Dude Jared Goff is not overrated. When I even try to tell someone that the Lions are going to be good this year, the first thing they say is "but Jared Goff is your QB." Not saying he's elite or anything, but definitely not overrated.
Same can be said about the majority of this list. Nobody said Carr Brock, Geno, Daniel, or so on were elite Qbs They're all mid tier starting Qbs in the league if they can repeat their career best year.
As a Lions fan he’s good but he’s definitely overrated and most likely gonna be replaced by Hooker, he’s played great.. but he also only had two seasons in LA that weren’t double digit interceptions.. stats don’t lie
@@noahbeck3155specially when he was also featured on the "Top 10 Most Under-Appreciated Players In The NFL Right Now". U simply can't b "Underappreciated" & "Overrated" @ the same time. Ur comment (2 which my reply pertains 2) proves that.
100% agree on the Josh Allen take, but I can't say the same for T-Law. Yeah, he had a bad first season, but many great QBs did as well, and it looks like he has finally found his game. If anything, I'd say he's underrated. (coming from someone who isn't a Jags fan)
Exactly. Look at Staffords first 2 years or Peyton Manning. Lawrence actually did better and led them to playoffs. Oh and he's only 23. Wait until he's Joe Burrow's age at 26. ( I been a jags fan since 95 and live by Cincy So I have to hear about Joey b all day long. Lol)
I think the Allen take is actually pretty poor. Problem is Allen being compared to Mahomes isn't fair to him, as Mahomes is easily the best QB in the league. He also has the highest % of a team's total offense for any player in the league with 85% share. He's asked to do everything, and ends up forcing the issue sometimes (hence why he's not as good as Mahomes). But he's still historically GREAT. Most TD's of any QB in history through their first 5 seasons? Also only 7 yards short of most total yards (passing & rushing) of a QB through 5 seasons? Only QB along with Brees to have back-to-back seasons of 5,000+ total yards & 40+ TDs? Brought a team that had 1 playoff appearance in 18 years to the playoffs every year but his rookie season? C'mon man. He may not be Mahomes, and the entire team ran out of gas last year, but he's still a great QB.
Hurts has a mickey mouse schedule last year with the best roster on the nfc... Doesn't win superbowl despite being favorites Is not overrated but my qb has one bad year because of injury and missed time overrated
He made a super bowl and played absolutely terrible in it… also his career is more then last year and his super bowl year. He’s inconsistent and has had plenty of bad years
A a Broncos fan, I agree. It was never Justin Herbert or Patick Mahomees alone who beats the Broncos, but it was Derek Carr ALONE who picked apart our top 5 defense every year with quick outs and hot reads. He's smarter and better than people think and I'm glad he's out the division lol.
Where the hell is Jalen Hurts? Dude literally had one good season and everyone is like ohhhh yeahhhh best ever when Eagle fans we're pissed for taking him a couple years back😂😂
I'm assuming you're talking about Carr. Yes, that never gets mentioned. This channel doesn't know shit about football. They take talking points from the media and use that as their source for these videos. They're extremely ignorant.
I don’t see how Geno qualifies as overrated. He was a formerly underrated player who put up a great season and we’re all waiting to see if he can do it again. I feel like this is basically saying that acknowledging a player was underestimated means they’re now overrated.
I agree. Geno always had talent, but was immature and made bad decisions. He calmed down and improved greatly by understudying Wilson with the 49ers, and might well have a good run of several years now.
@@Firethetruegamer no he isn’t. I mean Kirk is terrible on prime time and he relies on Justin Jefferson to bail him out. Plus we can’t forget that Geno smith was a beast in college before getting drafted to the worst team when it comes to developing quarterbacks. I mean the Jets picked Zach Wilson second overall and destroyed his career. If Geno was put in a better situation like he is right now, he would’ve been a top 10 quarterback for years.
@@Firethetruegamer right. because cousins has done so much with all the seasons he has been a start. geno just led a team projected to be a bottom 3 team to be a top 5 offense and made the playoffs. cousins has done what with a team projected to be nfc conference conteders? nothing.
Lol he's acting like Goff barely put up decent numbers dude had 29 tds to just 7 picks threw for 4,438 yards wich is 6th in the nfl and had the 5th best QBR
This list just lost all credibility when you put Herbert and Lawrence in there. Herbert is breaking records with a subpar OLine and average weapons while Lawrence just helped lead his team to the playoffs and a come from behind win over the chargers.
@@barrysanders3358 Herbert is ,miles better than Rivers at everything and I love Rivers but as a Charger fan that has seen every snap from both guys. Herbert is the most complete package of a QB i've seen. He's able to have such consistent high level despite everyhing working against him with this team
I think Jalen Hurts is overrated because of how many superstars he has on his team and how much of the spotlight is on him. For example: Darius Slay, A.J. Brown, Jason Kelce, Lane Johnson, Devonta Smith, James Bradbury, Haason Reddick, Josh Sweat, and now Deandre swift. Still everyone says that jalen hurts carries smh
If you watched the Vikings this season and how they struggled after Cousins tore his Achilles you would not say he's overrated. Jared Goff took the Lions to the NFC championship team so I wouldn't call him overrated either.
Bro is living under a rock. The chargers lost the playoff game bc of Staley, and your judging Lawrence and Herbert off of 1 GAME. Like Jesus it was their first playoff game. Geno led the Seahawks who were supposed to be dog to the PLAYOFFS. Derek Carr was not the reason the raiders sucked. It was their defense. Josh Allen had 42 TOUCHDOWNS and has led the bills to the playoffs for 4 straight years. Stop living under a rock
I’m sorry Lamar is way more over rated than Josh Allen. Yes bills have fallen short of the Super Bowl but at least they have been to the AFC championship unlike Lamar
Dak vs QBs ranked “better than him” 1 Justin Herbert 2021 (9-8)- worse record (9-8, 12-5), missed playoffs, more ints than Dak (Herbert 15, Dak 10) 2022 (10-7)- again worse record (10-7, 12-5), blew a 27-7 lead in his very 1st playoff game and went home. Yet there’s no “one and done” narrative surrounding him🤨 Josh Allen 2021 (11-6)- worse record (11-6, 12-5), less yards AND TDs than Dak (Allen 4,407 36tds,4.449 37tds) w/ 50 more pass attempts, worse completion% (63.3, 68.8), more ints than Dak (15,10) more total turnovers (20, 18) 🤯 2022- led NFL in turnovers (Allen-19, Dak-16), 🤯, worse completion percentage (63.3, 66.2), never hear y’all say “I’m worried about the turnovers”😂 Trevor Lawrence 2021- (3-14), 1,008 less pass yards than Dak despite 6 more attempts (596, 602), worse completion% (59.6, 68.8), 12:15 TD to Int ratio vs 37:10 for Dak, Trevor literally had more ints than TDS…shameful, 71.9 rating to Dak’s 104.2 2022- (9-8) only 2 more passing TDs than Dak despite 5 more games played (25-23), worse record (9-8, 12-5), through 2 playoff games he got 5tds 5ints and a 1-1 record…yall would bury Dak for that, yet again not a narrative surrounding him either about turnovers, hasn’t done nothing Dak hasn’t done but ppl believe in him to win…laughable but I ain’t laughing Jalen Hurts 2021 (9-8) only 3,144 pass yards Dak had 1,405 more, only 16TDs to Dak 37, TD to Int ratio 16:9 vs Dak’s 37-10, bounced vs Bucs 1st round of playoffs 2022 (15-2) he basically matched Dak rookie passing stats with a loaded roster, only 3,700 pass yards and 22tds, Dak missed 5 games and threw 23tds, also Dak would never get credit for 22tds 3700 yards…
Geno is so damn overrated. He has one good season, and people all of a sudden call him great, forgetting how shit he was in New York. He’ll crash back down to Earth in 2023
How you talk about the cowboys and the fact that you didn't mention anything about missing a number one receiver one year and then a hurt Gallup in another year shows how much you dislike the cowboys you are only telling half the story and that's truly unfair
your argument for daniel jones and jared goff makes no sense, your logic is always based off of self belief and words with no backbone. “he needs to elevate the level of play not rise to it.” that’s statistically false. he had one of the most game winning drives this year. Bro looks at stats and a few highlights and makes a video. he has no one to throw the ball to and still had the 6th highest QBR and has one of the highest completion%
No way is goff overrated... he had statiatically one of his best years in the nfl... but despite this a lot of people arent sold on him and a lot of people have that as a knock on the lions
That's crazy, I didn't know that not being able to score on multiple drives after going up 27-0 (which caused the jags to be able to come from behind and win) was not on the quarterback
@@mosestar6127 It doesn't, but people act like he's the 2nd coming of christ when his team is, on paper, one of the best in the NFL, with absolutely nothing to show for it. He puts up numbers for the regular season, then they do nothing in the postseason.
it’s blatant ragebait, saying stuff that’s outrageous and straight up wrong like this gets people riled up in the comments and drives up interactions which RU-vid sees as a positive and pushes their content in the algorithm. Pretty much the same thing people in sports media like Colin Cowherd and Skip Bayless do except guys like that are despised while vids like this are praised for some reason
Diehard cowboys fan. The Dak deal is odd (he also was invited to the 2021 pro bowl but turned it down). I say diehard, however, I’m realistic. He’s not overrated in my eyes, it’s just that he plays for the cowboys, and like you said, that’s what leads to that. Also, to put pro bowls in perspectives. Google Amari Cooper (4 time pro bowler) and had alotnof hype being a top 5k pick out of college. Then put Brandin Cooks stats next to his (who was a later 1st round pick in 2014) stats are very close. Cooks has even had better years that Cooper but never made a pro bowl. Cooper had the top 5 hype out of college, Cooks didn’t. It’s a popularity contest. Im trying to not look at pro bowls on a resume and just all pros
I wouldn't say Goff is overrated. I'd say he's rated where he should be. I've never heard anyone say Goff is Elite. He's above average in my opinion, he's smart with the ball and can make things happen. With that said, One Pride baby!!!
Do you think Tom Brady was just a competent quarterback, a system quarterback, a quarterback that can read defenses fast I think the difference maker is coaching at Chief's, Eagles, 49ers & Bengals
HAHA, Dak Prescott the first one i see. Let´s see if he can take the first spot. LFG. Plus Goff is not overrrated he is underrated no one expect ANYTHING from him still he delivers. I´m not a Lions fan (is anyone truly?)
brock being over raided is crazy " it doesn't take a lot for a guy to look good in kyle shanahans offense" did you see what happened in the NFC championship dude they got there butts handed to them
I see some of him being overrated like going to the playoffs like it can be a fluke but if he returns to form like last year then he fs underrated bc tps loves to take advantage of who they are or were instead of their play
TPS: Dak has put up numbers in a contract year in 2019. Counting numbers don't quite cut it when Dak is being talked about as a top 10 Qb. Hes just fools gold!!Yet they talk about Jalen Hurts as if he is top 10. What has Jalen shown in 2 seasons and 4 games. In 2 seasons Jalen has made the playoffs twice. Lost the 1st one to the Bucs. Only won 2 playoff games in pursuit to a Superbowl appearance. His numbers are high.................. Oh hey looky their TPS. Jalen's numbers are high, but yet you guys and other people view him as a top 10 Qb. That is laughable keep trying to say that Jalen's elite. When he hasn't shown enough to be elite. If he was elite he would of won the Superbowl. I think TPS is just a bunch of fools and Hurts is just a flash in a pan.
Can we rate the worst takes by TPS. Because this is another video of just garbage takes and use of anger inducing slander. Use statistics or something to back up your thoughts. Not just calling someone awful because you don't like them. Subjective>Objective
How you guys gonna say allen and herbert are overrated and leave out Lamar Jackson. He is the definition of overrated, especially y'alls measuring stick of postseason success. That clown ain't won a playoff game and has an mvp somehow. And he ain't NEVER been a solid passer in the pros
Josh Allen is so absolutely overrated! People gave him more credit for losing to Mahomes in the 13 second game than they did Mahomes for winning it. Which is even crazier when you you think about the Bills having the top in the defense in the league at that time and the Chiefs defense was mediocre at best!
Agree with everything except putting Jalen Hurts over Josh Allen. Josh Allen may be a tad overrated for the reasons mentioned but no way you can call him overrated and not say the same about Hurts.
Love how you say josh Allen is over rated. Coming out of college everyone said they took the wrong josh. Mahomes has Reid calling plays when Allen had a rookie oc this year. Ntm half the team was injured
Saying Jared Goff is overrated is a blasphemous statement. You talked about the previous accolades in prior years of other QBs but don’t mention Goff making it to the SB in 18 and almost winning, and how he statistically was better than Josh Allen but I bet you didn’t put Josh Allen on this list 😂 crazy how the narrative on why Derek carr is overrated and Jared Goff is different. Jared Goff didn’t have a single thing last year in Detroit besides amon-ra but when he has a top 5 season and people praise him for it since he ACTUALLY had weapons now he’s overrated. Do better TPS
Jones is the most widely hated / disrespected / panned (by experts) "overrated" QB in the league. Not even half his own team's fan base believs in him. Saw this title & knew he was on the list.
Geno is not over rated, even Brock Purdy is not overrated either and I don't even like Brock Purdy, geno came from small to all and Purdy almost made the superbowl
Geno for sure overrated. People say he's a top 3 QB in the NFC after one good year where NO ONE expected anything from the Seahawks. Going into this year, no one will look at them as an easy win and if Geno isn't great, it'll hurt them early and often. I'm not trying to be mean, but if you've been doing something for 9 years and you only have one good year to show for it, you're not that good at it
Hurts isn’t on this list because he was the runner up in the MVP race last year and without him the Eagles showed how valuable he was. Plus he was a 2nd round pick , that was viewed as a reach, and never had any expectations attached to him. Aka the complete opposite of Herbert and Lawrence who have been anointed as gods since before they were drafted. The excuse that the Eagles have a stacked roster is only used to justify smack talk on hurts. When people talk about best offenses the Eagles never get mentioned.
Why do people keep saying every quarterback wins with Kyle Shanahan when the narrative was clearly that Kyle could only win with Jimmy G until last year.
Matt Ryan gave the Shanahan offense it’s best season statistically and an MVP. Also RG3’s rookie season in Washington and Matt Schaub, Andre Johnson and Arian Foster in Houston.
Quarterbacks do not win or lose games and should not be given records. It is a ridiculous concept. they are part of a 75 person team in the ultimate team sport when you count the coaching staff. Winning and losing are done by teams. I estimate that the coaching staff is responsible for about 30% of the success or failure of team. Out of the remaining 70% the special teams get 7% because they are on the field 10% of the time. That leaves 31.5% each for the offense and the defense. The offense's 31.5% is then split up between 11 positions. The quarterback, as the most important player on the field, has about 5% of the responsibility. That is why statistics, not win and loss records, are the measure of a quarterback. It is that way with every other position, why not quarterbacks? Some of the quarterbacks that you mentioned are vastly underrated, not overrated. Kirk Cousins is the first that comes to mind. In the past 3 seasons Cousins has led 25 4th quarter comebacks, a ridiculous number. In 2022 he tied the record for the most ever in a season with 8. The reason that does not add up is because the defense was so bad that they gave away 10 of those comebacks in the final minutes of the game. Even with those lost 4th quarter comebacks Kirk is on a pace to become the career leader in 4th quarter comebacks. But that is not all. Over his career only one quarterback has outperformed Cousins and that is Aaron Rodgers who is clearly a top 10 all time quarterback. Cousins has accomplished all that with mostly poor defenses and mostly poor offensive lines. For most of his career his coaches have not done a whole lot for him either. If you use the "Real GOAT" scoring system which first compares a quarterback to the average quarterback of his era Cousins scores a 411 as of the end of the 2022 season. This system uses 16 different categories and leaves no stone unturned. A score of 400 or more means that you should be in the Hall of Fame. In the most comprehensive quarterback rating system ever he outscores Troy Aikman, Bart Starr, Terry Bradshaw, Joe Namath, Ken Stabler, Bob Griese, Bobby Layne, Jim Kelly, John Elway, Eli Manning and Matthew Stafford. Longevity is a key piece of the Real GOAT system and if Cousins continues to play the same or better for another 4-5 years he will end up as a top 20 quarterback to start a career after 1946. And of course with the Real GOAT system all that can be proven.
I understand that allen is not as good as burrow or mahomes but if u look at me and say hurts is better ur an idiot hurts has had one good season with one of the most complete team in the last decade while allen has diggs knox brick hands Davis a oline that is bottom ten and no running game and he has had 2 pro bowls 4 playoff wins 1 AFC championship appearance All time bills passing yards and TDs
Geno is not overrated he hasn't been talked about enough. Herbert is a bit overrated but it's mainly his coach holding him back. Also only 2 of those int's were actually Trevor's fault; the ref missed a dpi and his receiver dropped a pass. I think Purdy deserves his respect.
OK, not saying Geno is a Mahomes or even close, but bashing him for bad play while sitting on the bench for the VAST majority of the last 11 years is bush league. Yes, he needs to validate last year by balling out again his year, but that is the stated position of EVERY analyst I have seen. Hence, nobody is OVER rating him. If you felt the need to include the NFC West, how about Murray?
Honestly, Daniel Jones deserves to be dunked on even more, I just can’t see him as the future for the Giants. Also, controversial pick, I still do not 100% believe in Lamar Jackson, the injury issues are starting to get concerning, his passing game is still a question mark, and I’m sorry but I can’t ignore the fact that he has his many playoff wins as Baker Mayfield. I’ve always found the whole “He has no one to throw to” (I guess everyone just forgets Mark Andrews exists) to be a massive excuse but this year is his chance to prove that wrong.
In Carr's defense, he doesn't play defense. Even when Brees was putting up insane seasons from 2014-2016, the best he could manage with that godawful defense was 7-9.
“as overrated as it gets” but they talk more good about geno than not. not saying he’s a top QB but sheesh, he’s not “as overrated as it gets” come on TPS
Alright this video has some mixed feelings ngl, I kinda wanna give my take on this list tho: 1. Yea let’s be real saying Dak is a top qb in the game is really shouting overrated lol, he’s had a really good team since he was a rookie and over this last season we can see what dak really is. He’s a solid good qb but he ain’t elite or top tier, just gonna leave it at that. 2. Derek Carr ngl was a pretty good qb in his early days but has sorta lost a step but at the same time you can’t point the finger at him all the time for the downfall in Vegas. He’s had a mediocre supporting cast, plus a ok coaching staff, I might be giving too many excuses but that’s just what I think about him to be honest. Like now when you see him in the league if I’m being honest he is a little overrated but at the same time the team he had on Vegas also really wasn’t the best either so I kinda think this could go two ways 3. Yea so I’m gonna be honest I’ve really never thought of Kirk Cousins to be overrated, I thinks he’s a solid starter and can get the W you need, obviously he isn’t the greatest in big moments but he still gets the job done, and if anything he seems more overhated than overrated, like last year people wanna say JJ was the reason the Vikings were winning games which is true but at the same time you gotta have a somewhat good competent qb and I honestly think Cousins had a good year, people can disagree with me but I think cousins did good. 4. So yes Goff has had an up and down career, however he did pretty solid for the lions last year to almost make the playoffs and that’s a team that wasn’t expecting big things who also had a bottom defensive as well, Goff deserves some credit for how he did last season. 5. Now, as a giants fan from watching those games, I could tell DJ wasn’t really doing much more than a game manager in the beginning, he was making sure the team got the win, however over time he started winning the games and was showing how he could be a starter, now yea DJ’s stats definitely weren’t eye popping or anything flashy but he got the job done and is progressing slowly but surely and I think Coach Daboll is a good fit for him. As for him being overrated, I don’t think he is in my opinion but then again when your Daniel Jones and you sign a contract where your making 40 mill a year, you can definitely be looked as overrated 🤷🏽♂️. 6. Yea so let’s all be real when Russ left Seattle we all just knew they were tanking, I don’t think anyone expected Geno to turn into a qb like this within one season. However Geno’s stats don’t lie, he honestly looked really good, obviously he’s over 30 so he’s not gonna be with Seattle for a long long time but he honestly made a come back and the fact he broke russ’ passing yard record is just incredible too ngl. I also like the new contract Seattle gave him as well it’s not like a hurts or Lamar deal, but at the same time it’s not some cheap one year deal, I think Geno definitely earned himself a contract and I don’t think he’s overrated at all tbh. 7. So Brock Purdy I can see why he gets the label of overrated, first he’s on the 49ers powerhouse team, and he was almost about to take them to a Super Bowl. So honestly this is a good take, he also wasn’t intended to be the starter so the sample size for him is a little smaller however we don’t know if he’s as actually good as he is or if it’s the 49ers friendly qb offense. We just need more time to see, and plus he was also a rookie so he might go through a sophomore slip if he does become SF’s starter next season. He’s a rookie and even if the sophomore slump happens I think he definitely could have a high ceiling since he’s still young. But I do think he is a bit overrated cause of how he did in that powerhouse offense. 8. Alright honestly Lawrence I feel like is progressing and you can’t prove your case that’s he overrated based on one game, yea he threw four picks but not everyone is going to have a great game all the time. T-Law has potential to be great he’s in the process tho so give it some time. 9. So ik people are gonna disagree with me on this but the Herbert I can kinda see because honestly we’re saying he’s a top 5 qb in the game and how he can go on to bigger things, people keep saying that but I don’t really see it tbh, and I’m not saying he’s bad I think he’s one of the most elite and gifted athletes but I need to see it first big things from him first like breaking records is great and all but I need to see him go far to the big game and ik it may seem expecting a lot but again this a guy who’s been called a top 5 qb for a while now. As for tps tho again you cannot say a guy is overrated off of one game, and if anything in the game Herbert didn’t even turn the ball over chargers just couldn’t get into the endzone in the second half and the defense didn’t go hard at the jags enough either. 10. Lastly im going to have to agree with the Josh Allen take here, like ik it’s pretty controversial but over this last year i would say Allen sorta took a little bit of a step back. The bills were Super Bowl favorites this whole year and in the beginning Allen did look good, but toward the middle and end he was struggling a bit, obviously the bills still made the playoffs but even the last game of the season and even the wildcard round Allen was not looking the greatest and honestly the two games the bills played which were New England and Miami should have been easy W’s but ended up being closer than it should of cause of Allen and his turnovers, so I’m not that surprised that the bills lost the divisional round. I can say that I would definitely put Burrow over him and Mahomes is always gonna be top of the qb tier, but I would not say Jalen Hurts is over him, Hurts had only one good season and is now considered a top 5 qb in the game which I don’t even see tbh cause again it’s one good season and on top of that he had the best o-line, top receiving core, great rbs, and a top 5 defense. Oh yea and let’s not forget Philly had one of the easiest schedules. Like in terms of where hurts falls in the qb tier, I would not put him in the same tier as Burrow and Mahomes, personally he should be below them, and I’m not saying he’s a bad qb cause he is progressing but he has the best roster out of all the qbs on this list, and everyone went from last year saying that this a make it or break it year for hurts to he’s a top 5 qb and honestly I’m not buying it. If anything, Jalen Hurts really should’ve been on this list. Maybe it’s the inner giant fan in me coming out but I’m still not convinced that he’s that guy. Maybe in the future I’ll be right or I’ll be proven wrong, who knows, but as of right now I believe Jalen Hurts is the most overrated qb right now. Until I get proven wrong I will keep this word Overall tho, those are my takes on this list some people may agree and other may disagree, hey think what you wanna think but I just wanted to share my opinion 🤷🏽♂️
