Тёмный

Ashoka Buddhism Controversy Exposed | Keerthi History 

Keerthi History
Подписаться 2,3 млн
Просмотров 539 тыс.
50% 1

Ashoka the Great, probably the one Indian king we all have studied in schools, How great he was, How he planted trees, How he converted to Buddhism after witnessing the cruelty of Kalinga war.
What if I tell you it’s all A BIG LIE?
The evidence Ashoka’s own inscriptions tell a completely different story. I think it’s time to dig out the facts and counter the lies we have been told for generations.
The story we have been told is Ashoka the great Emperor invaded a tiny kingdom Kalinga. But the people of Kalinga were not ready to surrender either. So the Kalinga war happened which resulted in the death of 1,00,000 people which is a huge number of population 2000 years back. So Ashoka felt really guilty and converted to Buddhism and practiced nonviolence for the rest of his life.
This is the story we have been told for years.
This is the story which is still being taught in schools.
We even have movies based on the story.
But how far it is TRUE?
It’s high time we uncover the actual story of Ashoka based on the inscriptions and evidence we have instead of making a fake story.
Follow Me On Other Social Media Platforms
Facebook: / keerthistory
Instagram: / keerthihistory
Twitter: / keerthihistory
Support Me As A Patreon : / keerthihistory
About Me :
I am a passionate History Graduate with a deep love for uncovering the forgotten stories of India. With a keen eye for detail and a relentless drive to uncover the truth, I have dedicated my life to exploring the rich and complex history of country, shedding light on the forgotten aspects of India's past. Through my tireless research and dedication to the craft, I am committed to ensuring that the legacy of India's rich cultural heritage will never be forgotten!

Опубликовано:

 

19 дек 2023

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 5 тыс.   
@Keerthihistory
@Keerthihistory 7 месяцев назад
Suggest me few topics for next videos please ❤️
@cricketophile133
@cricketophile133 7 месяцев назад
If british had never come to India
@ahelimukherjee1619
@ahelimukherjee1619 7 месяцев назад
Women Scholars of ancient india
@cricketophile133
@cricketophile133 7 месяцев назад
India's if no foreign invasion happened
@vajitelugucreations90
@vajitelugucreations90 7 месяцев назад
Actual story of Alluri Seetharamaraju..
@SMVM99
@SMVM99 7 месяцев назад
Who ruled Kerala during ancient times and how it ruined.
@biswajit681
@biswajit681 7 месяцев назад
I don't understand why you all RU-vidr historians don't put your facts sources in the description?? It is always good practice to mention the references.
@arjun111
@arjun111 6 месяцев назад
Because she wants to create propoganda 😂
@user-es2lz7qo1k
@user-es2lz7qo1k 6 месяцев назад
Yes what is your base. What kind of research you did.
@shreekumar7262
@shreekumar7262 6 месяцев назад
Ashoka is actually a butcher
@Atheistprogrammer1
@Atheistprogrammer1 6 месяцев назад
Source : trust me bro
@codewalters
@codewalters 6 месяцев назад
And that's the best point. People believe history is black and white . History is also politics in the past.
@chalanadilshanrodriguez5429
@chalanadilshanrodriguez5429 7 месяцев назад
I am a Theravada Buddhist from Sri Lanka. According to Sri Lankan books, he became a Buddhist after the Kalinga War. He propagated Buddhism, so he was called Dharmashoka. Ashoka Chandashoka Dharmashoka .... It is mentioned in the books that Ashoka did not wars after becoming a Buddhist. I'm not saying I'm 100% right. .. I have little knowledge of Indian historical sources. Which Indian source mentions that Ashoka fought wars after the Kalinga war......................... Mahindra Thero, the son of Emperor Ashoka, brought Buddhism to our country. In ancient times, the people of Sri Lanka called India as Jambudhveepa. According to our books, Emperor Ashoka built 84000 Buddhist temples all over Jambudhveepa. Buddhism was given to many Buddhist countries in the world Emperor Ashoka. He is a hero to Theravada Buddhists.
@animeworldixr5951
@animeworldixr5951 7 месяцев назад
No worries Bro His Legacy is unmatched its natural that south indians and odias hate him we hindus and buddhists are one Ashoka was shavite even after becoming buddhist
@user-ju9ii1hf3v
@user-ju9ii1hf3v 7 месяцев назад
True , after the war of kalinga he did so many good things for all the people inside his empire and international trade
@chalanadilshanrodriguez5429
@chalanadilshanrodriguez5429 7 месяцев назад
@@animeworldixr5951 Thank you brother. We respect Hinduism... It is our own thing.
@cryptonash16
@cryptonash16 7 месяцев назад
Why did he have to destroy the Kalinga (BlackLinga) empire? Just to promote Buddhism and appease Bhikkus, He tried to destroy the Linga worship religion which is from Kalinga and Telinga (Trilinga) Desam. The Kalingas were a very rich empire with rich trade history with South East Asia for thousands of years. Any Indonesian and Malaysian always refer to dark or Indian-looking people as Keling. After the Kamboja/Saka/Aryan invasion into India everything changed. The Kalingas fleed to Southeast Asia or Bangladesh, some even migrated to the Hinterlands or South India to save themselves. You see alot of Shaivite temples in the south and also as far as Champa (Vietnam) as they brought the Linga culture with them. Every King was always power-hungry.@@animeworldixr5951
@shubhamdubey9561
@shubhamdubey9561 7 месяцев назад
​@@animeworldixr5951fk your Buddhism
@arjun111
@arjun111 6 месяцев назад
Respect for great asoka his symbol of lion is our national symbol🙏🙏🙏🙏
@soulflower2021
@soulflower2021 4 месяца назад
Right it's to me like Germany would put hakkenkruz in their flag 💀
@user-2c5Goi0fr8id-m
@user-2c5Goi0fr8id-m 7 дней назад
@@soulflower2021 No wonder they want Persians, Greeks and Brits to call the nation Bharat. *Rig Veda 10.23.4* "In this rain, Indra throws drops of moisture on his yellow beard" *Rig Veda 1.130.8* “Indra defends his Ārya worshiper. He consumes the malignant; he tore off the b_______ skin; and him who delights in cruelty.” *Rig Veda 2.20.7* “Indra, slayer of Vṛitra, destroyer of cities, scattered the b______-sprung servile.” *Rig Veda 3.34.9* "Indra gained possession of the Sun, Horses, Cow. He struck the Dasyus, and gave protection to the Ārya tribe." *Rig Veda 9.73.5* “They have roared in unison, burning up riteless men, Blowing away the b______ skin which Indra hates.”
@soulflower2021
@soulflower2021 7 дней назад
@@user-2c5Goi0fr8id-m what is this gibberish you are spewing here ? ..loser chutiya with bad understanding of Vedas
@abhishekmaurya2587
@abhishekmaurya2587 5 месяцев назад
In the book Ashoka Vadan, Emperor Ashoka has been described as very cruel because by showing him cruelty, he wanted to prove that he was initially angry and later became a Buddhist. He gave up his anger. If you want to know the true history of Emperor Ashoka, then Know them from inscriptions not from books
@Upanishad11
@Upanishad11 16 дней назад
😂😂 Ashok inscription mentioned he was Buddhist before Kalinga war .
@Upanishad11
@Upanishad11 16 дней назад
Mourya empire established by chanakya , not Ashok 😂😂
@r.dhammapali778
@r.dhammapali778 7 месяцев назад
I'm a Buddhist nun from Srilanka and our great historical chronical Mahavamsa has a several chapters dedicated to Ashoka. And I believe most of the historical facts the world know by now are either taken from Ashokan rock edicts or from Mahavamsa. If there are other sources I think you should better mention them in your narrative. It is true that a king has always limitaitons in following parama ahinsa and an emperor is even less capable. However Ashoka contributed a lot for Buddhism by holding the third sangha council since Lord Buddha's passing away and it is as a result of that council that he sent missionaries to seven areas including Srilanka. By this time both his son and daughter had enetered the order pf sangha and Srilanka received both of them, first Maha Mahinda thero his son, along with Buddhism and then hos daughter Sanghamiththa theri with a sapling of the Bodhi tree under which Lord Buddha attained Buddhahood. The countries which received Buddhism from Ashoka still remains Buddhist to this day so unlike the empire of Alexander the great which collapsed soon after his demise the dharma empire of Ashoka the great still remains well intact today. Making him quite close to a chakravarti raja mentioned in Buddhism. (But not completely). P. S - it's better if you include references to your information under the video description.
@nvvinaykumarch3529
@nvvinaykumarch3529 7 месяцев назад
Thanks for the details. However, her only point is that he was already a Buddhist before the war. Yes, we can ask for references.
@LucknowPropertiesPlotHouseBuy
@LucknowPropertiesPlotHouseBuy 7 месяцев назад
This info she got is from tv series and nothing else. She is not a historian of any kind. RU-vid People are making myths according to their taste.
@Factscraft
@Factscraft 7 месяцев назад
​@@LucknowPropertiesPlotHouseBuyisne ye bi kaha Bindusar ki wife Brahmin thi lekin woh toh ek Jain thi saathi pura mourya Empire buddist or Jain the naaki vedic or hindu
@Nomad97249
@Nomad97249 7 месяцев назад
New history
@davelawson2564
@davelawson2564 7 месяцев назад
reference is stone edicts of ashoka not half baked stories from Mahavamsa
@zerefdragneel2445
@zerefdragneel2445 6 месяцев назад
After all that "Ashoka will always be the Great King in the Entire Indian History", all hail to Chakravarthy Samrath Ashok
@dreamingaboutjungkook3930
@dreamingaboutjungkook3930 6 месяцев назад
Why not chandragupta and Bindusara the great? Because they were hindus
@user-tg3vq6qf6h
@user-tg3vq6qf6h 6 месяцев назад
​​@@dreamingaboutjungkook3930Chandragupta us always mentioned above Ashoka Bundusara was nothing compared to both if them
@Soumyadeep_exe
@Soumyadeep_exe 5 месяцев назад
​@@user-tg3vq6qf6hwhat 😂 did you know South was conquered by bindusar upto mysore Ashoka only conquer kalinga and khotan region From my opinion Chandragupt maurya>>bindusar>Ashoka
@user-tg3vq6qf6h
@user-tg3vq6qf6h 5 месяцев назад
@@Soumyadeep_exe Ashoka conquered in a different way He had the biggest empire for any Indian
@shreyanssinha9029
@shreyanssinha9029 5 месяцев назад
There were not 😂​@@dreamingaboutjungkook3930
@ayanbiswas6035
@ayanbiswas6035 6 месяцев назад
Mam , what you mentioned the inscriptions, any references for these?
@opkhanna6521
@opkhanna6521 6 месяцев назад
Source trust me bro 😂😂
@cyrilmatthew2995
@cyrilmatthew2995 6 месяцев назад
Reference:- Trust me bro
@ShaikhKhajaPeer
@ShaikhKhajaPeer 6 месяцев назад
@@cyrilmatthew2995 HAHAHAHAH....what a reliable source, where is this located "Trust me Bro"
@vibhamishra8692
@vibhamishra8692 4 месяца назад
He had refered Buddhist scripture of Srilanka...
@AnonymousTraveler-ze2vm
@AnonymousTraveler-ze2vm 3 месяца назад
She is hoping that people will not do their homework. This is called right wing orthodox Hindutva revisionist history. However, one must still have compassion regardless. So sad that the only emperor that is proof showing India was not just a non-political entity before the British is attacked this way despite the fact that Hindutva claims India was a political entity before the British. Diabolical indeed
@RajaClasses
@RajaClasses 7 месяцев назад
Who will always support Keerthi Histery rise there hands....🤚🤚🤚
@Keerthihistory
@Keerthihistory 7 месяцев назад
🥺🫶❤️
@VijayKumar-vy8uo
@VijayKumar-vy8uo 7 месяцев назад
​@@ronniegeorge9761 I support my mother language grammar too 😊
@dinesht4149
@dinesht4149 7 месяцев назад
🤚
@1jerrynimoparker
@1jerrynimoparker 7 месяцев назад
✋✋✋
@world.employment.organization
@world.employment.organization 7 месяцев назад
A Sri Lankan sinhalese here. Ashoka is revered by us as a great buddhist emperor. There're asura and sura rulers in every faith; occasionally, a country cannot function without violence. It's not possible for a ruler to expand his empire, defend and propagate a faith without violence in those days. Do you believe that the medieval rulers who followed islam and christianity were devout? Did they propagate their faith with ahimsa? I don't think so.
@broony8547
@broony8547 7 месяцев назад
Hello ..I'm a srilankan and as you all know buddhism is the religion of majority here. Buddist monk called "Mahinda" The son of Ashoka the great came here and established buddhism as a result of 3rd 'dharma sangayana' which was conducted by king Ashoka.And dear Keerthi I think it's not that much fair to judge a great king by some information you collected from various types of resources. There could be so much untold , unwritten stories in history that you probably can't explain in a couple of minute youtube video.It's almost been 2000 years do you think people who had been lived through all those years didn't notice a single thing you say? Don't know whether stories we've been told true or a lie but forever greatfull for bringing buddhism here for the sake of politics or with the thought of spreading buddhism. ps. Be aware before beliving everything that random youtube historians say.This video is filled with lack of information and biased (why I say it's biased ; I've seen hefty amount of people's hate towards king Ashoka for the fact that he converted in to a buddhist.And most of them are hindu people.Can't help with that. Can't change history.Pleas don't hate someone just because they don't belong to the same religion as yours.) I'm amazed of amount of people that compliment these kind of videos without any kind of research . Hope people will do more quality contents.
@pawannnnnnnnnnnnng
@pawannnnnnnnnnnnng 7 месяцев назад
He accepted Buddhism for his use but still he spread it because he wanted the support of the people of his country
@aalampara7853
@aalampara7853 7 месяцев назад
Mahinda or Mahendra is not son of Ashoka! No such proof exists externally! They were just Buddhist monks
@broony8547
@broony8547 7 месяцев назад
​@@pawannnnnnnnnnnnngMaybe... but anyway buddhism is such a great gift we got from India.❤
@funtimefunny2153
@funtimefunny2153 7 месяцев назад
Wow Keerthi is so knowledgeable , wow she exposed hard working historians who spend their entire lives studying and yet dont know what happened soo many years ago , yet she with her infinite knowledge knows everything
@Jr.Champion
@Jr.Champion 7 месяцев назад
keerthi conviction towards BJP & Sangha's so adorable 😊
@abhishekmaurya2587
@abhishekmaurya2587 5 месяцев назад
You can know the history of Emperor Ashoka only from his inscriptions. If you know from Buddhist books then you will be very confused because in Buddhist books he was described as cruel because they want to show that he was cruel and later became Buddhist. In the inscription of Emperor Ashoka, there is mention of his living brothers. You can read in inscription number five which is the inscription of Kalsi.
@sunilparmar1894
@sunilparmar1894 5 месяцев назад
Please attach the source of information in the description ❤
@MrKarambeer
@MrKarambeer 7 месяцев назад
She says let us assume on every point and she tries to paint a different picture...if she's such a great historian why doesn't she write a book and mention all the edicts and challenge the old versions???
@opkhanna6521
@opkhanna6521 6 месяцев назад
She is graduated from WhatsApp University 😅😄
@user-sf3dj9is8h
@user-sf3dj9is8h 6 месяцев назад
That's because only Communists and urban Naxals are allowed to write History, and their source is their imagination 😂
@user-sf3dj9is8h
@user-sf3dj9is8h 6 месяцев назад
​@@opkhanna6521whatsapp has a lot of Information but you are educated in imagination University 😂
@anyone510
@anyone510 5 месяцев назад
She failed in 10th
@prakashk5904
@prakashk5904 4 месяца назад
Part of propaganda to rewrite history
@RajKumar-bf3wd
@RajKumar-bf3wd 7 месяцев назад
Impressive explanation. Many stories have been added with so called secularism by our historians, but now things are changing with the reality coming out. 😇😇😇
@Keerthihistory
@Keerthihistory 7 месяцев назад
@amoghaudupa
@amoghaudupa 7 месяцев назад
@@Keerthihistory so that means Ashoka the great is actually Ashoka not so great
@animeworldixr5951
@animeworldixr5951 7 месяцев назад
Mate dont beleive everything you hear blindly most of the things she told has no proof except buddhist sources plus fun fact these so called sources were many years after Ashokas death. In Ashokas time there as no concept of religion like today everyone followed dharma or sanatan or mixture of indic faiths people say Ashoka was a buddhist but no one will tell even after becoming buddhist Ashoka was a Shavite Ashoka own son was devotee of Mahadev @@amoghaudupa
@Gupta_Dynasty
@Gupta_Dynasty 7 месяцев назад
​@@Keerthihistoryfake history brahminism dharma taller plz debate with science journey and
@SatyamSingh-fm2bn
@SatyamSingh-fm2bn 7 месяцев назад
​@amoghaudupa74 Probably he was not... and this story was formed to create an impression that Hindus are the one to be blamed and should be converted to Buddhism.
@user-vq7th1mz8t
@user-vq7th1mz8t 5 месяцев назад
Absolute non-sense explanation without any references.
@vissapragadasatyanarayana2750
@vissapragadasatyanarayana2750 4 месяца назад
But the whole point is whether king Ashoka was already a Buddhist when he started the Kalinga war?.
@Patienc1persistent
@Patienc1persistent 4 месяца назад
​@@vissapragadasatyanarayana2750yes he is because in inscription there was no mention that chandragupta was Jain's or ajivik . Even Jain word was not spoken at that time. Which proves that chandragupta was Buddhist. For more information search SCIENCE JOURNEY channel.
@JohnnieWalker-pw5yj
@JohnnieWalker-pw5yj 2 месяца назад
​​@@vissapragadasatyanarayana2750 But the point is whether King Ram was already Hindu when he started Ramayan war...? (Logic lovers stay away from this ques😅)
@Shankar-qx7wq
@Shankar-qx7wq 2 месяца назад
As per Sri Lanka Ashoka converted to Buddhism before Kalinga war
@Shankar-qx7wq
@Shankar-qx7wq 2 месяца назад
@@JohnnieWalker-pw5yj no he is not because there is no such thing as hinduism and only gods exist at that time
@jishudas
@jishudas 5 месяцев назад
Could you provide your fact checking links? I mean I am sure you did not go and read those inscriptions on those stones. Where is this data coming from?
@savinduvidanage8001
@savinduvidanage8001 7 месяцев назад
Please note that most of the historical texts and legacies about Ashoka the great had been found in srilankan budddhist texts and mahavamsa . So under the british colonel era they adopted these theories and stories to made the current indian incomplete history .(the current indian history is a british made one and disorted the srilankan history also ) The written sources about Ashoka you can find out by referring the srilankan historical books and inscriptions❤
@Bloercon.Anurag_256
@Bloercon.Anurag_256 7 месяцев назад
Mam , I'm 14 years old boy in 9th std from a very very poor slum of Mumbai that is kalwa and you are the best and great teacher who explains me the true history beyond my Maharashtra state board textbook, thanks a lot ma'am 😊🎉
@internationalenglish7413
@internationalenglish7413 7 месяцев назад
This is the best comment I have ever seen on RU-vid. You will succeed in your life. You may become a Doctor, Scientist, a social reformer, Leader, or whoever you wish. God bless you.🙏
@Keerthihistory
@Keerthihistory 7 месяцев назад
🥺❤️🙏🏼
@tbeingsocial
@tbeingsocial 7 месяцев назад
My dear 14year old boy.. all this history shown is true but teachers are only going to pass you if you follow the text books so do not get confused and give answers as per the book. Keerthi.. idk but if possible try taking steps in a way where our education system changes and that's majorly required in India
@Bloercon.Anurag_256
@Bloercon.Anurag_256 7 месяцев назад
@@internationalenglish7413 thanks btw I wanna be a space scientist i.e an astronomer but I can't afford fees😞😔 btw I come 1st in my class and I couldn't even afford a tution but my father took a loan and gave me a tablet..☺️🤗
@Bloercon.Anurag_256
@Bloercon.Anurag_256 7 месяцев назад
@@tbeingsocial sure didi ☺️🤗
@Learnthruplay
@Learnthruplay 6 месяцев назад
Whoever does your the animation on your videos should do a whole movie or series on Indian history. I always feel our country has so many stories that never get depicted properly
@RichardJucewicz
@RichardJucewicz 4 месяца назад
thx! i ll check it out. remains my question for this moment about the emblem. what do you see it represents?
@user-hq2il1jc6h
@user-hq2il1jc6h 7 месяцев назад
Next topic - Romani gypsies persecution (indian origin dalit, banjara and lohar community living in Europe)killed by nazis, Christian missionaries.
@Keerthihistory
@Keerthihistory 7 месяцев назад
Noted
@user-hq2il1jc6h
@user-hq2il1jc6h 7 месяцев назад
@@Keerthihistory thanks keerthi 🕊️ you are doing a great job 👍👍👍
@GoogleAccount-yi2le
@GoogleAccount-yi2le 7 месяцев назад
Nice topic
@weronikaasomsson2404
@weronikaasomsson2404 7 месяцев назад
There will be 2 earthquakes in Alaska ( 7.6 and 7.3) After that children will go missing. It will be Jesus who is coming with promised redemption! Our God has revealed all those details to his prophets right now and He is coming in promised redemption. But governments will say it was UFO. Now you have been told in advance, so do not be deceived. Only God knows the future. Jesus loves you, accept him as your Saviour and be safe! We are in the last pages of the Bible now. What saves us is the faith that Jesus He bled and died on the cross, and he was resurrected three days later. His blood cleansed us from our sins so that we can stand in front of God blamelessly. Believe in what he has done for us with the full heart, confess your sins to him and pray, build a relation with him. Ask him to come into your heart. It is God's grace that saves you. It's nothing that you can do but what he has done for us. No works required. Call upon him as Your Lord and Saviour!(see also Bible, 1 Corinthians 15:1:6)
@trueobc5727
@trueobc5727 5 месяцев назад
Banjara, great warrior made by birth criminals by British Lohar are not dalits, they are वैश्य, doing manufacturing of irons
@kaakutstha
@kaakutstha 7 месяцев назад
Incredibly, it was known as far back as the 1920s, that Ashok was already a buddhist for several years before the Kalinga war. R.G. Bhabdarkar mentions the fact in his book published in 1926(?). So there isn't the slightest doubt that we have been deliberately fed a blatant lie for 76 years post independence!
@Keerthihistory
@Keerthihistory 7 месяцев назад
🥲
@deepmalarajeshkhanna5905
@deepmalarajeshkhanna5905 7 месяцев назад
​@@Keerthihistoryakka pls There is so many anti-hindu things happening in indai Even in histories Thats why 😓🇮🇳🕉🚩pls save We minorities suffering in muslim nations
@Divine_Vibes_
@Divine_Vibes_ 7 месяцев назад
​@@deepmalarajeshkhanna5905where do you live bro/sis??
@UjwalRam
@UjwalRam 7 месяцев назад
Why even this story has been manipulated. They should be happy to show that our king is ruthless na.
@davelawson2564
@davelawson2564 7 месяцев назад
@@UjwalRam then hindus will become violent , then how can muslim rule continue as it has for past 75 years since independence ?
@T-Series_theatre
@T-Series_theatre 5 месяцев назад
🚩🚩So here is the PHD student of WhatsApp University founded by BJP😂😂
@renukadasjoshi4096
@renukadasjoshi4096 4 месяца назад
What is stopping you from debunking her claims with solid facts? I doubt you have that by the way
@aryanmore8392
@aryanmore8392 5 месяцев назад
Source: believe me bro 🤡🤡
@sarthakverma5670
@sarthakverma5670 5 месяцев назад
Source:my followers are pure andhbhakt beleive anything that glorified hindu not any other
@yuvraj35929
@yuvraj35929 12 дней назад
Cry 😂😂😂​@@sarthakverma5670
@ugarajahgovindasamy6933
@ugarajahgovindasamy6933 7 месяцев назад
A lie can travel halfway around the world while the truth is still putting on its shoes----Mark Twain
@Keerthihistory
@Keerthihistory 7 месяцев назад
💯
@rajkamble-fr6dm
@rajkamble-fr6dm 7 месяцев назад
​@@Keerthihistorynice made up stories, now I want you to provide evidences about the whole video you have made up and if you're such sure then do a debate not with me , I have a guy to do with , If you are ready for it then say it I'll let you the name
@MainakBose666
@MainakBose666 7 месяцев назад
Exactly what's happening with this sort of misinformed videos.
@ugarajahgovindasamy6933
@ugarajahgovindasamy6933 7 месяцев назад
​@@rajkamble-fr6dm You are simply being emotional.Ashoka's atrocities are mentioned in Ashokavadana which were written in Pali by Buddhist monks.If you want to find fault then go after the writers.
@ugarajahgovindasamy6933
@ugarajahgovindasamy6933 7 месяцев назад
@@MainakBose666 Who is misinformed,you or her?
@Madhavi6131
@Madhavi6131 7 месяцев назад
Really it's bizarre to know the facts of Ashoka, how wrongly we were taught about him in our history books. Thankyou Keerthi for tracing out the facts and wide opening our eyes😢
@animeworldixr5951
@animeworldixr5951 7 месяцев назад
BRO PLEASE DON'T BELEIVE HERE BLINDLY PEOPLE DON'T REALISE THAT THERE WAS NO CONCEPT OF RELIGION LIKE TODAY ALL FOLLOWED DHARMA OR MIXTURE IF INDIC FAITHS ASHOKA ONE SON WAS SHAVITE AND FUN FACT MOST OF THE CALLED SOURCES WHICH WRITE BAD ABOUT ASHOKA WERE WRITTEN IN 5TH OR 6TH CENTURY CE 600 YEARS AFTER ASHOKA YOU ONLY TELL HOW AUTHENTIC THEY ARE IT IS NOT WRITTEN IN ANY OF HIS RICK EDICTS ABOUT KILLINGS OF AJIVIKAS AND JAIN PAINTER ANOTHER FUN FACT THERE IS NO WHERE WRITTEN ASHOKA LEFT HINDUISM EVEN AFTER BECOMING BUDDHIST HE WAS A SHAVITE AND USED TO FEED 100 BRAHMINS ASHOKA IS GOAT 🗿 🇮🇳 PROUD TO BE BIHARI 🇮🇳 JAI HIND JAI BHARAT 🇮🇳
@animeworldixr5951
@animeworldixr5951 7 месяцев назад
BRO PLEASE DON'T BELEIVE HER BLINDLY MOST OF THE SO CALLED BUDDHIST SOURCES SHE MENTIONED WAS WRITTEN IN 5TH OR 6TH CENTURY CE 600 YEARS AFTER ASHOKA
@ghoshsuman9495
@ghoshsuman9495 7 месяцев назад
In the time of Ashoka, Hindus faced terrible oppression. Ashoka aimed to convert everyone to Buddhism, and many of our sacred texts were destroyed by Buddhists. They almost wiped out Hinduism from our land. But in Kalinga, people fought fiercely to keep their beliefs alive. The entire state resisted, even children joining the struggle to defend Hinduism. Later, Sri Sri Adi Shankaracharya emerged, spreading Hinduism's message across the country once more. Against all odds, Hinduism rose again, reclaiming its place in our land.
@Sahil-lover-gy6dj
@Sahil-lover-gy6dj 7 месяцев назад
@@ghoshsuman9495Read major edict 3 of ashoka
@rassik142
@rassik142 7 месяцев назад
We have been taught Indian history in the wrong words. The historians made certain people as 'great' and conveniently ignored the real heroes in our history, this might be for their vested interests. When I was a student of history I had many questions appeared in my mind which was unanswered. Now I am getting answers one by one. The time is up to rewrite our history with the actual incidents without any dilution. Thanks to Keerthi for providing such valuable information. Jai Bharat Mata 🙏.
@archanas.958
@archanas.958 6 месяцев назад
Actually, his step brother announced as crown prince he fought his brother for the high king's position because of some ministers who seen Ashoka as a more capable king and wanted him to rule this under their influence he fought with susima and won the empire and took whole empire under his control even the people of Empire wanted him to be the king..
@aryanmore8392
@aryanmore8392 5 месяцев назад
What is your source of information???? Can you tell me...
@palakdelouri5263
@palakdelouri5263 7 месяцев назад
My grandfather had read alot about Ashoka and even he told something really similar to what you have mentioned in the video. Good to know, that my grandfather was reading through the right sources.
@Keerthihistory
@Keerthihistory 7 месяцев назад
🫶
@Hyper_Facts712
@Hyper_Facts712 7 месяцев назад
​​@@Keerthihistory One thing u missed you telling history with this timeline ur absolutely wrong these are now Religion . According to timeline of that history Sanatan was Civilization people only had Culture according to weather Jainism, buddisum, Ajivika's, Charvakas these are school's of thoughts these people were learning in that time because of them we are still in the way of Sanatan these people always question we Answered and we lerned these are not Religion just a school of thoughts
@funtimefunny2153
@funtimefunny2153 7 месяцев назад
​@@KeerthihistoryWow you are so knowledgeable , wow you expose hard working historians who spend their entire lives studying and yet dont know what happened soo many years ago , yet you with your infinite knowledge know everything
@gk47ab.1
@gk47ab.1 7 месяцев назад
Same here
@shobhagorghate3571
@shobhagorghate3571 7 месяцев назад
​@@KeerthihistoryWhats App University Graduate🎓 Sold People Trying To Manipulate History📖 Ashoka He Is Great Warrior And Empire Of India 🇮🇳
@user-mc5lt8sy5d
@user-mc5lt8sy5d 7 месяцев назад
Grandson of ASHOKA, 𝗦𝗮𝗺𝗽𝗿𝗮𝘁𝗶 𝗥𝗮𝗷𝗮 was a 𝗝𝗔𝗜𝗡 shravak, He had built more than 2500 𝗝𝗜𝗡𝗔𝗟𝗔𝗬𝗔'𝗦. 🙏
@animeworldixr5951
@animeworldixr5951 7 месяцев назад
TRUE ONE OF HIS SON WAS ALSO A SHAVITE PEOPLE DON'T REALISE THAT THERE WAS NO CONCEPT OF RELIGION LIKE TODAY ALL FOLLOWED DHARMA OR MIXTURE IF INDIC FAITHS AND FUN FACT MOST OF THE CALLED SOURCES WHICH WRITE BAD ABOUT ASHOKA WERE WRITTEN IN 5TH OR 6TH CENTURY CE 600 YEARS AFTER ASHOKA YOU ONLY TELL HOW AUTHENTIC THEY ARE ANOTHER FUN FACT THERE IS NO WHERE WRITTEN ASHOKA LEFT HINDUISM EVEN AFTER BECOMING BUDDHIST HE WAS A SHAVITE AND USED TO FEED 100 BRAHMINS
@vishweshwarraoantharam1863
@vishweshwarraoantharam1863 6 месяцев назад
You have given such a detailed narration on king Ashoka as if you were present during that period.
@vaibhavkrish4619
@vaibhavkrish4619 6 месяцев назад
Buddhism is not actually meaning the follower of gautam buddha gautam buddha never created any religion he just give knowledge and shows the path of peace innerself
@omprakashshende797
@omprakashshende797 18 дней назад
👍👍👍
@shobhagorghate3571
@shobhagorghate3571 7 месяцев назад
Whats App University Graduate🎓 Sold People Trying To Manipulate History📖 Ashoka He Is Great Warrior And Empire Of India 🇮🇳
@opkhanna6521
@opkhanna6521 6 месяцев назад
Yes She is WhatsApp University graduate 😂
@sham_arya
@sham_arya 6 месяцев назад
Cry harder kiddo
@vissapragadasatyanarayana2750
@vissapragadasatyanarayana2750 4 месяца назад
But the whole point is whether king Ashoka was already a Buddhist when he started the Kalinga war?.
@yaminisingh1717
@yaminisingh1717 4 месяца назад
You should read NCERT than said anything about her
@navinsingh5564
@navinsingh5564 3 месяца назад
Jalil na😂😂😂😂😂 go read history.and that time budhism was not a different relgion as of now
@sudheerreddy5761
@sudheerreddy5761 7 месяцев назад
The way you elaborate the history is like watching an interesting movie❤
@arjun111
@arjun111 6 месяцев назад
Truth is Science journey 🙏🙏🙏👍👍
@gouravsharma8304
@gouravsharma8304 5 месяцев назад
that liar journey was alredy eposed way back😂😂😂 jab usko buddhist text dikhaye to manne se hi mana krr dia 🤣🤣 debate se bhag gya vo bhemta
@dph3729
@dph3729 4 месяца назад
@arjun111.absolutely right bro.🤝 She knows nothing.
@Stoic623
@Stoic623 5 месяцев назад
I am from Karnataka recently watched a videos of Dharamendra Kumar’s sir. Channel “ Mysorina Kathegallu” he explains well. He goes the places and explains and shows the evidence Bloody shit she is lying by showing piece of paper that is no where found. There are four ancient places found related to Buddhism 1. Sanathi. Yadir 2. Maski Raichur 3. Rajaghatta Doddaballapur 4. Kanagina Halli. There are few more . She is spreading lies.
@pranalipatil5779
@pranalipatil5779 7 месяцев назад
Can please include the historical evidence that crown Prince Sushima was out of patliputra when bindusara died. Because I remember reading that Sushima was unable to counter the rebels and was called back and Ashoka was send in his stead. Plus Ashoka already had support of lots of ministers. Because his horoscope said he would be a chakravarti samrath.
@AmanYadav-ie6fp
@AmanYadav-ie6fp 7 месяцев назад
I am not aware of all the edicts, but knowledge which I got till now is that although Ashoka had kept his sword but he was ready to take it whenever a threat approached. How can we expect a ruler to follow the path of non violence to complete extent ? Either he would have given up his kingdom like Buddha, only then we could imagine that all the violence which he did after convertiong to Buddhism was not ethical ? How can we forget a ruler has two religions, one which he follows personally and other which he has towards his subjects? It's relevant even now. Even if he would have completely discarded the violence, he would have been responsible for the fall of the empire, like Firoz Tughlaq? He is surrounded by both the sides. You will all never spare him. Before blindly following anyone, just have fact check and form your own opinion. History is not that much easy and straight forward as you all are taking it.
@mohanbandivadekar2232
@mohanbandivadekar2232 7 месяцев назад
You are right she is a one sided pleader who wants to show Ashoka was brutal,she has to consider he was emperor
@krato6468
@krato6468 6 месяцев назад
What danger did mauryan empire had from kalinga? ashoka massacred the common people of kalinga. That's not a warrior's religion. That was a tyrant's cruelty. This has nothing to do with buddhism, whether he adopted it before or after. The truth is common people were massacred by the tyrant ashoka.
@AmanYadav-ie6fp
@AmanYadav-ie6fp 6 месяцев назад
@@krato6468 that's what I am saying he has nothing to do with Buddhism in administration. Buddhism was his personal religious affiliation
@user-vx8sb4kg5c
@user-vx8sb4kg5c 6 месяцев назад
The question is why the wrong story is being told in history.
@PirateRadioPodcasts
@PirateRadioPodcasts 4 месяца назад
Meh. Historical RE-visionism, driven largely by modern day politics.
@jaligamraju7496
@jaligamraju7496 7 месяцев назад
Trust me Keerthi ma'am I started beleiving ur history more than our academic books and more than our history lecturers 🎉🎉🎉
@Keerthihistory
@Keerthihistory 7 месяцев назад
Damn! That’s scares me honestly. I really have to very careful with my informations🥺❤️🙏🏼
@Keerthihistory
@Keerthihistory 7 месяцев назад
Damn! That’s scares me honestly. I really have to be very careful with my informations🥺❤️🙏🏼
@Keerthihistory
@Keerthihistory 7 месяцев назад
🥺❤️🙏🏼
@funtimefunny2153
@funtimefunny2153 7 месяцев назад
​@@KeerthihistoryWow you are so knowledgeable , wow you expose hard working historians who spend their entire lives studying and yet dont know what happened soo many years ago , yet you with your infinite knowledge know everything
@funtimefunny2153
@funtimefunny2153 7 месяцев назад
​@@KeerthihistoryWow you are so knowledgeable , wow you expose hard working historians who spend their entire lives studying and yet dont know what happened soo many years ago , yet you with your infinite knowledge know everything
@meghrajnadar5158
@meghrajnadar5158 7 месяцев назад
Not a history student but like to understand history good work
@Keerthihistory
@Keerthihistory 7 месяцев назад
You don’t need to be a History student to understand to history of our own motherland ❤️
@user-mh3ws1ol5c
@user-mh3ws1ol5c 7 месяцев назад
@@Keerthihistory nailed it ❤️
@Hyper_Facts712
@Hyper_Facts712 7 месяцев назад
​@@KeerthihistoryAshoka did what Indian's King never did, in this land not a single king killed any civilian they always respted everyone and we have 100s evidence to say our kings never tried to king there brothers to take over all the power
@weronikaasomsson2404
@weronikaasomsson2404 7 месяцев назад
There will be 2 earthquakes in Alaska ( 7.6 and 7.3) After that children will go missing. It will be Jesus who is coming with promised redemption! Our God has revealed all those details to his prophets right now and He is coming in promised redemption. But governments will say it was UFO. Now you have been told in advance, so do not be deceived. Only God knows the future. Jesus loves you, accept him as your Saviour and be safe! We are in the last pages of the Bible now. What saves us is the faith that Jesus He bled and died on the cross, and he was resurrected three days later. His blood cleansed us from our sins so that we can stand in front of God blamelessly. Believe in what he has done for us with the full heart, confess your sins to him and pray, build a relation with him. Ask him to come into your heart. It is God's grace that saves you. It's nothing that you can do but what he has done for us. No works required. Call upon him as Your Lord and Saviour!(see also Bible, 1 Corinthians 15:1:6)
@mr.spongebob13
@mr.spongebob13 7 месяцев назад
​@@Keerthihistorybecause of asoka we knew the history of Gupta empire, Maurya empire,nanda empire and all those empire till 7AD so pls don't compare asoka with anyone and give him respect as a god
@Reincarnation111
@Reincarnation111 5 месяцев назад
I don't know how historically true all that she said is, and if this is inscribed on monuments, how could it remain unknown - hidden in plain sight? However, I personally never considered King Ashoka great. Even a 5-year-old child may know that aggression and violence are WRONG....and it took him killing millions to realize that? 🤔🤔
@sasmitsatyam5775
@sasmitsatyam5775 7 месяцев назад
this so chosen twist of history...she is just protecting Hinduism...
@Shrikrishna679
@Shrikrishna679 7 месяцев назад
Mam you also provide information that Samrat Ashoka alone did he really built 84000 Buddhist monasteries? According to Leftists those 84000 Buddhist temples destroyed by Brahminical forces During ancient Times whether it is true or fake? If Ashoka alone really built 84000 buddhist viharas now only few of them survived but later what happened to those Buddhist temples? Now where are they? Dr Ambedkar in his books said all ancient Buddhist structures destroyed by islamic Invasions but his so called followers deliberately argue paralogically those Buddhist structures vandalised by brahminical forces itself Plz you do video regarding this topic Keerthi mam 🙏
@bijoydasudiya
@bijoydasudiya 7 месяцев назад
The Brahmins led by Pushyamitra Shunga decimated Buddhism but the OBCs are fools to politically support the rightists who surprisingly deny their rights blatantly. It's travesty of truth and distortion of history by the Neo-Nazi party as a part of their conspiracy of false propaganda and subsequent monarchy.
@OSLO-TheLabrador
@OSLO-TheLabrador 4 месяца назад
Please provide authentic sources in the video or in the description box. So we can research more on our own. I hope this is not a propaganda video. History needs authentic source, archeological survey reports, majority of historians should agree on the fact.
@pradeepshet3494
@pradeepshet3494 6 месяцев назад
MAM WHATEVER IT MAY BE WHAT IS AND ALWAYS WILL BE THE GREATEST EMPEROR OF INDIA IS SAMRAT ASHOKA . CAN'T CHANGE.....
@kishorek2272
@kishorek2272 7 месяцев назад
Like Samrat Ashoka Maurya the great,King Raja Raja cholan I the great was also highly supports the Buddhism even though he was a shaivaite Hindus and he gave a land in Aanaimangalam to the Buddhist monks🇮🇳🚩👑🐯🐅⚔️🕉️☸️❤️🔥!
@amoghaudupa
@amoghaudupa 7 месяцев назад
Ashoka is not great
@harsh6764
@harsh6764 7 месяцев назад
​@amoghaudupa7450 Ashoka is Great and he will be forever. He is greater than shivaji. Ashoka is considered as Greatest kings of all time in the world
@kishorek2272
@kishorek2272 7 месяцев назад
@@harsh6764King Raja Raja cholan i the great(Ponniyin Selvan):-The spiritual successor of Samrat Ashoka Maurya the great because he was also loves and helps both the Hindus and the Buddhists in his own Empire like him🇮🇳!
@amoghaudupa
@amoghaudupa 7 месяцев назад
@@harsh6764 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 The man who caused the death of more than 2 lakh people in the Kalinga war despite being a practising Buddhist just bcoz he wanted to conquer it... The man who wiped out the Ajivika sect by killing 18000 Ajivikas and Jains just bcoz they showed the Buddha in a negative light... The man who ordered every single Jain monk to be executed just bcoz they showed the Buddha bowing down before a Jain Tirthankara... The man who killed 6 of his brothers to claim the throne... Morally, do you think such a man is great?? He was a great conqueror for he expanded the Mauryan Empire , but he was never, is never and will never ever be a great man for his violent ways... On the other hand, Chhatrapathi Shivaji Maharaj fought to protect Bharat and Hindu dharma by laying out the platform for Hindavi Swarajya... He respected women and severely punished the people who violated the honour of women... He also facilitated the reconversion of people to Hinduism from Islam... He protected Hindu temples as well... Chhatrapathi Shivaji Maharaj was the leader of the people... Ashoka was not... I am not a Marathi... I am a Kannadiga... I don't give a damn about linguistic differences... My nation and dharma comes first to me and I will celebrate every single warrior who fought to protect our nation and civilization... Whether it's Chhatrapathi Shivaji Maharaj, Maharana Pratap, Chhatrapathi Sambhaji Maharaj, Raja Suheldev, Immadi Pulakeshin, Raja Raja Chola, Sri Krishna Deva Raya, etc... Chhatrapathi Shivaji Maharaj was the leader of the people... Ashoka was a violent and ruthless man... It's a shame that you don't want to accept Chhatrapathi Shivaji Maharaj who protected your ancestors, but will happily accept Ashoka who wiped out an entire philosophy (Ajivikas)
@schoolkid1809
@schoolkid1809 7 месяцев назад
​@@kishorek2272All Tamil king's are always supports nd Respect other Religious ~
@katb5007
@katb5007 7 месяцев назад
The presentation of the life of Emperor Ashoka the Great seems highly biased and far removed from the historical facts. It is true that Ashoka had already converted to Buddhism few years before the Kalinga war but probably he did not practice it seriously in the sense of complete renunciation of violent means as an emperor. The real transformation in Ashoka came after the kalinga war and he actually started his journey on the path of the Dhamma since then. So where is the contradiction? His pilgrimage to the Buddhist holy places, patronage of the Dhamma and building of 84,000 votive Stupas spread all over the subcontinent bear testimony to his devotion to Buddhism post-kalinga war. That Buddhism in a short span of time spread far and wide in all directions from the land of its birth leading to its present status as a world religion shines as the glorious achievement of Emperor Ashoka. There is no evidence that Ashoka resorted to any violent means after Kalinga war as winning people's hearts through Dhamma was his stated goal rather than military conquest. It seems that for some so called historians especially in present day India it is hard to digest the fact that the greatest emperor in their history had adopted Buddhism and had tried to establish Dhamma Rajya, a society based on the ideals of social equality and harmony.
@pathiranasir.
@pathiranasir. 5 месяцев назад
you are playing fool. india din,t have integral histry unless they found parallel sri lankan history to navigate their historical line up. That is not my agument. That is great indian historian expression .
@mint583
@mint583 6 месяцев назад
I guess you forgot to mention the references on the basis of which you have made the video. Can you share the reference of the shilalekh that was found on stambha?
@Harisksmsksm
@Harisksmsksm 7 месяцев назад
Only one inscription where tell about Ashoka Wel..! if you anyone have doubt regarding Ashoka.. considered the divanapiaya inscription everything has been tel abt Ashoka.. most of scholars said after the Kalinga war.... Ashoka didn't conquer any kind war because he move to buddist that the reason but who knows... After the kaligha war also ahokaa wil conquer the World.. different types of historien tel different types of thoughts Note it.😂 Freiends History is not wht happened history is wht we write that is the history...😢 4:38
@deepankartripathi4599
@deepankartripathi4599 7 месяцев назад
Everytime I fell in love with the analysis, with history, the broken myths and in love with keerthi .. ❤
@Keerthihistory
@Keerthihistory 7 месяцев назад
🫶
@funtimefunny2153
@funtimefunny2153 7 месяцев назад
​@@KeerthihistoryWow you are so knowledgeable , wow you expose hard working historians who spend their entire lives studying and yet dont know what happened soo many years ago , yet you with your infinite knowledge know everything
@deepankartripathi4599
@deepankartripathi4599 7 месяцев назад
Please realise the context , even if you read romila thapar she mentions even "Dhamma". Policy wasn't a religious move but a political move to enhance the position and influence of Ashoka ..@funtimefunny2153
@deepankartripathi4599
@deepankartripathi4599 7 месяцев назад
@@jinkigang when you devote yourself to a specific religion it means you follow the believe and customs of that religion in later and spirit , so draw a corollary between Ashoka and Chandragupta maurya...Chandragupta accepted jainism and moved to perform the extreme practice of starving upto death and died ..this was expected of Ashoka too if his voice of conscience resulted in change of heart but these are debatable topics ...open to views
@deepankartripathi4599
@deepankartripathi4599 7 месяцев назад
Ashoka neither before nor after Kalinga favoured non violence ( as per hard working historians not my view )
@shailibutola2411
@shailibutola2411 5 месяцев назад
Conclusion : WHY ???
@richajain7131
@richajain7131 6 месяцев назад
I salute you Keerthi for your study and bringing the truth to new generation. 100 slaps on the authors of NCERT books who distorted history and write Akbar the great or Ashoka the great
@Rishi-zu4ue
@Rishi-zu4ue 7 месяцев назад
Moral of the vedio : every person who had a Great prefix was a merciless maniac ...... prime examples Alexander,Akbar and Ashoka . Western historians think More land under control means more greatness 😂. And can't bear Purushottam das slayed their Boy...😅
@Madhura_Yuvaraj_Badhe
@Madhura_Yuvaraj_Badhe 7 месяцев назад
I thought I would not br studying history after 10th but here I am watching your videos because they are so interesting. Thank you for this knowledge, Keerthi ma'am 🙏 Please keep making such informative videos and letting us know the truth.
@raju8516
@raju8516 7 месяцев назад
Bro this a propoganda channel dont take her seriously . Asokavadana is not a historical document its a religious text written 400yrs after asoka death. And its full of magical miracle moral stories like asoka walking on water, flying in sky, healing diseased monks just by toching. That violence part is also a fabricated moral story to warn people that who accepted buddism when they deviate towards violence karma hits them and suffers more(like ashoka brother death)
@Madhura_Yuvaraj_Badhe
@Madhura_Yuvaraj_Badhe 7 месяцев назад
Well, I have not said anything, just thanked Keerthi ma'am for this knowledge @@jinkigang
@Madhura_Yuvaraj_Badhe
@Madhura_Yuvaraj_Badhe 7 месяцев назад
But yes what you say does make sense @@jinkigang
@Madhura_Yuvaraj_Badhe
@Madhura_Yuvaraj_Badhe 6 месяцев назад
But then why did he kill the innocent people?@@jinkigang
@Madhura_Yuvaraj_Badhe
@Madhura_Yuvaraj_Badhe 6 месяцев назад
What excuse would you give for him killing his own brother?@@jinkigang
@guttula_sai
@guttula_sai 3 месяца назад
May I know if it is Ajrikas or Ajivikas? As when I searched for the term Ajrikas I could not find any but instead I found it when I searched for the term Ajivikas.
@debashishmohapatra1372
@debashishmohapatra1372 4 месяца назад
I am from Kalinga modern day Odisha. Please make a video on Kharabela the kaligna king who dig out Ashoka Buddhism philosophy and reestablished the Sanatan Dharam.
@AK-ct8bb
@AK-ct8bb 7 месяцев назад
The problem with Santani historians is that they are more of "Kathawachak" than historians. No inscription read here as a reference which is an integral part of credibility. 1.Ashoka was a lay budhist before Kalinga war. His father was an Aajeevak and Mauryans were also Buddhist Not Sanatani. 2. Alexander Cunningham was the historian who discovered history of Ashoka. No Indian was aware of such a great emperor. 3. The fact she's trying to say are based on a scripture Ashokawadana not an inscription. If you read Ashokan inscription his teaching ideas prove him to be greatest emperor of all time. But for very obvious reasons since he was a Buddhist so these "Sanatanis" never like him and try to demean him in every possible way. 4. Ashoka was fond of his brothers he made an artificial Hill called "Bhikuna" Pahar for him brother the remains are still there. 5. He sent his daughter and Son for propagation of Dhamma in Srilanka without any violence he spread Dhamma every where such a great king he was. 6. His rock inscriptions, Stupa are rich cultural heritage of India. 7. Just imagine the Sanatanis who were not aware of the existence of great king are now writing fictional stories to prove that he was cruel king??? 8 These Brahmins even called Ashokan pillar as " "Bheem ki Gada" how talented they are.??? The only talent they hv is to prove others evil and hijack the heritage of Buddha.
@user-ww9ww1pp2u
@user-ww9ww1pp2u 4 месяца назад
Mauryan empire were not buddist at all. Chandragupt was hindu who is after passing his throne to son adopted Jainism not buddism. His son was hindu Ashoka started as hindu and become buddist. Ashokas descendents were also Hindu go search 1st shunga emperor he rages war against buddism 149bce and Tibetian account clearly mentioned him. If you do not trust your country account.
@Upanishad11
@Upanishad11 16 дней назад
😂😂 mourya empire established by chanakya , not Ashok 😂😂 . Ambedkar Navayan organisation product probelm. Yes Ashok inscription and historical literature indicate he was Buddhist before Kalinga war
@Upanishad11
@Upanishad11 16 дней назад
Buddha darshan is darshan which takes many things from Sanatan Dharma. Four tatva, dev, devi, dhyan. Buddha learned Dhyan from his brahmin guru and in Buddha darshan most followers were brahmin . This is truth
@Anand2024
@Anand2024 7 месяцев назад
Ashoka was really a violent man It's really disturbing to hear that he has done such atrocities
@kishorek2272
@kishorek2272 7 месяцев назад
Yeah and the most kindest king in India(Bharath)is none other than King Raja Raja cholan i the great🇮🇳🚩👑🐯🐅❤️🔥!
@kishorek2272
@kishorek2272 7 месяцев назад
@@SreeRamakrishnaNagulakondaBut king Sri Krishna Devararaya of vijayanagara Empire killed our Prince Veerasekhara cholan(one of the chola descendanst)very mercilessly in 1529🇮🇳!
@smlanka4u
@smlanka4u 7 месяцев назад
Enlightened Moggaliputta Thero converted King Asoka, and helped to be a better person after the Kalinga War. King Asoka's son and daughter visited Sri Lanka, and they coud confirm what happened. Later developed texts could try to change the history to insult King Asoka. A lot of texts have changed in India to change the history to protect caste system, etc.
@kishorek2272
@kishorek2272 7 месяцев назад
@@smlanka4uking Devanampiya Tissa of Anuradhapura:-The 1st srilankan king who was converted to Theravada Buddhism by prince Mahinda Maurya and Princess sanghamitra(children of Samrat Ashoka Maurya the great)was mentioned in the book named,"The Mahavamsa"🇮🇳🇱🇰🦁☸️👑⚔️❤️🔥!
@smlanka4u
@smlanka4u 7 месяцев назад
@@kishorek2272, Asoka ended the wars which Chandragupta Maurya and Brahamana Chanakya started from Magadha. Maha Padmananda (Porus) and the other 8 regional kings in Magadha lost the power because they were trying to stop Alexander the great. Hindus came from Thakshila (Pakistan), and they took the Magadha Kingdom from the people who spoke Prakrit Languages. And then, they have developed new text to make their own history in India. Some stories are older than the evolution of Humans. They have tried to make a founder of Jainism. And they have copied the story of Rama-Panditha in Jataka tale to make a new story to make the Budhha and Avatar of Vishnu. Also, their new stories have tried to adopt the Buddha's teachings. They have destroyed the history of India. But Sri Lankan texts have details about the early Kings in India. Uggasena was the first Nanda king, and he took the power from Kalashoka according to the texts. He was the newphew of Maha Padma Nanda because he married his daughter Dhurdhara. Likely, Chandragupta married Dhurdhara later. Brahamins have tried to Brahamanize a lot of cultures and knowledge systems while trying to change the mindset of normal people.
@VinodS-et6bt
@VinodS-et6bt 5 месяцев назад
Hi Keerthi, I also heard this before, but you told with evidence. Thanks, please clarify me is there any relation between Ashoka symbol in our flag and Ashoka Kingdom? also I was taught in schools that Ashoka planted tree all over India and so that's why the tree named as Ashoka tree. Is it true ?
@Gupta_Dynasty
@Gupta_Dynasty 2 месяца назад
"Ashoka chakra "
@opkhanna6521
@opkhanna6521 6 месяцев назад
Respect our king ashoka his symbol is out national symbol 🙏🙏🙏🙏
@learnerspoint8259
@learnerspoint8259 7 месяцев назад
Great Job Keerthi Ji🙏🏼... I've one question, Which inscription does establishes the fact that he was already a Buddhist before Kalinga War?? Please clarify 🙏🏼
@just_laugh99
@just_laugh99 6 месяцев назад
🎉
@RationalismIsFuture
@RationalismIsFuture 7 месяцев назад
Ashoka is great indeed
@VishwasJi1511
@VishwasJi1511 7 месяцев назад
kim jhond u bad boy 🤣🤣
@SuperThausif
@SuperThausif 5 месяцев назад
"Might have?" "Might have?" "Might have?" What is the meaning of the term "might have" Keerthi is repeatedly using in her video? Somebody please enlighten me.
@shruti1339
@shruti1339 4 месяца назад
Please recommend the books or articles which you mentioned in the video so that we can confirm it
@ARULSD
@ARULSD 7 месяцев назад
Perhaps historical narratives could have been framed to emphasize promoting the ideals of peace, nonviolence, and ahimsa to children. Instead of imparting stories filled with bloodshed, torture, killings and to focus on narratives that highlight the values of harmony and compassion might have been a more constructive approach.
@bhanukadassanayake
@bhanukadassanayake 7 месяцев назад
References, trust me bro?
@cyrilmatthew2995
@cyrilmatthew2995 6 месяцев назад
Yeah :- "trust me bro" ... If you don't trust - you are anti-national, hinduphobic, go back to Pakistan/Britian
@DakshPratap-qh3cn
@DakshPratap-qh3cn 3 месяца назад
It's impossible for neo Buddhist to accept truth even after gaving evidence
@shankarmsy3812
@shankarmsy3812 6 месяцев назад
🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗 👉Which book did you refer to???? 👉How many books about Ashok and mourya Empire did you refer to???? 👉 Where did you gather information about archeological evidences. 👉 where did you get reference and evidences that Ashok had contact Greek army and used them.. If your argument is true and evidential you will definitely reply on my comments.. else not.🤗
@mk6701
@mk6701 6 месяцев назад
Thanks for this post, I came to about this at least 10 years back. Even after the kalinga (Malinga) war, based on one of his inscriptions, he has mentioned that he won’t hesitate to rise his sword again. This Ashoka is a waste fellow.
@kaviarasu1997
@kaviarasu1997 7 месяцев назад
Hello Keerthi Mam, History is one of the subjects I hate the most during schools because they make us to remember things by heart, but your way of teaching and explaining makes History interesting to me....Kudoos to you and keep working!
@raju8516
@raju8516 7 месяцев назад
Bro this a propoganda channel dont take her seriously . Asokavadana is not a historical document its a religious text written 400yrs after asoka death. And its full of magical miracle moral stories like asoka walking on water, flying in sky, healing diseased monks just by toching. That violence part is also a fabricated moral story to warn people that who accepted buddism when they deviate towards violence karma hits them and suffers more(like ashoka brother death)
@silentkiller9337-r6x
@silentkiller9337-r6x 7 месяцев назад
Thank you for sharing the truth. I am from Odisha and as an Odia I feel ashamed of my own people who believe in the lie. The Kalinga war has many untold stories we will never know. We all know winner writes the history. Here we heard from our ancestors that Ashoka only stopped the warWhen normal people joined the war with whatever weapon they had. When all men were either dead or captured. River Daya was red with blood. When the whole Royal Family was massacred but the people refused to lose and choose to die with respect because Ashoka was not a human he was a demon. When they saw old men and young boys fighting, they stopped.
@Utkala.editzz
@Utkala.editzz 7 месяцев назад
​@@jinkigang Wdym ?? I don't see any sense in this reply for his comment 🗿
@kanishkkumar5431
@kanishkkumar5431 6 месяцев назад
@@Utkala.editzz this video got no sense. .... spending lies and biased facts and peoples r actually believing her. .....
@krato6468
@krato6468 6 месяцев назад
@@kanishkkumar5431 Even if you ignore the video, it is true that normal citizens of kalinga were fighting against ashoka at the end. They didn't even have weapons. That shows the cruelty of ashoka. Fighting against an army is one thing but massacring normal citizens is very very inhumane and cruel thing to do. Who did he want to rule over after killing the citizens? Truth is the level of cruelty that has happened inside india (whether by british or by kings such as ashoka) is on par with hitler's concentration camps. I'm not arguing whether ashoka was already a buddhist or he adopted buddhism later, i dont care about it. None of it changes the cruelty he did. Whole rivers were red with blood during that battle.
@krato6468
@krato6468 6 месяцев назад
@@jinkigang not sure who you are calling terrorists. ashoka was the terrorist in his story, not the common people of kalinga. He murdered the common people whom he wanted to rule in the end.
@kanishkkumar5431
@kanishkkumar5431 6 месяцев назад
@@krato6468 at that time ..peoples of every indian state. .fighted against themselves. ... What's so new about it ... even bengali and biharis fighted against maratha cruelty
@balanr1729
@balanr1729 7 месяцев назад
Keerthiji always mesmerises with her topic and make the listener sit at the edge of their seat.😊😊
@user-tg7it2zn1t
@user-tg7it2zn1t 7 месяцев назад
The real history is uncovered by you, the world will come to know, good narration, god bless you eternally, I am also history student, ♥️👋
@Agnostic7773
@Agnostic7773 7 месяцев назад
Ashoka knew what is kshethriya dharma and strategic king who ahead of his times He is Indeed Great ruler of Bharat but only our conspiracy historians who hate Bharatiya culture spread such controvery theories .Thanks for you spreading Truth with your big voice Every Bharathiya culture tradition given different methods for happy life
@user-ju9ii1hf3v
@user-ju9ii1hf3v 7 месяцев назад
True, it is always necessary to do some politics to maintain peace and stability Otherwise....... civil wars and foreign invasions can happen easily.
@Agnostic7773
@Agnostic7773 7 месяцев назад
@@user-ju9ii1hf3v True,that's why he became our great king ..All fault done by historians who distrot history for their propaganda
@vijaykumara7927
@vijaykumara7927 7 месяцев назад
Hat's off for the fact teller Keerthi❤. You should dig deep and take out the reason and who were responsible people who wrote different history ?
@zoyaali9545
@zoyaali9545 5 месяцев назад
Out of curiosity. Why do you pronounce the “r” as “gh”. I have many south indian friends but they pronounce the “r” quite nicely. Saw it first time so just asking.
@arunmandadi2711
@arunmandadi2711 5 месяцев назад
Just one doubt, what do you want to tell here exactly! Whats the point!!
@skjames1981
@skjames1981 7 месяцев назад
It was an honest and logical explanation by Keerthi. However, there are at least two things she was wrong in her research. First, a Buddhist merchant and second; that Ashoka was himself a Buddhist when kalinga war happened. The rest of the information that she has provided are true and I appreciate her. Well done Keerthi 😊🙏
@janhvisinghchauhan9224
@janhvisinghchauhan9224 7 месяцев назад
The Buddhist merchant daughter name was Devi she is from vidisha she is his first wife and Ashoka has made Sanchi stupa and barmukt stupa for her
@skjames1981
@skjames1981 7 месяцев назад
@@janhvisinghchauhan9224 Very true Janhvi. That was my point. Anybody can be a Buddhist because it doesn't have religion and caste system. He was a merchant by caste and later on he became Buddhist while Keerthi didn't realise that unfortunately. However, I follow Keerthi History and I always do that 😊
@maltesharalikatti2818
@maltesharalikatti2818 7 месяцев назад
The biggest historical misconception that we've been fed throughout our schooldays : "Indian King's were non-violent & so we should be, even if the enemy is beheading us".
@rajesh1234530
@rajesh1234530 7 месяцев назад
indian kings were ofc violent to protect their empire but this is just next level dictatorship , for some reason watching this vid made me remember Auranzeb
@user-jr9rw1pv5h
@user-jr9rw1pv5h 6 месяцев назад
You want complete picturesque about Ashoka's Kalinga war , read Dharmarahasya book. This book contains inscription based story
@chakrichakravarthi746
@chakrichakravarthi746 6 месяцев назад
You did not tell anything about how he treated his people.!!.
@tfriend9133
@tfriend9133 7 месяцев назад
the fear is completely visible
@kirananilkumar3089
@kirananilkumar3089 7 месяцев назад
Such an amazing and eye opening video. Yes, I did hear about this unknown side of Ashoka's Buddhism but not very detailed like this. Can you also make a video on Ashoka's wives, please? About Vedisa Devi, Karuvaki, Padmavati and the evil Tishyaraksha?
@Keerthihistory
@Keerthihistory 7 месяцев назад
Will try
@chanakyaprime
@chanakyaprime 7 месяцев назад
​@@Keerthihistory your whole video is Full of lies You're anti nationalist like soch by mohan Mangal and dhruv Rathee
@trueobc5727
@trueobc5727 3 месяца назад
Tishyraksha was not evil. She, a beautiful Yong, was forced to married with old Ashoka She was from Kalinga. She was burned alive by Ashoka
@kirananilkumar3089
@kirananilkumar3089 3 месяца назад
@@trueobc5727 well if you know what she did to one of Ashoka's sons, you will retract your statement of her innocence.
@Upanishad11
@Upanishad11 16 дней назад
Chandragupta mourya was never Jainism. Jain text later wrote about this things but not chankaya and not Greek account have this theory
@iamvishal5258
@iamvishal5258 6 месяцев назад
Every temple in India is an old buddhist temple All these are bhuddist universities( nalanda, takshashila) & temples,destroyed by brah...., if its hindu temples why can't they build it now. In india buddha lived and died, after that,buddhists were beaten they gone to beside countries & invented karate at that time, now our beside countries became Buddhist countries , but India was a real bhuddhist country. See the basement of nalanda university, or search in google the images of nalanda, takshashila, etc university, there will be buddha carvings. Nalanda is Buddhist university destroyed by aryans, Bakhityar Khilji is a bhuddist called as thilak, thilak protected university for 18 times. The books are in pali language not sanskrit, sanskrit is not old language it's created after 6 th century, but many tells that it's oldest language, there are no proofs.
@chessmine1909
@chessmine1909 7 месяцев назад
Nowadays I am starting to doubt our own education system. Keerthi Mam please continue this spread of the untold stories and truth..
@jhoneyyorpen1818
@jhoneyyorpen1818 7 месяцев назад
She also got all this info from some wiki lol😅😅😅
@Skmax673
@Skmax673 7 месяцев назад
Vedic Hinduism during Ashoka's time. 😂
@arjun111
@arjun111 6 месяцев назад
She is graduated from WhatsApp University😂
@dragongamingyt6599
@dragongamingyt6599 3 месяца назад
​@@arjun111 and you from chatni university 😂😂😂
@dentodream7944
@dentodream7944 2 месяца назад
​@@dragongamingyt6599😂😂😂
@PoonamBBagul
@PoonamBBagul 6 месяцев назад
If u want a New topic then cover the caste system in India why should it prevail
@shyarilovers4503
@shyarilovers4503 7 месяцев назад
Can you please provide ,from where you read this ?
@arjun111
@arjun111 6 месяцев назад
Wikipedia and WhatsApp 😂
@cyrilmatthew2995
@cyrilmatthew2995 6 месяцев назад
"Trust me bro"
@Momomooo23
@Momomooo23 6 месяцев назад
​@@cyrilmatthew2995weren't you born a sinner? go do some apologizing
@cyrilmatthew2995
@cyrilmatthew2995 6 месяцев назад
@@Momomooo23 I don't understand what you mean by born sinner ... I don't owe my apology to anyone ...are you high ?
@Sage.ji.
@Sage.ji. 5 месяцев назад
WhatsApp University
@muralibio7016
@muralibio7016 7 месяцев назад
Ambedkar says....Hinduism is nothing but collection of castes.....Till date it is true..
@neelt4975
@neelt4975 7 месяцев назад
So whatever Ambedkar says is true??
@DakshPratap-qh3cn
@DakshPratap-qh3cn 3 месяца назад
​@@neelt4975yes according to fools it is
@DakshPratap-qh3cn
@DakshPratap-qh3cn 3 месяца назад
Hindusium was started by indus valley fool ambedkar was not even aware how much developed indus valley was
@trueobc5727
@trueobc5727 3 месяца назад
So Ambedkar married to Brahmin girl second time. Now don't ask why not in his community, when got educated???????
@grandpaskitchenbakery1840
@grandpaskitchenbakery1840 3 месяца назад
Because ambedtkar could understand the Sanskrit much😂😂
@Pheonixeditz7
@Pheonixeditz7 6 месяцев назад
Actually, the answer to your question is that we in history didn't see anything and just focusing on inscriptions So, We didn't actually know what was happened and we have to just trust on reliable sources.
@umeshrangari6665
@umeshrangari6665 Месяц назад
Which inscription you read sis
@jimreganpaul1358
@jimreganpaul1358 4 месяца назад
Can you share the bibliography where you got all these informations?
@narasimmangopalswamy2638
@narasimmangopalswamy2638 7 месяцев назад
This is a new form of toppling the history. This madam is always doing this in all the historical events on the behest of vested interest. One should analyse what is true and what is correct by exploring the historical events
@Momomooo23
@Momomooo23 6 месяцев назад
toppling history is what was done in NCERT. ask me, I had CBSE board. Not one full page even about chattrapati shivaji maharaj or Ahom kingdom . But full on chapters about invader Mughals. She is showing the real history
@wannabefighterpilot
@wannabefighterpilot 5 месяцев назад
she is showing the history that you want to hear*@@Momomooo23
@Sushmita7777
@Sushmita7777 7 месяцев назад
Its good you're bringing up the historical knowledge to all of us, and it would be great to mention your source of knowledge and the incriptions you're talking about !
@RedRebel008
@RedRebel008 7 месяцев назад
if you believe this video to contain misinformation here are the timestamps and faults. I've researched extensively for 4 days and this is what I found - 1:56 - 1) Susima was never crown prince. It was never decided who was more worthy to be the king Susima or Ashoka, The mauryan court was divided into 2 one that favored Ashoka and one that favored Susima not only them the other brothers also wanted and fought for the throne. 2:13 2) There is no solid evidence suggesting that the Greeks helped Ashoka in the Assasination of Susima. 2:17 3) It hasn't been proved if Susima was assassinated or died in battle due to lack of evidence. 2:28 4) According to her it was a civil war, then how is it possible that Ashoka was the one that killed each of his brothers and not other soldier 2:50 5) Ashoka's Hell wasn't an actual place as no location has been described and no sites have been dug. Ashoka's hell was an imaginary place for the sinners, It was a concept to improve morality among citizens. 3:27 6) Ashoka's early regime describes the fight among the brothers for the throne and Ashoka's hunger for territory, which we have been taught correctly in our textbooks. It didn't include any sort of torture, just war. 3:20 7) Chandashoka as earlier I mentioned refers to the war hungry Ashoka, brutal in nature (which we have been taught in the textbooks). 7:00 8) Ashoka did release the prisoners of the Kalinga war. 5:13 9) Look at the text carefully it mentions I've been a Buddhist layman for 2 and half years "BUT FOR A YEAR I DID NOT MAKE MUCH PROGRESS" The Kalinga war ended at 261BCE which came first And 260BCE was the date the edict was written in which was a gap for 1 year, this is not particularly a mistake but it does tell us he was Buddhist before the Kalinga war but after it he had finally started acting non violent and became a true Buddhist. 6:23 10) Ashoka didn't kill all his brothers, he defeated most of them and others were killed during the war by common soldiers and not Ashoka particularly. 7:27 11) The hostility is not even present, the lines tell us that god tells ashoka to calm down and apologise so to prevent violence. There is no hostile tone present. 7:57 12) There are no accounts that suggest a war that Ashoka fought or initiated after the Kalinga war. 8:15 13) The Ashokavadna is not corroborative evidence as its a prashasti and much has been exaggerated. And no other historical evidence suggests that Ashoka ordered the killing of Ajvikas 8:35 14) There are no historical evidences that support this legend written in the Ashokavadna and thus is considered a false narrative by historians. mam I believe, this is just a mistake, Kindly reassure your data and sources. These mistakes that I pointed out have been gathered from Wikipedia, Quora, Chat GPT etc. I have tried my best to separate the biased and exaggerated data.
@monk9948
@monk9948 7 месяцев назад
Don't believe in the history of these youtube historians.
@RedRebel008
@RedRebel008 7 месяцев назад
@@monk9948 if you believe this video to contain misinformation here are the timestamps and faults. I've researched extensively for 4 days and this is what I found - 1:56 - 1) Susima was never crown prince. It was never decided who was more worthy to be the king Susima or Ashoka, The mauryan court was divided into 2 one that favored Ashoka and one that favored Susima not only them the other brothers also wanted and fought for the throne. 2:13 2) There is no solid evidence suggesting that the Greeks helped Ashoka in the Assasination of Susima. 2:17 3) It hasn't been proved if Susima was assassinated or died in battle due to lack of evidence. 2:28 4) According to her it was a civil war, then how is it possible that Ashoka was the one that killed each of his brothers and not other soldier 2:50 5) Ashoka's Hell wasn't an actual place as no location has been described and no sites have been dug. Ashoka's hell was an imaginary place for the sinners, It was a concept to improve morality among citizens. 3:27 6) Ashoka's early regime describes the fight among the brothers for the throne and Ashoka's hunger for territory, which we have been taught correctly in our textbooks. It didn't include any sort of torture, just war. 3:20 7) Chandashoka as earlier I mentioned refers to the war hungry Ashoka, brutal in nature (which we have been taught in the textbooks). 7:00 8) Ashoka did release the prisoners of the Kalinga war. 5:13 9) Look at the text carefully it mentions I've been a Buddhist layman for 2 and half years "BUT FOR A YEAR I DID NOT MAKE MUCH PROGRESS" The Kalinga war ended at 261BCE which came first And 260BCE was the date the edict was written in which was a gap for 1 year, this is not particularly a mistake but it does tell us he was Buddhist before the Kalinga war but after it he had finally started acting non violent and became a true Buddhist. 6:23 10) Ashoka didn't kill all his brothers, he defeated most of them and others were killed during the war by common soldiers and not Ashoka particularly. 7:27 11) The hostility is not even present, the lines tell us that god tells ashoka to calm down and apologise so to prevent violence. There is no hostile tone present. 7:57 12) There are no accounts that suggest a war that Ashoka fought or initiated after the Kalinga war. 8:15 13) The Ashokavadna is not corroborative evidence as its a prashasti and much has been exaggerated. And no other historical evidence suggests that Ashoka ordered the killing of Ajvikas 8:35 14) There are no historical evidences that support this legend written in the Ashokavadna and thus is considered a false narrative by historians. mam I believe, this is just a mistake, Kindly reassure your data and sources. These mistakes that I pointed out have been gathered from Wikipedia, Quora, Chat GPT etc. I have tried my best to separate the biased and exaggerated data.
@monk9948
@monk9948 7 месяцев назад
@@RedRebel008 I don't believe in her at all. There were lot of misinformation I agree.
@RedRebel008
@RedRebel008 7 месяцев назад
@@monk9948 then start by reporting her. Channels that are spreading fake news are being deleted but we need a plausible cause and I just gave you more than 10, I already reported her, now it's your turn.
@divyasajjan8577
@divyasajjan8577 6 месяцев назад
The fact that The Great Emperor Ashoka segregated the false monks itself states the whole narration. The book mentioned " Ashokavadhana" might be written by some false monks. Am forever grateful to the Great emperor Asoka for spreading the Dhamma. It's the nature of the world to blame and praise. May all beings be happy and well🌷 May all beings be aware of impermanance🪷
@surveysy7561
@surveysy7561 6 месяцев назад
Thank you Keertiji for straightening the facts
Далее
Violent History of Indian Kings
21:01
Просмотров 1,9 млн
Dark History Of Heeramandi | Keerthi History
12:07
Просмотров 727 тыс.
What is going on? 😂 (via haechii_br/IG) #shorts
00:15
Unusual Methods Used By Sushruta | Keerthi History
7:51
Muslims debate with a Hare Krishna Monk
20:51
Просмотров 2,6 млн