Assassin's Creed Origins VS AC Odyssey VS AC Valhalla VS AC Mirage - Which Game is Best? 

Origins for life.

Odyssey is still and will always be my fav. The depiction of ancient Greece is stunning🤩

I enjoyed Origins and Odyssey! Completing Valhalla side quests feels like doing house chores.

I gotta give it to Odyssey. That game stood out to me the most of the 4 and I had the most fun with it and preferred the story more

For me grafics and combat goes to Valhalla and open world to Odyssey and Origin, stewlth to mirag. Sorry but i love those finishers in Valhalla

I think Origins perfectly introduced the new action-RPG gameplay with a great story and setting, but Odyssey perfected it as a whole with an amazing open world, ship combat, and the objective of killing the cult members. Valhalla was cool but it just didn't feel the same and it felt like they took a step back. I enjoyed the medieval England setting but that was about it. Never played Mirage. So Odyssey is my favorite but Origins is a close 2nd.

For me, Odyssey was the best. The graphics, the world details, the story, the characters, the gameplay and the controls were far away the best in it among the other AC games.

Odyssey forever ❤

Origins is the best of all ubisoft games

I can't quite put my finger on it... but this gets me excited for AC Red. They really should bring back mocap for cutscenes though... Out of all 4, I had a blast with Valhalla

Origins was ahead of its time

Odyssey was my first assassins creed game and it’s my favorite game of all time

Ac Origins is the best

I don't care how many details Valhalla has over Odyssey, Odyssey is the best AC game by far for me I don't even have words to describe the feelings I felt visiting Thermopylae and other amazing locations in ancient Greece. And I also love Vikings history and did some research because of Vikings tv show but I just didn't feel the same about Valhalla.

All these games from Origins to Valhalla are made by a big studios with massive teams over 1k developers for production graphics and story with huge budget while in mirage it was a very small team of 200 developers whom had the ambition decided by themselves to do a standalone title that at least show love to the Original AC1 with the resources and assets they already have even though they were told to cut down their budget!!above that they tried to improve some stuff like the lighting and they also used way less filters and depended more on the natural colors and direct lighting of the environment so this alone need to give a praise for the team that decided to take pressure and create a project within only 2 and half years there are also some minor details that no one really talked about in AC mirage which is the carpets and pillows as well the clothes when basim stands on they do bend and for the fire when burning a haystack in the middle of the city people will gather looking at it and asking who did that adding to that if there are guards nearby they would come and try to search for the person if they found basim holding the tourch they would tell him to directly extinguish the fire and try to attack him… and BTW thank you for the comparison ❤❤

Origins is just the sexiest of all of them. The locations are sooo exotic, especially Alexandria with its Greek/Egyptian architecture. Thematically the weapons, armour, music, atmosphere all come together in such a unit. It had the feel of a franchise revival entry, very focused direction. Bayek's voice actor was just amazing. Odyssey just has the most of everything and will please the most people. You could name it AC: Quantity and most would know which game you mean. Combat was incredibly fast and fluid, classes/perks all just worked and build options were plentiful and easy to switch. Many beautiful locations, but architecture didn't make my jaw drop until I got to Atlantis. Facial animations were a huge downgrade over Origins, but there was a lighter tone to the story, even hilarious at times which was a welcome change to the serious and sombre tone of Origins. Valhalla brought back that darker, serious, mystical tone of Origins in its story telling. You could tell it was the same team that made it. Much slower pace, but I almost burnt myself out on Odyssey and played the story/regions like seasons of a show pretty sparingly. Way better experience. Combat was weighty and vicious but the skill tree was horrible, not much reason to be anything but a warrior. The world had more to say but it also felt the most dead somehow. Like it had environmental storytelling and notes/lore of what occured but it all happened a while back and anyone to inform you about it is dead or had left.

Odyssey has been my favourite since i first played it back in 2020, but I also enjoyed Valhalla but particularly for the snow areas like Norway ect, Ancient Greece is by far the best map out of these these games can’t tell me otherwise.

Origins and Valhalla are my favorites

Origins still rocks. Even though the details lax. But imagine if it just came out on PS5 today with the original root game play of AC games, It would smash!

Origins blows them all out of the water by full game experience. Bayek is an incredible character. The story is the best and the world is the best. Combat is still extremely satisfying and the dlc for the game was top notch.

Damn, Origins is my favorite AC but it’s lacking so much in normal details 😭

Loved them all .. platinumed them all

Need to try Origins after watching this. Finished Valhalla and Odyssey. Both amazing in their own right

Origins and Mirage

Origins. Anubis Armor. Ultima Blade. Game over. imagine wanting realistic footprints as a ' best game' qualifier.. that is just not what makes a game for me.

I've just started playing them my first pick was Valhalla hope the rest are good too

Valhalla underrated masterpiece

Odyssey is spectacular. I don't think any other AC will top it!

Origins!Will always be my favourite. The second for me is Mirage.

I prefer oringins

I really liked all of these games, odyssey less so bit still. I might have to say origins. Bayek, his story, the world and side missions I feel make it more complete. There’s a reason I have all the locations In it complete and not in the other games get

origins over all

Assassin's Creed Origins is the best . ❤❤❤❤❤

Ac origins the best

Some of the comparisons seem bias, Mirage is a perfect blend between the old AC titles and the New AC open worlds. So the tweaks/physics will be different

Origins and Mirage they are the best

Origin the best ❤

Good video Valhalla seems good actually.

I somehow enjoyed Mirage the most. I am the "older AC games" person and that hit the spot.

Origins. Most def.

Cool bro

Origins all day

For me Odyssey, Every details of all the map are awesome when u see the sunset and sunrise, how amaze to see the greek world in the AC ❣️

At first play, Valhalla was nothing special, and as one dude said here, side quests were like house chores. Then I started new game, with hard settings. And at this point, Valhalla is No1 for me! I highly recommend you guys to give another go. Berseeker atleast and Master Assasin stealth awarnes level. You'll love it to, combat is amazing, stealths kills are quite challenging to execute! Also, choose "your fait" option to guide you with skill tree, spice the game a bit. Before tougher bosses, you can always adjuste your skill tree.

AN EPIC MADE VID!!!!!

The best asassin's creed game : origin and mirage The best rpg : odyssey

I like them all despite small diferences!

Origins and Odysey for life

1. Origins 2. mirage 3.odyssey 4. valhalla ik ppl don’t like mirage bc of the stealth, but i love stealth so that’s why it’s 2

Odyssey is my favorite. Beautiful and unique Greece world with mythical creatures and old gods, good storytelling, some variabilities, fluid and enjoyable combat system. Possibility to create universal silent assasin (if use corresponding abilityes). Sea part is also nicely developed. I return into this game again and again. For me its one of the best action RPGs.

Big fan of Mirage. I absolutely love the architecture of Baghdad.

Origins and odyssey are the best IMO. Odyssey being my favorite because you could do awesome builds then they go away from builds with Valhalla so much I didn’t even finish the game and never tried mirage just didn’t look interesting to me. I hope Red looks better

I think in terms of world details, Valhalla takes it 👍

Loved these games, but I really think ubisoft messed up making the far worse female eivor canon. Female eivor is utterly awful. She looks stupid and sounds even worse. It takes me right out of the game and the story and it's frankly embarrassing, when the male evior is so damn good. Also, basim does have mirages. He can see his nightmare in the desert, and hallucinate flowers. Those are just two mirages I've seen.

If you shoot at the water in odyssey with the bow, it has an impact

I preferred the gritty art style of Origins and the pyramids were amazing to be able to explore. I love the Viking culture in Valhalla but the world wasn't as good. Odyssey though was my favorite overall. I'll never forget Kassandra and the experience of ancient Greece. Odyssey has a special place in my gamer heart like no other.

Odyssey for me since I'm a sucker for anything Greek mythology! Wish the dialogue was a bit better written but eh it's ubisoft so what can you expect right. I still gotta play Origins & Valhalla not so sure about Mirage though tbh.

These games may not be the best but its damn impressive they all come out within 5 years, they're beautiful, some have phenomenal stories and writing and gameplay is really fun too!

If mirage was a full game it would be better than all 3 combined

i love all 4 games ❤

In terms of world details? Origins and Vallhala. In terms of gameplay? Mirage is the best in terms of the overall world? Origins and Odyssey

Don't lie to me after Origins maincharacter has auto run, Basim has too?

Unity and Black Flag

Atleast Viking simulator is much more fun than demi god simulator and thief simulator. Although ORIGINS THE BEST.

По моему мнению все они достойны и со своей чудесной историей

In AC Mirage ,you can see hallucinations/mirages....just only inside the city

You should have done riding mechanics in both of them

I've heard Mirage isn't good so I haven't played it but man, it looks gorgeous!

Where is the snow in Greece? Love it!

Although ac odyssey is my all time fav ac game, i have to admit the details of valhalla are pretty nice

{Odyssey} is 10 times better than Origins, it bored me, I can never finish it, Odyssey I am finishing it for the second time and I am a lover of the saga but for me Origins is among the worst in graphics and I don't know why the character looks tiny in front of characters like those from Valhalla and Odyssey

Can someone tell me what the valhalla armor set from the thumbnail is called?

For Valhalla!

I don't care what anyone else says but I think that these last four ac games have been absolutely pukka. each and every one holding a special place in my heart. cant say that about many recent games these days if I'm honest

Odyssey, Valhalla, Origins. I also feel like lots of people prefer Origins over the other two not because it's better but because it's the first game of its kind with theme and vast exploration in AC series so there's lots of nostalgia associated with it

The only AC games l played are Origins, Odyssey, and Mirage and platinum all three. I never got the chance to play Valhalla yet but l had the disc and brought the DLC. I’m going to play that one soon and try to platinum that game. :)

None of these.. I love Ezio Triology😢❤

You're wrong. Basim does see a lot of Mirages. That's basically the plot.

What i'm getting from this video is that Ubisoft have actually removed a lot of stuff from Mirage that was in previous titles, like the hot weather effects or boat going on fire. A bit lame.

Mirage 💯💯

Valhalla for me level design and graphics easily some of the best open world I ever played in a game , it was just the story was kinda boring.but as it looked so dam good I wanted to explore every last.part of the map

Mirage for me is the best. Really enjoyable to play

I miss Valhalla, the in-game level of detail and atmosphere was excellent.

The side stuff in Valhalla killed any replay ability for me personally. Stacking stones, pointing lasers to see Basim’s dream etc. I feel like it would’ve been better if it was a separate Viking open world adventure rather than tied into the Assassins creed storyline. Odyssey was fun but feels like a long game. Graphics of the natural world were pretty bad sometimes. Kind of cheesy but fun. And you’re a demigod not an assassin. Just started playing Mirage and it seems like a reskin of Origins with game mechanics of Valhalla. Basim is hard to like. The story feels slow and drawn out and I sure it’s because it was meant to be a dlc and not a full game so they did what they could to give us the illusion. Origins was cool and fun but it felt like a short story.

Origins: One of the best stealth game. Odyssey: Good open world game. Valhalla: Boring. Mirage: Back to the old style of Assassin’s Creed.

I've played Origins and Odyssey for a bit, only watched gameplay of Valhalla and Mirage. In my opinion, Odyssey is the best. It feels like Origins was the blueprint and they improved on that. Valhalla appeals to me the most in terms of setting, but it seems really boring and soulless. Mirage seems like it can't decide what it wants to be. On a side note, I prefer the new AC games over the old ones.

Odyssey is best one Ong it NEED A REMAKE IT WOULD BE INSANE

i played all but Mirage. hated odyssey loved a lot Origins and still playing Valhalla but it´s a bit confusing with side quests

I’m playing all 4 right now

Wow, Basim looks like Prince Of Persia in that shirtless outfit with white pants.

Clothing physics is awesome in Origins except the legacy outfit no physics which is disappointing.

No words for this ***** - made me laugh as hell AC Valhalla - Predators leave the body and don't eat it - Predators are like "Must have been the wind"

I enjoyed the egyptian setting the best. I enjoyed the combat style of odyssey the best. If they could put the combat style of Odyssey in origins. Origins would probably my all time favorite. My least favorite ever mirage.

Looks rathee balanced between the first three to me... Mirage is just less refined in more places than the others

Love valhalla forever. It makes me feel like real viking. It is far away from being an assassin, but it's good game in RPGs.

Everything feels the same and bland in terms of the playground environment, and the customization is not upheld from its predecessors. Although, initially bring a fresh vibe with the release Assassin's Creed Origins. However, as time goes by, everything feels very monotone to me, and it is nothing different from playing any other ARPG game. It's as if everything is forced to align with competing games with similar samples. There are indeed some new combinations poured into it with a new mechanical approach for each series. However, unfortunately, all of that doesn't satisfy me to enjoy the game that originally brought the stealth formula, and this stopped me from pursuing all the achievements on Steam in all AsCreed Series that I initially planned. And with the return of the old formula in Mirage, it refreshes my old memories of playing Asc123. Although it feels sad, finishing it in a week feels like a relief.

Valhalla the GOAT. The Masterpiece.

I’m split between Origins and Valhalla. Bayek and male Eivor are easily my favorite protagonists in the series. Odyssey was sort of fun, but I can’t stand the fact that it manages to both look worse and somehow perform worse than the other two.

i have and i love all of em and im waiting for ac red

Origins is on the top , Odyssey is on the edge of not being AC game , but valhalla is just...wtf is this really (im talking about not being really AC game,the game itself is fire)