Тёмный

Are Amphibia and The Owl House Really the Same Show? 

Marngel Rambles
Подписаться 8 тыс.
Просмотров 16 тыс.
50% 1

It's no secret that Amphibia and The Owl House are very similar shows with fandoms that consist of the same people. Given how similar they are, is it fair to say that one is a rip off of another? The short answer is obviously no. But the reasons for it are rather interesting.
Follow me on Twitter: / marngel23
Join our Discord server: / discord
Become a RU-vid member: / @marngelrambles
Become a patron: / marngel
Credit to ‪@Kalamity_Music‬ for the background music:
• Amphibia x The Owl Hou...
#amphibia #theowlhouse #disney #memes #disneychannel #videoessay

Кино

Опубликовано:

 

4 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 100   
@StareachValcin
@StareachValcin Год назад
Amphibia and the owl house definitely have similarities, and can be considered sister shows considering that Dana Terence and Matt Braly, who made the owl house and Amphibia respectively, also worked with Alex Hirsch on his series Gravity Falls, with all 3 shows possibly taking place in the same universe. However, the stories that Amphibia and the owl house are trying to tell are relatively different, as are the characters and their development. Amphibia at its core is about the nature of change, while owl house is about the nature of acceptance and understanding. I love both Amphibia and the owl house, although I think I like Amphibia a bit more.
@deathisautumnoflife6377
@deathisautumnoflife6377 Год назад
Owl House & Amphibia are in the same universe. This was proven with an Easter Egg in The Owl House Season 2, Ep. 21 when cutting to Luz's mom cooking and showing a newspaper on her iPad with the headline "Girl Lost in Frog Land?? Hoax??" next to a picture of Anne.
@brucealmighty3268
@brucealmighty3268 Год назад
There was also a S3 Amphibia episode that showed other worlds, and though it was blurry, you could see the Owl House itself. They also likely are in the same universe as Gravity Falls, since Eda went by the alias Marilyn in the human realm, the same name as the woman Grunkle Stan was briefly married to, and Eda does match a physical description given.
@traviswhitfield8045
@traviswhitfield8045 Год назад
Amphibia and Owl House actually do have one more thing in common. They show that cartoons are not just for kids and prove why animation should be respected more.
@Starwarsfanboy0928
@Starwarsfanboy0928 Год назад
Yes. Thank you. Animation isn’t a kids genre. It’s an art form made to be enjoyed by the general public.
@matteoassignon8000
@matteoassignon8000 Год назад
Any story driven cartoon that isn't miraculous and RWBY
@MelonLord379
@MelonLord379 Год назад
Yes. Thank you! SOMEONE had to say it!
@jamesholton2630
@jamesholton2630 8 месяцев назад
Amphibia and the owl house are now deleted
@jaxongreen21
@jaxongreen21 3 месяца назад
@@jamesholton2630what
@veronicapiccinini7956
@veronicapiccinini7956 Год назад
I like to believe that The Owl House and Amphibia are like Yin and Yang. Two opposite series that complete each other. Amphibia has The Chosen One and "Change (or more specifically, becoming a better version of yourself)" as thematic. The Owl House has The Unchosen One (a random, average person who chooses to save the world, even if they are not the Chosen One, damned be the consequences) and accepting yourself, warts and all.
@mayracordero382
@mayracordero382 Год назад
The owl house and amphibia are like sister shows and sharing the easter eggs with great stories about luz and anne so I really miss these shows a lot! 🥰🐸❤🦉🏠
@lizzievanelsen2222
@lizzievanelsen2222 Год назад
To me one of the big things that sets Luz apart from other similar protagonists that I have seeen is that at first she isn't stuck in the Demon realm, but chooses to stay there.
@8is
@8is Год назад
They’re shockingly similar; it even got to the point where it doesn’t feel like they were paralleling each other as sister shows should, but instead just doing the exact same things. That’s why I sort of understand why someone would think they are ripping each other off. I don’t agree with that since it’s not necessarily bad to do the same things and I think the shows did *a lot* of different things with their similarities. Amphibia had a lot more focus on a way different message and theme, which is why Amphibia’s ending was so different from The Owl House’s. I would say that The Owl House was a lot more story driven, which is why it got an “happily ever after” ending. TOH doesn’t have a deep meaning behind its ending since it was always much more about experiencing the journey rather than the destination since it so story driven.
@lionescrawl9861
@lionescrawl9861 Год назад
At one point a lot of stories follow the same story. Examples: Harry Potter, Star wars, Eragon
@agustinberto6138
@agustinberto6138 Год назад
I love both of them. However I'll have to give it a slight edge to Amphibia. I can't really put to words what it is that makes me choose it, but you can be for sure that they both will share a place in my heart
@Paul_Recall
@Paul_Recall Год назад
People consider Amphibia’s ending problematic? I understand some things could’ve been hinted at better, but we always knew Anne would have to leave the Plantars eventually. I absolutely loved it, and thought it was a truly beautiful and emotional ending. Life can separate us, but our loved ones will always be a part of us, and it was so heartwarming to see that message done so well.
@MelonLord379
@MelonLord379 Год назад
I agree. I would love it if she got to see the Plantars again someday, especially now sense Marcy's Journal hints at that. But I do think that the ending was essential for the show because of its theme. I cried when Anne had to tell Sprig goodbye. 😭
@MaxHumphreysMaxHumphreys
@MaxHumphreysMaxHumphreys Год назад
4:10 Anne is a pretty great character, but I personally prefer Luz over Anne. Luz is my favourite Protagonist of all time. Not only is she very relatable, but as a fellow neurodivergent, her hardships feel more real and relatable than they already are. If Luz were real, I would want to give her a big hug after all she's went through! It's almost as If I'm looking at a self reflection. A young, kind, brave, dorky, and kind of wacky human who just wants to be understood. And that... is basically everything I could ask for in a protagonist.
@Starwarsfanboy0928
@Starwarsfanboy0928 Год назад
Not to mention that many people who are neurodivergent can relate to Luz and her struggles, which makes her arc in the show all the more powerful.
@stormyandsnowy
@stormyandsnowy Год назад
I thoroughly enjoyed both shows equally. I prefer TOH, but I still REALLY enjoyed watching Amphibia! ❤
@p.lion_artz
@p.lion_artz Год назад
I love these two shows, but I can say I feel more related with amphibia about it lesson, change and letting things go, is like my whole life, moving around many places and leaving good friends, but learning to adapt to it, I think this is why my fav character is anne tho, I feel so related to marcy and her story
@LivvyTube24
@LivvyTube24 Год назад
Being completely honest, I was more emotionally attached to Amphibia, rather than The Owl House. I believe the reason why is that Amphibia focused mainly on character development, and was a lot more subtle with adding plot relevance (hence why people mistake some episodes for being "filler"). Owl House, however, was generally more fast-paced than Amphibia in terms of plot, but because of this, it prevented us from getting to know the characters as well as we do with Amphibia. So overall, Amphibia is my favorite, and very slightly better in my opinion.
@garrettscott6948
@garrettscott6948 Год назад
I wanted to make my own versions of both these shows: Both universes are actually just one: the realm of nocturnal animals. Anne Boonchuy is actually the owl lady instead of Eda, Sasha is working for the Emperor, taking Lilith's place, and the Core and the Collector are actually just one person.
@flameofdestruction271
@flameofdestruction271 Год назад
I thought i wouldn't like the owl house more i like amphibia but after seeing all the shows i felt like owl house was kinda my personal favorite cause of the plot and characters, not just about lumity. so owl house was better in my opinion
@toadlord8594
@toadlord8594 Год назад
Honestly Owl House is great but I was always personally WAY more attached to Amphibia story and characters mainly because the show centers more on the development of our cast of characters and more added nuance to them than Owl House’s character cast. In some ways Amphibia and Owl House are Yin and Yang to each other.
@MelonLord379
@MelonLord379 Год назад
Yes, I can see that. I've always been more attached to Amphibia as well, and I love that you added about the Yin Yang. Yin Yang is my soul symbol. There are different symbols for each month, and Yin Yang is mine, sense I was born in March.
@Starwarsfanboy0928
@Starwarsfanboy0928 Год назад
Despite being similar to one another that doesn't stop both shows for being amazing and giving us two of the best animated projects that came from Disney in recent years.
@traviswhitfield8045
@traviswhitfield8045 Год назад
Hell yes.
@MelonLord379
@MelonLord379 Год назад
I agree 1,000%.
@DizzieContent
@DizzieContent 9 месяцев назад
I honestly cried at both finallys so yea they have a lot in common and both finallys are sad c:
@נדבהורביץ-ג5ר
@נדבהורביץ-ג5ר Год назад
Both The Owl House and Amphibia are my favorite Disney shows. ❤️🧡💛💚💙🩵💜🩷
@MelonLord379
@MelonLord379 Год назад
Same, I also love Gravity Falls. Amphibia is my favorite of the three but I love Gravity Falls and The Owl House a lot too.
@נדבהורביץ-ג5ר
@נדבהורביץ-ג5ר Год назад
I love Gravity Falls also. The Owl House is my favorite out of the three, but I love both Amphibia and Gravity Falls a lot as well.
@MelonLord379
@MelonLord379 Год назад
@@נדבהורביץ-ג5ר I never related to The Owl House as much as Amphibia, but It's cool that it's your favorite!
@amitysluzara2022
@amitysluzara2022 Год назад
While they do certainly have a lot of similarities both these shows are also very different from one another. I slightly prefer TOH
@mr.smart75
@mr.smart75 Год назад
Both of these shows are equally great (altough I love Amphibia more than the TOH cause of it's message and themes) I had very different experiences with both of these shows! As much as I'd like to say that these shows are vastly similar I mean the differences are there! Overall though between Amphibia's ending and TOH's ending I loved Amphibia's message more cause life moves on even if you're not ready to embrace changes hey that's life! Anyway this is very big comment love your videos Marngel!
@couldntcomeupwithausername
@couldntcomeupwithausername Год назад
I love both Amphibia and The Owl House. They do share a lot of similarities, and even referenced each other a bunch of times.
@03mbc
@03mbc Год назад
Yeah they are kinda of the same show. But both amazing in there own way So sad they ended I wish they gotta more seasons.
@mayracordero382
@mayracordero382 Год назад
I wish they did has more seasons but I'm hoping for a tv amphibia movie and spin-off series of the owl house!
@Starwarsfanboy0928
@Starwarsfanboy0928 Год назад
Sad that they both have to end but hey, three years is good enough for me. Heck, even the creators love both regardless that they even did a crossover during the San Diego Comic Con back in 2021.
@lunamoth105
@lunamoth105 Год назад
1:27 also they both teleported on end of sezon 2 to human realm
@Nyanboii
@Nyanboii Год назад
I binged Amphibia and TOH, Amphibia I watched months ago and TOH just the other week. I gotta say, damn both cartoons are probably one of the peak disney shows ive watch to date.
@lydiahaynes41
@lydiahaynes41 4 месяца назад
I love both shows it's hard to say which one I prefer because they're both amazing for different reasons
@Migrane0
@Migrane0 5 месяцев назад
I chalk the similarities more up the fact that they were made at the same time by the same company. Some executives steering the shows in similar directions
@23yyyy
@23yyyy Год назад
These 2 shows have many similarities but the one that sticks out the most was that i have to pirate both season 3’s
@8is
@8is Год назад
You could’ve just used a VPN, but okay.
@23yyyy
@23yyyy Год назад
@@8is does that work for disney + hot star
@8is
@8is Год назад
@@23yyyy yes
@23yyyy
@23yyyy Год назад
@@8is oh ok
@8is
@8is Год назад
@@23yyyy It also works for RU-vid where you can see the season finale of TOH.
@tajklair
@tajklair Год назад
There similar yet distinct in their own way.
@zebrafish7267
@zebrafish7267 Год назад
Honestly, I like to think about them as two sides of the same coin. Similar in some respects, but totally different in others. Regardless, they are equally amazing.
@newsallypurpleyt8609
@newsallypurpleyt8609 Год назад
Interesting and cool vid. I agree that they are sister shows and they are in the same universe.
@Starwarsfanboy0928
@Starwarsfanboy0928 Год назад
Yes, they are in the same universe because King's Tide confirmed it. Wished we did got to see Anne make a cameo, but that would've been fan service that would've taken audiences attention away from the story. Oh well, at least we have the comic con crossover.
@vinililacart
@vinililacart Год назад
I'm only at 0:21 and already i've heard the best definition about the show's similarities, very well put!
@bigbangpegasusmaster
@bigbangpegasusmaster Год назад
"and making peace with them" *shows Anne breaking half of Andrias' body*
@MarngelRambles
@MarngelRambles Год назад
they did make peace. It just required Anne to make *pieces* from Andrias lol
@allycat545
@allycat545 Год назад
I loved both shows a lot. But i prefer Amphibia. Mainly because Amphibia's message was one i really needed to see at the time. The story and the emotional scwnes in that show also hit ne a little harder than toh. But don't get me wrong. Toh is still one of my favorite shows too! ❤
@MarcyWu-nh8oi
@MarcyWu-nh8oi 11 месяцев назад
I liked Both Cartoon Shows So Much Amphibia and Owl House Because They're My Favorites
@MelonLord379
@MelonLord379 Год назад
Wow, I never fully realized just how similar these shows were until I watched this video. Calling them Sister Shows is very appropriate, but I definitely wouldn't go so far as to call them rip offs of each other. They both have lots of things that make them unique, and as for which I prefer, I'd definitely have to say I prefer Amphibia. I definitely related to the theme and the characters more than I did in The Owl House. I love both shows, and think that both are amazing, but I have to love Amphibia more for my own personal reasons.
@Myrtus123
@Myrtus123 Год назад
I like both shows I think both shows have good storytelling buuuuuuut..... I defiantly prefer the owl house a lot more I related to Luz a lot more as character then Ann personally
@Kindog1223
@Kindog1223 Месяц назад
Same mom different dad
@csillafleischman1880
@csillafleischman1880 9 месяцев назад
I like the owl house more. I couldn't really tell you why, I just do. I do like Amphibia, but I only watched the entire thing because I knew Anne had some crazy powers, and I wanted to see her use it (and also understand the context). Marcy helped me through the second season (Man, I love that girl/woman), but I just wasn't that interested. Granted, I had watched the entirety of the Owl House by the time I started Amphibia, so that might play a role, but in terms of relatable characters to me (I know that is a highly personal thing), Owl House was more understandable. Because I still haven't found the misfit group that could help me and understand me, and Luz and the others finding each other gives me hope that it is possible. I absolutely love elements of Amphibia, too, but it mostly boils down to the calamity powers and Polly and Marcy. I also found that Luz's sacrifice was more meaningful than Anne's. I don't want to say it was cheap because it was actually well-written. I just think MC sacrifices have become somewhat of a token move, and we all know how they will turn out. That is true of Luz too, but it helped the Collector understand death there. But this is just my personal opinion, and it ties into a much longer argument about character death and why it has lost all its weight in my eyes.
@PXLFrosty84
@PXLFrosty84 Год назад
In short: Both are heavily inspired by Gravity Falls
@zonephanx5830
@zonephanx5830 5 месяцев назад
It’s also similar because Luz and Anne had this complicate relationship with this mean girl who turned out to be their loved one
@bianzdemape3862
@bianzdemape3862 5 месяцев назад
bro why anyone haven't talk about anne and luz said "alright i know what your putting down"
@calebsoria1777
@calebsoria1777 Год назад
They areNt the same show They’re the same earth, but can easily separate to different universes.
@miltonpaul4705
@miltonpaul4705 Год назад
Do a video of Amphibia and owl house characters similarly
@Vexyi
@Vexyi 5 месяцев назад
amphibia, owl house, gravity falls are canonically connected
@lydiahaynes41
@lydiahaynes41 4 месяца назад
The amphibia episode with frog Stan and Soos was a good episode
@Vexyi
@Vexyi 4 месяца назад
@@lydiahaynes41 ik I was so surprised
@noahhollers6607
@noahhollers6607 Год назад
Great minds think alike
@connorthompson8376
@connorthompson8376 Год назад
#thankyouowlhouse #ThankYouDanaTerrace #TheOwlHouse #RememberTheOwlHouse #TheOwlHouseSpinOffSeries #AnimationDeservesBetter
@deecollinssuperitandficays863
@deecollinssuperitandficays863 4 месяца назад
I like both but prefer the Owl House a bit more than Amphibia after watching them both to the very end
@edwardscurry3285
@edwardscurry3285 Год назад
I like and fibia in the Outhouse to a very Heights Dent but out of the two I'll have to get the extra an extra five hundred points out of them both getting a hundred out of me because the Outhouse has more of that inspirational feeling of reminded us and telling us that it's okay to be yourself no matter how much time passes by in life that it is never too late to find your true self and that's what both losing and have found the loose. It anymore evolve way will she can still be at peace with the people she has grown to know in the world especially her more connected she feels to herself and those around her😇🤩✌️
@ThatBooCarlos
@ThatBooCarlos Год назад
Yes
@bluebellsforever
@bluebellsforever 4 месяца назад
Marcy and luz are the same character, but i like luz more
@pjvil8638
@pjvil8638 Месяц назад
Probably because Luz is the main character
@bluebellsforever
@bluebellsforever Месяц назад
@@pjvil8638 also she's way funnier
@popculturedata
@popculturedata Год назад
They're similar shows, maybe they're secretly the same show but from seperate dimensions
@bristleflight303
@bristleflight303 Год назад
I like owl house better, i have only watched thd first season of amphibia but i got bord, the characters werent that relatable. Ann was anoying. Eda is way vetter than hop hop becouse she desplats way more live and compation and i share her struggles and over all i just like it way better.
@Salamiix
@Salamiix Год назад
both of these shows are AMAZING! They are probably my two favorites and they are also really similar in many ways and i do think they are both sister shows not copies of one another though i do like Amphibia more TOH definitely deserves second place! (in my opinion ofc)
@S0bahz
@S0bahz Год назад
If i had a nickel every time a show includes a mc who is half american and travels to another world with her found family i would have 2 nickels; it isnt alot but its weird it happened twice
@Kirbana-68
@Kirbana-68 Год назад
no
@jazjaywilliam1749
@jazjaywilliam1749 Год назад
Owl house is better
@Thila-Thila
@Thila-Thila Год назад
Opinions are opinions, but I prefer Amphibia than The Owl House even though I love both shows
@jazjaywilliam1749
@jazjaywilliam1749 Год назад
😊 👍
@viliamsneakman1508
@viliamsneakman1508 Год назад
I love both but I like Amphibia more.
@sizar9003
@sizar9003 Год назад
Luz = Anne - girl find herself in magic world Eda = Hop Pop - old parental figure Belos = Core - basically just evil character with nothing complex about them Collector = Andrias - redeemable villains who is manipulated by pure evil one
@Lalandia-fy6qb
@Lalandia-fy6qb 9 месяцев назад
I prefer Owl House.
@Guard1anfan
@Guard1anfan Год назад
Ok I’m going to be honest I love TOH and dislike Amphibia-
@TripleAAABatteriesStudio
@TripleAAABatteriesStudio Год назад
How come?? Just wondering.
@Guard1anfan
@Guard1anfan Год назад
@@TripleAAABatteriesStudio I just never really got into it maybe I didn’t like the frog concept I just don’t really know
@ShevaAlpha2002
@ShevaAlpha2002 Год назад
I love both of these shows. However, I prefer Amphibia to The Owl House. Because I found the comedy and the message of Amphibia to be much stronger than The Owl House.
@pinguimalfaro5349
@pinguimalfaro5349 Год назад
The comedy of Amphibia is a little forced, but is fun
@brendonslife4584
@brendonslife4584 Год назад
Amphibia is better 😍😍
@pinguimalfaro5349
@pinguimalfaro5349 Год назад
Don't think so
Далее
Why is The Owl House More Popular Than Amphibia?
9:01
Which Cartoon Did Possession Best? An Analysis
18:20
Просмотров 316 тыс.
What if P.J Masks was a Young Adult show?
31:38
Просмотров 375 тыс.
The Owl House's Finale was ALMOST Perfect
30:21
Просмотров 154 тыс.
How The Owl House Quietly Fixed Its BIGGEST Flaw!
27:53
What If Luz Was Sent To Amphibia? | Channel Frederator
24:36
Emperor Belos Is A Great Villain | The Owl House
9:47
Looking Back at Old Theories of Amphibia
14:12
Просмотров 43 тыс.