'Bella, the Baby is Crushing You' Scene | The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn - Part 1 

For real, and idk if they had her eat less or if it was CGI as well but she looks like every bone in her body is about to break

In general, I think they did a good job with CGI. The only big problem was the baby

@@D0NCH33T0 I remember from the bts stuff it was make-up and post-cgi effects

@larissamartins8525 I hated all of the "speed" scenes. The one where they were on the treadmill was just terrible. And all the zooming features and effects were horrible. But I did love the looks of the wolves and that transition.

Jordan Davis 21 With all Her

tell Micheal Jackson he do have choice

Why is Edward blaming Bella for this . Its not like Bella wanted to get pregnant with a vampire baby thats crushing the life out of her

@@soph301but she’s choosing to keep it when it’s killing her so it is her fault

Plus Edward didn’t want to bang her while she was still human, but stubborn Bella wouldn’t listen and insisted.

That wasn’t acting. He was thinking about how she cheated 😅

RIGHT? LMAO

LMAO

No but like how the hell can Carlisle hide it in the house when they can literally smell blood from several miles away 😭😭

He was like "WAIT WHHAT?" 🤨

@@luistorres513 I think Carlisle as a doctor will have some experience how to hide it...

You forget BELLA wanted the baby too!! And she ASKED Rosalie to do this.

@@Maddluv4eric No, I didn't forget, and I do know that Bella asked Rosalie to do this, I'm commenting on the fact that Rosalie generally dislikes Bella, but the thought of having a baby in the family, makes her tolerate her.

It seems that Rosalie hates what Bella is giving up (not Bella herself). Bella, as a human, currently has the opportunity to have everything Rosalie wants and can never have. More envious than hateful.

@@kflowers8276 You know what, I accept that, because you weren't rude about it like some people, you explained yourself and allowed me to see things from a different perspective.

@@Sanaa_K_Mohamed unlike people on tiktok

Lmao🤣

Can't wait till Renesmee (a.k.a. Re-name-me) hears about this: "Yeah me, your father, and your boyfriend hear Jacob wanted to kill you when you were in the womb☺"

I don't know why you call it "his baby", Edward never planned to have a child with Bella, it was unexpected because being a vampire, he shouldn't be able to get anyone pregnant and so that was not how he saw the fetus, he saw it as a parasite that was killing his wife. Obviously, for her safety, he would have preferred her to have an abortion.

The father of the year everybody

Deadbeat vampire 🤣

I was so scared wtf 😭

Yh Rosalie even mentions this.

The baby was doing a little more than just breaking ribs.

Right?! My kids bruised the hell out of my ribs when I was preggers. They felt bruised for a while after they were born.

Yeah, but no normal baby/fetus breaks all of your bones AND your spine 😭

😬 And that's why no one should be forced to continue with a pregnancy that's unwanted or life-threatening.

Twilight (2008) is my comfort movie, new moon is good, eclipse is okay but I just can't with breaking dawn. But twilight goes so hard

Personally, i hate kristins acting. its like she doesn't wanna me their but is been forced to.

YES! I will never be ashamed to say I watch these movies.

Genuine question, If you dont care, then.. why comment?

Same

omg please don’t make me cry 💔

dr. jellky will help he did before he do it of again

Daughter and Son. Cause you know if Bella dies, Edward goes with her.

@@VDA19and grandchild

Edward saw the situation more "realistic", Bella looked "romantic". Throughout the series, Bella has always compared vampires to angels, and that was morbidly absurd. It was huge luck that Renesmee was a near-normal and harmless child. At least that's what SM wrote.

I mean 😂it’s a vampire in a human. Edward wasn’t ready and was more realistic compared to Bella so it’s understandable as to why he was upset.

This is what pisses me off. The birth of this child should have been the joint decision of the two of them. They have relationships based on making each other accept things. What is it called, a toxic relationship. And the romanticization of that is sickening.

@@semracelik7538 After Breaking Dawn I realise Bella is the toxic one. She only cares about what she wants.

@@Emma-yg2uf 💯

Bro the way I laughed at this scene 💀

Tbh I don’t see how they got this far . Edward should have dump her .Bella cheated

​@@lionmartelpantherTrue

@@jobangharekhan2601is it just me or when he dumped her in New moon, he seemed pretty content without her 🤷🏼‍♀️

She should have just ended up with Jacob lol. Edward did to much back and fourth with her

​@@abbybarrett4855not true, he isolated himself away from his own family, he was in a depressive state

Book Edward never did that.

I don’t. She’s willing to let Edward die because he would follow if she dies, never did she ask Rosalie to stop Edward from doing anything if she dies, If the Volturi chose to fight many would have perished. Bella is the true villain of Twilight. If it was in the real world then yes I understand.

Jordan Davis 19 How This be

Bella is a prolife queen 💅

@@hiro9920 I guarantee most women would do what Bella did

I don't! She was causing problems and friction and didn't care as long as she got what she wanted.

mud blood Carlisle have to take my blood Cameron poellnitz

💯

Looking back he was the only good actor in this movie series. The others looked like they were in a parody show.

The books were pretty bad as well.

You just hate the movies because you are told to by the internet 🥱 let people enjoy things that you don't enjoy

@@elliexio6817 yes, tell them

lol 😂

what's the song?

@@happyishness. Cold by Aqualung & Lucy Schwartz, Breaking Dawn soundtrack

I love it, I'm listening to it straight, I'm marathoning a lot of twilight this week

Thank you ​@@chickennugget3325

In their defence they had no idea what it would be or crave for this is the first time they had ever dealt with a situation like this.

this whole thing doesnt make sense lol

Let alone how long they have lived and the world Knowledge they all had

Actually in the previous scene, Carlisle already gave bella food but bella's system refused it. They didnt know what a hybrid baby (a half vampire, a half human) wanted. They thought it's like human baby. Later, finally they knew that the baby's food was vampire's food.

Jordan Davis 19 How Times Have

In general, instead of talking to each other, they were concerned about making things accepted

Agreed

There was actually a huge debate recently about choosing between baby and mother in extreme situations. 95% of the fathers chose save the wife. Almost 80% mothers chose to save their body instead of the baby.

@@bobtina6120 there was a reddit thread on this topic not too long ago. It's pretty important to discuss this as parents beforehand, because apparently women who would normally choose to save themselves are affected so much by the process of giving birth that in the heat of the moment they choose the baby.

I really feel for Edward(or the fathers) in this situation. When you really love someone, I'm sorry but I would never trade that person for the baby either if there's a choice.

First it shouldn't happen because vampires are dead so he cant get anyone pregnant

Honestly, nothing in this situation really makes any sense to me. Like, the baby is half human but have a high chance of being some sort of demon baby? And also grown really rapidly despite vampires not aging at all? It shoudn't age slower like a vampire but still age like a human? It shoudn't be slithly weaker than a pure vampire? Vampires in Twilight are confusing...

@@sthefanybatista2101 u explainin this has me more confused 😭

@@sthefanybatista2101 Maybe the older it gets, the slower it ages.

Tbh the whole thing doesn’t make sense. She should’ve never been able to get pregnant in the first place.

Stephanie Meyer is very much a conservative Mormon. So, her version will be a lot mor in favour of the pro-life perspective, just like her books promote abstinence and girls marrying as soon as they leave school. Edward, Bella and Renesme are basically the Holy Family. However, she had less of a hand in the movies, where they could explore the grief of the father, the medical risks of bringing a pregnancy to term and take a more balanced approach to things like abortion. The blood is O- though, which means it's for patients.

@@MsJubjubbird Pretty sure the vampires don't care either way. At least Jasper wouldn't.

@@megancheang7858 they're just constructs if the author's mind though. However, she is projecting her religious views through the story and characters she's created. I mean Rosalie insisting that the foetus is called a baby really is hammering that pro life point of view home.

I thought the Cullens only feed on animal blood, not humans. So it makes sense why Carlisle wouldn't share the human blood pouches.

Tbh I don’t think Edward didn’t want a child, yes I know he didn’t react well to finding out BUT that’s only because of the dangerous stories he’s seen with babies like the one they would have. Plus, he’s been waiting for years to find someone to spend the rest of his life with and he does but now this thing is taking her away too. So I don’t think it’s much of a not wanting a child, I think it’s more of not wanting to get his entire family killed by the volturi lol

Same 🥲 adulthood hits different

It is really, you're right. And not many people seem to ponder back before the Cullens were a family. As much as I like Carlisle's character he started it. He turned Edward, turned Esme, and turned Rosalie. Did he ever stop to consider, it might not be their choice? Maybe their destinies were to die. I don't blame Rosalie one bit. Carlisle is selfish. He should have given them the option. They were alive before he turned them, albeit barely. But he could have hastily told them the process, and given them the choice for immortality

So she asked Rosalie for help. Rosalie would gladly both protect and care for the baby.

@@semracelik7538 that’s all fine and dandy, but it isn’t her job to like it would be for Edward. All I’m saying is that he should’ve gotten more of a say.

Nah, it's the mothers say ultimately because she'll be carrying it and she'll be the only one truly making a sacrifice. If Edward didn't raise her someone else would've, he wasn't being forced to be a father. His mentality was extremely toxic though, if he truly loved Bella he would've loved the child as it would be the only part of her left.

@@mariakhan7986 I don't think Edward will live if Bella dies. We're also talking about bella and edward, toxicity is at the core of their relationship. Besides I did never believed that they loved each other for their personalities. The one was obsessed with his extraordinary beauty, the other was obsessed with her silent mind.

@@KMXC17 You don't get a say on someone else's body, even if that's your girlfriend. Plus it takes two to make a baby, so fathers should assume the consequence of their actions and accept whatever the person who carries the baby decides to do. And if they don't want to raise it it's fine, they don't have to 🤷‍♀

He is devestated to see her like that too. He feels like he is losing her forever. You are right he could have comfort her but he was angry with her. Id say its a normal reaction.

It IS so bad! She was literally a walking dead when Edward left her in the second movie then she intended to do the same.

@@sangriad.938 He did dat fr her safety But no judgement women's like u won't understand men Just keeps playing victim cards Yikes

Can't u see hw miserable he s U women's always acts sympathetic nd blame men Pathetic u r He s afraid to lose her He s being realistic here

@@priyadarsh2504 Edward was a dick in new moon but here he acts justified.

I’m pretty sure Rosalie was pro life as the author was morman

that's true. rosalie was ready to be an adoptive mom in a rich vampire household lol

@@berriexcream "Pro forced-birth" you mean. Please don't use blatant and dangerous misnomers. Allowing a woman to die so a fetus might have a chance to become a baby is in no way even remotely pro-"life".

Rosalie was following what Bella wanted though.

Rosalie previously admitted that she was jealous of Bella's mortality and luxury of choice. Rosalie was beaten to death and saved outside of her control and exists in a state of permanent pause. Immortality must be incredibly isolating. She didn't want Bella to feel welcome because she thought Bella was just some dumb girl attracted to "pretty sparkly immortality" and never consider all that she would have to give up. It was a fair deal that the two women made. "Protect me and care for me and if I die, you can have the kid." Rosalie kept to it and was the only one who didn't shame Bella or try to convince her to kill her and her husband's child.

He really was in a "fuck that baby" mood THE ENTIRE TIME.

@@Nyicolee ain’t care at all😭😭😭

@@Nyicolee It wasn't a "baby" for him because they had no idea what it would be and Edward racked his brains watching demonic creatures on the internet and thought that would be what Bella would have. And let me remind you that Edward never thought of being a father nor did he want the "baby" because he thought the baby wanted to kill Bella, that is, he saw it as a parasite until he could read her mind.

It's not "baby" for hım. he never thought he would have a baby and was afraid of losing Bella. He saw the "baby" as a parasite, and he was right. Renesmee could have been something wild and terrible.

@@semracelik7538 yet, you should NEVER make a woman feel bad about a particular decision envolving her body. Never! Especially envolving pregnancy

Same. When you're immature, this kinda love seems so idyllic. When you grow up and gain a healthy mindset about romance, (which includes having independence and your own life seperate from your partner) you see it for what it is: Obsessive, codependent and unhealthy. Really is just too much.

Bella doesn’t really love her husband if she make him put through this and watch the little monster kill her.

@@Emma-yg2uf exactly!

Oh please.

Jordan Davis 21 like Was Have

Yes but Leah did Yell at Bella and she deserved it.

Too bad nobody told her what a selfish twat she’s being. She indeed chose to leave Edward behind when she ignored everyone’s pain and continue with this.

Because the director of the last two movies is utter shit and he did an awful job. Pretty much all the Twilight directors were awful/ Maybe not the second and third. But the first and last defiitely.

Man it's been 3 or 4 years since I read the books I need to get them out and start reading again there's some scenes I didn't like that they decided to ad in the last 2 movies of breaking Dawn yes Bill condon tried to make it as the books specify but some scenes I felt was a waste of time

that and I think they didn't want the movie to be as "Mormon". One of the big criticisms of the books was the very conservative message that it sends to young girls. They also added some more action scenes because the readers had grown up and had to keep them engaged

Rose only wanted the baby.

She only wants the baby she was ready to kill Bella for that

And Alice should've corrected her back. Rosalie does not care a bit about Bella, only about the unborn fetus she's carrying. She is a perfect example of the typical "pro-life" advocate- leave the mom to be destroyed and die for all she cares as long as the fetus survives to become a baby. Her character was unpleasant throughout the books but I could understand given her past, but this scene truly made me finally lose any respect for her.

THISSSSS. I realized all of this when I first read it when I was like 12. It’s so obvious to see. Also it’s why Jacob tries so hard to make her see it. Twilight is actually really dark & tragic. Jacob & Bella were soulmates & they would’ve effortlessly been together if not for the addiction. I call it vampire “thrall.” It’s subconscious. Also the only reason edward chose bella was bc he couldn’t read her mind. If he did , he wouldn’t be interested and wouldn’t have pursued her. He never should have. Idk how people can watch or read these and think it’s like just a romance..it’s actually incredibly dark and destructive. It’s quite obvious in the books too.

@@MetalMaidennn Dude, I know you made this comment two months ago but I just have to reply because... the Twilight saga has been the one story that has plagued my mind for the past like 15 years. I started out as a dumb naive fan, then over time and learning more about the terrible writing of Stephenie Meyer and also maturing and realizing things myself... I became an anti-fan. I still loved elements of the story and certain characters and the immense potential the story had, if it had a WAY different ending. In general, Jacob is my favorite character and SM's assassination of his character is honestly the most tragic part of this whole story imo. Bella and Edward were never good for each other, the entire core of their relationship was based on the fact that she was just under his vampiric spell. I've read SO many great fanfics where Bella chose to stay human and end her relationship with Edward and I truly wish that was canon. Like... its sounds stupid but this crap actually makes me want to cry lol how much potential this story had but stupid Stephenie Meyer just HAD to have her special little love story play out the was she wanted, instead of being a good writer and just let the story play out in a way more sensical way that would have been better and a way better model for younger girls to follow. The amount of girls and women I see that just have stars in their eyes about how much Bella and Edward were TRU WUV and will justify their opinions because well that's how it's written, that's what the author intended... well have none of them ever realized how much the author is a freaking idiot??? Ugh. I'm going to stop now lol.

Ugh. This thread. ❤️

This is why I'm Team Jacob.

I never read the books so imma just ask carefully: since Edward can’t read her and she is a shield, his vampire euh.. love spell shouldn’t do anything either, no? She just fell for him? It’s been years with the movies as well, I mean no disrespect.

It was emotionally trying. I feel so bad

I read the books while I was in prison, I hadn't seen the movies or anything prior to that. And I was immediately shocked at how abusive and toxic the characters were. I still don't understand how so many girls just overlooked all that, it was honestly scary

Bella is the real toxic partner. She lets everyone watch her slowly die. Doesn’t give a crap about who she hurts and leaves behind.

Well; Bella isn't much better. Imagine being Edward for a moment. I get that nobody seems to care about the fathers in these situations, but it's their lives that are being ruined too. Edward would have lost his wife, would despise his daughter, and just hate himself, blaming himself for all of it and probably eventually killing himself. Bella forcing Edward to go through with that is equally as "abusive" as Edward, but ultimately; neither of them were abusive, they just weren't compatible. They should have never been together and the whole thing was nonsensical. Neither party should have been forced to give up anything, especially something as serious as what they were both giving up. Edward giving up the love of his life and Bella giving up her child. Never should have happened because they should have been on the same page before this situation even occurred. All of it is ridiculous and incredibly toxic.

Even Jacob was toxic with Bella, the whole triangle was bonkers.

Jordan Davis 21 When Them The

sound like bones dr jeklly

Twilight was written by a Mormon

It didn’t inspire teen pregnancy any more than it inspired right out of high school marriages or vampirism. It’s a first love romance with extenuating circumstances. If anything it inspired Fifty Shades of Grey.

Bella was pregnant at 19

They were married

😂😂😂😂

It was never perfect, it was a bit toxic, I didn't see it back then since I was a teen and didn't know any better but as an adult it was toxic and she had no goals in life and just cared about him and hurt her dad, he did the same to his parents when he tried to kill himself

@@humanoide7076 they weren’t toxic that much like anna and christian or elena and damon you know but i understand your point. bella and edward are still my favorite ever.

@@louarianator All of them were toxic but I do agree that Elena and Damon are the worst I can't speak for the 50 shades bc I didn't see it all I know is that is all about sex XD I was a fan of Twilight though cant blame you, I had the books and posters but then life happened (I never understood Bella even as a teen, you know just leaving everything for a guy it seems weird, right now at 32 I live with my bf but I'm 50% out since I have to choose to follow him and disregard my own plans that can't fit with his family since he is the provider for his mom and sister, and I'm an independent person)

Jordan Davis 21 When People

Did twilight establish that they have no reflection? Thought that were just sparkly.....

It explains why in the books. She wanted to be around him more because they were connected by Renesmee. It’s like she had a rope pulling him towards her.

LOL

Most husbands do that

@@barb7124 most lol not true

@@barb7124 raise your standards

@@barb7124 um no. Most terrible abusive shitty husbands do.😊 Who tf in their right mind would scream at their pregnant dying wife like that and leave her alone?

@@katgreer6113 I would've divorced his ass. 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

Yet ignored all the pain she cusses to the ppl around her like Jacob, Edward, Charlie just to pop out Rafiki. Edward will never love the baby leaving it in a broken Family.

A parent. I'm tired of everyone leaving out fathers. Bella was a PARENTTTT, because fathers can be fiercely paternal as well and ready to die for their kids. Most fathers are.

​@@elistari1050 uhh yeah, that wasn't a part of the point.

Bella was completely selfish. It's her body her choice, of course, but she chose to ignore the wishes of her husband (the father) and decided she'd rather die and leave him with a child he didn't want and would likely despise, that future child motherless, her own parents childless, and everyone around her emotionally destroyed. I loved the series until this part. I have never lost any and all respect for a character so quickly.

Maybe cause the scenario is shitty ?

Actually, it was because the amniotic sac was too hard for them to break.

Bloodloss, and it might cause a conflict if they intend to kill the baby.

Even more sad after she cheated on him.

@@MA-rn2xpdidn’t she cheat with the director?!

Yeah... like how could he stick his ice cold "popsicle" between her legs (if he is cold to the touch) ? 😏😄😆😅

The latter I think, since they need to procreate.

@@hederlisa I don't think imprinting is necessary for werewolves (shapeshifters) to procreate though. Take Sam for example, he loved Leah before he imprinted on Emily, had he not met Emily, he still would have had a chance to procreate with Leah. Same with Jacob, he still fell in love with Bella even though she wasn't his 'soulmate'. Had Bella 'chosen' him, he could have had a baby with her. I think every wolf has only one 'soulmate' destined for them but they can still fall in love with other people before meeting them. And thus, can procreate. Jacob's soulmate was Renessmee. If she wasn't born, then either Jacob would have fallen in love with someone else, just like he did with Bella, or he would have been alone. Not all werewolves imprint. Maybe this is what happens with their 'soulmates'.

I’ll never be ok with Jacob imprinting on ratatouille.

@@Emma-yg2uf Ratatouille? 🤣 I understand, but it wasn't in a romantic way, it was more like he's a guardian wolf and his instincts are to always protect her.

@@Sanaa_K_Mohamed It’s still grooming. If Jacob was disgusted with himself and tried to fight it by waiting until she’s fully grown then I understand but he was with her like she’s already his.

Nope