than Palestine.

thousands still lying in the rubble, while many others died because of lack of medicine, or famine that aren't even included. The number has been estimated much higher than 34,000

@@belgianbull4722 guess you shouldnt vote in Terrorist governments eh

Especially with mass graves being uncovered...

IKR, it's probably north of 34 Billion...

Recently saw that it’s now at 42k

@@leviashanken2506 What does that even mean?

totally agree

​@vid8w7 I think they're pointing out the obvious hypocracy

Wrong. "Antiracism" and antifascism" are both zionist fronts. That's why you saw attackers of the UCLA encampment dressed in black bloc and using black bloc tactics. That's why the encampments are swimming upstream without the institutional support BLM and OWS benefited from.

It means if a tree falls in the forest, and no ones hears it, it's antisemitism.@@vid8w7

The government you elect is the government you deserve. - Thomas Jefferson

It’s a strategic money chess game: either you take the money, or I will offer this same cheap amount to you opponent running against you that happens to think it is a lot of money. So, take the money and keep your job, or risk it. This is why the price of them being bought is so cheap.

I personally would take the AIPAC money and when I got elected, give them the finger.

@OP: Lol, if only! 😄

@@nyvarsitysports The way for us as voters to decrease the impact of AIPAC and Israel would be to vote third party. When democrats see that they are losing elections because of this than maybe their stance might change

Khazars are eighth century converts to the Pharisess' Talmudism . Khazars have no DNA relationship to the biblical people known as Israel or Judah . Kenites were the leaders of the Pharisees , said so by Jesus Christ in John 8 . It may be correct to say that modern Khazars are "spiritual" Kenites , but still the Khazars have NO DNA relationship to biblical people , and therefore NO claim to land in Palestine . Khazars' claims to land in Palestine are predicated on lies .

because the Jews there have NO MIDDLE EASTERN BLOOD. they are all Ashkenazi!!

Jewish is a religion, not a race or ethnicity.

@@karenz1634 so why won't Israel open their society to everyone claiming to be Jews ?

This has been determined by every country before DNA testing was invented. Jews are a people and they have long records.

😂

Of course. She would be absolutely consistent.

She deserves her own show

Zionists never want to admit to those crystal clear facts.

Gaza has received 4.6 billion in foreign aid and also receives foreign weapons from states like Iran. Why should Israel provide any of those things to a state who wants them destroyed? All that money, they could have provided those things for themselves instead of building missles and tunnels.

The side that controls the power and water is because the work hard to have a working environment … that’s always been the case …

Whereas Hamas receives nothing from impoverished Qatar billionaires.

@@elda6973🤦‍♀️ 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

Sometimes feels like the shows premise is like a WWE match where one of them plays the "heel"

Interesting because Bri did not at all deal with the issue of Hamas (let alone Oct 7) and some of us would like to know what the solution is without their surrender. So I'm grateful that Robbie asked but Bri didn't answer but made that 'I told you so' look into the camera.

@@leviashanken2506 It's because the answer to that question has already been given SO many times, that those who are asked for the 50,000th time simply shrug in exasperation as Bri is now doing here. Her and Robby have been over this countless times and for him to act like this is some "gotcha" question is really begging credulity at this point.

@@spiritof6663 I know this, I've been watching this for a long time too. But I don't think Robbie presented it as a gotcha but a legitimate question that has not been satisfactorily answered. Surely Bri has repeated her legitimate points many times, too . That's no excuse to trivialize her side or his side.

There aren't two sides in a genocide ​

The agreement that leaves Hamas in charge..

Not what happened. They produced document that did not reflect what was agreed upon, so Israel said NO! And thank goodness! They wanted 700 prisoners--criminals!, released in exchange for 132 Hostages!

@@Ivan.A.Trulyuski and now sacrifices the hostages that were never important in the first place.

@@Ivan.A.Trulyuski As opposed to giving Isr control?

The agreement that would still leave hundreds of hostages in Gaza?

Oh? What is that point? Enlighten us

@@omahhum82 That's depends on the particular point they trying to push.

Epic bs

well then I will expect her not to use so many hypotheticals from now on

Katie Helper got fired for an awful lot last. When you stop giving a s#!+ if you get fired. Good job Bri, rub their noses in the truth.

Epic 😂😂😂😂 world salad at its finest

It was a disturbed, dishonest, histrionic rant.

So true!

They was no beheading of babies on October 7 that has already been shown and debunked.

@@twatts1523 And the 35,000 dead bodies are not "Hamas." And the 17,000 orphans are not "Hamas." The nonstop nonsense online is astounding. Americans want to whine about college students. Why? They can't handle the reality of so many graves.

So true! 😂

They're evil. Say it.

she is amazing she is brilliant.

I like her a lot

Nice try but Ethno-states do not have people of different ethnicities serving in govt.

@@timcardona9962 That's the point. Rob would be ok with kicking Bri to the curb if he was legally allowed to. Ethics and morality are a second thought in his mind.

Turn tv off..

Its fine as humans we disagree all the time

That means you are a human. You are already better then every politician that supports this for more campaign funds for their personal re-election.

Me too.

Read the Bible. Then your will understand the truth about all of these matters.

The Jews accepted it when they were literally given 24 hour notice by Egypt, Syria, Tunisia, Iraq and the list goes on

​@@omahhum82in your eyes was that bad to do or is it justified?

@@aaronhyik346 it was bad, but what you don’t understand is that Israelis are not in the “if it’s not fair than don’t do it to others” game. That’s a liberal game that one can afford playing when their survival as people is not on the line. They are about survival, having realized they are unsafe anywhere else in the world.

@@omahhum82 there are more than 6 million jews in the US they are safe here not counting the jews in Europe and around the world that is not a justification to steal and m0rder thousands of innocent civilians just so they can have a land, if its bad when is done to the jews is bad when done by the Jews. Sorry but the truth is the truth

​@@omahhum82 funny how everyone was welcome until Israel's foundation

When the Germans invaded Eastern Europe, they liberated nations from Bolshevik terror.

Hamas has more in common with the nazis than Israel does.

Well he certainly is out-spoken by her, if that's what her class and depth are.

you are a bot, right?

Taboos? Those dusty talking points have been around liberal circles for decades

@@omahhum82 she literally said that Israel doesn't have the right to exist as an ethnostate for Jews only. I didn't expect this to be allowed to be said on The Hill.

@@jihenfrikha5056 she’s been dancing around it for a while, and I don’t think anybody is surprised. She doesn’t seem to care that the entire Arab world is made of ethno states though

@@omahhum82Arab countries have had a majority of Arab populaton since the beginning of the middle ages. the Zionist project would have worked centuries ago the way orther settler colonial projects worked in north America and Australia etc. Israel was created in the mid 20th century, it's an outdated colonial concept that no longer fits international laws and global human rights. Too bad for then but it's no longer sustainable.

Is he bought off? Seems like it.

@@adinahaun6001 Brainwashed, but I bet the money doesn't hurt

White supremacy?

Because that’s his job

He shares their sentiments.

He has no humanity, much less compassion.

Doesn’t want to be attacked by the Lobby

Palestinians want self determination, the Israelis want ethnic cleansing. It’s against the Geneva Convention, which Israel has signed and pledged to abide by and uphold. They have not, and it’s clear they have been talking out of both sides of their mouths for generations. History has proven this again and again. If you can’t see the distinction, it’s pitiful

She's a great writer. I understand (and share) your disgust over her latest apologia for Zionism, but you're missing out if you skip "White Teeth."

@@rworded1meh

@@Ccats231 Oh, c'mon... It was a fun read.

It was pure delusion

Because it’s an illogical argument. It’s like saying the IDF must cease to be tomorrow. It’s not ever going to happen. It’s like saying that the U.S. will recognize Palestine when all the Israelis go back to where they came from. Not going to happen. Pie in the sky

No

what about banks that work with Saudia Arabia? Wait, you don't care what they are doing to Yeminis care of U.S. backing? By the same updated definition of genocide ... that is a genocide. Why is this battle so near and dear to your heart? OR, What about banks here that deal with our govt that did crazy stuff in Libya, Iraq, Afghanistan and Somalia? .... Hmmm ... so, essentially you would have to keep cash on hand. GTFOH

@@chrismorris8847 I don’t know you, but I love you

@@omahhum82 OK then.

Care to provide a few examples?

Ilan Pape has said the greatest piece of propaganda Israel has ever created was saying the situation is complicated. It’s not