As females we need to continue to speak out, especially against these trans athletes. Its simply not fair to girls, and is a real health concern for women everywhere.
This clown has missed the point There is a spectrum. A spectrum of male/female and 150,000,000 that don’t fit exactly into all of these biological markers.
@@poerava do you not know what a spectrum is? You identified three things. Two sexes and “doesn’t fit” which is not a sex. You’re not identifying the scale but results of sorting… since “doesn’t fit” is not a sex, it does not belong on a continuous quantitative scale of sex…. And two sexes is not a continuous quantitative scale but two values of a nominal variable. I was hoping you were joking
@@DerpMcDerp-gb3ss I’m Tahitian bro There’s a third gender in Polynesian culture. I’m sorry that you haven’t got your head around this. Must give you a head ache when you want to make a circle fit in a square. Maybe talk to some doctors. Ask them if they pronounce a baby with ambiguous genitalia and XXY chromosomes, a male or a female. I know it hurts b b b b because male and female (In most of these occasions the least harmful proceeds is to not allocate a sex to the child. Some parents opt for surgeries to give a child a sex assignment but that’s another chat)
@@poerava 1. The topic is sex, not gender. Three genders is not three sexes and three sexes is not a spectrum. Second, you’re retroactively calling cultural names for feminine, gay, and transgender males a third gender… which doesn’t even make sense. XXY doesn’t have ambiguous genitalia. You don’t know how sex chromosomes work. Do you actually not know what males and females are? What klinefelter syndrome is? That’s a male specific condition.
Just think how men now are threatening suicide if they don't get to oppress us women. Well, if you don't want to live, you must do what you want. Stop being kind to people who want to hurt you. Don't be a nice girl.
110% Support our women in sports. Our women matter in sports and as an athlete, I vow I personally will do whatever I can to promote and further protect our girls and women (genetic females for the WOKE minded) as they lead the way for us NOW and in the FUTURE on all levels of success in society. They must have a voice and we must stand with them hand in hand- continuing to raise them up.
It's amazing how this side of the issue are able to trace everything they say and stand by to facts, concrete biological reality and historical facts. What does the other side have to offer? Speculation, feeling, threats and disrespect. It's always crickets or "agree to disagree" when I talk to anyone about the facts.
How sad it is that many people don't understand these basic things! Unbelievable. BTW, misunderstanding may harm trans-people themselves. I do care about everyone's rights. Humans have some medical conditions that connected to one's sex. Even if you are a trans-woman, you still have to be diagnosed as a male in order to receive the proper treatment. It's just a matter of facts.
This debate is a bit of nonsense because there's way more ciswoman in pro sports that have off the scale male features, and probably testosterone, and maybe a genetic hormone imbalance, than there is transwoman in sports. The only trans person in the Paris Olympics was assigned 'female' at birth and is competing in the female category. There's zero transwoman at the Paris Olympics.
There was a time when phrenology was breakthrough science that reached highest levels of academia. It was only 15 years from its origin theories to widespread acceptance. And had lost most all of its following within 20 years thereafter. A brief period that nonetheless had profound impact on social ideology and negatively affected people’s actual quality of life
It was never really science but something ideologues embraced and did not scrutinize because it agreed with the predisposed ideas. Similar to how the actual basis behind redefining sex and claiming sex is a spectrum is nonexistent.
@@DerpMcDerp-gb3ss that isn’t something I can argue against; sounds about right. I do know it took better science to dislodge phrenology from the upper class ‘ideologues’ it did not lose credibility like a fad that falls out of vogue, it was disproven. But then it lingered among laypersons for about a decade and actually gained momentum among the poorer and less educated demographic, this period was when traveling hucksters kept it alive. Much like conspiracy theories today, the fact that elites had stopped giving it much credence only bolstered the acceptance among the common people.
This was an excellent presentation and analysis. She covered all bases and explained in the most simplistic terms. However, it’s naive to believe that this form of colonisation is being perpetrated by a grassroots movement, consisting of less than 1% of the population. There are clearly extremely powerful people driving this nefarious movement.
Why is a guy who studied the biology and evolution of Spiders and Insects talking like he's an expert on mammals, let alone humans? He's saying weird, irrelevant, old-fashioned outdated and irrelevant information, but he's saying it with such undeserved confidence. It's weord
“Why is the biologist talking about biology?” To be clear, you think that he only has knowledge of insects and hasn’t studied biology extensively? You think that he did not learn about sex and that insects do not have sexes? You do realize male and female insects are male and female for the exact same reasons as any other species with males and females, right? This is not outdated information at all. This well accepted scientific consensus
“Why is the biologist talking about biology?” To be clear, you think that he only has knowledge of insects and hasn’t studied biology extensively? You think that he did not learn about sex and that insects do not have sexes? You do realize male and female insects are male and female for the exact same reasons as any other species with males and females, right? This is not outdated information at all. This well accepted scientific consensus
You just dismissed an evolutionary biologist on a very well known and accepted topic in evolutionary biology with undeserved confidence. Do you seriously not know what a male and a female is?
Why doesn't the pdga listen..really listen? I didn't realize until 2 years ago..after being a "member" since 2006... That the pdga had or has Owners. I thooought.. the pdga was a membership based association... Not a dictatorship. Keep standing ladies!
I stand with you . The problem is ask most men if it's worth putting a dress on to see a load of fit women getting changed. It's all wrong. I wish you all the best
Every time a female has her right to give OR DENY consent taken away via DEI, she should quote the findings of the WPATH Files, that shows how trans ideology is being used as gay conversion therapy, against LGB young persons (80-90% of whom are NOT trans, but whom are advised to transition rather than dealing with their internalized homophobia or the homophobia or their parents, guardians, or counselors) and demand an explanation as to why the organization in question is advancing antiquated stereotypes about males and females, and why they’re supporting the equivalent of the homophobic “pray the gay away” Jesus Camp, but with scalpels, hormones, and puberty blockers?
17:22 "this is not about trans rights, it is about women's rights". 17:55 "de-program themselves from the thought-terminating cliches like trans-women are women and trans-men are men" --- THANK YOU FOR YOUR HONESTY, WISDOM, AND COURAGE.
Riley Gains should be given the congressional medal of honor! Women and men, gay and straight should applaud her! Support her! Follow in her footsteps! The trans-mafia is a grooming, predatory sub faction in our deteriorating society. Women are in the cross hairs and we must stop this maddness!!!
Okay, I'm gonna say it (wondering why this seems to be a topic never to be spoken about): The window of opportunity is much smaller for women agewise and the opportunity costs are higher than for men concerning family planning. Even if a woman is infertile or is sure very early to never wanting to have kids: She still needs to adress the issue in some way or form from a female perspective. Something men and "transidentified" men never have to deal with. Also being "trans" is a life choice which is detrementral to health and fitness. Like many other lifestyle choices. Even if he thinks he "has no choice" bc of that dubious "woman inside" he claims to have: If he wants to take hormones which impact his performance, how in the hell makes that him eligible to crash ("indentify") into another category?!
No. No exception. Ever. Kellie Jay Keen has lead the way and we will hold the line. STOP WEAPONIZING “COMPASSION”. Women… STOP BEING “NICE”, you are destroying all the rights your mothers and grandmothers fought for! And you are taking all women down with your need to be “nice” and “fair”. NO!
Thank you for addressing the puberty myth. I am not a biologist, but simple life experience and basic knowledge of physiology and anatomy show pre-pubescent girls and boys are obviously different in all physical measures and abilities. I am so frustrated by pre-puberty transition being put forward as an acceptable standard and am glad it’s being talked about.
It's also to my mind a potentially harmful suggestion. You're talking about saying "Well if you've taken puberty blockers early enough." There absolutely no way any child can give informed consent to puberty blockers at an age that means they miss out on puberty. It's a path to sterility and total lack of sexual function as an adult. A gross and barbaric experimental treatment with no evidence for positive outcomes and clearly obvious life altering negative ones making a person a life long medical patient with all sorts of health consequences beyond the sterility.
Please ICONS- Caitlin Clark is trans Someone speak up please!! We are being psyop’d like crazy as our kids look up to HIM and WNBA starts making $$$ I guarantee- this is going to be bad Save womens sports !!
Good for you! Keep speaking out! This whole thing is crazy, biological males & females where identified for international sports when performance enhancing drugs became popular. As a former NCAA division 1 athlete in Rowing at UC Berkeley. I was the stroke seat of an undefeated National Champion crew in 1984. I was one of the first generations to benefit for equal opportunities under Title 9. Even with the tall beefy women on our heavyweight team, there is no way they could ever compete against biological males. There is underlying agenda to eliminate gender... and eliminating women first.
