Are Palestine encampments free speech?

Подписаться 983 тыс.

Просмотров 14 тыс.

50% 1

CLARIFICATION: The First Amendment standards described in this video only apply to public colleges and universities. Private institutions have more power to restrict speech.
Are the Palestine protests happening on public college campuses protected speech?
Encampments prevent other students from using the space, cause disruptions to campus activities and create a public safety risk. So no, they aren’t protected speech. You also don’t have a First Amendment right to protest wherever, whenever, or as loud as you want. You do have a right to share controversial statements and signs. #FirstAmendment #freespeech #college #palestine #protest

Опубликовано:

19 май 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 174

@noneyabizz8337 27 дней назад

As soon as your actions start impacting the rights of someone else, you've got problems.

@charleswyllie426 27 дней назад

That's the entire point, they want to disrupt normal functioning until the university cuts off its relationship with the defense industry.

@izumi2165 15 дней назад

it's so fucking ironic to say that when they are just a minor inconvenience for others rights while they protest in order to put a stop to human rights violations with numerous war crimes, which, if you ask anyone who isn't brainwashed, is more important than your right to have clean walls/floor or a place to sit on grass

@charleswyllie426 15 дней назад

@izumi2165 they're not really protesting to stop the war though, even though that's the position of their chants/slogans, they have concrete demands for their institutions to stop partnering with and investing in the arms industry. A few schools have acceded to student demands and the protests stopped overnight.

@wompa70 27 дней назад

The government can’t restrict your speech. That’s why even though I thought social media companies were making a mistake in suppressing certain posts, I also thought they were within their rights as the service providers. That changed when it came to light that the government was directing the whole thing.

@Todd_Swank 25 дней назад

Well, they moved from being a platform to a publisher when they start removing posts based on their advertisers whims. They just need to start being treated as publishers and sued for libel like the NYT and washington post would be if they published untrue statements.

@nathandunlap7921 18 дней назад

Hate speech is a crime

@JoeHeine 27 дней назад

"Protected speech" itself is a weasel term

@Fodkdj 27 дней назад

True, all speech should be protected, but property rights are more important

@Kian139 26 дней назад

@@Fodkdj the speech in freedom of speech is any communication of thoughts and ideas within you property rights. If laws protect or violate freedom of speech is another question. Freedom of speech is essentially a property right.

@Fodkdj 26 дней назад

@@Kian139 you’re right, I just worded it poorly

@torg2126 26 дней назад

@@Kian139 so can I graffiti your walls? Your rights end where the next person's begin, for good fucking reason.

@auronsavant 24 дня назад

Not everything is. Defamation isn't, personal threats isn't, and shouting fire in a crowded theatre isn't. Protected speech is an appropriate term

@charleswyllie426 27 дней назад

Dwight Eisenhower had something relevant to say about universities with ties to the defense industry: “In the same fashion, the free university, historically the fountainhead of free ideas and scientific discovery, has experienced a revolution in the conduct of research. Partly because of the huge costs involved, a government contract becomes virtually a substitute for intellectual curiosity.”

@drkarim-kq9md 27 дней назад

When you arrest your professors for freedom of speech then think twice being a pro genocide cheerleader.

@Kian139 26 дней назад

Is the pro genocide cheerleading when people call for intifada and "from the river to the sea"? Those are chants for genocide and jews say "not this time".

@46dkm 27 дней назад

The protest itself is constitutional. The other things that they are doing such as the danger to public space getting other peoples way no those are charges that should be filed, and these people should be jailed, but the speech itself is protected.

@samuela1918 27 дней назад

If we can critize and shutdown Palestinian protests then we should be allowed to also shut down any hatefilled campaigns against white people.

@Lucky-si5lz 8 дней назад

Right and only a fraction of people actually know what's going and aren't just doing it/saying it for attention

@Brian-zf8jl 27 дней назад

Its a university. This is what kids do, they take cringey political stances and act a fool. Spare me the public safety bullshit, that's just beaurocrat talk for death by technicality.

@dogguy8603 27 дней назад

Cool, just dont bother other tuition paying students, that includes keeping walkways free, etc etc

@charleswyllie426 27 дней назад

Keep your university's money out of the defense industry and vice versa and these kids will have to protest about something else

@chase-warwick 27 дней назад

You have a right to protest but you do not have a right to be disruptive especially on private property.

@Brian-zf8jl 26 дней назад

@@dogguy8603 Seems to me that's up to the university. There are plenty of universities out there that don't let their students act like animals. Go there.

@lithium25693 27 дней назад

So if the 1st amendment can be regulated then the 2nd amendment can also be.

@imcannabess 27 дней назад

You don’t have a First Amendment right to camp out on a college campus.

@tektekken176 27 дней назад

The second amendment is regulated you clown 😂 there are over 50,000 gun laws in the US. Now you get it

@flyingphoenix113 27 дней назад

The...2nd amendment is heavily regulated? Idk what your point is. Have you never heard of the National Firearms Act (NFA)? The Assault Weapons Ban of 1994-2004? And, countless other pieces of 2nd amendment legislation?

@jerrymiller9039 27 дней назад

The second amendment is regulated but it is still a fundamental right of all Americans to own the weapons of their choice. If you want to put limits on it okay but they need to be reasonable and based on each individuals actions.

@tektekken176 27 дней назад

50,000 gun laws on the books says the 2nd amendment is regulated

@stand4justice4867 27 дней назад

They're paying their tuitions they have the right to use the facilities to protest against génocide.

@AnonymousPerson-hr6qd 27 дней назад

no they don't they are paying tuition for classes and other activities that is defined by the university, not whatever the heck they want to do.

@chase-warwick 27 дней назад

Paying tuition doesn't mean I have a right to disrupt the universities activities. That would mean any student could with enough other like minded people cudgel the university into supporting any idea regardless of whether it was actually valid.

@davidtucker9498 26 дней назад

I hate to be the one to tell you, but actually they are protesting FOR the genocide of Israel. They literally support Hamas and their goal of wiping out Israel. Yes, Democrats have become literal Nazis.

@jaredwilliams8621 24 дня назад

1. Paying tuition does not give you full reign on a campus. Paying tuition gives you access to classes and other services provided by the college. 2. These protesters are disrupting access to classes and services for other students who are also paying tuition. You are allowed to say what you want, but once you begin taking something from others, you are no longer participating in protected speech.

@jeremywheeler2122 25 дней назад

Can you incite violence by yelling from the river to the sea?

@pennyelizabethcreasey6559 23 дня назад

Do you even know what that means?

@reycantu1747 27 дней назад

No such thing as protective speak about Israel They are a protective species

@stephanmarcus448 24 дня назад

So you only get to protest in ways that can be ignored? I don't think you're getting it.

@omerfaruk-mc8im 2 дня назад

Sir,the people PAID to have that yard. The students didn't bomb Palestine innit?

@fascistpedant758 27 дней назад

In other words, you can say whatever you want as long as no one else can see or hear you. If everyone had always followed her rules, she still wouldn't allowed to vote today.

@joshjoshinson3452 27 дней назад

Do you think women in the civil rights movement created encampments on public property and then blocked men from entering a public space? No. They protested during daylight hours in public areas peacefully, then dispersed after. Big difference between that and these terrorists you call protesters.

@valtrojo 27 дней назад

this is a very closed minded analogy from this video. please re-watch the video and re-evaluate this statement edit: this is also not "her rules", it's law

@jerrymiller9039 27 дней назад

No but OTHER PEOPLE ALSO HAVE RIGHTS . That is the part that you do not understand.

@jackhuenger7274 27 дней назад

Civil disobedience is not protected free speech. It can be a useful tool for change, but it's not protected. Being arrested for it is kind of part of civil disobedience.

@KeithGroover 27 дней назад

The video is only like forty seconds long and you still didn't watch it. Sheesh.

@Todd_Swank 25 дней назад

Sorry, but unless you call for violence, when and where and how loud is and should be allowed on all public locations. You can even yell "fire" in a theater. You arent banned from doing so, you are banned for ruining the private businesses services.

@pennyelizabethcreasey6559 23 дня назад

OMG the ignorance you show is so embarrassing. Yes you can be kicked out if not from the establishment then from the rest of us. We're sick of your types.

@eksffa 22 дня назад

No it’s not. End

@draighodge6039 23 дня назад

Squatting is a crime.

@bkf778 22 дня назад

That’s in a home. Not on a lawn in a school you pay tuition to. Why are all Zio’s so opposite of smart?

@draighodge6039 22 дня назад

@bkf778 A thief is a thief: squatters, robbers, burglars, larceners, and pickpockets are all stealing, that is, they seize the property of others. Anyone who notices is a moralist not necessarily a 'Zio'. Does Mohammed condemn stealing?

@terryweber2214 24 дня назад

At least they're not playing video games.

@wackywankavator 10 дней назад

This video is very anti-libertarian.

@dsgio7254 22 дня назад

.....Noise..... levels ...... ? hahaha Dear the same things were saying when people engage in civl disobedience asking for civil rights .. Didn't they ?

@sadiagazi6987 19 дней назад

Wa wa wa cry me a river. As a holocaust is happening in Rafah you whine about people protesting to stop the killing.

@PocketsxEDC 27 дней назад

I feel you but it is and should be protected speech. Let these idiots spout nonsense for all to see so we can develop a reality based opinion

@LittlePenguin1-17 26 дней назад

First Amendment grants use the right to protect and speak freely. But that don’t protect us from saying mean things to our employers and not face consequences from them. Or protest on private property instead of public property.

@johnwatson6194 27 дней назад

karen the topic is not so simple. we call ourselves a country of laws but we are not a country of laws. boston tea party participants broke all sorts of laws but saw it fit to do so.

@grifdenton5224 21 день назад

Indeed. "Country of Laws" is a cop out politicians use when trying to infringe on fundamental rights.

@TheActualFrozenCactus 16 дней назад

Is this FSU?

@gwenstefanirockx 27 дней назад

It's also vandalism.

@johnwatson6194 27 дней назад

is someone who happened to be near the encampment who is also voicing anti war sentiment also an arrestable law breaker? apparently so because many were beat up who were not part of the encampment.

@user-lp5nm8is7d 27 дней назад

They don't care

@BeaconOfHope1948 22 дня назад

Cesspools of hate are what they are. Am Yisrael Chai Forever 🎗️

@ZOMBIEHEADSHOTKILLER 27 дней назад

WRONG! it is protected. protesting is a natural, and constitutional right, covered by both freedom of speech, and the right to assemble. Indeed you can "protest whenever, wherever, and as loud as you want" protesting is specifically supposed to be disruptive, unpleasant, inconvenient, and yes, even unsafe... if people dont like it, they can change their ways so there is nothing to protest against. PROBLEM SOLVED.

@jerrymiller9039 27 дней назад

You have a right to free speech but other people also have rights such as peacefully attending a school that they pay large amounts to attend. You do not have a right to interfer with others rights and nobody has any obligation to either listen to or care about your protest.

@dylanprinster2798 27 дней назад

by SCOTUS precedent, many encampments fall into time manner place restrictions and clear and present danger tests, and therefore not all form of protest is lawful

@Hedgehobbit 27 дней назад

You have the right to "peaceably" assemble, not "disruptively" assemble.

@scoutwilliams5875 27 дней назад

You described terrorism and hostage taking perfectly. You should be spokesperson for the protests so they can finally say something that’s true.

@ZOMBIEHEADSHOTKILLER 27 дней назад

@@Hedgehobbit 1. disruptions are not violent by default, some are peaceful. 2. protests have no obligation to be peacful, especially when protesting non peacful things.

@jimmars 27 дней назад

tents are a public safety risk. that is gold. OBEY such a weak hit piece.

@DarkMatterX1 26 дней назад

That isn't what she said at all. Your reductive fallacies are comical.

@jimmars 26 дней назад

@@DarkMatterX1 remember when you were wearing a mask in public because of the public safety risk you posed to others . That was gold too!! Obey

@DarkMatterX1 26 дней назад

@@jimmars I didn't wear a mask. Except on occasion I wore a Soviet era NBC mask to mock the vaxxies.

@Vlad-sw4zd 26 дней назад

I don’t like the argumentation here. The only property which can be protected by freedom of association is a private one. If the college is public, I’m not sure I can find reasons to defend government repressions. And I know for sure that about 5 years ago they used the same argument to forbid protests in Russia, saying you have a right to protest but not everywhere. All the city squares are occupied with public festivals and people walking, so the protests will disturb them.

@Kian139 26 дней назад

Public property is property. How do you make that distinction?

@Vlad-sw4zd 26 дней назад

@@Kian139 well, yeah, but it is built on taxpayers money If the campus territory is anyone’s property it is taxpayers property And taxpayers have a right to protest against the way their money is spent right in the building it was spent on

@Kian139 26 дней назад

@@Vlad-sw4zd nowhere in the world does that logic hold. Not all public property is public space. Private property can also be public space.

@luffydragon6600 27 дней назад

Palestine 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸

@bsmithhammer 27 дней назад

NOPE.

@rocklee5231 27 дней назад

🥱

@sebholding 27 дней назад

No. Because something called "private property".

@Riggy931 27 дней назад

Public universities aren’t private property entirely and even if they were most of the students protesting would have rights to use it.

@philc7653 27 дней назад

@@Riggy931 many of these larger protests had huge numbers of people that didn’t go to that college.

@Riggy931 27 дней назад

@@philc7653 sure, but students are allowed to invite people over to their spaces on campus. Regardless, I am of the believe that free speech is actually absolute and not dictated by governmental whims. Public university land should be free and accessible for protests at all times.

@Alt300 22 дня назад

@@Riggy931well until they ask you to leave thats when they can arrest you for staying

@Riggy931 22 дня назад

@@Alt300 yes, I’m saying that’s stupid. Imagine knowing something is public, as in paid by the public. And the government choosing when the public can use it to exercise their rights. Universities were invented as public forums, let them be that

@ramstrong1961 27 дней назад

what a load of bs (unsubscribe)

@TTHBLOX_ 20 дней назад

Free palestine🍉

@MandyMoorehol 26 дней назад

Lololololol

@yellow4525 23 дня назад

Imagine getting smart and young people together ans expecting them not to protest

@LinneaOvretveit 22 дня назад

You're so MEAN SO SO EVIL...#FREEPALESTINE

@Dylan-ji1xx 22 дня назад

Only evil here is hamas

@apexalaska 22 дня назад

You literally have no idea what you are even saying. You are completely ignorant of the history, geography, and politics, of what you are advocating for, yet you just scream it out like a literal NPC. Just brainwashed and programmed to shout out nonsense gibberish with zero original thoughts in your vacuous head.