“War is where the young and stupid are tricked by the old and bitter into killing each other.” -That Russian guy from one of the old GTA games(IDK I never played it)
"War is old people who hate each other but don't fight. Instead young people who don't hate each other but fight." - United States Marine Corps officer
@@Satoru_Gojo_Frthat's not how it works. The officer at one point was a lt leading boys into the fight, now he's a Colonel sending other lts to go fight for him. Does that mean he's old and not willing to fight?
@@chikntaco141 I'm talking about the people who make wars official and make peace treaties official. Like the president. When has the president fought in a war? (Other than George Washington) Especially the later presidents. I see your point, though. People at the bottom can become powerful through hard work.
Война перемоловшая половину Европы и стёршая с карты 4 империи, посеяла зерно самой страшной войны за всю историю человечества. Сумрачный гений Ремарка отразил её бесподобно, а экранизация Майлстоуна не менее восхитительна. Всем мирного неба над головой.
Si que la hay, porque todas esas vidas por más feo que parezca valen y sabes cómo? Porque protegieron a su nación y al mundo entero, y si que la hubo 🫡
@@Bech3not in this one because they fought for 4 years in a war to take a 100 meter land and then return home without actually achieving anything good except trauma
Those who served, nothing we can ever say can express my gratitude. You have made sacrifices nobody could ever imagine, this short is but a taste of what some have gone through. So I thank you from the deepest part of my soul 😢❤
I'd happily say this the best war movie I've ever seen. Watched it at least 10 times. No Hollywood over dramatisation, just showing world war 1 for what it was. A pointless loss of an abundance of lives, all to groom the egos of power hungry, narcissistic leaders, living in their ivory towers. So sad and so moving. Brilliant brilliant movie!
This was quite meaningful and painful. I think of children who were sent to the front at the age of 12 and cried on the battlefield. And photos taken without thinking that it would offend them when they grow up
@@Furkan-YILDIZ my grandpa was 9 at the time when he already used heavy machine guns as an every day weapon on the eastern front in berlin back in 1944 and 1945, it's really sad, because I was told there were people younger than that, at the age of 7 already serving for the ''fuhrer'' in the hitler youth.
твой внутренний голос (я) понимает,что человек рождён и живёт на этой земле, не для этого ужаса, а для созидательного труда. что бы собирать положительный опыт, в облачное хранилище( БОГ)
Hello, the Holy Spirit today says to you: Only in Christ Jesus is there salvation, accept him as Lord and Savior of your life and your story transformed forever ⚘⚘⚘
No one deserves to get hurt. Humanity thinks that we have no enemies except ourselves but actually, we have no enemies. We forced, we overthinked or we didn't think about it. Killing is not a solution for fast population, killing is not a solution for money or food, killing is not a way to feel good, killing is not even a decide. Understanding people is way better than killing.
Seeing those giant tanks for the first time made the scene feel like a horror movie. Just these mechanical, seemingly indestructible monsters lumbering toward you and crushing your allies like tomatoes
Thankfully, as long as you knew their weakpoints and they weren't with infantry, it was easy to take them out with grenades. Unfortunately, early on, the Germans couldn't even fathom the idea of tanks.
Yeah, war is just really terrifying. Seeing your fellow soldiers getting gunned down, heads blown clean off, seeing people with missing limbs, seeing mighty tanks crush people like tomatoes and destroy buildings, seeing thousands of artillery shells raining hell to your position, hearing the planes flying above you, hearing the cries of pain from injured soldiers or innocent civillians that got in the way, its just, insanity. Theres even a quote that goes like "Everyone dies in war. Even if a person survives and goes back home, he is not the same person anymore". If you read through all this, thank you very much and i thank your great grandfather for serving.
In todays modern warfare you are always in range of something, We got fucking Hammered by Russian Kalibr Cruise Missiles in the far west of Ukraine, a whole country away from the front lines. If the enemy want to reach you they can do so far away where you cant shoot back only lie in the deepest hole in the ground like a hamster and pray you dont get killed.
@@Adil_Turysbek_TVRCThe Franco-Prussian War was not calm either, but the politicians or at least the majority did not fight it, but their parents, do not compare two conflicts that were equally terrible at the time.
@@neodeer9338No hay victoria que festejar si estás muerto, podrías morir con honor si tu país gana la guerra, pero si pierden moriste en vano hombre. Aún así da igual en un campo de batalla cualquier consuelo o motivación.
@@neodeer9338come to think of it, a mother waits for her child to come home from a way but gets nothing The people who started the war shakes hands and the child died for their cause, war sucks 💔
The tank scene and Paul seeing his friend getting burned alived still haunts me. I couldn’t imagine the horrors these men had to face. So sad a generation of boys had to kill each other over meters of land with no clear objectives other than to completely wipe out each other. Young lives snuffed out in a game played by rich warlords and kings.
Older men declare war. But it is youth that must fight and die. And it is youth who must inherit the tribulation, the sorrow, and the triumphs that are the aftermath of war. -Herbert Hoover
@@magmafamwastakenJust the life of millions of people. "We advanced a couple of kilometers, it cost us thousands of men" I don't now if the phrase is like that, but it has all the right.
Jesus replied: "I am the way, the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me" | John 14:6 | If you only receive Him, as LORD and Savior of your life, the sweet Holy Spirit will dwell in your heart
@@Mesa_13 Иисус ответил: «Я есмь путь, истина и жизнь. Никто не приходит к Отцу, кроме как через Меня» | Иоанна 14:6 | Если ты только примешь Его как Господа и Спасителя своей жизни, сладкий Дух Святой поселится в твоем сердце
@@Mesa_13 что? «Чистилище»? Фильм имеешь ввиду? Да, неплохой. Но не очень достоверный, хотя мне понравился. И этот тоже хороший, но сам роман «на западном фронте без перемен» жестче чем фильм по нему, автор ведь сам был на войне.
Jesus replied: "I am the way, the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me" | John 14:6 | If you only receive Him, as LORD and Savior of your life, the sweet Holy Spirit will dwell in your heart
@@kwng5385 Jesus replied: "I am the way, the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me" | John 14:6 | If you only receive Him, as LORD and Savior of your life, the sweet Holy Spirit will dwell in your heart
@@tallonteel6670 Kinda how every religion is. Copy and paste. Feeding lies to generations for control of the masses. Everyone thinking the same thing eventually like robots.
Война происходит не только из за жестоких стариков, а из-за природы человека! Человек не может без войны ему всегда нужен враг! Если у нас нет врага мы будем убивать и резать друг друга и даже если нет причин их все равно найдут чтобы убивать и резать так что война, убийство, смерть это сущность человека. Как бы это все прискорбно не звучало, но это так!
War is certainly a fascinating job. In some cases, they may be forcibly conscripted into the military. However, since they cannot return home alive, they must leave the battlefield no matter what. Even if they call me a traitor.
@@momsIayer_21 he is saying that people should not take war as something to get excited about when your not involved in it, unless of course your a warlord or terrorist
what do you mean, sad? do it for your country, shove some patriotism down your throat, you are doing god's work and then live your life in a way where your country don't give a s**t about you and lets you d*e or live miserable life while leveling you in the same category as someone who never lifted a finger! Totally worth it, brother #sarcasm
I never thought that the main characters were gonna die, but it shows how war doesn’t care who you are or how important you are. This film is a masterpiece
@@ulfrjotunson7840 all wars are civil wars because we are all humans trying to live on this rotting planet and all men are brothers because we are all humans trying to live on this rotting planet
@@fluffycloud1617 The longer wars go on the more the country needs soldiers so they will need to recruit younger soldiers since the others died or left the country
Can't believe my great grandfather would live through something so horrifying as this. He ended up being a sturmmann. WWI stormtrooper. He left for the USA soon after the war in 1920s. Then had many children (13) and took care of them all through the depression. Totally different breed of man. In photos he has such a kind face and a twinkle in his eye. He was said to be one of the most kind and honest people, always quick with a joke and wore a constant smile under his giant brush of a mustache. He apparently never talked to my grandfather about the war until after my grandfather came back from WW2. Two men that really set an example of sacrifice and hard work for me to follow.
In war, no one fights for honor or for the fatherland. One fights for the right to live past this moment in time and continue one's existence. -My Grandpa (who fought in the German army as a teen)
As a Russian i can say, that can’t. People just don’t want to know the truth. Even when Prigozhin told the truth about why this war was started - nobody listened to him
and this quote is still not agreeable.. because Hitler himself fought in ww1. so it doesn't apply to him..and he still praised war. he was the soldier who rose higher. unlike leaders like Winston ugly British racist guy
Yes must of us have made let our great grandfather down but remember we can make tham proud if actually start put the work in instead of being inside all day and playing video games. START going to the gym and eating better, or make yourself the best man you can stop watching porn and touch yourself.
are generation might be a disappointment but that doesn't mean you have to be get out of bed make them proud fix your self up and I'm not just saying this with a fucking ass sitting in my bed I'm saying this from experience I changed for the better now it your turn you got it 👊
@@makemegood3258You shouldn’t force others what they need to do or don’t see I also support people who playing video games but that doesn’t mean that it is bad and think as sign of weakness when those of videos games it didn’t even harm us physically or mentally compared to what our ancestors did to other people by harming them in name of religion and at that time there was no technology where we can mindlessly put blame on it because it is non living things. We can do many things without judging others for small things make into big issues for our insecurities when we can do both playing games and do exercise as we need. while you defend the acts of violence committed by our ancestors is beyond my horror. See I am not appreciating my ancestors for killing thousands of innocent people or soldier just to protect it land or family.
Jesus replied: "I am the way, the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me" | John 14:6 | If you only receive Him, as LORD and Savior of your life, the sweet Holy Spirit will dwell in your heart
The whole horror of the early 20th century is that so many bright young men volunteered for service because they had been conditioned to think it would be a glorious adventure. All they got was mindless and needless suffering. All their families got was dead fathers and sons while the ruling elite enjoyed a life of luxury that was paid for with the blood of an entire generation. There is nothing honorable or impressive about mindlessly going to war for the sake of nationalistic expansion. There's arguably something honorable about doing it to defend innocent lives in the face of an aggressor, but even that is a slippery slope and changes nothing about the fact that war is fundementally evil and insane. I write all of this as a Christian who truly believes that I would rather die for nothing than kill just for my country. Don't fall into the trap. War is an abomination and a stain on the soul of humanity.
"War is like a chess game the king so called the powerful leaders stay behind while the so called weak people fight for their fearless leader"-Me a 11 year old
@@tbfrstudio5416it is because they were "Kings" or generals, not dictators unlike now. It all changed when victory starts to depend on technologies not to man power
The worst thing is that war, any war, will never disappear from this world. even as a child, I could never have thought that I would live in a state that would fight (I myself am from Russia). the saddest thing for me is that I am Russian and Ukrainian, I have a family both there and there. And in general, any films about the war should not be compared. they show all the horror that lies in this word. Whatever nation we are, color, and religion, we are all brothers, and children of God. We are the people..
@@O22THага, я из России тоже, но войны, это самое ужасное сто делало человечество. Хотел бы я чтобы мы жили в мире много лет, но она была, идёт и будет всегда к сожалению. Все думают, что всё было нормально до войны на Украине, но это не так. Афганистан, Ирак, Иран и многие другие страны воевали то с США, то с Россией и многими другими. И этот факт печалит меня очень сильно.
I can't find the words to express what I feel. Grief combined with disgust and contempt, I don't know. But alas. I hope we will survive these horrible times in our homeland, guys. Best of luck!
