BATTLE OF THE 4TH GEN MAIN VOCALS - vocal analysis 

the funny thing about this is that NMIXX sullyoon could also make it to this ranking. the vocal line of that group is just insane.

the vocals of nmixx is literally insane imagine having hard and tiring choreos and singing live too like they are really powerful sullyoons vocals are no joke too

I agree with NingNing analysis, I don't know but when she performs on the stages, we can clearly see her stage presence and her confidence in her dancing and attitude, but when it comes to live vocal, she looks like she afraid that she will crack her voice, her notes are mostly heady. I hope that she will be more confident in live vocal, she is a promising vocalist with a lot of potentials, I really like her agility.

The fact that other NMIXX vocalists could also be in this list is insane. ❤

haewon has a fullness/robust quality that is pretty rare in 4th gen, reminds me of older vocalists in kpop, its so nice

I really hope ningning becomes more confident singing live because this girls vocals are to die for. I think I kind of understand why winter gets most of the high notes now, I think when it comes to live stages winter is just more confident and goes for the high note whereas ningning tends to take the safer route and does it in head voice. I hope in the future ningning will show us a stage where not only is she confident in performing but singing too.

In ten years time, lily and Haewon are going to be absolute vocal monsters

Now Lily A5 again in Young, Dumb, Stupid The only 4th gen that can slay this

10:22 is one of my fav moments of haewon's vocal omg i just loooove her vibrato here so much it literally gave me chills when i first heard it😻😻😻

We all know Sieun is a flawed vocalist but I feel her vocal range in general makes her Stand out she has incredible accessibility in all of registers and surprisingly her lower register too

Sieun is a really interesting case. She has SOOOO much potential. If only she trained in a more vocal-centric company or company with history of good vocal training like SM, she's gonna be unstoppable.

NMIXX LILY ON ANOTHER LEVEL✋🏻 I saw her all performance (since 12 years old) she is incredible

There’s something that i love about ningning is that it sounds easy for her, she doesn’t need to like scream or get everything force out of her chest, it sounds easy in the ears everytime

Ningning really just needs to work on exposure; SM's fault entirely. When she gets to perform live and she's in her element, she's absolutely on fire. SM forcing to lipsync their first three years was definitely a detriment. edit: It frustartes me sometimes that she often chooses to be safe than risking notes, but I guess we also can appreciate her for taking care of her voice. Anyway her headvoice is immaculate and she definitely relies on it and mixes more heady whenever she's in doubt (which ig is okay considering how piercing Winter is).

If Lia master the foundation she can be the queen of vocal bc her tone is so beautiful and unique, that’s something you can’t train to achieve. I hope she improves in the future.

Finally someone else who believes HAEWON and LILY complete each other...oo i love nmixx

When sieun hit a whistle note I was in utter shock

Lily and Haewon are the best 1,2 punch in the 4th gen and then you add Sullyoon.... it is insane. Plus every other member can support. ❤❤❤❤❤❤

Out of all in the list, I love Yunjin and Liz the most! They have long ways to go to perfect their skills but I know they'll get there with proper training and hardwork. I feel bad with Yunjin's recession tho. I believe she is also aware of this as she mentioned this in our of LSRFM's vlog. But I like that she keeps her songs in her comfortable range. When I listen to her songs, I feel very relaxed. As for Liz, she's got a lot of raw talent. And based on her performance in their concert, you can see that she's working hard improving her vocals. Amazing singers, I admire these two soo much!

even though liz is low and behind now, she has such a unique vocal colour that is rich, but smooth and sweet that stands out from the rest of her group. starship needs to capitalize on that. she needs real deal training and a giant confidence boost because she has astronomical potential to rise the ranks. go liz

I love Lia’s voice! Her emotion when she sings she makes me want to cry. She just get shy but she sounds so beautiful.

Im voting jo yuri as well. She has a very rich and unique vocal color and can definitely go up there. She has been slaying since 2018

Lilly vocal range is actually Eb3-Bb5-Bb5 The Eb3 was in the staff's wedding "To you my light". The Bb5 (hv) was in her vlive practicing on "Ego" - Beyonce.

I think Lilly has best vocal technique and powerful in pop song, but i like Sulyoon's voice tone/color/timbre, it rich but soft. The best musicality is Yunjin, and I considered only Yunjin now that I can called her as true artist.

If youre lazy to watch the video heres the final ranking: 1 - Lily and Haewon 2 - NingNig 3 - Yunjin 4 - Liz 5 - Lia 6 - Sieun hope that helps

Idk much about vocal technique but I loved and kept repeating Ningning’s belt during Savage’s 1st prechorus on their 1st encore. Like yes girl! Belt that with confidence! I wish she sang more like that. I notice the fear in her eyes whenever she has to belt or even just sing live in general (which is interesting since Winter’s the opposite, girl doesn’t give af lol). I personally think her nicest moments are when she’s in a casual setting. So much potential when she gets over that hurdle.

my favorite vocalist is Yunjin. every time she sings i feel her love for music.

Yunjin is a weird case, cuz she seems to be the same as her predebut stage until you get to the higher end of her mixed voice and that at least to me is where i hear the difference, but nonetheless she still is a great vocalist with loads of potential

New intro, new analysis and a new start! Corrections about the vocal ranges: Lily: Eb3-Bb5-Bb5 Yunjin: F3-F#5-C6(mightve gone higher)

haewon has the best vocal tone in 4 gen argue with me

Lily has A5 note in headvoice on her cover song "All I want for Christmas" tho

Weeekly Monday deserve to be recognized as one of the top 4th gen vocalist. Her high note in 'Solar' on Weverse 💕 even her low note from 'when we were young' by Adele cover on radio. I mean there's a lot Monday sing live on Weverse that uploaded on RU-vid. Maybe it's time to analysis Weeekly Monday vocal.

The funny thing is my 4th gen fav idol is all started with letter L. Lia, Lily, Liz..gosh, I hope someday they can make a collab

Sieun have si much potential omg :0 My favorite is Liz, I LOVE HER VOCAL TONE!!!

Baby monster is coming guyssss haram pharita rora Chiquita already breaked recordss

Lily is so far ahead of any other 4th Gen idol, she's basically on the short list for the GOAT K-pop vocalist.

The way Sullyoon could also make it on this list 😭 Nmixx fighting!

I thought Lily's lows consistently were only down to A3 wow she's even better than I thought 🤩

Sullyoon is also a good vocalist,visual that actially can sing live

lily and haewon is good but i love ningning's vocal more, her voice is everything

I think that Billlie has some AMAZING main vocalists. It'd be really cool to see what you thought.

Ningning's supported range: F#3 - C#5

Liz voice is so beatiful

I find Weeekly's Monday very impressive.

Nmixx is everything

Honourable mention to one of the best vocalist in 4th gen , the one and only, Monday from Weeekly💝

The thing is although I love nmixx vocal ability and I like Haewons and sullyoons voices I can't stand Lily's voice sometimes. In highlight medley she sounds nice but sometimes in actually Nmixx songs I feel like her voice doesn't suit Idk why. With NingNing I actually like her voice because I think it's really sweet but yes NingNing just needs more confidence

it would be nice an agility ranking. I feel like, in k-pop, riffs and runs are overlooked, but I'm a sucker for agilty, one of the reasons I love SulHaeLy so much.

liz has much pontential to make her mix balanced

i like yunjin and lily, i think they r great they have a powerful voice and that is so charming and so interested

I think LILY's supported range is G#3~Eb5~G5

Late but I seriously hope Lia gets the right sources for vocal training after Itzy disbands, she has so much potential, but her biggest issue is her confidence and her mixed, her A4 sounds effortless at times and she can even sing Bb4 back then, she needs to be taught how to belt properly

If Sieun had sm vocal trainers she would be unstoppable

I swear Ningning always looks/sounds like she will be sent straight back to China by SM if she makes just one mistake on stage. She has so much fear in her big eyes😂

How can someone be talented..haewon is literally top tier vocalist while being most skilled dancer in idol dance. Not even yg or sm can have idol like her . LMAO

Bro the rapper line in NMIXX they can sing very well too. like dude they're rapper with almost swag voice but they can SLAY when they sing💅🏻🥵i can agree that NMIXX be one of the best 4th gen pure talented group

I have a suggestion next time u can make the relaxed vocals in green, and the strained ones in red!

For me it's Lily by far. She's "the different". Best vocalist, not only capable of reach high notes, but with an amazing and unique timber, texture, style.

14:12 😱😱 I saw Lia as not so good, but wow, she made me eat my words

Lia Vocal tone so unique & beautiful ❤️

I hope to see Monday of Weeekly in your next 4th Generation Vocal Analysys, pls. I know Weeekly are quite underrated, but I think Monday is quite good to be analyzed in your channel.

I think Lia has the potential to be a powerhouse vocalist the problem is that, In true JYP fashion, she’s forced to sing with an unnatural tone. I think they wanted her to be the next Nayeon and make Yeji the next Jihyo but Lia, as you said, does better in a lower register. JYP has all these talented women in his company but if you’re not in Twice you’re given scraps. He has Twice until 2029 now so hopefully he’ll stop trying to recreate their magic and let Itzy and NMIXX create their own magic. Anyways, I’m not gonna sit here and rank talented women like they’re objects created solely for our entertainment during women’s history month or ever, so I put all of them at number one because they all have strengths and weaknesses and that’s just called being human and the real talent is putting yourself out into the public eye and taking criticism like water off a ducks back. All these Queens are amazing and deserve the world. Werk ladies!!

Okey but the intro tho>>>>>

Great video, i know it's just the most popular ones but maybe it will be more interesting if you want to make the most underrated ones like weeekly monday, purple kiss swan, cherry bullet bora etc and rank them too and compare the most popular and underrated so that will be awsome but i just tell anyway

I would give NingNing C#5 cus she consistent with her C#5 in the Hyper Line Concert

i'm suprised to not see goeun and swan of purple kiss on here or haram of billie

i have a question about haewon, u mentioned that she's very close to achieving resonance, can u show me which moment where she almost did that? thanks in advance^^

So underrated is sullyoon, winter, swan, and isa. 4th gen I so talented.

i wouldn’t give G3 to Lily. she has very few good G3s. she’s rather only consistent with G#3 / A3. if you gave G3 to Lily you should also give it to Haewon cuz even Haewon has more G3s than Lily. i agree with pretty much everything else you said, i feel like a big problem for haewon is her nasality tho, especially when she doesn’t necessarily belt big long sustained notes. her placement is usually good for those like that sustained C5 you showed but a lot of the times she opts for this very nasal unpleasant sound which i wish she would fix SO SO BAD

El rango belt de Lily mas alto que su head voice?😮 Actualmente, ya llega a un C6, aunque es en estudio😊

Sieun is awesome.

It is not just how high the note is, but how precisely on tune it is. All other things being equal, whoever has the most power wins. Some girls have just devastatingly beautiful voices-- that counts for a lot for me. IMHO, in order: Precisely on tune, range, power, the beauty of voice.

Lily doesn't have G3s, she sometimes gets too light even on A3s. She's also quite consistent with Eb5s, I don't see why she wouldn't get D5/Eb5.

would you consider doing this for lead vocals as well?

Lily and Haewon remind me of Solar and Whee In ❤️

i know you write a note on the first screen, but i guess you better add a note on the title that this is the rank among only popular group of 4th gen; cause i expect more of 4th gen gg main vocalists would get mentioned cause if we talk more about 4th gen in general (that not only the popular one) it contain many great main vocalists tho

Nmixx is the best 4th gen girl group vocally. I sometimes even forget that they are from JYP.

some very generous choices for nmixx members and some omissions or extreme pickiness for Ningning as usual lmao

my ranking : 1. Haewon ( i love her voice, her texture is everything. she is abs a vocal monster) 2. Lily ( obv amazing no doubt, i just personally prefer haewon's vocal tone over hers) 3. Ningning ( i mean,, she could easily be a vocal monster with a little improvement and much confidence, MY FAV FAV VOCAL TONE BTW) 4. Liz ( i need starship to give her a solo album asap, she'll EAT IT UP LIKE DAMN, i think she lacks in lower register but overall, she's so talented, again one of my fav) 5. Yunjin ( she can improve, her voice tends to strain a lot, and i believe her falsettos and head voice is more developed than chest voice. overall, beautiful tone) 6. Sieun ( she's endearing to listen to. her voice fits different genres easily) 7. Lia ( she can def improve a lot. huge potential i see in her. she's better than a lot of vocalist but i had to put her last in this particular list. her voice tends to strain, but her bright tone is really good)

Love your VDO. Very Informative. It must take you a lot of work. I truly appreciate !!!. Please keep up the good work, i followed you.

This didn’t age well.

The gripe I have with this is it only shows the note being used but it doesn't show how well the note is executed. There were a lot of shouted, unsupported and shaky notes when Lia sang live. Plus there are so many examples where heavy autotune is evident.

Heyy. What do you think of BABYMONSTER’s vocal line ?

just realized how much Haewon sounds like Hani in her mid range

Let me say this I think this video is a bit biased with the commentary. First it's lets stablished that Haewon, Ningning, and lilly will definitely occupy the top 3. Ok why I say it's a little biased? If you read her analysis there are a lot of flawss for ningning, when infact she's almost perfect as a singer. Among all of this girl she has the widest range while lily has the highest. Her transition from tones are actually really smooth as well, the only problem is the lack of sources of performances for ningning showcasing her vocal. She also mentioned that ningning has lack of confidence while performing, and I totally agree but it's important to understand that being stable while performing is not equal to a better technique the best example is ningning and winter. Lets do side by side comparison. Overall Range: 1.ningning 2.lily 3. Haewon Highest range: 1. Lily 2. Haewon( because her highnotes are more powerful. 3. Ningning Lower range: 1.ningning 2. Haewon 3.lily Resonance Haewon Lily & ningning. Vocal gymnastics: Ningning/lily Haewon. Tone: (can be based on personal taste) Ninning Haewon lily Story telling ( if you ask vocal coaches they will all agree that inorder to be a good vocalist you should know how to convey the meaning of the song and not just spitting notes). Ningning Hawon and lily. Averall skills Ningning/lily Haewon Now to the ranking I agree with other ranks but I'll definitely replaced haewon with ningning. And if I'm to put winter she will be on the fourth just behind a little bit of haewon. Karina and sulyeon will also fit on the rank 5&6 they almost have the same level of skills.

liz reminded me of soyeon of t-ara.

Monday from Weeekly wipes them all

I don't know if you plan to make another video like this in the future but I would like to know your opinion/vocal analysis about kep1er's chaehyun

I haven`t really noticed yujin vocal change, but know that you mentioned I can clearly tell that she doesn`t project into her mask more and the sound produced is indeed coming more from the throat

sullyoon could make it too, nmixx vocal line is the best. period

i guess it's just age that is holding these girls back, they are just starting really and with age comes very suttle changes in the larynx altering the dynamics of ones vocals, and that also depends on how they protect or not their voice, and then their is the constant demands made on them to use lipsyncs and other voice aids for a perfect sound, and lets be honest many do, newjeans hanni is one of the few that refuses point blank to use any aids at all,

I am 100% agree with your ranking

i think weeekly monday would be near yunjins spot, even if she regressed

All of the NMIXX members have vocal support, so they are JYP's adopted group from SM

Raini Rodriguez

Would you consider doing the same video but for Nugu groups? Cherry Bullets Bora + Haeyoon, Weeekly’s Monday, Purple Kiss’s Swan, etc?

Me SM Entertainment Ningning because she can cover other vocalists from SM Entertainment. Can you try making this for the 1997 to December 31 2006 first gen girl group

Haewon and lily>>>

6:48 *Eb5 great video!

Yunjin, Liz and Lily have my favorite tone.