Тёмный

Anti-Liberalism and Conservatism 

The Dispatch
Подписаться 6 тыс.
Просмотров 1,7 тыс.
50% 1

Jonah is joined by Robert Kagan-a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and author of Rebellion: The Antiliberal Tradition That Is Tearing America Apart - Again-to debate Robert’s theory on the anti-liberal history of conservatism and why he thinks Trump is a logical product of the American right.

Опубликовано:

 

1 май 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 21   
@robertgalindo5979
@robertgalindo5979 20 дней назад
Why the populist-right loves Trump is the most overdeterermined answer of our time. Especially for something with such an obvious answer.
@corporalsoletrain2132
@corporalsoletrain2132 18 дней назад
I'm a NeverTrump conservative and have been from the jump in 2015. But a question often arises in my mind: why do populist lefties hate him so much? He stole Bernie Sanders' economic and trade policies, he loves Russia almost as much as Hillary and Jill Stein, his tweets weren't any meaner or more slanderous than the shit you guys made up about Mitt Romney, his cult is only marginally more creepy than Obama's, he's got two more rape allegations than Bill Clinton who he was close friends with for 30 years and to whom he donated millions... basically, he's the same as the liberals that I've been arguing with for my entire life.
@diegotomasarene-morley7249
@diegotomasarene-morley7249 2 дня назад
They aren’t crazy… they are scared for their lives. Very rational.
@diegotomasarene-morley7249
@diegotomasarene-morley7249 2 дня назад
Buckley was hard on Wallace and Leander Perez even early on. If I remember correctly.
@FreebornJohnLillburne
@FreebornJohnLillburne 16 дней назад
Courts and the common law are inherently conservative because they are supposed to adhere to tradition and rules. That’s kind of the point of courts. What you want is a “conservative” court and a liberal legislature. Moreover, Originalism is merely the judicial recognition of republicanism, which itself inherently liberal. Goldberg has it right. Originalism is conserving liberalism
@peterw.5984
@peterw.5984 19 дней назад
I'm not persuaded by Kagan's arguments.
@themetsfan861
@themetsfan861 18 дней назад
About 25 mins in, I think much of what he's arguing is incredibly weak. He seems to be defining "liberalism" in a very Whiggish sense.
@scottpandich3972
@scottpandich3972 12 дней назад
Kagan seemed to wave off too many perfectly legitimate criticisms Goldberg had. In particular, the idea that Trumpian/MAGA/whatever anti-liberalism is, in some way, a reaction to the anti-liberalism of the Left (basically, they don't play by the rules so we won't, either) seems perfectly valid to me. I was saying Trump was like a cruder, oranger version of Obama as far back as 2015/2016, and the idea of fascism being at least partly a reaction to socialism/communism has been around for much longer.
@timstevens3025
@timstevens3025 3 дня назад
You would be hard-pressed to characterize Obama as a socialist/communist. If you think that, I'd be interested in hearing how 8 years of Obama proved that thesis. It's NOT a stretch, however, to characterize Trump as an authoritarian who would flout the Constitution to hold and wield power. He's already previewed that. We don't have to guess.
@scottpandich3972
@scottpandich3972 3 дня назад
@@timstevens3025 I apologize for any confusion I may have caused you, as I was not attempting to suggest that Obama was a socialist/communist. I brought up the relationship between fascism and socialism/communism merely as another illustrative example of the general concept that right-wing movements sometimes arise as reactions to left-wing movements. The idea that Trumpian/MAGA/whatever anti-liberalism is, in some way, a reaction to the anti-liberalism of the Left, and the idea the Trump is a weird, funhouse mirror version of Obama is a different illustrative example of that general concept. I would never suggest that Obama is a socialist/communist, since he, like the progressive movement of which he is a part, actually has more in common with fascism than socialism or communism, in particular, their corporatist approach to the organization of society and the economy; the attitude toward private property evinced in Elizabeth Warren’s proposed Accountable Capitalism Act, for example, sounds very much of a piece with what Nazis and Fascists in the 1930s said about the relationship between private property and the state. That shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone familiar with history, though: in the 1920s and early 1930s American progressives routinely expressed great admiration for Mussolini. And to be clear, I am NOT saying "progressive = fascist"'; I am merely pointing out that they overlap with regard to several critical tenets, and the overlap between those two groups is greater than the overlap between progressivism and socialism/communism.
@Tunick1902
@Tunick1902 7 дней назад
Don’t know either of these guys well but feel Kagan made a very strong case and Goldberg was simply acting as a tribalist.
@diegotomasarene-morley7249
@diegotomasarene-morley7249 2 дня назад
The fetishization of originalism… it becomes a false idol in its extreme
@carneades4409
@carneades4409 20 дней назад
I'm shocked to find that the author of Liberal Fascism is clueless on this topic
@carneades4409
@carneades4409 20 дней назад
when Kagan ascribes ideological commitments to conservatives that aren't part of their self-conception that's wrong; when Goldberg call liberals concerned about civil rights post 9/11 "objectively pro-terrorist" that's fine 🤡🤡🤡
@diegotomasarene-morley7249
@diegotomasarene-morley7249 2 дня назад
Buckley and Trump are nothing alike. I don’t think Buckley would have ever come close to supporting him
@xxcrysad3000xx
@xxcrysad3000xx 20 дней назад
The problem with originalism is that, whether it's original intent of the founders or original understanding of the people at the time, their positions are not that liberal. So to bound all future legislation to an originalist understanding of the Constitution and its mechanisms, that is a major constraint on what can and cannot be accomplished. You're constraining government action to what a bunch of unrepresentative elites thought about government and could agree upon more than 250 years ago, not high liberal ideals of universal rights for all, but a kind of procedure that more often than not stood in the way of their realization.
Далее
The Great Wimpification of America
1:24:39
Просмотров 814
CAN YOU HELP ME? (ROAD TO 100 MLN!) #shorts
00:26
Просмотров 10 млн
The best home workout !! 😱😱
00:27
Просмотров 11 млн
Макс Корж
00:49
Просмотров 81 тыс.
Yoram Hazony Rediscovers Conservatism
1:11:36
Просмотров 133 тыс.
Jonah Goldberg on Conservatism and President Trump
1:28:12
Why Big-Tech is Anti-Democracy | Victor Davis Hanson
10:52
CAN YOU HELP ME? (ROAD TO 100 MLN!) #shorts
00:26
Просмотров 10 млн